If we add congestion into the mix since everyone is bicycling, I imagine a higher number of accidents would occur. Right now an estimated 67 million people in the USA ride a bicycle for an estimated 15 billion hours combined per year. 228 million licensed drivers times 290 average hours on the road equals 66 billion hours per year. Let us assume the bicyclists will have to spend three times more travel time due to lower speed of bicycles. That equals roughly 200 billion hours of bicycling per year. 200 billion hours divided by 15 billion equals 13.3. 900 257 deaths per 15 billion hours equals 3,341 deaths per year. The average number of deaths per year from automobile crashes for the last few years is about 36,000.
Even if this is a conservative estimate. I think it is safe to say you are essentially correct.
Half are elderly.
About a third are on ebikes
87% involve a car.
That's around 0.8 deaths per hundred thousand people worth of bike modeshare not invovling a car. 1/15th of the USA and a quarter of netherlands road deaths.
This is with drunk cycling penalties being almost completely unenforced (although not sure how it compares to US drunk driving prevalence).
Granted cars are used for the longer trips so it's not completely sound, but bikes are used for congested trips. Small vehicle modeshare also shortens all trips.
My guess is the safest vehicle would look like a train followed by lightweight velo no heavier than a dutch bike (and not optimized for aero) or a recumbent trike with a roll cage and a lap belt. Also we can conclude that either current ebikes are too fast and heavy, or they result in people cycling who would be too frail otherwise.
For my commute to work, its something like my choice of a 35 minute drive (not counting the circling I will have to do finding a parking spot at the other end) or a 45 minute bike ride. I probably save time on the whole even without counting the parking fiasco, considering now I don't need to find time in my schedule to work in my cardio.
So to answer your snarky question with snark in kind, mostly from the other 4/5 of emissions.
For a lot of people I talk to about getting around when it comes up, the major stopping point with biking is just the lack of infrastructure and feeling afraid of cars. Most people aren't comfortable taking the lane while biking so it becomes a dangerous experience when they don't. As the saying goes, though, if you build it, they will come. Any city I've been in that has built out a gridlike network of bike lanes seems to have a lot of people riding around. Once you build them that network you enable a lot of trips for those people uncomfortable with the existing road network.
A nearby neighborhood did something similar but with physical medians. Much better, but still people just use less busy streets mostly.
My main issue getting to work is not those streets, but post ww2 neighborhoods that have one entance and exit forcing me on to highways with glass covered shoulders and speedlimits over 55. That is what I want them to fix. But that would actually involve earth moving and eminent domain, not just a bit of paint or concrete.
These trucks also contribute to the rise in vehicle size. I did not like driving when I was in a sedan sized car sharing the high speed highways hours from cities on those highways
If they're going extremely long distances you could even have some kind of dedicated hard wearing road surface. And if lots of them are going to the same place you could get them to move in a convoy. And once they're in a convoy you could hook them together...
The US rail system is very well established and has been well built out since before the rise of the automobile. But goods need to get from the rail depot to the end destination and right now the best we have is enormous 18-wheelers and as long as those are on the road, it's too dangerous for me to want to take a smaller car
The interstate system and truck delivery seems to be pretty fantastic at servicing the continental US when paired with freight trains, cargo planes, etc. And it is similarly effective for delivery of all other kinds of things including people.
These systems would be good to implement in many cities, but interstate shipping and travel is another thing altogether.
More realistically, it's smaller cars on slower city streets.
The distinction is professional drivers and safety standards.
Is that still true after you adjust for the number of buses on the road vs. the number of cars? If not, then this is like saying driving drunk is less dangerous than driving sober since only 30% of car crash fatalities involve drunk drivers.
https://usa.streetsblog.org/2014/12/19/heres-how-much-safer-...
That data could be representitive of buses being big and heavy or it could be representitive of them sharing space with pedestrians.
Compare the same dataset for busses on a grade separated RBT with well paid/trained drivers and platform doors and you get a very different story.
But there's nowhere that buses share space with pedestrians and cars don't, so that can't account for why buses are more dangerous than cars.
Edit: you are right it's about 3% die at 30kpmh, vs ~35% at 50kpmh. My bad. Still lower speeds dramatically improve the safety of cars.
https://nacto.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/2011PedestrianR...
Also, residential roads in the US are usually 40km/h
I personally know someone who was hit at about 10-15hm/h and they were hospitalized and broke their spine.
No more juicing your safety rating by adding more mass.
Basically, the industry puts 0 thought into protecting other road users, and it's a really big problem. We should start mandating safety features for those outside of the car.
The big problem is that driving isn't just for rich people. It's a lifeline for the poorest Americans that have no choice but to trade free time for commuting time to be able to afford to live. So if we mandate expensive safety features, it's just a tax on the poor. People might be willing to pay the tax to save their own bacon, but they certainly aren't going to do it to save some random person riding their bike to work. That's why we have to dramatically rethink how we build our cities and suburbs. Things like electric cars to combat climate change are a distraction from the real issues. Fossil fuels aren't smashing pedestrians, dividing our cities into unliveable neighborhoods with 20 lane freeways, or mandating 1 parking space for every person in a 10,000 person office building. That's just cars, and electric cars fix none of it.
