News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by extr on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:42PM (#36251536)
After going back and forth between in-person and remote jobs, my conclusion:

* Remote work is much better if you know what you're building and "just" need to execute.

* In-person is much better if you don't know what you need to build, are trying to "figure it out as you go along", and are relying on the implicit fast feedback loop of standing next to each other.

Obvious, right? But I think what I've realize is the dimension of "we know what we need to do" is actually pretty much orthogonal to the product, size of the company, tenure of the employees, etc. I've been in early stage startups with no PMF that nonetheless have strong product-centric leadership who can set down an unambiguous vision for what they believe needs to be done. And I've been in startups that have PMF yet have no vision, and everyone is standing around in their remote offices twiddling their thumbs on "what to build next".

For large companies like FAANG, I actually think they mostly fall in bucket 2. I worked at Meta remotely for a year. My instructions when I joined were something like "Yeah so just talk to a bunch of people and look for opportunities to contribute". WTF? No wonder remote is not working well for them. You had to go 5-6 layers up the reporting chain to find anyone with any sort of holistic sense of what needed to be done, and they were not exactly empowered to share that vision lest it conflict with someone elses.

TL;DR I think remote work is well set up for companies with leadership that resembles a benevolent dictatorship. I think if you are all-remote and your leadership is effectively "managerial" in nature, NGMI.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by RHSeeger on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:52PM (#36251647)
> In-person is much better if you don't know what you need to build, are trying to "figure it out as you go along", and are relying on the implicit fast feedback loop of standing next to each other.

In-person has benefits in those situations, but whether or not it's better varies a lot based on the person and the office. I find it VERY distracting to have people talking around me. As such, I get a lot less done when in an office, because I can't concentrate as well. When you add in the other negative (commute time, in person interruptions, etc), going into an office for work can far outweigh any benefits of being around the people you work with.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by makeitdouble on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:19PM (#36251894)
> implicit fast feedback loop of standing next to each other.

I have a hard time grasping this one. Is it brainstorming ?

For things like pair programming or specification of a product, having separate screens and independent access to the same documents makes things a lot faster and efficient.

Same way meetings tend to go smoother all participants can access whatever data they need independently from the presenter, and move through the docs at their own pace.

Basically a mix of synchronous communication and access to all needed resources seems to me to perform better than IRL binding of two or more people looking at each other.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by extr on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:00PM (#36252195)
I wouldn't call it brainstorming. More like "alignment". Fleshing out the vision you have for what you need to do, and putting that up against your coworkers vision, and figuring out where the disagreements/gaps are. You can do this quickly if you have an experienced and disciplined PM guiding the discussion, but most people don't, so they just have long conversations. Which works fine IRL, but it's very uncomfortable to be on a zoom call for more than about 45 minutes at a time.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by makeitdouble on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:31PM (#36252371)
> Fleshing out the vision you have for what you need to do, and putting that up against your coworkers vision, and figuring out where the disagreements/gaps are.

This is a part that probably varies a lot individually...I'm a slow thinker, and have a hard time reacting to fully formed ideas thrown at me thrown at me over a table. The other side coming with fully prepared for the discussion, while on the receiving end you need to do your homework realtime also doesn't help.

If it's random brainstorming it doesn't matter a lot. If it's an actually important topics, it feels like a DDOS on your brain when you actually want to take time to understand the implications. Then sure, some situations require speed, but I don't see that many of them in day to day life. "What you think about moving to X framework for our metrics ?" can probably wait for 30 min. and not be a realtime exchange.

> it's very uncomfortable to be on a zoom call for more than about 45 minutes at a time.

I've finding these meetings way more comfortable in remote...someone can be rambling for as long as they need, the effect on everyone's productivity is that much reduced. Same for people who speak very slowly actually, it's a lot less stress IMO and easier to engage when paradoxically you don't need to be 100% looking at them in the eyes.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by mLuby on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:11PM (#36259987)
> have a hard time reacting to fully formed ideas thrown at me thrown at me over a table. The other side coming with fully prepared for the discussion, while on the receiving end you need to do your homework realtime also doesn't help.

That's the feature, not a bug. It gives the meeting initiator a better chance of steamrolling their way to approval.

Notice the difference between meetings where people share agendas and docs ahead of time vs those where you show up and they walk you through the doc.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by bb88 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:30PM (#36251991)
I might be reading your statements wrong. But it sounds like what you're saying it sounds like is:

* Remote work is better if the management has a common goal and everyone can swim towards it.

* In-person work is better if the management is adversarial or competitive with each other, or doesn't have a common goal to work towards.

In either case, it seems like the problem is management, not the work location. Am I wrong here?

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by majormajor on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:45PM (#36251565)
Your experience matches mine, where yeah, it could work even in situations where it commonly fails if there was "just" better management... but... well, yeah.

EDIT: and so many of the challenges people are running into now are not new, either - companies were incentivized to make remote work work for two decades pre-Covid, and for a while pundits were all convinced that software jobs were all going away overseas as a result, but despite the salary savings the ROI just wasn't there for all but the most basic of work.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by tikhonj on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:13PM (#36251848)
My best experiences working remotely—both during the pandemic and with folks in other locations before that—has been with research-oriented work. The reason? We had the time and space to work and communicate the way that made sense to us. We had plenty of shared pair/group sessions to work out design ideas and experiments, iterate on the system, debug trickier issues... etc. Everything else we could do well asynchronously. Since this was longer-term, more speculative work, we didn't have to worry about tickets or product/management breathing down our necks every day.

On the other hand, the projects that suffered the most were the ones where folks had less scope and autonomy. If you can't unilaterally make decisions for anything that spans more than a day, and you're forced into some ticket-oriented process where everyone has "their" task to do, communication naturally suffers. If you're all in the office, there's a bit more slack to talk quickly and informally outside your immediate silo; remotely, this takes more intentionality, so the friction imposed by your culture and process has an outsize effect.

So my conclusion has been, pretty much, the opposite: remote works better when people have real scope, independence and autonomy. If engineers and small teams can make decisions over longer time-frames, they'll have the space to adapt and work effectively. They might need somebody to set the example or foster the right habits, but it's fundamentally healthy and effective. The frictions with remote work come up when it's thrust against a less flexible culture that makes it harder for folks to adapt.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by majormajor on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:01AM (#36252958)
I think you're using different phrasing to describe the same effect. Autonomy and the org knowing what it wants to do/needs to do go hand in hand. In your long-term speculative research oriented work, you had autonomy because you knew what you were working on - not what it was in terms of tickets per se, but it sounds like you knew your scope and your objectives.

At 10+ person org sizes, most people can't have long-term scope and autonomy if the management don't know what it wants/needs, since they're just going to change their mind in a week or two. Once those decisions are made you can start delegating responsibility for execution.

