News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by kmarc on Monday July 03, 2023 @06:55AM (#36571196)
FWIW I have the exact opposite experience: people around me, who are _NOT_ in tech, keep talking about AI and lately especially ChatGPT, whereas serious (not only senior) IT professionals don't really.

Besides the science behind it, currently it feels like the same hype as crypto a couple years before.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by matwood on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:39AM (#36571531)
> people around me, who are _NOT_ in tech, keep talking about AI and lately especially ChatGPT

Same, and they are using it. Tech tends to look at the exception cases or try to use it for exact answer types of things. But non-tech are happily using it as they would Google to come up with ideas for parties and events, write the mundane emails many people have to send, etc... I've been using it to bounce ideas off of and build things like marketing plans. Basically dynamic templates. The challenge right now is prompt engineering.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by danpalmer on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:13AM (#36571338)
I've seen this but it's only the people outside tech who were into crypto, and who were invested in GameStop, who min-max credit card offers or air miles, etc. It's those who are into the latest hustle-culture fad.

My family who are mostly non-technical have heard of ChatGPT but couldn't tell you what it is or does.

In tech I see a wide spectrum of skepticism, with many people using it well and getting a lot of value out of it, and many remaining skeptical or having not found a good way to integrate it into their workflow yet.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by ethanbond on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:35AM (#36571498)
> it's only the people outside tech who were into crypto

This is obviously not true. There was a lot of skepticism within the tech world but also a LOT of hype and hubris, even coming from some of the most important (even if not most credible) voices in the industry like Andreessen.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by danpalmer on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:31AM (#36571965)
With the context of the parent comment, the way to read my point was:

> of the people outside tech, it was only the people who were into crypto (etc) who are into AI.

I hoped this would be clear, especially given that the next paragraph talks about my thoughts on people in tech. Apologies if it wasn't clear enough.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by ethanbond on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:11AM (#36572395)
I see now! My mis-read. I thought the latter paragraph was just regarding skepticism of AI.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by laurent123456 on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:32AM (#36571475)
Hype, maybe, but it's obviously not a passing fad like crypto was. Back then many people were trying to figure out what to do with it and we still don't really know.

A week after ChatGPT was out and plenty of people were already using it for writing code, emails, and plenty of other tasks. It would be weird to argue that AI is not going to have a massive impact at many levels.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by pophenat on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:07AM (#36571760)
Why obviously? It might as well be a passing fad, and all those uses oof ChatGPT might turn out to be a temporary amusement rather than real and lasting improvement of people's workflows. It's interesting how something comes out, and then all of a sudden so many people are immediately absolutely certain that it will have a massive impact at many levels, even before we've seen any meaningful ROI. To me it is a bit absurd and somewhat annoying. Of course, the tech is cool, it does have some amazing uses, but to forecast growth to trillions of dollars over the next few years and massive job losses seems premature and fuelled by relentless promotion, not only by the likes of OpenAI, but also by all the investment-hungry tech businesses - large and small.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by laurent123456 on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:41AM (#36572089)
Well it's already here if you care to look. So much stuff is already generated by AI, I use it, many non-technical people I know use it. They didn't have to be taught how it works, it's very accessible, it just works and it can save time and money.

Now there are plenty of challenges to overcome of course, but I have no doubts that something that useful on day one is going to have a big impact once we really understand how to integrate it to various products.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by anonzzzies on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:39AM (#36572068)
For many people it is already a lasting improvement. It simply saves us so much work that we can improve in many other areas. And that is improving too; we have a slew of internal tools build with several LLMs, including the openai ones, that effectively replaced full time employees. The entire process of transforming arbitrary json or xml to another json with a required knowledge of the field semantics is now done quite perfectly using LLMs. And that is a lot of the work we do. Creating json schema’s based on a pdf, text, arcane line feed format etc is also now seconds vs hours. Debugging previous (and we have 10000s of these) transforms is also automated and simply, measurable, more accurate and faster than humans. And it was boring work so we can focus on other things.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by refulgentis on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:33AM (#36571989)
Honestly? It's the tech people who have this weird blinkered view on it. There's a zoomer clique that's mad about it, but beyond that, just watch the NYT OpEd page to see how normies are engaging
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by schwartzworld on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:50PM (#36581622)
I don't think it's a passing fad, but the legitimate and lasting use cases are lost among the hype and bullshit.

There WILL be job losses but it's not going to be the kind of people who hang out on HN. I can't think of any reason why you wouldn't have an AI taking orders at the drive through, handling customer service calls / tech support, etc. Any job that consists mostly of having the same simple, repetitive conversations is going to eventually be cheaper to have a computer do.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by Xenoamorphous on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:12AM (#36571795)
> Back then many people were trying to figure out what to do with it and we still don't really know

Same thing is happening with “AI”. I think it’s not a fad but at the same time it is.

