News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by Sohcahtoa82 on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:30PM (#30960793)
I've never understood the appeal of using a product like Affirm, especially if you already have a credit card.

Credit cards already give you a 30-day grace period before purchases start accruing interest. Using Affirm to extend that to 42 days seems inconsequential.

It seems like their target customer are people bad with credit, which would make them predatory.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by L_Rahman on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:54PM (#30961086)
0% APR over 12 months for a big ticket purchase like a mattress in an inflationary environment and a bull market can easily equal an additional 5-7% discount on 2000 dollars.

Admittedly this is not how most people are using Affirm, but it's definitely been useful to me in that way.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by jerf on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:42PM (#30961597)
Only if you have a source of post-inflation dollars, such as, your salary having been adjusted for inflation in the meantime, or you've sold inflated commodities recently at a post-inflation price, perhaps a used car that appreciated over the purchase term. If you are stuck with pre-inflation dollars this is no advantage.

You should not simply assume that you have access to more dollars just because inflation is rising. If your prices go up but your income does not, or your income significantly lags (anyone who got a pre-emptive inflation raise let me know, otherwise it always lags), you're paying for today's inflation with dollars from last year.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by 30367286 on Friday April 08, 2022 @11:49PM (#30965145)
Yeah, the trick on taking out low interest loans is they have to be long term, like a mortgage. Over 30 years, I'm definitely paying it back in post-inflation dollars. In one year? Not really. I'd have to get a raise on, like, the day I took out the loan.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by cogman10 on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:27PM (#30961452)
Bingo. That's why I've done payment plans as well. Not because I couldn't just buy the thing, but because spreading the payments out over 12 months means more investment capital.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by after_care on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:51PM (#30961708)
> because spreading the payments out over 12 months means more investment capital

This is essentially borrowing money to invest. It doesn't matter if the investment makes money or loses money the lender will expect payment. This strategy can make a lot of money, but it's also ruined many people. One key thing to watch while implementing this strategy is your debt to assets ratio. Also understand that during a market crash this ratio might change suddenly and dramatically.

I don't make small (sub $10k) purchases on credit, period. Not only is it somewhat risky but it also encourages overspending because it makes the 'pain' of spending money decrease. As for your $2000 mattress, I saved way more money by buying a $600 mattress instead and I sleep like a rock.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by knodi123 on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:47PM (#30962323)
> This is essentially borrowing money to invest

Yeah, I don't know why more people don't see it this way.

Everyone seems to agree that you shouldn't eagerly make extra mortgage payments to pay off your home loan ASAP. Because you can pay it off over 30 years and presumably make more $$ investing than whatever paltry interest rate you had on your home loan.

But the same people can't explain why it's a bad idea to take out a 2nd mortgage to invest in the market, or even secure a low-interest loan with your home as collateral. But isn't it exactly the same thing?

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by hiq on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:18PM (#30962626)
> But the same people can't explain why it's a bad idea to take out a 2nd mortgage to invest in the market, or even secure a low-interest loan with your home as collateral. But isn't it exactly the same thing?

So what was their reasoning?

In the end it's all math, where some numbers are random variables with the corresponding variance. So this all depends on what rate you get, what returns you expect from the market, what's your risk tolerance, etc.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by antifa on Saturday April 09, 2022 @09:34AM (#30967934)
A second mortgage is extra risk to a person's most important asset which is typically reserved for funding a major home improvement project or for emergencies.

The "$2000 0% APR mattress loan" is useful because $167/ month is much easier to budget for and doesn't require a huge hit to savings.

One of these is just sane budging, the other is minmax gambling.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by knodi123 on Sunday April 10, 2022 @01:24PM (#30979339)
> A second mortgage is extra risk to a person's most important asset

Okay, fine, so that's the reason we don't like borrowing money to invest.

Now explain why it's good to have a mortgage at all? Don't just say "because a couple hundred a month is a small number". That's not a reason, it's just a single, incredibly subjective and situational factoid. Is there a logical or mathematical reason not to increase the amount of my mortgage as long as I can easily afford the monthly payment?

