News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by ProfessorLayton on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:31PM (#30292046)
As a heavy twitter user who mostly enjoys it (I'm very particular of who I follow), I just don't understand what they've been doing all this time. Their product has been incredibly stagnant for years save for the occasional feature here and there and some styling.

They've screwed over devs trying to build on their APIs and eroded all trust along the way. New features have been rolled out haphazardly, and they totally botched Vine and let TikTok takeover.

Despite all these issues, I like it, but it's increasingly frustrating to use, and can't help but question what's going on inside the company.

Related: Here's how to hide all the crap they've been adding to the timeline

twitter.com##[aria-label="Timeline: Trending now"]

twitter.com##[aria-label="Relevant people"]

twitter.com##[aria-label="Search and explore"]

twitter.com##[aria-label="Footer"]

twitter.com##[aria-label="Who to follow"]

twitter.com##[aria-label="Discover new Lists"]

twitter.com##[aria-label=" liked "]

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by lordnacho on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:43PM (#30292196)
One could argue they filled out their niche. Took the VC money, made the thing global, does what it says on the tin. The world now has a broadcast-short-messages service that can be used by people to reach their audience.

Unfortunately that's not enough, since these tech firms tend to be priced to eat the whole planet, thus requiring a lot more than going global with a little thing that works.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by riffic on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:18PM (#30292725)
> world now has a broadcast-short-messages service

Twitter is a company that has a track record of both user and developer hostility. They shouldn't be this for the world, and they don't need to be either.

I like to say if you're skating where the puck is going to be, you should be skating towards running your own software that speaks ActivityPub.

By you, I don't mean you per se. I mean organizations with budgets who would typically be assigning email accounts and that keep an LDAP directory.

Twitter could even sell a white-labeled version of this and manage it on your behalf on their own servers.

Some of the target organizations may not want to be subject to rules applicable to American corporations. They're free to operate something like this outside those bounds and use an interoperable protocol.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by reaperducer on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:58PM (#30293271)
One could argue they filled out their niche

Between this and Facebook's recent woes, I wish this was a sign of a global tiring of social media in general.

I'm frequently wrong about these things, but one can hope.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by doublepg23 on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:18PM (#30293496)
Wouldn’t TikToks rise be in opposition to that idea?
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by the_other on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:41PM (#30294494)
I don't use TikTok, so I'm probably wrong here.. but isn't TikTok "algorithmically served user generated content" rather than "community" or "social media". As I understand it, it's like a TV station. If there's "dialog", it's in the form of answer-films, rather than actual discussion. If it does behave the way I think it does, then it backs up the idea that social media is on the wane.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by shakezula on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:24PM (#30293570)
It’s not the end of social media, just nearing the end of its first gods.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by Traubenfuchs on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:52PM (#30293882)
TikTok can be considered at least 3rd generation, if FB and Twitter were second and first is MySpace. I am sure one could argue there are more generations. Twitter is not among the first social media god generation.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by klyrs on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:53PM (#30295305)
In my experience, first generation happened on BBSs (contemporaneous with usenet, which wasn't on my radar until it was nearly dead). Then came niche community discussion boards and AOL. Then, Geocities and webrings. Friendster came out a few months earlier than MySpace, but they were close enough to be the same generation. By my count, TikTok is sixth generation? I can't help but feel that I'm missing a few; not even considering my anglocentric experience.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by oldsecondhand on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:50AM (#30298348)
TikTok is just another iteration on Vine. It doesn't seem an upgrade from that just has more money behind it.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by beebmam on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:13PM (#30292650)
They're not even remotely priced at the magnitude to eat the whole planet. And yet, their market IS eating the entire world (except China, due to insular political reasons). That points to me like they're significantly undervalued.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by underwater on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:38PM (#30293011)
What is Twitter's market? They seem increasingly like just another online community. Most of my feed is the same few Twitter influencers with high follower counts. The drama, conventions, and memes all make it feel insular and hostile to outsiders. Feels more like Tumblr than some global, open, platform.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by echelon on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:44PM (#30294530)
Twitter has all of the "smart people" and "money" on it, unlike Reddit, TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, etc.

