News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by protonbob on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:37AM (#32651667)
I know that technology has displaced workers in the past, but it seems to be doing so at a faster and faster pace. It makes me rethink my involvement in the creation of software and its ethical implications.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by koala_man on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:48AM (#32651797)
The fact that making work more efficient can be a problem highlights some fundamental flaws in our society.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by phoe-krk on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:04PM (#32651977)
I think it revolves around just one fundamental question that's become obvious since the start of the industrial revolution: why have workers if you can get work done without them? You can answer this question rather quickly; very often, the benefits of being able to produce something en masse outweigh the initial drop in quality due to adopting an automation process that is not yet mature but evolves over time, and that's been proven many times in the past two centuries.

It's just the speed and the scale that have been following logistic distribution. We're still before the midway point as a global society, but we can certainly see the big speedup as more and more work becomes automated.

If people's work can be automated away as a whole and people somehow become poorer rather than richer, then the benefits of automation are sucked away from them. And here comes the flaws you mention - or the flaw, I think, singular. They happen exactly in this one point.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by chrismorgan on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:25PM (#32652207)
Sometimes it’s just an initial drop in quality, other times it’s permanent. My favourite example is book binding: hot-melt glue has completely supplanted cold glue in mass production, despite being drastically inferior, because it’s (just barely) good enough, and it’s so much faster/easier/cheaper for production.

Many aspects of computer setting of works for printing also show a significant regression in potential quality (prose, musical engraving, &c.), though the right software and proper human tweaking can balance that out—but people seldom actually do as much tweaking as would be done automatically by the experts of old. And as for text presentation on screen… well, that’s just lousy compared to what an expert setter would do. But it does adapt to different media with no or minimal effort required, doing in one second what used to take days, and that’s a rather big deal.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by toomanydoubts on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:36PM (#32652321)
Something I sometimes think about, is how really can capitalists benefit from that? If you can automate your company away, and fire all employees, and if every company is doing that, then workers have no jobs or ways to make money. So the customers for most of the companies start disappearing. It's the ultimate accumulation of capital, to a point that the wheels of economy grind to a halt.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by dougabug on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @01:33PM (#32652929)
That’s exactly what happened to the Magratheans in “Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy”:

“Unfortunately, the venture was so successful that Magrathea soon became the richest planet of all time and the rest of the Galaxy was reduced to abject poverty. The Magratheans went into hibernation, awaiting an economic recovery that could afford their services once more.“

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by vidarh on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @03:29PM (#32654059)
This is exactly Marx' thesis. He took capitalists on their word with respect to believing that competition will drive margins towards zero over time, and that as a consequence cutting labour is inherently a pre-requisite for surviving competition, and that as a result that capitalism will eventually, once it runs out of new markets to expand into, start experiencing crises of simultaneous overproduction and under-employment.

If he was right, it can be "patched" and made to work with a sufficient level of redistribution to avoid such crises, or left to fail catastrophically without.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by avgcorrection on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @05:26PM (#32655332)
Why should it matter what benefits the group of people who end up just sitting on a pile of money in the end?
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by avgcorrection on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @05:25PM (#32655317)
That’s not the fundamental question.

The fundamental question is: Why have owners?

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by barrkel on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @01:27PM (#32652869)
Rapid change is a real problem and not a flaw of society. People cannot change careers quickly without loss of human capital. There is no flaw in society that you can fix to prevent this.

It doesn't mean that we shouldn't make things more efficient, but economies exist to serve people, not the other way around. That sometimes means bailing some people out, sometimes it means phasing something in, and sometimes it means changing the definition of value.

For example, painting used to be how you'd get a portrait. But photos did that much better. Painting shifted: it became much more abstract, and because photos were cheap and easy, they didn't have the same cachet as a portrait. Not many people hang big photo portraits on their walls they way they might have done with paintings.

I suspect authenticity, or some other thing which the machine cannot replicate, may be valued more in future.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by protonbob on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:59AM (#32651907)
I agree. But I also think that meaningful work that provides value to your community and to yourself is something that provides some of the greatest satisfaction available to man. If you remove that ability by either automating someone's job or reducing it to a kitschy "artisan" label which implies that their work is now inefficient and flawed compared to the efficient automated way, you are taking away something important about the human experience that cannot be replaced by leisure activities.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by xapata on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:39PM (#32652355)
> ... greatest satisfaction available to man.

