News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by tjansen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:50AM (#30126701)
The 10% is not as bad as it sounds, because the author fails to mention that these statistics are heavily in favour of expensive cars with a good dealership network. And Tesla has no dealerships at all, as far as I know.

When you own something like a BMW, you typically don't drive the car to the inspection yourself. Especially not if it's a leased or company car. Instead, you bring your car to the dealership (or they will pick it up), they inspect the car, fix any issues they encounter and only then bring in an official inspector for the actual inspection. This way, the inspector will hardly find any issues. Also, dealerships typically don't chose TÜV, but one of their competitors that do the inspection at the dealership.

TÜV is where people go who want to save money by skipping the dealership. Most people who do this drive cheaper cars. That's why cheap cars are always having much worse numbers in these statistics. They are alternative statistics, like ADAC's (Germany's equivalent to AAA), but they all have the same problem. There are no good statistics for German cars. They all favour expensive German brands because those who the statistics will never see a broken car. The dealerships will always take care of that. I'd rather trust US-based Consumer Reports than TÜV or ADAC statistics.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by throwawayt215 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:51AM (#30127251)
Well, here you go:

"Tesla ranks almost dead-last on Consumer Reports reliability list" - Nov 2021

https://www.sfgate.com/tech/article/Tesla-ranks-almost-dead-...

HN discussion:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29273140

Another test from Belgium from a few weeks ago where Tesla came last:

https://www.test-aankoop.be/mobiliteit/auto-s/nieuws/enquete...

Translation of title and adjacent:

"Tesla is the least reliable car brand. Owners of a Tesla report problems with their car more often than drivers of other brands. Those looking to take advantage of salon conditions in the coming weeks had better grab our ranking of most reliable car brands."

So it's TÜV, Consumer Reports and Test Aankoop where Tesla scores poorly, and they are all very recent.

Edit: "Test Aankoop is an association that informs, defends and represents consumers in Belgium. We work in complete independence, financially, politically and ideologically." - translated

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by frevib on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:14PM (#30128081)
And for the Dutch TÜV (Consumentenbond) Tesla also ranks last. The only brand that scores under the usual “pass” rate at 5,5/10

https://www.consumentenbond.nl/test/auto-fiets-reizen/automa...

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by optimog on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:05AM (#30127382)
The graph of Test Aankoop also gives numbers on overall owner hapiness. Even while being last in terms of reliability, it scores 2nd in terms of overall hapiness (right after Porsche). So it must not be that bad, right?
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:34AM (#30127661)
> So it must not be that bad, right?

Not really. Could be the case that if you're in the 90ish percent that has no problems, you love your car, but if you're in the 10% bucket you're screwed.

Similar analogy: I love JetBlue, when there aren't any problems. Wider seat pitch, better entertainment system, good value. When there are problems though, it's a nightmare. Once my flight was cancelled due to "weather" (mind you it was a beautiful sunny day, and I counted one other cancelled flight on the entire airport departure board). JetBlue said they could get me on a flight 3 days later, and gave 0 assistance getting on another airline because they don't have any of the "peering" relationships other airlines have. All they did was refund my money the day of, and no compensation because it was for "weather".

This jives generally with what I've heard about Teslas: people fanatically love the cars, except when autopilot steers you into a truck or a concrete divider.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by ok123456 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:03PM (#30127959)
>This jives generally with what I've heard about Teslas: people fanatically love the cars, except when autopilot steers you into a truck or a concrete divider.

Now that's what I call "survivor bias."

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by 11thEarlOfMar on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:22AM (#30127570)
It's always an 'on balance' determination vis a vie what owners care about.

Yes, not everything fits right in my 2018 Model 3. The right headlight is not flush with the hood. You can hear that the windows aren't secured when rolled down and you close the door.

Everything else is brilliant. 95k miles in, I've had zero drive train or mechanical issues. Three sets of tires and an underbody shield that tore when I hit 6" of standing water at 70mph. Conversely, the punch when you hit the accelerator is exhilarating, takes curves flat and fast, the sound system is excellent, it's so quiet, I can drive for hours without physical discomfort, the seat material is durable and doesn't scuff or fade.

