If you want to see a real leader, look at Tim Cook. He made decisions based specifically on where the company is, where it's going, and already factored in external factors (such as the pandemic growth). Contrast this to dozens of other "CEO"s who made a horrible decision hastily, executed layoffs horribly wrong, and then vaguely blamed a pandemic. The exact same lazy gameplan because these CEOs cannot lead, might as well replace them with chatgpt, maybe they'll write better layoff emails.
As a reminder, the CEOs core role is to steer the company. When that ship slams into an iceberg, you have failed your core role. What happens when workers fail their core role?
If Apple failed to plan for a huge economic event that let competitors gain some ground, they can survive that misstep because they have such a huge moat. Conversely, if Apple did over-hire, they can also survive that climate due to their size and stay the course while others falter.
If you're captaining an ocean liner (Apple) you don't worry too much about 5-10' seas and 10 knots of wind. If you're captaining a 50' yacht (eg. all the mid-sized SaaS businesses announcing layoffs) you definitely pay attention to that sea state.
> When that ship slams into an iceberg, you have failed your core role.
I agree with your line of thinking, but I don't think any of these companies failed in their core role. Looking at the FAANG companies, stock prices are down a bit, but none of these companies are on the verge of collapse and all are still market leaders in their respective areas.
Hell, for all we know, this could have been the plan all along. Hire a bunch of people while interest rates are low and let them all go when interest rates go back up. I realize that layoffs are not a good thing and they affect real people, but the reality is that they are not a sign that a CEO is failing in their core role.
> What happens when workers fail their core role?
It depends... If I've got one employee on my team who continually fucks up our deploy process causing outages. Yeah, they probably need to be fired. If every developer on my team fucks up our deploy process causing outages, then issue is probably that our deploy process is bad and firing people isn't going to fix anything.
Which brings me back to my original point.
You've completely missed the point of my analogy. If you compare everyone else the the person who is the best in the category, then everyone else will pale in comparison. Using "You're not as good as The Best" as a reason to fire someone is stupid since there's only one person who can live up to that bar.
I'd much rather eliminate scarcity and the need for people to have a job to provide their basic needs. Accomplishing that is even more difficult though
It's like if someone asked you to open a car dealership in a town you knew nothing about. The safest thing to do is just pick the area where all the other dealerships already are. You don't gain a competitive from doing that, but you also ensure they don't either.
It's not the ideal strategy, but doing what everyone else is doing so you don't fall behind makes the most sense some times.
> You don't gain a competitive from doing that, but you also ensure they don't either.
In fact, you may gain a competitive advantage from doing the opposite of the herd if the herd is about to run off a cliff.
My point is that we only know it was a bad decision after the fact.
The economy is incredibly complex and anyone who tells you they can consistently predict what comes next is lying to you or lying to themselves. Even experts who dedicate their lives to studying economics get things wrong regularly. Calling for a CEOs head because they failed to predict something that pretty much everyone of their competitors also got wrong seems stupid.
But the point is when everyone gets something wrong, there should be time for at least reflection and steps to remediate such a mistake from happening again in the future. Just saying the "economy is complex" is no excuse. If anything, it is defeatism.
I agree with you there, but when almost the entire industry got something wrong, I don't firing your CEO does anything to prevent that mistake from happening again. If you ask yourself, would it be reasonable to believe another person would have done better in this situation, I don't think the answer can be "yes" when pretty much everyone got it wrong.
If one or two CEOs got it wrong, you could argue that they were incompetent, ignorant, or greedy and they should have been better informed because plenty of other CEOs were. Everyone getting something wrong says to me that the failure wasn't down to individual mistakes and there was something larger at play.