News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by MonkeyMalarky on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:03PM (#32804706)
Also why parents buying their teenaged children large vehicles is a tragedy of the commons type situation. They're more likely to get in accidents because they're young and and inexperienced, but hey a big car will save them..

Edit: Wow a whole reply chain spawned from this comment got nuked! Stay safe out there Americans, you've got some wild divisions amongst yourselves and its only getting worse. For the record, I love trains, subways, buses and biking but I also own a crossover sized vehicle and recognize that everyone has their own personal preferences and requirements and that no one transit solution will meet everyone's needs, I hope you all can see that too without violence.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by m463 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:40PM (#32804994)
On the other hand, most obstacles struck in 1-car accidents are heavier than even these cars.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by galangalalgol on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:22PM (#32804871)
I wonder what the right "if everybody drove this.." is? It is probably not a lotus 7 clone. What is the smallest vehicle with superb crash test ratings?
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by nico on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:16PM (#32805297)
A bike. If everyone just rode a bike, not only accidents would be less lethal, there would be a lot less congestion and pollution. Also we might get fitter too.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by ghastmaster on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:46PM (#32805871)
If everyone rode a bicycle, there would be a lot more bicycle deaths. According to table 6 of this study, https://injuryprevention.bmj.com/content/21/1/47, 71.4% of the fatalities involved motor vehicles. If we apply that percentage to todays number of bicyclist deaths (900) in the USA, we get 257 deaths that do not involve motor vehicles.

If we add congestion into the mix since everyone is bicycling, I imagine a higher number of accidents would occur. Right now an estimated 67 million people in the USA ride a bicycle for an estimated 15 billion hours combined per year. 228 million licensed drivers times 290 average hours on the road equals 66 billion hours per year. Let us assume the bicyclists will have to spend three times more travel time due to lower speed of bicycles. That equals roughly 200 billion hours of bicycling per year. 200 billion hours divided by 15 billion equals 13.3. 900 257 deaths per 15 billion hours equals 3,341 deaths per year. The average number of deaths per year from automobile crashes for the last few years is about 36,000.

Even if this is a conservative estimate. I think it is safe to say you are essentially correct.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by Schroedingersat on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @07:51PM (#32831609)
Netherlands has ~200-250ish cycling deaths a year with a ~30% modeshare.

Half are elderly.

About a third are on ebikes

87% involve a car.

That's around 0.8 deaths per hundred thousand people worth of bike modeshare not invovling a car. 1/15th of the USA and a quarter of netherlands road deaths.

This is with drunk cycling penalties being almost completely unenforced (although not sure how it compares to US drunk driving prevalence).

Granted cars are used for the longer trips so it's not completely sound, but bikes are used for congested trips. Small vehicle modeshare also shortens all trips.

My guess is the safest vehicle would look like a train followed by lightweight velo no heavier than a dutch bike (and not optimized for aero) or a recumbent trike with a roll cage and a lap belt. Also we can conclude that either current ebikes are too fast and heavy, or they result in people cycling who would be too frail otherwise.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by ARandomerDude on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:17PM (#32805697)
Do that with two toddlers and let us know how it goes when you get back from the grocery store.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by asdff on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:01AM (#32806273)
I see parents bring toddlers in trailers to grocery stores and farmers markets routinely these days. They make these big ebikes that can even haul kids directly without the trailer now and millennial parents have been buying them.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by frumper on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:25AM (#32806392)
That’s cute, but not practical for most people.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by asdff on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:40PM (#32812877)
I mean it could be. Life existed before the car. Your grandparents might have even experienced that as a toddler.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by frumper on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:27PM (#32813661)
Lots of things could be, but removing cars from the average American's life will limit job opportunities, limit economic choices, and consume a lot more of our time.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by asdff on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:05PM (#32814346)
It's not about removing cars, its about limiting them and choosing a more appropriate tool for the job. Sometimes you can get away with a hand trowel instead of an excavator.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by frumper on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:20PM (#32814563)
Yes, but if you own a car, then you're already paying for something that can save you time and personal energy so you can do things you enjoy, like playing with your kids, or tending your garden. Often times the quickest and easiest tool to use is what you're going to reach for, and that's a car most of the time.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by asdff on Thursday September 15, 2022 @04:52PM (#32858290)
And the whole thing is that the personal convenience you get comes with great costs to every other facet of life when you account for the negative externalities that a car centric lifestyle brings. Now you have a bunch of black particulate on your window sills because everyone in your neighborhood has a heavy car that produces tire dust. Maybe you live a few years less on the whole because you a literally hardly moving around all day when all the walking you do is in your home or on the way to the car, when you could have been working in at least some time cardio wise riding a bike or merely being a pedestrian for all those decades. Often times for short trips on surface streets, like what would be a 10 minute car ride turns into a 12 minute bike ride or so, because stop lights eliminate all the advantages of a powerful car on city roads and perhaps effectively set the speed limit for everyone to like 15mph regardless of the signed speed. Four minutes a two way trip on the whole is not much time wasted away from your children or your crops.

