To think that any of this would then be used to build a trustworthy ecosystem for non-developers to use, seems delusional to me. And building a VTOL taxi airline on top of it seems like it puts the cart 3 miles uphill from the horses.
Billion!
Since this is an allegation, we must presume innocence. However I still cannot imagine what planet would entrust 10 figures to her control. Witness her rap.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7jlSHGAem6g
But I also realize reading this Twitter thread I do not understand the world of crypto at all.
stay away from all of it.
It's the same thing as reading the terms and conditions.
This is making it so there is no "undo", and no escrow agent. There's value, for those looking to take advantage of others.
Smart contracts on a general computing platform can enable anything, including the reversible payments and reliance on trusted third party delegates that you see in traditional banking, so as a consequence of this maximally expansive design space, I assume they will eventually lead to a financial system that offers a much better set of trade-offs than that of any other financial system.
I don’t understand at all how wheels move and what is that round thing near my chest and what do with it. Maybe it’s the fifth wheel. Or why fuel is needed, I can’t even find a mechanic who will look under the hood for me if I can’t. Also since my last car could use my ATM card and sign my cheques I had to be extra careful when turning on the ignition and had to see the gps log whether it drove to my bank when I was taking the afternoon nap.
There was no service warranty and guarantee with the car at all. I had to hire an entire division of technicians and engineers to use it. I think few lawyers and auditors as well.
In fact it felt I also needed a PhD in all things automobile to use my car.
Most importantly I can’t see in front of me at all. Front is opaque. I just drive hoping I don’t run someone over or something doesn’t run me over and my car.
Crypto is neither understandable nor useful.
No mention of the person or the Arrow company on the internet previous to this episode seems to exist. Other than looking at the chain records, how should we believe that any of these stories are true?
- People don't read what's in front of them.
I've seen this emerge in a vast array of fields. No matter how much we highlight specific details, for all our efforts in red-flagging irreversible actions, folks will often blitz past a confirmation dialog, nag screen, or notification message, without internalising the details or the risks. For those in financial technology, as in this specific example, irreversible actions also extend the attack surface for fraud.
Even the brightest minds can be lazy (some might even say it's a feature, not a bug) and one should never rely upon the opposite. We consequently face a design choice, for all irreversible (or hard-to-reverse) actions, the most common options being:
a) allow a grace period;
b) redesign, if possible, to make it user-reversible;
c) build a forcing function for diligence[1]; or
d) expect support tickets about that feature.
The default is (d), and the helpdesk won't thank us, since the workload generally scales linearly with growth at a high opportunity cost.
OTH I'm pretty sure that if the mark had been using such systems years ago, he wouldn't have $100m+ worth of ETH now ; )
Beware the survivorship bias: https://xkcd.com/1827/
We had multiple threads about base rate error on HN just yesterday!
Most financial activity happens in fiat, and so of course it stands to reason that most fraud is also done in fiat. The real question is whether the legitimate-to-fraudulent ratio is higher in cryptocurrencies than in fiat.
[1]:https://www.lesswrong.com/s/XsMTxdQ6fprAQMoKi/p/DSzpr8Y9299j...
In a twist of irony, you can see another example of it in the distribution of terms reinvented by internet rationalists :-)
> Most people think of stereotyping as “Here’s one example I heard of where the out-group does something bad,” and then you correct it with “But we can’t generalize about an entire group just from one example!” It’s less obvious that you may be able to provide literally one million examples of your false stereotype and still have it be a false stereotype.
Also here in Belgium, plenty of people are getting scammed by wire transfer, and no way to get their money back.
I think you have overly optimistic view on banks or the court system giving your money back.
If somehow you get through an in-person meeting with a bank branch manager to unwittingly wire millions of dollars, and the topic of how much money you're wiring and the exact purpose of wiring such a high amount isn't brought up, and you somehow still accidentally wire millions of dollars away without anyone ever bringing up the amount and purpose of the transaction, then I'm sure you'll still be able to recover that money back because banks are required to actually validate transactions of that size with KYC, AML, etc. laws. Only cryptocurrencies allow one the ability transmit this amount of money in seconds.
Isn't that only for cash transfers?
> which would likely involve a mandatory in-person meeting with the bank customer
At least at Chase and Fidelity, wires can be done over the phone with no limit.
> to verify their credentials and purpose
I've never seen a banker really help to verify wire instructions, as in contacting the intended recipient. Normally they just ask the sender if they've verified the instructions, if they understand that the wire is irreversible, etc.
Of course when it gets to the bank's wire department, they make some attempt to block suspicious wires. But they're guessing based on limited info, as they don't typically contact the sender or recipient.
