News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by nomilk on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:02PM (#31436396)
What is the practical significance? (please explain like I'm 5)

Google says:

> The main difference between IPv4 and IPv6 is the address size of IP addresses.

What are the practical implications for internet users and infrastructure maintainers?

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by ATsch on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:27PM (#31436719)
> What are the practical implications for internet users and infrastructure maintainers?

For users: the widespread deployment of NAT has eliminated global end-to-end connectivity of the internet. That drives further centralization of the internet, as offering services requires expensive purchases of IPv4 space, big central NAT gateways and makes p2p applications difficult to impossible.

For infrastructure maintainers: the increased address space makes it possible again to allocate addresses as you wish. There's no need to architect your network around IP address scarcity. You can allocate pretty much as many networks as you want, for whatever you want, without worrying it's going to be too small.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:23PM (#31437500)
Can you convince me that end-to-end connectivity is desirable in most cases? I certainly don't want ingress from the public Internet to devices on my home network in the general case, and I think it's kind of nice that the Internet only knows the address of my router rather than that of my physical machine (of course, there are other ways to fingerprint devices, but let's not make it easier than necessary). You definitely want a gateway to implement firewall rules, and I'm not sure whether I care if that gateway is doing NAT as well or not? What can I do with a non-NAT-ing gateway? The only thing I can think of is that cloud IP addresses aren't as carefully guarded (I don't get up-charged for an un-associated elastic IP address).
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by imoverclocked on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:15PM (#31438172)
Being able to talk directly between peers has advantages. Most services today basically require some kind of arbiter who has a public IP address.

While there are ways to poke holes in NAT, it’s not really scalable. Also, you might be behind more than one level of NAT and not even realize it today. eg: When I ask a website for my IP, it shows something different than what my hotspot is assigned… and my hotspot is not reporting an RFC1918 address. This means I am already sharing ports with someone else on the public IPv4 address that the world sees. Also, no http proxy in the middle here.

As for obscurity of addresses, NAT is pretty easily guessed in most scenarios today. IPv6 has far more address space per network making it really hard to scan. That combined with privacy addresses that change constantly is a pretty compelling reason to use IPv6 over IPv4+NAT if what you care about is people not being able to guess your IP.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:11PM (#31438801)
> Being able to talk directly between peers has advantages. Most services today basically require some kind of arbiter who has a public IP address.

Right, but you can't do this without punching holes in your firewall, and I assert that's not a desirable tradeoff, at least for consumer use cases. As far as I can tell, you still need an arbiter with a public IP address.

> While there are ways to poke holes in NAT, it’s not really scalable.

Agreed, but this is a relatively infrequent problem. It seems like there is some belief that IPv6 is going to make p2p stuff painless, but for most use case it's still going to require poking holes in something; however, for a few use cases (e.g., 2 game consoles in the same network) it will be significantly better. I definitely agree that there's some benefit to foregoing NAT, but it doesn't seem like it will improve most use cases and it certainly doesn't seem like it will deliver the painless p2p experience that many people expect.

> As for obscurity of addresses, NAT is pretty easily guessed in most scenarios today. IPv6 has far more address space per network making it really hard to scan. That combined with privacy addresses that change constantly is a pretty compelling reason to use IPv6 over IPv4+NAT if what you care about is people not being able to guess your IP.

My concern about obscuring addresses was more about making fingerprinting more difficult (some website can't just see my IP address and associate it with my identity), albeit this isn't a well-founded concern, and it could be mitigated by rotating IP addresses.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by alduin32 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:44PM (#31439927)
> Right, but you can't do this without punching holes in your firewall, and I assert that's not a desirable tradeoff, at least for consumer use cases. As far as I can tell, you still need an arbiter with a public IP address.

That's true, but setting up these firewall rules dynamically is way easier than setting up NAT mappings (for example, UPnP through two different NATs never works properly).

And even for consumer use cases, gateways could provide a way to allow all traffic to a specific destination, as most operating systems should provide a proper firewall. Of course, there is still work to be done, the UI for these firewalls should be made better (for example, allowing an application to request to accept incoming packets, and letting the user choose if it should only for the LAN, or for the whole Internet, etc).

Indeed IPv6 by itself will not make p2p stuff painless, but it's still a better basis than IPv4.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by jjoonathan on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:12PM (#31439582)
Well, the trusted-network ship has probably sailed, but giving up peer-to-peer in exchange for allowing sloppy endpoint security was a terrible trade.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:24PM (#31439707)
I'm not sure what this means. Are firewalls "sloppy endpoint security"?
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by alduin32 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:45PM (#31439939)
I think the person you replied to meant that gateway firewalls enable sloppy endpoint security (which I agree with).
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:14PM (#31438842)
I certainly don't want ingress from the public Internet to devices on my home network in the general case

This is ultimately an operating system issue. For most of the history of the web, we've used NAT routers and firewalls as a fig leaf over the operating system issue. What is it? Operating systems are extremely promiscuous about listening for traffic on a multitude of ports. Operating systems are promiscuous about including a vast number of daemons running in the background handling a variety of tasks. Operating systems are promiscuous about running a bunch of daemons that phone home all the time.