For my commute to work, its something like my choice of a 35 minute drive (not counting the circling I will have to do finding a parking spot at the other end) or a 45 minute bike ride. I probably save time on the whole even without counting the parking fiasco, considering now I don't need to find time in my schedule to work in my cardio.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by mytherin on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:34AM (#32806749)
That is actually extremely common in the Netherlands. [1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rQhzEnWCgHA

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by midoridensha on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:34AM (#32806746)
I see this every single day here in Tokyo. It's totally normal to have 1 or 2 toddlers on a bicycle.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by ironmagma on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:03PM (#32805604)
We might also get heatstrokes. Source: Florida resident
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by kqr on Monday September 12, 2022 @05:05AM (#32807657)
I wonder how the climate got so hot...
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by ironmagma on Monday September 12, 2022 @11:22AM (#32811721)
“Collectively, cars and trucks account for nearly one-fifth of all US emissions, emitting around 24 pounds of carbon dioxide and other global-warming gases for every gallon of gas.” (Source: epa.gov)

So to answer your snarky question with snark in kind, mostly from the other 4/5 of emissions.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by COGlory on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:42PM (#32805463)
I'll just bike all around Montana.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by vkou on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:18PM (#32805314)
And barring that, an electric scooter.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by jonhohle on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:43PM (#32805469)
And maybe an electric motorcycle or trike for when you have to carry more stuff. And an electric car for big families, and an electric van for vacations…
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by asdff on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:06AM (#32806293)
The right answer is the tool for the job. Chances are you don't need a huge pickup truck when you buy $200 of groceries. I can do it in a bike with some panniers so that means everyone can do it with an ebike. Need more than $200? Just take multiple trips a week and cancel your gym membership. Need to haul a few hundred pounds of manure? By all means take the truck. It's just when you look around at the modern world today, a lot of people are sitting in traffic by themselves in a vehicle on their way to work less than 10 miles away, or buying a few things from the store less than 2 miles away as soon as the need arises. Its a lot of wasted vehicular capacity. If you were a business buying a machine that you only used a fraction of its capabilities, you'd consider getting away with a leaner machine for most use cases.

For a lot of people I talk to about getting around when it comes up, the major stopping point with biking is just the lack of infrastructure and feeling afraid of cars. Most people aren't comfortable taking the lane while biking so it becomes a dangerous experience when they don't. As the saying goes, though, if you build it, they will come. Any city I've been in that has built out a gridlike network of bike lanes seems to have a lot of people riding around. Once you build them that network you enable a lot of trips for those people uncomfortable with the existing road network.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by galangalalgol on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:56AM (#32809447)
Are there any good examples of how to do this infrastructure? In my neighborhood they took the major street in the neighborhood and took one of the lanes and painted it to be a bike lane mext to the sidewalk, and parking spots further out. No physical median, just white paint on light concrete. No one parks in those spots, they would get demolished by cars. And no one bikes there, they bike on less busy streets one block in either direction. Also, at every intersection the parking spots disappear for a right turn lane. The bike lane doesn't, but it is hard to see so the cars go over the whole way.

A nearby neighborhood did something similar but with physical medians. Much better, but still people just use less busy streets mostly.