What about women? Yeah, yeah, I know it's uncouth to worry about gendered language. On to the real topic ...

> reducing [a job] to a kitschy "artisan" label

Automation doesn't (only) reduce jobs, it (also) allows people to get meta. They are now free to think about how the job gets done, rather than constrained by time to only do the job the way they did it yesterday. Or, they can do other jobs that they prefer.

I used to live in an apartment without a washing machine, and where the closest laundromat was a 20-minute walk away. I got used to a bucket-and-plunger method for washing my clothes. It was enjoyable in that "I am the salt of the earth" way. When I found a used sink-attachable tiny washing machine on Craigslist, I had a smile on my face the rest of the day.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by swatcoder on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:08PM (#32652032)
Well, it highlights that there's some disagreement between people who see maximizing production as inevitably positive, and other people who are unconvinced.

It sounds like you might be so squarely in one of those camps, that you see it as a fundamental flaw that people may disagree with you. To me, that sounds even worse!

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by vkou on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:57PM (#32652582)
We could work those flaws out after we figure out what people getting put out of work are going to eat. Or do.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by jermaustin1 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:44AM (#32651745)
Having worked with a lot of artists, they are seeing stable diffusion and other image generators as a way to generate lots of ideas. A base they would then ,usually starting from scratch, build their end product off of.

So even though to a casual glance, these images look amazing, if you look closely, you see all the flaws that come with them being generated. Weird artifacts, a lack of symmetry that humans usually add to their creations.

These flaws would not exist (to such a degree) when a professional artist paints the same scene.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by dweekly on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:57AM (#32651890)
Yes - this will make artists hyper productive IMO; and will make a lot more people willing to make art! If you've ever had a little ditty and wondered what it would sound like as a violin concerto in D minor, now you can know! If you ever wanted your wife painted as a Rembrandt, there you have it. If your five year old comes up with an idea for a fun video game called Laser Chicken, now his friends can play it.

Imagine pairing this with bespoke automated clothing output - take a photo of an outfit, verbally describe the changes you want to it ("a little more debonair, dark lapels, 1920's styling"), click a button, preview it as it would look on you in several recent pictures you took, and a week later your tailored suit arrives. Now for sneakers. Hats. Bags. Watches.

The 20th century was about mass production to ensure everyone could have things: food, clothing, transport, entertainment. The 21st century may turn to expression: allowing each person to express themselves however they want in their goods and services. Or just following along to buy whatever your favorite tastemakers recommend. However involved you want to be!

The world is about to get a lot weirder and more interesting.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by protonbob on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:02PM (#32651949)
Making artists hyper productive will cheapen even further their output. If one artist can do the work that you are currently paying 8 to do, you only need to pay one artist that can wrangle these tools.

I would agree that this is like 20th century mass production. To be clear, I don't necessarily think that mass production is a good thing either. In fact, it has been probably the most detrimental thing to our environment that humans have ever done.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by skydhash on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:14PM (#32652097)
They cheapen the entry fees for learning, but the expectation will keep getting higher. It's like games where, even for indies, they won't accept N64 quality these days. Text to speech is quite good now, but people prefer real narrators. Everyone can create music with a cheap laptop and some midi keyboards, but only those really talented will make it.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by Retric on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:36PM (#32652320)
Some very popular games are much less polished than N64/SNES quality.

Mobile, Indy, and Retro are all very popular, just look at what people are playing on Twitch.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by tshaddox on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:21PM (#32652163)
> If one artist can do the work that you are currently paying 8 to do, you only need to pay one artist that can wrangle these tools.

And maybe the number of places paying for art will grow by a factor of 8.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by namose on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @04:11PM (#32654469)
Maybe, but it hasn’t worked that way for software. I think people might see the opportunity to inject bespoke art in a lot of places it wasn’t previously. College students who could only afford movie posters previously will have art commissioned, every building will have a mural, etc etc.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by dweekly on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @12:55AM (#32658517)
One of the many things that I loved about Lisbon was that art was hilariously pervasive. It felt like every vertical space was filled with beautiful and original art. The whole city was a gallery. It would be wonderful to see that in more places.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by boppo1 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @03:18PM (#32653950)
I thought Teddy K was dead. Maybe you're a bot trained on his works.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by skydhash on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:05PM (#32651996)
This concept was used in westworld [0]

[0]: https://youtu.be/2xm4feEKDjw

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by josephg on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:02PM (#32651948)
> These flaws would not exist (to such a degree) when a professional artist paints the same scene.