All of this stuff is completely opaque to the user. All of it occurs on a default opt-out basis. All of it requires an extraordinary amount of knowledge for the user to feasibly withdraw consent. This is the operating system problem.

In another world, I can envision computers running operating systems which are totally transparent and easily understood by their users. All running services would be opt-in and users would be fully aware of exactly what's happening on their machines. That would be the world where end-to-end internet connectivity is highly desirable.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by jherico on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:22PM (#31439693)
I don't think it's just an OS issue, because people often want promiscuity within their home network, but want a moat and drawbridge keeping the rest of the world from that network. There's too much value in home / office situations where you want discoverability enabled, but only to other devices behind your gateway to the internet at large.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by autoexec on Thursday May 19, 2022 @07:37PM (#31441612)
Not only that, but you don't need your OS handling and selectively allowing or dropping every random packet thrown at your IP either. You don't want to even have to worry about an OS inadvertently revealing info about your devices because of how they're accepting/dropping packets or screwing that up and letting in things it shouldn't. You can offload all that work to your gateway and free up your devices to only handle the traffic that they actually care about.

You can still have a DMZ, servers, and devices directly connected to the internet, but a gateway with a stateful firewall is a wonderful thing and your typical gateway with NAT helps makes things dead simple solving far more problems than it causes.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:29PM (#31439759)
Personally, I’d prefer not to have this isolation. I’d rather be able to access my home computer, printer, and other devices from anywhere in the world, not just when I’m at home. Moats and drawbridges are an anachronism from the Middle Ages.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by jherico on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:52PM (#31440012)
Right, but you don't want anyone in the world to have access to your home computer and printer, right?

You're talking about a different problem: How can I extend the concept of my "home network" to the devices that I use and trust regardless of where I am? I'd argue that this is something that suggests that VPN functionality should get built into gateway devices.

Regardless, I don't want scammers in Malaysia port-scanning my 10 year old printer that's never going to get a security update.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:28PM (#31440408)
I want anyone in the world to have access to my home computer and printer when I authorize it. Right now, to do that I have to configure my router as well as my operating system to allow it. But what if I'm not at home? I might be on someone else's network. Now I am at their mercy to configure the router so that my computer is accessible. In all likelihood, they will refuse to help me.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by teawrecks on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:40AM (#31469331)
You're talking about widening your attack surface as wide as physically possible (no virtual devices yet). Now you need to ensure every device that can see the internet is perfectly impenetrable. How feasible you think that is?
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by teawrecks on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:16PM (#31440265)
Think doors and keys then. Or "smart locks" and "biometric scanners" if that's still not modern enough for you. There's a cost to convenience. Yeah, it'd be really convenient if your house didn't have any walls, you could just walk into any room from anywhere else. But so could any untrusted party.

Bugs and therefore vulnerabilities are inevitable. The larger your attack surface, the more likely some rando is to find a vulnerability and exploit it. No walls is real convenient up until someone unexpected walks right in and trashes the place.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:09PM (#31439539)
> This is ultimately an operating system issue.

It's ultimately an issue at every layer, hence "defense in depth". Every layer does its part for security, we don't punt because some other layer ought to handle it.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:11PM (#31439570)
That’s one way. Another way is to remove some layers. You don’t need to secure nonexistent layers.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by thfuran on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:15PM (#31439619)
You don't need to secure non-existent layers but you probably shouldn't remove your front door to prevent people from picking its lock.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:17PM (#31439640)
The IP layer exists whether you're using v4 or v6.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:24PM (#31439710)
I realize the OP is about IPv6 but my comment puts the blame on operating systems. Between the operating system running on the server, through the routers of the internet and a user’s home router, through the consumer operating system running on the user’s laptop, and all of the firmware and microcode along the way, there are many, many more layers involved what is specified in the OSI model.

And so many of these layers exist for legacy reasons, business expedience, and market failure. They don’t actually make things better.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by mschuster91 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:29PM (#31439005)
> In another world, I can envision computers running operating systems which are totally transparent and easily understood by their users. All running services would be opt-in and users would be fully aware of exactly what's happening on their machines. That would be the world where end-to-end internet connectivity is highly desirable.

