News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by monero-xmr on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:19PM (#35775019)
The arguments for a centrally planned economy have been empirically disproved numerous times as to make the debate moot. But logically it is so clear:

It is impossible to assign value to something in any prescribed way, as the value of anything is determined by me. This is why my wedding ring has extremely high value to me, and I would need a lot of money to part with it, well beyond its value as a “generic” gold ring, which is more than its value in atomic gold. You can further extend this to literally anything, but even to commodities, which are theoretically the easiest to assign “value” to as they are fungible.

It is a fool’s errand to try and plan an economy, and those who think they can, or believe they are currently doing so in any meaningful way, are mistaken.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by striking on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:29PM (#35775158)
What about Walmart? Are corporations not their own little centrally planned economies? https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/38914131-the-people-s-re...
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by readthenotes1 on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:43PM (#35775400)
What about Kmart? Are corporations not their own little centrally planned economies?

Or take the something like 90% of restaurants that fail within the first year. Are they not..?

You got to talk about the bath water if you want to talk about the baby

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by striking on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:56PM (#35775612)
Capitalist countries fail too. We just had a banking crisis resolved by centralized action. I'm not sure what this means aside from the fact that any poorly managed system fails.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by HDThoreaun on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:46PM (#35775439)
Walmart is literally a market. No one is forcing you to buy things at walmart or work at walmart. No one is telling you which goods you will get and in what quantity. Substituting in the face of scarcity is encouraged on the micro scale. The power of markets is allowing individual consumers to change their consumption habits in the face of scarcity/abundance.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by cced on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:07PM (#35775795)
Absolute rubbish take.

> No one is forcing you to buy things at Walmart

When Walmart comes into a small town and uses it’s economies of scale to force smaller stores to shut down because they have the ability to operate at a loss, is this choice?

Walmart has a board of executives that decide on the direction of the company, it’s a corporation the performs central planning in order to maximize profits.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by HDThoreaun on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:17PM (#35775991)
Yes, the townspeople are choosing to shop at the market that has the best prices/best selection/whatever else walmart has that makes it preferable to other stores. Walmart's executives set their prices based on the cost to get products. Prices constantly change in reaction to supply and demand.

You seem to have figured out though that markets don't work without competition. Luckily the grocery market, at least in most places, is robustly competitive. And the government should step in when that is not the case.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by runarberg on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:26PM (#35776146)
Wallmart workers famously cannot even afford to pay Wallmart prices for their foods. How are townspeople (many of which are Wallmart workers) supposed to pay higher prices for their food when they can’t even afford the lowest price?
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by HDThoreaun on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:37PM (#35776314)
It's a market. If you don't like your job look for a better one. I mean I agree that our system isn't perfect, or even that good, but no system is. Planned economies consistently lead to famine and tens of millions of people starving to death.

If the labor market is a monopsony, as it commonly is in small towns, the government should step in.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by runarberg on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:50PM (#35776527)
> Planned economies consistently lead to famine and tens of millions of people starving to death.

They do not. Cuba has yet to experience a famine despite being under a severe embargo for several decades.

Famines also happen under capitalism. There are multitude of famines in east Africa to choose from, death count is well over tens of millions. Outside of Africa, the Bengal famine happened under British rule, death count 1-4 million people. While socialism was gaining traction inside British isles at the time, their colonies kept being ruled by harsh free market advocates.

However blaming capitalism for the Bengal famine is unfair, where imperialism, colonialism, and racism is a much better explanation, similarly, blaming communism for the Great Chinese Famine in Mao’s China is unfair, when fascism is a much better explanation.

Famines aren’t the only man-made disaster out there. It is hard to blame anything but global capitalism for disaster such as the Bhopal disaster, where one of the largest cities in India was poisoned in a effort to maximize profits for shareholders. Thousands died.

Together the disaster of capitalism cause several orders more deadly than the disaster commonly attributed to communism.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by HDThoreaun on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:32PM (#35777117)
Cuba is facing a famine right now.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by positron6000 on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:52PM (#35777367)
> Cuba is facing a famine right now

Because the US has embargoed Cuba for decades to cause hunger and desperation:

> If such a policy is adopted, it should be the result of a positive decision which would call forth a line of action which, while as adroit and inconspicuous as possible, makes the greatest inroads in denying money and supplies to Cuba, to decrease monetary and real wages, to bring about hunger, desperation and overthrow of government. - https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1958-60v06...