The flaws in AI generated art were 100x as obvious in systems like this only a few years ago. In 5 years I doubt anyone will be able to tell the difference between AI and human art.

When the photograph displaced most portrait painters, we invented a new type of artist - the photographer. I hope we’ll see the same thing here - artists who specialise in using stable diffusion (and friends) to make new art in a new way. This blog post is like one of the world’s first photographers saying “hey look how the photo changes when I move the subject relative to a light source!”. I can’t wait to see what results we get with deep expertise (and better algorithms).

How long before we have filmmakers using AI to cast, direct and shoot their films?

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by samatman on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:14PM (#32652099)
Maybe, maybe not. It didn't happen with CGI, the uncanny valley hasn't been surmounted, car chases aside.

The mulchers, as Bruce Sterling calls them, have a fresh meat problem. They've consumed all the words, and all the pictures, and we already know that feeding them their own mulch gives worse results.

We're not at the scale limit for data but we know where it is. It's not clear that refinements to the mulching process will create mulch good enough to tell apart from creation. It might. But it might not.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by pwinnski on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @03:50PM (#32654258)
> with CGI, the uncanny valley hasn't been surmounted

I'm not so sure about this. While some scenes are still obviously using CGI, I think a lot of CGI in movies now passes unnoticed, even entirely digital characters.

We certainly notice when those characters do things humans can't do, of course, and when budget or schedule or both result in things being pushed out too early, but how would we know when digital characters look natural on-screen? We wouldn't!

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by hbn on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @01:06PM (#32652666)
I wonder if anyone is gonna take advantage of this point in time where the average person isn't aware of these breakthrough AI models, and sets up themself an account as a professional-grade artist on Fiverr, offering to draw highly detailed landscapes or whatever where the client can provide reference material and ideas.

You generate the image in 30 minutes (maybe less if you get the process down to a science), then wait around for a few weeks to keep up the illusion that you're actually doing the drawing by hand, and send it off to your satisfied client. You could be charging hundreds of dollars for your "artistic services," and have dozens of clients going on simultaneously.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by bombcar on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @01:48PM (#32653065)
real clients are going to want sketches and ideas so they can tweak them before final art.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by hbn on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @02:31PM (#32653496)
Wonder if you could convert an image to a sketch

That makes the process a little less simple, but still easier than doing the real work

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by tartoran on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:54AM (#32651858)
> Having worked with a lot of artists, they are seeing stable diffusion and other image generators as a way to generate lots of ideas.

But it also dillutes their own ideas. I know of painters painting AI generated stuff and that is likely a new genre but a lot of genuine artwork will lose interest on the market. It is what it is and don’t I love or hate it…

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by jermaustin1 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @11:59AM (#32651905)
You don't just paint a better version of the generated images, you look at a bunch of generated images, and get a better idea of what you want to paint from that.

Say you know you want to do a portrait of a woman in armor, you can generate a dozen of those in around a minute on a 3090, look at the generated armors, the faces (usually all sorts of screwed up), and the composition. Its just a way to kickstart the creation process.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by tartoran on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:03PM (#32651965)
Yes, I get that but if everyone’s doing it it becomes a race to the bottom sort of thing… I hope I am wrong and things turn out in a completely different direction that I can’t see now
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by Applejinx on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @03:06PM (#32653831)
You say 'look at the generated armors' etc. but this does not mention what you use to look with: the artist's eye.

People so quickly assume that access to these tools will make everyone an artist, but the raw output is so lacking in a voice and intentionality. If you supply the voice and intentionality through your iterative process and a hybrid visual/text language playing the generator like a violin… you're playing the generator like a violin.

Your artistic skills have been translated to a wholly new set of vocabularies, and it's your eye that is tested most. Can you see/imagine better than the next guy?

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by Retric on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:03PM (#32651968)
The issue is an ever smaller percentage of the population can be successful at ever more difficult opportunities that result from ever better automation.

Manual labor still exists, but it’s a vastly smaller percentage of overall jobs. Productivity and automation seem like the same thing on the surface. However, the argument for a long tail of creators in an ever more wealth society breaks down when AI can start writing niche romance novels not just barely coherent news articles etc.