The easy thing to do is to blame this all on poor management, but I think that's too pat. I think figuring out the best way to use a team of 20, 100, 1000 engineers to accomplish business goals is just an incredibly hard problem... and one that's often an ongoing, Sisyphean task, where high-bandwidth, low-latency communications are incredibly useful.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by extr on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:39AM (#36253239)
I agree. Research is ideal for remote work, since you are effectively your own manager and by definition there is no specific vision that needs to be worked toward - you are discovering that vision yourself. It's the literal ivory tower. In my experience if you give non-R&D engineers and small teams total autonomy they will all end up building great solutions to problems that are slightly different than the problem you actually needed solved.

> I think figuring out the best way to use a team of 20, 100, 1000 engineers to accomplish business goals is just an incredibly hard problem...

Agreed, don't mean to downplay how difficult good management is. I think the key thing I've realized is that in a remote environment, bad management is so much more obvious and detrimental to the employee and organization. In office, if your manager doesn't communicate vision/objectives well you can always tap the shoulder of the guy next to you, or discretely pick your skip's brain in the break room. The rest of the organization can pick up the slack. But that's much harder remotely.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by chambers on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:47AM (#36253300)
Do you write a blog? Your experience resonates with mine.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by extr on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:27AM (#36254935)
No, but maybe I should start one.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by beoberha on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:11PM (#36251833)
I think you articulated a sentiment a lot of people have very well. For the non-decision makers, there is a strange dichotomy I see with coding.

Remotely, I’m vastly more productive in getting coding work done. I’m sure most people would agree. But that productivity is almost erased by onboarding new hires. There are so many aspects of software engineering where it’s so much easier to be sitting next to someone, pointing at their monitor, and discussing what and why you are doing something. Instead, you need to hop on a call and awkwardly screen share on a call or write out paragraphs of text to impart the knowledge. In my experience, having such barriers to doing these things makes new hires much less likely to reach out and put themselves into the situations where they can learn, no matter how much they are told it’s ok to bother people.

To me, this is why remote works so much better at smaller companies with less bespoke tooling and legacy code. There’s no better way to learn than in person and there is a huge productivity boost when doing so. That said, personally, I’m willing to deal with the lower productivity in my work life to get the higher productivity in my real life by being able to do laundry during the day and not sit in traffic.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by extr on Thursday June 08, 2023 @10:07PM (#36252242)
Yes, I am going through this right now as a new hire onboarding to a boutique codebase. As soon as you are 100% reliant on internal docs, you realize just how large the gap is between them and mainstream OSS libraries.

I think a decent middle-ground between "Document everything" and "Organically relay all information" is to just write "doc-stubs". Just a list of everything out there with no real content. It gives people a jumping off point to ask questions and lets them know what they don't know.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by throwaway173738 on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:12AM (#36258076)
I’m also a big fan of having new people document things they wish they had known starting out.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by xyzzy123 on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:31AM (#36253655)
I am at the point where remote works better for me for a lot of what are ostensibly team / collaborative activities.

For example, incident handling has been lot more efficient for us with the team looking at different aspects and sharing on a call/huddle than what we often used to naturally do (involving a gaggle forming around 1 person's computer with different people offering suggestions of varying usefulness).

Demos and knowledge sharing I find also work better remote now than they used to in person now that people are used to the tooling.

I slightly prefer onboarding remote also, but that is because I'm the kind of person who gets distracted by wondering if I'm sitting too close or maybe I have not enough or too much deodorant etc.

The only thing that suffers remotely for me at this point is engagement. There's something about physically being with other people that makes their problems and desires seem more important to me, and I don't have any good hacks for giving more of a &"@$.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by viraptor on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:15AM (#36254401)
> t’s so much easier to be sitting next to someone, pointing at their monitor, and discussing what and why you are doing something

This feels like a tech choice issue to me. I'm constantly on calls with either slack/pop sharing where anyone can draw on the shared screen, or started coding session like in vscode where you can see each other's cursors. It... works the same for me as pointing at the screen. Just without it being awkward when it's more than 2 people getting to cram into a a small space.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by tomp on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:28AM (#36254514)
> ’s so much easier to be sitting next to someone, pointing at their monitor, and discussing what and why you are doing something. Instead, you need to hop on a call and awkwardly screen share on a call or write out paragraphs of text to impart the knowledge

For me, it's the exact opposite.

Before the pandemic, I always found the practice (and even the idea!) of "pairing" quite off-putting. You're standing behind someone, breathing in their body odor, awkwardly sweating next to each other, bending over if you want to type something... a really weird experience.

Remotely, none of those apply! You each get your own keyboard, your own screen, your own mouse. Both of you are 100% comfortable in your own environment. Using decent software helps as well, I recommend Tuple which makes sharing the mouse & keyboard seamless.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by throwaway22032 on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:47AM (#36255928)
Normal people get showers and wear deodorant dude.

How do you feel about sitting next to someone at a bar?

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by tomp on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:32AM (#36256267)
I'm guessing you've never actually spent 8 hours or so in a stuffy office doing hard/stressful work with people who also take walks (e.g. to go get lunch and get back to the office in 30 allotted minutes).

Also some people wear too much deodorant.

I agree, none of this is an issue if working with clean, civilised people... a few feet away. It can quickly become uncomfortable if you're too close to each other.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by kcatskcolbdi on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:21AM (#36256179)
I'm struggling to identify how it's not glaringly self-evident that the person you're replying to would not enjoy sitting next to people at bars.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by throwaway22032 on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:52AM (#36257130)
Ha, fair.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by jen20 on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:21AM (#36257443)
At least not people incapable of donning deodorant and a fresh shirt. One would hope the bartender would solve that problem too though.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by twic on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:16AM (#36256668)
Pair programming doesn't involve anyone standing behind anyone else or bending over. I think you're describing a sort of "hanging around and kind of doing some programming together", which is probably a more common practice than pair programming, and a rather under-documented one!
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by CraigJPerry on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:45PM (#36261318)
You can just plug 2 keyboards and two mice into a pc for in person pairing
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by twic on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:22AM (#36256753)
> Remotely, I’m vastly more productive in getting coding work done. I’m sure most people would agree.

I certainly don't agree at all. Home is where all the distractions are. Home is where i can drift off to make a cup of tea and end up spending an hour reading the newspaper without anyone noticing.

I think it would be useful to understand the distribution of peoples' feelings and experience about this. I have seen so many remote work enthusiasts just taking it as read that everyone prefers remote work because they do.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by beoberha on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:07AM (#36258008)
Sure, I get that. But the office has just as many if not more distractions. Much easier to get pulled into a conversation while getting tea at the office.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by andrei_says_ on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:07PM (#36251792)
> In-person is much better if you don't know what you need to build, are trying to "figure it out as you go along", and are relying on the implicit fast feedback loop of standing next to each other.

