News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by MereInterest on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:38PM (#30324832)
I like the takeaways, though I'd also add an additional one, that you should use systems that have reversible transactions. That way, when you fall victim to fraud, you can use the court system to recover your losses.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by TacticalCoder on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:33PM (#30325364)
> that you should use systems that have reversible transactions.

OTH I'm pretty sure that if the mark had been using such systems years ago, he wouldn't have $100m+ worth of ETH now ; )

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by ReactiveJelly on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:34PM (#30325913)
Almost nobody has $100M worth of anything, so...
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by Qub3d on Sunday February 13, 2022 @06:06PM (#30326500)
If the last lottery ticket winner hadn't bought a powerball ticket, they also wouldn't be worth millions.

Beware the survivorship bias: https://xkcd.com/1827/

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by chrisco255 on Monday February 14, 2022 @02:21AM (#30329163)
Ethereum is a technology platform with a rich ecosystem. Investing in ETH isn't a crap shoot.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by bko on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:27PM (#30325292)
You're mixing up reversible transactions and court system. If someone defrauds you in an irreversible transaction, you can still sue that person for damages if you know who they are. Similarly if someone defrauds you in reversible transactions, you can't just wave a wand and get your money back. You can sue them if you know who they are, or you can request a reversal from your bank/cc provider (may or may not be honored) but you're not completely safe. Most fraud happens in fiat and there are real victims out here.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by woodruffw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @05:00PM (#30326089)
> Most fraud happens in fiat and there are real victims out here.

We had multiple threads about base rate error on HN just yesterday!

Most financial activity happens in fiat, and so of course it stands to reason that most fraud is also done in fiat. The real question is whether the legitimate-to-fraudulent ratio is higher in cryptocurrencies than in fiat.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by Qub3d on Sunday February 13, 2022 @06:40PM (#30326769)
See also: the "Chinese Robbers" fallacy[1] -- just because you can find a ton of examples of fiat fraud, doesn't imply its worse -- without context it only implies its the most common form of currency.

[1]:https://www.lesswrong.com/s/XsMTxdQ6fprAQMoKi/p/DSzpr8Y9299j...

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by woodruffw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @07:14PM (#30327029)
Yes, that's called "base rate neglect" or "base rate bias."

In a twist of irony, you can see another example of it in the distribution of terms reinvented by internet rationalists :-)

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by Qub3d on Sunday February 13, 2022 @10:34PM (#30328099)
It's certainly under the category of base rate bias but it's a specific subcategory (think of it as the rhombuses and squares relationship). In this case the term is used to focus on the fact that it's not just one example here (or two or three), you can provide thousands of examples of currency fraud and the fallacy is still a fallacy

> Most people think of stereotyping as “Here’s one example I heard of where the out-group does something bad,” and then you correct it with “But we can’t generalize about an entire group just from one example!” It’s less obvious that you may be able to provide literally one million examples of your false stereotype and still have it be a false stereotype.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by cipheredStones on Sunday February 13, 2022 @07:49PM (#30327240)
"Base rate" appears multiple times in that article and is a pretty core concept in the rationalist movement. Memorably illustrating a concept is not the same thing as not knowing the technical term.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by koonsolo on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:48PM (#30325527)
I guess you haven't seen "The Tinder Swindler" on Netflix?

Also here in Belgium, plenty of people are getting scammed by wire transfer, and no way to get their money back.

I think you have overly optimistic view on banks or the court system giving your money back.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by skim_milk on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:25PM (#30325836)
How would one "accidentally" wire transfer millions of dollars? At $10k in America, KYC and AML laws force banks to step through extra layers of verification to wire such amount. It's virtually impossible for someone to accidentally wire millions, which would likely involve a mandatory in-person meeting with the bank customer to verify their credentials and purpose.

