News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by lotsofpulp on Saturday November 12, 2022 @05:55PM (#33578009)
> Assuming we even make it another 100 years, there is no way to know what our population will look like then, or whether we could not pull another technological/logistical revolution out of our asses, or whether global cultures would start to embrace a further explosion of population.

It seems like women in pretty much all cultures where women achieve financial independence and have control over how many children they have, choose to have 0, 1, 2, or rarely 3. Which makes sense given the risks and costliness of childbirth for them.

So I would guess that any culture that results in population explosion would have to either have medical advances that address the risks and costs of childbirth, or go backwards on women’s independence. Or really sweeten the deal in terms of financial and other incentives, but I don’t imagine that would fare very well.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by prawn on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:17PM (#33578193)
Beyond childbirth, raising children is also a serious challenge, and that’s with school/similar taking care of them for hours of each weekday. Maybe not in developing countries, but I think rearing might be as much a factor as birthing in the developed world when it comes to moderating family size.

I’m not convinced that how we do things now is the best balance of the interests of children and parents. As one example, on weekdays, a parent’s morning time with children is dominated preparing them for school while getting ready to work, and the evening time sees tired post-work parents doing the school run, sorting homework, preparing dinner, extra-curricular, etc.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by throwuwu on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:00AM (#33582637)
Having one full time homemaker smooths things out quite a bit.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by MomoXenosaga on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:17PM (#33585057)
Considering marriages routinely end up in divorce it would be stupid to sacrifice your career.

"Oh I see you have a 15 year gap in your CV" LMAO.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by throwuwu on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:53PM (#33585413)
“I spent the last 15 years raising a happy family and have good relationships with my children” is probably worth a lot more than career advancement and would likely reduce the divorce rate quite a bit. That’s not even considering the broader societal impacts of increased wages for everyone due to restricting labour supply, the creation and maintenance of strong family networks and communities and the improvement of QOL and reduction in expenses you get when you don’t have to outsource food, care, and attention to boxed meals, day care and screens. We only have ourselves to blame for the current mess we’re in.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by throwaway892238 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:11PM (#33578151)
These aren't even the beginning of the factors involved in child birth rates. Population is controlled by religion, government policy, cultural practice, wealth, quality of life, social equality, education, trade, war, climate, and a host of other factors. Any one of them could change and affect the population; multiple could change and shift it radically. And we cannot predict any of them with certainty even in 50 years, much less 100, for the entire planet.

If you don't believe me, look at history. Plenty of times in history there have been great civilizations that grew and grew until they collapsed, or periods of great societal progress followed by periods of great strife, or periods of great feast followed by famine. Some of these periods lasted hundreds of years. Even today there are nations that forcibly control population whereas others do not. Some developing nations starve due to international trade policy while others grow to provide most of their needs. Some become more radically conservative while others grow more liberal. Some countries collapse economically while others become burgeoning super-powers. And all this in the face of global climate change on a scale not seen in millennia.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by lotsofpulp on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:14PM (#33578172)
>religion, government policy, cultural practice, wealth, quality of life, social equality, education, trade, war, climate, and a host of other factors.

Which all are taken into account, by the financially independent woman choosing to get pregnant (because they have access to very effective birth control and are not being forced to have sex, and have abortion as an option).

>And all this in the face of global climate change on a scale not seen in millennia.

I think the biggest thing that has not been seen regarding population dynamics is women having complete control over if, when, and how many children they have.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by throwaway892238 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:19PM (#33578220)
A financially independent woman in some developed countries today still doesn't necessarily get to choose when she will get pregnant, or by whom. Financial independence does not trump social convention (especially since social convention dictates financial independence).

Hell, just look at the USA. A woman still can't choose when she can or can't have a baby, regardless of her wealth. This being one of the supposed "civilized nations"; other nations are far less subtle with their societal controls.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by lotsofpulp on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:20PM (#33578226)
>A financially independent woman in some developed countries today still doesn't necessarily get to choose when she will get pregnant, or by whom.

Then I would say she is not financially independent, since she cannot afford to hire sufficient security to protect her from rape.

>Hell, just look at the USA. A woman still can't choose when she will or won't have a baby, regardless of her wealth.