Or sharing a zoom session. Bonus is that I don’t have to commute to an office on another continent to engage in this second modality - more than half of my teammates are in other cities and I don’t see a benefit in the standing next to each other.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by maerF0x0 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:46PM (#36251579)
I'm curious if you've considered that there is a pretty major cost difference between the two options? (at least for the company) Would you conclude that In Person is much better , in excess of the additional costs ?
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by karmasimida on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:52PM (#36251639)
This doesn't make OP's point invalid.

If you are talking about cost, then the only factor here is the market.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by maerF0x0 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:50PM (#36252116)
>If you are talking about cost, then the only factor here is the market.

Can you please expand? I'm not understanding.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by pjc50 on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:56AM (#36255133)
Weirdly, companies don't seem to care about this kind of cost. I don't think I've ever seen "we're going remote first to save costs"?

More likely is the "prestige HQ" which is deliberately made more expensive than it needs to be for status.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by twic on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:52AM (#36257131)
That's the trend in commercial real estate - prestigious, luxurious, eye-wateringly expensive class A space is doing well, but the bottom has fallen out of the market for practical, cost-effective class B space:

https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2023/06/05/jeff-blau-to-cla...

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by marcinzm on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:34AM (#36256295)
The cost difference is probably rather small. CoWorking spaces in large cities charge something like $500/desk/month which we can assume is a reasonable cost of office space. That comes out to $6k/year/employee. Google's median employee pay is around $300k so we're talking a 2% difference in cost.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by turdprincess on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:11PM (#36251835)
With your Meta experience I am curious - would the people you had to talk to been in the office near you anyways, even if everyone was in office? It seems like with a huge global company the people who would be hard to get context from (so not the people you might have a video standup with daily or weekly) might be in a different office or building requiring a video call anyways
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by extr on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:54PM (#36252141)
Not everyone, but there would have been enough people around to have dramatically improved my experience. The problem there was Meta does not have a strong culture of documentation, and I didn't know what I didn't know. It was common to spend 2-3 days working on something only to find out on a random zoom call there was an entire team working on the same thing. Discoverability didn't exist. I found the environment untenable for doing anything of value.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by grepfru_it on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:03AM (#36254319)
At a large unnamed subsidiary of Microsoft, I saw four different teams working on a MSP solution. All of them crash and burned because each were run with 60+ engineers and not a single team talked to each other and they all reproduced the wheel (ignored federated systems and rolled their own)
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by foogazi on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:00PM (#36251735)
> In-person is much better if you don't know what you need to build

Not everyone is the same office - it’s a joke

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by squegles on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:51PM (#36251632)
Wow, this is matches my exact experience too. Just had never thought of it in these terms.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by swellguy on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:35PM (#36252026)
Big companies are also ridiculously overstaffed, as Elon Musk proved empirically. And many of them have only one thing that works and ambitions of doing more than will never work out. So there's a lot of wasted talent, in other words, but this ability to waste talent necessitates in person communication, just to make sure everyone is stack ranked according to the current arbitrary and probably mindless goals.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by ryandrake on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:13AM (#36253037)
Musk didn’t prove anything. All he showed so far is that if you turn off the airplane engine mid-flight, it will glide for a time on momentum.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by grepfru_it on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:07AM (#36254354)
Still waiting for all the major failures people have been clamoring about. I think the real talk is that you can run a lot of dotcoms on a skeleton crew and when money becomes tight you can trim a lot of fat. It’s not something people like to hear because they realize they are the fat
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by rightbyte on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:19AM (#36254868)
I don't like the "trim fat" methaphor. Layoffs are more or less random. There is no good, from the company perspective, selection.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by grepfru_it on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:29PM (#36266976)
Now is the time for managers and directors to find reasons to let go of the employees they don’t like. Some people don’t like eating fat, others will suck on it all day. Personally I trim a bit of fat off my meats before smoking them
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by wepple on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:35AM (#36256298)
Perhaps that’s me, the fat? If I were let go tomorrow there wouldn’t be any negative consequences for probably at least a year.

I do security things, and it seems those folks are all gone from Twitter.

But my hypothesis is that the negatives won’t emerge for some time, at which point something bad happens and everyone will be standing around shaking their heads at how negligent it was.

Although more generally I do sympathize with the idea that most tech companies are at least a little bloated because money has so often been cheap & revenues always go up historically

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by danaris on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:20PM (#36260975)
There have been major failures. Several times there were outages at Twitter that were plenty serious enough to be a death knell, or near enough, for a company with less network effect keeping people using them.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by grepfru_it on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:31PM (#36266984)
I’ve taken FAANG sites down and took it personally when anyone got a 500 error for a minor change. Truth is, no one really cares. You can complain it’s down but who are you going to leave them for? Welcome to running a lean ship. Twitter isn’t hurting
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by rightbyte on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:16AM (#36254849)
Come on. I have been whining about Twitter et al. being bloated for years. There is no way all those engineers were needed.

I Twitter fails due to the mass layoffs it doesn't prove much either since it might be too hard to unwind a mess.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by locopati on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:24PM (#36252731)
having worked for a fully remote company that was successfully acquired for a decent sum by a much larger respectable company, remote depends on the top levels of management communicating the vision regularly and being transparent about direction, changes in direction, and reasons for changes. add in someone skilled whose responsibility is for facilitating remote culture and you have a recipe for success.

the problem is there is a ton of terrible leadership out there who want to rule by fiat, ignore their employees, and don't trust their employees (who they either directly or indirectly hired) to so their jobs.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by bart_spoon on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:30PM (#36252762)
I don’t think in-person is better if you don’t know what you need to build. I’ve experienced teams where people were totally without direction despite being in-person. I think in-person just makes it easier to look like you are busy when you have no direction, and remote lays the fact bare.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by fendy3002 on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:35AM (#36253207)
Agree that though it's better in person during brainstorm / discussion, it isn't decisive. When people are having zero ground during the meeting, it won't provide any meaningful result no matter what you do. And if it resulting in something, usually it'll be bad.

What I found to be the best approach is one or two people already established a concept at what to make or at least the image of it, and the discussion can move to the details and implementation plan. And that doesn't need to be in person

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by extr on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:08AM (#36254792)
> What I found to be the best approach is one or two people already established a concept at what to make or at least the image of it, and the discussion can move to the details and implementation plan.

This is exactly what I was getting at by referencing a benevolent dictatorship. When remote, it's just easier if one person is providing direction by fiat rather than trying to collect everyone's input and communally make a decision.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by coldtea on Friday June 09, 2023 @05:25AM (#36255361)
>Agree that though it's better in person during brainstorm / discussion

Yes, that's why before WHF, people really loved meetings and brainstorm sessions at work /s

In person during brainstorm discussion usually means endless time-wasting and bikeshedding.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by m463 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:53PM (#36252903)
what is PMF? NGMI?
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by extr on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:05AM (#36252990)
Product Market Fit and Not Gonna Make It. The former is established startup product terminology, the latter is slang.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by refurb on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:40AM (#36253251)
I would assume the importance of in-person versus remote also depends on the role.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by 72f988bf on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:16AM (#36253534)
> In-person is much better if you don't know what you need to build, are trying to "figure it out as you go along", and are relying on the implicit fast feedback loop of standing next to each other.

true.