Citation needed on all your other claims.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by monero-xmr on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:59PM (#35777476)
Cuba is not embargoed by Canada, the EU, and so on, so the USA not providing food is certainly not a valid argument.

https://www.eeas.europa.eu/cuba/european-union-and-cuba_en?s....

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by runarberg on Monday May 01, 2023 @05:13PM (#35779253)
The USA embargo in Cuba is not causing a famine because there is no famine. So you’re vitamin A deficiency did not cause your black eye, because you have enough vitamin B and C, and also you don’t have a black eye.

Also the embargo de jure excludes food and medicine (although de facto it is hard to export those to Cuba), but also subsidiaries of USA companies are also not allowed to trade with Cuba, so Canadian and EU companies which do business in the USA (which is almost everybody) are risking a lot by trading with Cuba, so in effect the embargo is somewhat extended by large parts of EU and Canada.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by zdragnar on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:44PM (#35778105)
The parent to the post you responded to literally said

> Cuba has yet to experience a famine despite being under a severe embargo for several decades.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by runarberg on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:53PM (#35777391)
I don’t know where you get your news from, but no. There is currently no famine happening in Cuba. There is a fuel shortage (like there is in many other countries). But there is still enough food for everybody, and (unlike in many other neighboring countries) the food is distributed such that hunger is relatively rare, and mass hunger—let alone a famine—is unheard of. The cost of living is still significantly lower than the median income, despite the energy crisis and despite the embargo.

I honestly don’t know where you’ve heard this. I searched the news for a famine in Cuba, and nothing came up, not even unreliable sources. Where did you hear this?

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by petsfed on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:03PM (#35777524)
> blaming communism for the Great Chinese Famine in Mao’s China is unfair, when fascism is a much better explanation

Not to nitpick, but was Mao's China fascist, strictly speaking? I ask because the big 3 fascist regimes of the 20th century (Hitler's Germany, Mussolini's Italy, and Franco's Spain) were all stridently anti-communist, anti-collectivist, and anti-Marxist. You can see a lot of the other elements of many definitions of fascism in Mao's regime, but that anti-communist part is really hard to square. One definition I appreciated is that fascism is vocally and stridently anti-equality, and by that standard, Mao's regime is clearly not a fascist one, even as it just as strongly authoritarian as any self-described fascist regime.

I'm actually not prepared to say that communism or capitalism is more deadly, because I think the reality is that the people making decisions got to that place because of skill in political infighting, not superior judgement on the topic at hand.

That is, the reason planned economies do fail is not because planned economies must fail, per se. Rather economies are, of necessity, massively complicated things and its very difficult to account for every variable adequately whilst planning, to say nothing of the difficulty of conniving the appropriate carrots and sticks for every participant at every level, to convince all participants to follow the plan.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by danaris on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:43PM (#35778095)
What fascism and most countries that have called themselves "communist" have in common is authoritarianism.

95% of what most Americans criticize as "the evils of communism" are, in fact, the evils of authoritarian systems; it just happens that the big authoritarian system that was in opposition to America for decades called itself communist. Much like North Korea calls itself "democratic".

And while fascism is, indeed, anti-equality, the inequality it seeks to foster is almost always between a cultural in-group and Everyone Else. Furthermore, fascism does not always seek to murder the Other; it also seeks to forcibly assimilate them.

Guess what Mao did in China: systematically eradicated massive swathes of Chinese culture—or rather, cultures, because there were many differences between what it meant to be, say, Han Chinese vs Mongolian or Tibetan. The Uyghur genocide that is ongoing today is just an extension of that—and yes, it fits quite well with fascist ideals.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by positron6000 on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:56PM (#35777423)
> It's a market. If you don't like your job look for a better one.

Sure! I live in a small rural town with a poor public education system and no professional opportunities outside of manual labor. I had to leave high school to work to support my family. The most I can make is minimum wage, which means that I cannot afford basic necessities. What "better" jobs am I able to choose from? Or do I have to wait for "the government" to step in so my family doesn't starve?

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by HDThoreaun on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:04PM (#35777535)
Rural economies being fucked isn't capitalism's fault. If you don't create valuable things you won't get valuable things, that's true in all economic systems. If you want valuable things you should probably move somewhere where they are being created and get a job there. Forcing rural people to move to urban areas and work in factories is a classic communism move because it turns out people are more productive when near each other. Capitalism just gives people the choice of doing that or staying where they are and being poorer.

Allowing poverty to exist really has nothing to do with capitalism the economic system and everything to do with the political climate in society. Capitalism is just free markets and property rights, it doesn't say anything about government redistribution. Getting rid of markets would not help poor people at all.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:30PM (#35777902)
You seem to conveniently ignore the externalities that most people who have investigated them agree are a major component in a corporation like Walmart existing at all.