> I'm sure you'll still be able to recover that money back because banks are required to actually validate transactions of that size with KYC, AML, etc. laws
From what I've heard, fraudsters will (indirectly) transfer funds to e.g. a Nigerian bank and cash out there. It doesn't always succeed, but it does sometimes, or wire fraud wouldn't exist.
But the scenario in the OP is only possible in cryptocurrencies. You can't put a button on a website "Click here to send a JPEG through email for $3.50*" with the fine print "*and also 100 million dollars" and expect that to ever work out with the legacy banking system. Only in cryptoland could someone ever accidentally yeet 100 million dollars in a few seconds by visiting a website and clicking a button.
I'm able to work with total strangers, raise money, sell products, contribute to causes, commission art work etc, etc, hold those funds in a smart contract treasury and encode rules to govern the spending of those funds.
Safe guards do exist for the aforementioned issue. Number one is not holding significant sums of money in a single wallet, unless it's a multi-sig that requires multiple parties to agree to transactions (like Gnosis Safe wallets, which store $100B+ in assets and are battle tested at this point).
The value of the PEOPLE tokens on the secondary market proceeded to increase nearly 10x in the weeks following the dissolution of the DAO. Even though market cap is declining, at $327M mcap, it is still many multiples of the amount raised.
PEOPLE tokens in circulation are still redeemable for the underlying ETH, but the monetary premium has increased as a result of the dispersed liquidity to so many holders (16K+) as well as the novelty of retaining the token for a failed, yet valiant effort.
https://www.cnbc.com/2020/10/15/how-one-familys-nightmare-il...
When I purchased a house, I Googled the recipient, confirmed the certificate, Googled the number found on their website separately to confirm it was listed elsewhere as belonging to the company I expected it to belong to, called it, and got them to tell me the account details for the wire transfer, confirming it matched what I had been sent. Which, to their credit, their instructions also told me to do. And I initially sent the down payment, confirmed they received that, and only later in the process sent the remainder.
While there still are some ways to beat that (compromise the recipient's infrastructure, change the website, lock out the recipient from their email, insert into the email exchange, get a wire transfer done before the recipient can proactively call the target to warn them), it's a lot harder to pull off than "find a target that won't read the code very closely".
At least with crypto, the chain of ownership is transparent and can't be faked. So validation is cheap and easy to do.
In theory. The devil is in the details; does everyone know how to validate the chain of ownership, even the most non-technical of users who must rely on the system? If not, you either will never be mainstream, or you're reliant on a trusted agent to validate on your behalf (sorta like a title company!).
And if you screw something up with crypto, there is no way to address it. The complaint of "dealing with lawyers and trying to get someone to pay for it" is a feature, not a bug. Worst case, it's no different than the crypto outcome; best case, you have recourse.
AFAIK you don't need to be a title company to do this, any buyer could do it themselves.
And what if you don't know enough about land law to make sense of everything? That's when you need companies to do it for you.
Is checking the chain of ownership of cryptocurrencies easier than land? It depends whether you're talking to a real estate lawyer or a NFT seller.
I'm neither, and I don't see the intrinsic difference.
I worked at a financial institution, no way you could open an account, deposit some spare change, and then withdraw 900k after a few weeks especially in America. Compliance would be all over that account, which is probably why they got the money back anyhow because the crooks would have a lot of talking to do after getting that much money in their account. KYC and AML is required for both sides of the wire transfer.
I could find literally thousands of other stories like this in a minute scraping the web.
The fact is wires can also be irreversible and you cannot use the court system as a blunt instrument outside your jurisdiction. The value transmission medium isn’t the problem here.
No, it isn't. It's a reminder that we have all of this financial structure for a reason. The person you're responding to didn't make any light of the potential victim or call them a degenerate.
In traditional finance, you (Joe Shmoe) can't just wire someone ~100M USD, regardless of jurisdiction. There are controls, most of which have been written in blood or tears. Cryptocurrencies will also grow those controls, and we will all rightly question its value when it inevitably does.
But it's also not a disgrace for traditional finance: it's a disgrace with respect to the latitude our justice system gives to individual LEOs and a sign that the government is willing to extrajudicially punish people instead of pursuing justice through the courts.
Put another way: assert forfeiture is not some kind of "gotcha" against traditional finance in favor of cryptocurrencies. When law enforcement seizes your bank account, they're going to seize your cryptocurrency accounts too. And if you (unadvisedly) attempt to hide those assets, then you will be making their job in court much easier.
If someone goes through the legal process and is found to be guilty and their assets are seized that's fine. But if someone is pulled over, found to have some drugs, gets their car and cash on them possessed and is forced to go through a lengthy process that free up that money, then that's different.