> For large companies like FAANG, I actually think they mostly fall in bucket 2

Also true most fall in the "figure it out" bucket... But here's where it gets funny: just meet in-person you say?

No, this is FAANG. You're in MTV, but the people you need to collaborate are in NYC, LAX, SEA, AUS, SFO...

So your in-person experience is you booking a room just for yourself so you can video conference all those people who also booked a room for themselves.

Because every other team is in same situation, finding a meeting room is a challenge in itself.

Take the call from your desk then?

No, this is FAANG, every building is open office layout, it'd be rude & disrespectful to your colleagues around who are busy coding.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by WesolyKubeczek on Friday June 09, 2023 @05:14AM (#36255265)
> No, this is FAANG, every building is open office layout, it'd be rude & disrespectful to your colleagues around who are busy coding.

But at the same time it's perfectly okay to just come up to your busy colleague and pester them about something, because collaboration.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by __oh_es on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:09AM (#36256589)
Establishing working relationships and setting boundaries is a professional skill
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by gotaran on Friday June 09, 2023 @02:13PM (#36261768)
It isn’t okay, but there’s enough nonverbal cues you can use to determine whether someone is busy at their desk.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by WesolyKubeczek on Monday June 12, 2023 @10:13AM (#36293763)
I can be just as busy at a watercooler away from my screen. That’s not the point. I think that all of the arguments in this conversation, whether they are valid or not, are not at all relevant to the purpose of the conversation.

I have this wild guess that if a significant number of companies cut their leases on all those monstrous office spaces that are kept being built all the time, it could hurt some people with important companies a fucking lot, and the ripple effect could prove to be immense and disastrous.

Spice must flow, and the fact that there are parties interested in those office spaces running and bringing money in has diddly to do with whether there are any actual productivity advantages of bringing the office workers back to the office or not.

For enough dough you can buy enough experts and pundits and other talking heads that will overflow the information space with thinkpieces and analyses that go either way.

Meanwhile, the only actual productivity boost is when you have a private office with a closable door within walking distance from your living place. But it’s not like anybody would give you _that,_ plebeian.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by bluefirebrand on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:12AM (#36256625)
A lot of companies want the benefits of distributed teams, but also want to force everyone to come to offices and do conference calls in meeting rooms instead of work remote.

It's mind boggling to me. All I can think is that there is a lot of ego tied up in offices for some reason.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by noisy_boy on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:07AM (#36257263)
Because people with "people skills" need people in the office to justify their existence. It is beyond ego for them, it is about their survival.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by JamesLeonis on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:54AM (#36257851)
Wall Street is pressuring everybody for Return to Office to shore up their collapsing commercial real estate holdings.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by PKop on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:31AM (#36258369)
Not just wall street. All of the governments, and thus their budgets, where this real estate resides are completely dependent on property taxes and the overall commerce in the area which will collapse if people (and then secondary small businesses) just simply aren't there anymore.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by sangnoir on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:45PM (#36260491)
Budget collapses would be karmic, given how many local governments court commercial real estate while neglecting residential real estate by not encouraging (or actively fighting) the development of new homes. Too many city halls decided that housing people who work in their city is someone else's problem, and would be quite happy with 0 new residents within city limits if it meant all new developments are commercial.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by garciasn on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:58AM (#36257887)
And to further reduce headcount through silent layoffs.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by civilized on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:30AM (#36258357)
This was the first thing I noticed when I started working about a decade ago. Endless conference calls while people extolled the benefits of in-person interaction which wasn't even happening. As a result, I now have a healthy amount of cynicism about advocacy of office work. I take ICs who favor it at face value when they say it works better for them, but clearly, many of the most vocal advocates in management don't even care if any of the supposed benefits are realized.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by programmertote on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:31AM (#36258365)
Working for a FAANG right now and since RTO was mandated, I noticed that our team have been spending ~5 mins before the beginning of the meetings finding a room and setting up the audio/visual system for conference calls with other teammates across the country. This is for a company that has a lot of office space in its birth town and has HQs in a few other cities. A couple of teammates (out of 8 total) privately told me that they hate the RTO.

I personally prefer fully remote because I hate the distraction in the open office plan and associated pains like having to find meeting rooms, having to share restrooms with others (I admit this is just my personal pet peeve), and not being able to avoid distraction when I am in the zone for working. Most of all, I don't like the commute (I have to commute 1 hour each way, so everyday, I am spending 2 hours; when I worked from home, I started early and end up working an extra hour or two because I don't have to commute; these days, I try to arrive at 8-9am and leave by 5-6pm to beat the traffic and once I get home, I don't do any work). I consider quitting someday soon and am waiting for my wife to finish her residency and I will pull the trigger.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by ghaff on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:29AM (#36259302)
If I went into "my" office I probably wouldn't recognize a single person at this point and I'm not sure there's anyone who I regularly work with who is assigned to that office, much less goes in.

>No, this is FAANG, every building is open office layout, it'd be rude & disrespectful to your colleagues around who are busy coding.

Individual offices have not been the norm for everyone at large companies maybe ever? Cubicles are "better" but not that much better. (Source: I had one for years--both full-height and then shorter.) And the fact is that lots used to spend a lot more time on the phone than they generally need to today given other communication channels. When I've been in an office I absolutely make calls from my desk and everyone else does too.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by shaftway on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:00PM (#36260718)
> No, this is FAANG. You're in MTV, but the people you need to collaborate are in NYC, LAX, SEA, AUS, SFO...

I don't think this is really that common. I spent a decade in MTV on a wide variety of teams. I had VCs with people in different locations a handful of times and I never had one by myself. And getting deep focus with those people was so valuable that it was easier to just go to NYC, MUC, or SYD once a quarter than it was to jump on a call.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by gotaran on Friday June 09, 2023 @02:19PM (#36261858)
People taking calls from their desks is the worst post COVID office etiquette change I’ve noticed.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by zeroonetwothree on Saturday June 10, 2023 @10:58AM (#36271073)
Sure this happens but it’s not like it’s everyone. For example right now 80% of the people I collaborate with are in the same office as me. So it’s still noticeably better to come in the office.

The downside is it’s hard to get actual coding down because of all the “collaboration”. So my ideal would be 1-2 days in office to meet and then 3-4 days to code ins peace at home.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by microtherion on Monday June 12, 2023 @06:56AM (#36291479)
Even FAANGs do not apply perfect hashing to distribute teams across their office locations (well, for all I know, Google does, but the one I work at doesn‘t). And often it already helps if some of the team is co-located.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by q7xvh97o2pDhNrh on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:23AM (#36253601)
> My instructions when I joined were something like "Yeah so just talk to a bunch of people and look for opportunities to contribute".