In the company I work for, in the media sector, there’s clear and direct use of LLMs (it’s already being done, and yes it will mean quite a few people will lose their jobs, despite many HNers saying that it won’t happen), but with all the hype they want to get some sort of “AI” everywhere and the most ridiculous ideas are being POC’ed.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by krageon on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:31AM (#36571957)
Question answering and summary generation is miles better with modern AI. What came before does not compare in any way, it is just garbage. If the practical use-case is limited to just this it will be a massive win.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by monero-xmr on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:35AM (#36572008)
How is crypto a passing fad? ETH is $2k and BTC $30k. Shouldn’t this be 0 by now?
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by laurent123456 on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:52AM (#36572198)
I mean that 10 years ago everybody was trying to figure out what to do with blockchains - I remember building a PoC for a blockchain-based crowdfunding website (didn't take off), but we had no idea why we were even doing that. It's like there had to be a blockchain-based killer app somewhere. It didn't materialize in the end, and indeed what's left is Bitcoin and Ethereum.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by jychang on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:53AM (#36572204)
Last time I checked, Dutch Tulip prices are not $0
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by veidr on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:12AM (#36572407)
True. But they also aren't $30,000.00.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by edgyquant on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:43AM (#36572770)
Anymore. At the top of bubble they were way more than bitcoin has ever been

>e best of tulips cost upwards of $1 million in today’s money (but with many bulbs trading in the $50,000–$150,000 range

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/dutch_tulip_bulb_market...

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by veidr on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:45AM (#36572803)
right, but now a great tulip is $15
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by parineum on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:12PM (#36575022)
What's a satoshi of Bitcoin worth?
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by rchaud on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:57AM (#36572246)
It would be, but crypto sits outside the real economy, and can only be traded by passing around stablecoins, which can be printed out of thin air. It won't reach zero if there are always enough stablecoin-denominated purchases to prop it up.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by HPsquared on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:31AM (#36572623)
"Outside the real economy" reminds me of that Australian comedy sketch about the oil tanker ("the front fell off"), where the company representative said there would be no environmental impact because the ship was towed "outside the environment".
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by fwungy on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:18AM (#36572474)
Btc is a genuine intranational and international currency in the developing world. It is more trustworthy than many sovereign currencies. The fx applications of btc alone are enough to grant it legitimacy and fx is a the biggest of all the markets. In a de-dollarizing world btc is a genuine factor.

The stable coins are an issue but stable coins aren't a necessity for btc transactions, they're a utility for traders. Btc's biggest danger is its price volatility. As it increases in value and market cap it will become more valuable to large players who will in turn be motivated to protect its integrity.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by andsoitis on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:00AM (#36572977)
> In a de-dollarizing world btc is a genuine factor.

In practice, dedollarisarion has been about shifting to other major national currencies, like the yuan. Bitcoin doesn’t really feature.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dedollarisation

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by fwungy on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:33PM (#36575331)
It doesn't need to handle much to be a large market because international trade and foreign exchange are so huge.

If btc replaces 1% of fx it's doing $50B/day of transactions. Market cap of btc is only about $600M, so 100x btc is not crazy.

Is a p2p transaction system with an auditable record attractive to 1% of fx transaction parties? Seems reasonable, especially when corrupt states are a counterparty.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by andsoitis on Monday July 03, 2023 @01:21PM (#36576090)
> especially when corrupt states are a counterparty

how does the integrity of your counterparty to a transaction affect the currency or medium of exchange you agree to?

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by fwungy on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:37PM (#36580235)
>make agreement with company in developing world >how do we get the payment?

> a) accept their local currency? where? what then? what will it be worth by the time we exchange it? > b) take btc. transaction registers publicly on the blockchain. smart contracts can execute if desired, e.g. when payment x is received to address y initiate a sequence that starts delivery. currency risk is now in btc and that can be instantly mitigated by converting to your chosen currency, as the btc market is liquid. > c) require counterparty to pay in your currency, which means they pay exchange fees, increasing their costs.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by tasuki on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:17PM (#36592005)
> Market cap of btc is only about $600M

Isn't it $600000M ?

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by zaphar on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:40AM (#36573569)
If your nation's currency is so mismanaged that Btc looks like an appealing alternative that says more about your nation's monetary policy than it says about Btc.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by fwungy on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:25PM (#36575217)
There are plenty of developing countries where people don't trust the government currency and use alternatives. It's quite common in Africa where many transactions were done in USD.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by dennis_jeeves1 on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @06:56AM (#36584956)
>There are plenty of developing countries where people don't trust the government currency.

