News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by perfectstorm on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:27PM (#34040797)
but after 120mins of play, somehow they have to make a decision.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by amelius on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:29PM (#34040837)
A better approach I've heard someone coin is: after 90 minutes, you start taking away one player from both teams, every 5 minutes.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by smcl on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:40PM (#34041061)
I think that's a pretty bad idea - the objective is for a team to win, having to tear apart your team will be a very complex and niche tactical meta to master and will result in an incredibly slow paced game as lungs tire when teams get down to 7-8 players each. If teams are on even terms after 90 minutes, and cannot break the deadlock after 30 minutes of Extra Time then they're as evenly matched as possible and therefore deserve a way to win that doesn't break them physically.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by gspetr on Sunday December 18, 2022 @06:52PM (#34045942)
>I think that's a pretty bad idea - the objective is for a team to win

And a series of static 1v1s is more accurate than a series of 10v10s, 9v9s and so on?

People have criticized chess for pretty much the same thing wrt tie breakers for world championship, classic chess being decided by player's proficiency in a very different format and decision making.

I'm not saying I support the diminishing player count, but perhaps penalties should be deferred until another (3rd total) added extra time in the final match only. Maybe give the teams 2 extra subs if it is still tied after 2nd AET.

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by smcl on Sunday December 18, 2022 @07:29PM (#34046414)
Yeah I honestly think it is - some extra time to try to get an edge then a series of set pieces where ultimately if they’re evenly matched everyone, even the goalkeepers, could end up taking a pen.

There’s no easy way to handle a situation like this, but utilising an already integral component of the game like penalties is probably the fairest solution, and it helps that it’s the one with the most excitement and drama for those watching. It could be much worse, before penalties a literal coin toss was used. If recall correctly teams made it thru to the European Cup (what the Champions League used to be called) final based on a coin toss

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by tobltobs on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:40PM (#34041051)
And if no more players are on the field and it is still a tie then what?
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by amelius on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:55PM (#34041310)
Use your imagination. Anyway, by that time, the number of red cards will probably have decided the outcome.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by duxup on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:59PM (#34041369)
The odds of someone getting an open shot seems like it would make a goal all but inevitable.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by michelb on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:01PM (#34042295)
Both coaches duel with pistols.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by duxup on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:57PM (#34041334)
I don't know if that means the better "team" wins, but if that's the point I think is up for debate too...

Having said that in the US college hockey they do a 3 on 3 overtime. In contrast to a typical 5 v 5 game it is INTENSE. Crowd is on the edge of their seat and so on. Suddenly it's like some back yard / local ice rink where kids just get together to play style game.

It's still the same game as far as the players go, but just more space and a great pass or move to shake a defender / goal keeper is huge.

I don't know if that's the best route to go, but it really is exciting and I prefer it to shootouts by far.

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by amelius on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:02PM (#34041447)
Interesting!

> I don't know if that means the better "team" wins, but if that's the point I think is up for debate too...

Of course you should keep in mind that if you want the better team to win with a p-value of e.g. < 0.001, then you will have to play hundreds of games ...

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by duxup on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:05PM (#34041482)
Yeah more so in such a low scoring sport I imagine where rando outcomes are possible?

It's a constant discussion I have where folks talk about a playoff is there to determine the best team but ... that's not really how it works. Having said that, I'd rather not see an endless "regular season" where we just tally up stats and everyone just goes home after playing a ho hum game and happy that they're statistical champs ...

I like playoffs, it produces those extraordinary moments of greatness that we seem to want in sports.

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by coupdejarnac on Sunday December 18, 2022 @05:43PM (#34044775)
This is the quintessential American take on soccer. It's ok if you're not a soccer fan. Soccer doesn't need to be like hockey or basketball, where teams can be dogshit for most of the season and still wind up as champions.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by duxup on Sunday December 18, 2022 @11:21PM (#34048447)
I don’t know what the definition of dogshit is here but generally that’s not how it works… even to get into the playoffs..
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by nothrowaways on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:10PM (#34041555)
How do you decide that?
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by Cyph0n on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:17PM (#34041659)
But they already do just that: you have a finite number of players, a finite number of subs, and each player has a finite amount of stamina.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by kgwgk on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:55PM (#34043235)
They could add an additional ball instead - every 5 minutes. Would be much funnier to watch.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by squirtlebonflow on Sunday December 18, 2022 @06:19PM (#34045397)
Every 5 seconds and no stopping time
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by amelius on Sunday December 18, 2022 @07:10PM (#34046195)
You would need an extra referee per extra ball.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by diego_sandoval on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:37PM (#34040986)
In reality, they end up being like 140 mins.