Even then, you have the issue of bugs - not just in the programs themselves, but also in the kernel-mode stack and even in the hardware. As long as something is reachable from the Internet, it will get scanned and assaulted from the Internet - and the lower your attack surface is, the better.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:58PM (#31439374)
operating systems which are totally transparent and easily understood by their users

I sort of glossed over this part so now I have a chance to elaborate. Alan Kay has put a ton of thought into this issue [1]. He firmly believes that we can build an operating system and application software with an extremely small footprint (LOC's) so that a single person can understand the whole thing.

Since he gave that talk, we've moved further and further away from Kay's vision. We've made things more and more complex, opaque, centralized, and difficult to change. We've given away our future to big tech companies. Heck, we've even given away the past. We've lost much of the freedom we had back in the 90's, let alone the 70's and 80's when Kay did so much of his work. We're going to have to work incredibly hard just to regain what we've lost.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oKg1hTOQXoY

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by jamiek88 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:18AM (#31457217)
No one human mind could ever grok the entirety of say, iOS or Android.

Do we just go back to the software Middle Ages?

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by teawrecks on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:11PM (#31440223)
Why would I opt for a network topology that restricts what devices/operating systems I can safely use on my network? Especially when I already have a solution that doesn't restrict me in this way?

It's like saying, if a person walking around at night gets mugged, it's a "them" problem for not carrying a weapon to defend themselves. Uh, no, let's create an environment where even a completely unprotected child is safe. Oh wait, we already have.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by anthropodie on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:13PM (#31438151)
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throw0101a on Thursday May 19, 2022 @06:32PM (#31441025)
> Can you convince me that end-to-end connectivity is desirable in most cases? I certainly don't want ingress from the public Internet to devices on my home network in the general case […]

In the IPv4 case you have NAT and a firewall. If you have some software that you want others to connect to (communication, gaming, etc) you have to punch a whole through the firewall (via UPnP, PCP) and then the software has to use a bunch of protocols to figure out what the public IP address of your router is: see STUN, TURN, etc.

See "How NAT traversal works":

* https://tailscale.com/blog/how-nat-traversal-works/

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30707711 (2022)

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24241105 (2020)

With IPv6 you just have a firewall, which you punch a hole through when needed (UPnP, PCP) and you're done (because there's no futzing about with determining the network address). When the P2P session is done the whole is closed and you're protected again.

So if you have a 'home network', it cannot be reached from the Internet by default.

Note: you already have a device that's always on the Internet: your mobile phone. Lots of telcos are IPv6-only and you there's not NAT or firewall between it and the Internet.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by nikanj on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:30PM (#31437609)
In most cases no, but then again in most cases you would be perfectly happy with all your traffic going through a http(s) only proxy.

The two biggest use cases for direct p2p connections are multiplayer games and video calling. Latency is unavoidable if your traffic has to bounce around a third-party

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:44PM (#31437793)
> In most cases no, but then again in most cases you would be perfectly happy with all your traffic going through a http(s) only proxy.

Not at all--end-to-end encryption is still a very desirable property. I certainly don't want a consumer router decrypting my browser traffic even if it is re-encrypting it to send to my device. I'll tolerate HTTP proxies on the server side when I'm administering the proxy and I need layer 7 routing, but I want to avoid it wherever possible.

> The two biggest use cases for direct p2p connections are multiplayer games and video calling.

You still have to punch a hole in your firewall either way. The only advantage ipv6 has is that you can have two hosts listening on the same port (whereas port-forwarding in a NAT context only works for 1-host-per-port).

Tangentially, I was never a big fan of player-hosted games anyway because they tended to be more vulnerable to cheating and the host always had an unfair advantage (or else a dramatic penalty in the case of lag compensation). Moreover, it's much easier to send a malicious packet directly to another player than it would be to send it to the server and convince the server to proxy it through bit-for-bit (although a poorly written game server might still do just that).

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by aaaaaaaaaaab on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:57PM (#31438624)
>Moreover, it's much easier to send a malicious packet directly to another player than it would be to send it to the server and convince the server to proxy it through bit-for-bit

What prevents you from putting the same validation logic into the client, thus rejecting malicious packets at the destination?

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:36PM (#31439839)
I mean, correct validation logic is always ideal, but I'm positing a world in which software doesn't always get intentional validation logic. In particular, an intermediate server might prevent packets from flowing to the target client for any number of reasons which aren't intended as "validation". It's just harder to hack through an intermediary.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by aaaaaaaaaaab on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:34PM (#31440469)
Ok, but I still don't see why you can't move that intermediary to the client. Spin up a docker container and run the game server there. Ta-da! You have the same security as with a remote server.

My point is that IPv6 restoring the end-to-end principle need not jeopardise the - real or perceived - security of multiplayer games.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @08:30PM (#31441984)
It’s not clear to me who “you” is meant to refer to in this scenario.

If “you” refers to the user, then because the game isn’t architected to have a server running next to each client if the server binary is even distributed to users at all.

