News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by solardev on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:11PM (#32259253)
(Not the OP) For background, this is the company that supposedly locates gunshot sounds in cities (and sometimes battlefields) by microphone triangulation. It doesn't work all that well and is selectively deployed in minority areas and is used by police to selectively enforce crimes, sometimes also altering the evidence. Vice did a few articles on them and the company tried to sue but had it tossed out. Shady all around.

https://www.vice.com/en/topic/shotspotter

https://www.techdirt.com/2022/07/08/judge-tosses-defamation-...

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by YLE118 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:42PM (#32259932)
An egregious example from the first link:

Police said ShotSpotter, a surveillance system that uses hidden microphone sensors to detect the sound and location of gunshots, generated an alert for that time and place.

Except that’s not entirely true, according to recent court filings.

That night, 19 ShotSpotter sensors detected a percussive sound at 11:46 p.m. and determined the location to be 5700 South Lake Shore Drive—a mile away from the site where prosecutors say Williams committed the murder, according to a motion filed by Williams’ public defender. The company’s algorithms initially classified the sound as a firework. ...

But after the 11:46 p.m. alert came in, a ShotSpotter analyst manually overrode the algorithms and “reclassified” the sound as a gunshot. Then, months later and after “post-processing,” another ShotSpotter analyst changed the alert’s coordinates to a location on South Stony Island Drive near where Williams’ car was seen on camera.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by YLE118 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:43PM (#32259938)
And another:

In 2016, Rochester, New York, police looking for a suspicious vehicle stopped the wrong car and shot the passenger, Silvon Simmons, in the back three times. They charged him with firing first at officers.

The only evidence against Simmons came from ShotSpotter. Initially, the company’s sensors didn’t detect any gunshots, and the algorithms ruled that the sounds came from helicopter rotors. After Rochester police contacted ShotSpotter, an analyst ruled that there had been four gunshots—the number of times police fired at Simmons, missing once.

Paul Greene, ShotSpotter’s expert witness and an employee of the company, testified at Simmons’ trial that “subsequently he was asked by the Rochester Police Department to essentially search and see if there were more shots fired than ShotSpotter picked up,” according to a civil lawsuit Simmons has filed against the city and the company. Greene found a fifth shot, despite there being no physical evidence at the scene that Simmons had fired. Rochester police had also refused his multiple requests for them to test his hands and clothing for gunshot residue.

Curiously, the ShotSpotter audio files that were the only evidence of the phantom fifth shot have disappeared.

Both the company and the Rochester Police Department “lost, deleted and/or destroyed the spool and/or other information containing sounds pertaining to the officer-involved shooting,” according to Simmons’ civil suit

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by hiptobecubic on Thursday July 28, 2022 @05:12PM (#32270166)
What I don't understand about this is what basis they could possibly have for making such a correction? The data is X, their algorithm says Y about it. Are they just claiming that "analysts" are better at triangulating than whatever their algorithm is? It's not like image classification, where it's at least plausible that a person can meaningfully "correct mistakes."
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by solardev on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:52PM (#32271852)
Their profit depends on pleasing the police departments that make these requests. They probably thought nobody would ever find out or care, which is why they sued to keep journalists quiet.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ta988 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:08PM (#32260071)
The microphones are not hidden you can see them, they are just discreet.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by YLE118 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:33PM (#32260197)
Kind of like speeding and red light cameras, though they could be placing small enough microphones that you wouldn't see them while driving/walking by.

Of course that seems like a small nitpick given the content of the passage I copied from the article.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:03PM (#32259636)
Top article on that vice link:

>In Chicago, a government watchdog says Shotspotter alerts have only led to evidence of gun crime in 9 percent of cases.

>fewer than 2 in 10 investigatory stops following ShotSpotter alerts resulted in the recovery of a gun

9% actually seems like a lot? Considering that most criminals don't stick around after illegally discharging a firearm. And 1 in 5 resulting in the recovery in a gun? Vice is really bending over backwards to pretend that these numbers are bad.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by jchw on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:18PM (#32259753)
Well, I'm a layperson to anything related to criminal investigation, but this is a little concerning to me.

If you're in a particularly crime ridden area, my concern is how many of those 9% are the right evidence against the right person. It's pretty terrible if all it took to nab the wrong person was shoddy evidence from a shady and secretive company that is accused of having manipulated the evidence in the past. It is still quite terrible even if it's often correct, because that makes it much harder for someone who is innocent to do anything about it.