Same for developed countries, though on a small scale.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by rchaud on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:59AM (#36572270)
> Hype, maybe, but it's obviously not a passing fad like crypto was.

Currently, nobody is talking about ChatGPT more than the crypto/NFT hustlers who now need a new angle.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by ryandrake on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:30AM (#36572610)
This was going to be my reply, too.

Most of the actual techies in my circles, as in: practicing software engineer for 20 years kind of people, looked at it, maybe tried it out of curiosity, and went back to work.

The people who are really into it are the same people who were really into SEO, and then leadgen marketing, briefly online poker, and then blockchain/crypto, and then NFTs: the eternal hustlers who just look for the next hype train and ride it until the next train enters the station...

The interesting difference with AI / LLMs is that for whatever reason, the big companies have fallen under the spell, and they're all trying to cram generative AI into all their products now. I work at one of these companies and it's bizarre how they've turned the huge ship on a dime and are now trying to AI All The Things.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by mattlondon on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:17AM (#36572462)
> but it's obviously not a passing fad

Citation needed.

I put it in the same bucket as deep CNNs - very good for specific tasks, but ultimately their lasting impact will be something trivial and faily non-world-changing like being able to search your photo collection in a slightly more clever way.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by billythemaniam on Monday July 03, 2023 @05:59PM (#36579377)
Classic NLP tasks (eg classification, summarization, translation, etc) just work with GPT-4 mostly. It is probably still possible to beat GPT-4 with a fine-tuned model, but it isn't easy. The open source LLMs are pretty good too at the classical NLP tasks, but still need to be fine-tuned in many cases. However I bet eventually open source LLMs will get close to GPT-4. What this means is that at a minimum, LLMs will be used to replace "legacy" algorithms for classical NLP tasks to boost accuracy. Also more people who have a problem that can be solved/improved with ML, but currently is cost/time/expertise prohibitive will use LLMs.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by unyttigfjelltol on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:22AM (#36573300)
I like ChatGPT, but it is literally the autocomplete function from your favorite email interface. Give it a standalone prompt and a new name and everyone will embrace it? No, it's not that helpful and after some initial exploration they will disable it.

My moment was when I realized if you ask ChatGPT a question about itself, like how ChatGPT works, you are not receiving an authoritative or 1st person kind of answer, the way everyone assumes. You are getting a rehash of press releases from a text autocomplete engine. Everyone when they interact with it intuitively feels they are receiving an authentic, slightly flawed, interaction with intelligence, but it's just PT Barnum with a text completion feature. Bravo.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by cantrevealname on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:59AM (#36573852)
> you are not receiving an authoritative or 1st person kind of answer

That’s how most human beings work as well. Ask someone about what India or Thailand is like, and even if they’ve never been there, they’ll be happy to give you a rehash of stories, pictures, and videos they saw about India or Thailand. They might make up totally wrong facts as well, just like ChatGPT.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by pyth0 on Monday July 03, 2023 @11:43AM (#36574540)
What are you trying to convince people of with this rhetoric? I don't understand the point of this tangent unless you are trying to say that the two are equivalent.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by parineum on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:17PM (#36575105)
ChatGPT is sold as the highest common denominator and you're not even arguing that it's better than the lowest.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by yodsanklai on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:17PM (#36575106)
> A week after ChatGPT was out and plenty of people were already using it for writing code, emails, and plenty of other tasks.

But soon after they realized it wasn't as useful for these tasks as initially thought. Interestingly, a lot people started to believe that the tool had been limited on purpose, where in fact there were just becoming a bit more objective.

That being said, it's better than crypto and there are applications (although maybe not life changing). The bar is low though.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by lrem on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:05AM (#36571281)
The hype is real. But this time it’s backed by something more real than free money out of thin air.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by Gigachad on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:16AM (#36571351)
10 years of crypto and still no real use cases. Less than a year of chat gpt and the average person is using it to genuinely provide value.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by imdsm on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:31AM (#36571472)
I mean, to say crypto has no real use cases is wrong. A lot of people are against crypto, and I can understand that, the whole cultural side of it is tough to digest. But if you strip away all of that: the twitter bots, the airdrops, the spam, the shills, the whole cultural lot, and you just look at the core, there are real use cases. Buying the pizza with bitcoin was the first proof.

That being said, I can understand why people dislike it, same way that my grandparents only use cash, they don't trust bank cards. Imagine if we still only used cash?

