News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rayiner on Saturday November 12, 2022 @07:04PM (#33578537)
Define “women’s independence?” Fertility rates in the US cratered after 2008, but before that even states without many Hispanics like Idaho, South Dakota, Nebraska, and Wyoming had above replacement total fertility rates. I know folks on HN think those states might as well be third world countries, but they’re not exactly Gilead.

American women say they want closer to three kids than two kids: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/13/upshot/american-fertility... (average 2.7). Half of women with kids, and even 30% of women overall with a college degree, would prefer a homemaker role to working: https://news.gallup.com/poll/267737/record-high-women-prefer.... These women would probably have more kids if it was easier to have a single income household.

I suspect “logistics” has more to do with it than “independence.” Our education system and economy, in particular, causes people to spread out and move away from family. Raising kids without family around is much, much more difficult.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by VictorPath on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:16PM (#33578950)
> Fertility rates in the US cratered after 2008...These women would probably have more kids if it was easier to have a single income household...Our education system and economy, in particular, causes people to spread out and move away from family.

You might as well talk about how women might raise their children on Mars. Outside the Amazon jungle, for the past 10000 years women have been raising children under class-based society under class-based relations of production. The ruling class makes decisions about production, that's the point of a class-based society. Thus the world is turning into a place where the purpose of women's fertility is reproduction of labor, not an increase of it. The ruling class prefers two educated, productive children to three or four less educated, less productive children.

It doesn't matter what working class women want in terms of children, because this is a class-based society, and the ruling class has things aligned to what is good for them, not her.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by protomyth on Saturday November 12, 2022 @08:29PM (#33579014)
Are you intentionally ignoring the large Native American population in some of those states?
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rayiner on Saturday November 12, 2022 @11:08PM (#33579939)
Native American fertility rates are sadly extremely low. They fell from 1.62 in 2008 to just 1.23 in 2016: https://ifstudies.org/blog/baby-bust-fertility-is-declining-...
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by jvanderbot on Saturday November 12, 2022 @09:07PM (#33579240)
> I suspect “logistics” has more to do with it than “independence.” Our education system and economy, in particular, causes people to spread out and move away from family. Raising kids without family around is much, much more difficult.

I experienced this first hand. I moved to follow career with my wife, who also has an extraordinary career compared to median. We delayed and struggled to find the right time to start a family. The whole dynamic of planning the start of your family was self defeating. There's no good time to have kids while prioritizing career...

So we took the plunge, had kids, made it 6 months, and moved back to be near our family.

In retrospect it is obvious that the narrative of success being concentrated in gross salary was poisoning our lives and forcing us to make unhealthy decisions to live in awful situations. We're "richer" in our hometown by a long shot, when you calculate the slush money left over after cost of living, babysitters, day care, housing, even cars. Not to mention the joy of having a big family that the kiddos can play with all the time.

If we had realized this in our 20s, I'm sure we would happily have had 4 or more kids and accepted half the money overall for the same net takehome.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Saturday November 12, 2022 @10:04PM (#33579540)
Feminist made motherhood and home making unsexy so nowadays a lot of women just feel compelled to grind themselves in the jobs they do not want to do.

Men and women are fundamentally different on biological and emotional plane. They complement each other. But instead they are being forced to compete. It's time to recognise and change this.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by maximus-decimus on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:13AM (#33580277)
I'm sure a lot of men would rather be house husbands too rather than grinding at a job they hate.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by Fricken on Sunday November 13, 2022 @01:30AM (#33580621)
Separation of gender roles is a human universal. Meaning it is a trait observable in every human society that can be observed.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by mym1990 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @03:51AM (#33581285)
Citation?
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:02AM (#33582652)
Read history and try to find citation for the contrary of you can.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by skinnymuch on Sunday November 13, 2022 @10:13AM (#33583729)
Do you think women have always been the secondary “submissive” gentile gender? There’s a lot of cultures and a lot of history.

This is similar to people saying trans people have never existed. Instead of seeing the western world as abnormally sexist, homophobic, and transphobic. IE the way the British treated hijras (men identifying with feminine traits) when they took over India in the late 1800s. Before and since then (though this is affected by how awful the British were), hijras weren’t treated equally, but much better than the abusive and bigoted Europeans.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @11:56AM (#33584836)
Women having equal or higher status doesn't require them to take masculine roles. Feminity is neither submissive nor inferior.

I am aware of status of women in my own country India before invaders came.I won't go into the ancient history. But women like Ahilyabai Holkar, Laxmibai existed not too long ago.Both of them rose to the occassion. But my point stands that women generally do not enjoy these types of roles. Love, affection, child rearing, and home making comes more naturally to them then going out and picking fights.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by mym1990 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:27PM (#33589236)
There are plenty of examples of matriarchal societies, both in the past and current. The problem with people like you is that you feel entitled to tell others where their place is in the world, and thank god the world is slowly turning against that kind of nonsense.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by Fricken on Sunday November 13, 2022 @11:41AM (#33584707)
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by mym1990 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @08:29PM (#33589246)
Thank you for this!
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by jokethrowaway on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:25AM (#33581442)
That's very true but only because males are behaving more and more like females.