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by cogman10 on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:14PM (#30962004)
> Not only is it somewhat risky

Sort of depends on the investments doesn't it?

Sure, if you sink every penny into penny stocks or crypto you are definitely running a huge gamble. On the other hand, there are non-stock market investments that are perfectly safe. Go grab some TIPS/iBonds for the full amount of purchase. Or maybe go a little riskier and grab some bond index funds. Both of those options aren't playing the stock market.

If you wanted something a little more risky but not "throw it all on GME" then grab an ETF like VOO or VTI.

Obviously do what you like. I'm pretty comfortable with my ability to pay off my obligations.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by after_care on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:18PM (#30962050)
Plenty of rock solid investments have failed throughout history. :).

I would never tell anyone how to spend their money, I'm just bringing up a counter point to the conversation.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by cwkoss on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:55PM (#30962395)
Over the past few years, borrowing money at 0%APR to put into the stock market has been very profitable.

A lot of people are probably getting used to that idea, and if/when the market turns its going to be messy.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by ei8ths on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:37PM (#30961555)
that's exactly why I do the free 0% for 1 year on big payment plans. Let me keep my money in my investments longer. Yes I do have the money, but I don't want to easily give it up. Paypal just introduced like a 'spread the payments out for 3 months' options with 0% interest. Its awesome stuff.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by WYepQ4dNnG on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:07PM (#30961228)
That's exactly how I have used Affirm in the past ;)
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by antihero on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:35PM (#30961537)
If you pay your balance in full each month every card is 0% forever, at least in the U.K.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by tehwebguy on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:51PM (#30961710)
At this moment in the US at least Bank of America, Discover, Chase, Citi & Capital One have publicly available offers for cards with 15 - 18 months of zero interest. All but the Chase (Slate) & Citi (Diamond) offer rewards of 1% back or better.

It is very common to get a credit limit in the range of $10-20k on these cards, one could easily put all expenses on a 0% interest card, make minimum payments and put the amount of the statement balance in a high yield savings account until the promotional interest ends.

In total one would get negative interest in the amount of the rewards (say 1.25% average) plus the 15+ month yield on the cash stored away.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by chrisweekly on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:18PM (#30962043)
That's basically what I do: put most purchases on a decent Chase rewards card, and pay the statement balance each month. I haven't paid a penny of credit card interest in many years.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by horsawlarway on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:45PM (#30961639)
This is also true in the US - but not at all what the parent comment meant.

If you pay the balance in full every month - you have spent $2000 on a $2000 mattress by the end of the month. This exposes you to ~30 days of inflation and you will have paid no interest.

If you pay 0% APR over a twelve month period, and make installment payments until making a single lump sum to close out the line of credit at the end of twelve months - you are exposed to something closer to ~365 days of inflation (depending on the installment payments and the lump sum). You will have also paid no interest.

If we assume roughly 7% yearly inflation, you're paying less real value if you take option number two, because you will have paid $2000, but that same mattress is now worth ~$2140 - You are abusing the time differential between purchase and payment to receive a discount.

That said - this is not the majority of folks using these services.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by bena on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:31PM (#30962170)
Minus the depreciation of using the mattress for a year.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by horsawlarway on Sunday April 10, 2022 @10:25AM (#30977153)
Ok - maybe it's more clear if I phrase it this way:

You paid 2022 dollars for a mattress priced in 2021 dollars. Because of inflation, 2022 dollars are worth less than 2021 dollars (each 2022 dollar is worth ~93% of a 2021 dollar, if we have ~7% inflation)

The mattress would have cost you $2000 2021 dollars if you paid for it immediately. But because you paid the 2021 price tag with 2022 dollars, you are receiving a discount: 2000 * .93 = $1860. You are only paying $1860 2021 dollars, vs the 2000 you would have paid.

Now - and this is very important - none of this matters if you're just shoving those dollars under your mattress for a year. You have to be taking advantage of the inflation by buying an asset that holds its real value over time, and then exchanging it back for the nominal value in 2022.

As an example - assume that we have ~7% inflation, and the total stock market is exactly flat: it neither gains nor loses value compared to inflation (its real value stays the same). You have exactly $2000, and the mattress costs exactly $2000.