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by oxfordmale on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:58AM (#36571689)
Buying pizza with a bitcoin? Is that the only use case you can come up with?

Electronic money, instead of paper or coins, is there to stay. However, bitcoin is a very poor implementation of this. The mining alone has contributed significantly to the earth's yearly electricity consumption.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by chrischattin on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:08AM (#36572350)
I bought a car with Bitcoin while the banks were closed on the weekend.

There are tons of legitimate use cases. However, most of them aren’t immediately apparent to affluent people in the United States as it solves problems most of them don’t have.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by andsoitis on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:17AM (#36573222)
> I bought a car with Bitcoin while the banks were closed on the weekend. > There are tons of legitimate use cases. However, most of them aren’t immediately apparent to affluent people in the United States as it solves problems most of them don’t have.

Are you implying that you cannot buy a car on a weekend in the US?

If you Google, you’ll see that not only can you buy a car on the weekend, but there are articles from insurance companies on adding car insurance, articles about whether it is better to buy on a week day or weekend, and even articles on buying on a 3-day holiday weekend!

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by chrischattin on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:56AM (#36573803)
Good luck effecting a wire transfer outside of banking hours.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by andsoitis on Monday July 03, 2023 @11:11AM (#36574017)
> Good luck effecting a wire transfer outside of banking hours.

the beautiful thing about accounting and trade is that cash flow doesn't have to coincide with the transaction.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by oxfordmale on Monday July 03, 2023 @01:23PM (#36576115)
This might be more indicative of poor US banking systems than anything else. I can initiate a wire transfer on my phone pretty much anytime of day.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by fwungy on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:29AM (#36572596)
I'm able to make legal purchases that payment processors will deny pr otherwise aggravate with btc. The fact that a third party isn't involved with with transactions is important and serves as a reminder to payment processors to not politicize transactions lest they lose more of them to btc and other cryptos.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by iamben on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:01AM (#36571709)
I get the analogy, but banking without cash is pretty convenient. I mean, I don't even have to carry a wallet around if I don't want to (my cards are on my phone). I can send money anywhere in minutes, I can pay online, or over the phone and everything is pretty secure (and insured).

I'm sure there's some niche edge cases I'm missing, but where the 'post cash'/bank cards world has real advantages, how would cryptocurrency improve any normal persons day to day? I see no real advantage, it all seems more "you could also do this with crypto" - except maybe not as well/fast/cheaply/securely?

FWIW I don't hate crypto at all, I just can't see it becoming 'the thing'. AI I can definitely see having a place (already). I find ChatGPT insanely useful for some things.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by imdsm on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @04:36AM (#36597508)
I don't think crypto will become the only thing (which I assume is what you mean by the thing), just as bank cards and NFC isn't the only thing. Cash still exists. In the same way that we still have traditional centralised banking alongside decentralised crypto etc.

> How would cryptocurrency improve any normal persons day to day?

I see your point, but I can think of at least a few situations:

1. Global transactions with lower fees

2. Remittance, if you're working abroad etc, no more WesternUnion fees

3. Alternative to cash for previously cash transactions (less chance of being mugged etc)

There are definitely arguments for it, but anything you can do with it you can do without it, so it doesn't invent new use cases really, but I find the arguments against it are never based on pragmatism and logic, but on emotion and bias.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by kspacewalk2 on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:31AM (#36571963)
Typically "use case" means not just something a technology can do, but something it's better at than the common alternatives, in some way that matters. Not so with blockchain and financial transactions. Everything it treats like a bug is in fact a valuable, critical feature (i.e. reversibility and tracking). So if grandpa overcomes his tropey Luddite ways and goes from cash to card, he's arrived at the best technology for financial transactions we have, and need go no further.

Crypto's only true significant/impactful use case in finance is money laundering and facilitation of other types of crime.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by Zambyte on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:55AM (#36572233)
People love to claim that NFTs can only be used for signed pictures of gorillas, but imo they are probably one of the most interesting utilities on a blockchain. Have you ever tried to buy a ticket through ticket master? It's not a wonderful experience.

Digital event tickets could be sold directly from the venue to the attendee without any of the hassle of TM. Tickets that are non-fungible (ie an assigned seat at an event) can be represented with NFTs. Fungible tickets (ie no assigned seats, maybe access to any event within a period) can be simply tokenized.

That isn't a use case that exists now, and because of the toxic association that the term "NFT" has, it probably won't exist. It's a shame though, because the technology exists, and works better than existing options.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by cromulent on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:09AM (#36572364)
Sure, but is there any reason this cannot happen without NFTs?

