News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by endisneigh on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:17AM (#33357772)
Apple will be the one to win VR. They’ll wait until the very last possible moment. All Meta is doing is making their R&D cheaper.

Google should bring back Cardboard. Even with crappy quality, people will try it out for $10.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by duxup on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:31AM (#33358038)
I never understood why Google did the cardboard thing and ... didn't keep fiddling with it. It got so much attention and was a lot of fun.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by mcv on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:39AM (#33358182)
I still use mine occasionally. I'm not using it for anything spectacular, but every once in a while there's an AR thing or a Youtube video that's worth watching that way.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by raztogt21 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:42AM (#33358246)
because it's Google
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by csours on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:46AM (#33358311)
I had a friend who used it and it overheated her phone. It had problems after that. I never used the cardboard kit I got because of that story. I have no idea what the failure rate data was, but anecdotes are enough to kill a product.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by farnsworth on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:00AM (#33358558)
If an app breaks your phone, it's the phone's fault.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by csours on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:20PM (#33359882)
Sure, but it's still broken.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by antifa on Friday October 28, 2022 @11:30AM (#33372663)
IDK, that just sounds like any android phone I've ever owned after any 3D game I've ever played on it.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by ianburrell on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:49PM (#33360382)
They did keep working on it and released Daydream, which was dedicated holder for phone. They included VR support in Android and there were a few supported phones. But they canceled it and removed compatibility from OS. I still have mine, which was free with a Pixel phone, but not sure I can use it.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by Ekaros on Saturday October 29, 2022 @04:04AM (#33382020)
To me it made sense as cheap technology demonstration. Maybe allowing something further.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by twen_ty on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:29AM (#33357994)
I think you missed the most important point - no one wants VR apart from a niche audience.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by emadabdulrahim on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:34AM (#33358094)
No one wants VR because in its current state it simply sucks and is quite expensive for general adoption.

In the early days no one wanted computers either.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by mcv on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:40AM (#33358205)
And VR will continue to suck if it remains tied to Facebook, like the Oculus stuff.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by rahimnathwani on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:47AM (#33358350)
The Oculus stuff is no longer tied to Facebook, though? I got an email recently about account changes, and was prompted to create a new account, with the option to link it to my Facebook account.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by mcv on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:54AM (#33358476)
If that's the case for all Oculus devices, that would definitely be a massive improvement. I still see some people here complaining about the Facebook link, though.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by taeric on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:45AM (#33358286)
Bit of a false comparison, though. Computers obviously enable a lot more than VR seems to.

I think there will be a market for VR. However, I'm not entirely convinced games and entertainment are it. Certainly I think there will be a market for those, as well; but I can't shake the feeling that it doesn't actually add too terribly much to them.

The social aspect of entertainment is completely missed with VR. We want to do things /with people/ when we are being social. Is why people watch sports games in parties. Most of the folks at the party are marginally interested in the sport, but in the people they are there with.

For games, 3d shooter is certainly a genre. But it isn't the only one. And the casual market that they hope to capture is largely not the 3d market.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by moffkalast on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:54AM (#33358468)
You know what would be a killer app kind of application for AR? A real life HUD you could just wear all the time. Anything that can be done with a smartphone these days but without the hassle of carrying a giant brick around that you need to fumble with.

But to get to that stage you need to at the very least integrate all that functionality into a set of glasses (more than 60% of all people already wear glasses daily anyway), and you also need direct brain interfacing control to make it practically usable at all.

Way beyond anything we can currently do these days unfortunately.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by taeric on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:22PM (#33359921)
AR is a very different beast compared to VR. Such that, I agree moving to a HUD can be nice for many things. That said, requiring full body interactions for anything is a laughably bad non-starter. Looks great for performance art and movies, but is far from effective.

And, as I said elsewhere, also not gaming/entertainment focused. Arguably anti-social.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by ghaff on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:11AM (#33358739)
You probably need to believe that mostly a younger generation will at some point buy into ambient socialization in VR, which is to say the metaverse/Second Life 2.0 I guess. I guess it’s possible but I’m not the target market.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by taeric on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:14PM (#33359772)
Online socializing doesn't have to be VR, though. Witness by looking at all of the online socializing that happens today.

