If you want my opinion, though, it's easy with the benefit of hindsight to say they shouldn't have. But some industries were, in fact, thrown several years into the future and there wasn't a compelling reason at that time to assume they'd just fall back as things returned to normal. Others should probably have reasonably expected growth to slow down (or reverse) as people could get out in the world again. I don't think there's one broad answer to the market overall.
Frankly, it's a little odd to me that we would expect companies to just be able to weather whatever the economy throws at them with no changes needed. Companies fail. They grow, they then shed headcount. Sometimes its right, sometimes its wrong. But I'm not sure how we could ever live in a society where there could be a complete upheaval to entire industries over a single quarter, and then again 2 years later back in the other direction, and everyone trucks on like nothing happened.
When running a business, you can be entirely reasonable to invest in something you think is unlikely to actually happen if the potential reward time the chance is greater than the cost.
If you strip away all the bad armchair economics, I think what people are really upset about is the idea that gambling with people's jobs is an acceptable cost.
The real question is "should we tolerate shedding jobs" and it's an interesting question. Without stating a personal opinion on the matter, it's interesting to think about how drastically this would shift the economic structure of the nation if the answer was "no"
Yes, they all egregiously failed. A massive, widespread, collective failure for which they should lose their jobs, as many other people do. On the face of it, it was obvious, that's not even hindsight bias - it was the topsy turvy world that bad news meant good news for stocks and S&P 500 CEOs that persisted for nigh on 15 years that was weird and had to end sooner rather than later.
If it was obvious, then the market would have priced it in.
But it didn't. So the crowdsourced collective wisdom was indeed that industries were leaping 5-10 years into the future overnight. That was the thing that was "obvious" to most people.
You may have disagreed at the time, and if you'd shorted stocks you could have made some money. But the idea that "on the face of it, it was obvious" is blatantly untrue. You're able to say this only with the gift of hindsight.
Bubbles don’t exist? I’m sorry, but to paraphrase an old quote, the market’s can remain irrational, longer than your faith in a rational market.
I don't really understand the obvious claim. If it was obvious to investors and executives then what? They knowingly spent money they knew was a waste?
then, with that ton of money, they could buy enough shares to influence the board to implement their agenda.
in theory, this would quantify the definition of "obvious".
Ultimately CEOs of large companies are paid tons of money to be the person responsible for the company direction, so holding them responsible for making a wrong decision is fine. Just wanted to say that while hindsight is 20/20, it’s not necessarily the case that it was a poor decision in the moment when sometimes you have to play the odds.
These hypotheticals are way too favorable towards all of the non-Apple tech companies that gorged themselves during the irrational exuberance of the past two years. Since when was Google or Meta in danger of being outcompeted by a rival company who overhired to eat their lunch, rather than by their own mistakes? Were all of these overhired personnel really being put on vital projects necessary for the survival of these companies?
Perhaps some companies this analysis held true. But in most cases it seems just like a reactionary keeping up with the Joneses overhiring spree. Companies saw others doing it, and they imitated, not out of some sound financial policy.
Moreover, it doesn't pay to be a hero on Wall Street. Like you hint at here, it's much safer to go with the crowd and be wrong than to go against the crowd and be wrong. That's just a fact of life in business.
Look, right now market is pricing in a soft landing and FED reversing the fiscal policy in the second half of the year, which is highly unlikely (i.e. "obviously" not going to happen). Yes, there are several people pointing this out. No, I'm not selling my (imaginary) house to short stocks and make some money from it.
People disagree all the time. That's fine. But to insist that your viewpoint is "obvious" while the majority of people putting their money where their mouth is are obviously wrong... well, that strikes me as a lot of hubris.
I think a lot of things are probably much less "obvious" than you believe.
You could just let the puts expire and have capped losses, but that feels like another form of the market staying irrational to your loss
Hard to prove, but as a data point: I tried to.
I just couldn't figure out how, access to that kind of banking is more difficult in Sweden, especially if you don't speak Swedish.