The good news is, it looks like all the suburbs built in the 50s are due for things like water main replacement, street replacement, sewer replacement, etc. and nobody can afford it. So we'll have a chance to densify and cut cars out of our culture for good. Until then, hide your children and hide your wives, so that people can freely rampage through your neighborhood on their way to a meeting they're already 20 minutes late for. In a carbon-sensitive way, of course.
The Euro NCAP rating has been evaluating pedestrian safety for some 20 years now. That’s why all modern cars have tall fat noses – it distributes load across more of a person’s body and reduces injury rates. Fifth Gear did a great segment about this in the early 2000’s where they found it’s better to be hit by a 4x4 (term SUV didnt’ exist yet) than by a sedan.
https://www.euroncap.com/en/for-engineers/protocols/vulnerab...
The American NHTSA is starting to add pedestrian safety ratings as well.
https://www.fatherly.com/news/vehicle-safety-ratings-will-so...
The issue is that the US still hasn’t done it.
I will say that people seem to put up with emissions standards, so it wouldn't be unthinkable to add some standards that improve the safety of other road users. But as the other comments mention, it's a hard sell; most Americans think the people on the sidewalk or on bikes should be driving instead.
That's what the original article is about; people buy heavy cars so that they are more likely to survive the accident than whoever they hit.
If even one car model gets changed as a result of this, that would already represent a possible decrease in deaths. It doesn't have to be a total, dominating success to be a net positive.
I wouldn’t even really call it a backdoor. The equivalent European and Australian tests already have this, and they have not seen our recent uptick in deaths.
https://www.fatherly.com/news/vehicle-safety-ratings-will-so...
My favorite pie-in-the-sky-impossible-in-practice thing: force cars to be ugly as sin. Would help with the huge cars, but also has a nice side effect of getting rid of sports car drivers as well.
My favorite “pie-in-the-sky-impossible-in-practice thing”: force anyone advocating for this kind of petty authoritarianism (my sardonic comment included) to wear a neon pink t-shirt in public, labeled, front and back, with “I tried to be a little dictator on the internet and all I got was this stupid t-shirt”
Everyone can act like piloting a multi-ton machine through city centers is their god given right, but I like thinking about the alternate universe (and hell, the _actually existing universe_ in many places in the world) where people can feel safe, even if it means that city driving is a slog.
We could ensure collision avoidance by banning cars from cities! But that's presumably not what you meant.
Yes, it is much better (although certainly not good) to be hit by a small VW than it is to be hit by a pickup truck. European safety standards reflect this fact; the US's standards should as well.
Remember that the average speed in Manhattan is less than 5 mph. There is little to be gained in travel time by careening down neighborhood streets.
If you live 10m from a freeway, then at 35mph just over 15m is ok. At 5mph 2 hours seems less than acceptable. I can be math-dumb, so it wouldn't be surprising if I'm way off.
(10/35)*60 = 17
(10/5)*60 = 120
Even at just 2m away the difference in commute is substantial. (2/35)*60 = 3.4
(2/5)*60 = 24.0Out in the suburbs, the distances are long and speed does matter. That makes the situation very tough; 15mph speed limits are going to severely devalue your real estate investment. I really have no answer for a sane transition here, and that's a big problem American society faces.
(On the other hand, the ocean consuming New York City is going to severely devalue real estate investments, too.)
And now we all live in monster truck land.
Such a high percentage of cars are SUVs that it wouldn't even be sending a coherent message.
They claim only to have damaged 40 cars one time. There's no evidence they did that, no public outcry in New York, and no corroborating evidence at all.
Again, there is no movement like this. There has not been a spike in vandalism against SUVs. I work with auto insurance data in my day job, and changes in damage to parked SUVs hasn't notably changed.
. . . and I can dwell on the fact that the patriotic or religious bumper-stickers always seem to be on the biggest, most disgustingly selfish vehicles, driven by the ugliest [responding here to loud applause] — this is an example of how NOT to think, though . . .
Walkable, rideable, and a plentitude of public transport is infinitely more sustainable and humane than vast expanses of parking lots.
Are you drink?
Are you American?
Neither of those apply to race in the slightest.
https://www.politico.com/news/2021/11/19/the-lionization-of-...
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/dec/21/kyle-rittenh...
Now I don't think he was guilty, but the fact the media and population put him on a stage with confetti and a cheering crowd shows the state of society when the guys only public action was shooting some people in self defense.
A healthy society admits that sometimes people do die in ways that are unpreventable or not at fault without celebrating when it happens or what we see where people are itching to get in these situations so they can kill legally and be a hero.
Only 32% of Americans thought he should be found not guilty[1], and only a fraction of that group would want to celebrate him.
1. https://today.yougov.com/topics/politics/articles-reports/20...
If you look at all the recordings it’s very clearly within the law. That doesn’t make him a hero and he shouldn’t be a public figure or celebrated. But it’s also pretty telling that the majority of the population has a gut reaction that’s illogical if you view the recordings.
https://www.iihs.org/ratings/vehicle/ford/crown-victoria-4-d...
Edit: Wow a whole reply chain spawned from this comment got nuked! Stay safe out there Americans, you've got some wild divisions amongst yourselves and its only getting worse. For the record, I love trains, subways, buses and biking but I also own a crossover sized vehicle and recognize that everyone has their own personal preferences and requirements and that no one transit solution will meet everyone's needs, I hope you all can see that too without violence.