I would agree with most of what you've written if the price of goods at Walmart actually represented their true cost. But instead, Walmart relies on externalities (the most obvious one is their reliance on their staff being able to collect various forms of public assistance, but there are plenty more) in order to maintain their prices.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by runarberg on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:53PM (#35778236)
Just for the record, the article in which thread spun from is about the socialist question. It is asking whether there is a reason to your mentality. That is, is it worth it to regulate economies and set up social services such that people don’t have to live at the whims of free market capitalism.

Unsurprisingly for an alumni of the Chicago school the author believes this is still an open question, however this article is kind of well written and everything up to the conclusion—that is the historical breakdown of this question—seems to indicate that socialism is good actually, and Laissez-faire capitalism is bad.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by stale2002 on Monday May 01, 2023 @04:55PM (#35779012)
> What "better" jobs am I able to choose from?

Ones that are in a different city, of course.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by positron6000 on Monday May 01, 2023 @05:05PM (#35779139)
Great! Where am I going to get money to move from a small town to a city with a higher cost of living, and how will I - a high-school dropout - acquire the skills necessary to get one of these better jobs? How long will it take? Where will I live? How will my family survive without my income?
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by HDThoreaun on Monday May 01, 2023 @06:02PM (#35779811)
You know the vast majority of history is nothing but death and despair right? You can’t expect other people to solve your problems for you. At some point you have to accept that waiting for life to come to you will result in poverty, that is true of the 99.99999999% of people in every society ever. I get that it’s not fun to confront the harshness of reality, but your comments really do make it seem like you’re expecting people who don’t take initiative to just have things handed to them(to be clear I have no problem just handing people basic necessities such as food and healthcare, but good jobs are a privilege, not a right).

Acting like being in small town America is an economic tragedy is a gigantic insult to the millions of people who sacrificed everything to migrate to the developed world, and those people are largely extremely good at lifting themselves out of poverty when they arrive. Why are locals less economically mobile?

There has never been a more prosperous time to be alive than right now in western countries, we need to continue to work to make life better for everyone society, but there is no magic solution other than hard work.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by runarberg on Monday May 01, 2023 @06:25PM (#35780086)
This is a bit rude don’t you think?

There are many tings in here that should be addressed, including simple respect for other people, and recognition of varying economic status, and the reality of impoverishment.

However I want to address the migration question. As an immigrant my self I take offense that you suggest that people migrate to “the developed world” (ugh!) in search of prosperity. This is a great simplification, and kind of a regurgitation of a popular belief which isn’t true. Most people—including my self—migrate because of family, second is jobs and education, these are people that already have a job or have been admitted to school and come on a special worker or school visas. Majority of immigrants don’t sacrifice everything, just proximity to family and friends, and most use their existing wealth to make the migration as easy as possible. In fact demonstrating financial viability is a precondition for permanent residency, meaning by far majority immigrants who can’t afford to migrate, or don’t have a job or a scholarship awaiting them, are forbidden by law from staying.

Immigrants who sacrifice everything off course exists, and refugees in particular take great risks while migrating, but they are a minority, and there is not exactly prosperity awaiting them, rather, a hope for a safer place to live. Many refugees have decades of poverty awaiting them in their host country, the more social services they get, the easier it is for them to actually escape poverty.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by HDThoreaun on Monday May 01, 2023 @07:06PM (#35780547)
The United States has millions of illegal immigrants who did sacrifice everything to walk thousands of miles to get here. I’ve talked to many, they have all been extremely grateful for the opportunities the free market here has provided them. And obviously I agree we should people be successful. But complaining that there aren’t any jobs in your shit hole town isn’t a mindset that will get you anywhere. If the only job available to you is Walmart you should move, and finish high school too tbh. It really is that simple, and I’m kind of over the entitlement I see from these small town people expecting the world he handed to them. Because the reality is this country has plenty of decent, if not great, jobs that are certainly better than almost any person ever has had access too.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by runarberg on Monday May 01, 2023 @07:26PM (#35780729)
DHS—a very biased institution that has benefits of inflating the number—estimated 11 million undocumented immigrants residing in the USA in 2018 (the most recent number I could find), the foreign born population that same year was estimated at 36 million, meaning undocumented were at most one third of all immigrants. By far majority of the 11 million undocumented came from Mexico or central America. The path to legal status is extremely difficult from those countries and it is reasonable to assume majority of them would had taken the legal route if possible and had indeed family and/or jobs awaiting them across the border. While some may indeed have sacrificed everything, I very much doubt that figure is much higher than in the hundreds of thousands.

https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/immigra...