I have IRC logs of that period though, since I asked around on how to do that.
Just to say: it was quite obvious in my circles.
I am all for thoughtful discussions on how tech CEOs could be held responsible outside of empty mea culpas in blog posts, but "they should lose their jobs" feels like cutting off the nose to spite the face. Does ousting a CEO really help the company, or the workers who didn't get laid off? And where does the line get drawn? % of layoffs or absolute number of layoffs? How does the absolute size of a company get factored in?
If one or two CEOs got it wrong, you could argue that they were incompetent, ignorant, or greedy and they should have been better informed because plenty of other CEOs were. Everyone getting something wrong says to me that the failure wasn't down to individual mistakes and there was something larger at play.
If you want to see a real leader, look at Tim Cook. He made decisions based specifically on where the company is, where it's going, and already factored in external factors (such as the pandemic growth). Contrast this to dozens of other "CEO"s who made a horrible decision hastily, executed layoffs horribly wrong, and then vaguely blamed a pandemic. The exact same lazy gameplan because these CEOs cannot lead, might as well replace them with chatgpt, maybe they'll write better layoff emails.
As a reminder, the CEOs core role is to steer the company. When that ship slams into an iceberg, you have failed your core role. What happens when workers fail their core role?
If Apple failed to plan for a huge economic event that let competitors gain some ground, they can survive that misstep because they have such a huge moat. Conversely, if Apple did over-hire, they can also survive that climate due to their size and stay the course while others falter.
If you're captaining an ocean liner (Apple) you don't worry too much about 5-10' seas and 10 knots of wind. If you're captaining a 50' yacht (eg. all the mid-sized SaaS businesses announcing layoffs) you definitely pay attention to that sea state.
> When that ship slams into an iceberg, you have failed your core role.
I agree with your line of thinking, but I don't think any of these companies failed in their core role. Looking at the FAANG companies, stock prices are down a bit, but none of these companies are on the verge of collapse and all are still market leaders in their respective areas.
Hell, for all we know, this could have been the plan all along. Hire a bunch of people while interest rates are low and let them all go when interest rates go back up. I realize that layoffs are not a good thing and they affect real people, but the reality is that they are not a sign that a CEO is failing in their core role.
> What happens when workers fail their core role?
It depends... If I've got one employee on my team who continually fucks up our deploy process causing outages. Yeah, they probably need to be fired. If every developer on my team fucks up our deploy process causing outages, then issue is probably that our deploy process is bad and firing people isn't going to fix anything.
Which brings me back to my original point.
You've completely missed the point of my analogy. If you compare everyone else the the person who is the best in the category, then everyone else will pale in comparison. Using "You're not as good as The Best" as a reason to fire someone is stupid since there's only one person who can live up to that bar.
I'd much rather eliminate scarcity and the need for people to have a job to provide their basic needs. Accomplishing that is even more difficult though
It's like if someone asked you to open a car dealership in a town you knew nothing about. The safest thing to do is just pick the area where all the other dealerships already are. You don't gain a competitive from doing that, but you also ensure they don't either.
It's not the ideal strategy, but doing what everyone else is doing so you don't fall behind makes the most sense some times.
> You don't gain a competitive from doing that, but you also ensure they don't either.
In fact, you may gain a competitive advantage from doing the opposite of the herd if the herd is about to run off a cliff.
My point is that we only know it was a bad decision after the fact.
The economy is incredibly complex and anyone who tells you they can consistently predict what comes next is lying to you or lying to themselves. Even experts who dedicate their lives to studying economics get things wrong regularly. Calling for a CEOs head because they failed to predict something that pretty much everyone of their competitors also got wrong seems stupid.
But the point is when everyone gets something wrong, there should be time for at least reflection and steps to remediate such a mistake from happening again in the future. Just saying the "economy is complex" is no excuse. If anything, it is defeatism.
I agree with you there, but when almost the entire industry got something wrong, I don't firing your CEO does anything to prevent that mistake from happening again. If you ask yourself, would it be reasonable to believe another person would have done better in this situation, I don't think the answer can be "yes" when pretty much everyone got it wrong.