Do you mind sharing the job title for something like this? Sounds like a dream job.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by loarabia on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:34AM (#36253677)
Currently I’m a GTPM at Meta and this is the expectation we have for onboarding to a new team unless you’re early in career. I’ve seen this be the case for SWE and other roles in the technical domain. Typically you have an expertise area and at least on my team a starter project or 2 with a tangible deliverable to get you going on something while you ramp and meet others and figure things out. Meta is a big place though so could be other expectations in other organizations.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by suzzer99 on Friday June 09, 2023 @02:14AM (#36253965)
I transferred within my company to the much bigger company that bought us out and this is basically what my boss told me. Actually his exact words were "you need to create your own job." I hated it. Give me a freaking task, don't make me network and sell myself (remotely of course, no one I worked with was anywhere near me) just for something to do.

I created my own job, just with a startup. For a year I had two ostensibly full time jobs. By the end the startup wasn't doing much either and I considered going for three full time jobs.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by meinheld111 on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:46AM (#36254641)
You seem to be doing something right. Imo most ppl are overworked and underpaid
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by saagarjha on Friday June 09, 2023 @02:35AM (#36254123)
It’s less a job title (I’m a “software engineer” like everyone else) but the scope of the problem your role is aiming to solve. Look for places that 1. have an unsolved hard problem with 2. no real direction on where to go with it and 3. buy-in from someone to get it solved.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by extr on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:26AM (#36254929)
I was a Data Scientist. Personally I found the autonomy immensely frustrating. Combined with the stack ranking performance review system, it was effectively a way of pushing the manager's job on to the employee and forcing them to hold themselves accountable for their own priorities. Makes sense in theory, but once you add huge organization churn + being remote, it was difficult to get a sense of what priorities were exactly, or would be next month. It made me feel insecure at all times that perhaps I was working on the wrong thing and would be punished for it.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by jedberg on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:40AM (#36253729)
In person makes no sense for any FAANG, because they are geographically distributed. All you do is come into the office to sit on video calls all day with people in other locations, unless you're at a very low level and your influence is very limited to just your team.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by commiepatrol on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:49AM (#36257085)
I see where you’re going with this but pretty much all L3s and L4s mostly deal with just their team. That’s more than 50% of the company if I’m not mistaken.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by angarg12 on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:41AM (#36253732)
> * In-person is much better if you don't know what you need to build, are trying to "figure it out as you go along", and are relying on the implicit fast feedback loop of standing next to each other.

My anecdotal evidence is different.

I've spent the last 2 years building a large, complex, and ambiguous system working almost exclusively remote, and half of it from another continent. For the first year I never met a colleague in person.

However, all this time I have been working closely with another engineer. Both of us are senior and very tenured, got good rapport and were highly aligned and motivated. We were able to execute efficiently, sometimes spending hours huddling in Slack per day.

So my feeling is that remote works in some scenarios and not others, particularly involving new or junior engineers.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by forgingahead on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:58AM (#36253862)
This is a good insight, but the interesting counter-weight to the reality you describe is that many people who want "remote" and the independence of work, don't really want the same "benevolent dictatorship" either.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by abhaynayar on Friday June 09, 2023 @02:26AM (#36254052)
> "Yeah so just talk to a bunch of people and look for opportunities to contribute."

Hard relate. Had my first internship WFH at Big Tech during the pandemic. I had expected work to be more on the lines of: there's always a lot of work to be done, and people will let you know about that. Instead it was the opposite, exactly as quoted above.

While it meant I had more freedom, I would have preferred if someone just doled out concrete tasks to me. I felt a bit lost. But then again, grass is greener on the other side.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by godelski on Friday June 09, 2023 @02:28AM (#36254064)
> * Remote work is much better if you know what you're building and "just" need to execute.

> * In-person is much better if you don't know what you need to build, are trying to "figure it out as you go along", and are relying on the implicit fast feedback loop of standing next to each other.

This is why the other day I ranted about how my actual preference is in office but having a door that I can close. Realistically we shift between these two modes. In the first mode I need to reduce distractions and isolate myself. This is hard with slack and hard with an open office or cubicles. In person let's me even ignore slack as someone can knock on my door if it is urgent! But that's not all the time, so I open the door and communicate that it is collaboration and discussion phase.

I don't know why companies have become so allergic to doors. They are amazing and can let employees be in control of the chaos of work schedules. They'll know far better than anyone else if they're more productive that day/hour/minute in isolation or in collaboration. Micromanaging doesn't help, a door does.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by onion2k on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:31AM (#36254535)
In-person is much better if you don't know what you need to build..

Can you explain how some of the greatest technical research projects of our time like the internet, Linux, etc happened without a big office then?

It's clearly nonsense to suggest you have to be collaborating in-person to build big unknown things. There are thousands of examples throughout open source and more where that hasn't been the case, and millions of examples of projects from company offices that are awful.

The physical geography of the team is not an indicator of success.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by chii on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:45AM (#36254627)
> ...etc happened without a big office

while linux or git was created relatively sololy by a single person (at least at the beginning), i dont think you can call the internet a solo production.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by onion2k on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:25AM (#36254919)
I'm not calling any of them solo productions. Linux and the internet were both massively collaborative projects built by many people who met up maybe once or twice a year, and certainly not all of them at once ever. They were globally distributed. Being in an office together was not necessary for the success of those things, which were some of the hardest technical research projects ever, so I'm questioning if people really need to be in-person to make YouTube or GMail.

(I don't know the history of git, maybe that too though.)

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by ghaff on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:59AM (#36259844)
>i dont think you can call the internet a solo production

No, although there were certainly co-located or nearby individuals and teams that contributed specific chunks--certainly parts that were hardware or depended on hardware.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by marcinzm on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:27AM (#36256222)
Is your average company made of some of the most brilliant and driven and experienced people in the world in their fields? Do they have no actual business goals but a wide open field to just do something big and different and impactful? If so then literally nothing else matters except not getting in their way. But there's very few cases like this.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by wepple on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:29AM (#36256246)
> Can you explain how some of the greatest technical research projects of our time like the internet, Linux, etc happened without a big office then?

Stating that it’s possible is very different to stating which model might be more effective or faster.

Unfortunately we don’t have a parallel universe where torvalds lived on the same street as a bunch of other collaborators to compare

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by civilized on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:27AM (#36256812)
I bet if we talked to Torvalds about it, he'd have an incredibly strong opinion to share, and I don't have any difficulty guessing what it would be.

Indeed, searching for "Torvalds remote work" yields this: https://www.zdnet.com/article/pet-the-cat-own-the-bathrobe-l...

> Torvalds admits that when he started, "I worried about missing human interaction -- not just talking to people in the office and hallways, but going out to lunch etc. It turns out I never really missed it."

> "If you spend hours in online meetings from home, instead of spending hours in meetings at the office like you used to, you've just taken the worst part of office life, and brought it home, and made it even worse."