I drove a 328i for 20 years that I loved dearly. I haven't given it a 2nd thought since buying the Tesla.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by cogman10 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:42AM (#30127749)
As a fellow 2018 Model 3 owner (70k miles), I concur.

If you look at the reasons CR gave them a low score, it's fit and finish + the HVAC system (which have seen some pretty drastic changes since our vehicles in 2018).

My experience, brand new the condenser pump was too close to the frame (causing a knocking sound). A mobile tech came out, added a rubber pad, and it's been perfect ever since.

When I read the consumer report article listing panel alignment as a reliability issue, I'm suspect. I'm not trying to ignore the fact that it's pretty terrible for tesla to pay so little attention to these things, especially at the price, at at the same time the issues these cars have are generally both cheap/free to repair (especially since they are often caught at the point of sale) and then done for the life of the car.

Side note: My prior car, a ford edge, was WAY worse in reliability towards it's EOL (130k). By the time it got there, the fan belt had cut through the brake line (Um, wtf?), the brake master cylinder had sprung a leak, the alternator went out, the battery died, and the transmission was on it's way out, the HVAC failed and the compressor needed to be replaced. All fairly spendy repairs from regular operations. That's not to mention the regular oil/fluid changes, brake changes, and new tires.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by throwawayt215 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @02:12PM (#30129393)
Have you tried test driving some recent electric cars by other big car manufacturers?
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by 11thEarlOfMar on Saturday January 29, 2022 @02:45PM (#30129704)
No, but I'd like to. Which do you suggest?
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by 2III7 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @03:36PM (#30130131)
Hyundai IONIQ 5, VW ID3. The fit and finish are from another world compared to a Tesla. And they're probably more reliable too, but time will tell.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by throwawayt215 on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:42AM (#30134422)
Hyundai IONIQ 5

Volkswagen ID.3 and ID.4

Ford Mustang Mach-E

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by hiptobecubic on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:21AM (#30127558)
Great if it works, but likely not to work.

To me that suggests Tesla makes a cars for people who don't need a car, just want one.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by cogman10 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:45AM (#30127779)
Scratch a little deeper into the reasons CR gave it a low ranking. Panel alignment and HVAC system problems.

Both of those things are pretty fixable after purchase and are (generally speaking) one and done problems.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by pandaman on Sunday January 30, 2022 @01:35AM (#30134653)
Are you talking about all Teslas or some particular model? I am looking into the current Model X and it seems to have more problems than HVAC and panel alignment. Even the most reliable in their ratings Model 3 has dings for "body integrity" (which apparently stands for squeaks, rattles, wind noise and broken seals), "body hardware" (latches, locks, power windows etc) and "power equipment" (all small moving and illuminating stuff, probably wipers in this case) on top of the "paint/trim" and HVAC you mentioned (unless you meant panel alignment to be the body integrity issue then you get paint/trim issues).
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by halfmatthalfcat on Saturday January 29, 2022 @02:19PM (#30129479)
Not sure how you can claim likely. “Potentially” may be more apt.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by jorvi on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:47AM (#30127799)
Probably the halo effect of ‘doing good’ by driving an EV. It’s like when people choose to use the bank with a less slick app, website, local offices etc but that does ethical banking. The service is objectively worse, but those users probably rate their overal happiness with the bank very high.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by samcheng on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:19PM (#30128137)
The driving experience in an EV is objectively better, on the whole, than a gas car. The climate factor doesn't weigh into the driving experience. It's the instant torque, the always-full-in-the-morning home charging, the lack of smell and noise, the easy maintenance, and (in the case of Tesla) the in-car computing environment.

It's not about the "smug" or "halo" factor. If it were, why would so many people be lining up to buy the electric F-150?

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by jorvi on Sunday January 30, 2022 @08:21AM (#30136947)
That ‘objectively better driving experience’ rates almost dead last in reliability. Charging can be a negative as well, if your ‘tank’ is nearly empty it’s a 2 minute top-up with gas but a 30-60 minute wait with a BEV. You are not allowed to do maintenance on your Tesla, everything is locked down.

