News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Paul_S on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:30AM (#36533720)
Goodreads is only good (eh, decent?) as a database of books you've read. All the other functionality is pointless and or broken. The recommendation system is a joke and is obviously used to promote nonsense instead of giving you personalised recommendations.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by hospitalJail on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:41AM (#36533829)
I'm not sure why people like it so much. My aunt-in-law is high pressuring me to use it.

I have my library listing all the books I checked out. I have a pdf/epub reader that has a history of the books I read(although a new phone will probably wipe that out).

For a while, I was merely writing down my books in a dedicated notebook, but I realized that it didn't really matter, if a book was important, I remembered it. If it was bad, I forgot about it. I could have typed these into google sheets so it was sharable. I wonder if that is an acceptable option.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by prepend on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:51AM (#36533949)
For me, I like it better than my own list because I was spending unnecessary time finding and organizing books. So I like having the spelling and year right and just list management of want to read, reading, read. I did it in a google sheet, but now I spend less time using it.

I also like that I can add friends and see what they read. There’s no chance that I’ll open my aunt’s book list sheet once a week to see what’s changed but I would love to see her reading in my feed along with my other friends.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by cafard on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:29AM (#36534515)
I use a Google Sheet for the neighborhood book club list. It is handy for reference--did we read X, and if so, who picked it? The group has been going for something like 18 years, after which even the very good and the very bad can be forgotten.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Bellend on Friday June 30, 2023 @04:51PM (#36542091)
Would you consider sharing the sheet? I am always looking for books!
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by cafard on Sunday July 02, 2023 @11:16AM (#36562205)
I sent it to your Gmail address.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Bellend on Sunday July 02, 2023 @11:53AM (#36562632)
Thank you!!! :)
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by manojlds on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:42AM (#36534754)
It's social media for book readers. I user it to primarily see what my friends read and what they think about those books and about the books I read. It's not just place to keep note of books you read.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by joenot443 on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:34AM (#36536852)
Couldn’t agree more. There seems to be some confusion in this thread about the product’s value preposition - it’s a social network, not an archiving system. Using GoodReads alone strikes me like using Facebook alone, there’s just not much value there without other users.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by nozzlegear on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:53PM (#36538286)
This is exactly why my wife, our friends and I use Goodreads as well. It's fun to see what everyone is reading, and to comment on a book or ask what they thought about a book they just finished. We also enjoy comparing our year-in-review infographic that Goodreads creates each year.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by larperdoodle on Friday June 30, 2023 @10:35AM (#36535645)
But you don't just track books you've read, you also track books you want to read, which is much harder to remember.

I also tag them to indicate if I already own them and in what format (physical, epub, audio).

Saves me from purchasing duplicates when I'm at the used book store.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by hinkley on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:07AM (#36536228)
> you also track books you want to read

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsundoku

I know exactly what books I want to read.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Bellend on Friday June 30, 2023 @04:50PM (#36542069)
I am into my first thousand books. If I have a queue of 10-20 already purchased (garage, deals, new, offers) and someone recommends a book somewhere such as HN, I add it.

I don't think tracking books you want to read is Tsundoku.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by hinkley on Saturday July 01, 2023 @01:02AM (#36546756)
Neither do I.

I have over two shelf feet of books I plan to read and haven’t yet. No that’s a lie, it’s at least four.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Paul_S on Saturday July 01, 2023 @04:15AM (#36547932)
I never understood that concept. What is wrong with having your own library? I have about 200 books on my shelves I haven't read and any time I want to I can find something interesting. It's s luxury but not anything I'm embarrassed about. Makes more sense than keeping the books I've already read on my bookshelves.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @02:49AM (#36583089)
Nothing wrong with it as long as you have the space; anything else is more of a logistics challenge. I like owning books, sure they take up a lot of space and it's not likely I'll read or re-read them any time soon, but I think it's important to have it.

But also, more and more, having the physical space and safety to own a 'static' collection like books is becoming a luxury and a privilege.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by qingcharles on Saturday July 01, 2023 @06:39PM (#36556079)
Wow. I didn't know there was a word for this. This is why I only use ebooks now because physical books would just pile up.