Billionaires are tweeting each other in the open. Politicians. Reporters. CEOs, CFOs.

No other social network is like that. It's the only thing keeping Twitter relevant.

TikTok and Instagram have their celebrities and trend setters (which is where the ad dollars are), but you don't see anyone musing about "metaverse", "web3", and what their latest fund is going to pursue, geopolitics, OSINT, stocks, etc.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by underwater on Friday February 11, 2022 @03:01AM (#30298445)
I can only generalise from my own experience.

If I go onto "developer Twitter", there is a thriving ecosystem of thought leaders, developers attached to well-known project, etc. If I follow those people I feel like I am a part of a conversation between People Who Matter™.

But if I compare that to my own firsthand knowledge of those same projects and what's happening in the ecosystem, I realise that there is very little overlap between reality and Twitter's projection of reality.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by foepys on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:39AM (#30298261)
I don't believe for a second that anything being tweeted by billionaires, C*Os, and politicians is not approved by some marketing and/or social media department. It's not like people are required to tweet, they choose to tweet.

In the end Twitter is just the illusion of people talking to each other. It's all just to further their brand or to push their goals, not insight they give up for free. Sometimes someone slips up but this just results in even more carefully crafted tweets.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by mschuster91 on Friday February 11, 2022 @03:09AM (#30298517)
In the US, Elon Musk, the 45th and AOC are known to tweet on their own. For the 45th, it was easily discoverable if he tweeted on his own or not by looking on the app ID.

In Germany, health minister Karl Lauterbach, foreign Minister Annalena Charlotte Alma Baerbock (yes, her parents really did name her 1312) as well as a boatload of MPs (most notably Katharina Schulze) also tweet on their own.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by weq on Friday February 11, 2022 @01:05AM (#30297651)
LOL tiktok investors are not a thing?

twitter won; no doubt - but there is no stick or way to money-tise that doesnt not turn into a facebook slow drain gurrgler on your userbase.

this is the conundreum of social enagement based apps. Your a fad, and your only another fad away from history!

GREAT long term investment? NAahhhhh. Traditional PUMP n DUMP stock. Billionaires get made, mom and pops get DESTROYED! Celebs will go wherever the endorsement money is. Life will continue. These apps wont.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by altdataseller on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:57PM (#30294682)
Those topics are only important to you and your bubble though. Not to the vast majority of regular Joes like my mom, grandmothers, people in 3rd world countries, etc.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by ericmay on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:18PM (#30292723)
When you say they are you referring to Twitter specifically or social media/US tech companies in general?

If you mean Twitter specifically I'd be interested in reading your thoughts on the "bull case" for this takeover. I like Twitter and use it to shout into the void from time to time. I wonder if it's just like.. a company and not a growth company? Like what if we just had Twitter with some monetization and then it just paid out dividends to shareholders? Why is that such a bad thing?

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by stjohnswarts on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:12PM (#30294142)
I think the only thing that keeps them afloat is their importance to political figures who LOVE the short form sound bites. Of course that could just be the conspiracist in me :)
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by AniseAbyss on Thursday February 10, 2022 @09:44PM (#30296223)
The average voter prefers to base his/her opinion on a soundbyte. And I don't blame them people have actual lives and loved ones nobody has time to waste on democracy.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by Barrin92 on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:46PM (#30293130)
just because you reach the whole world doesn't necessarily mean there's a good way to monetize it, at least without losing what makes the service attractive.

Sure they could start slapping ads on everything, even paywall the site but at the end of the day there'd be significant competition eroding profits.