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by ttul on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:42AM (#36254608)
My experience leading an older startup is that category two is hard to escape whether or not you’re working in person. It has more to do with the “Innovator’s Dilemma” - once a company has found product market fit and is generating profits, everything is fine-tuned for that purpose. The company’s reason for existing is to generate profits from that one thing that really worked out.

Some companies are able to add great new products over time, but I sense that it’s more common for companies to have one great play, after which they either die or merge with another to enjoy better economies of scale.

If you’re big enough and rich enough, you tend to burn a ton of money on internal research groups, but very little of what gets researched is ever a successful product. Doing this as a smaller organization is nearly impossible, which is why I think so many startups just exit rather than finding entirely new things to build.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by badrabbit on Friday June 09, 2023 @03:46AM (#36254636)
Office work is nice for teams that actually benefit from open area desk layout. Teams that can work fine in cubicles and offices do great WFH.

For me, the extroverts that insist in socializing, gossiping and politicking in person make office work an unproductive nightmare.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by eecc on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:33AM (#36254974)
> You had to go 5-6 layers up the reporting chain to find anyone with any sort of holistic sense of what needed to be done, and they were not exactly empowered to share that vision lest it conflict with someone elses.

OTOH, from personal experience working on-site hasn't really ever helped particularly well in that scenario (which I'mm all too familiar with.)

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by datadeft on Friday June 09, 2023 @04:39AM (#36255021)
I totally agree.

I used to work for Amzn and the management was totally idiotic about remote work. We had to go to the office to be on call for datacenters 1000kms from the office. Makes perfect sense right?

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by heresie-dabord on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:21AM (#36255739)
> * In-person is much better if you don't know what you need to build, are trying to "figure it out as you go along", and are relying on the implicit fast feedback loop of standing next to each other.

Beyond the practical scope of this point, we also find the need for mentoring (building a sustainable team).

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by Etheryte on Friday June 09, 2023 @06:50AM (#36255942)
I think that's only one of many models where remote work works out. The other that I've seen function well across many companies is remote work where team members are highly skilled and have a lot of freedom in choosing what to work on. This essentially lets every domain expert identify what the biggest pain points are in their field and then figure those out. You don't need top down dictatorship for this to work, but you do need a clear vision of where you want to be.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by moonchrome on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:10AM (#36256116)
How often are entire teams at the same building ? Like the other person mentioned - you're going to meet in conference rooms with video - this was norm pre COVID.

I would say biggest benefits of in office is spontanious meet/discussion, assisting less senior coworkers etc. If I have a heavy day of work to plow through alone I avoid the office. If I need to sync or work on something with others in-person beats all the tools.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by bryanrasmussen on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:47AM (#36256415)
There are more conditions that pertain

Remote Work is better if

1. You do not have home problems that you will end up focusing on when you are there - so if you are single and do not own your home, or you have a great relationship and you do own your home but there are no problems the remote work is probably better. But just like being in an office and going into a private room can help productivity if you have problems with home life going to office to work can help with productivity.

2. Remote work is much better if you are a person who is motivated by love of what you are doing and you actually love what you are doing, if you start to not love what you are doing but you have not left the company yet etc. there can be some slight loss of productivity, not because intentionally goofing off so much but because like #1 above working remotely makes it harder to get focused on something one does for money and not love if you are a love focused worker.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by whoisthemachine on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:29AM (#36256833)
#1 can be solved by renting a co-working space if troubles at home are really that severe. I doubt that #2 is really any different than if you are unmotivated while in the office. If anything, one unmotivated employee in the office can more easily spread that lack of motivation to their co-workers.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by tpmoney on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:46AM (#36257051)
Why would you spend your own money renting office space somewhere and commuting there when you have a perfectly good office your company will pay for?
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by saganus on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:44AM (#36258611)
Because your rented coworking space could be closer to home for instance
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by bryanrasmussen on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:02AM (#36257220)
>I doubt that #2 is really any different than if you are unmotivated while in the office

ok but I know from my own experience that #2 can be really different. And really I don't understand how anyone could doubt it - in the office if you are unmotivated you have a limited range of things you can do to pass the time. at home there is no limitation.

At some point in the office it becomes reasonable to just do the work and get it over with.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by throwbadubadu on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:08AM (#36256578)
> You do not have home problems that you will end up focusing on when you are there

Not sure why this needs to be repeatedly brought up.. I mean it is called "home office" for a reason. If you don't have a real one, remote can suffer.. no surprise.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by bryanrasmussen on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:12AM (#36256620)
>Not sure why this needs to be repeatedly brought up

Not sure why you think a home office is going to solve marital problems or other issues that going into an office and being around other people might allow you to not focus on.

Aside from that then we can add inability to get a home office made to the list of things that can affect whether or not remote work is a good solution

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by throwbadubadu on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:37AM (#36256953)
Cos definition of of "home office" for me is a place where I can work reasonably and with focus.

Yes, even in "work office" that focus is not guaranteed, but even there martial problems or other issues will hit me. So yeah, still not sure why we need to bring this explicitly up again in discussion after discussion. You need a reasonable office to work, offices can suck - orthogonal to if home/remote/company.

> add inability to get a home office made to the list of things that can affect whether or not remote work is a good solution

Again, no-brainer, no home office no good solution? shrug

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by TeMPOraL on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:48PM (#36260540)
> So yeah, still not sure why we need to bring this explicitly up again in discussion after discussion.

Probably because the reality of remote working was set by the pandemic, which forced a huge number of people to switch to remote work. Remote workers with a proper home office suddenly were, and I think continue to be, a minority.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by throwaway894345 on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:08AM (#36257281)
FWIW, my wife takes our home office and I work from the main room or our screened in porch, but she often will work alongside me. It’s not really a problem.

I’m much more productive working from home; my only qualms are that team cohesion and sense of shared mission seems lower than it has at in-person jobs I’ve had. That may not even be causal.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by paulcole on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:05AM (#36256557)
There are more conditions that pertain

Remote Work is better if

1. You prefer remote work

This always gets to be such a dogmatic discussion that will to someone claiming anyone who likes working in an office has no social life.

It’s just a preference. Remote work is not overall objectively better than office work (but you can create a set of goals for which this is true). Office work is not the right choice (but you can create a set of goals for which this is true).

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by brookst on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:58AM (#36257184)
For an autonomous IC who does not need to lead or contribute to thinks like whiteboarding, strategy discussions, client visits, etc, that is true.

There are jobs where in-person is just better, full stop. Remote can be accommodated, but it is not always exclusively about what the employee prefers.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by paulcole on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:07AM (#36258011)
> There are jobs where in-person is just better, full stop

Well yeah a surgeon should be working in person, you got me there.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by no_wizard on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:43AM (#36257700)
Why does it have to be because some want to go in an office so we all do?