My main issue getting to work is not those streets, but post ww2 neighborhoods that have one entance and exit forcing me on to highways with glass covered shoulders and speedlimits over 55. That is what I want them to fix. But that would actually involve earth moving and eminent domain, not just a bit of paint or concrete.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by asdff on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:39PM (#32812869)
I think Irvine California has done a good job adding bike lanes to that sort of suburban design
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by goblinux on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:28PM (#32805369)
What about trucking and shipping? The US - where this study took place- is huge, and most of it is very far from ports. 18 wheelers/semis are the biggest users of the American highway system and are necessary to get goods to/from production and consumption sites

These trucks also contribute to the rise in vehicle size. I did not like driving when I was in a sedan sized car sharing the high speed highways hours from cities on those highways

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by Schroedingersat on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:34PM (#32805417)
Well put the trucks moving stuff in places where the people koving themselves aren't.

If they're going extremely long distances you could even have some kind of dedicated hard wearing road surface. And if lots of them are going to the same place you could get them to move in a convoy. And once they're in a convoy you could hook them together...

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by goblinux on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:29AM (#32809893)
Unfortunately not all goods are going to the same places. Nor are all goods moving at the same pace. Freight trains are a great piece of logistics infrastructure, but they can't just be US logistics infrastructure.

The US rail system is very well established and has been well built out since before the rise of the automobile. But goods need to get from the rail depot to the end destination and right now the best we have is enormous 18-wheelers and as long as those are on the road, it's too dangerous for me to want to take a smaller car

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by nradov on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:50PM (#32805513)
Come on. The USA has one of the best freight railroad systems in the world. A large percentage of our cargo moves on rails. But rails can't extend everywhere, and it will seldom be practical to carry perishable, time-sensitive cargo in trains. That stuff pretty much has to go by truck.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by sudosysgen on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:09PM (#32805642)
Trains can be far faster than trucks. There are various serious deficiencies in the US train system that mean that transit speeds are far, far lower than they could be. There is no real technical reason why trains can't be faster than trucks with a similar marginal cost as to today. The infrastructure and systems are simply deficient.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by dnadler on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:48PM (#32805506)
So build an entire second interstate system? That’s not really realistic, which tends to be the problem with most ideas to move away from cars.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by unglaublich on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:56PM (#32805564)
That’s extremely realistic. The Netherlands has a separate system for bikes. The truck system would just be what the motorized traffic system is now, be it a bit scaled down.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by dnadler on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:53PM (#32814147)
I think you and I have different concepts of realistic, ha. How do you propose people travel from rural place A to rural place B? Public transportation? That would be extremely expensive to implement, and would operate at a massive loss to service the entire US.

The interstate system and truck delivery seems to be pretty fantastic at servicing the continental US when paired with freight trains, cargo planes, etc. And it is similarly effective for delivery of all other kinds of things including people.

These systems would be good to implement in many cities, but interstate shipping and travel is another thing altogether.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by galangalalgol on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:46AM (#32806186)
Even in the Netherlands cars are not dead. A few years back (pre pandemic, maybe wfh will last, maybe it won't), I was staying with a friend. They all had cars, but one had just sold their car and committed to public transportation and bicycle. Even there he was really regretting his choice. In the US it isn't even a question. The vast majority of people need a car. We can make a goal of changing that, but it will be a while. So for now, what is the least bad car?
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by picture on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:55PM (#32805556)
They're alluding to trains.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by seer-zig on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:59PM (#32805586)
What about the last mile issue? Like getting products to grocery stores and outlets?
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by occz on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:02AM (#32806601)
Last mile distribution does not require extremely large trucks to be feasible.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by dnadler on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:55PM (#32814176)
I'd think that that depends on the density of the rail network and sparsity of the destinations.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by woodruffw on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:25PM (#32804891)
It resembles something like a public bus or subway.

More realistically, it's smaller cars on slower city streets.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by bombcar on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:02PM (#32805173)
A bus is an even bigger and heavier vehicle that will obliterate pedestrians, smaller vehicles, and goats.

The distinction is professional drivers and safety standards.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by woodruffw on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:09PM (#32805229)
Right: buses, despite their size, kill far fewer pedestrians and passengers. Size is a factor for personal automobiles because individuals lack the training (and restraint) that's key to bus driving. It's hard to see a world in which the US accepts that and increases the restrictions on obtaining a license, however.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by josephcsible on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:52PM (#32805899)
> buses, despite their size, kill far fewer pedestrians and passengers.