Twitter almost makes more sense as an open protocol than a commercial service, which is basically what Mastodon is. It's even what Dorsey wanted to do at one point with Bluesky, not sure if that's still alive.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by mywittyname on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:13PM (#30292644)
Adding to this: it's really hard for Do One Thing Well companies to pivot.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by the_other on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:43PM (#30294507)
Well, they could pivot to a paid-for service without ads and sponsored content. Then we'd see their real value.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by delecti on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:42PM (#30292185)
I'm amused at you questioning what they've been doing all this time, and then giving instructions to avoid seeing what they've been doing all this time.

I don't like those things in my timeline either, but that's your answer. Also those annoying voice chatrooms and their lame attempt at stories.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by zardo on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:19PM (#30294197)
I've noticed big strides in making the site more annoying to use if you aren't logged in.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by colordrops on Thursday February 10, 2022 @09:06PM (#30295917)
True, but these strides are microscopic compared to Reddit.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by meerita on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:39PM (#30292145)
What killed me it was Twitter killing developers apis: no more interesting apps than theirs. It sucks big time. They're also screwing the chronology, sometimes you get the latest tweets (most interesting) and sometimes they switch you to Recommended, which, normally, it sucks. Let me browse chronologically as it was in the old days.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by atorodius on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:42PM (#30292189)
I recently wondered about this, from another angle. In a way it was "weird" that they had an API, given our times. I.e., it was different: imagine if FB/Instagram/WhatsApp had an API. (I think it would be awesome, but it puts into perspective that it was weird that they had one imo)
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by wongarsu on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:01PM (#30292456)
Instagram has an API [1][2], Facebook used to have a decent API back in the days, Reddit still has an excellent API.

But somehow Youtube and Twitter are the only services where I prefer 3rd party clients.

1: https://developers.facebook.com/docs/instagram-api

2: https://developers.facebook.com/docs/instagram-basic-display...

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by masswerk on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:32PM (#30292944)
Back then, free APIs and mashups based on them were the hot thing. (Free geolocation resolvers, Google hat a free search API, Bing as well, FB had one, too, free weather forecasts APIs, etc., etc.) You couldn't be a trendy start-up without providing one. Things have changed a lot since.

PS: I keep a few selected apps from this era on my phone. Once a year I open them and admire them in their data-less beauty. (Favourite one: Partly Clouded) Let's call it software shinto.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by riffraff on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:31PM (#30292917)
It wasn't our times, it was a time when every service provided APIs, and many services provided parsable html to be scraped. The era of "mash ups".

It's incredible how things changed since the 00s.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by ximeng on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:52PM (#30293896)
WhatsApp has an API for $$:

https://www.whatsapp.com/business/api

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by mschuster91 on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:51PM (#30292325)
Facebook actually had APIs which got closed down after a couple of data-mining scandals (first these "quiz" apps and games, then Cambridge Analytica as the final nail in the coffin), and their messenger used to support federation via XMPP. IIRC that got shut down because of spam and scams.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by winternett on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:40PM (#30293054)
Now devs and social engineers are using FaceBook groups to covertly gather intel... I joined a local development (to my home) group and found out after answering development questions people posted that I was suddenly getting a lot of recruiter calls out of nowhere. Facebook apparently exposes contact info in the process, or perhaps the engineers cross-reference other sites as well. It makes the job easy for scammers too.

The convoluted ways in which people are gathering info on individuals is rampant in many Facebutt groups... There is way too much unsolicited spam and it grows every time I use an app or social site.

Makes me not want to log in at all a lot.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by ceejayoz on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:11PM (#30292608)
Facebook still has APIs, there's just a bunch of attestations and app reviews before you get access to them now. Some of them have been neutered, like friends' lists and whatnot, but there's a lot they still do.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by nradov on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:13PM (#30292637)
Is it viable for advertising supported services to have a fully functional API? Some third-party developer will build an alternative client app with no ads and eliminate the revenue stream.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by vkou on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:19PM (#30292744)
And they'll get their API keys revoked.