Being a house husband doesn't bode well with psychological traits where the extremes sit in the male population (which are responsible for things like men doing all the dangerous jobs, men being most of the inmates in prisons, men being the ones most likely to die in war).

I certainly hated my paternity leave and, anecdotally, I've heard from many peers who would have preferred to just work over taking care of their children. It's fine for a limited amount of time, but I can't tolerate that full time.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by gopher_space on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:52AM (#33581579)
> That's very true but only because males are behaving more and more like females.

Do you think a post bellyaching about simply having a family makes you sound masculine?

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:23PM (#33588458)
What makes you think masculanity == no emotion?

Men wanting propagation of life by desiring offspring makes them not men?

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by gopher_space on Sunday November 13, 2022 @07:49PM (#33588999)
It means not whining about your fundamental responsibilities in life, to start with.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @09:45PM (#33589703)
What makes you think men do that?
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by nxm on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:34AM (#33582094)
Perhaps some over-feminized men would, but I definitely would not.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @07:52AM (#33582586)
Can you present some evidence from history or psychological evidence?

Throughout the history men have fought war and died in wars. How many wars were fought by women?

In modern times women are in the defense forces, how many women have chosen combat duties and made supreme sacrifices?

Ofcourse there are exception.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by staticman2 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @11:58AM (#33584863)
Men don't want to be house husbands because they want to fight in wars?

Are you a man and should I assume you signed up for every war, as your Y chromosone dictated?

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:08PM (#33588347)
I am speaking about gender roles with war as an historical example.

> Are you a man and should I assume you signed up for every war, as your Y chromosone dictated?

Are you arguing men aren't predisposed to solve their problems physically? If this behaviour is uniformly distributed across men and women then why you don"t see equal number of crimes by either genders.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by staticman2 on Monday November 14, 2022 @05:33PM (#33602293)
We were talking about how many men today want to be a househusband. I fail to see what that has to do with historical wars. The comparison would be men today and if they are signing up for wars. Are you? If not why bring up war?

Also we were talking about what men want.

Does the fact men fought in wars imply they wanted to fight in wars?

Did men in history during times on peace sit around saying to themself 'I hope someone starts a war so I have an excuse to stab a guy and get away from my wife and kids?'

"Are you arguing men aren't predisposed to solve their problems physically?"

Assuming you are a man... unless you are Tony Soprano and you go around hitting people with a baseball bat you probably don't "solve your problems physically".

So why write a sentence like "Are you arguing men aren't predisposed to solve their problems physically"

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by 1659447091 on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:50PM (#33588613)
>> Throughout the history men have fought war and died in wars. How many wars were fought by women?

This makes it sound like the world would be better off if all the men stayed home raising the kids and away from things like international relations while having the women take care of all the larger societal functions

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by sudhirc on Sunday November 13, 2022 @09:43PM (#33589685)
I agree. Women are much better at organizing societies and solving problem non voilently. India have seen many such queens all through the history[0]. Queens like Ahilyabai Holkar, Naiki Devi, Rani Durgavati are from recent history. Indian society appreciated motherhood. But it also accepted women freely in the roles traditionally reserved for men. This is the society I want with additional reforms.

Issue with recent activism is two folds. Tendency to demean the motherhood and also make men feel guilty for being their natural self. This is I do not want.

[0] https://www.thebetterindia.com/292468/brave-indian-queens-in...

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by jokethrowaway on Sunday November 13, 2022 @04:28AM (#33581464)
It's mostly ideological.

Most of my rich friends in tech who take CNN seriously, don't want kids.

Whether it's to save the environment or because having kids has been painted like the ultimate martyrdom and having casual sex until you're 50 as the best thing in the world.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rtpg on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:24AM (#33582038)
You’re in a bubble if you think that people are not having kids to save the environment
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by nxm on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:33AM (#33582088)
There’s a percentage of couples that unfortunately have internalized the drama/scare around climate change that this is the case for.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rtpg on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:35AM (#33582101)
This is not a serious or widespread thing that people believe. Go look at some actual polls to see what people believe on a macro level
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by pwgentleman on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:19PM (#33585074)
I've been to a company event a couple years ago, for a big Scandinavian tech company, and the main speaker's point was this: The best thing you can do for the environment, better than recycling, cycling instead of driving a car, etc., is having one less child. So it doesn't seem to be that fringe, unfortunately.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by rtpg on Sunday November 13, 2022 @06:06PM (#33588327)
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/11/19/growing-sha...

2.5%. That is nothing of nothing. It is a non-event, and dwarfed by “I just don’t want kids” or “financial reasons”. Now that’s not “why do you have 2 kids instead of 3” but yeah.

Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by msmenardi on Monday November 14, 2022 @08:23PM (#33604031)
You're confusing the impact of the decision with the prevalence of belief in it. While that may objectively be the best way to combat climate change, it doesn't imply anything about how many people are making that decision for that reason.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by loeg on Sunday November 13, 2022 @07:17PM (#33588804)
The percentage starts with a zero.
Re:There are now 8B of us – but soon we'll hit a decline we'... by MomoXenosaga on Sunday November 13, 2022 @12:13PM (#33585013)
Also Christ. The oddest thing for me about America is that the power of churches never cratered.