Still, it's possible that the numbers Vice is showing does not demonstrate the problem.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by jahewson on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:36PM (#32259888)
No, these numbers are meaningless without a null hypothesis to compare them to. If you stop random people in the monitored areas, at the right time of day, how many guns do you find?
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by bushbaba on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:02PM (#32260036)
You need cause to investigate someone. So sounds like even if shot spotter is not accurate, it’s still effective. Criminal is a criminal.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by nequo on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:16PM (#32260108)
Not everyone who is searched has commited a crime. See, e.g., this paper: https://conrad-miller.github.io/qjab018.pdf
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:14AM (#32260418)
You are not required to have committed a crime to be legally searched. If you're fleeing the area where gunshots have been reported, it's not unreasonable to search you.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by cycomanic on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:20PM (#32260130)
So to rephrase your argument, shotspotter allows police to arrest people with made up evidence. You say that is a good thing, because they were criminals anyway.

You have an interesting concept of the rule of law.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:25AM (#32260474)
Not OP, but probable cause is not "made up evidence." If there's a report of a noise that sounds like a gunshot, and that results in a search of people who are running, and that search finds an illegal gun, that's reasonable.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by woodruffw on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:13AM (#32260706)
Why does this scenario presume that people are running? Even with this technology, it seems exceedingly unlikely that police are arriving on the scene within seconds of a possible gunshot; it's much more likely that they're corralling bystanders and frisking them.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Thursday July 28, 2022 @03:00AM (#32261262)
And why does your scenario presume that the situation is completely cold?

The average police response time in Chicago is 5-6 minutes[0]. I'm going to bet that active shootings are on the fast side of the average. Having lived in Chicago for 7 years, I can tell you there are areas where you regularly see police patrolling.

0. https://mediaprogram.maps.arcgis.com/apps/Minimalist/index.h...

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by woodruffw on Thursday July 28, 2022 @09:49AM (#32264244)
Not completely cold. I would just be mildly surprised if someone lingered around for 5-6 minutes and then ran.

In any case, this is all supposition. We aren’t being allowed to review the actual evidence, so for all I know SpotShotter is just telling the police what they’re asking it to.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by hiptobecubic on Thursday July 28, 2022 @05:14PM (#32270193)
I'm sorry, what's the premise here? People don't run away from random gunfights that happen on the street? Honestly, I feel like it's more likely that a random person is not involved if they are running.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by woodruffw on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:10AM (#32260694)
9% would be a lot, if we had strong evidence that SpotShotter was the source of hard evidence leading to a gun seizure, and not simply legal pretext for frisking people who the police think look suspicious (or, more accurately, would otherwise like to target but lack admissible evidence to do so).

It's the same problem that Stop and Frisk[1] in NYC had: you can make the contraband recovery numbers look fantastic, if you're willing to sweep peoples' civil rights under the rug.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop-and-frisk_in_New_York_Cit...

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by curiousllama on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:18PM (#32259750)
Honestly, I'd be surprised if 9% weren't below the rate from random searches. It's tragically quite common - and, to a point, quite rational - to carry a gun in some neighborhoods.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by braingenious on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:42PM (#32259933)
>9% actually seems like a lot? Considering that most criminals don't stick around after illegally discharging a firearm.

Are you under the impression that the only evidence of a firearm being discharged is carried away by the person firing the gun? I was under the impression that evidence of a gunshot is kind of famously objective because of the presence of bullets, bullet holes, casings, victims, property destruction etc.

By your reasoning, it’s a feasible proposition that criminals regularly patch up bullet holes and what, fireman carry their victims away from the scene?

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:12PM (#32260087)
>bullets, bullet holes, property destruction

Find the bullet hole, and you've found the property destruction, and the bullet is either embedded in the property destruction or fragmented all of over the place, as bullets often do. So you could have just said "property damage."

But tell you what, I'll go downtown and shoot a black paintball in a random direction, and tell you roughly where I was when I shot it, within 100m. It will be your job to find where that paintball hit. Good luck finding your evidence.

>casings

Casings are easier to find, but still very difficult if you don't have the precise location of where the shooting took place.

>victims

Firearm discharges don't always result in victims, or even victims willing to come forward.

What are you honestly expecting cops to do when there's a gunshot report? Spend hours combing the city for some rogue bullet holes? It's not realistic. The best evidence you're going to get is rushing to the area where shots were reported and finding someone fleeing.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by braingenious on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:06AM (#32260671)
So your answer to my initial question is “Yes. I believe that it is a reasonable assumption that all of the evidence of a gunshot is carried away by the shooter.”

That’s a fascinating position! Based on how difficult it is to find any evidence whatsoever, would you conclude that gunshots are essentially inconsequential 91% of the time? If I believed that, I would advocate for the legalization of recreational firearm discharge in populated areas, since obviously they rarely actually cause any noticeable issue.

Edit:

A tech company going “Beep boop loud noise! Give us more public funds for our technology that we refuse to explain!” is not the same thing as an actual report of gunfire to me. As for what I expect the police to do? Nothing. Literally nothing at all, anywhere at any time. They’re not obligated to, and in my experience, that’s what they usually do. Nothing.

