News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by jefftk on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:54PM (#34031521)
> Full GAAP audit or we all assume you're broke.

FTX passed a GAAP audit and was still broke. Safer just to take custody of your coins while your still can.

2021-08-27: "Both FTX and FTX.US have completed requirements to pass the US Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) audit" https://blockworks.co/news/ftx-joins-coinbase-kraken-with-us...

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by eftychis on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:27PM (#34031887)
I don't think FTX actually applied or passed GAAP. From the filings it is clear they couldn't have. They barely have records of their liabilities, and definitely not of their assets. I am not even touching co-mingling of different classes of accounts. The statement you are referencing is another lie to customers and investors.

I know they employed a "Decentraland" sketchy "auditor." But that's it. It is like employing me to do your haircut -- you are 100% screwed and not getting a haircut, but some hair will be cut.

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by FormerBandmate on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:41PM (#34032014)
> Both FTX and FTX.US have completed requirements to pass the US Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) audit

This is legally meaningless. Literally anyone can say they completed requirements to pass, they didn't actually pass

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by jefftk on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:01PM (#34032194)
My point is not "FTX's books were in good shape"; with the benefit of hindsight they clearly weren't.

Instead, my point is that an exchange saying that they passed a GAAP audit isn't the level of positive signal my parent seems to think it is.

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:06PM (#34032238)
They didn't say that they passed, just that they claimed to "complete requirements" needed to pass. The financial engineering version of lying with facts like "assembled in USA from foreign components".
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by jefftk on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:12PM (#34032290)
They claimed to have passed:

2021-07-21 "Yesterday, FTX became the first (?) crypto derivatives exchange to complete a GAAP audit!" -- https://mobile.twitter.com/sbf_ftx/status/142135472191111577...

2021-08 -26: "Both @FTX_Official and @ftx_us have passed US GAAP audits and plan to continue getting audits going forward." --https://twitter.com/SBF_FTX/status/1431087427154849795

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by HideousKojima on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:33PM (#34032471)
He doesn't seem to mention what third party completed the audit, and given what we know about FTX's accounting now that means it was either an internal audit or SBF was lying.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by jefftk on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:38PM (#34032512)
Coindesk seems to have obtained the audited financials and reported on them: https://www.coindesk.com/layer2/2022/11/18/a-complete-failur...
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by throwoutway on Sunday December 18, 2022 @10:14AM (#34038424)
I assume they were counting the FTT tokens as actually holding value when they were propped up
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by brazzledazzle on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:03PM (#34032218)
Reading it doesn’t it say they have completed the requirements to pass but haven’t actually passed? Seems like the kind of word play that should send red flags.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:00PM (#34031604)
> FTX passed a GAAP audit

Do we have a source mentioning the auditor?

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by jefftk on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:07PM (#34031685)
Prager Metis for international, Armanino for US: https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/11/11/meet-the-metave...
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:15PM (#34031782)
Prager Metis and Armanino worked with FTX, but I can’t find anything showing they completed an audit. (Far from blameless. Both seem riddled with issues [1].)

[1] https://www.ibtimes.com/crypto-auditors-under-fire-ftx-meltd...

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by mtmail on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:22PM (#34031844)
OP quoted "have completed requirements to pass" so that might be the start of the audit, not passing.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by jefftk on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:39PM (#34032521)
"CoinDesk obtained the audited financial statements of West Realm Shires, also known as FTX US, and FTX Trading Ltd., the combined offshore Bahamas-based entity that includes an exchange catering to non-U.S. customers and Alameda, the proprietary trading operation. It’s not clear why FTX commissioned two different audit firms to audit its 2020 and 2021 financial statements. The reports by Armanino LLP, which signed the report for the U.S. operation, and by Prager Metis LLP, which signed the opinion for the offshore operations, were issued at the end of March 2022."

https://www.coindesk.com/layer2/2022/11/18/a-complete-failur...