If “you” refers to the game publisher, then because they aren’t architecting it that way to begin with, because they aren’t thinking about running the server as a security feature.

Moreover, a game developer has incentives to protect its own servers; it has much less incentive to protect its end users. You might argue that it’s end users being hacked is bad for business, but most end users wouldn’t be able to attribute a hack to a particular piece of software or infrastructure if they even know they’re hacked in the first place (consider the rampant insecurity in the consumer router and iot spaces).

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by _carbyau_ on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:44PM (#31442772)
I love player hosted gaming. But the people I game with are looking for "fun experiences" (kinda like going to a movie as a group, but more interactive) rather than competitively climbing a leaderboard.

Different use cases beget different requirements.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by anthropodie on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:09PM (#31438109)
> You still have to punch a hole in your firewall either way.

No you don't have to do hole punching.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by zekica on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:38PM (#31439134)
You have to do hole punching, but with IPv6, you just send packets from both ends to each other and it just works.

With IPv4 it is much much harder.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:52PM (#31438569)
How do you have a direct connection between peers without one of them allowing ingress?
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by toast0 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:43PM (#31439199)
> Can you convince me that end-to-end connectivity is desirable in most cases?

p2p communications can be nice for latency sensitive communications. Sometimes it's faster to communicate from user A to user B directly instead of going from user A to server Z to user B (although, sometimes it's not faster... if latency is important, you really have to try all the accessible paths and use the best one, keeping in mind that paths may have asymmetric latency, so maybe you want A to send to B directly, but B should send to A through an intermediary; and path latency isn't static, so for a long session, if it's important, you need to probe throughout and change thigns around)

But, maybe you don't want your connection to be a full peer capable of receiving as well as initiating connections, you can run a stateful firewall on your end and drop incoming initiations. You'll still benefit from having end-to-end connectivity because it means your ISP can process your packets with basically no state, so there shouldn't be problems with connection state timing out and your connections being dropped without warning. If you run your own stateful firewall, you may still have that problem, but you might have less state required for a stateful firewall instead of a NAT, so maybe you can manage more connections.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by nybble41 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:59PM (#31438640)
> I certainly don't want ingress from the public Internet to devices on my home network in the general case

This is a job for a firewall. NAT is not a firewall. You can easily filter incoming connections to untrusted devices when using IPv6, with the advantage that when you want to allow a certain kind of traffic in you can do so without messing around with port forwarding or dealing with multiple devices competing for access to standard port numbers on a single public IP address. That's assuming you actually get a public IP address; if you're behind CGNAT then port forwarding isn't even an option, since it would need to be configured on the ISP's side and not just in your router.

If you enable UPnP for automatic port forwarding, as most do, then NAT isn't blocking much of anything. The only difference between NAT with UPnP and IPv6 with no filter preventing incoming connections is in whether devices which open ports but don't set up forwarding can assume that incoming connections probably came from the same local network. However, it's considered poor practice to treat access to the local network as a means of authentication. (Note that with NAT alone if your router receives a packet addressed to your local network's private IP range, and not the routers public IP address, it will forward it unmodified; preventing that is a firewall function, not a NAT function.)

> and I think it's kind of nice that the Internet only knows the address of my router rather than that of my physical machine

If you use IPv6 with privacy extensions enabled then the Internet will only know your /64 network prefix, which is basically the same thing (unique per subscriber and subnet). The rest of the address will be randomly generated and short-lived, unless you choose to assign an additional long-lived address e.g. for a server.

> I'm not sure whether I care if that gateway is doing NAT as well or not? What can I do with a non-NAT-ing gateway?

Doing NAT isn't the problem, requiring NAT is. When the architecture requires NAT devices can't receive incoming connections without port forwarding even when you want them to. We've gotten rather good at working around NAT's limitations (not without cost), but with IPv6 those workarounds are unnecessary. For example, any peer-to-peer multiplayer game, video chat, or file transfer app where both sides are behind NAT depends on third-party servers for NAT traversal. (Note that the fact that this works at all without actually forwarding all data through the third-party servers shows that NAT is not a reliable system for preventing incoming UDP connections: it can be tricked into thinking a connection is already established.) With IPv6 you don't need the third-party servers as the peers can connect to each other directly.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by deno on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:03PM (#31439452)
> With IPv6 you don't need the third-party servers as the peers can connect to each other directly.

