So much for an “unfathomable moat”.
There are definitely two tiers of Siri queries. There are queries like "set the brightness to 10%" or "set a timer for 5 minutes" which absolutely and consistently work without internet, and have for several years, and if you're legitimately having a different experience then its possible a cosmic ray hit your iPhone (or, realistically, you're running into a strange and rare bug which is not indicative of the general experience and will be fixed in three to five years or maybe never). There are also queries like "create a new note" (from the Notes app) which should be able to work offline, but don't. And, naturally, there are queries like "when did Resident Evil 4 come out" which wouldn't reasonably work without internet (but, if you're curious, she does get it right).
In other words, Siri clearly does some local guessing as to whether she can answer a query without the internet, and some queries appear to be miscategorized into the second bucket. My leading theory on why this happens, which may be incorrect, but it seems like: if an app has any Siri functionality which requires the internet to answer, all of the queries which are responded to by that app have to require the internet. It doesn't matter where the processing ends up actually happening to respond to the query, it just shuts the query down. Its weird, but its consistent with the behavior I've seen.
The more important point: Siri's real and weird limitations don't seem to have much to do with limitations in local processing. They've said that the speech interpretation all happens on-device. They encrypt practically all of your data that does get shipped to their servers, so a query like "Open the note titled 'Hello World'" is probably also being processed on-device. But: Siri still requires the internet for that query. That doesn't seem like a significant limitation with their ML algorithms or silicon or anything meaningful; it seems like just a case of dumb coding, which is certainly something Apple is no stranger to.
interesting - latest iOS in airplane mode - "hey siri what time is it?" - "you need to turn off airplane mode to do that"
but - "hey siri set a time for 5 minutes" - works just fine
Focusing on privacy and on-device learning is great, but when the strength of these models is in consuming all the data they can hoover up your motive is at odds with your philosophy.
Apple has access to SUBSTANTIALLY more fine-grained personalized data than Google does. Full stop. That's a weird thing to assert in the tech crowd, but think about it deeply and you'll realize its true.
Google has islands of services that they've done an extremely good job of building bridges between. They have some islands that Apple has nothing like (YouTube is the biggest one) (Search is a huge island, but only indefensible if the interfaces customers use to access it don't leak the queries and results; no one opens a browser and types "www.google.com" on mobile and even if they did, Apple controls the browser renderer, they could lift everything if they wanted to, they won't, I'm simply illustrating how much Apple should fuckin scare Google). But the waters between those islands are patrolled by Samsung, Xiaomi, Oppo, and Vivo, and there's sharks in there as well (uh, the metaphor is falling apart, the sharks are "Google's tumultuous history with privacy and user blowback if they overstep").
Apple is a continent. Many of their cities are ports that connect to some of Google's islands, but Google's product still has to be checked by customs.
You're right that even given that power, hoovering it up is at-odds with Apple's philosophy. Or, is it? I think "hoovering it unencrypted to the cloud" definitely is; but that's the point OP was making: if we're extremely close, as a species, to solving "make AI work", one of the challenges for the next five years is inevitably going to be "make it more personal". Its awesome that I can ask ChatGPT to write a date comparison function. It'll also be awesome if I could ask Siri "when did sarah and I talk about getting a cat" or something.
That requires personalized data to set the context. If Apple can swing at the fences and say "everything is on-device, nothing leaves, we can't see it, and now you can ask Siri that, and by the way there's new functionality built-in to iOS that apps can leverage to integrate with Siri's new LLM capabilities just like ChatGPT plugins"; that's an extremely compelling product. Extremely. And I know they would ingest that data, that they would do that, because they already do! Go ask Siri to call Sarah, or if you have any meetings tomorrow (assuming you're using Apple Calendar), and it will respond. I don't know where you're getting this take that they don't "hoover data"; they ingest everything from all their first party apps into Siri's `DATA MATRIX`. Its just, you know, 2010s era querying and data crunching.
