Many German people are still deeply distrusting of digital money transactions (keep in mind that there were two dictatorial regimes on German soil in the 20th century, of which one only ceased to exist little more than 30 years ago).
> How was it not authoritarian then but suddenly when the Asian people do it, it's a way to track everything people does
These people typically rather think that Asians should not make the same mistake (ignoring dangerous surveillance aspects).
How's that for "land of the free", eh?
And while we're at it: every phone call in the US gets recorded and stored. That's what that big datacenter in Utah is for.
Clearly you haven't heard of Real ID: https://www.dhs.gov/real-id
It’s just another extension of “we have to do this cause everyone else is and if we don’t we’ll be more vulnerable” which is from what I can tell the root of all evil.
https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/021816/why-g...
It's also an attempt to collect a percentage of all transactions, which will be funneled to the usual suspects, here's what led to this:
> "NEW YORK, September 19, 2012 — The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, Citi, Ford Foundation, Omidyar Network, U.N. Capital Development Fund (UNCDF), U. S. Agency for International Development (USAID), and Visa Inc. announced today the launch of the Better Than Cash Alliance. The new initiative will call on governments, the development community and the private sector to adopt the use of electronic payments..."
Moreover, it was not made illegal, rather it was no longer considered legal tender. A far cry from making it illegal.
There are on the other hand limits on the size of cash only transactions without a PAN Card (tax documentation)
Recently, the reserve bank has announced that it is going to withdraw the 2000 rupee note. That means that it will no longer print or issue via banks 2000 rupee notes.
They will still remain legal tender.
Regardless of the intentions, I don't see how banning people from using currency notes that they legally owned is not dictatorial. Why is using cash deemed guilty before even having any evidence.
Not legal tender: you cannot pay taxes with it, and generally cannot use in monetary transactions.
Until Sept 30th 2023.
As a "brown person", I resent this attempt at weaponizing racism just for the benefit of making your argument. Not only does it make your argument look petty and weak, but it actually damages the real efforts to battle true racism in the US. Please stop.
Pointing out double standards and hypocrisy is not weaponising racism.
> but it actually damages the real efforts to battle true racism in the US.
Why is this something an Asians in Asia should concern themselves with?
Yeah, just recently did a digital transaction in the US (ACH). Took 2 weeks for money to arrive.
It is pervasive, ubiquitous and very user friendly.
This is all thanks to the mobile data revolution ushered in by the telecoms companies in India over the last decade and a half.
Yes, data privacy is a larger issue that needs to be addressed in India, but that is no different than other digital payment methods like credit/debit cards.
One less mentioned point is that this payments revolution has done a lot to cut the country's carbon-footprint in the form of driving to the ATM or bank to get cash for routine transactions. Also, UPI is extremely consumer-friendly. If you withdrew cash from another bank's ATM, you may be charged fees whereas UPI is free for transactions up to INR 100,000 (approx $1200 USD)/day. This covers almost all day-to-day transaction needs for people.
I can choose a third-party fintech company's UPI app (eg: PayTM, PhonePe etc.,) or my bank's UPI app. So, it is incredibly flexible.
My car gives a mileage economy of ~10 km/ltr of fuel. So around 15-16 litres of fuel burning avoided.
If I did half of these ATM stops during other trips, thats still 7 to 8 litres of fuel burning avoided.
Isn't it the same in The West bar cash transaction?
>"If such a bank does not like an enterprise – such as Wikileaks – it can just freeze it out"
Same question again. For example in Canada they did just that during tracker's convoy.
I am not telling we are at their level (yet) but the direction ever country seems to be moving in looks like for more government / big corps spying and control.
This includes a lot of self-proclaimed pro-freedom types, as well. They'll support an oppressive regime so long as their own freedoms aren't restricted, and the problem grows.
The Indian government has no reason to track 500 million people in India, it would be more data than they would be able to handle.
Also most people don't care enough about this, yet the RBI is thinking about adding anonymity to UPI.
"The RBI may also test anonymity, security and privacy related to digital currency, It is possible to get a legal provision to ensure anonymity."
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/gadgets-news/heres-what-...
LOL, don't tell me you are from a technical background
This isn't an argument.
With the proliferation of cashless payment options, it's much easier now to deposit a paycheck or buy groceries in these small towns and villages.
The oppressive Indian Railways make it difficult to move around in the nation, while the amazing private network of high speed trains in the US is lightyears ahead.
I love the complex tax code of USA. An incompetent govt like India's would never be able to produce software as pleasing to use as Turbotax.
Allowing private companies to monopolize public contracts is great for the health of the nation. Pizza for school lunches is why Americans dominate sports around the world.
India should take inspiration from the free nation of USA. No surveillance here. What is a Snow den ?
> "India’s parliament on Wednesday passed legislation that gives federal agencies access to the world’s biggest biometric database in the interests of national security, raising fears the privacy of a billion people could be compromised."
https://www.reuters.com/article/uk-india-biometrics-idAFKCN0...
> "With this comes the spectre of bank surveillance, where every transaction you ever partake in is authorised and recorded by a privately run commercial bank, giving it a transaction-by-transaction history of your entire commercial life. If such a bank does not like an enterprise – such as Wikileaks – it can just freeze it out."
https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2015/sep/30...