You are literally the “smug” you are protesting. And I say all these things as a guy that wants all cars to become BEV as soon as possible (well, I’d rather have public transit be prioritized, but people are egotistical and shitty).

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by samcheng on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:30AM (#30145198)
The point is that people aren't buying EVs because of feel-good environmental sentiment. They are buying them because the cars fit well into their lifestyle.

Apologies if I came off as smug!

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by anamexis on Saturday January 29, 2022 @02:28PM (#30129555)
How many orders of magnitude more people are buying gas F-150s?
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by samcheng on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:37AM (#30144935)
Looks like about 5X (half an order of magnitude) in Ford's forecasting:

150,000 production target electric ~750,000 sales F-series 2021

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by daliusd on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:19AM (#30127527)
As far as I know Porsche is not bought because of reliability. At least I never heard anyone saying that :)
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by kohlerm on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:30PM (#30128289)
They are potentially. If your "problem" is to decide between a Ferrari and a Porsche, you might go for Porsche because of reliability.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by anamexis on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:26AM (#30127592)
I wouldn't assume happiness correlates with reliability.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by kjksf on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:59AM (#30127925)
So do you assume that people whose car breaks down often are as happy with the car as the people whose car doesn't break down often?
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by anamexis on Saturday January 29, 2022 @02:27PM (#30129541)
Sure, could be. I could imagine that as cars get more expensive, "happiness" with a car comes more from the satisfaction of owning a luxurious car and less from its reliability. I would imagine that someone who owns a Lamborghini is happy about it, but they are anything but reliable. On the flip side, reliability is kind of the point when you buy a Toyota.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by actuallyalys on Saturday January 29, 2022 @04:06PM (#30130454)
It certainly seems to be the case that reliability isn't that bad for the typical owner. Of course, if more people than the initial enthusiastic buyers start driving Teslas, the satisfaction might decline.

FWIW, I did a quick calculation and satisfaction and reliability aren't really correlated (coefficient of 0.17). Fiddling with a few other models didn't find much more of a connection.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by causality0 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:16PM (#30128109)
Tesla is sort of the real world version of that old "why don't we build cars like we build computers" joke from the 90s.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by Elora on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:47AM (#30127800)
> "Tesla ranks almost dead-last on Consumer Reports reliability list"

I find this laughable. We're on our 3rd Tesla and we've never had anything even hinting of a reliability issue/getting stranded. There is absolutely no maintenance outside of consumables, which is really just tires, as the brake pads last the life of the car if you drive it as it's meant to be driven (regen); maybe windshield washer fluid? There've been a small number of minor things, like a seat belt tensioner on one of the three started rattling. They came and fixed it in my garage. 12V battery was on its way out on our oldest Tesla, car gave a message ahead of it dying (so, proactively avoided leaving us stranded by using software to interpret collected measurements), Tesla came and replaced it in my garage in 10 min for free. New cars are supposed to get Li-Ion 12V batteries soon standard, so the company is purposefully improving reliability. (Note: yes, Teslas have a 12V battery for auxiliary/emergency power, i.e. in case you run the EV battery all the way down you can still operate door locks etc).

Just doesn't add up calling cars that are known to intrinsically be super low maintenance and have much lower part count/complexity unreliable. Everyone I know who drives a Tesla has the same experience: zero maintenance, replace tires every 30-40k miles or when you get a flat and that's pretty much it. One of the main reasons I highly prefer EVs is because of reliability and lack of maintenance. Something seems fishy here.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by apexalpha on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:30PM (#30128290)
You're already on your 3rd Tesla in 10 years?

Besides that, it's still anecdotal. There's a whole array of issues with Tesla's Quality.

Now that they got some competition in the top segment they dropped to only 25,000 Tesla S/Y delivered last year. They need to seriously improve their quality control if they don't want to be wiped out in the mid segment too.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by gpapilion on Saturday January 29, 2022 @03:19PM (#30129985)
So California expires car pool stickers that let you use the hov lane after 4 years. The only way you can get a new one is to buy a new car. (I believe they are phasing the program out). It probably explains why the commenter has 3 in 10 years.

