News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by a_shovel on Thursday February 23, 2023 @11:46PM (#34920892)
> This is perhaps the central tragedy of fy_iceworld. The game industry benefits from its legacy, but the conditions that spurred its influence no longer exist. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2019 does not offer a freely downloadable level editor for players to make new custom maps, nor does it allow a decentralized network of player-managed multiplayer servers to distribute these custom maps. We can only play what someone else has decided for us. This climate change has ensured that there will never be another fy_iceworld.

Couldn't agree more. I have a lot of fond memories of playing on stupid custom TF2 maps. In most ways, game development has gotten more accessible by miles over the last few decades, but this is one of a few ways it's gotten less accessible. It's easier than ever to make a full new game, but it's become impossible to make a single simplistic map for an existing shooter that your friends actually play.

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by kapp_in_life on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:01AM (#34920991)
>it's become impossible to make a single simplistic map for an existing shooter that your friends actually play

Counter strike global offensive still has a level editor. Though yeah fewer games nowadays ship with the community servers and mod tools you need to have that kind of organic community. Guess its mostly a problem with the changing monetization strategies where you want to sell microtransaction cosmetics which probably couldn't compete if someone could get whatever goofy modded cosmetics people added to their servers.

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by jamesfinlayson on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:21AM (#34921128)
One of the few that does. I think with Counter-Strike Global Offensive some of the better community maps get bundled up into events and... something gets sold I think? I don't think it's access to the map (because anyone can download the map) but I'm pretty sure players can pay for something.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by Manuel_D on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:40AM (#34921260)
Far cry still ships with level editors. The one in. Far Cry instincts was incredibly cool, especially for the original xbox
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by pongo1231 on Friday February 24, 2023 @10:16AM (#34925279)
It definitely was! I remember toying around with it on my OG Xbox for many hours on end when I was much younger.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by jimbob45 on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:08AM (#34921037)
Not only does it still have a level editor, it also shipped what was, in my opinion, the greatest user-made map[0] to exist within the last decade.

[0]https://counterstrike.fandom.com/wiki/Zoo

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by boywitharupee on Friday February 24, 2023 @09:28AM (#34924793)
Looks like Valve removed it from their official build. Can you still download and privately play this map?
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by jimbob45 on Friday February 24, 2023 @10:44AM (#34925607)
Yep! You just subscribe with the Steam workshop and load it up as a private game.

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=38917...

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by nerdponx on Thursday February 23, 2023 @11:48PM (#34920909)
Urban Terror has a lot of custom maps, but there don't seem to be many players online at any given time, at least not where I have decent ping.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by hackernewds on Thursday February 23, 2023 @11:52PM (#34920938)
Remember Counter Strike was not an independent game. It was a mod of Halo. Halo did not offer a downloaded level editor.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by lagniappe on Thursday February 23, 2023 @11:58PM (#34920972)
> Remember Counter Strike was not an independent game. It was a mod of Halo. Halo did not offer a downloaded level editor.

I thought it was half life

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by dopidopHN on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:21AM (#34921130)
Because it was. I was playing ton of video game at that time and the mod community around half life was really fun and creative.

Science and Industry was a fun mod as well. But yeah I also remember CS ad being at another level right away.

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by emsixteen on Friday February 24, 2023 @02:31AM (#34921952)
Do you remember Wanted? The wild west one? Good craic.

Then there's Ricochet.. :')

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by AlexandrB on Friday February 24, 2023 @08:28AM (#34924255)
The Natural Selection half life mod, and the standalone NS2 are still the best (maybe only?) asymmetric shooter/RTS hybrids I've played.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by dopidopHN on Friday February 24, 2023 @08:54PM (#34932962)
I did not until now haha! But now I do.

Someone else mentioned “natural selection” as well

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by sayhello on Thursday February 23, 2023 @11:54PM (#34920948)
Counter-Strike was a mod of Half Life, not Halo.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by nomad_dude on Thursday February 23, 2023 @11:55PM (#34920952)
Counter-strike was originally a Half-Life mod.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by vlovich123 on Thursday February 23, 2023 @11:54PM (#34920950)
You mean half life right?
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by squeaky-clean on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:44AM (#34921281)
It was Half Life and people typically used QuArK (Quake Army Knife) an open source tool originally made for Quake 1/2 maps, but Half Life used the same map file format. Later along Valve released Hammer, their own level editor.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by robertlagrant on Friday February 24, 2023 @04:28AM (#34922704)
I remember Quark being so revelatory at the time, and also so frustratingly unstable.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by yrro on Friday February 24, 2023 @10:57AM (#34925790)
QuArK, my first introduction to Python scripting. Python 1.5, if I remember correctly...