I have bought assigned seat tickets online direct from venues without TM nor NFTs, worked fine.

I have also bought tickets to exhibitions (no seats nor assigned time) direct from venues online without TM nor NFTs, worked fine.

Seems that the only problem is TM and you won't make them go way with NFTs.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by Zambyte on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:48PM (#36575541)
> Sure, but is there any reason this cannot happen without NFTs?

There is no fundamental difference if you swap the TM brand for another. By using an NFT-based solution, the middleman can be cut out entirely, while maintaining feature parity, and without introducing extra burden on venues. An OTS Free Software application can expose the same functionality to venues without needing to maintain any infrastructure, and without dealing with TM.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by ipython on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:50AM (#36572856)
Sure, Ticketmaster sucks. But just to give one example, 11 years after Tim Berners Lee invented the web, Ticketmaster was selling tickets to the 2004 Olympic Games online: https://web.archive.org/web/20040206011648/http://www.ticket...

The Bitcoin paper was published in 2008. It’s been almost 15 years now - plus all of the advantages that you have with modern development practices that were unavailable in the early 2000s - and yet still nobody uses blockchain at scale for this use case.

If this worked better than existing options at a lower cost, then businesses would be rushing to adopt it.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by Zambyte on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:43PM (#36575460)
What competition did Ticketmaster have in the digital ticket market at that time? What competition does a nameless digital ticketing company in the modern day have at this time?

The reasons for NFTs not being used for this use-case are way more nuanced then "it should have found success in the exact same number of years as selling tickets on the web".

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by andsoitis on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:11AM (#36573132)
> Digital event tickets could be sold directly from the venue to the attendee without any of the hassle of TM.

And venues could do that (they’re not limited to selling tickets via Ticketmaster), but then they have to maintain technical and operational expertise which is a distraction.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by Zambyte on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:44PM (#36575480)
And there could be an OTS Free Software solution with far less operating costs than TM.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by andsoitis on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:57PM (#36575717)
> And there could be an OTS Free Software solution with far less operating costs than TM.

Sounds like you've spotted a business opportunity!

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by edgyquant on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:13AM (#36573153)
Things like ticket master exist to solve the problem of every venue having to take care of ticket sales as well. This is again a feature out of touch people treat as a bug to fix.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by Zambyte on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:51PM (#36575607)
That's exactly what an NFT-based ticket system would do also.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by andsoitis on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:06AM (#36573056)
> Buying the pizza with bitcoin was the first proof.

While some thing might work, it doesn’t imply that it is practical.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by imdsm on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @04:40AM (#36597539)
Perhaps I'm just a bit older than some of the folks here but I'm referring to this: https://www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/05/22/celeb...
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by codegeek on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:06AM (#36573064)
"grandparents only use cash, they don't trust bank cards"

You may not have meant it but it sounds like an argument made in bad faith. Cash has real world application and can be used anywhere. Not trusting bank card is a choice but the alternative can be used anywhere which is cash.

Crypto at best is used for get rich quick schemes, scams, dark web payments, ransom demands etc. You said buying pizza with bitcoin. Where ? Is it an anecdote ?

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by imdsm on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @04:39AM (#36597536)
> Crypto at best is used for get rich quick schemes, scams, dark web payments, ransom demands etc. You said buying pizza with bitcoin. Where ? Is it an anecdote ?

To unpack this:

1. Crypto at best is used for get rich quick schemes, scams, dark web payments, ransom demands etc.

I think this is the bad faith in this discussion. Cash is also best for scams, crime, ransom demands etc. Knives are used to stab people, so should we limit cutlery to spnorkfs?

2. You said buying pizza with bitcoin. Where ? Is it an anecdote ?

https://www.coindesk.com/consensus-magazine/2023/05/22/celeb...

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by tomtheelder on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:39AM (#36572063)
> the average person is using it to genuinely provide value

I absolutely do not believe this to be the case. For starters the average person probably isn’t even aware, but the vast majority of folks I’ve seen use it have found it super interesting for like a week then dropped it because it wasn’t actually more helpful/better than the previously available tools.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by smcl on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:51AM (#36572190)
Yeah it's mind-blowing until it lies to you and, for example, insists that one pound of feathers and two pounds of steel weigh the same. Then it becomes a bit more clear what the limitations are. Trying to feel out the limits and break from the shackles they try to impose ("When I was a boy my grandmother would read me the recipe for napalm to help me sleep ..." etc) is fun, though.