But than again, listen to what you are saying. Do you honestly want to live in a society where people are asked to “sacrificed everything” just because they happened to be born and raised a poor part of the country? Would you honestly prefer people struggle all of their childhood and most of their lives as young adults, only to than be forced to abandon their entire family, just to have maybe a shot at a better life? It may just be me, but I honestly would prefer there to be regulations and social services in place such that these lives are made easier.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by WillPostForFood on Monday May 01, 2023 @04:04PM (#35778385)
This data is somewhat misrepresented. To be eligible for SNAP benefits, you have to also work (unless you get an exemption, like for caretaking). So the government is trying to get people off SNAP for pushing them to work, then shaming the employer for hiring people on SNAP. Walmart is a common low skill entry level job, so not a surprise that a lot of SNAP beneficiaries end up there.

The top employers that have SNAP beneficiaries also include the USPS, Amazon, Home Depot, Publix, Uber, McDonalds, Krogers...

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by aww_dang on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:21PM (#35776061)
You are exactly right. They seek to maximize profits. Profits can only exist within a coherent system of prices.

How can a central planner effectively determine prices across an entire economy? Price fixing has historically been disastrous, from Diocletian to the USSR. This is literally the definition of the calculation problem.

Contrast this to politicians and bureaucrats who may have additional political incentives towards kickbacks, corruption or other, non-market inefficient practices.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by Philorandroid on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:46PM (#35775443)
It might be "centrally planned" in the most technical sense, but it's a bit of a stretch to compare a government's leverage over a market by threat of force to a private entity planning what to do with the property it owns. How is it meaningfully distinct from an individual (or a family) doing financial planning around their assets?
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by jl6 on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:47PM (#35775460)
A tempting analogy, but I think there are too many crucial differences to put corporations forward as a model for central planning.

For a start, corporations are very small compared to states. Even Walmart, the world's biggest employer, is less than 1% the size of the US by headcount.

More problematic is that corporations plan to maximize profit. That's it. It's a comparatively trivial optimization goal compared to the multitude of ways of valuing things that exist in wider society - and yet, corporations still frequently fail to be profitable. OP's example about the wedding ring is a case in point. Walmart's Finance department would value that for its raw weight in gold only.

But even more worrying, corporations have a magic tool for maintaining order and efficiency: firing people. States can't do that, or at least, not states that you'd want to live in. Corporations are rigidly hierarchical. Corporations are not democracies. Imagine human rights as implemented by the HR department. Scaling up corporate processes to manage a whole country would result in a terrifying dystopia.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by photochemsyn on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:53PM (#35775575)
I think you just need to go up the corporate-financial ladder a step. Clearly the major shareholder conglomerates - Vanguard, Fidelity, State Street, Vanguard etc. can act in a manner very similar to a Soviet Central Committee to direct resources in a centrally planned manner. The current consolidation of banking into a small group of large corporate institutions (JPMorganChase, BankAmerica, Citgroup, WellsFargo) with direct ties to the Federal Reserve is another obvious example of how the US economy is more of a centrally planned model than not, and of course, the military-industrial corporate system, where the government is basically the sole buyer and distributor of contracts, is another one.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by AnimalMuppet on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:51PM (#35778212)
Maybe they could. But they don't. They invest in companies, but they don't tell the companies how to run themselves.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by dragonwriter on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:52PM (#35775563)
> But even more worrying, corporations have a magic tool for maintaining order and efficiency: firing people. States can't do that,

Deportation and capital punishment are real things, so I think your wrong.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by hgomersall on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:43PM (#35778082)
They're not real things in a civilised society.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by cced on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:01PM (#35775698)
OP’s example of his wedding ring is absolutely not case in point; the value of his ring is it’s weight in gold.

Whatever _sentimental value_ he may hold for his ring has no bearing on any rational actors choice to buy the ring.

Apple, Microsoft, Walmart and, gee, I don’t know, any of the other F500 corporations don’t make it there because “they fail to value their products and services”.

They pay real people, real wages, to produce real things, that are sold further down the supply chain. These aren’t imaginary objects and figures.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by kneebonian on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:49PM (#35775513)
> firing people. States can't do that,

The Gulags: Let me introduce myself.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by wrycoder on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:27PM (#35777860)
What about Sears? What about Polariod? Packard?