Option 1: you pay right now. End result: you have 0 dollars.

Option 2: you pay one year from now, and invest the 2000 in the market until then. End result: after 1 year, when you sell you investments, you have 2140 dollars. you pay 2000 for the mattress. End result: you have 140 dollars.

That's the discount.

Now - the Corollary to this is that you have taken on risk. It's possible that the asset you buy won't hold real value compared to inflation. So while you stand to potentially make 140 bucks in a neutral situation, you also might end up losing money on the assets you buy, and not being able to pay the 2000 dollars.

Such is life.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by kodah on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:38PM (#30961563)
Same thing in the US, that's how I use my cards. They're a proxy for purchase and identity protection.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by asdfasgasdgasdg on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:42PM (#30961603)
Yes, but then you aren't using it as a 12 month loan. You're using it as a one month loan. That is explicitly not what the person you're responding to is looking for.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by warent on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:34PM (#30960830)
I had poor credit from student loans and Affirm was very generous to me when other banks weren't. Affirm helped lay the foundations to rebuilding my credit. They've been good for at least my case
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:51PM (#30961057)
> helped lay the foundations to rebuilding my credit

Does Affirm report paid-off loans to credit agencies?

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by toomuchtodo on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:52PM (#30961063)
Yes. They also report each payment (had an Affirm loan for an Aviron row machine, as it was the only way to buy it, which is a whole other story).
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by FireBeyond on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:02PM (#30963056)
I have had at this point at least a dozen Affirm BNPL loans, all paid.

There's not a single Affirm tradeline on any of my credit reports.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by toomuchtodo on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:08PM (#30963109)
Odd. It’s on my most recent tri merge credit report a lender pulled (and provided me) for a recent RE refinance. Looks like they are selective about which loans they report? My purchase was ~$2k, with 12 monthly payments.

https://helpcenter.affirm.com/s/article/reporting-to-credit-...

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by op00to on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:41PM (#30960928)
How was Affirm generous? Did they waive interest?
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by skinnymuch on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:51PM (#30961056)
Poor credit means you’re not getting credit cards beyond measly ones
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by thaway2839 on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:43PM (#30961615)
It's funny because giving people with poor credit loans they couldn't repay is exactly what led to the financial crisis and what we villainized the banks for.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by horsawlarway on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:57PM (#30961798)
This is only true in a vague and mostly irrelevant manner.

Yes - we gave people with poor credit mortgages to buy homes, and yes that did lead to the financial crisis, but not because they were poor and had bad credit.

It was because the loans were very large, and were backed by the supposed value of the home the person was buying. Then packaged in ways that hid the risk until the last minute - making those assets toxic when the housing bubble popped.

For small personal loans, there are not the same sort of systemic risks.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by jonnycat on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:55PM (#30961096)
I can understand the value prop to the consumer - but I have a harder time understanding why it's an actual business, and why existing credit card companies or other lenders can't eat their lunch with the flip of a switch.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by cbhl on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:02PM (#30961177)
Here's patio11's write-up of the value to the business side:

https://bam.kalzumeus.com/archive/buy-now-pay-later/

Also discussion thread for aforementioned piece: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29841940

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by andjd on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:15PM (#30961328)
Affirm doesn't list their B2B pricing on their website, but credit cards typically charge up to 5% of the total purchase price in processing fees. It wouldn't be hard for a challenging upstart to make a solid business that just charges less. That's probably not the primary revenue driver for most BNPL companies though.

You've also seen credit card companies change their offerings to compete with the BNPL model. One of my credit cards has a "plan it" feature for large purchases, which allows you pay it of in a shorter period of time for a lower interest rate and without incurring interest charges on your month-to-month purchases.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:17PM (#30961352)
> credit cards typically charge up to 5% of the total purchase price in processing fees

Source? I thought it’s 2 to 3%.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by arrosenberg on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:47PM (#30961667)
Credit Cards are 2-4% + 0.1-0.3/transaction depending on your volume. Small businesses would pay the max on the flat and near it on the percentage.

