News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by PoignardAzur on Saturday June 24, 2023 @07:48AM (#36457861)
A lot of these feel like lazy worldbuilding.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by gortok on Saturday June 24, 2023 @07:54AM (#36457899)
It was a TV show back when they wrote 26 episodes a year, and were producing a show a week. Heck, the entire Star Trek universe is taking pieces of ideas that you see for seconds and turning them into whole backstories.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by PoignardAzur on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:02AM (#36457946)
Don't get me wrong, I love the expanded universe thing. Lower Decks is one of my favorite animated shows.

Just, you have to recognize that the source material had its flaws. Like, this:

A contract is a contract is a contract… but only between Ferengi.

That's just kind of... bleh? Especially when, yes, you consider the ethnic stereotypes "culture of sneering traders who will cheat you" evokes. But even without those stereotypes, it's just kind of childish.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by true_religion on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:27AM (#36458113)
Well, non Ferengi will often sign contracts then come back to claim they didn’t know it bound them to do illegal actions, or refuse to do something immoral or worse yet claim bankruptcy and try to run from debt.

So this line is a warning about outsiders.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by Ekaros on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:51AM (#36458278)
Federation is great example of this. They go to planet and one of their crew members commits a crime... And then they fail to allow just punishment to happen to that crew member. Just goes to show that they feel superior to other races and do not follow any laws that might apply to them.

With such people how could contract be contract?

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by nurettin on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:03AM (#36458358)
Yeah but it's usually something akin to "capital punishment for pressing the grass" which is just ridiculously outlandish pardon the pun.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by teekert on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:40AM (#36458606)
“When has justice ever been as simple as a rule book?“
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by nurettin on Saturday June 24, 2023 @02:25PM (#36461335)
You know s1e8! The quote fits so well with the website's intentions.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by scarface_74 on Saturday June 24, 2023 @12:17PM (#36459963)
The “crime” that Wesley committed in one episode was that he was playing sports with some other teenagers and accidentally fell into a flower bed.

The punishment? death.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by eesmith on Saturday June 24, 2023 @03:31PM (#36461937)
> they fail to allow just punishment to happen to that crew member

Which episode were you thinking of?

I'm assuming TNG's "Justice"? In ToS "Wolf in the Fold", Scott did not commit the crime but was subject to the local authorities; In DS9 "Hard Time" O'Brien did not commit the crime but was subject to and punished by the local authorities; In ToS "A Taste of Armageddon" the entire crew violate local law by not reporting to the disintegration chambers; In ToS "City on the Edge of Forever" Kirk and Spock steal clothing, and Spock steals tools (that one concerned the human race); In "Patterns of Force" Kirk and Spock are arrested and interrogated after stealing clothing and attempting to infiltrate a government building; In VOY "The Chute" Paris and Kim are imprisoned after a false conviction; In VOY "Ex Post Facto" Paris is imprisoned after a false conviction.

(Also, Nog attacked an army captain while under detention in New Mexico in DS9 "Little Green Men", and escaped without punishment by the local authorities.)

If you are talking about "Justice", I don't think your characterization is quite accurate. In fact, I think you've flipped things? Quoting Memory Alpha at https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Justice_(episode):

> Liato feels that Picard is suggesting some kind of a superiority. He suggests that the Enterprise just use their superior powers to rescue the boy, stating that they would just record him as a convicted criminal out of their reach, an advanced person who luckily escaped the barbarism of their "backward little world". But Picard tells them that he wants to honor and respect the Edo's rules and law, referencing the Prime Directive.

and

> Rivan is amazed at "the city" in the sky, and is surprised that with all this power, they do not just take Wesley. ...

> Finally, Picard asks how the Edo God aliens would react if they were to violate the Prime Directive and Data answers that they would consider the Enterprise crew to be "deceitful and untrustworthy" and subsequently reminds Picard that the Edo God aliens warned them to not to interfere with their children below.