Only bad companies fire people for taking risks and failing. Good companies reward that behavior if the risk was reasonable and the learnings were positive. They fire people who take unnecessary risk.
Hiring into the pandemic was a good risk in my opinion.
Sure, and then you lay people off when that correction comes in. In the meantime you're hiring the best people and having them do great work. And when they layoffs come, maybe some of them stay.
> All of those food delivery apps, at the very least, could not expect exponential growth once restaurants opened again.
Sure, but if they didn't build market share during the pandemic, they would never catch up afterwards.
When the market is on fire, you need to ride the rocket. You always know that you have layoffs in your back pocket for when the market cools.
It's not like these layoffs should be a surprise to anyone -- it happens after every hot market. Sure it absolutely sucks for those that are affected by it, I know because it happened to me in 2001. Barely got through it. But it's not a big surprise.
But 1) it seems rather disingenuous for companies to posture one way and then pull the rug under their workforce who are being sacrificed in the name of a cooling market, and 2) perhaps companies should consider other ways to pursue profitability without massive layoff sprees?
Talk about screwing up in engineering contexts and suddenly the tune changes: now people will talk about improving processes, blameless postmortems, and how the individual is not at fault.
Imagine a youtuber saying googlers should be fired because some decision was made that affected the youtuber's income negatively. Or imagine an Uber driver saying that. Or a small business owner dealing w/ a Stripe mishap or whatever. If you are the one being targeted by these calls for loss of employment, then comes out the "I'm not the responsible person here" card.
So on the one hand, you hear people with pitchforks about how CEOs or whoever need to take responsibility in some movie-esque "bad guy ending" fashion, but turn the tables and nobody wants to step up to be responsible for their own shit shows.
Even if we entertain the idea of firing CEOs, is the implicit assumption that companies can run fine without one? By that logic, anyone could just give a bunch of money to a bunch of fiverr code monkeys and that business would run just fine? I don't really get what the logical conclusion of this whole line of argument is supposed to be.
That makes me wonder why investors, particularly activist shareholders who drive the direction of boards, are never under scrutiny. Maybe their decisions to chase unrealistic growth, which forces the hands of CEOs and lesser executives, should also be reviewed. Maybe they should be somehow penalized or sanctioned for driving companies towards failure. Shouldn't a massive event like mass layoffs trigger a change in corporate boards? Why shouldn't responsibility go all the way to the top, why stop at the CEO level?
Sometimes the best way to do that is to invest in a business, other times it’s to buy other assets, and other times cash is king.
Lastly, they are only involved because the shareholders of said companies involved them. Going public is not mandatory.
I’ve seen lots of public post mortems for engineering screw ups. Can you point me to a Fortune 500 public post mortem for a bad acquisition or something else CEO driven?
An operational mistake by a SWE might be something like picking the wrong technology, and for a CEO, an operational mistake might be something like a bad acquisition. Just as a technology is a tool for the dev, an acquisition is a tool for the CEO. Both of these are examples of getting bad outcomes from their tool usage decisions, but they're still categorically operational mistakes, as opposed to gross misconduct.
So my two cents is that if one wants to argue that operational mistakes categorically warrant firing personnel, then yeah, I think I'm gonna have a problem with that line of thinking.
This is bullshit. An earnings call is nothing like an engineering post mortem for an outage. There’s zero introspection or root causing.
It’s typical Silicon Valley style hypocrisy, where founders and CEOs claim there’s a certain company culture but never walk the walk themselves.
Give me a NY bank any day. At least they aren’t constantly blowing smoke up employees’ asses. Everyone knows the score.
You mean unlike the Experian breach post mortem, or the numerous "everything is green" Slack outages? IMHO, Costco talking about container costs is introspection. I'll grant that taking analogies too literally does indeed lead one to conclude the other party's arguments are bullshit, but I think that's just a matter of perspective and unwillingness to engage in good faith discussions.