The internet is to create a robust market for electric cars. The complaint is that it favors rich consumers.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by TomVDB on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:04PM (#30127972)
The suspension arm of my colleague’s Tesla broke. He showed me the broken part. It was something that should never break.

My other colleague’s Tesla had multiple major issues, including one that requires an engine to be replaced.

They both still bought a new Tesla after that, and so did I, because they’re just so fun to drive, but your anecdotal evidence doesn’t disprove a fact about a 10% failure rate.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by judge2020 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:35PM (#30128347)
I imagine you mean motor instead of "engine".
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by fma on Saturday January 29, 2022 @05:42PM (#30131336)
You're on your 3rd Tesla? My parents still have their 2001 Camry and I still have my 2006 Corolla.

3rd Tesla in what, 10 years? is nothing to brag about...actually - to use your words, I find this laughable that somehow you think you've pushed your Teslas enough to see any hint of reliability issues.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by amluto on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:24PM (#30128200)
My Tesla disagrees with your Tesla.

Also, when something breaks, you have to put up with Tesla’s abysmal service and the black hole that is their customer support.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by pengaru on Saturday January 29, 2022 @03:24PM (#30130038)
> I find this laughable. We're on our 3rd Tesla...

Maybe if you didn't treat your vehicles as disposables you'd experience more of the wear and reliability problems?

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by pandaman on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:28PM (#30131714)
It could be that the lack of maintenance is the issue. When I take my car to the dealer for an oil change it goes on a lift and gets looked over by a mechanic (I get a video of this, so this is how I know). Tesla it not a magic carpet, it has the same suspension, brakes, tires etc. as a normal car. How often a regular Tesla gets lifted and its undercarriage is looked over? Perhaps not as often as every 10K miles when an oil change happens on my car?

And a Lithium 12V battery is not more reliable than a regular acid-lead. You can get an aftermarket one for any ICE car and some come with it as standard. It's only good in a warm climate though because in cold weather it will lose charge quickly unlike an acid-lead.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by mgraupner on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:34PM (#30128339)
Perhaps driving 155mph or up to 200mph (max speeds of the various Model S) as it is possible in Germany puts another level of stress on the suspension and they start to fail prematurely. Maintenance is not the same as reliability. So not laughable at all.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by SpelingBeeChamp on Saturday January 29, 2022 @01:24PM (#30128883)
As far as I know, no one has driven anywhere close to 200 mph in a Tesla.

https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a38453459/tesla-model-s-pl...

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by mgraupner on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:56PM (#30139372)
Thank you for the information, I was just looking up the max speeds in Wikipedia.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by Xylakant on Saturday January 29, 2022 @03:30PM (#30130078)
Fun bit of history: When Buell started selling their motorbikes in Germany, the motorcycles didn’t survive being driven large stretches on the autobahn - which lead to the famous recall party in Oschersleben where some of the factory team flew in from the US to fix and upgrade Buell motorcycles.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by solarkraft on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:42PM (#30128426)
Where do you live? I have the suspicion that the experiences vary mostly by region, where the bay area and other big american areas have relatively good service, but other areas are considerably worse.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by chemmail on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:30AM (#30134353)
Once you say Consumer Reports, you throw all credibility out the window. I read some of their "reports" sometimes in my fields of expertise. Basically they have absolutely no idea what they are talking about. Being biased is one thing, incompetency is another.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by throwawayt215 on Sunday January 30, 2022 @01:28AM (#30134623)
Say more?
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by namdnay on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:10AM (#30127426)
careful, "reliability" can mean a lot of things - having interior trim issues is not the same as DPF problems or ABS lockup
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by therouwboat on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:34AM (#30127663)
They are not considered equally serious. Engine, transmission and drive system problems have more weight than something like broken trim.

https://www.consumerreports.org/car-reliability-owner-satisf...

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by tjoff on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:01AM (#30126787)
That doesn't make 10% not bad. But lets exclude expensive cars. How come Tesla is worse than cheap cars then?

> The worst by far, however, was the Tesla Model S. 10.7 percent of the model showed up for testing with a defect of some sort. Not only was this the worst EV in the study, the Model S placed third-to-last out of all cars, including ICE vehicles, only besting the Dacia Logan and Dacia Duster.