Is that still true after you adjust for the number of buses on the road vs. the number of cars? If not, then this is like saying driving drunk is less dangerous than driving sober since only 30% of car crash fatalities involve drunk drivers.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by asdff on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:13AM (#32806328)
Yes because of the driver itself is behaviorally different between the bus and the car. The bus drivers are profesionals who drive no higher than the speed limit, they heed all traffic laws, they generally keep to the right or otherwise drive predictably, and some times they even have dedicated bus lanes. Your average car driver is not all of those things at once, if they were there would be a lot fewer people going 5 or 15 over the speed limit and driving drunk.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by josephcsible on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:24AM (#32806384)
Those are a lot of reasons to think it's plausible that it might still be true after the adjustment. Is there actual data that shows it is true, though? Also, I've seen buses break traffic laws before, so don't pretend they never do.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by asdff on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:53AM (#32806554)
The data does show this, look at figure 1 here at the top of the article:

https://usa.streetsblog.org/2014/12/19/heres-how-much-safer-...

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by josephcsible on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:34AM (#32806750)
According to that figure, while transit buses are safer for "Users (passengers and employees in a vehicle)" than passenger cars and light trucks are, they're more dangerous for "Others (e.g., pedestrians and passengers in other vehicles)". And isn't that exactly the same thing going on with big vs. small cars? Buses are bigger than cars and SUVs, so they're safer for their own occupants at the expense of everyone else. (Note that the figure measures fatalities per passenger-mile, not per mile, so the advantage that fewer buses would be needed than cars to move the same number of people has already been factored in.)
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by Schroedingersat on Tuesday September 13, 2022 @07:36PM (#32831488)
The USA has very pedestrian hostile laws/infrastructure and buses definitionally stop and start where there are a lot of pedestrians (and many of them will be crossing the road in a rush because they saw a bus).

That data could be representitive of buses being big and heavy or it could be representitive of them sharing space with pedestrians.

Compare the same dataset for busses on a grade separated RBT with well paid/trained drivers and platform doors and you get a very different story.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by josephcsible on Saturday September 24, 2022 @01:20PM (#32964664)
> or it could be representitive of them sharing space with pedestrians.

But there's nowhere that buses share space with pedestrians and cars don't, so that can't account for why buses are more dangerous than cars.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by __derek__ on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:14PM (#32805678)
Unlike large personal vehicles, modern buses/coaches are also designed with sight-lines that makes it easy to see pedestrians.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by bombcar on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:17PM (#32812545)
I'm highly disappointed that electric vehicles haven't taken advantage of the "no need for a engine in the front" and make vehicles that are different. Many trucks have the driver in FRONT of the front wheels, but very few passenger vehicles do that, even though without an engine there's really no reason not to.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by marcosdumay on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:59PM (#32805148)
Probably, high-speed trains that carry you from one slow car into another.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by evandwight on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:28PM (#32804912)
Not even pedestrians die at 30kmph.

Edit: you are right it's about 3% die at 30kpmh, vs ~35% at 50kpmh. My bad. Still lower speeds dramatically improve the safety of cars.

https://nacto.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/2011PedestrianR...

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by woodruffw on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:31PM (#32804933)
"Die" is a bad target. I don't want to be a quadriplegic if I don't have to be, and a car going 30 MPH (realistically 40, if the limit is 30) on a residential street is more than capable of doing that to me.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by kube-system on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:53PM (#32805110)
They absolutely can. People can and do die from falling over and hitting their head. A 30km/h impact is not trivial, it can be expected to break bones and cause internal bleeding that can be deadly. An impact to the spine or head can be very easily be life changing.

