Meh, a penalty series spoils the nature of the game.
And a series of static 1v1s is more accurate than a series of 10v10s, 9v9s and so on?
People have criticized chess for pretty much the same thing wrt tie breakers for world championship, classic chess being decided by player's proficiency in a very different format and decision making.
I'm not saying I support the diminishing player count, but perhaps penalties should be deferred until another (3rd total) added extra time in the final match only. Maybe give the teams 2 extra subs if it is still tied after 2nd AET.
There’s no easy way to handle a situation like this, but utilising an already integral component of the game like penalties is probably the fairest solution, and it helps that it’s the one with the most excitement and drama for those watching. It could be much worse, before penalties a literal coin toss was used. If recall correctly teams made it thru to the European Cup (what the Champions League used to be called) final based on a coin toss
Having said that in the US college hockey they do a 3 on 3 overtime. In contrast to a typical 5 v 5 game it is INTENSE. Crowd is on the edge of their seat and so on. Suddenly it's like some back yard / local ice rink where kids just get together to play style game.
It's still the same game as far as the players go, but just more space and a great pass or move to shake a defender / goal keeper is huge.
I don't know if that's the best route to go, but it really is exciting and I prefer it to shootouts by far.
> I don't know if that means the better "team" wins, but if that's the point I think is up for debate too...
Of course you should keep in mind that if you want the better team to win with a p-value of e.g. < 0.001, then you will have to play hundreds of games ...
It's a constant discussion I have where folks talk about a playoff is there to determine the best team but ... that's not really how it works. Having said that, I'd rather not see an endless "regular season" where we just tally up stats and everyone just goes home after playing a ho hum game and happy that they're statistical champs ...
I like playoffs, it produces those extraordinary moments of greatness that we seem to want in sports.
(45+5)+(45+10)+(15+15+5)
Unfortunately TV time slots are so strict, that getting actual 90+30 min of game time cannot really be a thing anymore.
Thus, strategies to waste time dominate, much to the frustration of everyone except the winning team
Will give enough incentive to try and win, but also be fair to both if there's a tie.
Penalties is just a more elaborate form of a coin flip, still largely random.
It's true that penalties test fewer skills than a full-fledged game of football. But they are still a contest of skill, not a game of chance.
I walked out of the pub in disgust.
Eventually the box was reduced and now penalties are a (99%) sure way of scoring.
I don’t know why you mentioned Messi and etc., I was replying to what you said about trying to optimize for PKs during a game.
"In Europe’s top five leagues, 10.41% of the goals were scored from penalties"
https://www.driblab.com/driblab-en/how-significant-are-penal...
If I am coaching a national team, I am studying every game in this tournament and learning exactly what characteristics, what combo of players, what scenarios are most likely to generate PKs and going all-in with that strategy. Maybe Argentina's coach already did.
Mbappe and Giroud act too cocky, always have a face on like they're the stars of a show and the camera's on them, and a lot of the time don't feel like they're playing for the team or as a team.
Argentina on the other hand acts as the sum of a machine's parts. And though Messi is a star, he doesn't act like it on the field, appears grateful for his team, and plays as a member of a team.
Super happy Argentina won, happy to have seen the SK vs Portugal match, and happy to have seen Morocco's games. But also happy to see Mbappe sit and pout even after pulling off a hat-trick in the final game of the world cup lol
It is always great to take a look at the following paper: “Cultural Biases in Economic Exchange?” [1]
[1] http://www.econ.yale.edu/~shiller/behmacro/2004-11/guiso-sap...
Hint: They were not repatriated back to Africa
It is important to highlight that the extremely few black people that exist today in the country is living in a society that not make any racist difference.
On the other hand many indigenous people like Qom [1] are abused by politicians themselves which don’t represent general society views.
I spoke of two players from the French team, not French people as a whole. If I were to say anything about the French team though, I'd say they deserve oscars for their fake injuries to kill the clock. Again, not speaking of French people or fans, just the team and in particular two players.
Saw how Argentina's goalie celebrated and agree it was in poor taste, but that does not discredit the points made in my original post regarding their team functioning as a well oiled machine rather than separate components in an incomplete machine.
What Messi said to Weghorst, hard to tell when there's one perspective given. What was reported as being said seems wildly unlikely to have sparked such a reaction. So, until more accounts from other sides are given to paint a duller picture, what was reported seems bias as hell
Who knows what all went down, but definitely not as simple as he was being asked to exchange shirts. He had to of been either instigated prior by the other team/another player or fuming from bad calls
About Messi, you are leaving out the fact that he only said that as a response because Netherlands' players were encircling and saying things to Argentina's players during the penalties. Messi is precisely an extremely respectful player compared to others.
I've lived both in Europe and Argentina and I can say for sure everyone in Argentina is much more warm, homely and accepting of other nationalities than what I've seen in other countries.
Tough for France and Mbappe. Dead and buried at 80 minutes then took it all the way to penalties.