Another good example is how the Rashidun Caliphate granted conquered Zoroastrian Persians Dhimmi or "people of the Book" status. I'm sure it seemed kind at the time since Zoroastrianism is obviously not "of The [Abrahamic] Book". This merely postponed persecution of the unconverted until such a time as they were disperse, weak and with less sovereign resolve. They got a worse and worse deal as the centuries wore on.
I'm not justifying Google here, but this is really every hegemon's SOP: corporate, tech or cultural.
I'm just as mad with Microsoft forces me to use a Windows account after juggling the slow creep Mojang deprecation, when Mozilla gives you fewer and fewer ways to install apps outside of their extension store until it's a Nightly-only feature, or when [your favorite app] is acquired by [your least favorite company] and starts down a path you'd *never expect*. It's all garbage.
Even Chrome has a flag you can flip and install an unpacked extension from file. Sending this stuff up to Mozilla for them to grace or relegating developers and corporate users to some unbranded or esoteric dev binary is offensive to the end user IMO. I mean, it's not even federation, just centralization. Sure you can host it on your webpage, but it needs to be signed by the mother ship either way.
Firefox removed "about:config" from Firefox on android as well. Maybe we'll get a cli flag escape hatch for a year when they do the same on desktop. Not trusting the end user in the name of security is not a Google-only play despite all the Moz Marketing.
These days I don't use Firefox because I want to, but because it's the least worse choice.
I'm confident their hostile behavior towards user control is one of the reasons why they're hemorrhaging users. And no, giving users way to change UI colors not control. It's a fucking pacifier and an insult.
> as we shift our focus to Manifest V3. This change will give Chrome users increased safety and peace of mind while browsing and installing extensions by providing more transparency and control over permissions, adding stricter protocols for accessing resources outside the extension’s context, and ensuring that extensions work well on all devices
It sounds like government gobbledygook, with even more lies (there are no extensions on Chrome on mobile, so what "all devices" means is anyone's guess).
I often wonder what goes on in the mind of people writing this. Are they happy? Why did they choose to work in tech instead of some administration, if BS is their thing? Is it just for the money?
If you think of privacy solely as reducing the risk of an extension going rogue and leaking data - then sure, MV3 is a win.
But if you include the issue of sites sharing data, then reducing the ability of extensions to use advanced heuristics to block advertising and tracking may cause more harm than good.
There are plenty of users who understand that extensions are extremely powerful, thoroughly vet the organizations that have the capacity to update those extensions, and are also required to visit numerous less-trusted websites (and in a modern age of advertising technology, that's practically all of them) whose data sharing practices they cannot vet. MV3 will be a net negative for the privacy of those users.
Now, it may be reductive to say that those users, and that privacy threat model, matter more than others. But it is equally reductive to pretend that MV3 is a universal good.
https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/g/chromium-extensio...
It’s the equivalent of an airport security policy - as I mentioned before, to reduce risk. Which, both in that analogy and here, can indeed be part of a defense-in-depth. But such a policy is not without tradeoffs, and it cannot be evaluated in a vacuum.
Static rule based adblocking works just fine for me on iOS so I’m not going to assume that’s going to be a large number of people.
How? The big joke is MV3 doesnt prevent any of the things Google says it would.
It's almost a yearly occurrence at this point -- some thing that, once upon a time in the past I spent effort on configuring so that I could have a happy experience with my computer, will now be announced deprecated forcing me to comply with some new edict from on high with absolutely no benefit for me.
Please stop doing this. Stop "fixing" things. I'm an engineer too, I know building new things is fun, but there is also honor in maintaining well functioning things and not making other people's lives unnecessarily hard.
I bet that, now that I finally have mutt working again with Google's newest incarnation of authentication, there's a team within Google excited about breaking it in 2 years.
Every duplicate messaging app? That's someone's promo packet item.
Every ground-up incompatible API rewrite? Also a promo packet.
Google produces new work purely to satisfy itself. Their hierarchy forms its own internal economy where promotions are purchased with headline-grabbing actions that fool managers into thinking they provide business value. We'll call this "Googlestan".
Yes, this occasionally causes problems in the external, "real" economy. Writing message apps as disposable products means you don't have an answer to iMessage or Whatsapp. Breaking APIs every 3 months makes Google Cloud a nonstarter for anything other than easily-migrated guest OSes with a more sensible deprecation policy.