Picard, before the sundown deadline when Wesley's execution was supposed to take place, instead appeals to the Edo god / high-tech "parent" and receives leniency. Its/their authority is above that of the Mediators, and recognized as such by the Edo.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by Ekaros on Saturday June 24, 2023 @03:44PM (#36462046)
So they broke the rules and did not accept absolutely reasonable and just punishment for the heinous crime. Likely they used something threat of genocide to attain their goals.

If you go to different country and break laws, ýou should be fully expected to accept any punishment. Especially when you are specially selected for such missions. And this should extend to anyone you take with you. Just leave the kids and families home if you can not lose risking them when they do evil things.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by eesmith on Saturday June 24, 2023 @05:04PM (#36462633)
I take it then "Justice" is the episode you were thinking of?

> did not accept absolutely reasonable and just punishment for the heinous crime

The Edo "Gods" are recognized by the Edo as being above the power of the Edo. The Edo Gods granted clemency, which was within their power and thus within the Edo legal system.

You used the word "heinous". Does the story show the Edo consider it a heinous crime? I suspect that's your personal characterization.

At the very least, the Edo youth with Crusher attempted to argue that the crime was done without understanding, which suggests they might consider other crimes (perhaps one carried out with forethought and malice) as more heinous.

(If the violation of any law which requires corporal punishment is "heinous" by definition, then the entire crew of the Enterprise in "A Taste of Armageddon" commit a heinous crime by not reporting to the disintegration chambers after the simulated attack on their ship.)

> Likely they used something threat of genocide to attain their goals.

That makes me think you are talking about another episode?

There is no threat of genocide in "Justice", or anything like that. At best the threat was to run away - something even the local authorities pointed out as an option.

Further, the Edo Gods' abilities were far superior to that of the Enterprise, eg, almost invisible to sensors, able to shut down the Enterprise transporter remotely, and able to detect the new colony in the nearby star system. There was no conceivable threat of genocide or use of force against the population.

> ýou should be fully expected to accept any punishment

That's ... just wrong. I mean, in the human system we don't "accept any punishment". We can appeal a punishment to a higher court, or to someone who is empowered to grant a pardon for some or all of that punishment. (Carter pardoned draft dodgers who hadn't even been punished.)

Picard figured out that the local legal system did recognize a higher court, as it were, and figured out a successful strategy to appeal to that authority, in a way everyone agreed was justice.

Thankfully, punishment was stayed by the supreme local authority. We don't know what would have happened had that not occurred.

> Especially when you are specially selected for such missions.

I agree. Thing is, they did prepare. Early on Yar reported "the inhabitants' laws and customs are pretty straightforward and nothing out of the ordinary" (quoting Memory Alpha). It was only later, after arrival and further research into the legal system, that they learned they themselves were subject to capital punishment for any violation of the law. Quoting https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sfqa596xxbc :

Yar: Careful Commander. They've got some strange laws here.

Riker: I thought you reviewed their laws.

Yar: They listed nothing about punishment.

(IMO they should have requested an emergency beam-out of the entire team at that moment, which would have saved Crusher, but given this is a fictional story, the writers would have made the crime occur just before Yar learned the legal situation they were in.)

You characterized this away team's presence on the planet as following a contract. I think it's a valid viewpoint.

How valid is a contract where the penalty clauses aren't included in the contract and aren't made aware to one of the signatories?

(Still, that doesn't explain why Yar didn't notice that punishment was missing, when it should be part of any similar contract.)

> when they do evil things

The show only establishes the Edo consider what Crusher did was a crime. We do not know enough about the Edo sense of morality to establish what they consider "evil".

In human morality, we do not regard as "evil" every person who commits a crime.

Why then do you characterize what Crusher did as an "evil thing"? Or are you speaking abstractly about some hypothetical "evil thing"?