Unless one is being held captive, one’s wealth should allow access to IUDs and travel to jurisdictions where abortion is legal. At the least, there is sufficient rule of law where the societal norm is that rape is completely unacceptable.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by throwaway892238 on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:29PM (#33578303)
You're about to be downvoted to hell, so allow me to quickly comment that you lack a certain amount of knowledge about the reality of women's reproductive rights in the USA. I'm not talking about rape at all. There are a variety of challenges to women just legally obtaining birth control in the USA, abortion is effectively illegal and unavailable to nearly all women in the USA (once again), and women need abortions for a whole lot more reasons than 'just' being raped.

Although even on that front, it is, well, just completely insane to insinuate that a woman needs to be rich enough to hire a body guard to prevent her from being raped. I can't believe I had to type that sentence.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by lotsofpulp on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:33PM (#33578334)
You will have to provide some sources for your claims, because I have read that quite a few US states have explicitly made abortion legal in recent months. And the Affordable Care Act made birth control free for many, many people:

https://www.cnn.com/2022/11/09/politics/abortion-rights-2022...

https://www.healthcare.gov/coverage/birth-control-benefits/

Also, I am using the term financially free to mean a person who not only has civil rights that would prevent them from ever becoming pregnant without their permission, but also someone who cannot be coerced, such as a woman with sufficient assets or income to sustain (and protect) herself.

>just completely insane to insinuate that a woman needs to be rich enough to hire a body guard to prevent her from being raped.

Yes, unfortunately, some women are born in societies where the concept of rape is not completely rejected.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by jacobriis on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:58PM (#33578503)
"Abortion is effectively illegal and unavailable to nearly all women in the USA"

In reality abortion is readily available until birth in many jurisdictions.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by addingadimensio on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:12PM (#33578594)
Lol how many abortions are preformed yearly in the usa?
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by svieira on Saturday November 12, 2022 @10:13PM (#33579604)
A number of children equal to either the entire population of either Fort Worth, TX or Baltimore, MD (depending on whether or not you believe Guttmacher or the CDC) is killed every year [2].

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b... [2]: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/06/24/what-the-da...

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by nxm on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:41AM (#33582131)
Abortion is not illegal in the US… please read up on what Roe v. Wade overturn actually did - returned the decision to the states.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by unrealhoang on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:37PM (#33578359)
How can all that be taken into account when we are currently living under only one specific configuration? Women under our current configuration do not choose to get pregnant simply because the current society doesn’t value repopulation. When we as a society value a birthing mother more than a successful business person we will have more babies. It’s that simple.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by lotsofpulp on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:40PM (#33578380)
>When we as a society value a birthing mother more than a successful business person we will have more babies. It’s that simple.

This is what I mean. Not that each woman is explicitly evaluating all of those factors, but implicitly, they all culminate in an environment where a woman may or may not choose to have x number of children.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by forkLding on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:06PM (#33578103)
Or there are technological advances in artificial wombs and children are grown in incubators so that women are no longer as involved in pregnancy/child-bearing.

We have research papers with animal fetuses being grown in artificial wombs. Never know, could be some technology developed for humans during the next 100 years.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by lotsofpulp on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:15PM (#33578180)
Yes, I meant to include that in

>medical advances that address the risks and costs of childbirth

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by tough on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:09PM (#33578132)
Damn the matrix is so close

We all batteries in 100 years

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by asdff on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:19PM (#33578641)
Once the machines take over they'd probably prefer to work with yeast as their bio battery of choice. No need to spend compute on a simulation, the yeast would be happy as clams living in a big vat with all nutrient needs met.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by gruez on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:21PM (#33578654)
I don't see why you're linking artificial wombs with the matrix. In a matrix like scenario, I see no reason why the machines would even bother with artificial wombs, when the real ones already work right now (no R&D required) and are already pretty efficient.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by kadoban on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:32PM (#33579358)
Humans make abysmally bad batteries or power generators. That was always the dumbest part of The Matrix. The original idea for that was that we were the computers for the Matrix simulation instead, which made at least marginally more sense.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by staticman2 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:12PM (#33584997)
The original idea was never anything other than batteries.