Indeed, for many folks that like the idea of online socializing, we like it /because/ it is not necessarily visual.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by treis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:02AM (#33358597)
It's hard to say until the technology gets to the point where you can start to match what a monitor does. You'd need a 8k or probably higher screen for each eye plus the graphics card to drive it at ~144hz. Then if you want it portable you need a battery to drive it.

Once we're there then we can see what sort of future VR has.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by taeric on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:20PM (#33359883)
I don't buy it. VR will always, by definition, be a race to feature parity with things in the real world. And escapism is often more about not replicating real life, such that all of the tactical feedback that goes into the majority of what folks thing will work in VR is as likely to be the reason to avoid it.

Think about it, even the amazing open world games like Zelda will be nigh inaccessible in a VR world where you have to actually climb. Yes, you can get some sweeping visuals where you can turn your head to see the landscape, but a large TV already goes a long way to getting that, with much much better controls for the movement. So, you can get enhanced "you can turn your head to look around," but at the tremendous cost of "everything else about moving and interacting is completely broken. You will still need obviously untenable item management. Want to have many weapons? It will be hilariously off looking compared to everything else in the world.

Can it help with some desktop management and such for work? I mean, maybe? It will definitely be a good aide. I'd wager the high level workers are already "retreating into their brain" for a lot of their work, such that I don't expect miracles out of AR assistance.

Robotics and control do have a lot of promise, of course. But, again, I'm more questioning gaming and entertainment.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by treis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @01:07PM (#33360674)
>Think about it, even the amazing open world games like Zelda will be nigh inaccessible in a VR world where you have to actually climb.

Even if climbing is an challenge insurmountable then you'd just make games with out it. Elevation changes could be handled by predefined paths.

>Yes, you can get some sweeping visuals where you can turn your head to see the landscape, but a large TV already goes a long way to getting that, with much much better controls for the movement

I think you're way underselling the impact of VR. It's a massive upgrade and a different level of immersion. You don't see people face planting trying to jump off a building when it's a TV.

Plus those stationary treadmill things look cool as shit. If you get that working plus the headset it's really something. Even just taking an evening walk through Paris/Tokyo/the Himalayas would be bonkers if all the technology comes together.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by taeric on Thursday October 27, 2022 @01:11PM (#33360745)
I think you are under thinking how much effort there is to "make it an immersive experience." The /vast/ majority of game travel time is always with characters that are running. It is a bit of a gag in games. Try using the characters at walking speed.

And then think of transferring that to "we want you to feel like you are in a vast world.... that you can physically traverse in less than a day. Probably less than an hour."

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by mywittyname on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:46AM (#33358315)
I'm not sure that I'd call current VR tech "the early days". The VFX1 and those arcade cabinet VR systems were the "early days".

The Occulus Rift came out six years ago. We are well into the phase of VR where improvements are incremental each generation.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by creshal on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:58AM (#33358521)
> We are well into the phase of VR where improvements are incremental each generation.

If that's the end of it, VR is doomed to remain a curious niche. It struggles to deliver compelling results for thousands of dollars (headset plus powerful enough PC), and if all we ever get from now on are tiny incremental updates, we'll never reach a steady state where perceived quality, relative to contemporary 2D offerings, can keep up.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by stonemetal12 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:48AM (#33359380)
I would consider those arcade cabinets equivalent to time sharing computers in labs of yesteryear. Current VR is about like the 286, it does some neat stuff but more promise than delivery.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by twen_ty on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:21PM (#33359912)
VR encourages staying in as opposed to going out - the whole thrust of technology should be that - so that humans could be more... human. The timeline where VR fits seamlessly in the latter is decades, away and betting on it as a company right now is madness.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by scyzoryk_xyz on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:36AM (#33358130)
Yeah, just like no one really wanted a Palm Treo or whatever flagship smartphone was dominant in 2004.

This is all about where the ball is going to be tomorrow, not where it is today.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by qbasic_forever on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:39AM (#33358185)
I can email grandma and get directions to the park on my smartphone. The value proposition is clear.

I can ??? by strapping an enormous headset to my face, flailing my arms around, and getting sick to my stomach and lightening my wallet by $500-$1500 with VR headsets. What do I gain by doing this?

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by blairbeckwith on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:44AM (#33358279)
You are arguing against the opinion "it sucks right now, but it can get better" with "it sucks right now". Is your position that things that suck can not get better?
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by qbasic_forever on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:47AM (#33358345)
I've heard that exact same defense for 10 years.