I forgot to add “witnesses and complainants” as something that could be considered evidence of gunfire, but I’m assuming they can also be carried away

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by shadowgovt on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:40PM (#32259925)
The reframing is that it have cops reason to go in armed and expecting an active shooter when 93% of the time there was no reason to expect that, and 4 it of 5 times SS reports led to civilians being stopped for no justification.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by pxmpxm on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:44PM (#32259941)
The reality is in those areas cops are always armed and expecting active shooters. Look up the gunplay stats for places like Back of The Yards in Chicago.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by solardev on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:45AM (#32260854)
Lived in Chicago (but not the south side) and can agree that the gun violence there is extreme. It's an war zone every day, with thousands of shootings a year and hundreds of homicides.

That said, I don't think anyone is opposed to technology that can locate gunshots and deliver law enforcement to the right places. The gripe is that this company in particular has a history of being opaque and trying to cover up their failings, leading to questions about the effectiveness of their underlying technology and data integrity. The public can't tell whether this is a legitimate social good based on an effective tool or if the company is just ripping off tax payers and sometimes outright working with crooked cops to fabricate probable cause.

Not every cop is crooked, and not every acoustic triangulation technology is fake. But this company isn't being transparent or well intentioned enough for the public, or even a limited group of outside experts, to make that determination. And they have a history of being willing to corrupt their data, altering evidence to facilitate false records from crooked cops.

The right tools in the wrong hands can still be a problem. We don't know if this is the right tool, but the company has shown itself to be the wrong hands.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by shadowgovt on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:02PM (#32260037)
In that case, a technology encouraging them to go out expecting armed resistance when no crime has been committed is an obvious danger for the community.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by pxmpxm on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:51PM (#32260292)
If you think armed cops are the obvious danger in shotspotter neighborhoods, you've departed objective reality.

Eg https://chicago.suntimes.com/crime/2022/7/27/23280415/chicag...

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by shadowgovt on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:03AM (#32262784)
> If you think armed cops are the obvious danger

Yes, I do think that.

https://www.npr.org/2022/05/26/1101496374/chicago-police-13-...

It seems to me that to think otherwise is a "the omelet requires breaking eggs" argument.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by SilasX on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:50PM (#32259971)
Honest question: what probability of finding a shooter is the “right” threshold to go in armed and expecting a shooter?
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by shadowgovt on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:03PM (#32260041)
You'd have to ask London police, since they don't. So my Fermi estimate would be somewhere between US and UK rates.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by SilasX on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:48PM (#32260279)
>You'd have to ask London police, since they don't.

No, I wouldn't, because your facts are wrong. Yes, London police are generally unarmed, but they still get called to respond to situations where there is a likely armed suspect, and in those cases, they send in special units that are armed.

The question here -- that you avoided -- is, what is the appropriate probability before sending in such an officer, and is it higher than the 7% in the situation you cited? You were asking others to be outraged that there was "only" a 7% chance of an actual armed shooter. In an attempt to move the discussion forward, I asked what the appropriate value is, so as to appropriately judge whether such intervention was unwarranted.

To which your entire response was to shoehorn in an irrelevant factoid about London and falsely imply I'm not aware of it. (And, of course, work in a Fermi reference, because, why not?)

If I may make a suggestion: next time someone asks a substantive question, and you don't have a substantive answer, just don't reply. That's a much better approach for the forum than what you just did.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by shadowgovt on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:14AM (#32262841)
If your claim is that the police should always show up armed and expecting to be shot at in the United States because the Second Amendment guarantees the right of a private citizen to own a firearm, then the conclusion is that every instance of calling the police out to respond is a possible fatal shooting in the making. That is definitely a conclusion others have reached (https://dontcallthepolice.com/about/).

In that context, ShotSpotter's mechanism bordering on ascientific prognostication should be considered dangerous to the community because it is increasing the chances of fatal encounters for no benefit. It's basically SWATting with a fancy corporate branding.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by SilasX on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:26AM (#32264753)
>If your claim is that the police should always show up armed and expecting to be shot at in the United States

What part of my comment is that (or anything else you've said) responding to? I asked a simple question: what is the appropriate "probability of a shooter" that justifies going in with a protocol that expects one? Now you're just guessing things that have little to do with what I said.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by halostatue on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:41PM (#32260247)
Let’s tighten that up, some. Canadian police are armed with lethal weapons and need to go into active shooter situations less often than the U.S., which is a wildcard outlier of gun violence, second only to active war zones.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by SilasX on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:28AM (#32264789)
You're both misreading the question. The question was not "how often do police go in expecting a shooter?" The question was, "what 'probability of there being a shooter' justifies going in armed/with a protocol that expects one?" User:shadowgovt, if you followed the thread, was asking us to be outraged that they went in when it was "only" 7%:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32259925

But yes, "tighten up" those Fermi estimates for a question no one asked and which has no bearing on the discussion.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by xbar on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:21PM (#32259785)
80% of all stops and searches are unfounded.