The same is true for directors and CEOs.
Do you want golden parachutes?
This is how you get these.
I reject these defeatist attitudes and question the engineering skills of anyone who thinks this way.
It is always better to try something. Human created systems are inherently problematic and do not fix themselves.
The dream is to engineer a system that does not have faults.
Some exceptions are perhaps Valve. Most other companies try to make a change at the margins and even that is heralded as a great innovation but generally fails to get adopted widely.
So why not speed up the process and at least cut the suffering from thousands of lives and skip the step when those risk-takers inevitably fuck up and overhire? Let all companies be boring cash cows after the initial stage, might even improve innovation from smaller players.
I vote for punish the CEOs.
When an individual engineer screws up, if the processes in place are working correctly, that screwup should only cost some time and possibly a bit of money—most likely within an order of magnitude of a few days and $100. This is why we have processes in place: because people are fallible, and it's not good to give any one person that much power.
When a CEO screws up, there's no one to catch that screwup. The buck stops there. So many of these companies are structured specifically to give the CEO some significant degree of autocratic power—the power to say "this is what we will be doing, because I say so", whether or not they have other justifications backing them up—and now that we're saying, "Hey, that kind of power is supposed to come with accountability," you try to tell us they shouldn't?
As for "companies can run fine without one," I'd say that's a very useful hypothesis to test. But your strawman of "give a bunch of money to people on fiverr" isn't the logical way to test it: it's "set up a system with democratic processes in place, create a management committee, possibly with a rotating chairship, and in general give the employees more say over the direction of the company they work for".
this sounds very similar to a government where politicians are elected (un)fairly. likely, this just presents another set of trade-offs.
However, over the past few hundred years, we've been gradually coming to the collective conclusion that autocracy is inferior to democracy for systems involving larger numbers of people and decisions of larger stakes.
I don't see why that should apply any less to replacing the hierarchical model of companies, where a CEO can walk into any room and say "You're fired," with a (more-)democratic system, than it did to replacing kingdoms, where a king could walk into any room and say "Off with your head," with a representative democracy.
Not really clear that corporations that stay autocratic do much better. As with kingdoms that turn into sprawling empires, all you're left is a bunch of middle management petty kings who the CEO-emperor delegates power to, who might not be much better. Bureaucratic rot sets in.
The market now is demanding flesh and CEOs are either expected to provide it, or else get fired. Just like in the former time period, they would get fired had they not shown growth. I personally do not think a CEO should be fired now for having to hire employees, when they would have been fired in the first place had they not rapidly hired.
Success isn't measured from the employee perspective.
Everyone here calling for their heads is using the wrong measuring stick.
By extension -- who doesn't hold the ceo responsible? The court of public opinion, which is what all of these comments and articles spilling barrels of ink on this issue think should be the case, but is not actually the case (and for obviously good reasons). A company is not a democracy (again, for obviously good reasons).
On the other hand, these debates seem quite one sided. The boards of these companies aren't firing their CEOs. Why aren't any of the op-ed authors curious enough to ask about this? This author literally links to another one of his own op-eds in order to dismiss any such arguments about whether or not this is pertinent! They've clearly already made up their minds on this point.
Or is the real point not to have a debate, but to get people riled up and indignant about something that will always have bad optics (even when it's necessary)?
What happens if the COVID lockdown demand surge happens and companies don’t hire?
Customers don’t get what they want. Businesses that want to move online can’t or have a worse experience. The companies themselves are under-resourced for the actual demand and can’t invest in the future of their business because they’re struggling to keep the lights on.
I understand people are pissed about layoffs. Entirely reasonable, and as someone laid off I can empathize. But at the same time, COVID was kind of a black swan event. No one know what would happen and companies made their best guesses. Many were wrong! And that’s fine.
For public companies, there was public information about their strategies and the bets they were taking. For private companies, it probably depends on what they’d share during hiring. I knew going into Stripe in January 2022 what their bets were, my confidence level in leadership, and my personal risk tolerance for an uncertain future.
