News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by LarryMullins on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @01:40PM (#34152042)
Whether it's good local privacy laws in your country or a good privacy-respecting TOS from a company, both are basically worthless when a bigger entity comes barging into the picture.

So your government collects biometric data but passes laws promising not to misuse it... you may very well find that those promises are worth less than dirt when a country with leverage over your own starts making demands that your government feels obliged or coerced to obey.

Or you give lots of your personal data to a software company that promises privacy in their TOS. Great.. until that company gets bought out by the likes of Google or Facebook, then those promises evaporate and good luck doing anything about it.

The solution is to never trust any promises of privacy, and don't hand over personal data to anybody unless it's taken from you at gunpoint. It doesn't matter what promises are given, because all promises can be broken with enough leverage.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by epolanski on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @01:58PM (#34152323)
Why would we have to give two damns about American demands, I don't see that having any chance.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by LarryMullins on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:07PM (#34152431)
Even if you're certain America today and into the indeterminate future has no leverage over your country, can't subvert your elections, bribe or blackmail your politicians, threaten sanctions or worse, then you still have to worry about American spies simply stealing that data.

Such private data should never be collected in the first place. You may as well stack up gold bars in your home, in plain view of street-level windows. Such concentrations of data/wealth are asking for trouble. Get rid of it now and you won't have to worry about keeping it secure in the future, no matter what world events may unfold.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by __MatrixMan__ on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:24PM (#34153299)
I live in America and I'm not convinced that America has leverage over my country. The steering wheel on this thing appears to be broken..
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by __MatrixMan__ on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:24PM (#34153300)
I live in America and I'm not convinced that America has leverage over my country. The steering wheel on this thing appears to be broken.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by LarryMullins on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:35PM (#34153437)
Understandable position, but I think you should be aware that the US Government is capable of moving fast and decisively in rare but unpredictable circumstances. Only 44 days elapsed between 2001/9/11 and the passage of the Patriot Act on 2001/10/25.

Things usually don't change that fast, but nobody can truly predict the geopolitical landscape even half a year into the future.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by Aeolun on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:54PM (#34154964)
I’m fairly certain nobody will be passing a patriot act over something this banal though.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by omgomgomgomg on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:33PM (#34152733)
I am not sure why this is downvoted, the guy is exactly right.

I would have thought HN is more on the small government political spectrum, it appears this does not count for foreign policy?

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by pc86 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:42PM (#34152832)
HN is on the small government side only insofar as it relates to tech legislation and adjacent regulations. It's pretty typically left-leaning California-esque politics otherwise.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by pasquinelli on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:44PM (#34153530)
hn has as much of an identity as reddit
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by anigbrowl on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:09PM (#34153148)
Well it's look how Americans are big on freedom for themselves, but view people in other countries as something like movie extras. The most extreme example of this is the emerging nationalist caucus which has elevated hypocrisy to an art form and has every intention of leveraging similar tactics against its domestic population.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by sfusato on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:37PM (#34152772)
Uhmm, you may want to update your knowledge on the history of the 1945-2022 period

tldr: USA is the current world empire; EU are their vassals

Homework: (1) find how many European military bases there are on US soil; (2) find how many US military bases there are on European soil;

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by tbihl on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:49PM (#34152910)
> (1) find how many European military bases there are on US soil

To do what? Counter the Canadian threat to US American territorial integrity? Prevent war between California and ethnic Nevadans? Monitor unmanaged flows of migrants from unstable regions? Hmm, well maybe that one.

But really, one of the great blessings of the US is a lack of any home-front excitement, which makes this comparison pretty silly. Not that that disagrees with the hypotheses that the US is a world empire and the EU's present existence is predicated on US military size and operations.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by sfusato on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:54PM (#34152983)
Right, so what for are the US military bases on European soil then? (Please spare me the part about protecting Europe from outside threats story). Would they leave if we asked nicely enough? Like Pretty please? Would it really take just that?
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by RandomLensman on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:10PM (#34153163)
They probably would, and a lot of US forces left after the end of the old cold war. Right now, not sure a majority/the median voter in Europe actually wants the US to leave, though.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by sfusato on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:27PM (#34153328)
I want to believe you they would, but I wasn't born yesterday. I'm within less than 2-hours drive from two such US military bases that have nuclear weapons deployed there. US military bases are considered US soil de-facto, they don't need to ask permission to do anything. They can launch an attack on anyone without consulting first with the host country. Yet, on paper, we're sovereign.