When? When is this magic moment where it stops sucking? We've been told oh just wait for better hand tracking... oh wait for better screens... oh wait for portable/wireless headsets... oh wait...

Shit or get off the pot VR. You've had 10 years.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by blairbeckwith on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:52AM (#33358421)
Tons of things have taken more than 10 years to stop sucking. Digital cameras, MP3 players, "smart" phones, arguably laptops...

I am not a VR believer by any stretch, but this is such myopic thinking.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by creshal on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:21AM (#33358919)
VR has been around for fifty years, that's a pretty long time to not produce any convincing results.

And all those inventions piggy backed off a very rapid pace of hardware getting faster, smaller, more power efficient and cheaper at the same time.

Moore's law meanwhile is dead, the rate at which CPUs/GPUs get faster is slowing down considerably, and VR needs a lot faster and cheaper and more power efficient hardware just to become affordable at reasonable quality.

That's not a good starting point, especially when you're a publicly traded company and your future depends on reaching that inflexion point soon™.

And then you still run into practicality problems:

• User input is still fairly clunky. Touchscreens just removed most of the friction of computer input devices, VR puts it back in. That won't make it particularly popular. Granted, future advances in hand/finger tracking might solve this, but this adds another set of sensors and hardware to make sense of them, when VR headsets are already struggling to reduce the bill of materials to become affordable.

• VR needs lots and lots of space. Digital cameras, MP3 players, smartphones, laptops, … for the most part reduced the amount of space a family needs to do things, compared to what came before, which made them a no-brainer for all demographics. No amount of technology improvement can really reduce VR's space demand without compromising on user experience. Not a problem for US tech bros, but ask an European or Asian family what they feel about doubling their rent so one family member gets enough space to use VR. Not gonna happen.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by scyzoryk_xyz on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:58AM (#33359531)
„Shit or get off the pot VR. You've had 10 years.”

What a strange anthropomorphization of technology/product. Is this somehow hurting you personally? Is there some other technology being developed by someone that is somehow not “getting it’s turn”?

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by silverlake on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:27PM (#33360021)
All the tech you like took much, much longer to develop than 10 years. The first computer was 1945. The first “mobile” phone was 1946. The first video phone was 1956. The first “internet” was 1969. Electric cars were commercially available in 1900. These were all developed by giant companies that no longer exist.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by cmsj on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:08AM (#33358694)
No, not really, because while nobody enjoyed the pre-iPhone smartphone experience, it was obviously useful and there was adoption - think Blackberry.

VR though... it's really hard to imagine use cases that will cause a billion people to buy a headset and wear it for a number of hours a day.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by falcolas on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:45AM (#33358288)
The same thing you gain by using headphones over speakers.

And you can get into VR for much less than $500. Have been able to for years now.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by juve1996 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:49AM (#33358379)
> And you can get into VR for much less than $500. Have been able to for years now.

Which isn't good then, it's so cheap yet barely adopted?

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by falcolas on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:11AM (#33358744)
10m devices sold per year (and growing) is not "barely".
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by mywittyname on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:47AM (#33358349)
Most people prefer speakers...
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by falcolas on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:14AM (#33358779)
And yet people use headphones everywhere. Especially in apartments to avoid annoying neighbors.

Speakers are, with few exceptions, inconsiderate of folks around you.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by 10000truths on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:54AM (#33358466)
Most importantly, using a smartphone is a very low-friction experience. It takes two seconds to pull it out of your pocket and unlock it, and two seconds to put it back in your pocket. Same with a desktop - to use it, I sit down at my chair, maybe press the monitor power button, and I’m good to go. When I’m done, I get up from the chair.

VR headsets are far more bulky and intrusive. They don’t allow for easy context switching between cyberspace and the real world, and they’re not portable enough to be used on the go like a smartphone.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by scyzoryk_xyz on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:22PM (#33359926)
Yep. They weren’t a low-friction experience before though.

Have you compared headsets lately? Because just recently I have, and this shit is changing. A 2017 Vive is very different from a 2021 Oculus from that friction POV. With nm chip architectures and battery tech improving, it really doesn’t take that much imagination to predict where they will be in 2025 or 2030.