That rumor of producers changing it to batteries started because Neil Gaiman thought the battery thing was dumb so when he was hired to do a promotional wrote Matrix short story he changed it to the humans being used for computer processing.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by PM_me_your_math on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:13PM (#33578166)
Well, that's not terrifying in the least bit. Imagine knowing that you were born to a machine and not to a woman who you can call mother. On second thought, its not just terrifying, it is immeasurable sadness for most, and probably psychosis for some.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by Supermancho on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:21PM (#33578233)
> Imagine knowing that you were born to a machine and not to a woman who you can call mother.

I'm really not sure what's so outrageous about the situation. Most adopted (or fostered) people manage without psychosis.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by tsol on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:14PM (#33578605)
I mean orphans are well known to have a rough time in life. They're not exactly the stereotype of happiness
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by themihai on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:24PM (#33578663)
Perhaps b/c they are usually neglected just like kids from broken families not b/c they are born from an artificial woomb.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by tialaramex on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:47PM (#33578802)
The biggest downside which appears to be cited by people who discover later that their birth parents weren't the people who brought them up is an uncertainty about why they exist - but for a person who can be told (once they're old enough to understand) the exact circumstances which brought them about that is resolved.

We already have surrogacy, which is when one human volunteers use of their womb to carry somebody else's child (that is, egg comes from person A, sperm from person B, A+B = new human life => fertilised egg is implanted in person C, the surrogate). I know two kids who were born this way, they have loving parents, the eldest will be aware that something is a bit unusual - any other mummies she knows who had a second kid the baby was obviously inside them, whereas her baby sister was inside this other nice lady who just showed up for a few weeks and she's been told that's how it worked for her too - but obviously the tricky details aren't going to be worth explaining to a pre-schooler once they're satisfied with any immediate questions (e.g. is this new baby my sister? Yes. Does the nice lady mean I get extra birthday presents? No)

An artificial womb potentially makes surrogacy an option for larger numbers of people. Some people find pregnancy pretty good really, and their main reason to stop after one or two is economics or practicalities, so this innovation changes nothing for them - but others don't want to risk a second pregnancy after discovering how badly their body reacted the first time, so such technology (if cheap enough) would mean they could have a second or third child.

This also changes the calculus for government intervention. Hiring women to be impregnated is a much more difficult proposition than hiring nursery or orphanage staff. An artificial womb would mean only the second is needed.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by themihai on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:20PM (#33578647)
I'm pretty sure people will do just fine and tbh I don't really see what's so terrifying. It's just biology.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by lostlogin on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:45PM (#33579108)
> its not just terrifying, it is immeasurable sadness for most, and probably psychosis for some.

Much like now.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by pojzon on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:42PM (#33579422)
Not even talking about lack of hormones during natural pregnacy we have zero idea about because this was not researched in humqns and how it would impact a human child post mortem.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by mym1990 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @03:55AM (#33581307)
It would certainly be a shock to some but most kids have no idea where they came from until they learn about the reproductive system. Their first instinct is that a bird dropped them out of the sky. So closing the gap between X and Y wouldnt be too crazy.

Now the social pressures of being a “machine baby” vs “natural womb baby” would be a different thing.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by staticman2 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:08PM (#33584960)
If a child is told they were delivered by a stork do you think they have immeasurable sadness?

If we invent artificial womb's the egg is still coming out of the mother's body.

The egg still get inseminated by a father.

Why should anyone care whether the mother painfully forced the baby out of the vagina after 9 months?

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by tejtm on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:01PM (#33578888)
"alumawomb" a word read in a graphic novel half a century ago.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by XorNot on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:06PM (#33578910)
Having a baby, despite the risks, is still "the easy part".

Raising the baby is the hard part, and no one's lining up to make that easier.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by dbjacobs on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:25PM (#33578266)
Artificial wombs would take care of the risk to women issue. Then it just becomes a societal values question.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by usrusr on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:42PM (#33578397)
But those women who do have three pass it on to more next generation women than those who have zero. Pretty much every culture will slowly transform itself into a variation where three isn't quite as rare as it used to be, unless bounded by external factors like resource exhaustion.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by CapitalistCartr on Saturday November 12, 2022 @06:46PM (#33578422)
Number of children chosen is not genetically heritable. We overwhelmingly descended from larger families, yet most in rich countries choose fewer.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by tluyben2 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @02:40AM (#33580918)
There were reasons for having kids and also lot more kids in the past; death or chronic illness of some of them, needing kids to take care of the elderly and work the lands and, the one many forget; religion nonsense as in not being allowed sex if not for reproduction.