We shouldn’t be ripping companies apart when they’re wrong. At least not with over-hiring that had a plausible justification behind it. I don’t want to work for a CEO who doesn’t take risks. I don’t believe that’s better for the world.
But, the bigger issue is, knowing that you should give this to contractors would have required the same foresight that would lead to you not hiring anyway. In other words, if you knew enough to know that you shouldn't hire full time people because you might lay them off, then you probably knew enough to not do this in the first place...so you wouldn't have to let anyone go.
As soon as they start looking for people and offering salaries starting at 150k, tens of thousands will jump straight in.
I imagine one of the selling points of recruiters was we haven't had layoffs.
I call bullshit. If you did you'd quit in shame.
The issue I have is with broad strokes generalizations that layoffs indicate a failure of a CEO. They don't necessarily mean that. Any more than shipping a bug to production indicates a failure of an engineer who should now be fired. Similarly, not laying people off is not an indicator of success. Nor is not shipping a bug to production.
The question is not "can we predict the future," but rather "did we do the right things to capture the right data to make the best decision" and if the answer to that question is yes - then any other reasonable person in the same position would likely have made a similar (if not the same) choice, and it's not clear what firing anyone does besides being punitive. Again, same for any employee that makes a mistake. This is not me giving a free pass to CEOs.
As the markets clearly priced in during the pandemic, this was the best prediction of the future. As measured not just by the CEO, but the response of consumers and the public markets. You would be hard-pressed, without the benefit of today's hindsight, to make a reasonable argument for why this wasn't the right decision to make based on the data in front of you.
I think it's reasonable to argue that Apple's CEO made the better decision, as opposed to the "obvious" one.
Fine. But that’s not the CEO “taking responsibility”, it’s the employees who fall on the sword who take responsibility.
If I build your house out of wood and it burns down, and I say I will “take responsibility” while doing nothing while you have to buy a new house, I’m not really taking responsibility am I?
I think level of responsibility for CEO should be different compared to regular employees. They get paid fuck you money and never need to work again afterwards.
There was a thread about google layoffs recently where people discussed L9s being laid off and how such people are expected to "redefine the industry" every year and walk on water in general. Yet, somehow the responsibility that seems to increase exponentially with level goes to almost junior level "oopsie couldn't predict what would happen after covid when free money stop flowing, no biggie I guess, let's just fire all these people we have hired during previous two years" for execs. It seems that the only way for them to get fired is if one of employees they sexually harassed talks and even then they get golden parachute.
Now if they hired those people by saying "well he hire for the quarter so you know bad quarter your probably gone."
No they made big statements about how they hire for the long term.
I think where this is really stemming from is that these market swings hurt people, and those being hurt feel the CEO should share in that. And there is merit to that argument, that austerity measures should impact CEOs and upper management just like they do the lower ranks, regardless of fault. These people are in a better financial position to weather the swings. Their compensation has a lot more margin or "fat" to cut into before it becomes painful, and thus can save a number of jobs that might otherwise have to be cut. Most importantly it shows solidarity with the workforce. It makes it feel more like this is an external event that is happening to us, not something that the CEO is inflicting on the staff.
I'll definitely dig into this take further!
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34740322
Those companies expected a major societal event to become the new normal without strong data to support it, and chased growth that was not going to be sustained.
This can be simplified to market reading. People in finance get fired for getting this wrong all the time. Michael Burry was told investors lacked confidence in his ability to read markets and was on the brink of divestiture during his short.
I think it's fair to say that's what we pay CEOs the big bucks to do, and if they fail to do it it's fair we ask for ramifications. I'm more startled by the comments who would like to preserve someone who makes millions, is already set for life, and often displays an inability to relate to the front line workers they're supposed to represent.
Should a CEO be allowed to get calls wrong, sure. Should they get paid 200 million when they do? No. Should they get paid 200 million ever? No.
Shareholders should be suing every company that does this until it stops, imho.