But that's how Google was built, and how Google will continue to be built, because all hierarchies have a rule zero: self-preserve. You cannot build a new Google without disenfranchising the people who currently know how to game the current Google, and those people will instinctively fight against an engineering culture they do not understand.
The only exceptions to this are the core economic vehicles between Googlestan and the outside world: Search, Chrome, and Android. Note how each one of these products have a dramatically more conservative roadmap, with a reasonably minimized number of breaking changes. Hell, Chrome specifically calls breaking changes "interventions", because they're that serious about not making them. These products form a moat around Googlestan that protects the country from invaders, so they themselves are isolated from the kinds of people who would gank them for the sake of a promo packet.
[0] If you're wondering, "how does Google internally handle breaking changes everywhere without boiling the ocean"... the answer is that they have an automated ocean-boiling machine that lets them rewrite the entire Google code corpus whenever an API breaks.
Even though I'm simply trying to guess from context without actually knowing, everything you just said sounds both accurate and hilariously well put.
Edit: WOW. I had no idea that's how things (even used to) work within those companies. A packet of materials you submit to get promoted. I'm almost bowled over with laughter.
That explains everything.
Here in the normal world, I get promoted by... being good at my job. Asking for it as part of a performance review, typically one I negotiate for as part of my employment, also helps.
I think this is an inevitable thing that happens when you have huge orgs with a limit on who can be promoted, there's not enough reward for everyone. I don't know how to do it. Trust managers doesn't scale, people reward their friends or whatever. Microsoft faced this too, but they didn't have a packet approach, it seemed like the senior managers decided, without having a paper trail like that.
Lab126 created some of the first e-ink technology, right? Is the Kindle, or e-ink screens, or e-ink patents, the worst thing ever... or is there something else I should know about in this space?
There's a lot to unpack in that sentence. Care to elaborate?
I'm sorry.
In my defense, I said it was a horrible idea at the time, we'd have to stream everyone's audio to the cloud to get the keyword spotting to work...
Also, Lab126 did not create e-ink! E-ink came out of the Media Lab long before the first kindle.
I'm glad that they're finally making one with a stylus, when I was there (more then a decade ago) there was a prototype tablet you could write on that had a brilliant new sort of user interface.
It's easy to bamboozle yourself from the obvious "maybe people are incentivized to do things to get promoted and perhaps even unnecessary things" to wild unrelated fantasies of how this could explain decisions you don't agree with
I'd add Google Maps and Google Mail onto this list.
There's some trivial truth to it, of course, but specific assertions are laughably false and more complicated than you are claiming.
I very much would like to reiterate this sort of thing is unhealthy, the point I was making was people moralize while assigning grand motives to a large # of uncoordinated actions about decisions that are obviously more complicated in real life if you were making them. This sort of is a perfect exercise in that
Promo-driven development and a bias towards greenfield is something that many engineers in other large tech companies are familiar with, and articles such as this are written by former googlers frustrated with the promo system: https://mtlynch.io/why-i-quit-google/ . Put two and two together and it seems like a likely explanation in light of no additional information and a meme is born.
I come from a company that has a google derived promo system, and I believe it when promo driven development can explain a lot.
Especially when that system values certain things like new 'innovations' vs important maintenance. Or tech leadership of multi-team projects which leads to forcing migrations on the rest of the company to get multi-team points vs. a seamless backwards compatible one done behind the scenes not being a multi-team project, so you don't get promoted for doing it. Or valuing mindless metric number go up over a more thoughtful review of the real impact which, gasp, might not involve some numbers sometimes.
These systems also change very slowly and are hard to change overall. I think google still does 5 leetcode interviews back to back, right? Despite them being shown they're not very good indicators of real job performance?
The average Google engineer's job is no different from anyone else working in a sufficiently large company. Their job isn't 'press the big evil switch on MV3', but rather 'MV3's staging branch is failing tests, go fix it'. The evil comes from perverse bureaucratic incentive, so it leaves me kinda ruffled to see people blaming the engineers on HN of all places. I can imagine some pinstriped upper-management prick at FAANG reading this thread in their penthouse and laughing their ass off.
> The evil comes from perverse bureaucratic incentive..
I think you're entirely right. I have nothing else to add, other than that I've always thought this, it's not a new change of opinion.
I guess I don't see any conflict between my comment and yours?
Yes, I know that "Their job isn't 'press the big evil switch on MV3', but rather 'MV3's staging branch is failing tests, go fix it" -- I've worked in software my whole career too. :)
> so it leaves me kinda ruffled to see people blaming the engineers on HN of all places.