They've been plenty of protests in Europe over this matter this year, but they won't show them on CNN, that's for sure.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by tbihl on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:04PM (#34154482)
In some cases, raising the rent will do it [0]. This one looks like political brinksmanship gone wrong for all sides, and the article suggests that it's being undone right now.

Random citizen asking obviously does nothing, but foreign base COs are always desperately trying to keep their forces on best behavior to minimize frustration. That's not easy when you import a bunch of guys in the age range that most often causes trouble, give them significant spending money, and remove them from past anchoring influences. It's worse when the receiving society is more orderly; I have Japan in mind.

Fighting against those problems is that all political leadership generally benefits from the arrangements. The foreign host nation gets economic activity and some amount of bargaining power, and the US gets a location that obviously is helpful for some strategic objective.

>Right, so what for are the US military bases on European soil then? (Please spare me the part about protecting Europe from outside threats story).

An anomalous, peaceful Europe is the water that you're swimming in, and I'm trying to point out that it's wet. I recognize the limited prospects of the endeavor. Though, if it's the outside part you're rejecting, I'll acknowledge my imprecise wording. Russia is the outside threat, being outside the Western European culture that is defended, but threats come from within Europe too.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Naval_Base_Subic_Bay

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by 8note on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:54PM (#34152990)
To ensure the American government passes EU friendly laws
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by pasquinelli on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:45PM (#34153551)
> Not that that disagrees with the hypotheses that the US is a world empire and the EU's present existence is predicated on US military size and operations.

oh, so why are you replying?

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by crote on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:16PM (#34153927)
The USA is rapidly losing that status, though. Its European bases were a holdover from the Second World War, extended by the Cold War - their presence should not be seen as any indication of its current political status.

In the last 20 years the USA has involved its allies into multiple pointless unwinnable wars. Human rights in the USA have been significantly eroded, and many values essential to modern society are currently being undermined. Additionally, Trump's presidency has done significant damage to a large number of diplomatic relations and resulted not only in widespread doubt about its democratic process, but a genuine coup attempt.

Meanwhile, during the same 20 years the European Union and China have risen in power significantly - and both are making significant effort to curtail the power the USA has over them. Those military bases exist because the USA is still somewhat of an ally and the EU has real threats right on its border - as long as the USA is not actively hostile towards the EU, having direct access to the firepower of a gun-drunk nation is quite convenient.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by epolanski on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @12:25PM (#34163319)
We are nobody's vassals and the EU has no realistic military opponents on its borders.

You're ridiculous and watch Fox news too much.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by sfusato on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @03:03PM (#34165209)
> We are nobody's vassals

History contradicts you. I'm an European myself if that wasn't clear enough, so this wasn't an American telling you, an European, you are our vassals.

> EU has no realistic military opponents on its borders

Fully agree on this.

> You're ridiculous and watch Fox news too much.

I might be ridiculous to your eyes, but I certainly don't watch FoxNews.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by frankfrankfrank on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:12PM (#34152494)
I get the sense you do not quite understand how much essentially all of Europe is a vassal state of the group of people that also has a stranglehold on America.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by omgomgomgomg on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:39PM (#34152800)
Please explain.

This might be true on military/nato matters, but economically, Europe and the EU can quite take care of themselves.

As for america, who has a stranglehold there?

If we leave conspiracy theories out of the equation, it is always the 2 parties un power and their corporate or institutional buddies.

I do not think anyone is thelling Trump or Bidens team who to invade or bombard next.

The US is the remaining superpower and thats all there really is.

Look at Musk, richest guy in the world, Trump was making fun of him.

It is not the people with money who have the power, money is a pre requisite to even be allowed near power.

The people with power un the us are simply the people with....power.

USA, with all its flaws, is nobodys vassal state.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by bloppe on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:51PM (#34153631)
I just formed a secret society. We have a secret handshake and are very powerful. In fact, we control everything.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by bee_rider on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:23PM (#34152625)
Life in Europe looks pretty nice from the outside at least. Could America sign up for self-vassalage or something?
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by cscurmudgeon on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:45PM (#34152877)
Just from the outside
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by dzikimarian on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:07PM (#34153133)
I'm inside and I'm pretty happy comparing to alternatives.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by cscurmudgeon on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:36PM (#34153455)
Happy to hear that.