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by Ekaros on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:12AM (#36458017)
Then again even in our own world contract is only as strong as the legal system backing it. Treaties and agreements change things, but going beyond that it is often true.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by zo1 on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:25AM (#36458101)
Judging by how many "contracts" between the west and Russia I imagine have been broken over the war in Ukraine, its actually deeper than many think. We forget how writers and comedians have a good pulse on human nature without all the fluff and feel good narrative we like to placate ourselves with.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by zo1 on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:30AM (#36458141)
Let's also not forget: "War is good for business."

In contrast with another one: "Peace is good for business"

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by ant6n on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:59AM (#36458746)
Ah the 34th and 35th of rule of acquisition. It’s easy to get them mixed up.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by amelius on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:09AM (#36458394)
I guess nowadays scriptwriters can just come up with economic rules and play them out using a gazillion AI agents to see if they make sense.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by uhtred on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:13AM (#36458434)
Are we gearing up to cancelling the Ferengi now for being racist? If so I surrender. Lock me up, throw away the key. Quark is one of my favorite characters on DS9.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by ravenstine on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:23AM (#36458491)
Given enough time, everything is *-ist.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by pierat on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:45AM (#36458659)
> That's just kind of... bleh? Especially when, yes, you consider the ethnic stereotypes "culture of sneering traders who will cheat you" evokes. But even without those stereotypes, it's just kind of childish.

I get on one level that the Bajorans were much like the historical Jewish peoples, conquered and then freed.

But.... I always thought that the Ferenghi were the eponymous Jew stereotype. Short stature, crooked teeth, would cheat you at a drop of a hat, overly large ears, code of conduct to only deal with their race. It feels like they were created in the antisemitic light of "Happy Merchant" ( https://www.adl.org/resources/hate-symbol/happy-merchant ).

Obviously, those are antisemitic tropes for starting to dehumanize Jews. But damn, when I saw them in ST:TNG, that's exactly what I thought Rodenberry was trying to portray.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by edvinbesic on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:53AM (#36458716)
I thought the Ferenghi were supposed to represent human greed.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by pmoriarty on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:10AM (#36458825)
They're cringe-inducing, antisemitic caricatures of Jewish people.

They're kind of like the Star Trek counterpart to Jar Jar Binks.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by flangola7 on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:42AM (#36459075)
Jar jar? What racial stereotype is he
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by shkkmo on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:25AM (#36458952)
I think seeing them as caricatures is itself antisemitic. There really are no similarities I see between the Ferengi and Jewish people.

In TNG they might be one dimensional like Jar Jar, but I think the Ferengi get a lot of nuanced characters in DS9 that blow Jar Jar Binks out of the water in depth. Rom's evolution is particularly great.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by pharrington on Saturday June 24, 2023 @11:13AM (#36459373)
>There really are no similarities I see between the Ferengi and Jewish people.

Correct. But there is a whole lotta similarity between the Ferengi and real life antisemetic caricatures, as is easily seen by any internet search for "antisemitic caricatures".

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by shkkmo on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:21PM (#36463994)
Sure, but acknowledging them as caricatures seems to me to be to legitimizing the anti-semitic stereotypes since a charicature is a portrayal that exaggerates existing characteristics.

Thus I maintain that claiming that the characteristics exhibited by the Ferengi are an exaggeration of Jewish traits is itself racist.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by uoaei on Saturday June 24, 2023 @11:23AM (#36459458)
Understanding and describing how racists talk about the groups they hate is not racist.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by pierat on Saturday June 24, 2023 @01:25PM (#36460716)
Indeed. And unfortunately, unmoderated and less moderated subcultures have this in spades.

It's also why I chose to link to the ADL in this description, rather than other meme sites. It provides the much needed context that the initial linked picture was done in the 1990s, by "A. Whytt Mann".

Naturally, the Ferenghis were made as a personification of the worst that capitalism has to offer. However, the caricature itself of the Ferenghi turned into something quite terrible indeed.