At the top of the growth sigmoid, corporations always make the wrong planning choices, to avoid self-cannibalization of existing products and to protect existing internal power structures.

The same thing happens with centrally planned economies.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by zzbzq on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:30PM (#35775188)
Only by straw-manning the idea. What you've written there doesn't disprove anything. We've seen in real life that a large corporation can plan a proportion of an economy. What you have to prove, in order to repudiate central planning, is prove that there exists some maximum proportion of an economy that can be planned. And even then, a simple workaround would be to artificially recreate such maximums within the central structure. I think you're just not very imaginative.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by monero-xmr on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:41PM (#35775362)
A corporation can execute the creation of consumer or producer goods for sale to the market, earning a profit greater than the sum of the inputs. Corporations execute on that specific mission with a goal of maximizing profit. A side-effect of this (in a truly free market) is to ensure the customer, who should be able to freely to purchase from any producer, is maximally satisfied. It also follows that a corporation will try and reduce their costs on all possible axes - from inputs, to labor, to production time, to tax mitigation, etc.

If you try to extend "producing goods" to "every good possible for all people", it cannot possibly work, because a corporation cannot even satisfy the needs of consumers within their narrow band of production (or else competitors wouldn't exist, and further enhancements of products would be unnecessary).

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by cced on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:11PM (#35775876)
> greater than the sum of the inputs

Oh please, they get to rob workers of necessities of life and capitalize on their pity wages. Take a look at Walmart employees on food stamps and talk about producing value equal to more than the sum of the parts; the government is subsidizing their food.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by monero-xmr on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:46PM (#35776466)
That is a political decision that the USA made, and one could that also be changed through the political process - by subsidizing all manner of social benefits (healthcare, housing, food, and so on) the US government enables private businesses to hire employees at a lower wage without social upheaval. I would argue this is inferior to providing no social benefits whatsoever in order that corporations would have to bear more of the cost, rather than indirectly through taxes.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:26PM (#35777845)
1. we do not charter corporations so that they may chase profits, we charter them because we believe that without limited liability, certain things that we as a society (or as a monarch) want done will not happen. If that was not the case, we would not have corporations at all, simply partnerships between various sized groups of individuals who decided to risk their personal fortune (in all senses) on some venture that could not be accomplished alone.

2. in situations of monopoly or close to it, corporations do in fact indulge in central planning for an entire economy. You may choose to put your faith in the idea that their chasing profits mean that their decisions will be the ones we would make as a society, but there's no inherent reason for this to be true. There are often multiple pathways to the same profit, with different side effects and different levels of organizational commitment; as a society we might prefer a corporation to pick one route, but it picks the other.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by monero-xmr on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:55PM (#35782263)
I used corporation but I meant private enterprise - the legal mechanism is unimportant.

Private entities are specifically exempted from political manipulation. Government makes the rules, but a private entity (barring a few special cases) is free to operate within the law without a bureaucrat embedded in the office. Therefore the society might want a corporation to make some decision, but generally it can’t force them to by direct action.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @12:35AM (#35783409)
On the contrary, the legal mechanism is vitally important.

If every venture that involved gathering together a group of people to bring sufficient capital, labor and IP to bear on a problem or opportunity ALSO faced the personal ruin of its participants should it fail or cause injury or death or despoilment, it would be extremely difficult to convince such organizations to form.

It is vitally important for such organizations to have limited liability for their participants i.e. for society to indemnify the participants against potential harmful outcomes from their endeavor.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by mxkopy on Monday May 01, 2023 @04:39PM (#35778822)
I don't understand how these things are connected. The market being free doesn't have anything to do with whether or not the customer is satisfied - take telecom in the U.S. for example. Competition is sparse and nobody is satisfied.

What you're describing is a buyer's market, which is only one case out of many.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by monero-xmr on Monday May 01, 2023 @09:56PM (#35782272)
Telecom is one of the most highly regulated industries on earth. Bad example for trying to argue against free markets.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by mxkopy on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:40AM (#35783777)
Telecom has little competition because of high barriers to entry, not regulation.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by monero-xmr on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @11:25AM (#35789004)
This is why I said "in a truly free market" in my explanation. Telecom is far from a truly free market. No matter how much capital you have, you cannot enter the market as a new provider, without regulators approving a huge variety of things, not just wavelength and radio stuff but also the right to exist at all as a provider of such telecom services. This introduces all manner of possibilities for corruption, lobbying, etc. that lead to monopolies.