Personally, I think one of the killer features for this category will be matured inside-out hand-tracking. Not having to do anything but put the headset on your head makes a huge difference.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by politician on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:37AM (#33359203)
Add that you've got a lithium battery pack pressed against the back of your head -- those things don't have a perfect safety record. If it blows up in your laptop, you probably won't be permanently disabled.

Or that excessive use of the device will probably have long-term consequences for your eyes. As a long-time user of smartphones, I am beginning to wonder if staring at a small screen has accelerated aging in my eyes. I can only imagine the damage from poorly calibrated VR glasses.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by scyzoryk_xyz on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:11PM (#33359734)
Did you try getting directions on a smartphone in 2004? How about showing your grandma how to send an e-mail in 2004 on a smartphone?

You gain nothing - not right now, not today. Nobody is holding a gun to your head. Nobody is saying this stuff works today.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by xvector on Thursday October 27, 2022 @09:58PM (#33366626)
Use your imagination. You can: - Attend meetings and feel an infinitely greater sense of presence than Zoom - Whiteboard with your coworkers - Play games more immersive than any you’ve ever played before - Extend a tiny laptop into a massive multi-monitor setup - on the go - Spin up a massive movie theater for yourself on a plane flight - …
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by time_to_smile on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:09AM (#33358696)
Do people really not remember the fairly large business adoption of Black berries pre-iphone? They remained the standard issue government smart phone even into the 2010s (DC at that time was very much like House of Cards in the usage of the device).

The iPhone completely changed the game, no doubt, but there were a lot of non-techies that had smart phones and used them heavily prior to the iphone's release.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by scyzoryk_xyz on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:09PM (#33359700)
This is true. Hard to call them “smartphones” by the current definition though. Blackberries were internet communicators, useful for work, calls and e-mails. Beloved by professionals for their utility, tactility.

Apple made a successful bet that multi-touch screens/UI done with sufficient discipline could be not an enormous pain in the ass to use. And that a well groomed AppStore would create a plethora of opportunities for change. Without Android quickly following that model we wouldn’t then have the arms race of functionalities. This is probably something Meta is hoping for - that this time around they will have a better seat at the table than they got in that smartphone arms race. I’m looking forward to all of it.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by qbasic_forever on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:37AM (#33358144)
Bingo. It's been about a decade now since the revival of VR. We've had 10 years of, "everyone is going to be computing in 3D". It never materialized. Worse, it looks like the content is shrinking and stagnant.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by conductr on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:41AM (#33358230)
Covid was it’s gleaming opportunity too.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by moffkalast on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:44AM (#33358278)
10 years or not, the tech is simply not there yet while being far too expensive for what it is. It's not exactly a recipe for growth or success. Like trying to make electric cars a thing in the NiCd battery and brushed motor era.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by jrumbut on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:37AM (#33358151)
I said that for a long time but honestly it's getting cooler. The exercise applications alone are a huge market (in theory almost everyone).
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by cmsj on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:10AM (#33358721)
what are the exercise applications? Isn't exercise a thing where your form matters, so you need to be able to see your own body?
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by jrumbut on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:22AM (#33358937)
To date I've enjoyed playful activities like swatting at glowing targets, boxing, or virtual light saber fighting.

Assuming you aren't serious about becoming a jedi and don't do it enough to give yourself RSI it should be OK. Maybe not as good as a personal trainer but I'd be shocked if it was worse than sitting on the couch, on balance.

Also, with the cameras on the headset as well as peripherals they can give you some idea of where your body is.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by moffkalast on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:43AM (#33358253)
Noone wants shitty VR, which is what current generation VR is.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by falcolas on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:43AM (#33358267)
VR has a market of over $5 billion per year. In 2021, over 10m devices were sold, and its still growing.

That's a bit more than a niche.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by juve1996 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:49AM (#33358385)
Citation?
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by falcolas on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:10AM (#33358730)
Google.

vr market value

vr devices sold

If I can do it, so can every other person on this forum.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by sergiotapia on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:46AM (#33358325)
I call bullshit. VR has a pure ergonomics problem and Meta is chipping away at that every year, this Quest Pro is so nearly there and the second we get VR sunglasses it's done. It's over. It will become mainstream and the PC will go the way of the typewriter.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by andsoitis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:10AM (#33358718)
I think “VR sunglasses” is an oxymoron. Isn’t the core selling point of VR deep immersion?