If somehow you get through an in-person meeting with a bank branch manager to unwittingly wire millions of dollars, and the topic of how much money you're wiring and the exact purpose of wiring such a high amount isn't brought up, and you somehow still accidentally wire millions of dollars away without anyone ever bringing up the amount and purpose of the transaction, then I'm sure you'll still be able to recover that money back because banks are required to actually validate transactions of that size with KYC, AML, etc. laws. Only cryptocurrencies allow one the ability transmit this amount of money in seconds.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by dlubarov on Sunday February 13, 2022 @08:28PM (#30327474)
> At $10k in America, KYC and AML laws force banks to step through extra layers of verification

Isn't that only for cash transfers?

> which would likely involve a mandatory in-person meeting with the bank customer

At least at Chase and Fidelity, wires can be done over the phone with no limit.

> to verify their credentials and purpose

I've never seen a banker really help to verify wire instructions, as in contacting the intended recipient. Normally they just ask the sender if they've verified the instructions, if they understand that the wire is irreversible, etc.

Of course when it gets to the bank's wire department, they make some attempt to block suspicious wires. But they're guessing based on limited info, as they don't typically contact the sender or recipient.

> I'm sure you'll still be able to recover that money back because banks are required to actually validate transactions of that size with KYC, AML, etc. laws

From what I've heard, fraudsters will (indirectly) transfer funds to e.g. a Nigerian bank and cash out there. It doesn't always succeed, but it does sometimes, or wire fraud wouldn't exist.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by skim_milk on Sunday February 13, 2022 @09:20PM (#30327749)
Yes, the banking industry won't do much to prevent Aunt Senile from wiring $80k to Nigeria, although I doubt they make it easy. Hell, I couldn't even phone-authorize a wire of 8k to buy a car two states over, but I guess that's just my bank. Had to bloody pay for the car on credit card, no joke.

But the scenario in the OP is only possible in cryptocurrencies. You can't put a button on a website "Click here to send a JPEG through email for $3.50*" with the fine print "*and also 100 million dollars" and expect that to ever work out with the legacy banking system. Only in cryptoland could someone ever accidentally yeet 100 million dollars in a few seconds by visiting a website and clicking a button.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by chrisco255 on Monday February 14, 2022 @02:31AM (#30329222)
It's a fair criticism. But the reverse is also true, in that money is frictionless to raise and coordinate in cryptocurrencies, such as the $45M attempt at buying a copy of the Constitution (which failed, but people simply got a refund), or the $56M that was raised for Julian Assange's defense last week.

I'm able to work with total strangers, raise money, sell products, contribute to causes, commission art work etc, etc, hold those funds in a smart contract treasury and encode rules to govern the spending of those funds.

Safe guards do exist for the aforementioned issue. Number one is not holding significant sums of money in a single wallet, unless it's a multi-sig that requires multiple parties to agree to transactions (like Gnosis Safe wallets, which store $100B+ in assets and are battle tested at this point).

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by ves on Monday February 14, 2022 @04:27AM (#30330011)
You’re aware that an enormous proportion of people’s constitution dao refunds were eaten up by gas fees, presumably.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by chrisco255 on Monday February 14, 2022 @07:47AM (#30331360)
No, they weren't: https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/constitutiondao

The value of the PEOPLE tokens on the secondary market proceeded to increase nearly 10x in the weeks following the dissolution of the DAO. Even though market cap is declining, at $327M mcap, it is still many multiples of the amount raised.

PEOPLE tokens in circulation are still redeemable for the underlying ETH, but the monetary premium has increased as a result of the dispersed liquidity to so many holders (16K+) as well as the novelty of retaining the token for a failed, yet valiant effort.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by Consultant32452 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @09:58PM (#30327944)
I recently bought a house. My title company made a BIG deal about fraud. Basically, people figure out you're in the process of buying a house, pretend to be your title company, and give you their wire info instead of the real info. You wire a giant pile of house down payment to the bad guys, and they walk. You will not get that $ back.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by kooshball on Sunday February 13, 2022 @10:34PM (#30328106)
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by lostcolony on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:02PM (#30328234)
Those are all intentionally sending money; you just have had someone tell you the wrong account. Which is just as easy with crypto. And, just like with crypto, you can always reach out to the party you are trying to send money to via another means to confirm the address.