If you want to work in an office go work in one. Join a co-working space or if there is sufficient momentum have everyone who wants an office join the same one in your area.

But don’t force it on everyone. Let people choose. That’s the thing I hate about these conversations is it should just be personal choice for the individual. Make async practices and communication better and re-tool the culture if need be, but remote first thinking benefits office workers too.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by ska on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:21AM (#36258208)
That argument works the outer way around too, either way you are asking others ot accommodate your preference.

I think “let people choose” is the right idea at the “choose your job” or sometimes “choose your team” level.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by no_wizard on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:41AM (#36259505)
There's objectively practices of team building, communication, knowledge sharing, collaboration (and other attributes of a positive work place) that work for both remote or in office folks equally well and drive a net benefit.

Some of them are

- Async communication. Embracing long form writing is huge here, as is dropping the expectation of "now" in regards to getting responses.

- Holistic documentation & discussions. Processes, cultural values (and what they really mean and are expected to be followed specifically) and really just about anything meant to be repeated over and over should be documented at length, and reviewed consistently. This useful to everyone and has the added benefit of storing historical context and discussion

- Work in the open, whenever appropriate. If people can see whats going on, they can see things that traditionally are the "in between" things. Engineers already do this (PRs come to mind) in alot of ways, but this should extend to decision making as well, whenever reasonably possible. This facilitates the above points too.

- For socialization, its important that people have several avenues to get to know their co-workers. I think this one is possibly the least understand part of it, but its more than just "random lunch with co-workers if you join this channel!" there are ways to do remote team building exercises, to setup meaningful interactions between teams and departments etc. For instance, a positive thing I've seen people do with remote first around this is having product and engineering have Q&A with each other once every 2 weeks to just talk about stuff, it doesn't have to be related to what is going on right now. It can even be non work related if that is fitting to the people at the time, but it exists to just share things with each other, talk through ideas etc.

Unfortunately, these are things that aren't common in the work place currently. Most companies that have remote workers right now haven't moved beyond the "message eagerly or start a call" phase.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by ghaff on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:46AM (#36259611)
It's perfectly reasonable to want a co-located team that you collaborate with/are social with/etc.

But if that's not the situation at the team/company level, you need to either figure out some compromise approach (like getting a co-working space or even just picking up some non-work social activities) or move on to an environment more in keeping with your preferences. At some point, if a situation just isn't to your liking, you should probably stop hitting your head against the wall.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by ska on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:43PM (#36260456)
I think that's what I was suggesting.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by mcv on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:43AM (#36257705)
During the Covid lockdowns and everybody was forced to work from home, the single people in the team seemed to be the most depressed about the situation. Some of them were really eager to get to the office as soon as possible. The people with families were stressed if they suddenly had to homeschool their kids, but otherwise they were fine.

Of course if your spouse also works from home, it's important to have a home with more than a single room. Not everybody has that luxury.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by rco8786 on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:50AM (#36256439)
That description of Meta sounds like a high level of disfunction that has nothing to do with remote or in person.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by Tade0 on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:22AM (#36257458)
The only other place where I encountered such a "system" was in one (small) company, where the CEO's dress code did not include pants and I wish I never went there in the first place.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by Stranger43 on Friday June 09, 2023 @07:58AM (#36256497)
I suspect what your describing is less the cause but a symptom of the real case.

In my experience(i have worked from branch offices most my career) the differentiating factor is literacy, ie how comfortable/confident are the organization with recorded text vs private spoken word and the more the organization writes the more effective the remote staff will be.

And one of the side effect of a written culture is that a lot of the informal conventions/conversations become formal structure so the same level of top down planning can look very differently based on weather the culture for disseminating it is literate or oral.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by XorNot on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:02AM (#36256529)
> In-person is much better if you don't know what you need to build, are trying to "figure it out as you go along", and are relying on the implicit fast feedback loop of standing next to each other.

I'm curious how often anyone actually finds this situation to happen and improve the feedback loop. I feel like it's more of an illusion of productivity then actual productivity because it's a pile of constant interruptions.

Like the given example with Meta doesn't seem like it would be better in-person, it sounds broken regardless.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by achow on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:38AM (#36256967)
Or in other words what business problem one is solving 0-1, 1-10 or 10-100. For first two remote is non-starter.

Similarly, what career stage one is in? Young workers who are in 0-1, and to certain extent 1-10, remote really does not work.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by jen20 on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:30AM (#36257553)
The first part of this is patently untrue. The most successful startup I worked at (defined as having IPO’d, and having their products effectively everywhere) was fully remote. This was very much 0-1, 1-10 type work. The only requirement to ever physically be in a given place was when visiting a customer.

The FAANG I work for now similarly has lots of 0-1, 1-10 type work (at least for my team), and a fully remote team. It works fine too.

The part about more junior employees is _more_ valid, though we had no problem on boarding juniors in either of those two situations.

Ultimately whether remote work is successful depends on whether the people doing the work have sufficient self-discipline to get the job done, and whether the hypothetical office alternative is set up for success. Most offices are not remotely set up for success, but optimize instead for middle management (toxin or cancer? [1]) being able to view their fifedoms.

[1]: https://www.talkfrom.com/video?name=leadership-without-manag...

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by danaris on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:15PM (#36260913)
My wife worked for several years for a company with only about a half-dozen employees. It was full remote.

She left there in 2011, after rising through the ranks to the level of division director.

They did almost all their business over email and Skype, because at the time, Skype was still the best voice/video conferencing software available without dedicated hardware.

If it was possible then for a small group of non-tech-focused people, it's certainly possible now, over a decade later and with an entire pandemic forcing the rapid improvement of all sorts of remote-work technology. That doesn't mean it's for everyone, but boldly stating that it's a "non-starter" is just unsupportable.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by mcv on Friday June 09, 2023 @09:36AM (#36257624)
> My instructions when I joined were something like "Yeah so just talk to a bunch of people and look for opportunities to contribute". WTF? No wonder remote is not working well for them. You had to go 5-6 layers up the reporting chain to find anyone with any sort of holistic sense of what needed to be done, and they were not exactly empowered to share that vision lest it conflict with someone elses.

That just sounds like poor leadership to me. If you've got a holistic sense of what needs to be done, please share it with the people who need to be doing it.

That, or cut it up into concrete chunks and tell people to build that. But telling people to "figure it out" and then not sharing the overall vision, sounds incredibly dysfunctional to me.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by gabereiser on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:00AM (#36257915)
I have the same conclusions as well however, in-person collaboration can be done remotely but it requires less professionalism and more trust. You have to allow for unforeseen moments and allow each participant to have their time to weigh in. Take breaks. It’s a 2.5x time slog vs in-person but it can be done with whiteboard tools and open honest communication. It’s the ones that expect excellence that struggle with remote’s imperfections.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by Nimitz14 on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:13AM (#36258094)
Fantastic summary
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by ghaff on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:15AM (#36258132)
Seniority is another factor.