I would not want to live in a community so policed.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:26PM (#32259824)
I wouldn't want to live in a community with 50,176 gunshot alerts either.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by telchior on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:40PM (#32259926)
You're assuming the "gunshot alerts" are actually gunshots, though. As noted, the sensors will identify other sounds as gunshots, and the company won't reveal its methodology so... do you live in a neighborhood with 50k gunshots, or 5k gunshots and 45k backfiring cars / fireworks / loud songs with gunshot sound effects?
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by hermitdev on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:39PM (#32260237)
I don't know about the accuracy of these sensors or the statistics cited, but having lived in and around Chicago for over 20 years, including 2 years on the south side, there are a lot of shootings. Summers are especially bad. Most weekends have double digit body counts. I don't know how many gun shots I've heard in Chicago over the years, but I can tell you how many cars back firing I've heard: zero. I've also heard a ton of fireworks. Southside around the 4th of July? Looks and sounds like a warzone. At least it did down near Bronzeville when I lived there. And before you question my ability to discern a difference, I can. I grew up shooting rifles & shotguns and happened to have a vehicle that back fired with some regularity. Gun shits tend to have a sharper report, a back fire lasts longer, a bit "boomier".

And while I like the concept behind ShotSpotter, the company, it's methods and its data governance are... Shoddy. That's probably the most charitable I can put it from what I've read about them.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by telchior on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:48PM (#32260280)
Yeah, I know nothing about Chicago so I'm not challenging anyone's anecdotal experience. Just pointing out that ShotSpotter, as a source, is potentially pretty awful.

Another thing I didn't point out in my comment is that ShotSpotter also changes its data if police tell them to. Which seems like either an admission that their sensor is not very good, or that they're willing to compromise good data when told to.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:48PM (#32259959)
I wouldn't want to live in a community with even 10% of the loud noises being gunshots, no. Saying that there's only 5k real gunshots doesn't make it sound any better.

Maybe we should focus on why there's so many gunshots in these specific communities.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by telchior on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:51PM (#32260291)
Sure, that sounds like a great thing to focus on, but in this particular thread that's specifically about ShotSpotter it mainly serves to change the subject.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:20AM (#32260453)
The topic has expanded to the related topics, as conversations do. ShotSpotter wouldn't even exist, much less be the topic of criticism, if there wasn't a rampant problem with gun violence in these communities.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by hiptobecubic on Thursday July 28, 2022 @05:19PM (#32270260)
The allegation is that gun violence is a requirement for ShotSpotter, but not the reason for it. The reason for it is that a magic wand that generates probable cause wherever and whenever you need it is extremely valuable to a police force that is judged by metrics like "How many guns did you find today?"

The gun violence is just the camouflage that provides plausible deniability. If ShotSpotter had been founded in London they'd have called it "StabSpotter."

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by bluedino on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:10PM (#32260080)
When's the last time you heard a car backfire? And who plays music loud enough to be mistaken for gunfire?
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by woodruffw on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:20PM (#32260132)
Is hearing cars backfire particularly unusual? I hear it once or twice a week.

I also hear kids shooting fireworks, and those modifications people do to their motorcycles and cars to make them sound like they're backfiring (even if they aren't; I don't know how these things work).

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by BenjiWiebe on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:09AM (#32260393)
Yes. Since basically all cars are fuel injected these days, it's really rare to hear a backfire.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by woodruffw on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:11AM (#32260403)
That maybe explains it. My neighborhood has a lot of vintage and modified cars.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by xbar on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:34PM (#32269779)
I heard you say that you wouldn't want to live in a community with 200,704 unfounded searches of the citizens.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by calvinmorrison on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:32PM (#32259863)
But ShotSpotter doesn't do stop and searches. If police are using this to justify searches, thats between the courts and police, not shotspotter
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ineedasername on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:39PM (#32260232)
It markets itself as pinpointing gunshots and police use that as probable cause. Either they reveal something of their methodology so that courts can determine if police reliance on them is reasonable or police shouldn't be allowed to use them.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by public_defender on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:37PM (#32259897)
The issue is that ShotSpotter may be profiting by giving police an excuse to search people when they would not otherwise have sufficient legal grounds.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by calvinmorrison on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:30PM (#32260182)
Again sounds like the issue is between the police and the courts over what constitutes sufficient legal grounds.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ineedasername on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:44PM (#32260259)
An assessment of "sufficient" cannot be determined without understanding how the ShotSpotter system works. Therefore the argument is that police should not be able to use them as probable cause if they don't give some insight into how they work.

