Re:The Socialist Calculation Debate
by malermeister on Monday May 01, 2023 @01:00PM
(#35775677)
This is literally what a socialist would say about the Soviet Union. Not true socialism etc etc
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Things aren't binary though. No one is saying the US isn't "real capitalism", they are just specifying what type of capitalism it is. But that's a very different than saying there's no true Scotsman. There's a reason one is a fallacy and the other isn't.
As flawed as the US economy is, at least there is still something resembling a market price for basics like a loaf of bread. Yes, you can claim that the USSR wasn't the socialist ideal, however moving further from that claimed ideal results in a more productive economy. To the extent that the west is increasingly centrally planned, it has become relatively less productive.