News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:14PM (#31438842)
I certainly don't want ingress from the public Internet to devices on my home network in the general case

This is ultimately an operating system issue. For most of the history of the web, we've used NAT routers and firewalls as a fig leaf over the operating system issue. What is it? Operating systems are extremely promiscuous about listening for traffic on a multitude of ports. Operating systems are promiscuous about including a vast number of daemons running in the background handling a variety of tasks. Operating systems are promiscuous about running a bunch of daemons that phone home all the time.

All of this stuff is completely opaque to the user. All of it occurs on a default opt-out basis. All of it requires an extraordinary amount of knowledge for the user to feasibly withdraw consent. This is the operating system problem.

In another world, I can envision computers running operating systems which are totally transparent and easily understood by their users. All running services would be opt-in and users would be fully aware of exactly what's happening on their machines. That would be the world where end-to-end internet connectivity is highly desirable.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by jherico on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:22PM (#31439693)
I don't think it's just an OS issue, because people often want promiscuity within their home network, but want a moat and drawbridge keeping the rest of the world from that network. There's too much value in home / office situations where you want discoverability enabled, but only to other devices behind your gateway to the internet at large.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by autoexec on Thursday May 19, 2022 @07:37PM (#31441612)
Not only that, but you don't need your OS handling and selectively allowing or dropping every random packet thrown at your IP either. You don't want to even have to worry about an OS inadvertently revealing info about your devices because of how they're accepting/dropping packets or screwing that up and letting in things it shouldn't. You can offload all that work to your gateway and free up your devices to only handle the traffic that they actually care about.

You can still have a DMZ, servers, and devices directly connected to the internet, but a gateway with a stateful firewall is a wonderful thing and your typical gateway with NAT helps makes things dead simple solving far more problems than it causes.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:29PM (#31439759)
Personally, I’d prefer not to have this isolation. I’d rather be able to access my home computer, printer, and other devices from anywhere in the world, not just when I’m at home. Moats and drawbridges are an anachronism from the Middle Ages.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by jherico on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:52PM (#31440012)
Right, but you don't want anyone in the world to have access to your home computer and printer, right?

You're talking about a different problem: How can I extend the concept of my "home network" to the devices that I use and trust regardless of where I am? I'd argue that this is something that suggests that VPN functionality should get built into gateway devices.

Regardless, I don't want scammers in Malaysia port-scanning my 10 year old printer that's never going to get a security update.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:28PM (#31440408)
I want anyone in the world to have access to my home computer and printer when I authorize it. Right now, to do that I have to configure my router as well as my operating system to allow it. But what if I'm not at home? I might be on someone else's network. Now I am at their mercy to configure the router so that my computer is accessible. In all likelihood, they will refuse to help me.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by teawrecks on Sunday May 22, 2022 @11:40AM (#31469331)
You're talking about widening your attack surface as wide as physically possible (no virtual devices yet). Now you need to ensure every device that can see the internet is perfectly impenetrable. How feasible you think that is?
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by teawrecks on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:16PM (#31440265)
Think doors and keys then. Or "smart locks" and "biometric scanners" if that's still not modern enough for you. There's a cost to convenience. Yeah, it'd be really convenient if your house didn't have any walls, you could just walk into any room from anywhere else. But so could any untrusted party.

Bugs and therefore vulnerabilities are inevitable. The larger your attack surface, the more likely some rando is to find a vulnerability and exploit it. No walls is real convenient up until someone unexpected walks right in and trashes the place.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:09PM (#31439539)
> This is ultimately an operating system issue.

It's ultimately an issue at every layer, hence "defense in depth". Every layer does its part for security, we don't punt because some other layer ought to handle it.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:11PM (#31439570)
That’s one way. Another way is to remove some layers. You don’t need to secure nonexistent layers.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by thfuran on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:15PM (#31439619)
You don't need to secure non-existent layers but you probably shouldn't remove your front door to prevent people from picking its lock.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by throwaway894345 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:17PM (#31439640)
The IP layer exists whether you're using v4 or v6.
Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @04:24PM (#31439710)
I realize the OP is about IPv6 but my comment puts the blame on operating systems. Between the operating system running on the server, through the routers of the internet and a user’s home router, through the consumer operating system running on the user’s laptop, and all of the firmware and microcode along the way, there are many, many more layers involved what is specified in the OSI model.

And so many of these layers exist for legacy reasons, business expedience, and market failure. They don’t actually make things better.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by mschuster91 on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:29PM (#31439005)
> In another world, I can envision computers running operating systems which are totally transparent and easily understood by their users. All running services would be opt-in and users would be fully aware of exactly what's happening on their machines. That would be the world where end-to-end internet connectivity is highly desirable.

Even then, you have the issue of bugs - not just in the programs themselves, but also in the kernel-mode stack and even in the hardware. As long as something is reachable from the Internet, it will get scanned and assaulted from the Internet - and the lower your attack surface is, the better.

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by chongli on Thursday May 19, 2022 @03:58PM (#31439374)
operating systems which are totally transparent and easily understood by their users

I sort of glossed over this part so now I have a chance to elaborate. Alan Kay has put a ton of thought into this issue [1]. He firmly believes that we can build an operating system and application software with an extremely small footprint (LOC's) so that a single person can understand the whole thing.

Since he gave that talk, we've moved further and further away from Kay's vision. We've made things more and more complex, opaque, centralized, and difficult to change. We've given away our future to big tech companies. Heck, we've even given away the past. We've lost much of the freedom we had back in the 90's, let alone the 70's and 80's when Kay did so much of his work. We're going to have to work incredibly hard just to regain what we've lost.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oKg1hTOQXoY

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by jamiek88 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:18AM (#31457217)
No one human mind could ever grok the entirety of say, iOS or Android.

Do we just go back to the software Middle Ages?

Re:460M Indian Internet Users Are Now on IPv6 by teawrecks on Thursday May 19, 2022 @05:11PM (#31440223)
Why would I opt for a network topology that restricts what devices/operating systems I can safely use on my network? Especially when I already have a solution that doesn't restrict me in this way?

It's like saying, if a person walking around at night gets mugged, it's a "them" problem for not carrying a weapon to defend themselves. Uh, no, let's create an environment where even a completely unprotected child is safe. Oh wait, we already have.