10 years in jail got my reading list down considerably though. Managed to read over 800 books, though the one book that I really, really wanted to read[*] I only obtained just before my release and never finished: In Search of Lost Time by Proust.

[*] Based on a comment by a character in Murakami's 1Q84 that the only time you will have enough spare time to read Proust is if you end up in prison.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by CSMastermind on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:41AM (#36533831)
The new UI "upgrades" make it much harder to use as a database of books you've read.

I accidentally marked the wrong edition of a book as read the other day and it took me like 20 minutes to figure out how to switch the entry to the correct version.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by manojlds on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:43AM (#36534761)
Genuine question, why does it matter which version?
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Brybry on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:57AM (#36535000)
It can mess with other views/lists on the site.

Like a series list might only have one version of the book listed and it'll show the book at unread for you which can be really confusing when you've read 1000+ books and you're checking if you completed something or where you dropped it.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by thomaslangston on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:57AM (#36534989)
Not OP, but

Different Translations

Corrections or Updates

Additions

Different Illustrations

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by manojlds on Friday June 30, 2023 @10:07AM (#36535161)
But why does it matter when you mark it as read?
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by me_me_me on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:38AM (#36533798)
I have trouble finding new authors or good books on there to the point that I stopped trying.

I only use it for reading up reviews.

I was kinda shocked reading through their top X list and finding absolute garbage, rated 8+. I wonder if they suffer from IMDB syndrome.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by comboy on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:07AM (#36534169)
GPT4 is so far the best book recommendation system I've found. It did work better back when it was slow though.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by jabroni_salad on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:19AM (#36534335)
That can be solved with better tiering and categories.

I like low budget horror. I like how rookie filmmakers are capable of bringing brand new ideas out of the aether without even realizing it. I like it when a cheap actor has a single moment of greatness for no discernable reason.

I'm not stupid enough to think that any of them stack up with The Greats but I still like the films and personally rate them highly. Most film nerds would probably not appreciate my toplist, but it's not my fault everyone sorts by All.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Brybry on Friday June 30, 2023 @10:02AM (#36535076)
What I've found as a better metric of 'good' (at least for fiction) is the number of ratings, especially combined with star rating.

If something has a high number of ratings it's popular enough that it's probably decent (at least if you're into that genre).

Like a 4.38 rating w/ 2.7 million ratings (The Fellowship of the Ring) is a better bet compared to a 4.98 star with 150 ratings (random new book by unknown author).

Also, Goodreads doesn't have a 10 point system like IMDB, right? I believe all the ratings are 0 to 5.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by me_me_me on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:25PM (#36537836)
I present you:

Ready Player One Ernest Cline 4.23 1,099,069 ratings 99,154 reviews

It joined club of handful of books that I just stopped reading and threw into trash. Yet its 4.23 as of writing!

There are different tastes and likes, but that book is so poorly written and has such barebones plot... I don't know how it is popular

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by rerx on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:43AM (#36533850)
It's great for following people who read interesting books and may leave reviews that are worth reading. Of course this is an an extension of the database of books you've read, because you can compare your ratings quite easily with those of other people and find things they liked that you didn't know about yet. That's a great source of recommendations, much better than the automated systems.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by myth_drannon on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:56AM (#36534017)
There are two recommendations systems in Goodreads. One is the official, I agree it is completely broken. The other is "Readers also enjoyed" section on each book page and this one is very good.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by mhb on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:59AM (#36534057)
It doesn't seem so good and I can't imagine it's using anything sophisticated to make recommendations. What would be great is if it copied Netflix's Cinematch of yore and did SVD on a giant matrix of what you're liked/disliked and what others who have read the same books have liked/disliked.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by totoglazer on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:49AM (#36534872)
Isn’t that how literally every one of these is implemented for the last decade?
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by mhb on Friday June 30, 2023 @10:42AM (#36535753)
I don't know, but Cinematch is the last one I remember working well.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by saargrin on Sunday July 02, 2023 @10:48AM (#36561954)
its not very good in my experience, within a few "next" clicks you're completely off the path of whatever you were looking for
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by krono on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:17AM (#36534308)
I only use it to see if/where a book belongs to/in a series. No other aggregate-type website seems to provide this information in any usable fashion.