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by dragonwriter on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:32PM (#34034526)
> Prager Metis and Armanino worked with FTX, but I can’t find anything showing they completed an audit.

The FTX et al. bankruptcy filing (by the post-SBF CEO) refers to the existence of audited financials for the WRS silo (which includes FTX.US) by Armanino and Dotcom silo (which includes FTX proper) by Prager Metis, with the other silos not having audited financials. This seems to be a fairly strong indication that the audits were completed.

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by fabian2k on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:02PM (#34031635)
FTX had many parts, did that audit actually cover all of them or was that just for a subset of companies?
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by jefftk on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:08PM (#34031696)
It probably didn't cover all of them: all of the announcements I can find from the time just talk about FTX US and International.

But if you're trying to decide whether to keep your money in another exchange, and they talk about how they have passed a GAAP audit "did the audit actually cover everything I care about" is still a live question.

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by coffeebeqn on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:25PM (#34031870)
Basically if you want to keep your money in a regulated institution, don’t use a crypto exchange. You can be your own bank or just sell the crypto and buy some funds where you know some basic facts about where your money is and who can touch it.

I can’t imagine why anyone would risk keeping their assets in binance. Do you know basic facts like which jurisdiction in the world they are even based in? Optimistically it sounds like a 50% chance they are actually fine and 50% chance they’re on the path of FTX. Big risk with no reward other than minor convenience

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by hef19898 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:00PM (#34032193)
No need to speculate, there were to seperate "audits", which were unrelated from each other, and only covered parts of the enterity of FTX. And Pager Matis' selling point seems to have been a Metaverse HQ...
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by dragonwriter on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:34PM (#34034540)
> FTX had many parts, did that audit actually cover all of them or was that just for a subset of companies?

No; this is covered in detail in the FTX et al. bankruptcy filing.

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by RC_ITR on Sunday December 18, 2022 @04:43AM (#34036273)
People seem to forget that the entire point of shell structures is accounting tricks.

Sure FTX (the audited entity) really did have a piece of paper saying “magic beans company owes FTX $1bn in bitcoin” and all a GAAP audit would do is look at that paper and say “yep, this paper is worth $1bn (with maybe some repayment risk discount).” Maybe a good audit team tries to understand who really owns magic beans corp, but it’s easy to hide things like that.

FTX the audited entity could be totally fine, but then the shells are where the problem lies.

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by anovikov on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:24PM (#34031862)
What's the value of coins if with Binance down, most certainly Bitcoin will be down too as it was propped up with fake printed USDT, which will collapse as well, and with them evaporating, every other coin will follow? If Binance falls, all crypto will vanish. And good riddance.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by coffeebeqn on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:32PM (#34031939)
BTC won’t vanish but most all other ones will revert to their natural state outside of the last few years bubble (zero-ish). I’m sure BTC will still be worth some thousands. And I’m a BTC long term skeptic
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by digitaltrees on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:37PM (#34032505)
At least Tulip bulbs can be planted. Crypto just burns electricity. The value of crypto is actually negative at this point.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by m348e912 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:07PM (#34032761)
People have been making the crypto tulip comparison since when bitcoin was worth less than $100. Not saying you're wrong at this point, but if you're right, you're about as right as a broken clock.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by digitaltrees on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:10PM (#34032788)
True but I have been making them from the beginning.

I actually think it would be good for people to see crypto as worthless. Maybe then they would spend it instead of holding it and it could actually act as a currency.

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by lostmsu on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:30PM (#34032956)
> Maybe then they would spend it

Why? Do you want to buy?

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by digitaltrees on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:40PM (#34033033)
Currency should be “bought” it should be used. Earned and spent.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by andirk on Saturday December 17, 2022 @07:28PM (#34033781)
Forex is a very real very gigantic form of investment.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by RC_ITR on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:42PM (#34034589)
If your argument is that a few years of irrational market pricing is meaningful, then boy do I have some Enron shares to sell you in 2001.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by jacquesm on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:20PM (#34034746)
That's definitely true. What - unfortunately in some ways - is also true is that a lot of people cleaned up on both Enron and bitcoin. They did this ultimately at the expense of other people but those people too were trying to do the exact same thing.