Don't get me wrong, Google's gonna do a lot of this too. But Google is playing from the position of "we have a model, we have the data, we just need to pay hundreds of millions of dollars a year maintaining all these servers". Apple is playing from the position "our customers are paying us for the silicon to run this, we have the data, we just have to figure out the model". If its not obvious at this point: the models/algorithms/etc are not a moat. They're going to be commoditized with time. Publicly accessible data isn't a moat. Personal data is a moat, because people care about privacy. And cost effective training and inference silicon is a moat, because its Physical, and like literally One Company on the planet makes it, and they're in a big time situationship with Tim Cook.
You dont spawn a network request on every local search on an apple device.
They may not be storing these queries or using them for further analytics, training, etc. But they could.
I got Nvidia on my paper. Did I do the math wrong?
Apple has purchased the entirety of TSMC's 3nm production for the next 1 to 2 years. They can do that, and can continue to do that, because they have a ton of money. They have a ton of money for buying chips because there isn't some crazy business middle-logic justifying the cost of these chips' performance; they buy chips, they sell chips to consumers. In comparison, literally zero other customers of TSMC derive the majority of their hardware revenue from selling to consumers. Companies like Nvidia make some money this way, but most of their money goes to data center sales, which has their own business justification for buying them which fluctuates (ChatGPT subscriptions? training models? is the past model good enough? etc).
We only see the tip of the iceberg so who knows what else it is capable of.
“Sorry, I’m having trouble connecting to the network”
“Now playing Eminem Love the way you lie featuring Rihanna”
Which TV? Bedroom or Living Room or Everywhere?
(Only 1 of the 2 TVs is ever on)
I won’t spam this thread anymore, but I would be pleasantly surprised if it improved.
- Hey Siri, <do something that involves AppleTV in any capacity>.
- I'm sorry, one of your devices is off
Siri: I'm sorry, that contact is not in your list
Me: Siri, what is the number for <my city> Toyota.
Siri: <my city> Toyota's phone number is 123-456-7890 [said too fast to remember or write down in one go]
Me: Siri, call <my city> Toyota
Siri: I'm sorry, you do not have that contact number.
Me: &$@@&/&&/&!!!
I find the worst errors to be when I ask it for information, or to send a text, and it instead places a phone call to someone. It will even call people that I have never called on my phone (a fact it should know), without asking first.
Starting to think all these Siri complaints are either made up or really outdated.
For me, Siri is like an 80s text adventure game, except I was better at those.
Edit: just now I was able to call by interacting a second time with Siri, and using the physical button. Using the button never would have occurred to me while driving.
I should be able to say hey siri, start playing <name of media> on <name of Apple TV>, and it should be able to start the TV and start playing it.
This isn't in response to a prompt either. He'll unpause the connected TV and it'll just start blasting U2.
In case someone doesn’t know they gave that album to all iTunes users as part of a promotional thing when it came out.
On my iPhone if I connect the Bluetooth headset and accidentally push the call/cancel button out comes U2…
done
Perhaps the verb "text" is unclear to Siri?
"Hey Siri, what is today's date?"
"That's sweet, but I think of you as a friend"
"What? The date, Siri, what is the date?"
"You're so sweet"
"Sigh"
Just swipe down on any iPhone.
And seriously, did you really try to assert the Google whatever it is has outperformed Siri? I’d love to meet someone that uses it so I can verify this statement. But with the advent of Chatgpt Alexa, Siri, and Google whatever all look like freshman projects. The next generation of assistants have just begun, and I assure you, the state of the past has nothing to do with what comes next. OpenAI hit a giant reset button across an awful lot of stuff.
Anything outperforms Siri. Google Assistant is head and shoulders above Alexa and Siri.
Do they? I can completely fathom, given my own anecdotal experiences, how garbage Siri quality is today. I haven't built anything against Siri APIs, but I've used Siri and various integrations and every single time I give her a shot, she disappoints me. It can do cookie-cutter, super well-traveled code paths that were engineered together for demos, basically just one off tricks without cohesion, but the whole infrastructure around Siri is not open and has not been improved in any way in many OS versions in any way that I've discerned... But I am not an expert with these systems or APIs.
The Neural Engine architecture especially considering M1/M2 hardware leaps (which are absolutely mind-bogglingly impressive) are both really superb technologies from my layman view as a mere software engineer, with improved battery life as well as performance, a real improvement over Intel x86 architectures - I just don't see Apple as a serious AI player right now, despite head start in AI w/ Siri acq, despite these hardware leaps that may make it easier to do cool stuff in the future like this post. The OCR stuff in Photos is cool and useful and I use it every day, usually to look up my Known Traveler Number.