AR perhaps, but that’s a whole different set of use cases. A single device cannot adequately cater to this “spectrum” of full vs, semi-immersion.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:51AM (#33359422)
> VR sunglasses

Unless they completely surround your eyes to block outside light, VR "sunglasses" would absolutely awful. For VR to work well, you need immersion, which is not possible when the edge of your vision is filled with the scene of where you are in the real world.

AR sunglasses on the other hand would be great, but I'm not convinced AR has much of a future outside of some specific niches.

The biggest hurdle for any sort of portable VR or AR is compute and power. VR is incredibly compute intense, which means portable headsets only have a 1-2 hour battery life and need a heavy battery.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by vel0city on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:48AM (#33358361)
Pre-iPhone smartphones catered to a niche audience. Tablets weren't very popular in the market pre-iPad. Bluetooth headphones were around for over a decade with a lot of people ignoring them before Airpods popularized them. Personal media players weren't nearly as mainstream before the iPod. Almost all of these product markets existed and mostly catered to niche audiences before Apple jumped in.

Of course, those are mostly their successes. They had stumbles too, no doubt.

If there's one thing Apple excels at, its convincing the mass market to adopt technologies that currently only cater to a niche audience. I have no idea what their plans for VR are, but I do imagine if they do something in it they'll make some waves. But maybe it'll turn out like the Newton. Maybe they will never launch a VR product. Who knows.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by andsoitis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:04AM (#33358621)
It’s not so much that the technology is niche, it is that the use cases are niche.

What is the main killer use case of VR? How many people want it or would enjoy it or would pay for it?

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by vel0city on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:30AM (#33359078)
I definitely agree the mass market appeal to VR is yet to be proven. This is a big part of why I say if Apple chooses to launch a VR headset. It may never be proven to be a successful mass market technology, and if so, I imagine Apple may never release a VR headset.

The main use cases I see are gaming, and of that market only certain kinds of games. Then on top of that its challenging having the space to play those games safely. Personally, I really enjoy my VR headset, I love playing games like Star Wars: Squadrons in VR.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by andsoitis on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:48AM (#33359382)
> The main use cases I see are gaming

I think of that in terms of “escape from reality” or “entertainment”.

I suppose there are also educational use cases and remote control use cases.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by time_to_smile on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:05AM (#33358642)
Are you living in a different timeline than me?

Ever since the ipod came out people were salivating for the possibility of an iphone. Upon it's release the hype for it was incredible and had been building for years.

Virtually everyone I know has a pair of non-airpod blue tooth headphones.

Everyone had a walkman, then a discman, pre-ipod. Yea adoption of early mp3 players wasn't particularly high because they were not that great, but the same is true for the mini-disc (which I believe had even lower adoption). I still knew quite a few people that had pre-ipod mp3 players.

Even among my gamer friends very, very few people have an Oculus. Everyone of the few people I knew who got an occulus (including myself) has had the exact same experience: First month, "wow this is a game changer!" second month, it's collecting dust. I know of literally no one who has used a VR headset weekly for a period longer than 3 months.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by vel0city on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:20AM (#33358892)
> Ever since the ipod came out people were salivating for the possibility of an iphone.

And yet barely anyone bought the devices which were already on the market which could have filled that niche. Which yes, they existed, almost exclusively listened to music on bluetooth headphones through my phone before the iPhone released. Even streaming internet radio over a 3G connection before the non-3G iPhone was released. The market wasn't wanting a smartphone, they wanted specifically an iPod phone. Because, once again, Apple is great at making the general market want tech that roughly already exists, but just isn't very popular yet.

> Yea adoption of early mp3 players wasn't particularly high because they were not that great

There were good MP3 players on the market before the iPod came out, but they weren't very popular. There was a bit of a lack of ecosystem with them and a massive lack of marketing.

I do agree there's not a large market for VR at the moment, and I agree its entirely possible there won't ever be a large market for it. I'm not saying its a given Apple will make a VR headset, I'm just arguing if they do it, it'll probably make a splash given their track record of releasing decently polished products with a good enough ecosystem to get the market to buy it. I don't think Apple would just dump a half-baked VR headset into the market.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by lotsofpulp on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:28PM (#33360031)
> Even streaming internet radio over a 3G connection before the non-3G iPhone was released. The market wasn't wanting a smartphone, they wanted specifically an iPod phone.