I am inside the US and have been inside and lived in many countries. As an immigrant from Asia, I am happy most in the US and so are millions of permanent immigrants including tens of thousands from Europe every year :)

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by dzikimarian on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @08:16AM (#34160653)
Great it works for you. :-)

I spent some time traveling in various parts of the world and EU works best for me.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by pessimizer on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:03PM (#34153760)
That's because the US allowed Europe to do social spending instead of military spending in order to keep them from going Communist. And anyway, the result was a monstrously armed US and a defenseless Europe, so it was ultimately a win-win for America.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by rnk on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:46PM (#34154283)
The US wanted to block communism for sure but we aren't organized enough to do subtle things in Europe. We didn't "let you" choose social safety nets over military spending, I say that in part because I've been hearing about insufficient euro military spending for many years. We must have advocated for block commies and military spending. ;-) The US must have tried to suppress communist parties in Italy etc after ww2, probably did terrible things.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by bloppe on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:33PM (#34152734)
I think you're giving American leadership way too much credit.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by eternalban on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:53PM (#34152965)
I don't think you parsed the comment correctly.

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/991680.The_Anglo_America...

https://archive.org/details/pdfy-A7-BNmZpG-RLOXZZ

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carroll_Quigley

-- preface snippet (1981) ---

The Rhodes Scholarships, established by the terms of Cecil Rhodes's seventh will, are known to everyone. What is not so widely known is that Rhodes in five previous wills left his fortune to form a secret society, which was to devote itself to the preservation and expansion of the British Empire. And what does not seem to be known to anyone is that this secret society was created by Rhodes and his principal trustee, Lord Milner, and continues to exist to this day. To be sure, this secret society is not a childish thing like the Ku Klux Klan, and it does not have any secret robes, secret handclasps, or secret passwords. It does not need any of these, since its members know each other intimately. It probably has no oaths of secrecy nor any formal procedure of initiation. It does, however, exist and holds secret meetings, over which the senior member present presides. At various times since 1891, these meetings have been presided over by Rhodes, Lord Milner, Lord Selborne, Sir Patrick Duncan, Field Marshal Jan Smuts, Lord Lothian, and Lord Brand. They have been held in all the British Dominions, starting in South Africa about 1903; in various places in London, chiefly 175 Piccadilly; at various colleges at Oxford, chiefly All Souls; and at many English country houses such as Tring Park, Blickling Hall, Cliveden, and others.

This society has been known at various times as Milner's Kindergarten, as the Round Table Group, as the Rhodes crowd, as The Times crowd, as the All Souls group, and as the Cliveden set. All of these terms are unsatisfactory, for one reason or another, and I have chosen to call it the Milner Group. Those persons who have used the other terms, or heard them used, have not generally been aware that all these various terms referred to the same Group.

It is not easy for an outsider to write the history of a secret group of this kind, but, since no insider is going to do it, an outsider must attempt it. It should be done, for this Group is, as I shall show, one of the most important historical facts of the twentieth century. Indeed, the Group is of such significance that evidence of its existence is not hard to find, if one knows where to look. This evidence I have sought to point out without overly burdening this volume with footnotes and bibliographical references. While such evidences of scholarship are kept at a minimum, I believe I have given the source of every fact which I mention. Some of these facts came to me from sources which I am not permitted to name, and I have mentioned them only where I can produce documentary evidence available to everyone. Nevertheless, it would have been very difficult to write this book if I had not received a certain amount of assistance of a personal nature from persons close to the Group. For obvious reasons, I cannot reveal the names of such persons, so I have not made reference to any information derived from them unless it was information readily available from other sources.

...

I should say a few words about my general attitude toward this subject. I approached the subject as a historian. This attitude I have kept. I have tried to describe or to analyze, not to praise or to condemn. I hope that in the book itself this attitude is maintained. Of course I have an attitude, and it would be only fair to state it here. In general, I agree with the goals and aims of the Milner Group. I feel that the British way of life and the British Commonwealth of Nations are among the great achievements of all history. I feel that the destruction of either of them would be a terrible disaster to mankind.

...