Gosh, it's still around, and its web site looks identical to how I remember it looking 25 years ago! https://quark.sourceforge.io/

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by renewiltord on Friday February 24, 2023 @01:41AM (#34921608)
And people say ChatGPT bullshits.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by antihero on Friday February 24, 2023 @03:58AM (#34922494)
I did this and showed them and they thought it was great I was doing something with my time that was not fucking about with their network.

Apparently this sort of thing didn’t go down so well in the USA…

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by paczki on Friday February 24, 2023 @01:03AM (#34921401)
Videogames largely moving away from mapping/modding in general has been such a disappointing thing to me for many years now. I'm still playing Doom and Quake mods to this day and some of the content people put out is incredible. Recently an episode 2 for the Quake mod DWELL released and is of unbelievable quality that we couldn't have even imagined playing back in the 90s.

Community servers on the other hand.. those have almost all but vanished completely. It's pretty much just Valve games as far as AAA goes, and even they do their best to hide their server browsers now.

Unfortunately, it just seems like you can't aggressively monetize free content so the industry in general has moved away from allowing it.

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by smrtinsert on Friday February 24, 2023 @01:36AM (#34921571)
The absolute best gaming I've ever done has been on custom servers with highly invested well run admin culture. It is sad to see that gone. This generation has much better single player experiences though, in a insane variety of aesthetics, so maybe that trade off is acceptable.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by taskforcegemini on Friday February 24, 2023 @03:32AM (#34922300)
> This generation has much better single player experiences though, in a insane variety of aesthetics, so maybe that trade off is acceptable.

I wouldn't generalize it like that

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by somenameforme on Friday February 24, 2023 @04:35AM (#34922741)
I think the world you're describing (and GP as well) is largely relegated to consoles. PC gaming has never been more moddable on average. In many cases, this even includes the exact same titles! For instance Bethesda titles on console range from zero to minimal modding, while on PC those exact same games allow complete and unlimited modding, alongside first party tooling support, to the point that you have entire overhauls of the game that scarcely resemble the original available, for free. Some, like Enderal, even get their own big releases. [1]

Basically gaming splintered, hard. So you end up with people, both living and playing games during the exact same time period, having radically different perspectives on the state of gaming. It's really interesting if you draw parallels between this and the state of bubbles within society in general.

[1] - https://store.steampowered.com/app/933480/Enderal_Forgotten_...

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by hobs on Friday February 24, 2023 @07:53AM (#34923968)
It's true that gaming is split, but its not something that happened recently.

Mapping and modding was never generally available to console gamers, and they've traditionally made up the vast majority of game consumers because high end PCs were much more expensive since PC gaming was a thing.

The only stuff you could genuinely expect a home gamer to do is something like cracking your system protection in the ps2+ era or going ham on the GAMESHARK.

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by usrusr on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:23PM (#34926997)
Has it ever been "un-splintered" though? PC and consoles have always been wildly different. The difference is that these days more IP is launched at both markets.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by darreninthenet on Friday February 24, 2023 @05:53AM (#34923205)
A mate and I played for hours on a DukeNukem 3D arena map we found somewhere... I still remember the ballache of getting our modems to dial each other and become connected so the games would see each other
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by jroes on Friday February 24, 2023 @06:21AM (#34923358)
Not sure the industry is moving away from mods universally. You or your kids ever play Roblox?
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by jack_pp on Friday February 24, 2023 @07:48AM (#34923933)
Well let's go by https://steamcharts.com/

CS:GO : allows both custom maps and community servers

Dota : allows custom maps, some of which have created and radically changed existing popular games like auto chess did to Hearthstone.

These two games which are in the top 2 have more hours played than the next 8 games in that ranking.

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by grogenaut on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:16PM (#34926915)
Heck both of those games ARE mods of other games originally... They also both spawned off massive mods and copies themelves. Anyone remember the autochess craze of '18?
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by paczki on Sunday February 26, 2023 @01:23PM (#34947892)
Yeah and it's fantastic that those games still exist and allow things like modding and mapping, however both of those games are a decade old. It does feel somewhat like the trend has died down significantly for newer games, no?

I certainly love them though! I'm still holding out hope for Source 2 SDK and Hammer 2 to actually become a usable tool outside of VR or Dota 2.

Facepunch [0] (Makers of Garry's Mod) are utilizing Source 2 with Valves permission and everything they're working on looks pretty promising, with great potential for a new era of modding.