This will never happen. NAT gets replaced with a stateful gateway still doing conntrack (look at OpenWRT...) and p2p works exactly the same. UPNP, port forwarding, STUN are still relevant and work the same... Except IPv6 hexadecimal addresses are a usability disaster and dual stack will forever be a security disaster. Worst technology ever.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by nybble41 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:18PM (#31439651)
> NAT gets replaced with a stateful gateway still doing conntrack…

Yeah, blocking incoming connections by default is a bad habit and needs to stop. It's fine for untrusted devices or private VLANs which shouldn't be accepting direct incoming connections in the first place (like cheap IoT gadgets), and should probably be additionally filtered to prevent inter-device connections and access to arbitrary Internet sites, but a laptop, phone, or tablet is perfectly capable of deciding on its own whether to accept or reject an incoming connection, and moreover as a mobile device must assume the network could be hostile anyway.

> Except IPv6 hexadecimal addresses are a usability disaster…

How are IPv6 addresses "a usability disaster" when you never see them? Just use DNS like a sane person.

> …and dual stack will forever be a security disaster.

That's a new one to me. How is dual-stack (IPv4+IPv6) any worse security-wise than any other situation where you have multiple "upstream" Internet connections, e.g. for failover or load balancing?

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by _carbyau_ on Thursday May 19, 2022 @10:33PM (#31442705)
Blocking incoming connections by default is what I like about the current scenario.

You don't trust "cheap IoT gadgets". I would like to be able to trust any/all my devices. But I don't.

I don't trust M$/Apple/Linux - AND any associated applications people might want to use at home(kodi, plex, screencast, NAS for example) - to be 100% perfect when it comes to "deciding on its own whether to accept or reject an incoming connection".

I see "block by default" as being a layer of security - one bit of defence in depth.

Happy to drop NAT (with it's IP<->port mapping complications) for a straight IPv6 firewall though.

EDIT: concision

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by nybble41 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @11:19PM (#31442977)
If you really want to block all incoming connections by default on your own network you can. Personally I think if a reasonably capable (i.e. non-IoT) host opens up a port to accept incoming connections, and there isn't a specific rule set by the local admin to block that port or host, then incoming connections should be allowed. NAT certainly doesn't stop all incoming traffic given that UPnP is enabled by default on most routers, not to mention all the methods available for UDP NAT traversal. It just makes it more complicated.

If you've ever connected your phone or laptop to a public WiFi network (or for that matter, the cellular data network) then it's been exposed to an environment were there is no extra layer of protection from incoming connections beyond that implemented by the host itself. We generally expect that to work without major security issues. Non-mobile, "appliance"-type devices might need stronger filtering if they weren't designed to be connected directly to the Internet, but that assumption is becoming less common as more devices require authenticated connections rather than trusting the local network.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by _carbyau_ on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:05AM (#31443231)
And that's the thing. With a firewall and IPv6 we can each configure for what we want without the NAT hassle/expectation.

I would aim for a default block with allowList and agree with you that a non-IoT host using a UPnP-like mechanism (does UPnP cover IPv6 firewall like scenario?) is probably ok.

Ideally I'd like some kind of notification system where I can click "allow" for the firewall. (Maybe the firewall notifies my phone?) I think UPnP as it currently stands is a bit too hands off but can understand not every user wants to deal with this.

And we agree regards mobiles being in a default hostile environment and expecting it to work. But I see that as a matter of fit-for-purpose. I don't trust every computer I have to that level.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by nybble41 on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:24AM (#31443338)
> does UPnP cover IPv6 firewall like scenario?

The miniupnpd UPnP daemon (used e.g. by OpenWRT) includes code[0] to handle IPv6 "pinhole" requests—not port forwarding, which isn't required for IPv6, but rather just opening a port in the firewall to permit incoming connections to a certain host.

[0] https://github.com/miniupnp/miniupnp/blob/b734f94bdf6ff555a2...

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by _carbyau_ on Monday May 23, 2022 @01:26AM (#31475583)
Awesome reference.

I wish I could upvote you multiple times. This interaction with you has been most enlightening. Thank you.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by gorgoiler on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:17PM (#31438187)
You get to use 16 bits of the address to chop up hierarchically for your site.

You get a /48 and each of your networks gets a /64, with hosts picking random 128 bit addresses in each.

The 16 bits in between the two subnets mean you have room to breathe for doing whatever you like. Maybe 64k VLANs, or maybe a hierarchy with semantic meaning. You don’t need an IPAM tool if the addresses have meaning.

My favourite: you can route a /56 to a Docker host and have 256 separate bridged networks, all globally routeable. You never need anything like that, but the open space is refreshing. Like I said: room to breathe.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by clord on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:57PM (#31438622)
Also in this line of thinking: hosts can be assigned an entire subnet, and applications can get individual /128s. This way, a single host can provide a bunch of independent services, which can be broken out into real machines as the system grows without renumbering.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by gorgoiler on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:05PM (#31438726)
I think the more important use case is tempaddrs. You don’t have to use the same address all the time, or even at the same time. You can just make up random addresses for each connection if you like, though in practice the rotation is much slower.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by Dylan16807 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:54PM (#31440033)
Is there a reason to give each host a subnet in that scenario? You don't need to do that just to let a host grab 50 IPs.