Affirm and similar were 6% last time I talked to them (admittedly 3-4 years ago), and represented a far superior value proposition for a lot of customers because it gives them a longer period of time and forces them onto a payment schedule.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by leetcrew on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:28PM (#30961475)
there's also a flat fee per transaction (eg, 3.25% + $0.10). this can make the effective rate pretty high for small purchases.

https://www.valuepenguin.com/credit-card-processing/intercha...

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by jjoonathan on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:26PM (#30961435)
Sure, 2-3% if you're WalMart. If you're (small respectable retailer) you'll be paying three times that and if you're a tiny retailer you'll be paying five times that.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by pc86 on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:29PM (#30961482)
Nobody is paying 10-15% in credit card fees regardless of their size. This is just blatantly wrong.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by kube-system on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:14PM (#30963165)
I wouldn't say nobody. High-risk payment processors can have rates that high.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by kazanins on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:05PM (#30961212)
Hi! Affirms scores (evaluates the risk) of each transaction in real time, which allows then to have reasonably low bad rates. Very few lenders can do it.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by radicaldreamer on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:13PM (#30961297)
Until there's a credit crunch or a recession, in which case all that "real-time" risk management will be moot and losses will be massive.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by acomms on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:37PM (#30961557)
I am curious why you think 'real-time' risk modelling in particular might be deficient? For the record I agree, but my issues are with fintech lenders desire to lend out money too freely (models that are designed to pump lending #'s, not repayment).
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by kazanins on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:22PM (#30962095)
Banks have been saying that about online lenders for over decade now…and yet LendingClub, Upstart and SoFi loan books are still fine (and this three companies are taking 1/3 of all personal loan originations in the US)
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by sgerenser on Saturday April 09, 2022 @08:41AM (#30967555)
We haven’t had a real recession in over 10 years, so that makes sense. Unless you count the very brief one back in mid 2020, which was mitigated by a flood of federal and state dollars, mortgage and student loan moratoriums, etc.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by sidr on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:28PM (#30961468)
Why is this an advantage? The factors in assessing the risk are the creditworthiness of the customer and the amount. Also, I find it hard to believe that the creditworthiness of a customer actually fluctuates fast enough for Affirm to be able to do some arbitrage on it.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by kazanins on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:20PM (#30962071)
Time of purchase, purchased goods, user behavior during the purchase, etc are additional inputs into a scoring model
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by pueblito on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:20PM (#30963210)
The ol’ Algorithm-as-Patsy strategy. CFPB continues to sleep at the wheel, as designed.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by gmadsen on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:49PM (#30961039)
ive used them for a 12 month 0% interest. why not let them eat inflation for me, and I can put my money elsewhere
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by Ancalagon on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:17PM (#30962039)
Where will you put the money you’ve saved to beat inflation? When the market is good I’d say this Is a good plan but when the market is bad the only place that makes sense Is a HYSA
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by BbzzbB on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:47PM (#30961672)
The appeal, as I understand it (and I'm 100% an out-of-his-field armchair analyst here), is that this is loan sharking with extra steps ("late fees") for those of us with the worse credit scores that can't get better options. I forgot the exact number, but when I've done the math how much maximum interest you accrue by missing every payment is well beyond usury, as I recall it gets you above 30% interests in 2-3 months (and caps there, which I guess is the silver lining), where as I've considered "interest" to be late fees over the loaned amount.

For every person using this to their advantage as a credit tool, I bet there are a dozen who are just sinking deeper into their debt quick sand.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by mslate on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:04PM (#30961208)
The innovation isn’t the credit terms—-it’s A/B testing copy on the item & checkout page of e-commerce.

Quoting on-demand loan pricing with clearer upfront payment amounts is more intuitive to consumers than “putting it on the credit card”.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by dimitrios1 on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:46PM (#30960995)
There are many purchases I have made with Affirm to take advantage of pay-over-time without interest. In these arrangements I imagine the product is giving Affirm a cut.

Also for bigger purchases, it's better than a credit card. I pay my Amex balance off every month, but during the pandemic I used Affirm to purchase a home gym setup, and paid it over the course of 6 months at a much lower interest rate.