And as some have said here and claimed of me, this isn't my antisemitism showing. In fact, scholars have mirrored my own thoughts:

> In his 2007 critique of The Next Generation for the National Review, the commentator Jonah Goldberg described the Ferengi as "runaway capitalists with bullwhips who looked like a mix between Nazi caricatures of Jews and the original Nosferatu."[28] The scholar of religion Ross S. Kraemer wrote that "Ferengi religion seems almost a parody, perhaps of traditional Judaism."[25] He wrote that the 285 Rules of Acquisition bore similarities with the 613 Commandments of Judaism and that the Ferengi social restrictions on women mirrored Orthodox Judaism's restrictions on women studying the Torah.[25] Historian Paul Sturtevant wrote in 2018 that not only are the Ferengi "extremely legalistic" and "defined by their greed", echoing common stereotypes of Jews, but the major Ferengi characters on Deep Space Nine were all played by Jewish actors.[29]

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ferengi

And the 285 rules of acquisition vs 613 commandments ties back to the main article, since I like to keep tying back in.

That just seems to be way too many "coincidences" for me to be comfortable with.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by lanstin on Saturday June 24, 2023 @02:53PM (#36461608)
The similarity is between the Ferengi and the anti-Jewish propaganda that is so common historically.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by beardog on Saturday June 24, 2023 @11:35AM (#36459561)
* * *
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by DropInIn on Saturday June 24, 2023 @12:36PM (#36460170)
No.

Just because you have prejudices you apply to the work does not mean the creators did, which is where any factuality of racism or caricature could come to be.

Your prejudices and experiences aren't shared by everyone else, which means that they may create material that has zero negative features but for which You Perceive negative features due exclusively to Your Prejudices.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by andrepd on Saturday June 24, 2023 @12:43PM (#36460235)
Isn't that a bit... strange? You see a caricature of greed and you immediately think of Jews, doesn't that say something about yourself?
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by throw0101a on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:52AM (#36459168)
Originally, yes:

> The Original Series had come from hostility between the US and the USSR during the Cold War, Wright sought an equivalent relevant to the US of the era he was living in, the 1980s. There was meanwhile a palpable feeling that the nation's financial sector was essentially full of greedy barbarians, a notion Wright transplanted into the futuristic science-fiction setting of The Next Generation. (Star Trek: The Next Generation 365, p. 36) Rob Bowman offered, "The Ferengi sprung from the stereotype of agents and lawyers being cutthroat, greedy and wanting only money." (Cinefantastique, Vol. 21, No. 2, p. 35) Wright thus conceived the Ferengi as a species of profit-obsessed, ruthless aliens. He was especially fond of the contrast between them and the crew of the Enterprise-D, who had no desire or need for money. (Star Trek: The Next Generation 365, p. 36)

* https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Ferengi#Origins

Things got tweaked over time of course.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by MawKKe on Saturday June 24, 2023 @02:37PM (#36461464)
We're all Ferengi now...
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by g8oz on Saturday June 24, 2023 @11:09AM (#36459343)
I always thought it was interesting that the writers named the group after a real historical label for (Western European) foreigners.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franks#Legacy

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by dotancohen on Thursday June 29, 2023 @12:45AM (#36516385)
As were the Romulans.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by toyg on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:55AM (#36459193)
At what point trying to label something as racist ends up backfiring?

For people born toward the end of last century, the stereotypes you mention barely register at all. I only know them for having studied Weimar at undergrad level, but tbh the only stereotype of Jewishness, for me and my peers, is of well-dressed New Yorker professionals and LA executives using funny words.

Without comments as yours, I honestly would never have thought of late-1800s caricatures of Jews when looking at a Ferengi. You are effectively re-popularizing something that is utterly dead in the mainstream.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by brookst on Saturday June 24, 2023 @11:43AM (#36459642)
You’re kind of advocating the “let’s all pretend the past didn’t happen” theory of easing racial tensions by never mentioning slavery, etc.

It’s a viewpoint, but I’m very skeptical.

