TWTR started trading 8.4 years ago at 45/share (after being priced at 26). SPY was priced at 180 and is today at 440. Gold was down near 1200 and is now at 1900. Twitter grew in value at 2.2%/yr before inflation while the S&P index grew 11%/yr. Factoring in the IPO pop (which screws the VCs), Twitter would have grown at 9.1% per year.
(The banks also have strategies that earn them more at IPO, so they probably are earning slightly more than 10% per year on their investment.)
In short, Twitter is not keeping up with the broader economy at Musk's price. You're telling the investment banks, mutual funds, and most-senior vested employees that their company has the same worth as a low-risk government bond or a bar of metal.
Exactly! The stock has been a terrible investment since IPO, and Twitter management has done a terrible job of unlocking value. It's current management that has failed to keep up with the broader economy. Musk thinks he can do a lot better if he has full control. Musk's price is a reflection of how poorly current management has done; he is not trying to compensate you for future growth.
If you think current management can drive the share price much higher, then you should not sell to Musk. If you think current management is just going to be more of the same, Musk is giving you a big premium over where the stock had been trading, and you should take his offer.
If Musk thinks Twitter will be worth $400 in five years' time, then he can realize that value for himself. He'd be very foolish to offer you that price now.
I also understand his point about mismanagement from a anecdotal user perspective: I hate the platform but not the concept.
- Horrendous UX (Why can't I see the context of a tweet?)
- Seemingly crappy bot policing (Really? You, "Megan, Warrior, mother, wife, respect all animals, bless our troops, go cowboys [football][usaflag][fingerhorns]" really have 4138 followers and 4087 followed? Plus, the first follower I click has the same corny bio style, 4112 followers and 4056 followed, and only retweets political tweets?)
- Creates aggressive echo chambers and lopsided arguments. (Influential user blasts another, their army of followers comment and like each others comments, blasted user's entire dialogue gets buried under army's despite having valid arguments.)
- I'm sick of seeing the thoughts of politicians and celebrities.1. Seeing the context is as easy as clicking on the tweet. Tracking multiple threads off the same initial tweet would be nice if it were easier, but I'm not sure the UX would work for something like that (it's not an easy problem).
2. 100% agreed that the bot policing is garbage.
3. I think this is part of the chronological aspect of threads and replies, I'm not sure how you fix this without having an algorithm decide which tweets to show, which has its own host of problems.
4. I only see these when someone I follow retweets it, which is almost always something political. I honestly don't remember the last time I've seen a celebrity tweet, but that might be because of the extension I've installed.
A 54% premium on the current price is absolutely in the ballpark of "tremendous potential." If you think it's not, it's easy to vote against this. I'm not sure I buy Elon's "the company has to be private to make these changes" argument, and if there was a path for current public shareholders to remain private shareholders and potentially reap the rewards of a future acquisition or second IPO, I think a lot of them would be all for it.
If he’s taking the company private the future of the company should be irrelevant to you right? The only thing that matters is whether or not you think the price is fair.
>> Musk says there is tremendous financial potential in Twitter but then offers $54 a share, which is not even 2x the IPO price. That’s not a “tremendous potential” premium.
He believes the potential is predicated on taking it private and clearing house. The IPO price also seems irrelevant. Whether or not you think Twitter can exceed that price again is relevant.
Given it was at ~$70 last year he seems to be coming in too low for me as I think Twitter can get back to that point relatively quickly.
Telling someone what criteria they should use to make their own decisions is quite arrogant, and out of line.
If you want to use the stock price as your sole metric for deciding on accepting an offer, that’s up to you.
Define "add value", because otherwise I'm laughing hard at this notion.
If you define it purely as "produce a product that people enjoy using or find useful", then sure, it adds value.
But at a higher level, asking if it's a net positive on society as a whole, and I'd say Twitter will never succeed at that. Social media has caused a breakdown in political discourse where people no longer seek to understand, but instead seek to "win", and Twitter's short message limit completely eliminated any possibility of actual conversations in favor of 140-character[0] zingers that are nothing more than ridiculous straw men. Nuance is a thing of the past.
[0] I know it's 280 now, but for the longest time it was 140, and I'm not sure the difference really matters. It's still incredibly limiting.
I have a NLP/linguistics hobby,and Twitter has been a fantastic gold mine for generating corpora for "low-resource[1]" languages. No other social network is as open as Twitter is to scraping such information, and I have no confidence this will be the case if it's taken private to "unlock value". Hell, I even planned to use a Twitter bot to generate parallel corpora (for translations) since Twitter provides easy and free access to native speakers of almost every language that is currently spoken on this planet.
I'm just a filthy casual, I bet there are hundreds (or thousands) of PhDs and papers that would not have been possible without Twitter; I have no doubt that Twitter adds value to society by virtue of its breadth and openness. Sadly, Twitter is also is detrimental to society, by virtue of its breadth and openness; but I know which side is easier to monetized.
1. https://datascience.stackexchange.com/questions/62868/high-l...
The real arrogant move is jumping into a conversation to tell someone they are arrogant without any evidence to back it up.
Second, a large amount of your comment history is just telling people how "out of line" their comments are. There is a downvote button for that. Stop spamming it. It is you who is out of line.
The downvote button is for low quality comments, not for disagreement. If you had been here for any significant length of time, you would know that.
It’s also a bit ironic when you say “stop spamming” from a sock puppet account you created specifically to reply to my comment, but you probably already knew that when you did it.
I said they were a sock puppet account created three minutes before leaving their one and only comment as a reply to my own. These claims are verifiable, and their behavior lowers the standard of discourse in this forum.
You can address their point and move on. Leveling accusations unrelated to the point lowers the standard of discourse too.
edit: to add to this, the claim that this is a sockpuppet is not a verifiable claim.