When I purchased a house, I Googled the recipient, confirmed the certificate, Googled the number found on their website separately to confirm it was listed elsewhere as belonging to the company I expected it to belong to, called it, and got them to tell me the account details for the wire transfer, confirming it matched what I had been sent. Which, to their credit, their instructions also told me to do. And I initially sent the down payment, confirmed they received that, and only later in the process sent the remainder.

While there still are some ways to beat that (compromise the recipient's infrastructure, change the website, lock out the recipient from their email, insert into the email exchange, get a wire transfer done before the recipient can proactively call the target to warn them), it's a lot harder to pull off than "find a target that won't read the code very closely".

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by chrisco255 on Monday February 14, 2022 @02:38AM (#30329254)
It's rare that buyers of houses and property are that thorough. On the contrary, my friend recently bought a plot of land for which the sellers did not own the title. The title company, who's only job is to verify this, completely missed it. The fake sellers made out with tens of thousands of dollars and the real owners, who are from Germany, are still haggling with my friend and trying to get her or the title company to pay for their lawyer fees, and she still doesn't have title to the land!

At least with crypto, the chain of ownership is transparent and can't be faked. So validation is cheap and easy to do.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by lostcolony on Monday February 14, 2022 @01:01PM (#30335450)
>> At least with crypto, the chain of ownership is transparent and can't be faked. So validation is cheap and easy to do.

In theory. The devil is in the details; does everyone know how to validate the chain of ownership, even the most non-technical of users who must rely on the system? If not, you either will never be mainstream, or you're reliant on a trusted agent to validate on your behalf (sorta like a title company!).

And if you screw something up with crypto, there is no way to address it. The complaint of "dealing with lawyers and trying to get someone to pay for it" is a feature, not a bug. Worst case, it's no different than the crypto outcome; best case, you have recourse.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by hnfong on Monday February 14, 2022 @08:13AM (#30331582)
Where is the land mentioned? Is there no land registry there? In many jurisdictions, titles to land are registered through a government operated registry where would-be buyers could look up information on the situation of the land rights.

AFAIK you don't need to be a title company to do this, any buyer could do it themselves.

And what if you don't know enough about land law to make sense of everything? That's when you need companies to do it for you.

Is checking the chain of ownership of cryptocurrencies easier than land? It depends whether you're talking to a real estate lawyer or a NFT seller.

I'm neither, and I don't see the intrinsic difference.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by skim_milk on Monday February 14, 2022 @12:00AM (#30328533)
Man, BoA sure lets a lot through. I couldn't even wire 8k without my physical presence - this was during COVID lockdown of all things as well! I know nothing of buying a house, but when I bought another, more expensive car that required a loan, the bank went through the whole rigamaroo calling a bunch of people to verify all the details (after all, I was going to buy their car with their money) - took nearly an hour to actually get the money after being approved for the loan days beforehand with all their internal busywork. All for something that, what, might have covered half of the wages for the day of the employees working there at the branch office after three years of interest? I think I'll be staying with my tiny, irrelevant local bank after all!

I worked at a financial institution, no way you could open an account, deposit some spare change, and then withdraw 900k after a few weeks especially in America. Compliance would be all over that account, which is probably why they got the money back anyhow because the crooks would have a lot of talking to do after getting that much money in their account. KYC and AML is required for both sides of the wire transfer.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by maneesh on Sunday February 13, 2022 @05:37PM (#30326332)
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by djur on Sunday February 13, 2022 @05:43PM (#30326367)
Notice that this was Citi making a mistake in a payment on behalf of Revlon, and it's Citi that's on the hook for the excess payment, not Revlon.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by tedunangst on Sunday February 13, 2022 @06:07PM (#30326511)
So now for the fun question: who do I have to tweet at to get Citi to wire me millions of dollars?
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by rmbyrro on Sunday February 13, 2022 @05:04PM (#30326120)
Like she did with bank wire transfer fraud when she lost +300k? [1]

I could find literally thousands of other stories like this in a minute scraping the web.