It's effectively one group of greedy people feeding off people that are greedy too but a bit later to the musical chairs game. And so they end up without chairs, but if you start such a game you already know that somebody is going to end up without a chair, you just hope it won't be you.

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by bulbosaur123 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:19AM (#34035264)
Not true. Only censorship-resistant asset. Only asset in entire universe that cannot be confiscated.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by moffkalast on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:55PM (#34032148)
Binance just unverified everyone yet again, it's safe to say they're trying to prevent people from pulling out.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by digitaltrees on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:35PM (#34032486)
Maybe CZs attempt to take down a competitor by leaking information wasn’t a good idea after all. Sad to see people hurt as it backfires in his face. No amount of public relations or spin will save binance at this point. The run has begun. It will seem slow at first and then all at once.

The only thing that would save it would be a bail out by the Chinese government.

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by species9606 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:41PM (#34032541)
As CZ has said repeatedly, they’re not a Chinese company. If the CCP bails them out, they’ll have an entirely new set of reputation problems.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by digitaltrees on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:11PM (#34032801)
Probably won’t be a public bailout.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by EFreethought on Saturday December 17, 2022 @06:02PM (#34033192)
Frankly, taking a crypto exec at their word has not been a smart move lately.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by koalala on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:32PM (#34032458)
i just checked this and i'm still verified. i'm in europe though.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by worik on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:09PM (#34032775)
First up, best dressed
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by RealityVoid on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:37PM (#34033008)
I'm also still verified. But I also pulled out all my assets. I don't believe Binance to be on the brink of bankruptcy, but better safe than sorry.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by more_corn on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:18PM (#34034742)
Take your money out while you still can.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by digitaltrees on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:28PM (#34032429)
You can have an audit on Monday and a founder transfer all the assets to an affiliate on Tuesday so timing risk makes this stuff irrelevant.

Maybe time to make crypto decentralized?

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by oblio on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:33PM (#34032466)
> Maybe time to make crypto decentralized?

Is there money in that?

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by stanleydrew on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:54PM (#34033120)
If there were money in that I think we'd have seen it by now.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by conorcleary on Saturday December 17, 2022 @07:20PM (#34033734)
We already have it.
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by m3kw9 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:21PM (#34032901)
How did gaap value their magic coins?
Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by scoofy on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:56PM (#34033137)
Likely marked to market, but it honestly doesn't matter. In a world where wash sales are effectively free from any friction whatsoever, you can set a market value of whatever you want.

I've been a crypto skeptic for all this time especially NFT's exactly because I was at the right age to understand how wash sales drove the dot-com bubble, and looking at the defi space, wash sales could explain how all of these insane valuations kept happening.

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by everybodyknows on Saturday December 17, 2022 @11:40PM (#34035102)
Hmm, could wash trading have played some part in the apparent success of Donald Trump's "digital trading cards"?

https://www.coindesk.com/web3/2022/12/16/trump-nft-collectio...

Re:Binance outflows hit $6B as Mazars halts ‘proof of reserv... by dragonwriter on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:28PM (#34034507)
> FTX passed a GAAP audit and was still broke

Not a finance pro, but as I understand it:

A GAAP audit is not a test for whether or not you are broke.

It is also not a test of whether your financials are honest (except in a very limited sense).

It is a test of whether or not your various pieces of financial information are internally consistent given a standard set of definitions of how pieces should relate, and therefore that summary documents like the balance sheet are accurate, assuming the accuracy of underlying records.

While it is an important quality of work check for internal accounting, if you wouldn’t trust a company without a GAAP audit, there are very few scenarios where having the audit should significantly move the needle of trust.