Used to use it for book release notifications too, but that broke some years ago for me and I've yet to receive a response to my support request from like 4 years ago.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by slothtrop on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:30AM (#36534524)
To be fair to the rec system, I've tried several alternatives and the results are either worse or as mediocre.

The most useful aspects might be community-driven, but I find the web app so sluggish that I tend not to bother with it now.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by prithee on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:32AM (#36534562)
They are valuable the reasons you mention. I'm an avid reader, and sometimes people will ask me a question about a recommendation or what I've read, and I have a complete brain lapse (to the extent it's as if you'd wonder if I read at all). Having a list helps that anxiety. I don't really use the other features, and only settled on Goodreads after the Shelfari "merge".

I do the same with logging film watches on IMDb, which is actually useful because I can visualize exact watch behavior by the timestamps, and using exports I can also query my film history for personal recommendations (select documentaries that are horror tagged I've watched from the last 10 years).

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by purple_ferret on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:39AM (#36534700)
The lists are user made and can be good for finding stuff on a topic.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by humanistbot on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:51AM (#36534899)
I like Zotero, which is developed for academic reference management, so it can work with longform articles, blog posts, as well. It has zero recommendation features and very limited group support, which I see as a feature.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Freak_NL on Friday June 30, 2023 @10:06AM (#36535142)
Zotero is great for keeping an inventory of your books. Super easy to add books just by entering the ISBN and sometimes tweaking the fetched entry a little.

I always export the books we have to a spreadsheet file for reference on my smartphone when we're going to a second-hand book fair.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by dkarl on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:52AM (#36534925)
With Goodreads it's strange because the ratings and reviews are pretty central in the UI. Lots of web sites have or have had parts that were completely trash but were easy to ignore. For example, for years it seemed like most of the YouTube comments on any video were something like "die, <slur>" for no discernible reason, regardless of the video content or the demographics of the channel, but it didn't matter because it was so easy to not see that part of the page and just think of YouTube as a site that didn't have (useful) comments. With Goodreads the reviews and ratings seem so central and hard to ignore, it's weird that they can get away with putting garbage front and center, even if they have other core functionality that is useful.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by mypastself on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:53AM (#36534941)
Similarly to Letterboxd, I use it primarily for maintaining my read and to-read lists. It's a pretty decent tool for that purpose.

Unlike Letterboxd, though, sometimes its reviews can be valuable, as long as you avoid big, popular books. Or you think gif extravaganzas are an acceptable means of literary criticism.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by mritchie712 on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:58AM (#36535021)
ChatGPT is the best book recommender I've used. Tell it a few books (even one book works) you like and it will give you solid recommendations.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by anaganisk on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:59AM (#36535031)
I guess all that reddit content scraping is a net profit.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by nindalf on Friday June 30, 2023 @10:10AM (#36535233)
It is good, but only for books published before the training cutoff date right? That’s sometime in 2021.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by jemmyw on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:02PM (#36545998)
Well, I assume it'll get updated at some point and there are more than enough books in the time span until it does.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by spacemadness on Friday June 30, 2023 @10:29AM (#36535568)
I found it often did what social media is partly designed to do—-make one insecure about whatever the focus is. You’re either not reading the right books, not analyzing and commenting enough on books you read for enjoyment, or not reading enough regardless of your actual place on those subjective spectrums. All their to make you feed the social media machine with your free labor in the form of analysis/reviews or whatever.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by jan_Inkepa on Friday June 30, 2023 @10:45AM (#36535799)
They have further hamstrung it recently by having it that non-moderators (or some euphemism for someone with such rights) can no longer add new books. I regularly read weird stuff not in their system and adding this extra barrier is disastrous.

