That makes me wonder why investors, particularly activist shareholders who drive the direction of boards, are never under scrutiny. Maybe their decisions to chase unrealistic growth, which forces the hands of CEOs and lesser executives, should also be reviewed. Maybe they should be somehow penalized or sanctioned for driving companies towards failure. Shouldn't a massive event like mass layoffs trigger a change in corporate boards? Why shouldn't responsibility go all the way to the top, why stop at the CEO level?
Sometimes the best way to do that is to invest in a business, other times it’s to buy other assets, and other times cash is king.
Lastly, they are only involved because the shareholders of said companies involved them. Going public is not mandatory.
I’ve seen lots of public post mortems for engineering screw ups. Can you point me to a Fortune 500 public post mortem for a bad acquisition or something else CEO driven?
An operational mistake by a SWE might be something like picking the wrong technology, and for a CEO, an operational mistake might be something like a bad acquisition. Just as a technology is a tool for the dev, an acquisition is a tool for the CEO. Both of these are examples of getting bad outcomes from their tool usage decisions, but they're still categorically operational mistakes, as opposed to gross misconduct.
So my two cents is that if one wants to argue that operational mistakes categorically warrant firing personnel, then yeah, I think I'm gonna have a problem with that line of thinking.
This is bullshit. An earnings call is nothing like an engineering post mortem for an outage. There’s zero introspection or root causing.
It’s typical Silicon Valley style hypocrisy, where founders and CEOs claim there’s a certain company culture but never walk the walk themselves.
Give me a NY bank any day. At least they aren’t constantly blowing smoke up employees’ asses. Everyone knows the score.
You mean unlike the Experian breach post mortem, or the numerous "everything is green" Slack outages? IMHO, Costco talking about container costs is introspection. I'll grant that taking analogies too literally does indeed lead one to conclude the other party's arguments are bullshit, but I think that's just a matter of perspective and unwillingness to engage in good faith discussions.
The same is true for directors and CEOs.
Do you want golden parachutes?
This is how you get these.
I reject these defeatist attitudes and question the engineering skills of anyone who thinks this way.
It is always better to try something. Human created systems are inherently problematic and do not fix themselves.
The dream is to engineer a system that does not have faults.
Some exceptions are perhaps Valve. Most other companies try to make a change at the margins and even that is heralded as a great innovation but generally fails to get adopted widely.
So why not speed up the process and at least cut the suffering from thousands of lives and skip the step when those risk-takers inevitably fuck up and overhire? Let all companies be boring cash cows after the initial stage, might even improve innovation from smaller players.
I vote for punish the CEOs.
When an individual engineer screws up, if the processes in place are working correctly, that screwup should only cost some time and possibly a bit of money—most likely within an order of magnitude of a few days and $100. This is why we have processes in place: because people are fallible, and it's not good to give any one person that much power.
When a CEO screws up, there's no one to catch that screwup. The buck stops there. So many of these companies are structured specifically to give the CEO some significant degree of autocratic power—the power to say "this is what we will be doing, because I say so", whether or not they have other justifications backing them up—and now that we're saying, "Hey, that kind of power is supposed to come with accountability," you try to tell us they shouldn't?
As for "companies can run fine without one," I'd say that's a very useful hypothesis to test. But your strawman of "give a bunch of money to people on fiverr" isn't the logical way to test it: it's "set up a system with democratic processes in place, create a management committee, possibly with a rotating chairship, and in general give the employees more say over the direction of the company they work for".
this sounds very similar to a government where politicians are elected (un)fairly. likely, this just presents another set of trade-offs.
However, over the past few hundred years, we've been gradually coming to the collective conclusion that autocracy is inferior to democracy for systems involving larger numbers of people and decisions of larger stakes.
I don't see why that should apply any less to replacing the hierarchical model of companies, where a CEO can walk into any room and say "You're fired," with a (more-)democratic system, than it did to replacing kingdoms, where a king could walk into any room and say "Off with your head," with a representative democracy.
Not really clear that corporations that stay autocratic do much better. As with kingdoms that turn into sprawling empires, all you're left is a bunch of middle management petty kings who the CEO-emperor delegates power to, who might not be much better. Bureaucratic rot sets in.
Talk about screwing up in engineering contexts and suddenly the tune changes: now people will talk about improving processes, blameless postmortems, and how the individual is not at fault.
Imagine a youtuber saying googlers should be fired because some decision was made that affected the youtuber's income negatively. Or imagine an Uber driver saying that. Or a small business owner dealing w/ a Stripe mishap or whatever. If you are the one being targeted by these calls for loss of employment, then comes out the "I'm not the responsible person here" card.
So on the one hand, you hear people with pitchforks about how CEOs or whoever need to take responsibility in some movie-esque "bad guy ending" fashion, but turn the tables and nobody wants to step up to be responsible for their own shit shows.
Even if we entertain the idea of firing CEOs, is the implicit assumption that companies can run fine without one? By that logic, anyone could just give a bunch of money to a bunch of fiverr code monkeys and that business would run just fine? I don't really get what the logical conclusion of this whole line of argument is supposed to be.