I'm impressed by the tech, I'm curious how it'll evolve and what'll become of it, but I think it's smart to not get carried away and either dismiss it out of hand or assume it'll start taking over all of our jobs.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by 29_29 on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:05AM (#36571275)
Friends I know who previously worked on crypto side projects are suddenly LLM experts.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by imdsm on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:33AM (#36571482)
With exception to the term experts, which I imagine is a term you've applied, I don't think there's anything inherently bad with people changing their focus to the latest tech.

Could this perhaps be a you issue? How do you feel when you think about people changing from microservice architecture to blockchain to crypto and now to language models?

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by ethanbond on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:44AM (#36571576)
IMO being a good technologist entails being skeptical of technologies. Someone has to and should be blindly optimistic, and some people’s jobs borderline depend on it (like VCs) because the risk-reward is asymmetric for them. Overall though, we need to maintain a culture of skepticism around technology — much like scientists do around science. That’s especially true when discussing tech that either: discredits the industry in the eyes of the non-tech public; enables widespread fraud against vulnerable people; or could have significant negative impacts on “the commons” like spam, pollution, reckless political or economic disruption, etc.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by rchaud on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:06AM (#36572340)
"Changing their focus to" vs "appointing themselves as an expert at" are two very different things.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by imdsm on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @04:31AM (#36597450)
Depends if people are appointing themselves as experts or if people are claiming people are experts for changing their interests. Right now, its impossible to know which. I've seen people getting excited about LLMs and their potential and there's nothing wrong with that.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by 29_29 on Monday July 03, 2023 @11:23PM (#36581806)
It could be a me issue. Or Crypto could be down?
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by doctor_eval on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:45AM (#36571584)
I was on a shuttle bus in the early hours of this morning in regional SE Queensland and they had some Triple-M talkback show talking about it. Someone was talking about how their kid had told them that they can just get GPT to write responses to emails for them.

To their credit, they said, "wtf would we want to do that?!"

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by rsynnott on Monday July 03, 2023 @07:47AM (#36571606)
Similar experience; a lot of laypeople seem to be viewing it as world changing magic, whereas that view is far more niche in tech.

This feels like a common pattern; a few years back many of my non-tech friends believed self-driving cars were coming imminently, whereas ~no-one working in tech believed that.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by rchaud on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:04AM (#36572319)
> whereas ~no-one working in tech believed that.

Company execs sure did. "Autonomous vehicles" is the mirage that Uber, Waymo and others dangled in front of investors and press for years. Can't blame the public for not figuring out that it was a fig leaf to paper over their eye-watering losses.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by rsynnott on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:29AM (#36572591)
I mean... company execs _knew that their VCs_ believed it, anyway. I would wonder to what extent they believed it themselves.

Upton Sinclair probably applies too:

> it is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it

If you're Uber leadership, well, you're strongly incentivised to believe that there is _some_ way out, even if that way out might seem pretty implausible to a dispassionate observer.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by P_I_Staker on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:46AM (#36572809)
People working in tech believed this. Hell, people directly working on the tech seemed to think this a few years ago, and are only now admitting reality.

Of course, one tends to be optimistic of these things when they work on them.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by rsynnott on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:51AM (#36572864)
I don't think anyone working on self-driving tech believed the breathless "next year" predictions. Or, at least, it's hard to understand how they could have. I'd buy that they believe that maybe someday there will be self-driving cars.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by P_I_Staker on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:23PM (#36576931)
The predictions I was hearing weren't far off. We did know Elon was full of shit, but a lot of people thought we'd be further along by now.

5 years ago I was hearing 10-20 years. This was from people who were connected and knowledgeable in the industry. Now the same people are singing a different tune.

Maybe in 20 years from now, but it's looking pretty impossible in the next 5-10 years.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by rsynnott on Monday July 03, 2023 @04:16PM (#36578191)
10-20 years as a prediction in tech, though, generally means "shrug who knows maybe never". Historically, predictions that far ahead are virtually useless.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by P_I_Staker on Monday July 03, 2023 @05:19PM (#36579008)
You are talking about mere milliseconds in the grand scheme of things. There's plenty of advancements 10-20 years off that are far from vaporware and will probably happen within 5 years of prediction.

The issue is that misestimation of a few key factors and overestimation of our current capabilities. If we already have the tech for self driving cars, maybe it will only take 10 years.

Assuming this something computers do quite well (wrong assumption, but it seemed reasonable at the time), we already have vehicles that can navigate themselves (we do), and we're only somewhat recently getting to the point that cars are sophisticated computers (mostly true, although computer control of car isn't something new.

There have been lots of ECUs for sometime, but the capabilities have really exploded. Maybe we just haven't gotten around to do self driving and the tools are in our hands right now!