Actually, if you want to avoid renumbering, don't you want to have that whole block of servers share a subnet?

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by m463 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:08PM (#31439535)
also privacy (although there are privacy extensions for ipv6)
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by dec0dedab0de on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:24PM (#31436681)
The biggest benefit is that there are more public IP addresses. The original solution for public IP addresses running out was NAT/PAT which allows a network to have it's own private IP addresses, but hide all internet traffic behind one public IP address. Think if you have 10 devices connected to your wifi/router, but you're only paying for standard internet connection. By hiding behind one address, it provided a huge layer of protection between individual devices and the internet, but also made some types of traffic a huge pain in the ass (see ICE/STUN/TURN).

With IPV6 we can give every device it's own public address, but one major concern is that it could lead to an explosion of insecure devices accessible directly from the internet. Right now if your printer or refrigerator is insecure, it doesn't really matter because it is inaccessible from the internet. The business answer for this is properly configured firewalls and proxy servers, but that's too much for the average home user.

The biggest downside is systems that assume all addresses are IPv4. These could be legacy hardware thats been sitting in a closet chugging along for 20 years, or brand new software where the developer didn't consider v6 as a possibility.

EDIT:

Some specific benefits:

Cheaply hosting stuff from my house.

Easy Direct secure communication without a middle-man.

More competition for hosting companies

Room for more people

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by WorldMaker on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:51PM (#31437046)
The home side is basically the same as the business side: a good router has needed to be a good firewall regardless of NAT anyway, because the router can't just assume NAT (even if it is de facto everywhere). NATs as first-pass filter of a firewall was always an accidental feature at best.

Obviously we start to see which routers are "good" home routers shake out as IPv6 adoption picks up, but given current statistics homes are leading IPv6 adoption and it is businesses (with their complex surveillance proxies and IPv4 micro-management practices) that are greatly lagging in adoption curves. (Typical IPv6 graphs show a "bathtub" effect where IPv6 goes up in evenings and weekends as people switch from work devices and networks/VPNs to home devices and home networks.)

Homes are more ready for IPv6 than people want to give credit to. Claiming NATs to be one of the best features of Home IPv4 seems sometimes to just be FUD designed to be anti-IPv6 as much as it is a legitimate concern.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:31PM (#31437633)
> Obviously we start to see which routers are "good" home routers shake out as IPv6 adoption picks up

Experts might, but most security isn't a visible property to most users, or at least they won't readily or reliably attribute router vulnerabilities to the router. This in turn means that security will get worse but the market probably won't correct itself, or at least the correction won't manifest as markedly better routers (the consumer router space sucks as it is because the customers aren't usually experts). I don't think this is a compelling reason to avoid an ipv6 transition, but I don't agree with the implication that ipv6 will have positive security benefits.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by BenjiWiebe on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:25PM (#31438274)
I have yet to see a home router that doesn't have a default-deny firewall.

I also haven't seen one that has IPv6 support without having a default-deny IPv6 firewall.

They may exist, but certainly aren't common.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by viraptor on Thursday May 19, 2022 @09:26PM (#31442328)
> With IPV6 we can give every device it's own public address, but one major concern is that it could lead to an explosion of insecure devices accessible directly from the internet.

This gets repeated, but we've already got lots of home IPv6 routers and none of them allow direct access by default. You need to jump through some hoops to enable external access. Nobody wants public access by default and anyone who does it will get noticed and called out very quickly.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by shrx on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:34PM (#31440467)
> The business answer for this is properly configured firewalls and proxy servers, but that's too much for the average home user.

So what is the alternative for the average home user?

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by labcomputer on Thursday May 19, 2022 @09:24PM (#31442316)
> What are the practical implications for internet users and infrastructure maintainers?

If you want to talk to Indian web users, you'll probably want to upgrade your servers from Irix version 5.3 to at least 6.2 (but preferably 6.5.22, as it has some security fixes).

Now, you might be saying to yourself "Self, Silicon Graphics went bankrupt in 2006. Where the hell am I going to find install media for Irix 6.5 in the middle of 2022?" The answer to that, my friend, is eBay.

Or maybe you're thinking, "But labcomputer, I don't trust these modern computers with their instruction re-ordering mumbo-jumbo! I want them to interpret the binary as ~~god~~ the compiler intended! And besides, my VAX doubles as a space heater. What am I going to do?"

Well, good news! You're still in luck because you can upgrade your VAX to OpenVMS 5.7 and take advantage of all 128 bits of IPv6 goodness as you gently fall asleep to the roar of your VAXCluster's fans.