I also know that it isn't some nebulous cloud above which is where designs come from, but other employees. I also know, from experience, that if you're a valuable enough engineer within an org or a project, and you significantly oppose a proposed feature or change coming from the suits, it's not gonna happen. What are they gonna do, code it themselves?
> I can imagine some pinstriped upper-management prick at FAANG reading this thread in their penthouse and laughing their ass off.
Agree.
I’ve had high success rate effecting significant course changes in several roles, at several distinct jobs. One of the things I emphasize to mentees is that their word and will is powerful, more than in most IC roles. Even so, the error in your reasoning here is obvious to me, especially applied to such large companies. Your chance of success effecting a course change is high, but the company may value your contributions less than they value the course they want to keep. They may also be in a position to hire people whose talent and compliance are more valuable than your own.
What are they gonna do? They’re gonna find someone else among hordes of applicants to do what you won’t.
Those plans come from management layers above not from the co-worker beside you. Blaming the developers when it usually starts with a vp trying to increase some metric for bonus time missing the key point that it is the organizational culture that demands, forbids and sets the rules for how employees operate. It starts at the top because if the ceo did not promote based in metric scores increasing the vp wouldn't create projects developers work on that the end user hates.
just use a different ad blocker or a different browser.
I didn't decide to buy into the Chrome ecosystem. I just have to use it because of the marketshare. And I'm on Gentoo running a personal build of Chromium.
Manifest v3 is pure evil. Don't get it twisted. There's no ambiguity here. It's just a cash grab.
Anyone working on it on the Chrome team should feel shame.
The several websites not working with firefox are.
The reality is that ad blockers will continue to work to a significant extent that they do today. Engage with that, put some information with merit into your posts.
Google is an empire built on advertising: scams and malware, so their evil has always been present. But right now we have an easy way to protect ourselves. Manifest v3 is exposing that evil to technologically-minded people.
I will have to switch my parents over to Firefox or Brave to keep them safe online.
Now, I use private browsing, so I get the “default” experience. Perhaps you don’t use private browsing and so your targeting is really honed in. Perhaps you only see sensible ads for sensible people, a sensible wallet or a sensible car. If that is the case then fine, but if the only way to use the internet is logged in to Google and with everything tracked, then that is unacceptable to me.
Completely false. Compare the difference between uBlock Origin on Firefox MV2 vs uBlock Origin Lite MV3 on Chrome and there's a massive loss of functionality.
>curated extensions that meet the highest standards of security, functionality, and user experience. Firefox staff thoroughly evaluate each extension before it receives Recommended status.
https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/recommended-extensions-...
And then you moved me to legacy workspace to appease me.
And then months before you tried again to migrate my legacy workspace email to paid, which another Google employee said it's free forever. I'm willing to pay anything on your valuable service but those dark patterns is what really pisses me.
“This ruins ad blockers”, “this is so they don’t have to make REAL ad blockers work”, “they want a 30% cut of VPN money instead”, “this will cause cancer”.
OK, not the last one. But people literally posted here on HN that Apple was killing people by not letting Flux on the iPhone.
Considering how much information “normal“ ad blockers can see, I’m not against this. I like Apple’s approach (and understand this to be similar).
But obviously I’m in the minority.
Umm... IIUC, Apple already makes billions from Ads. I'll just leave this here:
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2022-08-14/apple-...
Google's revenue is 80% advertising.
Stark difference.
Make no mistake, Apple does not care about your privacy — only about moving the ad money out of Google’s pocket into their own.
I personally think the use of privacy data is a waste of resources, and that companies like duckduckgo have the longer end of the stick. Because it makes more sense to me, that I get advertisements for a robot vacuum cleaner when I'm searching for one, and not the 3 months after I buy one, but then there is a trillion dollar advertisement industry to prove me wrong. So who knows. But what pisses me off is that companies sell you a product, and then also include advertisement and privacy data harvesting in it, like that Samsung TV article that was on here recently. Or how Windows "home or whatever the non-enterprise edition is called" now sometimes installs pre-installers for things like candy crush or Minecraft without asking you to do so... Like what the hell?
I don't want you to read this as a defence for google, but at least they are sort of honest about the evil they do.