Also, residential roads in the US are usually 40km/h

I personally know someone who was hit at about 10-15hm/h and they were hospitalized and broke their spine.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by robotastronaut on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:11PM (#32805255)
My college girlfriend was hit by a car right next to me going those speeds during a turn. It seems slow, but meat on steel is pretty brutal at any travel speed. It was a four or five month recovery. Remember that the velocity of the vehicle is only a part of the picture — mass is the damage dealer here.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by picture on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:57PM (#32805570)
Mass is what contributes to inertia which allows the speed to be carried for longer... The acceleration, which is the difference in speeds, is the real damage dealer.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by xyzzyz on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:05PM (#32805199)
People regularly die by hitting their head on a hard surface when falling from a standstill.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by sdenton4 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:09PM (#32805236)
kpmh ?= kilometers per millihour?
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by VectorLock on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:04PM (#32805190)
They spent a lot of time marketing how safe the SMART car was for a small vehicle. I believe they even showed putting a semi tractor on top of the SMART car to show how rigid its safety shell was.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by josephcsible on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:58PM (#32805928)
Which is misleading. Which would you rather do: gently set a 50lb rock on your toes, or drop a 5lb rock on your toes from 4 feet in the air (equivalent to an 11mph collision)?
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by markovbot on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:24PM (#32804885)
it's probably a train
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by bombcar on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:03PM (#32805179)
Trains are the last word when pedestrians gang together and say “hit this”.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by thrown_22 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:36PM (#32804967)
Something similar to a Tuk Tuk but with internal and external air bags for crashes.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by starkd on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:33PM (#32804946)
Unless the people in the other car are in a big car as well.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by woodruffw on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:35PM (#32804961)
Where does that leave pedestrians and cyclists?
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by jrockway on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:36PM (#32804970)
As a fine paste, and a footnote in the newspaper "he should have been wearing a helmet" or "he was found with a phone". You want victim blaming in the US? Be a pedestrian or cyclist.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by WrtCdEvrydy on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:39PM (#32804985)
This can be fixed easily... divide the safety rating by the number of (thousand) pounds a vehicle has.

No more juicing your safety rating by adding more mass.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by jrockway on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:08PM (#32805221)
A lot of danger to pedestrians and cyclists actually comes from the design of the car. It's currently cool to have like some sort of livestock-rammer over your front bumper that just crushes pedestrians instead of sending them up over the hood. People don't have those for safety, they just think it looks cool. We should really make those illegal on city streets. (If you drive a pickup truck out on your farm, this doesn't apply, I can see the legitimacy of that sort of vehicle choice and that sort of mod. It's for actual productivity, not style.)

Basically, the industry puts 0 thought into protecting other road users, and it's a really big problem. We should start mandating safety features for those outside of the car.

The big problem is that driving isn't just for rich people. It's a lifeline for the poorest Americans that have no choice but to trade free time for commuting time to be able to afford to live. So if we mandate expensive safety features, it's just a tax on the poor. People might be willing to pay the tax to save their own bacon, but they certainly aren't going to do it to save some random person riding their bike to work. That's why we have to dramatically rethink how we build our cities and suburbs. Things like electric cars to combat climate change are a distraction from the real issues. Fossil fuels aren't smashing pedestrians, dividing our cities into unliveable neighborhoods with 20 lane freeways, or mandating 1 parking space for every person in a 10,000 person office building. That's just cars, and electric cars fix none of it.

The good news is, it looks like all the suburbs built in the 50s are due for things like water main replacement, street replacement, sewer replacement, etc. and nobody can afford it. So we'll have a chance to densify and cut cars out of our culture for good. Until then, hide your children and hide your wives, so that people can freely rampage through your neighborhood on their way to a meeting they're already 20 minutes late for. In a carbon-sensitive way, of course.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by Swizec on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:39PM (#32805445)
> Basically, the industry puts 0 thought into protecting other road users, and it's a really big problem. We should start mandating safety features for those outside of the car

The Euro NCAP rating has been evaluating pedestrian safety for some 20 years now. That’s why all modern cars have tall fat noses – it distributes load across more of a person’s body and reduces injury rates. Fifth Gear did a great segment about this in the early 2000’s where they found it’s better to be hit by a 4x4 (term SUV didnt’ exist yet) than by a sedan.

https://www.euroncap.com/en/for-engineers/protocols/vulnerab...

The American NHTSA is starting to add pedestrian safety ratings as well.

https://www.fatherly.com/news/vehicle-safety-ratings-will-so...

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by starkd on Monday September 12, 2022 @08:27AM (#32809131)
There comes a point where all those safety features increase the cost of the vehicle, putting them further out of reach for those poorest Americans. Technology does not solve ALL problems. Safety improvements must come from more driver responsibility just as much as technical improvements.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by bobthepanda on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:02PM (#32805176)
I mean, we could just do what Europe does and also include a pedestrian safety test in the safety rating.