Just because you have an API doesn't mean you're going to allow anyone and everyone to use it how they want.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by jrochkind1 on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:17PM (#30292715)
Facebook used to have an API (that was useable to do interesting things).
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by winternett on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:35PM (#30292985)
Chronological posts were the one thing making tools like twitter useful. The ideal that you could follow someone and see their minute-to-minute thoughts was refreshing.

In the age of bots and schedules posts, fake accounts and marginal content/reposts are rampant. Twitter to me now feels like a "dead body" repost zone where the only thing that grabs attention are snuff clips and pr0n.

Their overhead from all the volume is probably stratospheric, and they're scrambling to stop the hemorrhage of expenses over innovating now, so it's probably gonna take an entirely different platform to recapture the classic dynamic that Twitter once had.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by charcircuit on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:13PM (#30292638)
Chronological is worse since you will see a bunch meaningless tweets from people. It's better if twitter can show me the important tweets that I've missed since I last used it.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by bern4444 on Friday February 11, 2022 @12:07AM (#30297233)
Twitter's redone all their APIs and made it easier to get initial access more quickly. Have you looked at it recently?

https://developer.twitter.com/en/docs/twitter-api/getting-st...

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by pphysch on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:51PM (#30292327)
Twitter like all mass social media is competing for quantity of user not quality of user. Because their product is the user: behavioral analytics & advertising.

If you're gonna use Twitter anyways, Twitter has zero incentive to make it a more productive tool for you (in fact they want to be slightly less productive so you spend more time on it). Due to network effects, they are not worried about competitors shipping a better product.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by charcircuit on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:16PM (#30292684)
>Twitter like all mass social media is competing for quantity of user not quality of user.

Then why do they ban low quality users such as bots or users who have broken their rules?

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by dageshi on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:47PM (#30293147)
Their advertiser don't want to advertise to bots and the users who break the rules potentially cause a pile of bad publicity for them so they're happy to get rid of them.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by charcircuit on Thursday February 10, 2022 @08:56PM (#30295833)
Those are examples of twitter preferring quality over quantity.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by Kye on Thursday February 10, 2022 @11:27PM (#30296967)
There are plenty of low-quality tweeters who know how to ride the line and not cause Twitter PR problems.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by pphysch on Friday February 11, 2022 @02:13PM (#30305735)
Come on. Human users is implied.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by ARandomerDude on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:59PM (#30292420)
> I just don't understand what they've been doing all this time.

There was that one time in 2017 when they increased the character limit.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by winternett on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:29PM (#30292893)
They've actually screwed up the very basis that made it useful though, they reduced control over what users can elect to see, they've completely wrecked real time timelines, and they are covertly ratio-ing user accounts so that even their subscribers see posts later than they are completed or even in many cases not at all, and now they're marketing to users (main contributors to all the platform's content) to pay in order to boost their posts... The whole business model is like telling people they can ride electricity generating stationary bikes in order to charge up teslas for the wealthy.

I've never seen any other tool as productive as it boched terribly... Facebook was never really as useful for real time news and events in nature (mind you).

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by timmg on Thursday February 10, 2022 @07:42PM (#30295202)
> I just don't understand what they've been doing all this time.

They added NFT profile pics. What more do you want?

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by tshaddox on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:21PM (#30292778)
What they’ve been doing is tons and tons and incomprehensibly many tons of work on targeting and selling advertisements.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by riffraff on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:28PM (#30292879)
Based on the ads I see in my timeline, they didn't do a great job at that. I have used the service for many many years and I have literally never seen any ad that I wanted to click.