Windows users don't need to feel left out, either. Ole Billy-boy's got you covered. You can upgrade to Windows XP (on that powerful new Pentium II you just picked up) to access glorious <blink> tags on IPv6-hosted websites in 256 colors!

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by anthropodie on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:06PM (#31436449)
You no longer need services like tailscale or zerotier or VPN like wireguard just to connect to your home network. You also do not need static IP.

I host my own task manager, calendar, media center, document server, google drive alternative, google photos alternative on my home network and can reach it from anywhere. It is all possible with IPv6 without paying a whole lot to other services.

In future, I think IPv6 is going to play a crucial role in next generation of hardware devices and software applications that will bring people back from walled gardens to real Internet. We might finally have something where people host their own data like photos, stories at home securely and then they choose who should access or who should not. I know I am being way too optimistic but a man can dream.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by codethief on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:58PM (#31440688)
> You no longer need services like tailscale or zerotier or VPN like wireguard just to connect to your home network. You also do not need static IP.

I disagree. Technologies like Tailscale, zerotier and Wireguard mostly exist to secure your private, distributed network. Tailscale has all kinds of measures to circumvent NATs, sure, but the main point is access control, encryption by default and presenting as little an attack surface as possible (by routing everything through Wireguard).

IPv6 doesn't give you that: IPv6 addresses can still easily be spoofed, and ports can still be scanned. And vulternabilities in applications listening on public ports will always exist. VPNs provide you with an additional layer of security.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by viraptor on Thursday May 19, 2022 @09:28PM (#31442343)
> IPv6 addresses can still easily be spoofed

That's not related to IPv6. If your ISP allows spoofing addresses, then v4/v6 doesn't really make a big difference.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by codethief on Sunday May 22, 2022 @08:03PM (#31474068)
How is an ISP supposed to know whether the "sender" on an IP packet is legitimate?

> That's not related to IPv6.

I didn't claim it was. It is, of course, already an issue in IPv4 networks.

OP was claiming that, once everyone uses IPv6, VPN solutions like Tailscale or WireGuard would no longer be needed. I disagreed because one of main features these solutions provide is access control, i.e. which device gets to connect to which device (and which application) in your private network. Not only is this much more cumbersome to achieve with IPv6 alone (as you need to set up appropriate firewall rules manually on each device), the security guarantees afforded by such firewall rules also won't be as strong as 1) IP spoofing cannot be prevented, 2) encryption is not the default, 3) the attack surface is much larger.

> If your ISP allows spoofing addresses

This has nothing to do with one's ISP. The ISP cannot possibly know whether the sender IP address on an IP packet is legitimate or not.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by charcircuit on Thursday May 19, 2022 @09:42PM (#31442400)
>You no longer need services like tailscale or zerotier or VPN like wireguard just to connect to your home network.

You don't need IPv6 for this. People can just connect to your IPv4 address.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by kazen44 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:29PM (#31436758)
another point which makes ipv6 easier to handle for network operators is the fact that subnetting is (practically) a thing of the past.

Customers are supposed to get a /56, and the global routing table consists of /32's or at maximum a /48 in regards to subnet length.

This greatly reduces the global routing tables size because aggregation is actually doable, compared to IPv4.

Also, ipv6 has some neat features like duplicate address detection, link-local addressing and Stateless autoconfiguration.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by securitypunk on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:06PM (#31436447)
The IPv4 address space is depleted, so remaining on IPv4 means deploying NAT everywhere, with all the downsides that come with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_address_translation#Is...
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throw0101a on Thursday May 19, 2022 @06:44PM (#31441134)
> What are the practical implications for internet users and infrastructure maintainers?

You don't have to futz around with NAT and figuring out how to do connect P2P:

* https://tailscale.com/blog/how-nat-traversal-works/

You have your home router firewall, you punch a hole in it (UPnP, PCP) on an as-needed basis, do your P2P thing. When you're done, the firewall hole is closed.

No magic/fancy protocols trying to figure out what your "real" address is.

Instead of having to chat or talk your some provider's central server, the software on your device can talk directly to the software on the other person's.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by shepherdjerred on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:33PM (#31438357)
IPv6 simplifies networking by freeing us of the hacks surrounding IPv4. These hacks were made to stop us from running out of addresses.

Every device will have a unique IPv6 address. This solves a lot of pain regarding port forwarding and NAT — an issue I felt often when trying to play video games or host a Minecraft server when I was younger. It’ll be easier for regular people to access their local networks which could help make it a more mainstream option for people who want to home host services like file syncing or media servers.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by autoexec on Thursday May 19, 2022 @08:12PM (#31441863)
> Every device will have a unique IPv6 address.

You get a unique IP with NAT too, it's just not globally routable which is actually really nice since most people don't want the entire planet to see their internet network and folks running servers and P2P applications are generally capable enough at networking to configure their router to allow communication even with NAT in place.

