News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by droptablemain on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:30AM (#34442128)
Breaking story: website uses Google Analytics like 95% of other websites.

Why is this even a story?

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by tonywebster on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:36AM (#34442216)
I think bringing attention to common practices putting people in jeopardy is a good thing, because it’s likely website operators and the general public don’t think about these risks. If data is collected, it can be used by police and prosecutors. Ignoring the problem because everyone knows about analytics does not start necessary conversations. Google has increasingly been a target for law enforcement investigations, and the search warrants Google receives can be as broad as compelling Google to turn over data on the accounts or IP addresses of anyone who Googled someone’s name.[1]

[1] https://www.techdirt.com/2017/03/17/judge-grants-search-warr...

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by ehhthing on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:52AM (#34442495)
Shouldn't this be a discussion about how law enforcement search powers are getting out of control, then?
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by bee_rider on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:15PM (#34442808)
That’s another worthwhile topic, but since the privacy threat model of a companies selling some types of birth control will be unusual for the foreseeable future, it is also worth talking about in isolation.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by bee_rider on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:59PM (#34443355)
It also isn’t just limited to Google; I wonder how these companies protect their users from payment processor data collection…
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by lostlogin on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:58AM (#34442579)
The state controlling reproduction is the alarming bit for me, closely followed by the surveillance creepiness Google enables.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by ceejayoz on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:56AM (#34442550)
Law enforcement searches aren't the only risk here.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by mcculley on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:50PM (#34443252)
Every company in healthcare (and many other industries where privacy is important) needs to know that they should not be giving customer data to third parties.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by yellowapple on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:49PM (#34443957)
It is, but if you're a website operator, it's much easier to not use Google Analytics than it is to convince your government to clamp down on law enforcement search powers.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by BoorishBears on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:06PM (#34444206)
Turning this into dichotomy between website operators needing to crusade on government overreach and not using GA has got the be the worst faith argument I've seen in a minute.

This entire premise of this article advantage of people who aren't technically inclined and can't know well enough to realize that reverse engineering GA fingerprints is not even close to how the government would de-anonymize visitors.

If your local government decides to overreach and find out who's getting abortion pills, Google Analytics will not even be your 1000th biggest problem. ISPs will readily share which sites people visit, the stores themselves will get leaned on, your mail carrier with share where you get packages from.

I mean did you even read the article? "Abortion Ease, BestAbortionPill.com, PrivacyPillRX, PillsOnlineRX, Secure Abortion Pills, AbortionRx, Generic Abortion Pills, Abortion Privacy and Online Abortion Pill Rx."

What do you think HTTPS is going to do when one of these urls shows up in your traffic, email inbox, and a reverse mail address look up leads to one of these?

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by yellowapple on Thursday January 19, 2023 @03:33PM (#34445234)
> Turning this into dichotomy between website operators needing to crusade on government overreach and not using GA has got the be the worst faith argument I've seen in a minute.

Putting words in my mouth has got to be the worst faith argument I've seen in a minute.

> If your local government decides to overreach and find out who's getting abortion pills, Google Analytics will not even be your 1000th biggest problem. ISPs will readily share which sites people visit, the stores themselves will get leaned on, your mail carrier with share where you get packages from.

And it's much easier for website operators to stop using Google Analytics than it is for them to educate their customers on using VPNs and mailing their packages to dead drops (let alone for their customers to actually do those things).

This ain't about dichotomies or the lack thereof. This is about what people can do now to mitigate low-hanging fruit. Nobody said the solution is only to stop using GA; literally all that was actually said is that not using GA is something that the operators of such stores can trivially and immediately do.

That is:

> What do you think HTTPS is going to do when one of these urls shows up in your traffic, email inbox, and a reverse mail address look up leads to one of these?

The existence of problems outside your control does not erase the existence of problems entirely within your control. Website operators cannot force you to use a VPN or a secure email or an anonymous address. They can minimize the data of yours they're sending to third parties.

> I mean did you even read the article?

I mean did you even read the HN guideline specifically prohibiting such a question?

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by BoorishBears on Thursday January 19, 2023 @04:35PM (#34445944)
> Putting words in my mouth has got to be the worst faith argument I've seen in a minute.

"it's much easier to not use Google Analytics than it is to convince your government to clamp down on law enforcement search powers."

You literally wrote a one sentence comment that compares a decision for website owners to choose between not using GA and convincing their government not to clamp down on law enforcement search powers. I didn't put a single word in your mouth in stating what I did.

You wanting to walk back what you wrote doesn't make my comment put words in your mouth, they were the words you said.

> And it's much easier for website operators to stop using Google Analytics than it is for them to educate their customers on using VPNs and mailing their packages to dead drops (let alone for their customers to actually do those things).

GA is completely orthogonal to the entire discussion. That's the point that ProPublica (intentionally?) ignores, and apparently you're just unaware of.

It's doing literally nothing to protect or harm these people, because the government is not stooping to deanonymizing GA data when there are 1001 more direct and better established methods to achieve the same thing, it's a frankly absurd point.