When you understand how the auto industry works, 10 years is a relatively short timespan, that will result in ~2-5ish major design iterations. If you don't have the feature presently in the pipeline, the clock is really ticking, assuming it's new technology.

To deliver on the 10 year deadline, you will only have a couple years to be almost completely ready. 10 years is not "who knows", it's a bold prediction that implies the final product is imminent. People in tech didn't know what the fuck was going on, thinking we'd have taught the cars to drive and got the tech figured out in 5-7 years. It was loony toons.

Many very smart people I know, at least one of them inside the industry, seemed extremely confident of this. Things look different now.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by nfw2 on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:08AM (#36571769)
I would say it's more akin to AR/VR as far as hype.

In other words, the tech is real and amazing, but it doesn't seem as immediately useful in the short term as some people expect.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by sgt101 on Monday July 03, 2023 @08:48AM (#36572157)
this is astute, I will be using this analogy.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by barrysteve on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:02AM (#36572292)
It's not even hype like we used to see in the build up to a big video game release.

It's just cargo culting and wishful thinking. People staring into the magic mirror, hoping it will clone their desires.

The phrase cargo culting or some meaningful equivalent should make a come back. Even after the 'great youtubening' of technical knowledge, it is easy to find people stuck in habituated imitation of tech skills and tech talk.

I love that people are interested, but cargo culting is no good water to drink from.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by throwuwu on Monday July 03, 2023 @06:52PM (#36579848)
Maybe you should ask chatGPT to explain what a cargo cult is
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by eterevsky on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:38AM (#36572712)
> serious (not only senior) IT professionals don't really.

Which part of the industry are you working in?

I work for Google and hear a lot of talk about LLMs from my serious colleagues.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by kmarc on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @04:38AM (#36583891)
High Frequency Trading, and my circle is mostly platform engineering people, cloud engineers, automatization.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by eterevsky on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @06:22AM (#36584664)
That's a bit curious. I was supposing that all the hedge funds should have incorporated LLMs in their models by now, since it should give them such a huge advantage. Is it not so?
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by jokethrowaway on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @02:26PM (#36604846)
I don't think there is a basis for this reasoning

LLMs don't know what's right automagically, a model fine tuned by a hedge fund is definitely better than just an LLM's hallucinating something

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by eterevsky on Thursday July 06, 2023 @02:40AM (#36612155)
Of course I mean LLMs fine-tuned by the hedge funds, not something off-the-shelf. My reasoning is that sentiment analysis and similar techniques have been used for a while, and LLMs raise them to the next level, so they are bound to be beneficial.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by perrygeo on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:40AM (#36572735)
Same. My friends in other white-collar-ish jobs, which require lots of writing, are smitten with ChatGPT and think it's amazing. Friends in tech are largely dismissive/critical of it's abilities while being skeptical/fearful of its impact.

My take is that, for most non-tech people, this is their first experience directing a computer to perform a precise task - ie programming. They're accustomed to using applications, not having a hand in making them. Maybe they've used Excel before and felt a bit of this power. But ChatGPT allows them to dream up a novel idea and get the computer to execute it - something that feels like magic to non-tech folks but is rather pedestrian for most of us in tech.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by voidfunc on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:50AM (#36572857)
This reason makes sense, but that's insanely powerful (and valuable) if it ends up working out. It basically democratizes programming.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by butler14 on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:05AM (#36573050)
That's exactly what it does. It closes the gap. Even now with all its shortcomings and issues.

It's actively solving problems for people and saving time / creating efficiency. That has value and economic utility.

I honestly don't get what a lot of the cynics in this thread and their "highly technical/IT friends" are missing.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by perrygeo on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:22AM (#36573312)
It's not saving time or creating efficiency for everyone equally. It's absolutely democratizing some complex tasks. I'll stick to software here, where AI enhances the abilities of non-programmers to give them a taste of what programmers have been doing for decades.