In theory we might have ever more new types of jobs, but automation isn’t just getting better it’s also getting faster.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by vidarh on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @03:37PM (#32654144)
Meanwhile I've gotten into a lot of very heated arguments with artists who fear this will actively destroy their livelihood. I lean towards seeing these developments as a massive positive for a society as a whole, but I find it hard to ignore that. Most of the flaws you see today will be reduced over the next few months, and people will get better of finding ways of working around them. It will cause substantial upheaval for a lot of people, including job losses especially on the low end. Maybe many, or even all, of those job losses will be compensated with additional jobs elsewhere, but we don't know.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by protonbob on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:00PM (#32651918)
I would argue that the technology will soon be at a point where these flaws are much less visible and will then further cheapen the work done by a human.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by kirse on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:03PM (#32651958)
All of these AI image-algorithm furnaces are ultimately powered by the raw material shoveled in by humans. If we stop providing the algorithms with unique material the capabilities will decrease.

Further, when you automate one portion of the work you still need the human brain to strategize and orchestrate at a higher level. Job opportunities have only increased as a result of this, not decreased.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by atemerev on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:06PM (#32652008)
This happened before, and this will happen again. There are no more typists, nor data entry personnel. Hardly any human travel agents. No bank tellers. Human translators are next in line.

However, much more positions in machine learning and data science.

Software _is_ eating the world. The only viable survival strategy is learning to code. I don't believe that not everyone can learn to code. I teach people to code, and I have yet to meet one that couldn't learn, assuming some general intelligence (about the same that you need to learn a foreign language).

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by bitwize on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:16PM (#32652110)
The coding skills I'm trained in will be handled by Copilot or its successor in a few years.

I haven't gotten around to faffing about with Python and Tensorflow or whatever yet.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by lightsandaounds on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @01:04PM (#32652651)
Don't think of "coding" as writing javascript to make websites. Think of "coding" as "talking to computers".

As software eats the world, the value of people who can talk to computers will increase. Even if it takes fewer programmers to make a website, there will be more jobs for programmers to automate concept art production pipelines. You may not be writing javascript or python in fifteen years (I bet you will) but there will be code to tell the automation services what to do.

The interesting question is the general population becoming more tech savvy? Will this change in work encourage more students to learn how to code (whatever that looks like in twenty years)? Or will the demand for coders rise without a corresponding increase in supply?

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by atemerev on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @01:41PM (#32653007)
Well, in software engineering, like in many modern professions, you don’t get trained once and then work for life. Learning is continuous, and this is not optional anymore.
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by schroeding on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @02:07PM (#32653270)
... will there ever be a (better) Copilot for COBOL or PL1? This may be an escape hatch, just throw yourself at legacy mainframes, this may work for an additional 20-40 years. :D
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by atemerev on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @03:19PM (#32653959)
Yes, Copilot works for COBOL. (Haven’t tested for PL/I, though).
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by onion2k on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:19PM (#32652138)
I know that technology has displaced workers in the past, but it seems to be doing so at a faster and faster pace.

Technology has always enabled the creation of jobs faster than it displaces workers though. Sure, horse manure shovelers lamented the automobile, but people who became mechanics and petrol pump attendants didn't. The same will likely be true for artists - this will suck for them, but the proliferation of easily generated art assets will likely enable the creation of entirely new jobs we haven't considered yet.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by balutdev on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:01PM (#32651939)
Technology is the amoral multiplier of output from using the mind & nature to reduce effort.

If the highly ethical are avoiding involvement the advances will be left to the greedy and oppressive.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by boppo1 on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @03:14PM (#32653905)
I am a person who will, to a fairly serious extent, have my marketable skills displaced by this. You shouldn't worry too much about it.

The ratio of people the printing press helped to those it hurt approaches 1.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by TigeriusKirk on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:40PM (#32652373)
>I know that technology has displaced workers in the past, but it seems to be doing so at a faster and faster pace.

Yes, and isn't it wonderful?

Ideally machines will do all of our work as soon as possible.

Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by bckr on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @02:00PM (#32653198)
Only if we engage in our political processes enough to ensure democracy survives this transition
Re:4.2 Gigabytes, Or: How to Draw Anything by whateveracct on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @12:30PM (#32652265)
I doubt computers are gonna be good at physically using pencils or paintbrushes. Art will have value long after every commenter here is rotten in the ground.