But even so, another huge factor is how expensive it is to fix the typical errors. Is it $5 in parts and 2 minutes you can do yourself or $1000 and two days at a shop?

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by namdnay on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:13AM (#30127447)
What's strange is that Dacias are extremely reliable. They're built with 10-15 year old Renault components, which means they'll never be cutting edge, but they have great hindsight on what is reliable and what isn't
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by paganel on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:22PM (#30128180)
> What's strange is that Dacias are extremely reliable.

I'm Romanian and I was very surprised seeing this chart because, yes, relatively speaking they are pretty reliable. I think this part of OP's comment explains it best why that happened:

> TÜV is where people go who want to save money by skipping the dealership. Most people who do this drive cheaper cars. That's why cheap cars are always having much worse numbers in these statistics.

As Dacia are some of the cheapest models on the market that would explain this chart.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by rightbyte on Saturday January 29, 2022 @01:00PM (#30128614)
I guess people that buy Dacia cheap out on service of it at a greater degree than other brands.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by johannes1234321 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:28AM (#30127614)
> How come Tesla is worse than cheap cars then?

A primary point of complaint in the report are the breaks. In an electrical vehicle most of the time you break by using the engine as generator instead of using the breaking pads. Since they aren't used they corrode. In a cheap Dacia you don't have that luxury.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by hutzlibu on Saturday January 29, 2022 @03:33PM (#30130114)
"TÜV is where people go who want to save money by skipping the dealership."

I would just add, that most normal car repair stations offer that service, too. Meaning your repair guy takes your car in, checks and fixes everything - and takes it to the TÜV.

(and often they know the TÜV guy quite well, so also in germany there quite some cars with substandard safety)

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by hiptobecubic on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:24AM (#30127584)
YouTube complainers seem to think that it's more like six weeks in the shop. They post recordings of service calls where Tesla says things like, "Sorry the parts are not available. Tesla's priority is making new cars, not service and repairs," which is pretty shocking to hear.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:06AM (#30127388)
> But even so, another huge factor is how expensive it is to fix the typical errors. Is it $5 in parts and 2 minutes you can do yourself or $1000 and two days at a shop?

It could be that their first aid kit is out of compliance, those tests are really strict about things like that.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by tjansen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:12AM (#30126896)
> That doesn't make 10% not bad. But lets exclude expensive cars. How come Tesla is worse than cheap cars then?

Even when you buy a brand new cheap car, like a Dacia, you typically go to your dealership for inspections in the first couple of years. The percentage of owners who do this is certainly lower than for the premium brands, but still much higher than for Tesla if Tesla doesn't have any dealerships that offer the HU+AU inspections (that's what they are called).

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by cycomanic on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:09AM (#30127413)
In other words Tesla with their expensive cars doesn't even offer the service that even the cheapest other manufacturers offer. So they essentially push the onto their customers
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by microtherion on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:29AM (#30127053)
It's all a matter of picking the right peer group. If you compare the Tesla only against the Dacia, it would be the most reliable car in Romania!
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by adolph on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:18AM (#30127504)
In Soviet Russia, the car was not inspected, you were!

(In the year 2035, most other nations are similar since social creditworthiness is part of car inspection.)

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by HarryHirsch on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:59AM (#30126775)
Tesla is a luxury brand, yet one out of ten Teslas manages to show up with suspension problems at the 3-year roadworthiness inspection. That's quite something - one would think that the suspension is a solved problem, cars have has suspensions for over 100 years, coaches before that. That's just another symptom of appalling quality control.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by smileysteve on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:11AM (#30126879)
> a solved problem, cars have has suspensions for over 100 years

The Ford mustang and Cadillac escalade have adopted rear independent suspension for the first time in the last 5 years.

Coaches and cars until the 80s mostly used leaf springs. Solid rear differentials and leaf springs are still common in trucks.

Tesla's have adjustable height, adjustable response, and 4 wheel independent suspension.

