Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99
by techdragon on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:15AM
(#36957062)
Oh absolutely, there’s a lot of potential issues with the simple suggestion of requiring replication. I was tempted to write a bunch more to outline strategies and counter strategies from a game theory perspective but realised it was basically unnecessary since it will never happen.
I would expect pairs of labs to gang up, with one of them giving the other the details so that they can reproduce the result, and the contents of the publication staying more or less the same.
Reason is that everybody wants to prevent others from being able to build on one’s work faster than one can do themselves.
Even if the lab you give more information isn’t run by a buddy of you, having a single competitor is better than having the whole world compete with you.
For example, in this case, people will start cooking all kinds of variations on this stuff to find one that’s easier to produce, allows for higher currents before losing superconductivity, doesn’t have lead in it, etc.