In any case: the really egregious examples of civil asset forfeiture are the petty ones: the government stops someone for the crime of DWB[1], and seizes all of the property they have on their person (including, sometimes, the car itself.) It's a disgusting crime, but one that doesn't typically extend to the victim's bank accounts or other financial resources, unless there's a larger case being pursued against them. And so, once again, it's not clear how cryptocurrency improves the state of affairs: either you're carrying a hot wallet around with you for your day-to-day expenses (in which case you're subject to the same seizure), or it's roughly equivalent to a traditional financial produce and isn't subject to a spurious seizure (but might be subject to a larger one).
Scenario 2: they take your hardware wallet, then they must prosecute you and prove to a court that the money is not legitimately yours, to get the key. IANAL, but am I wrong?
Instead, I'll point out that the answer does not matter: from the moment that they have my hot wallet instead of me, I can no longer use it. It doesn't matter to me whether they can actually liquidate it or not. And, as I pointed out earlier, I'd harm my own case by attempting to liquidate my assets with a separate copy.
I'm not saying technical solutions make the rule of law unnecessary. But they can defend against some violations of the rule of law, depending on the parts of the justice system that are still just.
People effectively defending themselves against a national disgrace help towards getting the disgrace fixed.
But don't delude yourself into thinking that any meaningful number of people, even cryptocurrency believers, share your position. It's all fun and games until the Men with Sticks show up, and most people understandably tuck tail at that point.
If I'm going to be made a coward in the eyes of a few LARPers, I might as well pay as few middlemen as possible in the process. But that's just me!
> But don't delude yourself into thinking that any meaningful number of people, even cryptocurrency believers, share your position.
You'd be surprised.
Next you're going to tell me that the blockchain isn't made of Lego blocks!
> You'd be surprised.
Given the aggressive spread of custodial services, I don't think I would be. The average cryptocurrency user (even enthusiasts, true believers, &c.) is not a dyed-in-the-wool Burkean. Less prosaically: easy money comes with loose beliefs.
Try getting your money back when getting scammed via venmo or PayPal - rarely any better, and if you’re selling you’re more likely to get scammed with those services than crypto.
In nearly all cases, no separate restitution was required: the processor or my bank was able to reverse or halt the ACH transaction before the money settled. In the handful of cases where settlement had already happened, they were able to countermand the transaction.
Venmo/PayPal/Fedwire transactions should be able to settle in real time, which can be more convenient at the expense of easy reversability
If you use a payment card (debit or credit) with a payment service, then they might use either the payment card's network or ACH, depending on what the card issuer supports.
It’s definitely not a guarantee. Most of the Venmo type scams where people “accidentally” send you money and ask you to send it back or pay for an item with bad funds are not reclaimable from those services based on TOS. In those cases you’d be better off with BTC.
I'm a reasonably technical dude (senior data engineer at GAMMA/FAANG/whatever we're deciding to use nowadays), yet I don't have a damn clue what this means. And that's not an indictment of your communication. How on earth could I expect my wife, my brother, my parents, my kids, any of my friends, etc., to understand this?
On the other hand, all these people understand the concepts of bank accounts, credit cards, fiat currency, etc.
I'm open to learning more and having my views changed, but I'm so far convinced that there's absolutely nothing about crypto that is a simple, reliable, demonstrably real solution to a problem that isn't already handled by our current financial instruments.
Ideally wallets would have better UX where concepts like this could be handled safely and in an accessible manner. I think crypto isn't really ready for general consumption yet.
You can't ever expose that level to end users without it being an endless fraud source for people.
I’m interested to know whether the con artists could have realistically nabbed $100M, or if there was effectively never any chance of that due to other precautions. I would hope it’s the latter, but crypto’s strangeness stopped surprising me.
Fabulous comment, by the way. Easily one of the top ten in the last month. Thank you for the breakdown.
He could have approved a malicious contract to drain the lot.
But.. why? Isn’t that a remarkably bad idea?
Or is there some crypto advantage to keeping every last coin in the same basket? Other than it being a flex.
One can also use the borrowed funds to speculate on other cryptocurrency, as a collateralized margin loan. Many lending systems offer incentives too, where you can be paid to borrow.
If you want to maximize your potential losses, that’s a great idea.
It’s a giant flex.
no address reuse is almost impossible as the wallets make it very hard as well
people don't really seem to know that Metamask gives you unlimited addresses, fwiw it is expensive to do approvals in each address
https://zapper.fi/account/0xb1e9d641249a2033c37cf1c241a01e71...
But I'm not worth $100m so I guess the joke's on me.
Hell, given my distaste for crypto, if I were more unethical I may even attempt such scams, but I’d balance it out by donating the stolen money to environmental initiatives to combat global warming (after giving myself some fair compensation, I don’t have the skills to get away with hiding $100+ million).