[1] https://youtu.be/9cJxpKu_P0A

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by charcircuit on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:20PM (#30325224)
Even without reversible transactions the other person can just send you back the assets you sent them.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by randomhodler84 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @02:59PM (#30325021)
This is just saying “that’s what you get for playing with crypto you degenerate”.

The fact is wires can also be irreversible and you cannot use the court system as a blunt instrument outside your jurisdiction. The value transmission medium isn’t the problem here.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by woodruffw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:26PM (#30325287)
> This is just saying “that’s what you get for playing with crypto you degenerate”.

No, it isn't. It's a reminder that we have all of this financial structure for a reason. The person you're responding to didn't make any light of the potential victim or call them a degenerate.

In traditional finance, you (Joe Shmoe) can't just wire someone ~100M USD, regardless of jurisdiction. There are controls, most of which have been written in blood or tears. Cryptocurrencies will also grow those controls, and we will all rightly question its value when it inevitably does.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by bko on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:31PM (#30325334)
You ever heard of asset forfeiture? There's two sides to everything. Not really "owning" something is great if you're the victim of fraud, but has its downsides when you become a target and someone wants to arbitrarily capture your wealth

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset_forfeiture

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by woodruffw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:46PM (#30325497)
Civil asset forfeiture is a national disgrace.

But it's also not a disgrace for traditional finance: it's a disgrace with respect to the latitude our justice system gives to individual LEOs and a sign that the government is willing to extrajudicially punish people instead of pursuing justice through the courts.

Put another way: assert forfeiture is not some kind of "gotcha" against traditional finance in favor of cryptocurrencies. When law enforcement seizes your bank account, they're going to seize your cryptocurrency accounts too. And if you (unadvisedly) attempt to hide those assets, then you will be making their job in court much easier.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by bko on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:37PM (#30325935)
I'm all for the legal process and there is a legitimate way to seize assets. But asset forfeiture is not that. It's only enabled because it is trivial and is done outside of the normal legal process. It doesn't help that the beneficiaries are the very people that can initiate the forfeiture.

If someone goes through the legal process and is found to be guilty and their assets are seized that's fine. But if someone is pulled over, found to have some drugs, gets their car and cash on them possessed and is forced to go through a lengthy process that free up that money, then that's different.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by woodruffw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:45PM (#30325986)
I don't think we're in disagreement?

In any case: the really egregious examples of civil asset forfeiture are the petty ones: the government stops someone for the crime of DWB[1], and seizes all of the property they have on their person (including, sometimes, the car itself.) It's a disgusting crime, but one that doesn't typically extend to the victim's bank accounts or other financial resources, unless there's a larger case being pursued against them. And so, once again, it's not clear how cryptocurrency improves the state of affairs: either you're carrying a hot wallet around with you for your day-to-day expenses (in which case you're subject to the same seizure), or it's roughly equivalent to a traditional financial produce and isn't subject to a spurious seizure (but might be subject to a larger one).

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Driving_while_black

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by abecedarius on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:47PM (#30326001)
Forteiture scenario 1: cops take your cash. It's on you to sue them and prove to a court that it's legitimately yours.

Scenario 2: they take your hardware wallet, then they must prosecute you and prove to a court that the money is not legitimately yours, to get the key. IANAL, but am I wrong?

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by woodruffw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:53PM (#30326037)
The answer to this probably depends on your local jurisdiction, thanks to America's unique system of legal devolvement.

Instead, I'll point out that the answer does not matter: from the moment that they have my hot wallet instead of me, I can no longer use it. It doesn't matter to me whether they can actually liquidate it or not. And, as I pointed out earlier, I'd harm my own case by attempting to liquidate my assets with a separate copy.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by abecedarius on Sunday February 13, 2022 @06:33PM (#30326714)
My main point is the change from presumption of guilt to presumption of innocence. If they are effectively able to freeze it (but not transfer) before the court ruling, that main point still holds. Your claim was that crypto makes no difference, or worse.