In the US, I was not even aware of mobile broadband availability before iPhone 3G. And whatever quality mobile internet was available, I assumed was very costly and metered.

Some combination of the timing of iPhone 3G release coinciding with widespread deployment of 3G mobile broadband access and/or Apple negotiating ATT to provide unlimited data made it possible to have a little pocket computer that could stream whenever, wherever, however much you want.

That was a game changer. A lot of the big tradeoffs that people had to make with smartphones before iPhone 3G disappeared to make it a very compelling product compared to its competitors.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by vel0city on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:59PM (#33360562)
> In the US, I was not even aware of mobile broadband availability before iPhone 3G.

It was a $15/mo add-on to get up to 3Mbps unlimited data on my phone on AT&T in the US in 2006.

3G came out multiple years before the iPhone 3G.

I had a pocket computer with unlimited data on AT&T the day people were buying the original iPhone.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by lotsofpulp on Thursday October 27, 2022 @01:06PM (#33360661)
Interesting, I was in my early 20s, and was not aware. Or maybe $15/month seemed like a lot back then.

I just remember mobile companies charging nickel and diming for everything extra, so I never bothered to try and use anything that was not phone calls/SMS since those had been made unlimited and included in cheaper mobile plans.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by vel0city on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:11PM (#33362517)
If you had seen it, good chance you would have shrugged it off. Most phone's WAP browsers sucked. You would have pretty much been paying $15/mo to read sports scores or delayed stock ticker quotes on most phones sold in the store. They definitely weren't expecting people to use the dumb phone internet connections for much data.

I would buy unlocked GSM phones online and just pop my dumb phone SIM card into them. AT&T seemed to not recognize the IMEIs or at least wouldn't care that they weren't the cheap dumb phone on my plan. Then I'd have apps like Opera Mini and Google Maps. IMAP email would sync on the device without issue. internet instant messengers worked fine. I could stream music through m3u's. When the iPhone came out nothing about it seemed revolutionary to me, as I was a part of that niche market. Most consumers didn't even realize they could do those things on their phone, and for a lot of users it would be too complicated for them to even really consider it.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:42AM (#33359283)
> Bluetooth headphones were around for over a decade with a lot of people ignoring them before Airpods popularized them.

This is just flat-out wrong.

They may have shot up in popularity after phones stopped having headphone jacks, but there was certainly a Bluetooth headphone market before that.

> Personal media players weren't nearly as mainstream before the iPod.

Again, wayyyyy off base.

Personal CD players were VERY popular and common in the late 90s. I'd wager Napster and the advent of CD burners popularized them even more.

> Almost all of these product markets existed and mostly catered to niche audiences before Apple jumped in.

Cringe. This reeks of the attitude common attitude around 2010 where Apple fanboys would praise Steve Jobs for his innovation when Apple would implement a feature into iPhone that Android had for years.

> If there's one thing Apple excels at, its convincing the mass market to adopt technologies that currently only cater to a niche audience.

They excel at UI/UX. From a purely technical standpoint, they're often a couple years behind, but if you polish the crap out of it, people don't notice.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by vel0city on Thursday October 27, 2022 @12:57PM (#33360523)
Seeing people with Bluetooth headphones was a rarity 10 years ago. They existed, yes, but so did smartphones before the iPhone. Some people had them, but the vast majority of the market of headphones or phones didn't care.

By personal media players, I'm talking about MP3 players and iPod-like devices. Essentially post-CD players. They existed, they weren't popular. Even the initial iPod took a while to gain a real market presence.

I'm not an Apple fanboy, but I can definitely acknowledge there were lots of markets which were largely ignored by the mass market until Apple made it cool and easy to use. I had a 3G phone which could do video calls when the iPhone came out, so I definitely understand that Apple isn't usually on the bleeding edge of technology, they're just the ones that often manage to refine it enough to be acceptable by the mass market.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @06:01PM (#33364631)
> By personal media players, I'm talking about MP3 players and iPod-like devices. Essentially post-CD players. They existed, they weren't popular.

They weren't popular because they just simply sucked.

Flash memory was still expensive, so they'd usually only have enough room for 10 songs at the most. They didn't have displays to see file names, which I suppose isn't a big deal when you only have 10 songs.