In the village where I was raised, all families had kids until the wife cannot have them anymore or dies because of that. And because of the rapid decline of religion over there, it was pretty much inbreeding as there are not many candidates that want a life like that outside these families, so always some of them have massive defects (my neighbour had a son born without a left arm, a blind daughter, a son with a disabling low iq, and more like that).

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by haihaibye on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:27AM (#33581454)
> Number of children chosen is not genetically heritable

You mean it's not 100% genetic... very little is. But very little is 0% genetic

Twin study has .35 correlation between identical twins but .21 for non identical

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10519-016-9805-3

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by usrusr on Sunday November 13, 2022 @10:01AM (#33583636)
It gets passed on just fine culturally
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rayiner on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:04PM (#33578537)
Define “women’s independence?” Fertility rates in the US cratered after 2008, but before that even states without many Hispanics like Idaho, South Dakota, Nebraska, and Wyoming had above replacement total fertility rates. I know folks on HN think those states might as well be third world countries, but they’re not exactly Gilead.

American women say they want closer to three kids than two kids: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/13/upshot/american-fertility... (average 2.7). Half of women with kids, and even 30% of women overall with a college degree, would prefer a homemaker role to working: https://news.gallup.com/poll/267737/record-high-women-prefer.... These women would probably have more kids if it was easier to have a single income household.

I suspect “logistics” has more to do with it than “independence.” Our education system and economy, in particular, causes people to spread out and move away from family. Raising kids without family around is much, much more difficult.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by VictorPath on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:16PM (#33578950)
> Fertility rates in the US cratered after 2008...These women would probably have more kids if it was easier to have a single income household...Our education system and economy, in particular, causes people to spread out and move away from family.

You might as well talk about how women might raise their children on Mars. Outside the Amazon jungle, for the past 10000 years women have been raising children under class-based society under class-based relations of production. The ruling class makes decisions about production, that's the point of a class-based society. Thus the world is turning into a place where the purpose of women's fertility is reproduction of labor, not an increase of it. The ruling class prefers two educated, productive children to three or four less educated, less productive children.

It doesn't matter what working class women want in terms of children, because this is a class-based society, and the ruling class has things aligned to what is good for them, not her.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by protomyth on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:29PM (#33579014)
Are you intentionally ignoring the large Native American population in some of those states?
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rayiner on Saturday November 12, 2022 @11:08PM (#33579939)
Native American fertility rates are sadly extremely low. They fell from 1.62 in 2008 to just 1.23 in 2016: https://ifstudies.org/blog/baby-bust-fertility-is-declining-...
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by jvanderbot on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:07PM (#33579240)
> I suspect “logistics” has more to do with it than “independence.” Our education system and economy, in particular, causes people to spread out and move away from family. Raising kids without family around is much, much more difficult.

I experienced this first hand. I moved to follow career with my wife, who also has an extraordinary career compared to median. We delayed and struggled to find the right time to start a family. The whole dynamic of planning the start of your family was self defeating. There's no good time to have kids while prioritizing career...

So we took the plunge, had kids, made it 6 months, and moved back to be near our family.

In retrospect it is obvious that the narrative of success being concentrated in gross salary was poisoning our lives and forcing us to make unhealthy decisions to live in awful situations. We're "richer" in our hometown by a long shot, when you calculate the slush money left over after cost of living, babysitters, day care, housing, even cars. Not to mention the joy of having a big family that the kiddos can play with all the time.

If we had realized this in our 20s, I'm sure we would happily have had 4 or more kids and accepted half the money overall for the same net takehome.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Saturday November 12, 2022 @10:04PM (#33579540)
Feminist made motherhood and home making unsexy so nowadays a lot of women just feel compelled to grind themselves in the jobs they do not want to do.