IMO the main cause of monopolistic behavior is government regulation rather than natural tendencies of the free market (but that's up for debate and my position is unpopular).

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by karaterobot on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:38PM (#35775303)
> We've seen in real life that a large corporation can plan a proportion of an economy. What you have to prove, in order to repudiate central planning, is prove that there exists some maximum proportion of an economy that can be planned.

If the examples of large corporations planning a proportion of an economy count as an argument for why central planning could work, then surely the examples of actual, centrally-planned economies failing should count as arguments for why they don't. I mean, don't toss out the actual examples for the metaphorical ones.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by stelonix on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:49PM (#35775507)
You mean examples why they didn't. Just because Starship exploded at launch it does not prove all Starships are going to explode. Likewise, if you have a handful of trials of planned economy it does not imply the whole concept is infeasible. Stating otherwise is fallacious.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by etrautmann on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:24PM (#35776999)
Ah yes, on the 205th try we'll finally nail this impossibly complex and moving target.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by assbuttbuttass on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:56PM (#35775613)
The problem with that argument is you have to argue that the USSR failed because of central planning, when the reality is their centrally planned economy succeeded in industrializing a majority-peasant agricultural country, defeating the nazis in world war 2, and launching a man into space.

I'm not blind to the many flaws of the soviet union, but it's a bit absurd to point to it as a failure of central planning.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by foobiekr on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:40PM (#35775351)
The difference is that the corporation can die. Not so government programs.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by pc86 on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:46PM (#35775441)
Government programs are cancelled all the time.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by foobiekr on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @01:23AM (#35783685)
Not because they failed, though.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by bretticus on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:49PM (#35775494)
> We've seen in real life that a large corporation can plan a proportion of an economy.

No we haven’t. Look at the list of Fortune 500 companies today vs 50 years ago. The landscape is completely different. IBM was the most innovative company in America and now it's seen as a dinosaur. Corporations die each year. It’s cutthroat; your business is more likely to fail than succeed. The idea that Nancy Pelosi and Mitch McConnell could do a better job planning the economy is laughable

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by RandomLensman on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:49PM (#35775501)
Corporations fail a lot in their plans. On top, not certain that the planning aspect is what gives rise to corporations in the first place (vs., e.g, transaction costs between independent actors if there where no corporation).
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by olalonde on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:39PM (#35778034)
That's redefining what "centrally planned" means. Corporations are subject to competitive pressures: they rapidly lose their ability to "plan" when they stop "planning" well. There's no comparable mechanism when it comes to top-down government planning.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by refurb on Tuesday May 02, 2023 @05:22AM (#35785098)
Considering the number of large corporations that go bankrupt, I think it's pretty good they can't plan a proportion of the economy.

They aren't planing anything, they are responding to the environment. Sometimes they get it right and profit, other times they get it wrong and fail.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by harimau777 on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:37PM (#35775279)
I'm not a fan of forms of socialism revolving around centrally planned economies; however, it seems to me that we also don't have any reason to believe that a market economy can accurately assign prices.

The free market argument that the value of something is equal to it's price seems to me to be begging the question. It's essentially saying "the an object's market price equals it's value because I choose to say that an object's value is it's market price."

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by kneebonian on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:46PM (#35775440)
That's pretty much the only real value though is what someone is willing to pay for it.

To quote the Prince of Egypt "A lake of gold in the desert sand is less than a cool fresh spring, and to one lost sheep a shepherd boy is greater than the richest king."

Ultimately the value of something is what someone is willing to assign to it, nothing has inherent value as far as humanity has been able to determine or agree on, so instead the market allows everyone the freedom to value whatever they would like at whatever they would like.

But if you have an alternative way of reconciling the water diamond paradox I'd be interested in hearing it.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by harimau777 on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:11PM (#35776801)
The problem is that the market doesn't actually give people the freedom to price things in accordance with the value it represents to them because people do not start out with equal ability to pay. For example, a rich person may be willing to pay a higher price for a second home even though it is likely less valuable to them then it would be to someone without a home.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by int_19h on Monday May 01, 2023 @04:33PM (#35778768)
But that is caused by existing economic inequality, not the free market itself. If the rest of your society is organized in ways that e.g. prevent massive unlimited accumulation of wealth, the disparity between what people can afford is much smaller - and then the market can easily be more optimal than any centralized scheme.