[0] https://sbox.facepunch.com/news

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by axlee on Friday February 24, 2023 @07:57AM (#34924006)
It still exists, for example Trackmania lives and breathes by its editor and user-made maps. I believe Minecraft (probably the most popular video game in the world) also has a thriving modding culture, but I have never interacted with it.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by jackmott42 on Friday February 24, 2023 @08:38AM (#34924352)
Video games have also moved away from AAA, the bulk of interesting stuff in indie games, where modding is still normal.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by f0e4c2f7 on Friday February 24, 2023 @01:26AM (#34921515)
I have great news if you're willing to play VR games - PavlovVR is pretty much exactly what you're describing here. It has community servers and can be modded with anything you can put in an unreal engine level (so anything)

It's based on CS so it has all the same weapons and mechanics.

It has an active modding community that has added every map from every game you've ever played (including iceworld, but so many more)

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=11392...

I know something will replace it eventually but it has been my all time favorite game for the last 5 years or so.

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by nullandvoid on Friday February 24, 2023 @03:29AM (#34922285)
I'm holding out for s&box hopefully being a return to community driven gaming. Garry has a proven track record of shipping games with big audiences (I've personally sunk way too many hours into both Gmod & Rust), and with source 2 as the engine it's looking pretty graphically stunning.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by paulmd on Friday February 24, 2023 @03:34AM (#34922312)
> I have a lot of fond memories of playing on stupid custom TF2 maps.

typical pl_badwater fan vs average koth_trainsawlaser enjoyer

my guilty pleasure was 32v32 fast spawn on the usual payload and a/d standards. Yes, it is highly spammy and teams generally run multiple combos, and that changes up the tactics a lot. A pair of krubered demos (two combos) can break through (mk V.battlefield.wmv) or you can have a really dynamic playing field with very frequent pops. Multiple sentries are common on defense... but you have the extra stickies. With 32 players actually there is a lot more flexing between classes and a whole class of multi-combo plays that become possible, it is a lot of fun on a pub server where anything can happen.

Custom maps (like that one 32v32 all-custom server) are often balanced better for a larger number of players, but, 32v32 payload was a very fun and intense game format, it's all the fun of pubbing (fun bullshit loadouts because there's lots of room to flex) but just more focused and dynamic.

The late-game balance changes (iron bomber, air strike, parachute, combo pyro nerf, everything) really all made the game worse in the name of "e-sports matchmaking" that never materialized. I would like to go back to the Love and War update plz, but keep the airblast changes and maybe a very few choice others, but that was peak funhaving and then the nerf bat came down for fun and meme loadouts to make the game "good for esports". Give me TF2014 plz.

The decline of the self-hosted instance is tragic, when most of the newer games are gone they're gone. You will never get The Division back or BF1/BFV/2042/etc. Oops server rental program gone. Enjoy ur singleplayer battlefield experience.

Sadly it's also the only way to fight the bot plague, what Valve has allowed to happen to TF2 is disgusting. Can't wait for everyone to migrate to Team Comtress 2.

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by maeln on Friday February 24, 2023 @05:27AM (#34923060)
You can always recognized a TF2 player by how he will write a 5 pages essay about TF2 every time it is mentioned somewhere :P
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by hadlock on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:27PM (#34927044)
TF2 is one of the all-time greats though, it's worth the column inches
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by pongo1231 on Friday February 24, 2023 @10:29AM (#34925427)
>The late-game balance changes (iron bomber, air strike, parachute, combo pyro nerf, everything) really all made the game worse in the name of "e-sports matchmaking" that never materialized. I would like to go back to the Love and War update plz, but keep the airblast changes and maybe a very few choice others, but that was peak funhaving and then the nerf bat came down for fun and meme loadouts to make the game "good for esports". Give me TF2014 plz, nocrits.

Amen. I was playing a lot of pyro around that time, getting really good at the airblast + flare combo. Then the update came around which completed changed airblast physics and nerfed a bunch of stuff (imo needlessly) and I stopped playing regularly shortly afterwards. I still run a couple of servers to this day with third party bots but haven't fired up the game for a couple of years now.