Men and women are fundamentally different on biological and emotional plane. They complement each other. But instead they are being forced to compete. It's time to recognise and change this.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by maximus-decimus on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:13AM (#33580277)
I'm sure a lot of men would rather be house husbands too rather than grinding at a job they hate.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by Fricken on Sunday November 13, 2022 @01:30AM (#33580621)
Separation of gender roles is a human universal. Meaning it is a trait observable in every human society that can be observed.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by mym1990 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @03:51AM (#33581285)
Citation?
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:02AM (#33582652)
Read history and try to find citation for the contrary of you can.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by skinnymuch on Sunday November 13, 2022 @10:13AM (#33583729)
Do you think women have always been the secondary “submissive” gentile gender? There’s a lot of cultures and a lot of history.

This is similar to people saying trans people have never existed. Instead of seeing the western world as abnormally sexist, homophobic, and transphobic. IE the way the British treated hijras (men identifying with feminine traits) when they took over India in the late 1800s. Before and since then (though this is affected by how awful the British were), hijras weren’t treated equally, but much better than the abusive and bigoted Europeans.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @11:56AM (#33584836)
Women having equal or higher status doesn't require them to take masculine roles. Feminity is neither submissive nor inferior.

I am aware of status of women in my own country India before invaders came.I won't go into the ancient history. But women like Ahilyabai Holkar, Laxmibai existed not too long ago.Both of them rose to the occassion. But my point stands that women generally do not enjoy these types of roles. Love, affection, child rearing, and home making comes more naturally to them then going out and picking fights.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by mym1990 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:27PM (#33589236)
There are plenty of examples of matriarchal societies, both in the past and current. The problem with people like you is that you feel entitled to tell others where their place is in the world, and thank god the world is slowly turning against that kind of nonsense.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by Fricken on Sunday November 13, 2022 @11:41AM (#33584707)
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by mym1990 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:29PM (#33589246)
Thank you for this!
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by jokethrowaway on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:25AM (#33581442)
That's very true but only because males are behaving more and more like females.

Being a house husband doesn't bode well with psychological traits where the extremes sit in the male population (which are responsible for things like men doing all the dangerous jobs, men being most of the inmates in prisons, men being the ones most likely to die in war).

I certainly hated my paternity leave and, anecdotally, I've heard from many peers who would have preferred to just work over taking care of their children. It's fine for a limited amount of time, but I can't tolerate that full time.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by gopher_space on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:52AM (#33581579)
> That's very true but only because males are behaving more and more like females.

Do you think a post bellyaching about simply having a family makes you sound masculine?

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:23PM (#33588458)
What makes you think masculanity == no emotion?

Men wanting propagation of life by desiring offspring makes them not men?

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by gopher_space on Sunday November 13, 2022 @07:49PM (#33588999)
It means not whining about your fundamental responsibilities in life, to start with.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @09:45PM (#33589703)
What makes you think men do that?
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by nxm on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:34AM (#33582094)
Perhaps some over-feminized men would, but I definitely would not.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @07:52AM (#33582586)
Can you present some evidence from history or psychological evidence?

Throughout the history men have fought war and died in wars. How many wars were fought by women?

In modern times women are in the defense forces, how many women have chosen combat duties and made supreme sacrifices?

Ofcourse there are exception.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by staticman2 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @11:58AM (#33584863)
Men don't want to be house husbands because they want to fight in wars?

Are you a man and should I assume you signed up for every war, as your Y chromosone dictated?

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:08PM (#33588347)
I am speaking about gender roles with war as an historical example.

> Are you a man and should I assume you signed up for every war, as your Y chromosone dictated?

Are you arguing men aren't predisposed to solve their problems physically? If this behaviour is uniformly distributed across men and women then why you don"t see equal number of crimes by either genders.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by staticman2 on Monday November 14, 2022 @05:33PM (#33602293)
We were talking about how many men today want to be a househusband. I fail to see what that has to do with historical wars. The comparison would be men today and if they are signing up for wars. Are you? If not why bring up war?

Also we were talking about what men want.

Does the fact men fought in wars imply they wanted to fight in wars?

Did men in history during times on peace sit around saying to themself 'I hope someone starts a war so I have an excuse to stab a guy and get away from my wife and kids?'

