You mean examples why they didn't. Just because Starship exploded at launch it does not prove all Starships are going to explode. Likewise, if you have a handful of trials of planned economy it does not imply the whole concept is infeasible. Stating otherwise is fallacious.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate
by etrautmann on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:24PM
(#35776999)
Ah yes, on the 205th try we'll finally nail this impossibly complex and moving target.
Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate
by assbuttbuttass on Monday May 01, 2023 @12:56PM
(#35775613)
The problem with that argument is you have to argue that the USSR failed because of central planning, when the reality is their centrally planned economy succeeded in industrializing a majority-peasant agricultural country, defeating the nazis in world war 2, and launching a man into space.
I'm not blind to the many flaws of the soviet union, but it's a bit absurd to point to it as a failure of central planning.
If the examples of large corporations planning a proportion of an economy count as an argument for why central planning could work, then surely the examples of actual, centrally-planned economies failing should count as arguments for why they don't. I mean, don't toss out the actual examples for the metaphorical ones.