Maybe they do better for the US, but they seem to have done far worse than their competitors in ad space.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by cpeterso on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:45PM (#30293117)
I've used Twitter for almost 13 years (!!) and its ads are barely relevant to me. An example of Twitter missing the mark: my Twitter mute list includes a bunch of cryptocurrency keywords and yet Twitter still shows me cryptocurrency ads that include those muted words. I've explicitly told Twitter that I'm not interested in cryptocurrency, but they show the ads anyway. Perhaps Twitter still considers me in the target audience because I've proven that I what cryptocurrency is by muting those keywords.

In contrast, I joined Instagram just last year and use it very little, but its ads are much more (sometimes almost scarily) relevant to me. My wife is a big Instagram user, so perhaps Instagram has a shadow profile for our home IP address and I'm seeing ads personalized based on her activity (and thus peripherally relevant to me).

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by atlantas on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:15PM (#30292674)
Thanks, that's useful.

What I don't get about twitter as a company: Why do they have so many employees? If they scaled back they could have a nice business as it is.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by tshaddox on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:24PM (#30292818)
The goto answer for this is that they have the number of employees they have because they deemed each new employee to provide more value than they cost to employee. That’s their goal. Their goal is not to have the minimal number of people required to run some very simplistic description of their company. They would employee a thousand milk delivery people if they thought each one would provide more value than their cost to employee.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by 8note on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:23PM (#30293557)
Alternatively, the cost of hiring the employee is lower than the cost of letting a competitor hire them
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by deepsun on Thursday February 10, 2022 @03:40PM (#30292161)
Do they need to do anything? The product just works, pays their bills, why should everyone jump off pants trying to squeeze as much money from their product as possible?
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by j1elo on Thursday February 10, 2022 @08:41PM (#30295702)
For me (different language, if it makes a difference), the "Discover new Lists" was interesting but didn't work because just that one doesn't have an aria-label. Instead, it's just a series of divs placed consecutively in the Lists page, each containing a span inside, with the header and the suggested lists.

I found it a nice challenge to learn a bit about selectors and uBlock Origin filter rules, and got this working, for anyone who might care:

twitter.com##span:has-text(Discover new Lists):upward(6) > :nth-child(n+5):nth-child(-n+11)

PS. also a nice tip: you can use the uBlock's "element picker mode" and write your filter starting from the "##" (i.e. leave the domain name out), and that will provide immediate visual feedback of the affected area, without having to reload the page. Neat!

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by tootie on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:01PM (#30292464)
I honestly don't get it. My company gets a lot of traffic from Twitter apparently so I signed up to get some perspective. I mostly follow journalists and publications as well as some business and tech folks I like. I see so many context-free messages of people arguing about topics I'm out of the loop on or posting links to news I already saw in a better aggregator. Maybe once or twice a week do I see an interesting bit of insight but it's drowning in an ocean of gibberish. And as far as I can tell that's the entire premise of the platform.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by sergiotapia on Thursday February 10, 2022 @08:58PM (#30295856)
Thank you, here's how you can add these custom rules to Brave since it comes with a built-in adblocker.

https://sergiotapia.com/how-to-use-custom-adblock-rules-in-b...

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by elcapitan on Thursday February 10, 2022 @05:57PM (#30293962)
Do these ublock rules still work? At least in my web ui, most css classes and IDs seem to be randomized now..
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by ProfessorLayton on Thursday February 10, 2022 @06:41PM (#30294498)
They do. Twitter's randomized css means the filters need to be based on something else like aria tags rather than css. Going after these means twitter will have to decide between blocking adblock or... Screen readers.

It's unfortunate that these tags need to be leveraged outside of their intended purpose to make their product more usable, but here we are.

Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by elcapitan on Friday February 11, 2022 @05:49AM (#30299863)
Thanks!
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by znep on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:21PM (#30292770)
...and almost every time I end up on a mobile link to a tweet in a web browser I have to refresh the page to get anything but an error. Which has been going on for years, or at least seems like it.
Re:Twitter misses ad revenue and user growth estimates by kawsper on Thursday February 10, 2022 @04:23PM (#30292801)
You also can't right click their trending widget to open in a new tab.