"Are you arguing men aren't predisposed to solve their problems physically?"

Assuming you are a man... unless you are Tony Soprano and you go around hitting people with a baseball bat you probably don't "solve your problems physically".

So why write a sentence like "Are you arguing men aren't predisposed to solve their problems physically"

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by 1659447091 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:50PM (#33588613)
>> Throughout the history men have fought war and died in wars. How many wars were fought by women?

This makes it sound like the world would be better off if all the men stayed home raising the kids and away from things like international relations while having the women take care of all the larger societal functions

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @09:43PM (#33589685)
I agree. Women are much better at organizing societies and solving problem non voilently. India have seen many such queens all through the history[0]. Queens like Ahilyabai Holkar, Naiki Devi, Rani Durgavati are from recent history. Indian society appreciated motherhood. But it also accepted women freely in the roles traditionally reserved for men. This is the society I want with additional reforms.

Issue with recent activism is two folds. Tendency to demean the motherhood and also make men feel guilty for being their natural self. This is I do not want.

[0] https://www.thebetterindia.com/292468/brave-indian-queens-in...

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by jokethrowaway on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:28AM (#33581464)
It's mostly ideological.

Most of my rich friends in tech who take CNN seriously, don't want kids.

Whether it's to save the environment or because having kids has been painted like the ultimate martyrdom and having casual sex until you're 50 as the best thing in the world.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rtpg on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:24AM (#33582038)
You’re in a bubble if you think that people are not having kids to save the environment
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by nxm on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:33AM (#33582088)
There’s a percentage of couples that unfortunately have internalized the drama/scare around climate change that this is the case for.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rtpg on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:35AM (#33582101)
This is not a serious or widespread thing that people believe. Go look at some actual polls to see what people believe on a macro level
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by pwgentleman on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:19PM (#33585074)
I've been to a company event a couple years ago, for a big Scandinavian tech company, and the main speaker's point was this: The best thing you can do for the environment, better than recycling, cycling instead of driving a car, etc., is having one less child. So it doesn't seem to be that fringe, unfortunately.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rtpg on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:06PM (#33588327)
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/11/19/growing-sha...

2.5%. That is nothing of nothing. It is a non-event, and dwarfed by “I just don’t want kids” or “financial reasons”. Now that’s not “why do you have 2 kids instead of 3” but yeah.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by msmenardi on Monday November 14, 2022 @08:23PM (#33604031)
You're confusing the impact of the decision with the prevalence of belief in it. While that may objectively be the best way to combat climate change, it doesn't imply anything about how many people are making that decision for that reason.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by loeg on Sunday November 13, 2022 @07:17PM (#33588804)
The percentage starts with a zero.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by MomoXenosaga on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:13PM (#33585013)
Also Christ. The oddest thing for me about America is that the power of churches never cratered.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rippercushions on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:32PM (#33578728)
The "problem" with kids is not so much childbirth as the following 20-odd years. Childcare is hugely expensive in terms of money and opportunity cost, and we can't just outsource it to grandparents or set the tykes to work hoeing potatoes at eight any more.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by bamboozled on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:56PM (#33578851)
Grandparents have too much to do now ha, driving RVs etc.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by nxm on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:36AM (#33582104)
Or just continue working post retirement age as a way to keep active.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by throwuwu on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:01AM (#33582650)
If they need a way to keep active, taking care of kids fits the bill.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by _0ffh on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:03PM (#33579215)
Or cultures that do not have unsustainably low birth rates might simply supplant the ones that have, as they die out.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by pojzon on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:37PM (#33579392)
> go backwards on women’s independence

Many many countries recently went this path. Look at USA or Poland where abortion was forBiden.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by onetimeusename on Sunday November 13, 2022 @02:09AM (#33580775)
There is an inverse relationship between income and fertility[1]. If costs were the reason people were having fewer children then why would the poorest people be having more children than the highest earners? It's either we have a very backwards welfare incentive that actually reduces poor women's "independence" or something else is going on. In reality, if you, as a woman, focus on your career until you are 35, implying a higher salary, and then find your fertility has dropped to < 10% of what it was when you were 20 I am sure you start having fewer children.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Income_and_fertility