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by bloppe on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:36PM (#34153458)
Sounds to me like a highly ineffective secret society, given the slow but steady decline of Anglo-American hegemony since the cold war.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by eternalban on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:57PM (#34153698)
Ineffective is an ungenerous appraisal, when we consider what the world looked like mid 19th century when this project got started, and how it does now. They were quite effective up to the demise of USSR. The entire world speaks English.

William Engdahl's book Gods of Money [ch. 18 - Theft of a Nation] addresses the period you mention and what was happening. There was also an ideological shift in this period, since after the end of Cold War, Neo-Conservatives have been (and remain) in ideological charge. The Wolfowitz Doctrine always struck me as decidedly un-Anglo given its willfully provocative stance, lacking any nuance or subtlety. In fact the behavior of US post Cold War remains somewhat perplexing, even in terms of purely American national interests. There may have been a regime change.

https://www.nytimes.com/1992/03/08/world/us-strategy-plan-ca...

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by bloppe on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:14PM (#34153898)
In the mid 19th century, the British Empire was peaking as the largest empire in history. It was a long road to get to that point, and this secret society was created as the Empire was just beginning its decline.

The 20th century saw the rise of American military, economic, and cultural imperialism, which carried Anglo-American culture further as the British Empire declined relatively.

Sure, I'll concede that there are shady people in government trying to do things that are broadly objectionable and sometimes illegal, but to think this means certain individuals or secret societies have a "stranglehold" on global politics or economics goes much too far. There are far too many factors at play for a small group of people to wield the level of outsize power necessary to guide these processes. It's really a very large and ever-changing group of people who "control everything", and this happens in a highly uncoordinated manner.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by tpush on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:26PM (#34153325)
> [...] group of people [...]

What group of people are controlling everything? Please don't let it be Jews...

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by krapp on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @07:06PM (#34155687)
Just once I want to find out the vast shadowy conspiracy controlling everything is the Hare Krishnas, or the Mormons or... the Armenian Mafia. The Phoebus lightbulb cartel. A coven of witches. Anyone but "the Jews." Again.

Even the current moral panic and conspiracy complex around transgendered people leads to anti-semitism if you follow the strings and thumbtacks.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by xiphias2 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:14PM (#34152534)
The whole EU economy depends on the USD-EUR liquidity swap line between the two central banks. Basically EU has to do whatever US wants.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by coob on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:17PM (#34152558)
How?
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by xiphias2 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:24PM (#34152640)
It's quite nicely explained on the official EU site (much better than how I understand):

https://www.ecb.europa.eu/mopo/implement/liquidity_lines/htm...

Without a swap line banks couldn't just treat EUR as USD whenever an entity needs to keep USD for import/export purposes.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by monocasa on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:36PM (#34152761)
That goes both ways. The US economy is dependent on having markets for consumer goods. Losing the EU as an easy market nukes the US economy as well.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by sofixa on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:40PM (#34154230)
Yeah, one would think post-Brexit and post-pandemic and post-Russian invasion of Ukraine people would in general be more aware of interdependence in trade, finance, manufacturing, etc. but apparently not. (Yes, they did say that before WWI, and today it's a million times more intertwined)
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by xiphias2 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @07:46PM (#34156033)
It still matters game theoretically who loses more on not having a trade, and US having the reserve currency means that it has clearly more power over EU than the other way around.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by pkaye on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @07:53PM (#34156083)
Surprisingly the trade to GDP ratio is quite low for the US. And a good chunk of that trade is with Canada and Mexico.

https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NE.TRD.GNFS.ZS?most_rec...

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by sofixa on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:17PM (#34152564)
You should check out the GDPR and the Shrems judgements if you think that.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by RandomLensman on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:18PM (#34153227)
While without swaps between central banks there will (probably) be more issues in non-domestic funding markets, the whole EU economy isn't just depending on the swap line between the ECB and the Fed.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by hcks on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:05PM (#34152405)
Yeah ahah no chance sure. What are these silly Americans thinking lol we are strong sovereign nations aren’t we ;)
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by kmeisthax on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:49PM (#34152911)
Because sovereignty ends at borders.

Europeans want to vacation in the US. The US demands biometric authentication upon crossing the border. So you either give them that data or the US stops letting Europeans in.

And I doubt Europe is going to be any better at not demanding biometric data than the US is, because Europe has the same underlying incentives to do so (i.e. a restrictive immigration system, a large portion of the population who want to NIMBY entire races of people, and a large body of laws to enforce).