This is no different than other technologies. DNA testing wouldn't be admissible in legal actions either if the tests were essentially black boxes that couldn't be scrutinized.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by llanowarelves on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:12PM (#32259709)
If true, selective enforcement is bad.

But some minority demographics commit disproportionate (edit: violent) crime per capita so you expect some proportional scaling (more crime = more need for crime detection) if they happen to live in cities/areas where that's the case. (Usually big cities)

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by gorbachev on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:04PM (#32260046)
That depends entirely on what you consider as crime worth pursuing.

For example, it's well documented wage theft is a much bigger crime in terms of monetary value than all forms of robberies combined. But those criminals don't get nearly the same level of enforcement as robbers do.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by llanowarelves on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:20PM (#32260136)
May be true, but we're talking about (alleged) crimes that ShotSpotter can pick up: gets labelled as "violent crimes".

Other Spotters for things such as wage theft, fraud, etc would be great.

You could (and I would) argue some whole industries are heavily criminal (fraud) and bait people into moral hazard.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by gpm on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:36PM (#32259893)
> Usually big cities

I'm surprised to see this is somewhat true in the US. In Canada rural crime rates are higher than urban ones, but that trend doesn't seem to hold for the US (per sources below)

Of course extrapolating from "average crime rate" to "location of hotspots" might be suspect in both cases...

Stats Canada: https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/85-002-x/2019001/article...

Bloomberg article with some nice graphs, and really good links to sources (at the end of it) - the text focuses on NYC but the second line chart in particular (based off of linked CDC data) does a good job of answering this question: https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-06-07/is-new...

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by droopyEyelids on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:54PM (#32259991)
If you'll look past the unempathetic title of this website, and the nasty tone of the author, you'll see some of how violent crime clusters in Chicago (data visualization)

https://heyjackass.com

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ck2 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:19PM (#32260128)
Since sound speed varies with air density and air density varies with humidity, and humidity is relative and varies greatly in urban areas because of heat absorption/reflection of buildings vs trees, how would this technology be even remotely accurate or reliable?

If it was up in the atmosphere with long consistent pockets of air, maybe. On the ground, no way.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by solardev on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:05AM (#32260944)
It's not out of the question for it to work to some extent -- the question is what extent, when, how, and when it doesn't work. We can't make those determinations because the company is covering that up.

Even your ears can somewhat locate sound sources in 3D space, just not with perfect accuracy, especially in complex soundscapes like cities.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by TedShiller on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:35PM (#32259882)
> selectively deployed in minority areas

I don’t think police is deploying this based on skin color

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by cosmotic on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:45AM (#32260573)
It's technically not triangulation, it's multilateration

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multilateration

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by solardev on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:49AM (#32260867)
Thank you for the correction!
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by googlryas on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:54PM (#32259557)
Jackson MS uses shot spotter and is 80% black, and no, they aren't deploying it in predominantly white "minority" neighborhoods.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by Woberto on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:59PM (#32259607)
I think they meant races or ethnicities that are a minority in the US at large, since that's how the term "minority" is typically used
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by googlryas on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:02PM (#32259628)
Sure, but if a city that is predominantly black, whose government is predominantly black, decides to use shot spotter, it would be silly to claim that it is being deployed in minority areas in order to oppress minorities.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by trs8080 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:05PM (#32259657)
You win! The commenter made a grave semantic mistake by not adding "in the US" to "minority" and now their comment is completely meaningless and without merit.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by googlryas on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:32PM (#32259866)
OP's comment implied that it is a tool used by the majority(whites) to deploy in minority(black) areas, in order to oppress them.

I provided an example of basically the blackest city in America deploying it within their own city. Why did they deploy a tool of oppression on themselves?

It seems you were very distracted that I pointed out that whites are a minority within Jackson MS, but that was really just an offhand comment and not the point of the post.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by trs8080 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:42PM (#32259935)
> OP's comment implied that it is a tool used by the majority(whites) to deploy in minority(black) areas, in order to oppress them.

The OP said nothing like this. You're projecting a lot of personal biases onto their comment. But you know that, and are trying to hone in a single example in order to strawman/red-herring valid concerns about the technology and its effects.

> It seems you were very distracted that I pointed out that whites are a minority within Jackson MS, but that was really just an offhand comment and not the point of the post.

That was the whole point of your post. You literally said nothing else.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by googlryas on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:52PM (#32259983)
> The OP said nothing like this. You're projecting a bad-faith argument onto their comment. But you know that, and are trying to hone in a single example in order to strawman valid concerns about the technology and its effects.

Yes, I will admit I am projecting, or rather assuming, bad-faith on their part, or at least sneaky rhetorical tactics. I used to assume good faith, but the past 5 years or so have made me realize that very few people operate this way. If I see someone making a point, and an underspecified part of their post or a part where they use vague language may give a certain impression, and it just so happens that that certain impression furthers the point they were trying to make(rather than diminish it, or be orthogonal to the point), then I assume there was intent to do such a thing.