The future of the company is relevant to you if you care about Twitter and it's impact on the world.
Even if you're a shareholder, you can care about more than just money. Shares represent more than money - they also represent power.
Shareholders have the power to decide whether the wealthiest person in the world should take unsolicited control over what's arguably the most powerful communication platform in the world.
I think Musk would moderate bots more given his experience. But people less maybe.
> use Tesla to bail himself out of Solar City’s troubles
He didn't run Solar City I don't think.
He was chairman, and his cousins were the founders. Who started the company on his suggestion.
He means tremendous financial potential for him.
I wouldn't say he got nothing to show for it, considering his goal never was financial gain or anything of the sort.
Also - Twitter is more of a networking and influence tool in my opinion for "important people". These people are MUCH more likely to pay for Twitter, it's not like facebook where 99% of people would never pay for it. Which I think is what Musk was hinting at with blue badges for $2.
If he does that, boycotting advertisers will matter much less.
So that revenue is worth, what, $50,000 a year?
4chan? not really a 'social media' website. I think he did a good thing making it and we need more spaces like this in a more restrictive internet space
It might be a hobby decision, or it might be self-protection against censorship; I'd like to know.
As an owner, he wouldn't have to be the person running the shop. Unlike Tesla and SpaceX, I'm sure Twitter can be managed by someone other than himself.
Isn't past behavior the best indicator of future behavior?
In this case it's pretty clear that Musk doesn't have the bandwidth to run another company in the same way as he runs Tesla and SpaceX. You can reach that conclusion any number of ways, counting the number of hours he (claims to/appears to) put in, listening to his own statements on the matter - where he has repeatedly outright said this, observing his relatively hand-off approach to his more recent ventures like neural-link or the boring company.
It seems unlikely that his behavior at Tesla or SpaceX is about to change significantly, so it seems unlikely that he'll try and take as active a roll at twitter.
I think basic web hosting would be a bit cheaper.
_buys Dogecoin_ "TSLA will accept Dogecoin" TSLA does not accept Dogecoin. Musk sells Dogecoin for a profit "Jk"
Which is your right, but do you own nearly 10% of twitter like elon musk with the ability to buy up to nearly 15%? Unless you own big blocks of shares, your vote really doesn't matter.
> Musk says there is tremendous financial potential in Twitter but then offers $54 a share, which is not even 2x the IPO price.
Twitter IPO'd nearly 10 years ago. The IPO price really doesn't factor in today.
Musk offered $54 and twtr is currently trading less than $47. It means that major investors don't value twtr higher than $54 and do not expect a bidding war. If twtr was trading above $54, then it would indicate that musk was undervaluing twtr and investors expect a bidding war. Also, the fact that it is trading so much below $54 indicates that many don't expect twtr to sell itself to musk. Regardless, it will be interesting what happens in the coming months.
when you say absolutely nothing you mean money. but millions of people have fond memories of what his site used to be. nobody would say that about facebook or twitter.
Plenty of people have positive memories of both Twitter and Facebook.
E.g. Low moderation making difficulty attracting revenue is because that's based on an ad revenue based model.
Tesla and SpaceX aren't high risk positions - both have been proven for years now.
You're concerned about his ability to multi-task because he's successfully turned Tesla into the most valuable company in the world, and at the same time lead SpaceX to probably the most valuable private company in the world?
I'd saw your analysis is at least a few degrees off.
Did you consider what will happen to your current stock value if the BOD doesn't sell to Elon, and if Elon then sells off his shares and starts a competitor and moves himself and others follow? Do you think Twitter is anywhere near an upward trajectory that will provide you a better return than the relative stagnant value the stock has had for awhile now?
“Gimme your stagnant site, at a premium, and I will fix it.”
That said, I’d vote against, as well.
I don't think he works too much; on the contrary, I think he's bored.
Just open a chart and see what a disaster TWTR stock is since transitioned into the Biden administration. The market (institution shareholders) is not stupid. The lower price is how the free market punish TWTR for their actions. They have lost a lot of their users due to many of their limited free speech and work with government actions.
I thought people were mad at Twitter for resisting the government, not working with it -- when they were pushing back against the president of the US.
The biggest problem twitter had there was that they had rules and then certain users with such a large following that they where unwilling to enforce them.
It took a literal insurrection on the capitol to do it.
I don't have a solution, moderation is inherently a problem for that case.
Normally “Really? I’ve never heard of it.” isn’t good evidence, but when you’re asserting that Moot was one of the most popular social websites in the world it does have some bearing.
And it's really weird. I assumed Moot was mega famous with tech folks.
But that is weird. I mean I don’t really think that my finger is on the pulse of the tech community but I’ve been on this site for the past 10 years.
(Nothing wrong with weirdness, though, up to a certain level of messed up)
Only a certain subsection of us. My husband used 4chan in high school and college and told me about it and that's how I learned about him. 4chan is definitely a good case study in how being popular and engaging won't lead to monetary gains if your platform is too toxic. 4chan is still quite popular but half of the site is infested with actual "Hitler did nothing wrong" types.
There is a lot of evidence that platforms which de-prioritize moderation have trouble attracting revenue and experience significant compliance costs. See: the sad story of Moot, who ran one of the most popular social websites in the world and ended up with absolutely nothing to show for it.
This looks more like a hobby to me than a business decision. Hobbies are fine as long as they don’t distract from the job, like Bezos buying Washington Post (he is a hands-off owner who spends very little time on it). But Musk is in two high-risk positions with Tesla and SpaceX. He worked over last Thanksgiving and sent a rather dramatic email about it. So I would be concerned about his ability to multi-task. He has already tried to run three businesses at once and he had to use Tesla to bail himself out of Solar City’s troubles.