IMO it is perfectly reasonable to contextualize a fictional race by the creators and the time it was created. Intentional ignorance and choosing to ignore reality never sit well with me. I’m more in the “those who ignore history are doomed to repeat it” camp myself.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by DropInIn on Saturday June 24, 2023 @12:33PM (#36460145)
No.

A Character Type is different than a Caricature, which is Specifically when one is representing a Specific Person or Peoples.

When there is no such intent and is not based explicitly in such prior art, such characters are just that purely imaginary characters with zero bearing on real world racism.

Enough with the bs.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by grog454 on Saturday June 24, 2023 @02:01PM (#36461044)
This is a strange take that seems best described as "raciphobia". It's not "bs" to ask whether or suggest that a creative work was inspired by a stereotype.

There's the creator's intent which can't really be known. Then there's the observer's interpretation which is equally valid.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by Izkata on Saturday June 24, 2023 @02:54PM (#36461618)
We can know in this case: It wasn't, back when the Ferengi were first created their civilization was more like a cross between conquerors and pirates than anything else. Their current depiction evolved slowly over the course of TNG.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by DropInIn on Saturday June 24, 2023 @06:58PM (#36463421)
The creators intent can be known When They've Explicitly Discussed It.

You're Presuming based on your Prejudices aka Pre-Judging.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by TeMPOraL on Saturday June 24, 2023 @01:47PM (#36460919)
If history tells us anything, it's that keeping past offenses and injustices alive and on top of everyone's mind is how you get centuries of bloody wars, with each generation trying to "get justice" for what the other side done to their parents. Rinse, repeat.

"Eye for an eye makes the whole world go blind", and all that. Surely there is a better way.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by afavour on Saturday June 24, 2023 @02:20PM (#36461270)
You appear to be suggesting that because you weren’t aware of something that means it isn’t mainstream. I was also born towards the end of the last country and I’m very aware of the stereotypes we’re discussing here. So we’ve got two conflicting anecdotes.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by scubbo on Saturday June 24, 2023 @04:48PM (#36462521)
Add me (born 1990) to the list of people who immediately recognized Ferengi as playing into how racist people would stereotype Jewishness. "Utterly dead in the mainstream" is pushing it somewhat.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by at_a_remove on Saturday June 24, 2023 @12:18PM (#36459973)
A friend of mine, half-Korean, made a tremendous case that the Ferengi were stereotypes of Koreans and I wish I had recorded it, because it was thoughtful and well-supported.

I guess some stereotypes are really archetypes and people fit them as needed ... or as feared about one's self.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by DropInIn on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @01:01PM (#36495689)
Nearly everyone thinks the ferengi are a stereotype of them, from Capitalists to Jews to Koreans and where I live pretty much every ethnicity has had a stereotype of greed at some point because of population distribution and the nature of segregation into specific industries (banking, car sales, etc)...

Right now people are saying Indians/Pakistanis/Punjabs/etc are greedy because they are the vast majority of used car salesmen where I am, and I'm certain that they'd feel similarly about the representation of ferengi.

Ferengi are compilations of some of the least pleasant parts human nature. All people are manifest therein, because We're All Horrible.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by DropInIn on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @12:55PM (#36495580)
It's what we see in our own world.

A contract is a contract, provided all parties are in and beholden to the same jurisdiction.

Theres plenty of examples of bad actors who violated contracts without recourse due to living where no action could be taken or the wronged party simply not having "standing" as a non-citizen....

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by gortok on Saturday June 24, 2023 @07:59AM (#36457928)
Cardassians? Germany post WW1

The marquis? French resistance Against? The Germans.

Romulans? Romans.

Remans? Guess who?

Vulcans? Greek.

Klingons? Russians/Japanese depending on the Star Trek series.

Federation? Evolved America.

Ferengi? Present day capitalism.

Borg? Eventual conclusion of overreliance on technology.