The issue is that the US still hasn’t done it.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by sidewndr46 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:23PM (#32805347)
The US is of the opinion that the safest place for pedestrians is in cars.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by jrockway on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:25AM (#32806083)
I'm not sure people care what the result of the test is, if it costs them money or a feature they want more. That's just how Americans are.

I will say that people seem to put up with emissions standards, so it wouldn't be unthinkable to add some standards that improve the safety of other road users. But as the other comments mention, it's a hard sell; most Americans think the people on the sidewalk or on bikes should be driving instead.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by bobthepanda on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:13AM (#32806332)
I mean, if people didn’t care, car commercials wouldn’t tout “5-star safety ratings” as a feature.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by jrockway on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:25AM (#32807105)
Well, the safety features are for the purchaser in that case. If you let your cat drive and he goes off a cliff, you survive. That's worth an extra $1000! We're talking about a new thing; safety for people other than the people in the car.

That's what the original article is about; people buy heavy cars so that they are more likely to survive the accident than whoever they hit.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by iggldiggl on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:59AM (#32810358)
Probably the idea is to somewhat sneak that in through the back door, i.e. hope that car manufacturers would be too embarrassed to advertise with a bad crash test result, even if the bad result was "only" due to lack of pedestrian safety.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by bobthepanda on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:59PM (#32814254)
Right.

If even one car model gets changed as a result of this, that would already represent a possible decrease in deaths. It doesn't have to be a total, dominating success to be a net positive.

I wouldn’t even really call it a backdoor. The equivalent European and Australian tests already have this, and they have not seen our recent uptick in deaths.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by hedora on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:10PM (#32805653)
Well, Obama mandated pedestrian safety be included, then Trump blocked the change. Finally (hopefully) congress forced it through as part of the infrastructure spending bill:

https://www.fatherly.com/news/vehicle-safety-ratings-will-so...

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by rtpg on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:10PM (#32805248)
Other fun fixes: tax by the weight of a car. Disallow individual purchases of vehicles where the dashboard is over 6 feet off the ground (yes, some people would make an LLC just to buy the giant car. It would stop a lot of it). Place a price cap on cars!

My favorite pie-in-the-sky-impossible-in-practice thing: force cars to be ugly as sin. Would help with the huge cars, but also has a nice side effect of getting rid of sports car drivers as well.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by catiopatio on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:23PM (#32805344)
Comments like this make me think we should have a “speech tax”, online comment licensing requirements, and a real-name mandate.

My favorite “pie-in-the-sky-impossible-in-practice thing”: force anyone advocating for this kind of petty authoritarianism (my sardonic comment included) to wear a neon pink t-shirt in public, labeled, front and back, with “I tried to be a little dictator on the internet and all I got was this stupid t-shirt”

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by rtpg on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:42AM (#32806479)
Yeah, clearly my comment about making all cars ugly is a serious policy proposal that I have any power to enact, instead of me just venting about driving skills and safety. Sports car driver isn't a protected class

Everyone can act like piloting a multi-ton machine through city centers is their god given right, but I like thinking about the alternate universe (and hell, the _actually existing universe_ in many places in the world) where people can feel safe, even if it means that city driving is a slog.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by hedora on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:57PM (#32805571)
They already effectively do this by having laxer standards for passenger safety ratings for smaller cars.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by starkd on Monday September 12, 2022 @10:24AM (#32810781)
Is it any better for a pedestrian or cyclist to get hit by a Ford 150 or a volkswagon? The outcome is bad either way. Collision avoidance would be better than the lesser of two outcomes.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by woodruffw on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:07PM (#32814372)
> Collision avoidance would be better than the lesser of two outcomes.

We could ensure collision avoidance by banning cars from cities! But that's presumably not what you meant.

Yes, it is much better (although certainly not good) to be hit by a small VW than it is to be hit by a pickup truck. European safety standards reflect this fact; the US's standards should as well.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by adolph on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:40PM (#32804993)
Depends on if you’d rather death over disfunctionally maimed or comatose. Even a without a vehicle, human bodies interacting with a velocity difference of 35 or so is not pleasant.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by jrockway on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:30AM (#32806106)
Yup, and approximately 0 people would die if we made the speed limit on city streets 15mph. Give the bikes going 18mph a speeding ticket too, that doesn't even make me mad.