I'm not sure any of these sleazy moves will have the desired outcomes for these companies. I don't want to use linux, I did once, but I like my technology to work right out of the box with no effort to make it so or to maintain it, which is why I'm in the Apple ecosystem these days, but the ways things are heading, I think the only future will be linux, and trying to find appliances that aren't add-infested.
1 - https://www.statista.com/statistics/1330127/apple-ad-revenue...
Why play silly games to make 4 billion dollars seem small?
I could play this game in the other direction and say "Apple generates more money from ads now than 99% of the companies ever make over their entire existence"
In truth, 4 billion dollars is a lot of money.
More to the point of this discussion, when you ask them, they want it to be a very significant part of their business. They talk about it on earnings calls all the time! It's not like they are hiding it!
Which sort of totally blows up the idea that they don't care.
You said they do not.
"One of these companies profits by the proliferation of ads and the other does not."
That was wrong. They make a lot of money from it and they have said it is an important part of their future.
Rather than just say you were wrong, you instead try to paint it as not mattering by using percentages, when again, it is a lot of money and apple themselves say it matters a lot
Just accept that what you said was mistaken, and do better next time. What you are doing now just makes you look bad and unable to learn and grow.
However, the point has always been about the comparison between Google and Apple. Given that their total revenues are of different size, how can we reasonably compare them?
What if we add a 3rd competitor to the arena? Let’s look at Outbrain. They’re a digital advertising marketplace w/ $256M annual revenue. By your argument, $256M << $1B — therefore we should take Apple to care more about their advertising business than Outbrain do about theirs?
Apple is rapidly running out of growth room in new physical people to sell phones to, and is starting to significantly switch focus to new ways of extracting rent from existing customers through "services" and similar.
Things like "The Great Suspender" incident get ignored and folks assume no other extensions have the same problems.
Regardless of that, at some point you have to trust software. You can't expect everyone to read every line of code and compile all the software by themselves.
It's the sum of the parts in changes from manifest V2:
- no arbitrary code injection via executeScript, must be a file now
- no more remote code
- no more arbitrarily getting selected text or highlighted text on a tab
- declarativeNetRequest instead of intercepting requests
- explicit listeners on the page to help detect bad actors (vs just arbitrary JS running on the page)
It took Google three to four years to acknowledge that the community is completely correct with its criticisms, and that MV3 is garbage designed by people who have no knowledge on how people write extensions and which abilities they actually use.
They're finally adding features that should have been there years ago. The new scripting API which brings back arbitrary scripts, in a new form, the offscreen documents API, and hopefully they'll eventually implement limited event pages which are somewhat solving the background page lifetime and DOM issues (which are already implemented by Mozilla and Safari I believe). Obviously, everything was decided hastily in the last second so all of the features are supposed to be completed by "around" October 2022, just two months before the original MV2 cutoff.
I've also read some of the extension working group transcripts, it's pretty sad how Google/Chrome has no accountability and almost zero transparency.
sure but that's my choice, that's why it's an extension. Paternalism of telling me what to do with my browser is silly merely because something is potentially dangerous. The entire internet is potentially dangerous. Clicking on a link or installing a piece of software is dangerous.
You're an adult, make responsible choices about whose extension to install instead of demanding that Google strangle you with security policies which at the end of the day serves only one purpose which is to extend their control over the user experience.
Some of these "choices" aren't actually _made_ by anyone. Even with trust of an author, if remote code is being used and a domain or server is hijacked, then the remote code could be replaced. It's a lose-lose problem for Google and not addressing this problem means worse security for casual users. The boogeyman that they will remove useful extensions is antithetical to their behavior so far.
The entire debate we're having rests on the fact that they're not integrating this functionality (despite this being technically trivial) because it's in conflict with their entire business model. Which is the only reason people have to reach for third party extensions in the first place.
Google doesn't want ad blockers to exist, the evidence is not that they make the majority of their revenue from ads. It's that the most popular version of Chrome already has 0 ad blocking capability! Ad blocking and extensions are legacy features.
I regretted the decision for a while afterwards, but i've since realized i don't want this shutdown threat hanging over my head. Thanks for the 10+ years of hosting but i don't have to be treated like this, I'm better off without them.
"Google Apps for Your Domain" for anyone who (like me) could not figure out what that acronym means.
Just noticed the typo heh.
Do you really think Google is on some vendetta against adblock? Adblock has lived on the Chrome webstore for a decade, and many, many, many copies have appeared too. Google could have easily nuked any of them but hasn't.