(45+5)+(45+10)+(15+15+5)

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by smcl on Sunday December 18, 2022 @01:42PM (#34041089)
Remember that additional 20 minutes is added because it's actually time they spent not playing. So in reality they're now playing a full 90 or 120 minutes after having in the past possibly played only 75 or 100.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by Phemist on Sunday December 18, 2022 @06:13PM (#34045303)
And even those 20 min of injury time are probably waaayyy less than the time the game was actually on hold for due to injuries or other shenanigans.

Unfortunately TV time slots are so strict, that getting actual 90+30 min of game time cannot really be a thing anymore.

Thus, strategies to waste time dominate, much to the frustration of everyone except the winning team

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by smcl on Sunday December 18, 2022 @07:33PM (#34046465)
I think TV channels deliberately schedule optional shit after these kinds of games, the thinking being that the pundits can fill time to the next nearest half-hour slot begins then the schedule can resume
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by huhtenberg on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:00PM (#34041394)
Just flip a coin.

Will give enough incentive to try and win, but also be fair to both if there's a tie.

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by webkike on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:05PM (#34041483)
Oh yeah, that would have been SO much better and less controversial than a shootout. What a great way to end 120 minutes of people pouring their heart out. A coin flip
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by huhtenberg on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:10PM (#34041544)
But teams are on par - so either crown them both or choose randomly.

Penalties is just a more elaborate form of a coin flip, still largely random.

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by jogjayr on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:25PM (#34041766)
If penalties were truly random then teams wouldn't practice them. Goalkeepers wouldn't study their opponents' past penalties or use cheatsheets when facing kicks. There wouldn't be so much analysis and game theory poured into the perfect sequencing of kick-takers.

It's true that penalties test fewer skills than a full-fledged game of football. But they are still a contest of skill, not a game of chance.

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by webkike on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:19PM (#34041681)
It is random, it’s definitely not as random as a coin flip
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by dj_mc_merlin on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:18PM (#34041667)
People are not robots. Penalties do test the nerves of both teams. And besides, the feeling of fairness is more important than actual fairness in football. We don't watch it to get a perfectly stat driven understanding of the game, but because it's fun and emotional.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by mk89 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:44PM (#34042040)
Penalties are not random at all. There is a reason why some teams suck big time on penalties while others nail them all the time (or almost always, depending on the generation, players, etc).
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by huhtenberg on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:38PM (#34043796)
I meant "random" is a sense that it doesn't really reflect which team is better. It's a specific personal skill, but the football is a team sport first and foremost and the world champion status should reflect that.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by h4n1 on Monday December 19, 2022 @06:28AM (#34050914)
If all that matters is to recognize the best team, then why bother with a knockoit stage, or even a world cup tournament? Just collate stats. The point is to play the game, and if both teams are evenly matched in regular play, to move to an acceptable tiebreaker so that someone wins. France has still come a very close 2nd place, which the tournament does reflect.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by amadeuspagel on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:07PM (#34041505)
instead, if it's a draw after 90 minutes, just played until someone scores a goal.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by dj_mc_merlin on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:09PM (#34041536)
They tried that, look up Golden Goal. Most people agreed it was a bad idea.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by coupdejarnac on Sunday December 18, 2022 @05:46PM (#34044827)
It's as if half of the people commenting here watched a soccer game for the first time today, lol. That's fine and all, but it's incredibly unlikely that a neophyte has all the solutions.
Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by Kaibeezy on Sunday December 18, 2022 @03:54PM (#34043223)
They may as well have literally flipped a 70.3/29.7 weighted coin 10 times.

I walked out of the pub in disgust.

Re:Argentina Wins the Football World Cup by gus_massa on Sunday December 18, 2022 @08:17PM (#34046926)
Some goalkeepers are better. Some players are better. Both can be tired, or nervous. Each flip has a different weight. Anyway, people underestimate the amount of randomness in penalties.