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by mihaaly on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:07PM (#34153136)
The US needs relationship with EU citizens just as much as the other way around. Or even more, like in the case of people like me (I rather avoid the US after being there several times and experienced the mentality). The vacations are especially weak argument for sharing highly personal data with an entity that is prone to repeatedly and shamelessly abusing it, misusing it.

Will the relationship being more difficult if not yielding to the demands? Ok then. We are not made of cotton candy to melt in a drop of rain that easily when some difficulty comes along, especially if it is a bureaucracy thingy. The vacations will be a bit more difficult - for those attracted by the US instead of beautiful spots elsewhere. Business relations too, of course, but that one has double edge actually.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by petre on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:22PM (#34154003)
We already have biometric passports in the EU. Why the need to collect biometric data when I have it on me and in my passport as well? This is worse than PII, it should be covered by data protection laws like the GDPR.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by psychphysic on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:25PM (#34154049)
I a glass is always nearly empty kind of guy.

Have no plans to visit the US still expect my government would fold like napkin if US county police faxed over a request.

The US tapped even NATO ally governments if they want fingerprints they'll get them.

At any rate don't you have to sign, fingerprint and stand infront of a camera to pass most countries passport control?

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by Aeolun on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @06:06PM (#34155095)
I don’t think the EU minds the US having access to EU biometric data as long as citizens choose to give it to the US directly. To have them lift it out of our databases without any manual actions seems ridiculous.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by epolanski on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @12:21PM (#34163275)
Bingo. That's the point.

If people want to share with a third party, it's their business.

But for US to just access some database and lift them is ridiculous

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by Muromec on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @09:13PM (#34156721)
EU doesn't enforce fingerprints scan on the border most of the time. It's very strange, as all the infrastructure is there, passports and alien ids have fingerprints included in them, there are fingerprint-scanning machines on border crossing points, yet I'm yet to see it being used ever.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by vixen99 on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @02:58AM (#34158657)
The European Travel Information and Authorization System (ETIAS) will be in force by November 2023. 'The completely electronic system will keep track of visitors who do not require a full visa to enter Schengen Zone countries for the purposes of travel for up to 90 days'.

https://etias.com/

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by lakomen on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @06:10PM (#34155154)
Because Von der Leyen is deep in America's ass
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by arcticbull on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:15PM (#34152535)
Sounds like we can either have nice things and demand better of leadership, or not have nice things and let leadership go fallow. Losing faith in leadership means the whole thing falls apart anyways. I for one think the former is the way to go.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by survirtual on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:39PM (#34152802)
This is very correct. However, I would amend your solution: the solution is modern encryption and open source. These two in conjunction allow you to verify trust.

ToS is like HR: they both exist to protect only the company.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by ecef9-8c0f-4374 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:44PM (#34152852)
ok. now the US government demands not to use modern encryption and open source. And we are back at square one.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by devmunchies on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:49PM (#34152916)
That could go to the supreme court, maybe violates the 4th amendment?

"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated"

meaning, I got the right to secure my sh*t.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by jolux on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:35PM (#34153449)
> I got the right to secure my sh*t

I don't know if you've noticed, but the Supreme Court routinely flouts long-held interpretations of statute for nakedly ideological reasons. Rights don't mean anything if the government isn't willing to grant them, unfortunately. I would not bet on this court preserving a right to encryption as you describe it.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by anigbrowl on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:02PM (#34153077)
Great, but this news item is about the government of the USA demanding rights over the personal data of people in other countries. Not being citizens, the US govt considers them lesser people with no Constitutional protection.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by devmunchies on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:43PM (#34153528)
I was responding to "now the US government demands not to use modern encryption".
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:29PM (#34154095)
Basically the same right is in the human rights convention, which has no caveats about citizenship and to which the US is a signatory.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by survirtual on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:52PM (#34152962)
If nothing else, it definitely violates the spirit of the second amendment. My digital self should be as secure and protected as my physical brain under the eyes of law.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by synkarius on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:58PM (#34153040)
Citizens of other countries have no rights under the US constitution.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by rnk on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:09PM (#34153841)
It's more complicated than that. They have many rights inside our border. Outside our border I'm not sure. Web search found https://libertarianinstitute.org/articles/constitutional-rig...
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by synkarius on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:31PM (#34154764)
That's true about rights inside the US border, but in context, this thread was talking about non-US citizens in their home countries when said countries are being pressured by the US government.

