News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by monksy on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:43PM (#32259470)
You're telling me that cities are picking minority areas to put these in just for ill intent?

Also, the devices don't "enforce crimes", they only alert approximate areas where a gunshot/firework may have gone off at.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by elil17 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:54PM (#32259564)
They didn’t comment on motives, just on reality. That is where these systems are deployed.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ALittleLight on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:28PM (#32259833)
It's worded in a way that implies racism. You could write "high crime areas" or "low socioeconomic status neighborhoods" or any of a dozen equally accurate terms. Instead, the author chose something vague (are they being placed in Jewish neighborhoods? Chinese neighborhoods? Indian? Hispanic?) And suggestive.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by elil17 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:41PM (#32260248)
If something has a racist outcome then I don’t see how its “implied” to be racist. It is racist. They just didn’t say anything about whether it was intentional (which no one can know except people who decided where to put the systems).
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ALittleLight on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:27AM (#32260481)
Ah, then it must be racism keeping white people out of the NBA, right? Maybe not intentional racism, but the outcome is racist. Or Jewish people are overrepresented in Congress - I'm not saying it's some kind of intentional cabal, but you can't deny that it's a "racist outcome". Very few Chinese and Japanese people, per capita, are arrested for violent crime in the US. Is this because the police intentionally avoid arresting Chinese and Japanese criminals or do they subconsciously avoid arresting them because of implicit biases? Or maybe there is some other, much simpler, solution.

The reason violent crime enforcement disproportionately affects black people in the United States is because black people disproportionately commit violent crime. Black people, for example, commit most of the murders in the United States despite not being most of the population.

It is not racist to notice and react to crime. On the contrary, it is racist to insist that law abiding black people, the vast majority, endure high rates of crime. Reducing and hobbling law enforcement necessitates that citizens who might be protected are not.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by hiptobecubic on Thursday July 28, 2022 @06:15PM (#32270718)
Honestly I do think it's racism that ultimately is responsible for the demographics of professional sports in the US. The system is powered by people and people do not consider all the players in the same way, e.g. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/how-we-rise/2020/03/06/march-....

That's without getting into the socio-economic factors that lead people to pursue sports as a career rather than playing in school and then going on to be an architect or whatever it is.

The rest of your comments have been dissected and examined to such an extreme over the last like... 80 years... that I don't have anything new to add to the discussion.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by ALittleLight on Thursday July 28, 2022 @06:36PM (#32270885)
Your link is completely unrelated to the claim that racism is responsible for the demographics of sports. It discusses the tendency of athletes with dark skin to be described as big and strong and light skinned athletes to be described as smart or knowledgeable.

The issue is that black people are overrepresented in the NBA. This is a "racist outcome" per the language of an ancestor comment. Is it because the league is prejudiced against white people and keeping them out? Prejudiced against black people and expressing the prejudice, for some reason, by admitting more black players to the league? Or, could it possibly be that black people are just more likely to be good at basketball? Black people are ~15% of the US population and ~75% of the NBA. Must be an awful lot of racism there...

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:30PM (#32259847)
Another way of phrasing it is: these gunshot detection systems are deployed where the vast majority of gunshots occur.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by elil17 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:44PM (#32260258)
Well the system wouldn’t really be a problem if it wasn’t faulty. It’s the false positives that are an issue. You could put it next to the house of the biggest gun nut in America and it still wouldn’t be a fair system because it just doesn’t work well.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by daenz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @11:59PM (#32260333)
According to the data from the uncharitable vice article, their numbers seem pretty good.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by warkdarrior on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:46PM (#32259491)
Hopefully what is being enforced is the law, not the crimes.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by elil17 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:53PM (#32259549)
Sometimes police manage to enforce both…
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by PuppyTailWags on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:54PM (#32259555)
I don't think anyone truly intends ill. However, someone who chooses a technology that doesn't have real evidence of working as well as it's advertised, and then uses applications of that technology on primarily minority populations, the result can only be concluded as illness on the people.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by lkschubert8 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @09:58PM (#32259588)
I'm hard pressed to believe that there aren't some folks who have ill intent. The problem is weeding them out from people who are just using crappy metrics and people who just barely know what's going on.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by PuppyTailWags on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:03PM (#32259633)
I mean, I genuinely think most people don't intend ill. The most nasty, abusive people I know simply believe that they are in the moral right. In fact, believing that being morally right justifies their behavior is the biggest sign to me of a dangerous person, not a person who knowingly thinks evil things.
Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by dmix on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:12PM (#32259706)
The only question then is whether the police biased these installations in minority neighborhoods without connecting it to high amounts of shootings, which could easily be proven with data.

That's the sort of thing that would be useful in court if it's true.

Are local police required to publish where they are deploying ShotSpotters? Shootings and racial demographic data is certainly already public.

I've read the entire Vice court report and don't remember seeing that data. Haven't read the Chicago one.

Edit: reading the original Motherboard source all of the examples were described as small 'pilot programs' so they were usually only a single part of each city, in Cleveland for example :

> the Cleveland Police Foundation—has been deployed in a small section of Southeast Cleveland that city officials have described as a high-crime area.

> Those neighborhoods also happen to be among the least white in the city and those hit hardest by economic recession and the pandemic, according to local community organizers.

> The area the division chose for Shotspotter accounted for 37 percent of all shots fired calls, 37 percent of felonious assaults, and 45% of all homicides within district four, Sergeant Jennifer Ciaccia wrote to Motherboard in an email.

https://www.vice.com/en/article/88nd3z/gunshot-detecting-tec...

(Motherboard didn't provide crime stats in the other 3 example cities cited, only the demographic profile which was consistently non-white)

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by jjeaff on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:25PM (#32259815)
You seem to imply that intent is all that matters. But the law and history regarding discrimination in the US is more nuanced.

For example, perhaps literacy tests in order to vote in the Jim Crow south were purely based out of concern that only informed voters should be able to vote. Assuming they were applied evenly to both whites and minorities (they weren't), one could draw the conclusion that even though most of the people prohibited from voting were minorities, the intent wasn't racist.

But that's not how most racism works.

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by dmix on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:53PM (#32259985)
So basically even if we assume the data shows they were only deployed to the highest crime areas (and for sake of discussion we're not debating the legitimacy of that data like you could with biased Jim Crow literacy tests AND feigning that shotspotter actually provides some IRL value), it would still be discrimination because in a wider context it's just another tool that contributes to the oppression of minorities?

Which, in the sum of everything, ultimately out-ranks the value of attempting to address the homicides and gun violence that plagues their communities through law enforcement. Therefore it's a net negative for society?

(Apologies if I'm being overly literal here, my brain tends to seek the most rational explanations for everything).

Re:ShotSpotter requests to be held in contempt rather than d... by lkschubert8 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:15PM (#32259727)
Yeah I guess I was thinking of "ill intent" through a certain societal lens of their intent not their own personal lens. Which is admittedly a pretty subjective view. But, I would still argue someone doing something like a politician acting against the interests of their constituency for monetary gain to be ill intent regardless of their own moral justification. And that exact example seems to happen a lot.

Edit: Also to be clear I agree that the vast majority of people aren't these actors. The problem is it is very easy for someone with ill intent to get things moving in the direction they want. Very few systems stand up to real world abuse by a sufficiently motivated bad actor.