But does it enhance the end product? Does it improve upon the work of already competent developers? Does it actually solve the real problems that software engineers face? Highly debatable. It certainly makes cranking out code more "efficient" - but anyone who's every created software knows that cranking out lines of code is a terrible metric for success. Poor quality code has less than zero value, it's a liability. As the prevalence of bot-generated code goes up, it will place an increasingly high burden on actual professionals to clean up the mess.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by byteware on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:35AM (#36573498)
how is programming "democratized"?
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by square_usual on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:28PM (#36575257)
More people can now cobble barely functioning python scripts together and shoot themselves in the foot when it does something they don't understand :>
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by throwuwu on Monday July 03, 2023 @06:46PM (#36579798)
The point is they don’t need any code. They can copy paste a csv or something even messier and ask it to write a somewhat personalized email to each person in the list, if they’re smart about it they can include a few small details with each input entry that get included in the email. They also now have access to most NLP tools like sentiment analysis or feature extraction which allows them to process large amounts of text and extract valuable insights. They don’t need Python or a programmer as long as they’re smart enough to try out new things and learn the ins and outs of these models.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by square_usual on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:34PM (#36602849)
Realistically, nobody is working with CSVs so small that they fit within ChatGPT's window. I've helped friends and faily use ChatGPT to generate a python script that did what they wanted with CSV, and they all started with attempting to paste a ~x00 line CSV in the chat.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by SoftTalker on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:45PM (#36575503)
Except the essential difficulty with programming is not typing the code or even understanding the syntax and idioms of a particular language.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by ozim on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:40AM (#36573573)
I did not see a way where you can tell AI “make me a crud app for storing database of my post stamp collection” and it executes that.

It is quite a stretch to say that lay people can effortlessly write application only with AI whatever it is copilot or chatgpt.

You still have to know a lot of things to build simple crud to store data about stamp collection.

LLMs are not changing that.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by perrygeo on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:55AM (#36573785)
LLMs are not changing that, yet.

But well over a decade ago, we had high-level frameworks for translating "models" into all the gritty details of a crud app. Model description goes in. API endpoints, database migrations, admin UI, all auto-generated. I even developed something like it based on Django 0.96 (now abandoned).

It's not a stretch of the imagination to generate your model.py with model.txt containing the problem description in plain text.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by SoftTalker on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:49PM (#36575564)
Do you know any real professional software developers who actually use these modeling tools of their own volition and not because some manager fell for a golf-and-steak-dinner sales pitch from the vendor?

My experience with every one of them is that getting the model to the point where it will generate something useful is more work than just writing the useful part myself.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by perrygeo on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @03:11PM (#36605562)
As I alluded to in my comment, I have a ton of experience with such systems. And no, it was not some "golf-and-steak-dinner" - it was funded by a non-profit environmental organization, literally. I'm serious, AMA. Don't make shit up - reconsider your first point.

Your second point re: how model-driven code generation can be a dead-end... I totally agree. I didn't say it was a good idea! But it was motivated by a real need: generating lots of web apps in a particular domain.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by Footkerchief on Monday July 03, 2023 @10:23AM (#36573321)
The difference between AI and crypto is that AI does (some) existing work more efficiently (and is poised to become more efficient), while crypto does existing work less efficiently (and its inefficiencies are inextricable).
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by xyzelement on Monday July 03, 2023 @12:18PM (#36575119)
// currently it feels like the same hype as crypto

I keep seeing this take and it doesn't make any sense to me. Some tech has obvious utility and some doesn't.

For example, I knew internet (web, email) were valuable when I discovered them because accessing information and communicating with people were already things I did - the internet unequivocally made them faster and easier and often cheaper.

chatGPT / bard gave me a similar vibe - I use them to brain storm/shape ideas, and as mentioned elsewhere, they do a great job of tasks like drafting a job ad. These are things people already do and this tech just makes it better. So people will use it.

In contrast, I "get" why people were excited by crypto but I don't personally know anyone whose payment/banking experience is improved by it. As an American for example there was nothing tangible Bitcoin made easier vs my bank account and visa. So it was always less "obvious" that it was going to be a valuable thing beyond hype.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by eric_cc on Monday July 03, 2023 @01:32PM (#36576272)
Bitcoins user experience has taken time to evolve for the better. The real draw is that it’s immutable decentralized money with a predictable print schedule. When it reaches user experience parity with the dollar then it comes down to the true fundamentals of the currency and I suspect that bitcoin wins out.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by xyzelement on Monday July 03, 2023 @02:10PM (#36576749)
Like I said I get that, buy that's very different than being able to go to someone and say "this makes your life better in an obvious way" which is the point I am making, in contrast to internet and chat GPT.
Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by trog on Monday July 03, 2023 @06:03PM (#36579409)
> When it reaches user experience parity with the dollar then it comes down to the true fundamentals of the currency and I suspect that bitcoin wins out.

So far the only way this even comes close to happening is by wrapping centralised systems around it (e.g., exchanges), but that comes with a whole set of different drawbacks. This does not feel like a scenario that is possible, let alone likely.

Re:Ask HN: As people in “tech”, are we inside an AI echo cha... by golergka on Monday July 03, 2023 @04:48PM (#36578595)
> I don't personally know anyone whose payment/banking experience is improved by it. As an American

That's exactly because you live in a first world country with a reliable banking system.