They are definitely not predatory in my view, but I don't have the perspective of a low-income person anymore.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by 71a54xd on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:45PM (#30961641)
Even though I have the money, I've used this to leverage my liquid funds for side gigs. Although I have huge ethical issues with predatory companies like Affirm incentivizing people with less financial self-control to spend beyond their means. Honestly, I think companies like Chime are a bigger issue. They're the payday loan grift of today - especially with their advertising clearly targeting minorities that focuses on paycheck advances.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by thaway2839 on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:42PM (#30961598)
Chase is now offering further extended payment options much like Affirm, etc.

Might as well just go with your bank itself, instead of adding another 3rd party merchant into the mix.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by Ancalagon on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:19PM (#30962053)
I think Affirm differentiates based on how it evaluate loan giving
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by barkerja on Friday April 08, 2022 @09:49PM (#30964567)
> Credit cards already give you a 30-day grace period before purchases start accruing interest.

This depends on the timing of your transaction and your statement date. If you purchase something 1 day before your statement date, and you don't pay it off that same day, you will accrue interest.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by jallen_dot_dev on Friday April 08, 2022 @06:51PM (#30963464)
Other commenters are offering very rational reasons including inflation and the time-value of money, but I think there's a much simpler explanation when it comes to most people: they see a smaller number, it's psychologically easier to pay less today.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by officeplant on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:34PM (#30961525)
Makes sense for when I want to buy a Mattress or piece of equipment equally expensive over 12+ months with no interest. Except in cases where there is an equally good or better arrangement via one of my cards like 18-24 months no interest.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by matwood on Friday April 08, 2022 @04:51PM (#30962356)
IDK. My credit is great and anytime I'm offered 0% interest over 12-24 months for purchases $1k+ I take it. I much prefer having cash in hand. I don't buy very much stuff in general, but that's a different conversation.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by dvtrn on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:38PM (#30960876)
especially if you already have a credit card.

Asked and answered? Majority of Americans have credit cards. An awful lot still don’t, and have shit financial situations that make getting one pretty hard. This is a widely documented phenomenon.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by somerando7 on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:33PM (#30960817)
I believe affirm provides 0% APR for a year sometimes?
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by dlp211 on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:22PM (#30961406)
Or longer. Peloton financing through affirm can be longer than 2 years.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by morpheuskafka on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:54PM (#30961083)
Plus (as long as you do so sparingly), you can easily open a new card and get 1-2 years interest free plus a sign up bonus.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by Phrenzy on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:47PM (#30961020)
Some merchants will allow 6 months interest free through Affirm. I used them to finance my recent mattress purchase.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by oh_sigh on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:40PM (#30960905)
Spread out 0% Apr over 5 months instead of 2?

Agreed about them being predatory. They literally lose money for every person that uses their service in the recommended/correct way, and only make money when someone flubs a payment.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by stu2b50 on Friday April 08, 2022 @02:54PM (#30961087)
That’s not how the business model works (or how they’d want it to work anyway). Affirm makes money on transactions in the “correct” way via very high merchant fees.

Merchants will pay affirm a large fee for conversion benefits (e.g better a customer pay $700 even if I lose $50 to affirm fees than for them to pay $0 because they got spooked by the price). Affirm gets the fee. They suffer risks from inflation and nonpayment. Hopefully for them one is larger than the other.

Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by mint2 on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:38PM (#30961561)
If $X spooks someone for a discretionary spend item, then in most cases it’s a bad financial decision for them to pay $X just spread over Y months.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by bee_rider on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:50PM (#30961705)
This is a problem with the whole credit system, right? Yes it is a bad system.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by drc500free on Friday April 08, 2022 @05:38PM (#30962811)
Instead of building wealth, we're polishing poverty so that more people can live right up against the edge.
Re:Why I'll never use Affirm again by oh_sigh on Friday April 08, 2022 @03:16PM (#30961339)
Ah, okay, fair enough then. I didn't realize merchants were paying affirm for this. Though I really hope the merchants look at their data. The only time I've used affirm is when I'm already on the checkout page, literally credit card in hand, where I would have bought the product no matter what. But yeah I'll take a 6 month 0% interest loan instead of a 1 month 0% interest loan.