MV3 is not about adblock. Maybe one day the web will turn into some WASM-driven advertising shitshow, but we're thankfully a long way from that.
*Google knows this, which is why they haven't stopped ad-blocking.
I don't see any other reason for the features they killed to be killed. Specifically the preload hooks that ad blockers used.
"But they did not nuke it before" is not an argument btw. They didn't had utter market dominance before in case you somehow fucking forgot.
Yes, quite obviously. Google’s revenue is from advertising. Google is an advertising company.
fuck you Google!
> Sponsored Images: Striking, high-definition images that are featured in the Brave new tab image rotation. Advertisers have the opportunity to feature their brand prominently in this coveted space in front of millions of consumers.
"Fuck Google, have Brave shove ads in your face instead!"
They said some stuff after the backlash, but they never retracted or renounced their plan. Indeed, portions of the code are now in the current released OS.
There were outrage but Google had provided a flag to turn it off. It was in chrome://flags/#account-consistency.
Edit: Google removed the flag shortly after.
Behind the scenes every major change like that is a flag that's deployed first off then slowly flipped to default true as a rollout so that it's as low risk as possible of unintended damage / failure.
Why would Google ever commit to keep ad blockers working, unconditionally. It makes no sense.
I use Firefox in sometimes on mobile. I use Chrome for online banking and shopping. This usage is an extremely small portion of web use for me. (Does that make me an "actual user" under the Google employee's definition.) The majority of the time using the web I do not use a popular browser from a "tech" company. I use simpler software I can edit and compile myself, quickly and easily. I have all the "features" I need.
As such, 99% of the time I never see any ads. Google can do whatever it wants with Chrome. I still see no ads. I am not using it.
Unless and until one considers that there are other ways to access the web besides those dictated to us by "tech" companies, then one cannot seriously claim to be trying to avoid advertising. Firefox is funded by Google and other "search provider" profits from advertising services. Mozilla is against some forms of online tracking, but they are absolutely pro-advertising. I just watched their "Chief Security Officer" state this on video to the FTC earlier in the month. Are we supposed to believe there is some "standoff" between Mozilla and Google (or any other "tech" company, i.e., "search provider") over advertising. That would be pure fantasy. Mozilla (Corporation)^1 is like any other "tech" company. It has no business plan. It has nothing to sell that could sustain it as an employer of software developers. It only has its position as an intermediary, to assist with online advertising, in Mozilla's case to assist by sending search traffic to Google, and whatever else is required by their royalty agreements with "search providers".^2
1. https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2020/mozilla-fdn-202...
2. Mozilla even sells its own advertising services:
Advertising revenues - Mozilla also offers advertising services in three formats. The first is the New Tab advertising service, which places links to sponsored content when a new tab is opened in the Firefox web browser. The second format is through Pockets email product, Pocket Hits. Pocket Hits may include paid advertisements, which are placed in email newsletters that get delivered to global Pocket users. Lastly, Mozilla also sells web advertisement spots on content that Mozilla licenses and syndicates from publisher partners across the web.
Along with a "service" to remove advertising:
Subscription revenues -
Included in a Pocket Premium subscription are features like full text search on saved articles, removal of advertising from Pocket properties, the ability to create unlimited highlights and the ability to create a permanent library of everything a user has saved.
For me, playing both side of the coin, charging for advertising services and charging for advertising removal services, does not rank high on the scale of company integrity. But this sort of "playbook" seems quite common for "tech" companies. For example, Google does it with YouTube ("YouTube Red", now "YouTube Premium").
We are the end users of this software and, while clearly a minority, we do expect things to work. If a useful feature is being neutered, it is considered bad for the users. Thankfully, Google is not, yet, in a position where it can just force its adoption. Thankfully, there are still other options ( including some recent moves creation of non-G and non-F browser; and interesting variants of Chrome ).
Those vocal end users ( and that includes me ) want things in one specific way. For two different reasons:
1. I recently was forced to browse net without adblockers and it was a horrid experience. I pity the poor souls that live without them. 2. I still basically do everything tech related around the house. If Google starts being annoying, I will drop it like a hot potato. Thankfully, I am not longer local tech guy for my extended family.
In other words, it still makes sense for Google to appease the people, who do the work of converting and then supporting their software, because people sure don't call Google, when it raining ads.
By the by, didn't we go through the exact period with infinite pop-up ads and agreed that it was a really bad idea? Why would anyone think users want it back?