Plenty of people in the USA would argue that $200k is a bad number: those overpaid software developers with their share incentives need to be stopped /s. Shareholders should revolt against those rich software developers?
> It is absolutely a ruling class leeching off society that this happens
I mean, the same argument can be made for US tech companies leeching off the world (or just leeching off USA citizens if you wish to be parochial).
A relevant simple thought experiment: what would you do if you won lotto?
Of course they should. Hiring a few, strategic, expert developers at those rates might make sense. However, paying 200k+ for a newly graduated student with no experience should have been questioned firmly.
This kind of turnaround also happened at Barnes & Noble, all due to one man - the CEO, James Daunt.
https://tedgioia.substack.com/p/what-can-we-learn-from-barne...
CEOs get paid a lot because they are crucial to the success (or failure) of a company. Yes, they did build it.
Instead of complaining about executives earning so much, why don't we find ways for you and I to emulate their bargaining power instead?
When you say CEO compensation isn't tied to supply and demand, what data do have to support that? We pay football/basketball/baseball players well more than 1M dollars. Do you think the impact between a good and mediocre CEO for a large company is less than 1M? Even tiny drops in performance due to decisions at the CEO level would cost millions at the biggest companies. As companies scale larger, bad decisions will cost more and more. I think a rationale case can be made that many of these CEOs are generating more value than they cost in compensation.
You don't need to be paid a +$200M salary to know that pandemics end.
And now these same people have the audacity to bitch that the very employers they've been strategically milking with their Machiavellian labor market plays would realize their mistake.
No. Full stop. To these people I say:
You've been paid $300-400k in total comp for a decade to build platforms that have DEGRADED the society we live in. You have extracted maximum rents from a job market that favored you, to provide NEGATIVE value to society, all while looking down your nose at lowly plumbers, carpenters, and those subhumans in flyover country who grow your food, mine your copper, and produce your electricity. Now the job market no longer favors you, and you, of course, regard this as the fault of everyone else. Fuck off. Fuck right off, right now.
If this were true, should not companies hire now, thinking long term, like Google did in the last crisis circa 2008?
It looks like most companies hire or fire not for today, but for next quarter.
They are not doing the strategic long-term thinking here but optimize for short-term results.
This sounds like what you said it wasnt, "hiring for today."
It's not like Google/Meta/Microsoft were barely hanging on by a thread just able to get through their core workload before COVID hit. They didn't need another 10,000 employees to get through today. They needed (or, incorrectly, thought they did) them to support where the business would be going in the years ahead.
What you’re missing here is that it’s their job to be correct.
Covid was, perhaps, unpredictable but the end of Covid wasn’t.
Of course, accurately predicting the future is very difficult but these are the highest paid people in the entire world. They should be able to do very difficult things to dramatically help their businesses, that’s why they make the big bucks. If they aren’t performing they should be replaced by someone better. Otherwise what we have is cronyism and not capitalism.
I guess the question is whether leadership could have anticipated a retraction of the economy just a few years later. But this made me think of another question. How much job security can we reasonably expect in the first place? If we want jobs to be secure, then that needs to be legislated or people need to unionize (and take the pay cut). I'm aware that I have no say in how the business is run and I can basically be let go either anytime or within a short time and I need to prepare myself for that.
This is the kicker for me. C-levels assuming that a once-in-a-lifetime pandemic leading to online growth would sustain for the next decade. They should make 10Y plans, not 1Q based ones.
In other words, when COVID hit and tech companies saw large surges because investors and CEOs saw industries leaping 5-10 years into the future overnight, they hired to support that growth. As the market has shifted and inflation combined with an end to the public health emergency has tempered growth expectations, investors and CEOs cut head count to match.
It sucks, and I'm not saying this is how it should be to those people who are impacted. But if you wait until the world is already where you thought it might be before you react and start building for that world, you're behind. Whether or not CEOs should be punished for getting the call wrong is what this post is about, but getting the call wrong sometimes is expected/necessary if you want to have a chance of getting it right.