OP said:

> It doesn't work all that well and is selectively deployed in minority areas and is used by police to selectively enforce crimes, sometimes also altering the evidence.

Yes, I suppose it sometimes may be selectively deployed in minority areas in order to oppress them, but without any kind of mention of the rate that that happens, this appears to be OP trying to convince you that it may be worse than it is. If you didn't know anything about cars, and I said that cars are used to intentionally murder people, you would probably have a worse perception of cars than if you had a more thorough understanding of their usage.

Therefore, my point was to show that shot spotter is not just used to oppress minorities, I provided an example of a predominantly black city choosing to use the technology, which almost certainly means there are uses of the tech that aren't about oppressing minorities.

> That was the whole point of your post. You had nothing else substantive to say.

I'm sorry, but I understand my point better than you do. I apologize for not being more explicit earlier. Hope my post helped.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by kbenson on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:06PM (#32259666)
> it would be silly to claim that it is being deployed in minority areas.

No, it would be silly to claim it's being deployed only in those areas.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by flurben on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:07PM (#32259671)
As someone who has lived in majority-black towns in the south most of my life, those words are simply not used in the way you are using them. Blacks in the south are universally considered a minority, even in those geographies where they are actually the demographic majority.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by googlryas on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:34PM (#32259875)
Sure, and that wasn't the point of my post. My point is that black people who run the government that governs over an almost entirely black population still choose to use shot spotter.

Surely there is some merit there that is not merely keeping minorities down, or maybe all the black people running the government just secretly hate blacks.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by kbenson on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:05PM (#32259656)
Do you seriously think by "minority" they meant at the local populace level and not national populace level? When has that ever been the colloquial use?
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by googlryas on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:39PM (#32259913)
No, I didn't. It was somewhat of an offhand comment. I'll break it down a little more directly:

1) Jackson MS is 80+% black.

2) The (mayor + city council) of Jackson MS is 75% black

3) The command staff of Jackson MS police department is 100% black.

4) The city and police department decided to deploy shot spotter in Jackson

5) (don't get distracted by this please) The city has not deployed shot spotter in areas that are predominantly white

Given those 5 points, where is Jackson deploying their shot spotter tech? Is it in predominantly black/minority neighborhoods? Yes.

Why are they doing that? Does the predominantly black government intend to keep black people down?

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by michaelmrose on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:49PM (#32259963)
Systems overtly or tacitly designed to fuck minorities tend to successfully fuck minorities even when operation of local mechanics are effected by minority agents.

This may be non obvious but for example black cops tend to use disproportionate force against black suspects in areas where such behavior is culturally and systemically tolerated. Cops and suspects are in an adversarial situation and being part of team cop or team suspect is more important than sharing a skin color.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by pxmpxm on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:05AM (#32260375)
>Systems overtly or tacitly designed to fuck minorities tend to successfully fuck minorities even when operation of local mechanics are effected by minority agents.

An infallible argument; the oppressee can just as well be opressor, because otherwise we'd have to reconsider our preferred conjecture.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by michaelmrose on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:11AM (#32260402)
Not at all you just compare how for example black people are treated period instead of how black people are treated by white people.

The alternative is like a mirror of the argument that a fellow isn't racist because he has a black friend. It's parody masquerading as analysis.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by pxmpxm on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:17AM (#32260434)
Well in the context of this argument, it's moreso that a black fellow isn't racist towards black people because s/he is black... which tends to hold.

Also it's my experience that if an all black community decides to enact public policy that goes against the narrative, it's almost exclusively young white progressives that come up with these sorts of agency-removing arguments to protect their preferred worldview

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by michaelmrose on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:59AM (#32260917)
Cultures and systems can select for biased treatment of groups even when looking exclusively at the local segment of a larger system which happens to have black decision makers. If you look out your window into America today and don't see systemic racism either statistically or with your own eyeballs I honestly don't know what to say to you.

The topic of discussion is a company that produces a product that due to echos and analysis doesn't actually know where or if guns are fired being deployed in shitty crime ridden neighborhoods where disproportionately minorities being poorer are obliged to live. In the context of the gun shot imaginer system they have been literally caught doctoring data to match what the police wanted to be true in order to obtain a conviction.

Multiple things can be true. The shot spotter can be deployed in areas where gun fire actually and truly is more common, it can be misused to shake down or frame people in that area, such behavior can primarily be misused against people in that area, because more poor black people are obliged to live their they can in turn fall victim to such bad behavior more frequently even if not specifically targeted by law enforcement. Further faced with multi decade scare tactics and shitty public defenders poor people and by extension disproportionately minorities flinch and cop pleas.

This is how you fill your prisons up with black people.