All of the archetypes and races from Star Trek are taken from germs in our own history.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by jiggawatts on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:13AM (#36458024)
Borg = Space Zombies
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by the_gipsy on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:21AM (#36458067)
> Remans? Guess who?

Africans?

> Ferengi

Jewish people.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by synetic on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:29AM (#36458130)
I took Ferengi to be written as a ridicule of those pursuing an Ayn Randian style utopia where everything is a business negotiation. It is not, in my opinion, a reference to Jews.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by zo1 on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:35AM (#36458180)
As a fan of the series, I'd argue thay they definitely took inspiration for the Ferengi from a caricature of traders, greed, utilitarianism and overall love of money and materialism.

But to be fair yes, everything in real life is a negotiation at the end of the day. Relationships included.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by synetic on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:49AM (#36458265)
I disagree with the first sentence. I believe the Ferengi were written to show what they think happens with the sort of unfettered capitalism that the U.S. appears to be on a path to implementing.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by eddieroger on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:54AM (#36458302)
This is what I took from them as well, particularly since Star Trek was set in an Earth post-scarcity. When humanity has progressed to the stars as a result of the end of modern society in a war, the Ferengi were a foil against what we have versus what we can become.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by Steltek on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:03AM (#36458775)
Ah yes. All those Jewish women who aren't allowed to wear the clothes they want, own property, or conduct business without a male present.

It's not as straight forward as "ferengi" = "Jewish".

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by RobotToaster on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:48AM (#36458251)
I always took the Bajorans to be an obvious allegory to Palestine.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by ant6n on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:43AM (#36458635)
Yes, but Marquis != Bajoran resistance.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by orls on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:53AM (#36458294)
I always felt that the DS9 relationships between Cardassians & Bajorans was a product of the time when the show was written, and had stronger overtones of the 1990s Balkans conflicts and Israel/Palestine than anything else. (Though it’s far from a direct allegory for either)
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by arp242 on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:19AM (#36458469)
You also had The Troubles in Northern-Ireland at the time, and that's not a huge leap either.

I've also seen people describe the Bajorans as an analogue for the Jewish diaspora.

You can fit many real-life events, even more if you try hard enough.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by dopidopHN on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:23AM (#36458492)
Maquis : it’s a French word for tall grass or, like here, underground resistance.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by hef19898 on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:24AM (#36458933)
Only that the Star Trek Maquis is later also faught by the Federation. Which makes the Federation, what, Vichy France?

I really seem to be way more indulged with Star Wars, were supporting insurgents against oppresive regimes was what the Good (TM) do.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by dopidopHN on Saturday June 24, 2023 @03:27PM (#36461904)
There is some episode of DS9 where the legitimacy of the maquis is bring upon. One of the female lead has connection to it and it’s problematic.

I like those grey area better

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by ravenstine on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:25AM (#36458503)
I always thought the Vulcans had more in common with Eastern cultures than a Western one like the Greeks.

Also, Bajorans = Israelis

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by ant6n on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:01AM (#36458759)
Also, Palestinians = Bajorans. (Don’t attempt the transitive property on this one, for it will probably get u in trouble)
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by DropInIn on Saturday June 24, 2023 @12:47PM (#36460284)
Bajorans are not Israelis, though they are in part inspired by the Jewish experience.

Keep in mind there was no major Exodus, the vast majority of bajorans remained on Bajor and never left. The fee who did were either escaping the cardis or were taken for slavery offworld.

They're actually more aptly described as amalgam of Pre WWII Jews (more specifically Zionist terrorists like the Irgun aka Likud), the Irish during and after the Troubles, and the Current Palestinians....

If we're going to focus on the source people's at all maybe it behooves us to focus on the ones actually facing the horrors depicted, rather than those who used long past atrocities as excuse for their own misdeeds.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by DropInIn on Saturday June 24, 2023 @12:42PM (#36460226)
Bajorans? An amalgam of post WWII Jews, Irish during and after the Troubles, and modern Palestinians.