Ramblings over, just wanted to ask you to opine as to Apple LLM related information if you have any additional context!
a few notes on this
- siri is incredibly underinvested. They have another team that's building some sort of search and natural language processing engine, that has slowly sapped away some key headcount from the siri team.
- apple doesn't get the full advantage of tons of user data from the wild. this is both a bug and a feature
- the siri api model is clearly generations old, and i suspect that apple has been marshaling its resources into a big leap forward - alongside their hand tracking, ar, and hardware
- apple has shipped everything required for you to point at a light /in your house/ to turn it on or off (and optionally flick). this includes software - the individual components are built and ready - the only thing missing is gluing it together
There's something happening, and I think that the rumored glasses are the hardware totem.
You might be right but there’s no real evidence for it yet.
For Siri itself, I think it runs locally now.
that's a mischaracterization of what i said. what i said was that they have been clearly hiring key positions and cannibalizing the siri team for something new. that something new will likely be a major release. i also believe that the ar headset is the unifying product under which they're rallying.
The first proper integration of a Whisper & a GPT-class LM will be a big step change, a Siri-like AI that you can actually talk to somewhat sensibly and expect it to "understand" more than pre-set phrases... Google could be in a position to release something for Android, and their are Android SoCs with neural accelerators as well (sure nothing as impressive as Apple's chips but Samsung have demonstrated a cut-down SD model on their SoC).
Could you expand on this bit? I’m pretty deep in the Apple ecosystem, but I’m not sure what you’re referencing here
Alternatively whole-home mapping via AR also solves this. No triangulation needed.
Everything required for apple to know not only where you are, but which way your hand is pointing, as well as where "smart devices" are in your house is already being sold and rolled out en masse to the majority of people in the ecosystem.
To turn a single lamp on/off by pointing at it, something that nobody ever wants to do (alright, once for the cool factor). If someone wanted to overpay for useless features, they can already go for a Philips Hue.
I can turn off my lamps from anywhere in the world using a $10 Tuta ZigBee bridge and a $8 LIDL light.
I've put zigbee switches into every wall switch in my house and now when I stay in hotels, I forget to turn off the lights before getting into bed.
>something that nobody ever wants to do
I think that this gesture, if it works well, is something that will be a killer app for smarthomes. The other point of friction, which is interop, has been more or less solved by thread/matter. Homepods are $100, btw. Not to mention what happens if apple integrates u1 into a smart switch/bulb, which is something that the thread protocol allows for.
So my prediction would be that apple releases a ZigBee bridge and light for $50 in about 3 years and calls it a fancy name. People will tell you how absolutely essential and innovative it is and how you could never get that without an iDevice.
I remember seeing AirPods in somebody's ears for the first time. "What a dork" I thought back then. Now they're cool and everywhere.
One of these things is true.
AirPods are cool by that measure as well.
I won't buy Meta products but I keep waiting for someone to do VR workspace right - where I can truly work and travel from anywhere with a decent chair and a desk for keyboard (no need to lug around monitors, no need for huge table).
Having said that, for me to spend money on it it would (a) also be able to realistically replace my set up at home, which currently consists of 2 HiDPI screens and (b) not be that much more expensive than what that cost me.
Do you think OpenAI did? Perhaps Apple doesn't have the vast amount of data that Google has, but if OpenAI managed to have like 200 wikipedia-sized corpuses of different textual data for their English GPT models, that's certainly not out of reach of Apple.
Point at it? You mean with a finger? What do you mean they've shipped everything required?
I think this can be a scenario of converging incentives: on one side large models will incentivized hardware manufacturers to increase the memory available on the devices, while on the other sides model developers will be incentivized to trim the fat on the models and devise compression mechanisms that don't compromise quality too much.
It's not unthinkable to imagine a hand held device able to run full inference locally a few device generations in the future.
Note I'm not suggesting you can pack the full knowledgebase of humanity into those 2GB of RAM, but the key feature of an edge AI is simply to understand instructions, something Siri and Ok Google struggle with at best..