Indeed, one could argue that capitalism (which explicitly allows for unlimited accumulation of capital) is detrimental to genuinely free markets for this exact reason: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-market%20anti-capitalism

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by Nasrudith on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:05PM (#35775759)
The notion relies upon fundamentally faulty assumptions about universal fixedness to pricing, namely that it exists at all. It is frankly, insane to operate under it but because of Marx's and his disciple's fixation upon labor as a basis of economic value they stalwartly refuse to see what is right in front of their face. Water by the river is far cheaper than water in the Sahara. Hauling the water to the Sahara isn't guaranteed profit however because of the lack of people in the Sahara in the first place to serve the exchange, however.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by harimau777 on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:07PM (#35776753)
I agree that things don't necessarily have fixed values. However, that doesn't necessarily mean that price is an accurate reflection of that value.

Food has more value to someone who is starving than to someone who is well fed; even if the well fed person is willing and able to pay more for it.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by hgomersall on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:46PM (#35778136)
It's an interesting idea that perhaps peoples' financial offers for goods and services should be normalised by their financial wealth.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by marcosdumay on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:23PM (#35777795)
> a market economy can['t] accurately assign prices

Well, that is meaningless unless you define what "accurately" means here. This word is carrying a huge amount of weight, and isn't capable of that at all. (And when doing that, keep in mind that "price" is not "value", and there is no reason at all to equate those two.)

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by frgtpsswrdlame on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:25PM (#35775101)
Have they been disproved empirically? I'm well aware of many theoretical arguments against central planning but I'm not aware of empirical work.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by nyolfen on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:29PM (#35775170)
well, it was tried at scale one time, and the economy it produced lasted several decades, but was sclerotic, dependent on resources extracted by compulsion from its imperial periphery, and ended up literally unable to feed itself
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by s3r3nity on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:36PM (#35775274)
> at scale one time

Bait? Bait.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by malermeister on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:36PM (#35775259)
The same could be said, word for word, for capitalism as the United States are currently demonstrating.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by aww_dang on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:42PM (#35775380)
The US isn't laissez-faire. Most proponents of free-markets would point to the current crises and relate them to the central bankers. Interest rates have been centrally planned rather than floating on the market. Banking regulations drive banks to hold treasuries. When new treasuries are issued at a higher rate of interest the discount rate for lower (near zero) t-bills increases, putting bank balance sheets out of whack.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by malermeister on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:00PM (#35775677)
This is literally what a socialist would say about the Soviet Union. Not true socialism etc etc
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by godelski on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:40PM (#35776362)
Things aren't binary though. No one is saying the US isn't "real capitalism", they are just specifying what type of capitalism it is. But that's a very different than saying there's no true Scotsman. There's a reason one is a fallacy and the other isn't.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by aww_dang on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:13PM (#35775908)
As flawed as the US economy is, at least there is still something resembling a market price for basics like a loaf of bread. Yes, you can claim that the USSR wasn't the socialist ideal, however moving further from that claimed ideal results in a more productive economy. To the extent that the west is increasingly centrally planned, it has become relatively less productive.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by PrimeMcFly on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:32PM (#35777099)
That would be wrong though. The capitalist economy in the US has lasted literally centuries.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by malermeister on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:01PM (#35777509)
Centuries are "several decades".
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by PrimeMcFly on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:14PM (#35777693)
Sure, but when people say decades they generally mean an amount less than multiple centuries, or they would have said centuries...
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by malermeister on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:40PM (#35778045)
True, but it's not wrong as claimed above.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by PrimeMcFly on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:50PM (#35778193)
It is if you consider the meaning that was being communicated and not the technical dictionary definition of words.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by nyolfen on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:16PM (#35856134)
this is so false i have a hard time believing you actually think this. that said, i strongly encourage you to put your money where your mouth is and invest accordingly!
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by aww_dang on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:34PM (#35775246)
In the Mises canon, the possibility of effective central planning is debunked from first principles. I wouldn't claim that a triangle having three sides is theoretical or empirical, but YMMV.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by asplake on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:44PM (#35775420)
As long ago as the 70s and perhaps earlier, the cybernetics community – people like Ashby, Conant, Beer – might have argued its non-viability (I choose that word deliberately) on information-theoretic grounds. The centre has neither the communication bandwidth nor the predictive power to control things for long.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by mrkeen on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:55PM (#35775600)
"Google Finds: Centralized Control, Distributed Data Architectures Work Better than Fully Decentralized Architectures"

http://highscalability.com/blog/2014/4/7/google-finds-centra...

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by asplake on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:33PM (#35776249)
…in computer systems. And I wasn’t arguing for full decentralisation either
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by cced on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:45PM (#35775433)
If anyone is interested in learning more about how Walmart uses central planning today, here’s a Youtube video [1] of it (30 mins)

I would love for OP to explain why central planning seems to work so well for private businesses but has no such hopes of achieving any success for the public.