This is literally what systemic racism means. Its a racist outcome of a fucked up system even when said system isn't consciously malicious and lets be a little honest with each other. We both know that there is plenty of honest bigotry. There are plenty of folks in government and plenty of folks in uniform that wouldn't mind donning a sheet and burning a cross in their neighbors lawn.

America was born in racism and as much as we hope to generation by generation make it more equal some of us remain more equal than others and a lot of us like it that way.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ATsch on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:13PM (#32259711)
It is pretty frequently done when arguing in bad faith, or (sometimes deliberately) misunderstanding that "minority" refers to power and not numbers.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by fastball on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:30PM (#32259852)
Since it's the locality that is deciding whether or not to use ShotSpotter isn't that the most reasonable level to be talking about?
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by kbenson on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:12PM (#32260088)
No, as that would be a purposeful misinterpretation of the intent of the original poster, if it was obvious they didn't mean it to be interpreted that way.

Even if the response that used it differently was meant to make a valid point (I believe it was, as they expanded on it later), the way they used minority did nothing to help that point and instead caused unnecessary contention.

It would have been far more effective for their point to say "Jackson MS has a population and police department that are both majority black, and they still choose to deploy shotspotter in black neighborhoods.". Then we could jump right to exploring reasons why that might be, including valid uses of shotspotter because of effectivenessas well as other incentives regardless of it's effectiveness.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by fastball on Thursday July 28, 2022 @02:37AM (#32261128)
To me it read less like misinterpretation and more like reframing.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by kbenson on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:37PM (#32271754)
Eh, I don't think that actually changes my point. Even as a reframing, when looked at with respect to how well it communicated its point and fostered understanding and discussion of that point, it was poorly executed.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by monksy on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:43PM (#32259470)
You're telling me that cities are picking minority areas to put these in just for ill intent?

Also, the devices don't "enforce crimes", they only alert approximate areas where a gunshot/firework may have gone off at.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by elil17 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:54PM (#32259564)
They didn’t comment on motives, just on reality. That is where these systems are deployed.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ALittleLight on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:28PM (#32259833)
It's worded in a way that implies racism. You could write "high crime areas" or "low socioeconomic status neighborhoods" or any of a dozen equally accurate terms. Instead, the author chose something vague (are they being placed in Jewish neighborhoods? Chinese neighborhoods? Indian? Hispanic?) And suggestive.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by elil17 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:41PM (#32260248)
If something has a racist outcome then I don’t see how its “implied” to be racist. It is racist. They just didn’t say anything about whether it was intentional (which no one can know except people who decided where to put the systems).
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ALittleLight on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:27AM (#32260481)
Ah, then it must be racism keeping white people out of the NBA, right? Maybe not intentional racism, but the outcome is racist. Or Jewish people are overrepresented in Congress - I'm not saying it's some kind of intentional cabal, but you can't deny that it's a "racist outcome". Very few Chinese and Japanese people, per capita, are arrested for violent crime in the US. Is this because the police intentionally avoid arresting Chinese and Japanese criminals or do they subconsciously avoid arresting them because of implicit biases? Or maybe there is some other, much simpler, solution.

The reason violent crime enforcement disproportionately affects black people in the United States is because black people disproportionately commit violent crime. Black people, for example, commit most of the murders in the United States despite not being most of the population.

It is not racist to notice and react to crime. On the contrary, it is racist to insist that law abiding black people, the vast majority, endure high rates of crime. Reducing and hobbling law enforcement necessitates that citizens who might be protected are not.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by hiptobecubic on Thursday July 28, 2022 @06:15PM (#32270718)
Honestly I do think it's racism that ultimately is responsible for the demographics of professional sports in the US. The system is powered by people and people do not consider all the players in the same way, e.g. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/how-we-rise/2020/03/06/march-....

That's without getting into the socio-economic factors that lead people to pursue sports as a career rather than playing in school and then going on to be an architect or whatever it is.

The rest of your comments have been dissected and examined to such an extreme over the last like... 80 years... that I don't have anything new to add to the discussion.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ALittleLight on Thursday July 28, 2022 @06:36PM (#32270885)
Your link is completely unrelated to the claim that racism is responsible for the demographics of sports. It discusses the tendency of athletes with dark skin to be described as big and strong and light skinned athletes to be described as smart or knowledgeable.

The issue is that black people are overrepresented in the NBA. This is a "racist outcome" per the language of an ancestor comment. Is it because the league is prejudiced against white people and keeping them out? Prejudiced against black people and expressing the prejudice, for some reason, by admitting more black players to the league? Or, could it possibly be that black people are just more likely to be good at basketball? Black people are ~15% of the US population and ~75% of the NBA. Must be an awful lot of racism there...