I could have been clearer there. I can see why you replied as such.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by jolux on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:45PM (#34152875)
> These two in conjunction allow you to verify trust.

Not when it comes to server-based software.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by survirtual on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:49PM (#34152919)
Yes, actually.

- If you host your own servers you can still verify.

- if you are using well-designed, human-centric software, untrusted servers (read: all servers you do not have control of / cannot audit) would not have any access to private data due to encryption, and clients can be verified to make sure decryption only occurs on the client side

The trouble is, this kind of software is a poison pill to advertising. It will be a long time before it takes over.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by jolux on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:34PM (#34153418)
> would not have any access to private data due to encryption

It's pretty difficult to fully scrub yourself of the metadata involved in making a connection to a server. For sure it can be minimized, like Signal does. But this has inherent UX tradeoffs that most people are not willing to make, like requiring you share your phone number to use the service, and not having server-based backup (yet, at least).

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by survirtual on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:38PM (#34154818)
It is difficult with the way things are now, yes. It will not be difficult for much longer.

It was once difficult for me to communicate with you, me being a stranger to you and you being the same, having never met in person. But here we are.

We are all experts at solving difficult problems & giving access to those solutions to everyone.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by murderfs on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:30PM (#34153365)
You say "human-centric", but you really mean "what I want". Many more humans would be upset at being unable to recover their data if they forget their password than would be pleased by this.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by survirtual on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:19PM (#34154631)
I said human-centric and I most certainly mean it. Humans cannot be trusted to do the right thing when it comes to mass scale, nameless faces. We need to be kept in check, and we have the mathematics to do it.

Custodial services can always still exist for those among us that are incompetent.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by lisper on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:54PM (#34152984)
> These two in conjunction allow you to verify trust.

No, they don't. They only allow you to verify that some entity that possessed some private key made some claim about some set of bits. It tells you absolutely nothing about whether any of those claims are actually true, including whether the possessor of the private key is who they claim to be.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by survirtual on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:27PM (#34154722)
I didn’t mention anything about signing?

I said encryption. You can do encryption all kinds of ways. In this case, I am talking about encrypting your own data on a client and not allowing a server to see it. This would just require a secret key derived from a password ran through a password hashing algo.

You only need asynchronous crypto when you involve another party, so it would play a role in a trustless architecture, but I am unsure what your point is.

When I say “verify trust” of a system, I am referring to a product making a claim, such as “your data is private and we don’t sell it” — then backing up the claim by building the product in such a way such that it is impossible to sell it. Encryption + open source is just about all the way to proving that claim, and it can be verified that way.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by lisper on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @06:36PM (#34155425)
> I said encryption.

No, you didn't. You said "modern encryption" which is generally understood to mean public-key encryption.

But even so, your claim is still false because you can't trust your encryption software even if it is open source unless you build your entire tool chain yourself (and nowadays you have to roll your own silicon too if you really want to be sure).

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by LarryMullins on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:03PM (#34153091)
Let's say hypothetically, Facebook buys Signal. They get all the code and signing keys, then use those to push a new update to the Signal app. This update decrypts your messages using the key on your device, then sends those decrypted messages to Facebook.

What are you going to do about it? Call your senators, who are now in love with Facebook for giving the federal government access to these previously private communications?

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by __MatrixMan__ on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:19PM (#34153250)
Fork signal, put together a non-profit to run the nodes, start paying $1/mo or somesuch, and stop using the facebookified version.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by LarryMullins on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:31PM (#34153382)
That's great if you stay on top of the news, see it coming and get your data out of the way before the compromised app is pushed to your phone. Maybe habitual HN users are safe, but I think most Signal users would be compromised like this.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by void-star on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @09:33PM (#34156867)
What’s wrong with the existing signal? This is not a sarcastic question. I’m actually curious what the privacy concern over signal is and what is meant by “the facebookified version” and what the privacy concern therein is. The new “stories” functionality I’m guessing? I haven’t used it so I’m interested what observations there are there…
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday January 01, 2023 @06:37PM (#34212387)
In the hypothetical above, it contains malware which is exfiltrating message content before encrypting it for send.

