That doesn't seems to be right. Oryx lists 1450 lost Russian tanks, of which destroyed: 835, damaged: 62, abandoned: 53, captured: 500.
And these are only the visually confirmed losses.
https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-docum...
The "this is all Ukraine's fault!" talking point has been around since before the war. Absurd, but definitely around.
If you think the statement is false, you could provide evidence-based arguments. For example, it should be possible to check whether NATO provided safety guarantees or not (it is an objective statement).
Obviously, given military, economic, media, etc superiority, NATO can do whatever to whomever with impunity.
If you think, there are no plans to dismantle Russia, why NATO refuses to make it official? (however little it might mean, given the history)
Look into who made a fat profit on all this tragedy. Cui bono. Make your own conclusions based on the facts.
It doesn't seem to matter, they'll keep repeating it, ad nauseam...
From this comment on Hacker News [1]:
>> The Soviets brokered a deal with us. We agreed NATO would not expand eastwards.
> This is simply not true. It is a talking point developed for Putin's speech at 2007 Munich security conference to justify the shift to genocidal wars against its neighbors. It did not exist before 2007 and was not brought up when, for example, Poland joined NATO in 1999. There was an endless stream of whining and unspecified threats from Russian diplomats at the time, but not once do I remember talk about any deals.
> It's nothing more than a simple, yet effective hook for catching western self-flagellants into their net, while the truth is that western governments went above and beyond to accommodate Russia and build cooperation, and it still lead to a maniacal dictatorship carrying out genocide in Europe and threatening rest of the world with hunger and nuclear armageddon.
So at the very least there were promises.
What on earth makes you think that?
Honestly I think if Putin pulled out he'd be fine -- most of the opposition is dead, running scared, or on his team. A lot of Russian assets have been frozen, though, and if he wants to get those back he'd have to walk away from his 2014 gains, or else justify why all of that $$$ is gone.
As long as we keep sending bullets and shells and missiles and training new soldiers, Ukrainians seem willing to defend their sovereign rights. Anyone saying Ukraine should give up, in any way, is doing the kremlin's job, whether they realize it or not. Putin is the only one who benefits
Win it, ideally.
> Ukraine's position is more righteous here.
No shit.
Can they afford fresh forces? Can they afford to replace the hardware they've already lost?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum
> The memoranda, signed in Patria Hall at the Budapest Convention Center with US Ambassador Donald M. Blinken amongst others in attendance, prohibited the Russian Federation, the United Kingdom and the United States from threatening or using military force or economic coercion against Ukraine, Belarus, and Kazakhstan, "except in self-defence or otherwise in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations." As a result of other agreements and the memorandum, between 1993 and 1996, Belarus, Kazakhstan and Ukraine gave up their nuclear weapons.
There's no reason to believe any new one would be better respected by Russia; it'd be just an opportunity for Russia to rest, rearm, and invest in propaganda efforts.
They've been prepping defenses on the left bank for most of a month.
It's not just a smear, there's actual history behind the moniker (https://www.salon.com/2021/10/21/rachel-maddow-explains-orig...)
For sure. More revealing is what's said internally about their own.
"There’s two people I think Putin pays: Rohrabacher and Trump." - Kevin McCarthy
McConnell's no MAGA, but he's not really in full control of the Party any longer.
I agree with you the war needs to end. In a just world the US would lead the deescalation, but don't expect that to happen without offering the military industrial complex a replacement sandbox.
Are you seriously stating that because Putin didn't further invade during Trump's presidency, a president who was keen on taking down NATO and the alliance between EUA-EU wasn't playing in the hands of Putin?
What exactly should have Putin done so you could see that? Just further invading Ukraine is the only point you can see for that?
It seriously tires me out to have to read this bullshit on Hacker News.
Lots of strategic reasons to wait until 2022, not factoring his suspected health issues.
If Putin had a puppet in the White house he would have invaded. The US could block all NATO support. No one in Europe is going to against the US on military matters. This is the biggest advantage he could possibly have.
How do we know there wasn't a big GOP win?
The election outcome of several Senate seats is still unknown at this moment, and at least one is going to a run-off, so I doubt this was central to their decision making.
Despite Russia's now openly admitted US election interference, I don't think they have more foresight into actual election outcomes than the US itself does.
I'm not discounting your logic, though. Clearly the GOP has expressed intent to reduce US support for Ukraine. It's just too early to apply the logic to the situation on the ground.
I guess it depends on how you define "big". A supermajority in the Senate was never in the cards. A majority, however slim, would still be (per my own definition) a big win for the GOP.
> They'd need unity on fucking Ukraine over; it seems unlikely all ~51 would be on board here given the popularity of the Ukranians in the war in the US.
I think this is partially because Americans haven't felt the brunt of increased energy prices caused by the war to the degree that Europeans and others have.
If/when that impact hits, the fact that half the country listens to media personalities that are openly supportive of the Russian side and are happy to suggest that appeasing Russia would bring down energy prices, suggests to me that public opinion could change pretty quickly.
And I'll give the GOP credit for one thing: they have listened to what their base voters actually wanted (regardless of the morality of it) and they changed their tune.
I'd love to be wrong, but doubt many people are willing to put the Ukrainians rights to peoplehood over the price of gas at the pump.
> I think this is partially because Americans haven't felt the brunt of increased energy prices caused by the war to the degree that Europeans and others have.
European polling remains very strongly pro-Ukraine, despite already massive hits to energy costs. 62-14 in the UK (https://www.ipsos.com/en-uk/public-continues-support-britain...), 70-21 in Germany (https://www.euractiv.com/section/energy-environment/news/ger...). Those costs are easing now, as well, as Europe has successfully filled up significant reserves and had a very mild November.
I agree, but Europeans are willing to stand their ground despite high energy prices because an uncountered Russia is literally an existential issue for them. They will keep their thermostats at 18C this winter if that's what it takes, just like Americans sacrificed at home during WW2 after the war came to our territory.
But that's not the case in the US today. Biden knows this, which is why he went har in hand to the Saudis asking them to increase production, only to get double-crossed shorty thereafter.
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6d/US_oil_p...
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c1/US_Natur...
> pointless bloodbath needs to end
Yes, it does, right after Ukraine's territory is restored and the 1M or so people that have been relocated to Russia are returned home.
One of the lessons of WWI was heavy-handed reparations create more even larger problems. It took WWII to clean it up the mess, and while the de facto military dictatorship that emerged under the Kaiser was was bad, the Nazi replacement was far, far, far worse.
What is important is that whatever end this comes to puts an end to wars of territorial conquest like this. They make little sense in the modern world, and are an absurd waste of life and wealth. After the war, Ukraine will become a NATO country, and the west will invest heavily in rebuilding and GDP will grow. So long as the people of Russia tolerate totalitarian rule, they will live with stagnant growth and dim future. If the people of Russia can once again open up, maybe that future will be different.
Any of the debates have been on the _method_ and _extent_ of support, not _whether or not to support_. Both red and blue have had objections to types of aide being sent for legit national security concerns (for instance, classified fire control systems on 155mm artillery).
More meat into the grinder.