Interestingly one of those groups is still being very actively oppressed and abused, yet everyone always ignores that and often denies their part in the references which inspired the creation of the Bajorans.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by hydrok9 on Saturday June 24, 2023 @01:30PM (#36460764)
The Cardassians seem a lot more like Stalinist USSR, or maybe East Germany to me.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by chongli on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:02AM (#36457944)
Could you elaborate? Do you mean they’re lazy at world-building? Or do you assert that the process of world-building itself is lazy storytelling?

Personally, I happen to love the Ferengi and their Rules. They started off as villains on TNG but they’re just too comical for that. DS9 seriously developed their culture into a lovely satire on capitalism. At the same time, the show developed their individual characters to an impressive extent, transforming them from the “greedy merchant/criminal” hat to something much deeper.

I think the greatest lesson of Star Trek is that we need to look past our stereotypes and past the most visible manifestations of culture to see people as individuals. The Ferengi, being such a strong caricature, challenged us to do so even more than the Klingons.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by ant6n on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:28AM (#36458977)
Once you look past the stereotype, the other cultures allow a new perspective on us, that is, the perfect humans in Star Trek. A rather poignant moment in this respect is the Episode in DS9, when the humans encounter the “dominion” with whom they will start a war a 2 years later. Quark gives this little speech to Sisko, arguably the moral center of DS9, who’s been kind of looking down on Quark the whole episode:

“The way I see it, hew-mons used to be a lot like Ferengi: greedy, acquisitive, interested only in profit. We're a constant reminder of a part of your past you'd like to forget. But you're overlooking something: Hew-mons used to be a lot worse than the Ferengi. Slavery. Concentration camps. Interstellar wars. We have nothing in our past that approaches that kind of barbarism. You see? We're nothing like you. We're better.”

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by acheron on Saturday June 24, 2023 @10:45AM (#36459099)
That was one of the best moments where the writers actually took the Ferengi society seriously. Unfortunately they didn’t really stick with it later in the series.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by OscarCunningham on Saturday June 24, 2023 @07:59AM (#36457925)
Yeah, the Ferengi exist only as a counterpoint to the Federation; not as a society that could actually function. Capitalism is always shown in a negative light, except for that one episode where Nog goes on a fetch quest.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by chongli on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:10AM (#36457998)
I disagree. Every time we think “that could never happen” in our society, it happens. In my life time, I’ve watched the rise of software as something you buy and own, and saw it transform completely into something you rent. The Ferengi society is the logical conclusion to this process. On Ferenginar you have to pay for everything, with the equivalent of parking meters everywhere.

Our society is rapidly heading in that direction. The main difference is that at least the Ferengi are honest about the values that govern their society. I think we’re far more likely to end up like the Ferengi than we are the federation.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by OscarCunningham on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:25AM (#36458088)
Yeah, the bit that's bad world-building is that they have these terrible values which are repeatedly shown not to work, and yet simultaneously they have a successful interstellar civilization.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by chongli on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:41AM (#36458217)
that they have these terrible values which are repeatedly shown not to work

What? Like our values? The Ferengi are developed to be every bit as unique, individually, as we are. We see Ferengi scientists, murderers, reformers, inventors, and leaders.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by paulryanrogers on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:02AM (#36458354)
> The Ferengi never tolerated slavery.

Ferengi females were arguably slaves since they had so few rights.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by sharkbot on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:48AM (#36458681)
But the Ferengis changed their society to include “fe-males” due to internal politics and change from within. It wasn’t instituted from the outside, it was Ferengi society advancing via the means of their own political system.

I think that speaks highly of the Ferengi social system.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by tempodox on Saturday June 24, 2023 @11:30AM (#36459526)
But they have indentured servitude, which is not that far from slavery.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by Ekaros on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:30AM (#36458134)
And clearly they are somewhat integral part in operation of the part of galaxy they are in. As people keep trading often in their currency. Even the federation occasionally get hands on Latinum.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by Ekaros on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:02AM (#36457945)
Not that Federation was a society that could function either... I'm not sure deeply about others, but in general it felt that most of them would fail.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by hnlmorg on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:16AM (#36458041)
There are odd episodes throughout Star Trek that do show the diversity within each society. Such as Klingon scientists.