Alexa is DIMENSIONS better than Siri. Siri can create a timer ... okay even an alarm. That’s it. It is comically bad. Their text to speech is excellent, but the rest is unbelievable bad.
If Apple has some kind of silver bullet, it’s time to put it out or be left behind.
We’re circling back around to local compute being the default as hardware performance of next gen phones and tablets reaches a “good enough” point for most users.
There will be scientific problems that will require modern server clusters but most consumer facing AI needs will be done on hardware within a decade.
I’m not saying AGI in a decade, I’m saying cutting edge logic embedded in software now will be the basis for logic in chips in the years to come.
I think it's quite likely that Apple realized the same quite a bit earlier and eased up on Siri versus focusing on other things.
I think that the only thing that changed is adoption of fingerprint reader. Both in iPhone 8 and in mac.
AI might be that thing that could tremendously change my usage pattern. But it should be as smart as human assistant. GPT4-level intelligence might have the necessary power for that.
> Do they? I can completely fathom, given my own anecdotal experiences, how garbage Siri quality is today.
Siri is a dead end. When Jobs bought Siri (what, 10 years ago?) he explicitly junked almost all the AI back end, mainly buying the speech recognition engine. I didn't understand why and still don't (but strangely he didn't ask me :-).
John Giannandrea has run Apple's AI effort for the past five or six years. He is the reason Google has a big AI effort (he consolidated a bunch of AI projects and bought Deep Mind, etc) before he decamped for Apple. For all I know the Siri team isn't even part of his remit.
You can never look into Apple (even if you work there) so one can only speculate based on what visible signs appear. But Siri isn't one of them.
Blue Origin still has not reached orbit.
I'm sure he's great but this made me laugh
(And yes he’s a great guy)
If you do that, you can do inference on mobile devices, which is a huge privacy win; it plus into their general privacy positioning in a big way. If you open up that SDK to developers it would be the iOS app gold rush all over again.
Note, Google is also moving in the direction of on-device inference with Coral, but they obviously will want to transmit the personalized model weights back to the mothership.
Ultimately, I'm very reassured that it's Apple and Microsoft leading the way for personal and business AI assistants respectively. As Stratechery has emphasised, the latter not only already has all the data from most firms outside Silicon Valley, but more importantly has always adhered to and designed their software according to a computer-as-a-tool philosophy versus Google's "ML/AI will do everything for you behind the scenes"; the former has not only made a show of data security but invested massively in the hardware architectures necessary to making on-device AI a possibility. Without at all being a "fanboy", Apple is quite literally the only company I would trust my personal data to for use in a GPT-based assistant.
What they have been invested heavily in is the Apple Neural Engine ("ANE"), special silicon right on the SoC to handle ML / AI code. Optimize on a server, then run the model on your iPhone or probably soon, your Apple Watch.
WWDC this year is going to be very, very important.
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/06/amazon-fully-committed-to-al...
I dominated a 13" mbp m1 for like two solid years on hardcore startup software engineering. The base model. It was almost entirely perfect until the last few months when I upgraded to the new 16".
These are alien devices. They're just not possible yet here I am using one.
Apple has decent hw but no LLM software. Unfortunately, in LLM space software changes are the ones driving performance for now, since the space hasn't stabilized yet. Since their competitors control the software, they get to adapt it to their hardware. That is, Google and Microsoft are going to adapt GPT/Bard to Qualcomm ARM etc. while Apple is being ignored. Unless Apple gets in with their own LLM (quite possible), their hw advantage will end up not mattering one bit.
Examples would be the fact that Samsung almost always beats them to the punch on camera technology and other whiz-bang features, but Apple eventually adopts to much mass market consumer acclaim and groans from Android techies. Another example is they’re just now considering touch screen on laptops.
A counter example is the TouchBar - which was “innovative” but many didn’t like.
We must be talking orders of magnitude differences in operational cost, not to mention completely unique features like privacy. The very definition of disruption, waiting in the wings.
Not only that, but this model of 'wait in the wings and pounce when the tech is really there and absolutely nail it' is Apple's forté, aligned completely with the cultural and strategic DNA of the company.