Saying by not using GA they're even tangentially protecting customers shows a complete lack of understanding of why this government overreach is such a problem.

-

tl;dr/too technical;didn't understand: The government doesn't need your GA fingerprint they can get the things that the fingerprint is made and then some straight from Google... and your ISP... and the site's host... and the mail services.. and the list goes on.

They can literally ask for all people who searched for a given term in a 5 block radius and you're trying to talk about hashed fingerprints???

It's like worrying that the government is going to check for your DNA in the toilet at a local restaurant when the establishment can be compelled to give them a receipt with your card details, your bank will give them the transaction details, your search history with the restaurant name is up for grabs, the municipal security cameras that watched you drive up are up for grabs...

-

Once you understand that then the pointlessness of this line of reasoning comes up, and why ProPublica is doing this becomes more questionable.

By inventing some totally ludacris wrong, they're painting themselves as having uncovered some unique in-depth aspect to the dynamic between these abortion pill sites and their users, but to do so they're painting the sites as negligent with the most inane stretch of logic possible.

Instead of focusing more on the actual problem, the overreach, they create a new boogeyman because it gives their reporting a unique angle. But of course that boogeyman is serving the interests of people who are having their rights stomped on.

By completely misunderstanding the topic (and in ProPublica's case I'm not buying it was unintentional) both you and the article are just throwing FUD into the actual conversation that matters.

It's annoying to see supposedly creditable publications intentionally muddy things for their own benefit, and it's even more annoying to see people with a poor grasp of the situation just run with it blindly without taking 5 seconds to apply critical thinking and context to it all.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by yellowapple on Thursday January 19, 2023 @06:49PM (#34447308)
> You literally wrote a one sentence comment that compares a decision for website owners to choose between not using GA and convincing their government not to clamp down on law enforcement search powers.

Right, and note what I didn't say:

- Whether or not those things are a dichotomy or otherwise mutually exclusive

- Whether or not those things encompass the complete set of privacy violations or the mitigations thereof

Your assumption that I've made or even implied answers to either of those within the words "it's much easier to not use Google Analytics than it is to convince your government to clamp down on law enforcement search powers" - and then arguing against that assumption - is where you're putting words in my mouth. It's also what makes you accusing me of bad-faith argumentation or a lack of critical thinking or context hilariously ironic.

There's nothing for me to "walk back". You blew up at me for merely suggesting that businesses which should be valuing their customers' privacy can take very easy steps to actually signal that. Whether or not they're siphoning a bunch of data to third parties is a rather strong signal of whether or not they take their customers' privacy seriously, and the fact that you are not only incapable of understanding that concept but feel compelled to resort to unwarranted hostility and personal attacks in response to it speaks volumes.

> GA is completely orthogonal to the entire discussion.

GA is literally the context of the discussion. Just because there are other ways for others to violate your customers' privacy doesn't mean it's okay to willingly and deliberately violate your customers' privacy yourself. That you not only fail to understand this but are needlessly hostile to those who do understand this speaks volumes.

If you'd like to have an actually intelligent and civil discussion instead of angrily flinging insults at me, I'd be happy to oblige. Until then, have a nice day - hopefully better than whatever tragedy you're choosing to take out on me.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by BoorishBears on Thursday January 19, 2023 @07:38PM (#34447699)
When you started this comment by saying "Yeah I created a division between those two options but that's not a dichotomy!" I questioned if I should bother reading

By the time I got to the invention of "angrily flung insults", and projection about bad days I had my answer...

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by nickthegreek on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:35AM (#34442205)
It is a story because some states might be able to sue for information regarding visitors to those sites due to local laws. Its about informing citizens that their private purchases might not be as private as they want.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by raverbashing on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:37AM (#34442223)
Looks like the GDPR worries about privacy and data sent independent to 3rd parties had some merit
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by chopin on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:41AM (#34442299)
Websites subject to GDPR use Google Analytics left and right. Even government websites do this. GDPR has good intentions but enforcement is lacking severely.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by robertlagrant on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:45AM (#34442381)
GDPR isn't intended to stop its use. It's intended to inform users of data sharing and provide them a mechanism to subsequently delete.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by TylerE on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:17PM (#34443590)
Instead it's just another way to train users to click Yes/Accept without thinking! How could this possibly go wrong?
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by mrguyorama on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:51PM (#34444757)
Actually, the longer GDPR has been around, the more I see websites popping up with a comprehensive modal that gives gentle explanations of what each toggle does.

Hell, now some websites even default to "non-required" tracking off, and literally do not require you to do anything to limit the data they harvest from you. And I'm pretty sure this is some third party's drop in solution.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by robertlagrant on Friday January 20, 2023 @04:38AM (#34450791)
> Instead it's just another way to train users to click Yes/Accept without thinking! How could this possibly go wrong?