It’s also worth noting that the Ferengi were space worthy centuries before humans and one of the reasons speculated for their stagnation was the placement of greed above all else.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by gvurrdon on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:38AM (#36458202)
Which episode showed Klingon scientists? I’d be very interested to see that.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by transcriptase on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:02AM (#36458353)
TNG 6x22 - "Suspicions"

:)

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by ravenstine on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:16AM (#36458446)
Also "Affliction" and "Divergence" in season 4 of Enterprise.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by gvurrdon on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:05AM (#36458373)
Thanks! I’ll take a look at Netflix later.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by dundarious on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:10AM (#36458410)
I believe this has one scientist each from a few of the major species, including Klingons: https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/The_Chase_(episode)
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by XorNot on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:11AM (#36458013)
The Federation has Replicators and the Transporter. They are almost the only type of society that makes sense in the setting.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by Ekaros on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:16AM (#36458040)
Do they transport for example Ores or building materials out of planets? Who actually builds all the stuff that can't be replicated? And can they just quit their job or take personal time off when ever they want?

Also if you really think that everything goes through replicators, what does that mean for energy expenditure? If done on planets where does all the energy go?

And don't everyone else have those two things too? So why did Cardassia need mining outpost?

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by hnlmorg on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:20AM (#36458065)
Replicators were always described as being energy hungry. In some instances slave labour was “cheaper”. In other instances they used the “this material cannot be replicated” loophole. Such as the drug that the Dominion were addicted to.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by XorNot on Saturday June 24, 2023 @01:13PM (#36460627)
Which also doesn't make sense: you can't replicate the drug, but it hardly implies you also can't replicate the factory which makes it, for example. Just how far up the "can't do that" chain do you go?

The thing is, the mechanism of the Replicator is less important then what it represents: productivity with zero human labor input. We don't live in that world - we have trouble conceiving of that world. But that's essentially the whole promise of AI: robots which can build more robots, which can then build products for us.

At some point, your whole civilizations pipeline becomes "energy + robot labor". And once you get the first part of the Dyson swarm up and running, energy is infinite - at least in human terms.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by hnlmorg on Monday June 26, 2023 @06:26PM (#36486713)
I agree but Star Trek was never intended to be hard Sci-Fi. Sometimes it even breaks from its own cannon (and I’m not just talking about Discovery/Klingons. Almost all of the alien species have undergone revision over the years).

So I’m ok with replicators being a lazy plot device. It’s not like there aren’t countless others, like transporters, the usage of large mother ships rather than lots of smaller vessels, universal translators, 3D geometry presented in 2D, every species being bipedal, etc.

The point behind Star Trek is that it presents the best of humanity rather than the worst — which is what most other popular sci-fi stories focus on.

Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by hnlmorg on Saturday June 24, 2023 @08:18AM (#36458058)
So did the other species mentioned.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by BirAdam on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:10AM (#36458412)
The Klingons and the Federation both make sense in a world that is post scarcity: war as religion, or science/adventure as all-consuming hobby. Thing is, as you noted, most other civs make very little sense.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by tonfreed on Saturday June 24, 2023 @09:42AM (#36458624)
Well the Ferengi were a largely unknown race when first encountered in TNG, beyond the fact they were hyperlibertarians they didn't bother elaborating. They were the portrayed as an annoyance more than anything serious to worry about. DS9 was the first series to really build on it, and they recycled a lot of old rejected b plots from TNG in the first couple of seasons so there was a lot of filler dialog which became canon.
Re:Ferengi Rules of Acquisition by CalChris on Saturday June 24, 2023 @12:14PM (#36459935)
The Ferengi are a monarchy led by the Grand Nagus.