> Even the initial iPod took a while to gain a real market presence.

I don't even consider the iPod to be innovative in any way besides maybe the click wheel. It was just that the iPod was the first product that was actually designed to be a good product and not a cheap money grab designed to get a few dollars from all the Napster users.

To put it more bluntly, IMO, all the other products were made by boneheads. The iPod was the bare minimum of what an MP3 player should have been. It wasn't innovative, it just wasn't made by boneheads.

Personally, I had always expected MP3 CD players to become a thing. I didn't like the iPod's idea of a hard drive (Though they weren't the first to make a portable MP3 player that used a hard drive). I expected them to have high failure rates from head crashes.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by trophycase on Friday October 28, 2022 @12:46AM (#33367776)
iTunes was the killer app, not the ipod.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by antifa on Friday October 28, 2022 @12:07PM (#33373306)
As someone who owned mp3 players, portable CD players, and portable mini disc mp3 players, and did not find itunes or the scroll wheel appealing, the iPod's main innovation was almost entirely just "heavy marketing".
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by dmarcos on Thursday October 27, 2022 @03:15PM (#33362580)
Blackberries proved the smartphone market. Many people used and loved them a ton. VR not there yet.

Apple takes existing markets grows them and sets the new standard: PCs, smartphones, fitness trackers, headphones… Not first or early mover.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by vel0city on Thursday October 27, 2022 @05:16PM (#33364176)
While Blackberries were some of the most popular early smartphones, the overall market size pre 2007 was way smaller than post 2007.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/263437/global-smartphone...

The market for smartphones was miniscule before Apple made the mass market decide they really wanted one. I don't deny there were smartphones which existed before the iPhone, I used them and enjoyed them. But most consumers didn't have them. These days most people over the age of 16 have a smartphone, you can't say that was true in the Blackberry heyday.

Apple didn't make the smartphone. Apple made the public want to buy a smartphone.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by neither_color on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:54AM (#33358463)
It's getting better every year, the hardware just wasn't there before. I think the sweet spot will be in new vr-native experiences and not awkward skeuomorphic-ish implementations of the offline world in VR(which is what horizon seems to be trying to do) or gaming. Turning a 2D experience into a VR one will continue to have worse graphics and odd mechanics for the foreseeable future, and gaming in VR is just not relaxing compared to sitting on the couch with a controller. Not everyone wants to flail about and gesticulate after a long day of work.

I personally like to sit back and watch random "experiences," virtual tours and stuff and when I introduce someone new to VR I show them these first rather than games. Complete immersion without having to think about what to do with your hands.

Another interesting experience is Liminal https://liminalvr.com/ It uses sounds/visual stimulation with the intent of affecting your "mood" and it's being developed by bona fide psychological researchers. It's truly something that can only exist in VR!

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by WXLCKNO on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:32AM (#33358059)
I went from

Cardboard -> Note 4 with Gear VR -> S8+ with newer Gear VR -> Oculus Rift CV1 -> Oculus Quest 2 -> Selling my Quest 2 (and CV1) because Facebook (temporarily) made Facebook accounts mandatory to use it.

I doubt I'll ever purchase another VR headset from them in the future.

Cardboard blew my mind at the time, I was so excited to get a taste of VR.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by Sohcahtoa82 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:54AM (#33359477)
I went Cardboard (though used it very little, probably only 1 hour cumulative) -> HTC Vive -> Valve Index.

I'll probably buy a Valve Index 2 if it ever happens.

Portable VR is highly limited by battery power. VR requires high pixel counts and high framerates to be immersive, and pushing that many pixels uses a lot of power.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by megaman821 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:27AM (#33357963)
I was watching https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x6AOwDttBsc about Meta's VR prototypes. They seem pretty clear-headed on where they need to get to, but a lot of it seems like a decade away. At double the price-point of Quest Pro, Apple may solve some of VR's issues (battery-life, speed, ergonomics and looks) but the screen-tech just doesn't exist yet.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by pavlov on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:34AM (#33358088)
If Zuck had never embarked on his VR adventure, and Apple today came out with a device exactly like the Quest Pro but with no advance leaks about what it’s like, people would be stunned.