I'm not saying technical solutions make the rule of law unnecessary. But they can defend against some violations of the rule of law, depending on the parts of the justice system that are still just.

People effectively defending themselves against a national disgrace help towards getting the disgrace fixed.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by randomhodler84 on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:08PM (#30325702)
Then you missed the point of this whole thing. Some of us would rather die with the keys then let the State steal funds from them. Cryptocurrency is the first technology that lets you take wealth to the grave and keep it there.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by woodruffw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:13PM (#30325734)
Look: if you want to clutch those hashes to the grave, more power to you. I think the Federalist Papers' authors wouldn't know whether to laugh or cry, but that's the wonderful thing about this little American Experiment of ours.

But don't delude yourself into thinking that any meaningful number of people, even cryptocurrency believers, share your position. It's all fun and games until the Men with Sticks show up, and most people understandably tuck tail at that point.

If I'm going to be made a coward in the eyes of a few LARPers, I might as well pay as few middlemen as possible in the process. But that's just me!

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by kyboren on Sunday February 13, 2022 @08:10PM (#30327366)
I think you mean keys, not hashes.

> But don't delude yourself into thinking that any meaningful number of people, even cryptocurrency believers, share your position.

You'd be surprised.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by woodruffw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @08:42PM (#30327543)
> I think you mean keys, not hashes.

Next you're going to tell me that the blockchain isn't made of Lego blocks!

> You'd be surprised.

Given the aggressive spread of custodial services, I don't think I would be. The average cryptocurrency user (even enthusiasts, true believers, &c.) is not a dyed-in-the-wool Burkean. Less prosaically: easy money comes with loose beliefs.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by cjlars on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:34PM (#30325378)
Big difference between manually initiating the transaction and amount vs accidentally signing away everything because of one obscured line of code.
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by amptorn on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:19PM (#30325213)
Can a smart contract make a wire transfer with your knowledge?
Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by fossuser on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:23PM (#30325259)
Yeah the op comment wasn’t made in good faith.

Try getting your money back when getting scammed via venmo or PayPal - rarely any better, and if you’re selling you’re more likely to get scammed with those services than crypto.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by woodruffw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:29PM (#30325311)
I have done multiple clawbacks via payment processors. In each case, I escalated (vendor -> processor -> my bank -> CFPB) until the dispute was resolved to my satisfaction.

In nearly all cases, no separate restitution was required: the processor or my bank was able to reverse or halt the ACH transaction before the money settled. In the handful of cases where settlement had already happened, they were able to countermand the transaction.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by reese_john on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:32PM (#30325890)
Yes but, not sure this is a fair comparison. Doesn't ACH transactions take 1 to 2 business days to settle by design, as they are processed in batch and go through an intermediate clearing house ?

Venmo/PayPal/Fedwire transactions should be able to settle in real time, which can be more convenient at the expense of easy reversability

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by woodruffw on Sunday February 13, 2022 @04:47PM (#30325998)
Venmo and PayPal are, to the best of my knowledge, settled via ACH if you use a bank as your source of funds. That's what I've always done, since it provides the greatest amount of personal control over my transactions.

If you use a payment card (debit or credit) with a payment service, then they might use either the payment card's network or ACH, depending on what the card issuer supports.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by fossuser on Sunday February 13, 2022 @11:07PM (#30328265)
I’ve had a PayPal failure, a PayPal success, an apple pay failure.

It’s definitely not a guarantee. Most of the Venmo type scams where people “accidentally” send you money and ask you to send it back or pay for an item with bad funds are not reclaimable from those services based on TOS. In those cases you’d be better off with BTC.

Re:Social engineering scam that nearly cost me all of my ETH by hollerith on Sunday February 13, 2022 @03:01PM (#30325034)
Brought up over and over again on HN, your point is. Also healthcare in the US is generally not as good as in other developed countries.