Remember that the average speed in Manhattan is less than 5 mph. There is little to be gained in travel time by careening down neighborhood streets.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by adolph on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:08PM (#32815255)
I'd be less sanguine about the potential reduction in death. It'd be interesting to see the stats in terms of distance from home to freeway, and freeway to destination and get the change in commute time compared to deaths occurring between those segments.

If you live 10m from a freeway, then at 35mph just over 15m is ok. At 5mph 2 hours seems less than acceptable. I can be math-dumb, so it wouldn't be surprising if I'm way off.

  (10/35)*60 = 17
  (10/5)*60 = 120
Even at just 2m away the difference in commute is substantial.

  (2/35)*60 = 3.4
  (2/5)*60 = 24.0
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by jrockway on Monday September 12, 2022 @03:53PM (#32815935)
Just as a sample, I used to have a 3.5 mile commute in NYC. It's about 45 minutes by walking, 25 minutes by bike (google maps says 15 minutes, I never did it that fast), 12 minutes by subway, or 19 minutes by driving. That's with current speed limits. New York City is so clogged with traffic that walking is actually competitive with driving, and biking would be faster than driving currently if the traffic lights weren't timed for an imaginary 25-35mph speed limit (that is never achieved).

Out in the suburbs, the distances are long and speed does matter. That makes the situation very tough; 15mph speed limits are going to severely devalue your real estate investment. I really have no answer for a sane transition here, and that's a big problem American society faces.

(On the other hand, the ocean consuming New York City is going to severely devalue real estate investments, too.)

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by pshc on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:39PM (#32805446)
In that case we’ll have to get an even bigger car to be safe.

And now we all live in monster truck land.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by jupp0r on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:16PM (#32805693)
Or get rid of human drivers. All data points to the fact that we are terrible at driving.
[dead]
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by clarkmoody on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:59PM (#32805153)
Promoting destruction of property and intimidation has no place in civil society.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by smt88 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:55PM (#32805557)
It doesn't matter because there is no such activist group and vandalization of SUVs is not a common crime.

Such a high percentage of cars are SUVs that it wouldn't even be sending a coherent message.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by josephcsible on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:00AM (#32805942)
There absolutely are such vandal groups. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31939177
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by smt88 on Monday September 12, 2022 @09:55AM (#32810292)
So this guy says "there are activist groups," and your evidence is this website: https://www.tyreextinguishers.com/news?slug=tyre-extinguishe...

They claim only to have damaged 40 cars one time. There's no evidence they did that, no public outcry in New York, and no corroborating evidence at all.

Again, there is no movement like this. There has not been a spike in vandalism against SUVs. I work with auto insurance data in my day job, and changes in damage to parked SUVs hasn't notably changed.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by cma on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:17PM (#32805301)
Just putting on a bull bar on a big truck/SUV in a city center itself isn't destruction of property or intimidation even if it may lead to that. It might actually intimidate some people walking around at street level if they knew how mangled up in it you can get caught, but the vast majority aren't even aware.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by fnordpiglet on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:34PM (#32804956)
I feel like SUV rage was much worse in 1995-2005 era.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by adolph on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:46PM (#32805044)
Yes, it peaked with David Foster Wallace being cheered by graduating Kenyon folks when he was making a counter-example:

. . . and I can dwell on the fact that the patriotic or religious bumper-stickers always seem to be on the biggest, most disgustingly selfish vehicles, driven by the ugliest [responding here to loud applause] — this is an example of how NOT to think, though . . .

https://fs.blog/david-foster-wallace-this-is-water/

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by woodruffw on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:24PM (#32805349)
I think you're right. There's certainly been an uptick during COVID in cities, however.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by treeman79 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:25PM (#32804892)
Not everyone lives in insane places where people feel the need to car shame.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by bigDinosaur on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:52PM (#32805109)
The overwhelming (and I mean truly overwhelming, to the point you often cannot even get people to engage with any criticism of cars) majority of places are the absolute opposite. Car shaming is basically rounds down to zero. Contrast that with bicycle or bus or public transport shaming which is frequent and often extremely abusive.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by Gigachad on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:11PM (#32805253)
SUV drivers have to face occasional online complaints while the other are up against literal murder attempts, often successful.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by foxes on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:09PM (#32805226)
It's more than abusive, social media is filled with frothing car fanatics that want to kill cyclists merely for slowing them down from being able to roar up to the traffic light and stop in traffic a few seconds earlier.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by foxes on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:28PM (#32804913)
Not everyone lives in insane car filled wastelands. Aerial pictures of lots of American cities are truly abhorrent, vast concrete and asphalt wastelands purely for car parking. The American system and people definitely need car shaming. I don't want the same thing exported to my city.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by userbinator on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:51PM (#32805095)
Neither do we want to live in the equivalent of a factory farm.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by foxes on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:00PM (#32805158)
How do you get reducing car dependence in cities = factory farm?

