I would reckon they would change it for a v2 but they need to recoup costs first, but I could be wrong.
Lock picking (even raking or bumping) seems like the kind of thing that someone smart enough to figure out how to do is also smart enough not to engage in home burglary.
So unless your threat model is the three letter agencies entering and bugging your house, I assume other physical security upgrades should come first.
You get notified if unusual movement within your property is detected rather than you having to do the boring task of reviewing surveillance footage.
If they canvas your house and see a shitty, easily bumped lock, you are now an easier target and they're more likely to break in.
I reckon opportunistic break ins it wouldn't make a big difference whether it's this lock or a better one though.
So, other than picking, there's a bunch. There's snapping the cylinder, which is common in the UK and only takes pliers, there's using a crowbar against the door to move the frame out of the way around the latch, breaking windows, and more.
My threat model doesn't include pickers, for sure, but I'm particularly angry about this product because it's visually distinctive and famous, so unlike a regular lock which is basically a roll of the dice as to its quality, this quietly screams for attention and that's a problem. Thieves do canvas houses looking for targets.
Meanwhile, lockpicking has a chance of looking no different from the rightful owner using a key, especially at a distance, is relatively quiet, and leaves basically no trace.
The three letter agencies will have no problems gaining access to a house via picking a lock.
Their ability to access without detection extends beyond that.
On top of that, let’s be honest, if they want to bug someone, they will just access the mic on their phone, Alexa device, smart tv, etc.
If you look at it a certain way, this isn't really a defect: when this lock gets bricked by a firmware update or recruited into a botnet, you won't be trapped on your porch for too long before your neighbor's kid can let you in.
But also, full agree on "our goal is to be better than an open window." I hope they don't extend a job offer to that marketing intern.
But then again, all press is good press
And a reputation cost for not.
The presence of an Apple specific model at a higher cost (adding NFC for HomeKey entry, which works even if your phone/watch battery is dead) caused it to get pushed onto the LPL's radar.
Putting security pins in there wouldn't have involved any engineering at all.
For another data point, I never managed to pick locks in my twenties, but something aligned for me in an evening lock picking course in my sixties, and I picked everything in the room. One wants a training set of locks to learn on, one pin, two pins, three pins, ... then one learns easily. It also helps that with age one's brain quiets down. To pick a lock, you need to listen to it.
I asked the organizers, surely they had something that would stump me. They handed me an American padlock identical to one I'd been buying for years. It stumped me.
It took LPL more than one pass to pick a basic American. He made it look easy, still reassuring me there was some skill involved:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oaP1nFZ9AXE
Videos by others describe more advanced American locks that took several months to overcome. American takes basic countermeasures, that Level could have easily adopted.
I don't know about serrated pins though!
I think the point is, almost anyone with 5 minutes to watch a video on basic techniques (or who is interested in spending 30 minutes just messing around with no prior knowledge) could probably pick this very expensive lock.
To do what you're describing, some people wouldn't get it, and for those that can do it (most, with some practice), it'll probably take 30 minutes to an hour of practice - or a day or so for the outliers.
It's a huge difference in difficulty between the two for a few cents in parts.
For those who don't know, watch LPLs videos on this brand and you'll see what's level of security they offer (basically none)
0: video https://youtu.be/WpbKOL1cM34
Even "real lock companies" are not immune from selling shiny gadgetry with misleading marketing
That said, I do intend to re-core and re-key it someday.
Regardless, if someone is intent on breaking into a house, I doubt a locked door is going to do anything. Not only are windows abundant, but even exterior doors seem to have gotten cheaper and thinner than days of yore.
No, $10 lock would not be as effective as $330 lock in displaying someone's vanity and Apple cult membership.
Having your lock defeated by the LPL is just normal as he's an expert at doing in. Many skilled locksmiths cannot open locks he able to do. Not guarding against raking and bumping, that's shameful for an exterior door lock. Then doubling down on their failure, that's Baghdad Bob level of PR right there.