If IPv6 wants to do away with NAT, what solution does IPv6 offer for preventing device enumeration and tracking?

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by imtringued on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:36AM (#31445164)
Your ISP won't give you permission to mess with their CGNAT setup. Your best bet is to get a cheap server with an IPv4 address and do the forwarding yourself.

It is really amazing how people on the internet will call you stupid back when you were a kid when it is completelybout of your control.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by viraptor on Thursday May 19, 2022 @09:31PM (#31442353)
You can still use NAT with IPv6.

And no, some services services are a serious pita to configure with NAT even if you know what you're doing. That's also assuming you're not NATed by your ISP and can bind external ports in the first place and that's not a given.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by autoexec on Thursday May 19, 2022 @09:50PM (#31442453)
Yeah, I've seen a few other options too like proxies and NPTv6 but all of it just confirms that IPv6 isn't the NAT killer people make it out to be. In the end, there are uses for NAT that remain useful and desirable.

I know we'll all have to move to from IPv4 eventually, but I can't help hoping that by the time that comes we'll have moved on to IPv7 or at least IPv6SE or something that addresses all the issues that have hurt IPv6 adoption.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by guntars on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:01PM (#31438019)
Something else that isn't often mentioned is that NAT requires keeping track of connection state on the router and anyone that writes code knows that state is the devil. That's state for every connection and for every device on the network. A perfectly implemented NAT router with unlimited memory is just as reliable as an IPv6 router that just forwards packets. In reality, the consumer grade devices have 16MB or so of memory and fall far short of this ideal.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by yardstick on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:25PM (#31438269)
IPv6 router firewalls still should be stateful (Ie allow connections initiated from my LAN to the Internet, but don’t allow connections initiated from the Internet to my LAN).

Sure, if you are speaking about core routers, they don’t care about state. But for homes and offices, traffic direction matters for security.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by guntars on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:28PM (#31440409)
That's fair, I can see how any kind of more advanced filtering than "just block incoming SYN packets" would require state, but at least it's optional.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by fouronnes3 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:08PM (#31438099)
I'm completely out of the loop, but last time I checked "IPv6 will kill NAT forever" was basically a lie, and there is NAT-hell in IPv6 too. Is that so?
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by paxys on Thursday May 19, 2022 @01:17PM (#31437397)
There are a lot of theoretical advantages to IPv6. Every single internet endpoint can have a unique address. You will no longer need any form of NAT. Any two random connected devices can talk to each other with a simple TCP/UDP request.

Practically all of this is still very unlikely, but at least it is a step in the right direction.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by enw on Thursday May 19, 2022 @12:58PM (#31437160)
With IPv6 we can host from home without NAT or DDNS.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by gopalv on Thursday May 19, 2022 @02:10PM (#31438118)
> What are the practical implications for internet users and infrastructure maintainers?

There are technical implications on routing and "what is on the internet" vs "connected to the internet" (the difference between having an address vs a NAT gateway for access).

But for India specifically, the difference is more political & specifically for the internal cloud infra land.

IPv4 was "sold & bought" during the era when US and Europe controlled who got how much.

See the xkcd for an idea of the distribution - https://xkcd.com/195/

If you are a up&coming cloud provider in India, you definitely have a scarcity of ipv4 addresses you can hand out to your customers - you can hand out ipv6 addresses no problem, but if people's devices are on ipv4, then this is behind the scenes and needs a fair amount of complexity.

You can do several tricks on the hosting side with DNS and SNI (so thousands of domain names can map to a group of 10-15 IP addresses and the loadbalancer can use the SNI to route the connections to the right internal ipv6).

So IPv6 adoption for cellphones for instance is not really important for the clients on phones, but it really matters if you want to build out a cloud infra stack hosted in India by a provider (like Reliance) who doesn't own enough ipv4 ranges to scale up things.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by dheera on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:14PM (#31439607)
It means that instead of "1.2.3.4" you now have to deal with "f0fd::8a8a:99:::://4::88ff::deca:dead:beef::/16" or something like that, and remember how many colons go where and you now have to remember hex numbers instead of decimal.

What's the Google IPv4 DNS? 8.8.8.8. It's beautiful enough to be a decoration to frame and hang above a fireplace.

What's the Google IPv6 DNS? Heck if I can remember, it has some 4's, 6's, 8's, 0's, 2's, and some colons and double-colons liberally sprinkled like a salt shaker that had its cap fall off as you were shaking it.

I'm basically a walking DNS server of the company I work at, I know all the IPv4 addresses of pretty much every machine, and I couldn't do that with IPv6. I also know all the IPv4 addresses of every single IOT device in my home.

It's really no wonder that the world is very slow to transition to IPv6.