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by jollyllama on Friday February 24, 2023 @10:57AM (#34925786)
The game had already been ruined before 2014. The Mann vs Machine update was not good for the game. Free to play was the end of a lot of social mores that held the game/community together: ex. the backburner was op and nobody used it, if you did, you were ostracized. A month after, the Grordbort update of 2011 was also really bad; the laser weapons were obnoxious and if you had a lower end graphics card, broke the game update for you. Pre 2011 TF2 was completely different, for the better.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by pongo1231 on Friday February 24, 2023 @11:34AM (#34926367)
I personally liked MvM as a cooperative gamemode which added more depth to the classes in the form of upgrades. Easily accumulated a couple of thousand hours just playing that either on boot camp valve servers or community ones with custom maps and plugins (off the top of my head UberUpgrades and Potato come to mind).

Didn't particularly like mann up as a) it costs money for each tour and b) it heavily incentivized you to win by giving you the chance to win a expensive shiny golden gun, which in return made players just develop some meta which they religiously sticked to and vote kick you for deviating from it even a tiny bit, or god forbid making even the slightest mistake. From my experience most players were in it for those items which they could sell for a profit, actual fun be damned.

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by jollyllama on Friday February 24, 2023 @11:54AM (#34926632)
MvM isn't the issue; the other changes, like adding the Sentry Buster, were bad for the existing meta on a lot of other modes without adding anything better.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by paulmd on Friday February 24, 2023 @02:17PM (#34928683)
the sentry buster doesn’t exist outside MVM. Did you mean the caber somehow? Did you not like the caber existing, or it later getting nerfed?

Or please explain what you mean about how an mvm only enemy ruined casual meta somehow(?). I’m confused there

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by jollyllama on Friday February 24, 2023 @03:19PM (#34929539)
Ok, I guess I'm wrong on this count. I'm probably confusing the sentry buster with other anti building weapons.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by paulmd on Friday February 24, 2023 @01:16PM (#34927777)
2011 is about when I started playing (although I have a copy from forever ago that I just never got around to, I have the "proof of purchase" in my inventory!) and yeah I'd definitely agree that f2p was the start of the "fortnite-ization" of tf2 where (what would become known as) casual play started to become the focus. I've heard it described as the "saturday morning cartoons of video games": just a silly little game, tune in next week for more fun. actually literally cartoons in the case of the bimonthly (rip) comics.

Before the proliferation of unlocks the game played a lot tighter as an actual game, let's say pre-2011/2012. 2011/2012 to 2015-ish is the saturday-morning cartoons period.

And I'm not saying either "serious game" or "silly little game" is better or worse, just that there's a bit of a tonal shift between, say, the pyro update and pyromania, right?

2015-2016 is maybe the tail of the cartoon period, that's pre-matchmaking, but also they started to have some bad ideas (iron bomber, parachute, air strike, nerfing combo pyro, etc) that made the game overall worse imo. Just a matter of taste but that's where they started circling the drain in design terms and going after some of the fun meme stuff, then later the e-sports thing came in and ruined it.

I think the irony is that the e-sports game they wanted in 2016 is already there, it's the game they had in 2011. But you can't take away people's unlocks and their hats, the things they'd pivoted to with casual made the pivot back to e-sports a lot more difficult, it's a lot harder to remove weapons from the game even if they don't fit what you're trying to make anymore. At best you can try for the "comp/casual" split (not that the split they ended up doing made any sense - 6v6 with no weapon/class limits? 12v12 with funhaving loadouts nerfed? that's the worst of both worlds) but the comp/casual split fractures the community too.

I think the other part of the problem is it's tragically unhip to have a 2007-vintage arena shooter as your e-sports title in 2016. I've heard the take "musk didn't want to own twitter, he wanted to own a network with twitter's size/reach that works and behaves completely different in every way". And tbh Valve didn't want TF2 to be an e-sports title, they wanted a title with TF2's userbase and reach that played completely differently from the thing they had spent the last 5 years turning it into. And then they took the CS:GO devs and tried to cut away the funny meme stuff and turn it back into a serious e-sports game and now it satisfies neither side.

But anyway yeah I completely get the feeling that TF2011 is a thing that a lot of people would like to play too, before things got too silly and too much about the hats/less about the actual game itself. I just also think that's really the serious e-sports game that Valve really wanted in 2015-2016 and they didn't know it.

Would love to see both TF2011 and TF2014. Hell TF2007/2008 would be funny too, let's have 6-pipe demoman and sentries you can't move (pyro kinda needs airblast though).

(actually the Xbox 360 version is frozen in time, because Valve refused to pay Microsoft to validate updates... it has the very first update because you get one free and welp guess that's it!)

Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by stoltzmann on Saturday February 25, 2023 @03:33AM (#34934973)
tf2classic.com is pretty much TF2008++.
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by splatcollision on Friday February 24, 2023 @03:26PM (#34929623)
As an average scunt main I would to inform you that you are wrong. You say that the pyro nerf was bad. Duck you (politly) pyro is dumb. I hate it when I get spy checked by m1 combo every second stop. Pro play is good game good j_peg #1 pro player, bad water mid, sawmill foeva. Crits make tf2 good I know random crits can be poopy sometimes but it’s funny random crit amazing yes gamim
Re:The legacy of fy_iceworld, Counter-Strike's divisive and ... by paulmd on Friday February 24, 2023 @04:21PM (#34930311)
> As an average scunt main I would to inform you that you are wrong. You say that the pyro nerf was bad. Duck you (politly) pyro is dumb.

average lime scunt main vs typical loch n load enjoyer (oh no I already did that bit)

I loved LnL+sticky+Persian persuader… play with stickies since you have plenty, save the LnL for spamming chokepoints (which is fine since regular GL explodes on impact too) and busting sentries, grind on the engineer’s dead buildings and turn it into three full-health packs.

Wanted more ammo? We had a tool for that: it was called “dying and going back to the respawn room”.

I get that scouts hated LnL but scouts also control the engagement because of higher mobility, everyone used atomizer which gave triple jump even while using another weapon, and you get one more jump than I have shots loaded, plus it’s specifically a “fuck that one class specifically” loadout with a large downside of having to actually hit your shots instead of rollers, and half the ammo loaded. I know that’s a controversial take but LnL was fine imo.

Same for Pyro. He has a flamethrower and a shotgun, if you as a scout choose to run in and force the fight over open terrain against a pyro who knows you're coming... you die. You can still kill him with two meatshots with no chance of response if you flank him unaware, the flare gun moves slow enough you can dodge. To not die to the shortrange juggle class, don't approach the shortrange juggle class with your mobility class. Skill issue, you have a pistol if you really need to plink on him, he either needs to land flares or use the shotgun, you 100% have the control of the engagement at all times right up until you let yourself approach and be juggled.

But yea modern scorch shot is busted, I think that one's just not fun for anyone, I don't feel good about just blind spamming with AOE fire grenades that block a choke for a couple seconds either. Not sure the current weapon design is saveable for that one, I run it too when I play pyro (because all the rest of pyro's combos have been stripped away) but it's basically a better version of the detonator in the sense of being horrifically annoying to play against for zero effort on the pyro's part. On the other hand, it also forces snipers to at least occasionally engage with the rest of the playing field.

The two I’m really torn on are rescue ranger and short circuit. Short circuit used to be actually fairly important for clearing stickies/etc, I’d use it plenty myself on offense pushing out of the gates etc, even as a demo main I felt it was reasonable (up until you got like three of them just vaporizing everything while they repair or rescue ranger). It went through a number of variations and I’m not sure any of them felt super great but it also did something kinda important and the class is otherwise very weak offensively (except for other unpopular weapons like mini sentry). Not that I like a couple turtled up engies vaporizing my shit but like, uber a heavy or a couple snipers with charged machinas to alpha-strike it, 2 charged shots on a sentry is instadeath even if they're swinging wrenches. That was always the charm of “silly little game” TF2, no matter how fucking lame a given strat was there was always something you could do to break it with an even sillier strategy.

Until the vaccinator came along that is. Like god it was decent to start with and was just buffed incessantly in the last few years. Oh you can trivially swap resists to block any class/loadout variation made to counter you, even pop multiple resists at a time, and oh also the charges now follow the patient so you don't even need to keep healing them? Yea just keep buffing it that's great /s. Meanwhile quickfix was done dirty, airblast immunity on uber was a situational strat for pushing on ramps (thundermountain, upward, etc) and you were vulnerable to damage to offset that, just shoot them till they die (damage, my one weakness!). That was fine, what was the problem?

Rescue ranger is another tough one to balance. I kinda feel like you shouldn’t be able to run both Short Circuit and RR together, that’s maybe a little too much mobility and tankiness for sentries especially when you have a couple engies. Forcing engineers to commit to the nest or walk the sentry out by hand is not a bad thing imo. Maybe that's a thing like the Equalizer where it really should be two weapons - the "repair gun" and the "teleport the sentry" gun... or just not have teleporting sentries.

Iron bomber should not have existed though, non rolling rollers are not a good gameplay idea, but whatever. Same with air strike and the parachute… not great.

But that’s what I mean is all of the worst decisions came in the last few years of TF2 development. Jungle Inferno was 2017 and the last few years of decisions before that were already downhill. 2014-2015 is pretty much the apex of “silly little game” TF2.