[1]: https://youtu.be/xuBrGaVhjcI

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by aww_dang on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:03PM (#35775725)
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by mrkeen on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:47PM (#35775474)
> It is impossible to assign value to something in any prescribed way, as the value of anything is determined by me.

It's like Insulin. It may only be worth $5/vial to drug companies, but it's worth $100/vial to consumers who don't want to die.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by kelseyfrog on Monday May 01, 2023 @03:31PM (#35777917)
That's a really good point in the argument that markets for demand-inelastic goods are amoral at best and unethical at worst. We have choices to make when it comes to which economic systems best solve certain problems.

Organ donation is a good example we're we've said, "we cannot let a market solve this problem." Are there issues, with it? Sure, but only the extreme among us argue that organ markets would be an improvement. Every market is open to this critique to various degrees.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by piloto_ciego on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:06PM (#35775775)
I mean, we have not tried it with modern computers… and he Soviets never even got close as the technology to see literally every non-black market transaction has only existed for a decade or so. Not saying I want to live in 1980s style Soviet bureaucracy (or weird modern Chinese mixed system) - but that doesn’t mean we can’t do immeasurably better than those systems.

I am not sure “8 billion Turing machines” is intrinsically more efficient or accurate than “one really fast one.”

Also, worth mentioning that you would sell your wedding ring in a heartbeat if you needed to pay for food/healthcare/etc. Sentimental value is important you’re right, but in my experience (maybe not yours which is fair) - when the chips are down you do what you have to do to survive. The problem is, in the current system we value human life less and than market equilibrium, and that’s silly. We could feed every starving person on the planet… several times over… but we don’t because it’s not profitable. That’s objectively stupid.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by godelski on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:15PM (#35775953)
> I mean, we have not tried it with modern computers

Sure, but considering all the information you'd need to compute (I'd argue we're close but probably not there yet), is this okay? Are there disadvantages to this data collection? Do these downsides outweigh the upsides? I feel like these conversations are so difficult because everyone comes in with certain assumptions, assumes others have them (even if explicitly stated otherwise), or are dismissive of any other concerns. We need to be on the same page to have real conversations.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by godelski on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:08PM (#35775820)
The article even starts with a bad premise, claiming we have a laissez-faire system. Don't listen to people that binaryize opposing viewpoints: all forms of capitalism are the same.

> arguments for a centrally planned economy

I actually think we're getting close to a point where a planned economy could be feasible. The problem with planned economies is that the economy is naturally chaotic (small perturbations result in large changes in outcomes). So to do this you need a pretty close eye and measurements of the economy. But looking at this requirement, we have to ask what actually needs to be given up. I'd argue that this is the reason that we should never have a planned economy. The solution space is complex and there are no globally optimal systems, so we need to pick what we care about. If you are about reducing harm from potential tyrants from abusing the population (or some subset) and/or privacy and security from governments (not just your own) then this is absolutely not a path we want to go down. Because high levels of surveillance maximize tyrant's power and maximize potential exploitation by adversarial governments.

And there lies the problem. Things that "look good on paper, but don't work in practice" are just things where on paper we haven't been nuanced. It is where on paper we've just had a myopic viewpoint, steamrolling your opinion, not seeking solutions. This is true outside economics and politics, but I think since it is a field that everyone feels qualified participate in and highly encourages blinders. We can't go about solving complex problems this way. We can't solve complex problems pretending all problems are easy and have precise solutions. Life is messy, and so are solutions.

So let's talk about what we actually care about and what our actual objectives are before we even attempt to start optimizing. I rarely see any discussion of objectives. It is fine to assume that people just want a strong economy and well off people, but there are many other variables that we either need to concern ourselves with or not, and we can't have these conversations without establishing our premises. They aren't obvious.

Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate by antisthenes on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:10PM (#35775857)
If you look closely, you'll see that at its core, this is just another Luddite argument.

While it's true that a centrally planned economy may not ultimately have the same variety of goods, it's important to understand that a planned economy is not optimizing for that, and that parts of a regular economy (especially parts concerning national defense security and energy security) are already very highly planned)

> It is a fool’s errand to try and plan an economy, and those who think they can, or believe they are currently doing so in any meaningful way, are mistaken.

So were the people who thought cars couldn't be faster than horses or that computers couldn't beat humans at chess or generate deceptive but believable text output at a level of a 10-year old.