But the VR excitement pool has been poisoned by Meta’s image and a decade of overpromise.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by gonzo41 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:24AM (#33357892)
You're right about apple. Focusing on execution rather than bleeding edge innovation has certainly been a winning strategy.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by criddell on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:32AM (#33358050)
I think you're right. On top of that, Apple isn't afraid to ignore the low end. Meta and Microsoft can have that market.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by akmarinov on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:59AM (#33359547)
Even if they try to get the low end - they fail at it, their customers just buy the high end stuff, see iPhone 5C, iPhone Mini, iPhone Plus now - all "cheaper" and cancelled or not doing well.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by sylens on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:30AM (#33358012)
Apple's advantage in silicon will win the AR/VR war. Meta is out there talking about 1-2 hours of battery life for the Quest Pro. I'm very curious to see what performance Apple's headset/glasses/whatever provides on their own chips.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by cube00 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:22AM (#33357870)
Certainly seems that way with their entry into the advertising market. Watched and learnt from DoubleClick, Google and Facebook. Cut them off and now it's time to strike.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by elicash on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:25AM (#33357930)
Google should throw resources into Project Starline and shift their focus from business to personal use. I get it's insanely expensive and that shouts "enterprise!" but people will pay a lot for a realistic enough experience of being with their loved ones that they don't get to see.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by bob_theslob646 on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:35AM (#33358114)
https://blog.google/technology/research/project-starline/

It looks like it's similar to Cisco's telepresence.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by throwaway4aday on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:26AM (#33357941)
Unlikely, a significant proportion of VR sales are due to gaming. Apple may win the business VR market but it'll likely fall flat for all other uses.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by criddell on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:35AM (#33358100)
Apple is huge in gaming. Earlier this year, Mashable reported that mobile gaming was now 60% of the entire gaming market. Consumers apparently spend $1.6 billion per week on mobile games.

https://sea.mashable.com/tech-1/20432/60-of-entire-gaming-ma...

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by mywittyname on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:00AM (#33358554)
But how many of those hella-profitable games could even use VR? Pretty much just the "Core" genre. A VR 4x game is going to contain a lot of fluff.

I guess mobile will be the proof of the future of VR one way or the other. Mobile game companies have the funds to conduct the research to determine if VR increases profits and customer spend, and by how much.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by throwaway4aday on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:12AM (#33358756)
That figure is for the Play store and the App store combined.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by criddell on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:29AM (#33359067)
Yep.

Other articles I've read have said they are somewhere between Microsoft and Sony as far as gaming revenues go.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by personjerry on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:29AM (#33357989)
Have you heard of Apple Arcade?
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by throwaway4aday on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:13AM (#33358771)
No
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by jadbox on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:32AM (#33358055)
Hololens may give Microsoft a headstart into entering AR/VR for businesses.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by joeadk on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:31AM (#33358030)
Meta seems to be trading the capital they have built up to advance a new era of 3D immersive computing. If the talk of creating a more open system is genuine, and the hardware itself becomes ubiquitous and cheap, Apple's closed system dependent on expensive marked-up hardware will eventually collapse.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by gilrain on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:24AM (#33357900)
It certainly helps that they’re already a hardware company.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by ClumsyPilot on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:25AM (#33357925)
what indicates Apple will even play in VR market?
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by HeckaSmart on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:28AM (#33357971)
Every report, rumor, public interviews from executives have pointed to a VR device in 2023.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by mistercheph on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:34AM (#33358093)
*AR device
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by HeckaSmart on Thursday October 27, 2022 @05:43PM (#33364434)
No, VR.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by icapybara on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:27AM (#33357965)
Just individuals' hopes and dreams that VR will some day be useful I think.
Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by sf4lifer on Thursday October 27, 2022 @10:59AM (#33358535)
If history is any indicator, Apple is no where near releasing an AR/VR headset. They are never first to market, they have always waited until the tech is mature and people are ready to deliver a cohesive amazing experience. The argument that iphone was first to market could be argued for first without a keyboard, but just about everyone had a cell phone and most had some form of smartphone at the time.

Where would VR even be if Zuck hadn't bet facebook on it? I'm not sure it'd be getting the attention it is, the hardware isn't ready, the software isn't ready and frankly users aren't ready.

Re:Meta stock sinks more than 23% by noveltyaccount on Thursday October 27, 2022 @11:22AM (#33358932)
Cardboard and Daydream. Daydream was like fifty bucks, included a useful controller. Had to chuck it in the trash.