I still use it...well, can I say I still use it if the last time I tried to add a book I couldn't? ... I just checked back - that was a month ago, and I even made a forum post about the book that it be added, but nope, book's not there...it seems nobody has even looked at the post. Sad times at goodreads. What a weird site. It's still charming in many ways.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Frummy on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:03AM (#36536142)
Yes that is the most painful thing on the entire platform. And supposedly the only reason it exists is because Amazon the owner doesn't want to deal with copyright issues of the photographs of the book covers. Antiquarian bookshops might have a lot of books that never have been categorised in this manner and to read mostly niche stuff and essentially being told nope you can't keep track of this read the 2023 best seller instead, kills culture.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by rerx on Monday July 03, 2023 @09:15AM (#36572444)
At least they integrated more automation so that many titles from Amazon's catalogs appear on Goodreads quite soon without manual work. So a lot of the recent stuff in the main languages at least often doesn't need to be added manually anymore.

It's crazy how much Goodreads relies on unpaid "librarian" contributions to keep their data in check. One problem with allowing the general population to add titles to the database is that the chance of getting malformed entries that will require manual fix ups (from these volunteers) later on is pretty high.

> I just checked back - that was a month ago, and I even made a forum post about the book that it be added, but nope, book's not there...it seems nobody has even looked at the post.

Volunteer librarians + zero dev support means that, if you really want to see the addition, you should bump your post daily or so until by chance it catches the eye of somebody...

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by matricaria on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:13AM (#36536356)
Why would you need a service to keep track on what you read? I have a text file with a list of book and some notes about every book. Works perfectly for me.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by mypastself on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:25AM (#36536634)
Same reasons to use a service instead of text file for anything else: ease of use (e.g. you can connect your Kindle to automatically add a book to the list on completion), metrics, challenges, etc.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by joenot443 on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:32AM (#36536796)
For myself, it’s much less about keeping track of what _I_ read, and much more more about seeing what my friends read. Perhaps it’s trite or mundane, but there are people from high school I haven’t seen in years whose reviews I look forward to because it brings me joy to read their voice again.

I’ve always seen GoodReads as more of a social network than just a list of what one’s read because you’re right, the latter is well replaced by a document.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Loughla on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:21AM (#36536549)
I'm learning now that this is even something that people keep track of.

This next section isn't meant to be shitty: but what's the purpose of even keeping track of that? I've read hundreds, maybe thousands of books over my life and don't have a list of them anywhere, nor can I see a use for that.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by dimaor on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:25AM (#36536640)
personally, having a list of books helps me keep up the reading habit. usually I have months of reading, followed by months of not touching a book.

having a list in notion reminds me to continue.

in addition having a list of books I want to read (ghost library in japanese?) reminds of the things I don't know yet or haven't read which in turn helps keeping the reading habits.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Loughla on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:28AM (#36536706)
Thank you for the response. A list of prospective books to read is something I believe everyone should have.

It was the list of books already read that didn't make sense. I hadn't considered it as a motivator to pick back up the habit.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by creer on Friday June 30, 2023 @03:14PM (#36540631)
You may also simply have much better memory of author names and works titles than I or others have. I often can't quote a name on the spot even when I vividly remember the book (or movie, or track). Or be much earlier in your reading career.

For me these lists (which I regret starting far too late in my own reading career) now cover about 9000 items.

For me the prompt to starting the process was noticing that I was again and again giving a chance to really terrible authors. That had to stop. And it did.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by stepbeek on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:26PM (#36537859)
I've been tempted to start foor gifts. Family buy me books for Xmas and having a big list of what i already own would make that easier.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by ZeroGravitas on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:28PM (#36537871)
I have lists of books I want to read. And books I'm "reading", which actually means have them on hand and ready to go and or actually reading them.