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:30PM (#32259847)
Another way of phrasing it is: these gunshot detection systems are deployed where the vast majority of gunshots occur.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by elil17 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:44PM (#32260258)
Well the system wouldn’t really be a problem if it wasn’t faulty. It’s the false positives that are an issue. You could put it next to the house of the biggest gun nut in America and it still wouldn’t be a fair system because it just doesn’t work well.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:59PM (#32260333)
According to the data from the uncharitable vice article, their numbers seem pretty good.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by warkdarrior on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:46PM (#32259491)
Hopefully what is being enforced is the law, not the crimes.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by elil17 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:53PM (#32259549)
Sometimes police manage to enforce both…
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by PuppyTailWags on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:54PM (#32259555)
I don't think anyone truly intends ill. However, someone who chooses a technology that doesn't have real evidence of working as well as it's advertised, and then uses applications of that technology on primarily minority populations, the result can only be concluded as illness on the people.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by lkschubert8 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:58PM (#32259588)
I'm hard pressed to believe that there aren't some folks who have ill intent. The problem is weeding them out from people who are just using crappy metrics and people who just barely know what's going on.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by PuppyTailWags on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:03PM (#32259633)
I mean, I genuinely think most people don't intend ill. The most nasty, abusive people I know simply believe that they are in the moral right. In fact, believing that being morally right justifies their behavior is the biggest sign to me of a dangerous person, not a person who knowingly thinks evil things.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by dmix on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:12PM (#32259706)
The only question then is whether the police biased these installations in minority neighborhoods without connecting it to high amounts of shootings, which could easily be proven with data.

That's the sort of thing that would be useful in court if it's true.

Are local police required to publish where they are deploying ShotSpotters? Shootings and racial demographic data is certainly already public.

I've read the entire Vice court report and don't remember seeing that data. Haven't read the Chicago one.

Edit: reading the original Motherboard source all of the examples were described as small 'pilot programs' so they were usually only a single part of each city, in Cleveland for example :

> the Cleveland Police Foundation—has been deployed in a small section of Southeast Cleveland that city officials have described as a high-crime area.

> Those neighborhoods also happen to be among the least white in the city and those hit hardest by economic recession and the pandemic, according to local community organizers.

> The area the division chose for Shotspotter accounted for 37 percent of all shots fired calls, 37 percent of felonious assaults, and 45% of all homicides within district four, Sergeant Jennifer Ciaccia wrote to Motherboard in an email.

https://www.vice.com/en/article/88nd3z/gunshot-detecting-tec...

(Motherboard didn't provide crime stats in the other 3 example cities cited, only the demographic profile which was consistently non-white)

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by jjeaff on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:25PM (#32259815)
You seem to imply that intent is all that matters. But the law and history regarding discrimination in the US is more nuanced.

For example, perhaps literacy tests in order to vote in the Jim Crow south were purely based out of concern that only informed voters should be able to vote. Assuming they were applied evenly to both whites and minorities (they weren't), one could draw the conclusion that even though most of the people prohibited from voting were minorities, the intent wasn't racist.

But that's not how most racism works.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by dmix on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:53PM (#32259985)
So basically even if we assume the data shows they were only deployed to the highest crime areas (and for sake of discussion we're not debating the legitimacy of that data like you could with biased Jim Crow literacy tests AND feigning that shotspotter actually provides some IRL value), it would still be discrimination because in a wider context it's just another tool that contributes to the oppression of minorities?

Which, in the sum of everything, ultimately out-ranks the value of attempting to address the homicides and gun violence that plagues their communities through law enforcement. Therefore it's a net negative for society?

(Apologies if I'm being overly literal here, my brain tends to seek the most rational explanations for everything).

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by lkschubert8 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:15PM (#32259727)
Yeah I guess I was thinking of "ill intent" through a certain societal lens of their intent not their own personal lens. Which is admittedly a pretty subjective view. But, I would still argue someone doing something like a politician acting against the interests of their constituency for monetary gain to be ill intent regardless of their own moral justification. And that exact example seems to happen a lot.

Edit: Also to be clear I agree that the vast majority of people aren't these actors. The problem is it is very easy for someone with ill intent to get things moving in the direction they want. Very few systems stand up to real world abuse by a sufficiently motivated bad actor.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by sergiotapia on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:29PM (#32259840)
Imagine working for such a hellscape company or worse, dedicating your life to this bullshit. Really sickening.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by hiptobecubic on Thursday July 28, 2022 @06:20PM (#32270772)
I feel like you wouldn't work for a company like this unless you somehow believed that all the bullshit they were doing was for the greater good. I would imagine police probably also don't see themselves as racist-in-a-bad-way but as heroes, otherwise why would you ever work there? That's where all this "thin blue line" craziness comes from. I mean, I get it, wanting to protect people in your community from crooks and scumbags that hurt them is natural. It's easy to trick yourself into thinking that these little exceptions to civil rights are justified.