Unless you flex with your $100M in aave on your main with an ENS name, how will your victims know you are rich and worthy?
The 4% rule is fairy tales, especially post pandemic economy. we will be working more for less as time goes on.
Nah, I want cars, some homes, a yacht and a hot ass babe to pleasure me and raise nice children as we travel the world and dress fancy.
Boy, are you in for a nasty surprise. But don't come crying to us, old men who warned you that what you really should want is a nice cabin near a lake with plenty of fish and an absolutely plain ass woman.
Outside of silicon valley, 170k per year is a huge amount of money. Especially if you're going to travel outside of North America and Europe.
Yes. Probably not for the other things.
It seems like this is becoming the minimum standard for scam operations. For example, there is currently a BTC phishing scam going around that tries to convince the user they've accidentally received an email meant for someone else, which just happens to include a link to a million dollars worth of BTC. The website looks legitimate, albeit amateurish, to the point that it could even be convincing to another web developer. The rest of it is much like the OP's scam.
It starts with an email from the hacked account of a real bank manager in an Italian town, and is addressed to a real self-proclaimed stock market "guru" from the UK, now living in the US. The email states that 19 BTC has been deposited into an account that was created for them on a site called Coinlux, and they provide the username and password for the account. The Coinlux name was even used by an actual company at one point, so searching for any of the names or details surrounding the scam generates very real and convincing results.
Upon visiting the page, you're presented with a moderately professional-ish looking site that asks which fiat currency you want to use and lets you login. You're then prompted to enter a phone number to "secure the account" which, surprisingly, initiates an actual phone call from a number in the UK using a Twilio-like service. After confirming the verification number, you're allowed to view the account, which has some realistic dummy transactions in the history and other features that make the site somewhat believable (it even has a fake chat system and working account recovery).
After initiating a withdrawal of any amount, it provides a warning that you should make a small test transaction first (of 0.0001/$4), to ensure that you're sending to the correct BTC address -- after all, you wouldn't want to send 19 BTC to the wrong place and lose it all. It takes much longer than a normal transaction (likely because the scammers are manually initiating them), but it does eventually go through, and they've now succeeded in convincing the user that there is real BTC in the account and you can actually withdraw it.
However, if you try to make a larger withdrawal (or a second one at all), you're now presented with an error stating that you're not withdrawing enough, because of a "minimum withdrawal amount" defined when the account was created. This minimum amount happens to be 19.01 BTC, or 0.01 more than is in the actual account currently. So you've successfully withdrawn ~$4, but you have to deposit ~$400 if you want to access the entire 19 BTC.
As if it weren't obvious enough at this point, checking the address[1] which sent the 0.0001 makes the entire scam plain as day. This means that anyone with any amount of tech knowledge is probably not susceptible to the scam, though I do think that certain personality types could get caught up in the excitement of potentially "stealing" a million dollars. On the other side, non-techies will likely fall for this in droves, and the transaction history on that address does show there have already been successful victims -- though this particular person's scam has been massively unsuccessful so far, and they may actually be in the red overall.
[1] https://www.blockchain.com/btc/address/bc1qt80xra3r2df8gvzr0...
Thomas's wallet is public and advertised on Twitter via his ENS domain. He had $100M+ in aETH, a derivative token provided by Aave when you lend out your assets for interest. The aETH is redeemable for the underlying asset.
The scammers created a fake NFT project associated with space and drones, and proceeded to give Thomas a free one, but asked that he stake it (or deposit it into a smart contract), to earn yield in the form of Armstrong ETH, a token they made up that had the same acronym as Aave's (aETH).
The catch was that when he went to stake his NFT, they asked for an approval for spending aETH from his wallet. Approvals such as this are normal when interacting with smart contracts, since the contract has to be "delegated" responsibility over the tokens in order to move them. However, what wasn't normal is that the approval was actually for Aave ETH.
If he had only looked at the front end of the scam site, it wasn't obvious what was going on. However, a quick glance at Etherscan revealed that he had signed off on an unlimited spend approval for Aave ETH.
Luckily, he had done so on a fresh wallet and not his main wallet that has $100M in aETH. When the scammers tried to get him to stake a second NFT from his main account, he got suspicious and discovered the truth.
This scam was specifically targeted at Thomas, and orchestrated over multiple weeks, for the specific assets in his primary wallet.
Couple takeaways:
- divide your assets across multiple wallets. New wallets are free. Don't put all your eggs in one basket.
- use a hardware wallet or an audited battle tested smart contract such as Gnosis Safe for storing significant sums of money.
- always verify your transactions
- avoid associating your public identity with your main wallet / vault address
- be careful, scammers are getting more creative and advanced in technique including standing up professional front end websites to give the appearance of legitimacy