As a natural feature of clearing out those lists when I finish a book, you create a book read list. I don't have much use for this but it is interesting to review the stats on say author nationality.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by creer on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:44PM (#36538139)
To keep track of authors and series I follow, over many years. To collect quick notes. Both for myself and ready for recommendations to others. To avoid trying again authors I dismissed ages ago (but whose book covers and blurbs still tempt me.) To keep several lists/queues to things to read (theme-based lists most of them). A few years ago I added date marks for when I read or re-read each item. I general these lists have made my reading more systematic and I can now always, but always instantly pick something that I wanted to read AND is on the shelf at the library.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Shugarl on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:46PM (#36538169)
Personal satisfaction. "Ooga booga, number get bigger" kind of thing
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by m_0x on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:52AM (#36537202)
Because it's prettier than a text file.

Because I can see what my connections (close and not-at-all-close friends) are reading.

Because I like it and have been using it pretty much since 2013.

Goodreads works perfectly for me as it was intended to be used: a nice book database

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by senko on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:00PM (#36537354)
Why would you need a list at all?

If it's worth remembering, you'll remember you've read it, and if you want to refresh your memory what better than to reread?

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by anytime5704 on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:33PM (#36537977)
Your memory must be better than mine.

Having a couple notes about the things that stood out to me at the time is a great way to remind myself how I felt about books I’ve long since stopped thinking about.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by bmlzootown on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:39PM (#36538083)
Yeah, I've read the same book multiple times before, years apart, without realizing it. Only when I went back to Goodreads later to mark it as read did I realize that... well, I had already read it.

On the flip side, I can enjoy a book more than once. This is a definite plus.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by senko on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:17PM (#36538704)
Oh I'm sure I can't recall a bunch of (details of) books I've read.

On the flip side, I have a firm belief that every book worth reading changes you at least a little, so even if I don't remember it consciously, it has had an impact on me.

I did try writing notes at some point, and stopped after the first attempt. That was several years ago and I never read those notes :)

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by derstander on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:33PM (#36537967)
> Why would you need a list at all? > If it's worth remembering, you'll remember you've read it, and if you want to refresh your memory what better than to reread?

If it’s not worth remembering, you won’t remember if you read it or not — so you could waste time rereading a forgettable book until you realize. ;)

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by beej71 on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:30PM (#36538912)
My memory doesn't "iterate" very well. Ask me all the places I visited last year, and I'll fail to recall some of the big ones. But if you say the name of the place, of course I know I was there.

Same with books. I've had plenty of times where I'd start reading a book and then a chapter in recall it. It's just nice to have a list.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by newaccount74 on Friday June 30, 2023 @02:33PM (#36539950)
I don't keep a list of books that I read for exactly this reason. But the drawback is that I have a few nordic detective stories on my bookshelf and I don't remember which of them I read already.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday July 04, 2023 @02:52AM (#36583111)
I mean it's convenient to have quick links to extra resources and the like, but... those are a single search query away anyway, so a text file is fine.

I really should start a notes file or spreadsheet to log my collections of things; I'm at a risk to accidentally buy doubles of e.g. video games now with all the cross platform releases and promotions. Play them though? Nah, I got a backlog and I prefer my 10 year old comfort games.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by Sparkle-san on Friday June 30, 2023 @12:10PM (#36537547)
I will add that goodreads is the best metadata source I've found for calibre in terms of accuracy and completeness.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by mhermher on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:40PM (#36539071)
For me, it's more of a database to keep track of books I want to read in the future. I can't read everything immediately after reading a recommendation or seeing it mentioned somewhere. Mostly I use goodreads to organize this list. It ends up getting into the "read" list after, but that part isn't as important. And when I am approaching an empty stack of books to read, I go on there and try to pop from the top of the stack on my "want to read" high priority list.
Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by kjs3 on Friday June 30, 2023 @04:39PM (#36541912)
it's more of a database to keep track of books I want to read in the future.

I use a notepad.

Re:Goodreads Has No Incentive to Be Good by ddingus on Saturday July 01, 2023 @12:57PM (#36552107)
I do that for a lot of things. Paper has no downtime, is robust, etc...

When it comes to longer term basic information, bitmaps and text are where it's at!

I can always convert my paper to a bitmap, and often from that to text if I want to. And authoring simple text basically works on every computer going back to the Apple //e I started on, which sits on my workbench to this day. (it's there to play various games people still write for it!)