GDPR doesn't specify UX.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by Nextgrid on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:22PM (#34444403)
It's intended to ask users for consent before stalking them. But lack of enforcement means that in practice implementations use a non-compliant popup that forces users to accept (and is often technically flawed in that the tracking scripts are loaded regardless of the user's answer).
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by ensignavenger on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:04PM (#34443423)
Presumably the person ordering these drugs is already providing the site with payment information (credit card) and a shipping address... seems like anyone suing for this information would probably start there rather than with google analytics.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by RajT88 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:27PM (#34443689)
I am not going to visit or look up these sites on my work computer.

But if they are headquartered outside the US like many online pharmacies are, likely they are going to just ignore any law enforcement requests for user data.

Putting myself in the shoes of an online pharmacy selling abortion meds, I would be crazy to headquarter in the US. I'd be surprised if even a few were US-based.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by yunohn on Friday January 20, 2023 @03:57AM (#34450568)
Quite a few of the websites from the article claim to be USA based.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by nerdjon on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:34AM (#34442190)
It is going to continue to be a story until we take this data collection seriously and actually try to curtail it.

We can't just wipe it away with "we already know this is happening" when its wrong in the first place.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by paulryanrogers on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:38AM (#34442245)
Because it could lead to prosecuting women for exercising reproductive rights?
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by lostlogin on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:00PM (#34442626)
That’s just it though, it isn’t a right anymore.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by willcipriano on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:18PM (#34443598)
It never was, Roe was a bad ruling.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by bagels on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:39AM (#34442250)
It may be a violation of HIPAA for the pharmacies to be doing this.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by j45 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:37AM (#34442234)
It is immature journalism.

Either the writer or an editor who ultimately decided on the headline.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:31AM (#34442141)
becauae it is then possible to obtain this data and imprison them
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by b1n on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:43AM (#34442327)
Because it IS news to a lot of people. And putting it in context brings home the reality and implications of tracking that many people may not be aware of.

If you've ever seen any SaaS websites where they have...

- Our Product vs Competitor 1

- Our Product vs Competitor 2

- Our Product vs Competitor 3

- Our Product vs etc...

... then you can see why this is important from an SEO perspective.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by godelski on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:10PM (#34442748)
Just because something is obvious to you doesn't mean it is to others. You're in a bubble if you think everyone is highly tech literate.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by t433 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:03PM (#34443415)
Ironically this dipshit you're replying to is the one missing the obvious implications of this after the overruling of Roe v. Wade, or they just don't care because HN is overflowing with clowns like him.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by godelski on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:21PM (#34443628)
Even though I disagree with the parent, HN has strict guidelines about calling people names and I'm actually in favor of these guidelines. We all fall prey to our emotions so please just edit the comment. If HN is overflowing with clowns we have to take extra caution not to become one ourselves and to dissuade them from coming here.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by t433 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:22PM (#34444401)
I am aware of the guidelines and choose to ignore them.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by libraryatnight on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:31PM (#34443023)
If this is obvious to you, perhaps you're not the audience. Are you genuinely curious who the audience is, or are you just being a dick?
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by 33955985 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:43PM (#34443158)
That you don’t think the possibility of governments prosecuting vulnerable women seeking health care in the US using surveillance capitalist tools is a story says more about you than the article.
Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by wodenokoto on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:48PM (#34443222)
It’s the surprising consequences of this.

The privacy implications here are totally different than for a travel blog.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by toss1 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @12:50PM (#34443254)
Because in this instance, the consequence is that this data can now enable a quasi-fascist minority to impose their religious views on others, with consequences of serious jail time for (in other states) innocent and vulnerable women.

When will people realize that surveillance capitalism is morally bankrupt (aside from also being a fraud), and that personally identifiable information is toxic waste?

This is so far beyond "Don't Be Evil" . . .

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by brodouevencode on Thursday January 19, 2023 @01:57PM (#34444070)
Because it is centered around a highly divisive topic abortion. If it were anything else no one would care, even activities that are not widely legal. For example:

Online retailers selling marijuana products send fingerprints to Google Analytics overwhelming majority would not care

Brothels selling appointments online send fingerprints to Google Analytics overwhelming majority would not care

Online retailers selling firearms send fingerprints to Google Analytics overwhelming majority would not care

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by dsfyu404ed on Thursday January 19, 2023 @03:38PM (#34445290)
Firearms people get pissed over the tracking. Before it was more broadly legal weed people used to be pissed over that. I presume the kind people who book prostitutes online don't like the data trail either.

The reason you're hearing about of this is because HN cares a lot about abortion whereas all those other topics are of much less importance around here.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by tomjen3 on Thursday January 19, 2023 @02:33PM (#34444540)
Not breaking news: business has surveilance cameras.

Breaking news: the business is a gym, and the area includes the showers.

Re:Online pharmacies selling abortion pills send fingerprint... by jjav on Thursday January 19, 2023 @11:56PM (#34449430)
> Why is this even a story?

It's a story because it's a privacy violation and also a HIPAA violation.

Very similar to the case where health care providers were using Facebook trackers which was sending PII and PHI (private health info) to Facebook which has triggered multiple lawsuits.

https://themarkup.org/pixel-hunt/2022/06/16/facebook-is-rece...

It's great that some light is being shined on these violations. You can't just put spyware tracking on sensitive websites.