People who have been in the industry and with a company for a long time largely have a network and don't really have problems connecting with people. (And at larger companies that network is often pretty distributed anyway.)

But the--admittedly not universal--consensus is that new folks struggle with onboarding and generally making progress in their careers. And even coming into an office doesn't really help if their managers and more senior co-workers are mostly not there. It's certainly hard for me to imagine graduating school and working remotely.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by BlargMcLarg on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:22AM (#36258222)
A lot of that struggle has to do with what others point out already: the onboarding processes and documentation being of shoddy quality and relying on word-of-mouth to transfer knowledge and repeatedly check in.

If you start raising future generations to be, you know, adults, instead of mentally stunting them into being eternal teens well into their 30s, and companies make an effort not to have a horrible onboarding and rely on 3 year tenures (and paradoxically do nothing to keep said employees that long), the problem is far less prevalent. Heck, most CS students are expected to do far more complex things at school without any assistance these days.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by ghaff on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:06AM (#36258947)
It's hard to argue with better documentation and process. However, if I think back to my early time in the computer industry (admittedly with much more limited electronic communications and other tools), it's just really hard for me to visualize taking away the in-person face-to-face--including a lot of social and quasi-social activities.

And with many travel budgets so squeezed at the moment (and COVID of course), you have teams with people who have never met anyone else on their team in-person in their whole multiyear tenure with the company. And to your point about short tenures, maybe they never will. If I'm honest, even though I've been around for ages, I'm less connected with co-workers than I've been in the past.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by danaris on Friday June 09, 2023 @01:11PM (#36260856)
From where I sit, needing the in-person face-to-face as your social activity for the day is a symptom of something that widespread remote work should at least help to fix: the splintering and atomization of communities that once existed outside of the workplace.

Once upon a time, it was considered the norm to find a job where you were, because you lived in a community that was part of your support system. Over the course of the last century, this norm eroded and was replaced with the norm of moving to wherever you got a job. More recently, the situation deteriorated even further, with the disappearance of the "job for life" assumptions that were prevalent in the mid-to-late 20th century, in favor of an expectation of changing jobs every 2-5 years—with a high chance every single time that you'd have to move.

One inevitable result of all this is the aforementioned splintering of local communities. Changing the employment norms so that a much higher percentage of people never need to move to work in person at a job would make it much easier to begin to restore local communities, and provide a much better chance of good socialization outside of work.

Now, there are caveats. This still relies on people not working too many hours, and while it would still help for the people who do work in person, and move in order to do so (those communities existing and being more prominent, and sustained by the people who stick around, makes it much easier for others to find them, too, even if they'll have to keep finding new ones every few years), it doesn't help them quite as much as the ones who can stay and grow their place in the community over many years.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by kartoshechka on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:15AM (#36259088)
I graduated from uni and all my jobs were 100% remote, and I don't really feel I had any serious problems in onboarding or advancing in my career at least yet :)

I'm not gonna pretend that every project had 100% coverage and up-to-date documentation, but you should overcome fear of appearing weak/dumb and just ask a question, not even waiting for the next daily meetup. If culture is good enough, people are gonna realize it isn't you dumb, but docs and processes suck ass and will do something about it, maybe even asking you to participate. If not, just leave when the next offer lines up, I did that once when people straight up refused answering to my questions directly, and instead nagging that I didn't ask them properly.

Building up network is obviously more reliable when meeting in person, but it doesn't defeat the idea of getting to know each other through daily interactions, retros, 1-1s, whatever. And moreover if you appear professional and capable in eyes of colleagues by getting shit done, they're would want at least keep in touch

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by kodah on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:29AM (#36258336)
Tech pays Industrial Psychologists, I don't know why we don't put them to work on this.

I restarted my software career doing remote work. I didn't have a problem finding things to do because my responsibilities were clear (read: I had a good manager) and I was self-taught so I already had a muscle for seeking knowledge on my own.

I suspect that remote work success is highly influenced by an equation involving how good your manager is and how much you innately know about what things your role is responsible for which can be propped up or replaced by seniority. I also suspect that new grads don't have muscles for finding/seeking internal and external information on their own, which feels powerless. There's ways to solve all these things without treating all of these folks the same.

Frankly, I think these are all the problems you and I relate to, but what's really solved for the business by returning to an office isn't productivity or happiness. It's a real estate problem.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by ghaff on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:03PM (#36259893)
>I suspect that remote work success is highly influenced by an equation involving how good your manager is

I suspect the people on here who like to hate on managers either have a bad one or just don't realize how much crap they're being shielded from--a lot of which is inevitable in a large organization (where you can't tell everyone "hey figure it out on your own").

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by kodah on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:24PM (#36260186)
That could explain some situations, but I very well doubt it's as simple as "managers are unappreciated".

Some managers are given wide latitude in controlling their teams work. Some managers execute on that, others don't.

Some managers are given a lot of control over hiring. Some execute on that, other don't.

Some managers are given wide latitude over reviews. Some managers execute on that while others don't.

The reason managers are perceived to be less useful in tech usually, in my experience, boils down to where they spend their time and political capital. They either spend it on their team and enabling them or on themselves and enabling themselves. All of the above are ways that could go either way and the feeling is generally an accumulation of those decisions over time. I guess I could surmise that there's just a lot of "bad" managers in tech, but I don't think that's a useful sentiment without knowing why.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by zingababba on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:05AM (#36258916)
Probably the best distinction I have seen tbh...
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by jacooper on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:48AM (#36259648)
What are PMF and NGMI?
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by x86x87 on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:11PM (#36259999)
I don't think it's true. This whole office/in office/rto has to do with people being dishonest about why the rto needs to happen and being stuck romanticising the good old days.

There is huge overhead to in person work and the benefits are wildly oversold.

IMHO a professional software developer in a company with good management/clear direction will thrive in a remote work scenario.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by rhtgrg on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:15PM (#36260072)
Not to mention that even in-person workplaces (especially at large companies) still involve plenty of remote interaction due to the global nature of the workforce. Plenty of Googlers being required to be in-office will actually be working alone in-office, with their teammates far away...
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by pandaman on Saturday June 10, 2023 @01:43AM (#36267944)
If this is true then there is no need to worry: companies with thriving WFH developers will surely overcome the stuck in the old ways ones. Not only their developers have same or greater performance due to constant thriving but their expenses will be much less so they will be able to offer better compensation and steal the talent from the in-office dinosaurs.
Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by x86x87 on Saturday June 10, 2023 @11:23AM (#36271317)
This is going to happen in the medium/long term.

The only reason big corporations have a chance of pulling this off is the overall state of the economy. Once we see recovery their RTO antics will fail if the shift is not completely done.

Re:Google uses in-person office attendance as part of employ... by pandaman on Saturday June 10, 2023 @11:59AM (#36271645)
We will see. Has not happened in the past so I see a little reason to happen in the future.