As for the real world... nothing. I quite like signal.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by fsflover on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:27PM (#34154073)
This is why I do not recommend centralized walled garden called Signal. Try that with Matrix.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by dustyharddrive on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @11:02PM (#34157408)
Matrix metadata is not private.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by fsflover on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @05:12AM (#34159405)
Unless you are using your own server?
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by dustyharddrive on Tuesday January 10, 2023 @02:37PM (#34330315)
And all your correspondents are using their own servers. P2P Matrix can't come soon enough.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by astrange on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:28PM (#34153343)
> ToS is like HR: they both exist to protect only the company.

This is, of course, not true about HR and yet another thing people just say to sound cool.

HR’s job is to hire people and run your payroll and benefits. If you have a health insurance question are you going to avoid them because they’re going to fire you as soon as you look at them? No.

If you’re a first level manager molesting a distinguished engineer are you totally safe from HR because you’re “the company”? No.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by awesomegoat_com on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:16PM (#34153930)
Well, HR as any other power structure is to protect status quo.

They will sack anyone if they see it necessary to protect the status quo.

But more importantly, HR will create mindless policies to show you how powerful they are. As border force forcing your sneakers of.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by Aeolun on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:51PM (#34154937)
> to show you how powerful they are

To show you how useful they are. It’s very much a matter of misaligned incentives I think. Of course HR has all day to execute their own policies, so they don’t see them as an overt burden.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by Gwypaas on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:40PM (#34152818)
> Or you give lots of your personal data to a software company that promises privacy in their TOS. Great.. until that company gets bought out by the likes of Google or Facebook, then those promises evaporate and good luck doing anything about it.

This is the point of GDPR. You own your data. You only give companies the right to process it for the stated purposes, which you can withdraw at any time.

Complete privacy is impossible in 2023. Accept it and embrace GDPR-like legislation to take control of your data no matter who holds it.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by mihaaly on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @02:53PM (#34152970)
I sense that many people consider organizations and groups of people as a definite thing. A country, the Google, the Facebook, etc, talk about these like if they were a reliably formed predictable object or entity. While those are an ever changing blob composed of ever chaning composition of people with ever changing views, intentions and agenda in an ever changing environment. Any relationships with those are momentarily only. Relying on promises from those? Like building a house on a solid cloud. No such thing. The saying is especially true in case of big entities formed of humans: a promise is like a fart, you hold it while you can.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by CamperBob2 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:45PM (#34154275)
Exactly, and the same is true of the laws themselves. "I'm not breaking the law, so I have nothing to hide," is wrong in so many ways that it's hard to enumerate them all.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by astrange on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @03:25PM (#34153313)
Google and Facebook are both very good at protecting your personal info. Their business value is based on nobody else having it. Their security teams are much better at their job of protecting it than, say, you are.
Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:19PM (#34153970)
> Or you give lots of your personal data to a software company that promises privacy in their TOS. Great.. until that company gets bought out by the likes of Google or Facebook, then those promises evaporate and good luck doing anything about it.

Sounds like the contract binds me, but does not protect me. It protects the company, but does not bind it.

> Conservatism Consists of Exactly One Proposition, to Wit: There Must Be In-Groups Whom the Law Protects but Does Not Bind, Alongside Out-Groups Whom the Law Binds but Does Not Protect.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by akudha on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @04:38PM (#34154209)
The battle is lost the moment data is collected. It will be leaked, misused, stolen etc. The question is not IF, the question is WHEN.

All the laws, promises, good intentions etc are not worth the paper they are written on. If there is data to be stolen, it will be stolen.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by tick_tock_tick on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @05:15PM (#34154584)
> I recommend that Europeans petition their governments to delete such databases now, so that compliance with American demands simply won't be possible. Delete the databases now so your governments can't fold to pressure later.

LOL dude the EU is one of the driving forcing on making sure there is a complete history of ever person.

Re:US Government demands direct police access to European bi... by judge2020 on Tuesday December 27, 2022 @07:10PM (#34155721)
> It doesn't matter what promises are given, because all promises can be broken with enough leverage.

This has always been the case. Before, it was the threat of imprisonment for speaking out against your government, and having higher taxes levied. Now, it's simply privacy, since that is the key to the countries/companies gaining without literally stealing from you.