Walkable, rideable, and a plentitude of public transport is infinitely more sustainable and humane than vast expanses of parking lots.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by savingsPossible on Monday September 12, 2022 @05:51AM (#32807876)
One could argue that this is the exact good use of shaming: As a mild punishment for anti-social behaviour
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by Gigachad on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:28PM (#32804911)
SUV shaming is a lot like drink driver shaming. A completely rational action for healthy society.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by UpstandingUser on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:34PM (#32804952)
> SUV shaming is a lot like drink driver shaming.

Are you drink?

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by jrockway on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:38PM (#32804979)
"Drink driving" is the UK term for what Americans call "drunk driving."
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by CDRdude on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:40PM (#32804990)
"Drink driver" and "drink driving" seem to be the British phrases.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by Nicksil on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:58PM (#32805146)
>Are you drink?

Are you American?

[dead]
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by celtain on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:53PM (#32805113)
While those activists are being stupid, this argument is even worse. A heavier car is intrinsically more dangerous to those around it, as the article we're commenting on explains. People can also choose how large of a personal vehicle they want to buy.

Neither of those apply to race in the slightest.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by anigbrowl on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:35PM (#32804965)
Being born as a member of a disfavored ethnic group is just like buying a car
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by gitfan86 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @09:30PM (#32804925)
Then your child gets to live the rest of their life knowing they killed someone.
[dead]
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by smt88 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:56PM (#32805563)
Please elaborate and provide links
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by thedrexster on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:18PM (#32805703)
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by Gigachad on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:18PM (#32805704)
Here's one example https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/dec/21/kyle-rittenh...

Now I don't think he was guilty, but the fact the media and population put him on a stage with confetti and a cheering crowd shows the state of society when the guys only public action was shooting some people in self defense.

A healthy society admits that sometimes people do die in ways that are unpreventable or not at fault without celebrating when it happens or what we see where people are itching to get in these situations so they can kill legally and be a hero.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by smt88 on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:03AM (#32806285)
"The media and population" didn't put him on a stage or celebrate him. A small, extreme subset of the Republican Party did.

Only 32% of Americans thought he should be found not guilty[1], and only a fraction of that group would want to celebrate him.

1. https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/20...

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by Gigachad on Monday September 12, 2022 @04:34AM (#32807502)
The majority of people only got their opinions from twitter and late night talk shows so their thoughts are really only a reflection on whatever the media was broadcasting.

If you look at all the recordings it’s very clearly within the law. That doesn’t make him a hero and he shouldn’t be a public figure or celebrated. But it’s also pretty telling that the majority of the population has a gut reaction that’s illogical if you view the recordings.

Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by smt88 on Monday September 12, 2022 @05:13AM (#32807690)
The majority of people don't read Twitter or watch late-night shows, and there are no late-night shows that celebrated Rittenhouse.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by stjohnswarts on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:29PM (#32805374)
Yeah I actually bought my nephew a fairly well kept up 20 year old crown victoria for his birthday because his single mom couldn't afford a car. So I'm guessing you wouldn't like my purchase, but I was thinking selfishly I suppose about his personal well being.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by hotpotamus on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:52PM (#32805535)
I don't think that's an especially heavy car. I don't think it's a bad choice, but I suspect a modern unibody sedan will behave a bit better in a crash. And it seems like side protection came a long way in that time too - my 2016 sedan's doors felt like like opening a bank vault after I was used to the thin doors of my 2001 car.
Re:Heavier cars are safer for their drivers, but far deadlie... by nradov on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:55PM (#32805553)
Don't be too confident in your nephew's well being. The Ford Crown Victoria (and similar Panther platform vehicles) has terrible ratings for side impact crashes.

https://www.iihs.org/ratings/vehicle/ford/crown-victoria-4-d...