Other innovations in the last 50 years include aluminium, passive rear stearing, disc brakes, all wheel coilovers.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by mikestew on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:36AM (#30127675)
Tesla's have adjustable height, adjustable response, and 4 wheel independent suspension.

None of which are new to production cars. Off the top of my head, Lincoln and Mercedes are two brands that had such features when I worked on them…back in the 80s (though forward-looking adjustment might be more recent, I seem to recall Lincoln had a system that would adjust the rear on-the-fly based on what the front suspension was doing).

So if the implication is Tesla’s on the cutting edge or something, I would bet Tesla could have purchased off-the-shelf parts, and had a choice in vendors, to build their suspension.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by KaiserPro on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:42AM (#30127748)
> The Ford mustang and Cadillac escalade have adopted rear independent suspension for the first time in the last 5 years.

Those are rare outside of the USA for a reason.

> Tesla's have adjustable height, adjustable response, and 4 wheel independent suspension.

Which were pioneered by Citroen. Who ironically arn't know for reliability, but we can surmise from this report that even Citroen are more reliable than a tesla.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by tagoregrtst on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:23AM (#30127573)
The technology has existed for the better part of 100 years now, and only myopic number crunchers who drove American car manufacturers to the ground kept the suspension from going into the mustang.

However, the Escalade should probably still have leaf suspensions. Its a bloody truck!

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by brianwawok on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:15AM (#30126918)
Adjustable height air suspension is only in new Teslas, and only specific models. Most cars hitting the 3 year inspection would not have that feature yet. I think older S had a more traditional suspension.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by aeyes on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:27AM (#30127028)
First generation Model S already had air suspension.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by arpinum on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:23AM (#30126994)
Author lumped together suspension and headlight problems, we do not know the split between these two issues, but they carry vastly different consequences
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by xxs on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:27AM (#30127032)
Headlights in 3years? There is no reason anything to happen to properly driven LEDs in 3y. That's junior level of engineering.

In that regard I'd expect suspension issues to dominate in the category.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by snypher on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:41AM (#30127164)
In contrast, there shouldn't be anything in a suspension system failing after three years. Perhaps they inspect for a torn boot, but I wouldn't expect cracks in castings or sheared fasteners.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by geoduck14 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:50AM (#30127843)
>Headlights in 3years? There is no reason anything to happen to properly driven LEDs in 3y. That's junior level of engineering.

That's a bit of a exaggeration, plenty can go wrong with LED headlights.

A single bad solder might knock out a bank of LEDs. Bad weather stripping can let water in and short something out. You can hit a bump and knock a connection loose.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by lttlrck on Saturday January 29, 2022 @01:29PM (#30128934)
All those things sound like basic engineering or QC issues.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by benjamir on Saturday January 29, 2022 @02:58PM (#30129796)
Nope. Mercedes C class models from the 201x years regularly use a lot of lamps. Nobody seems to now why.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by lottospm on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:54AM (#30127883)
They'll also fail you for improperly adjusted headlights, beam pattern and such. I bet the lights are blinding oncoming traffic because they "self-adjusted" or automatic leveling software somehow fails.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by xxs on Saturday January 29, 2022 @03:58PM (#30130369)
>I bet the lights are blinding oncoming traffic because they "self-adjusted"

That would be quite hilarious, of course if it was not dangerous. It's hard to imagine how they would not switch off the "high beams", if it was lit enough.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by xiphias2 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:12AM (#30126892)
I bet you people were going fast with Teslas on not perfect roads. I have been doing that as well with my BMW, and the huge potholes that I don't always see made lots of damage to my suspension that I didn't have with slower cars.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by robbiep on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:06PM (#30127992)
The great thing when you’re talking statistics is you can basically average over all cars, although not being German there are some interesting points being raised in here about who takes their car where for their registration check. Regardless, the underlying assumption is that a similar proportion of all vehicles arrives at the servicing centre and STILL Tesla is failed at a ~10% rate, so, underlying assumption being similar driving habits (which you have to have) your comment doesn’t compute
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by cycomanic on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:13AM (#30127452)
In Germany?
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by ranieuwe on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:03PM (#30127965)
Not all German roads are perfect. Plenty of high way that’s a bit bumpy (although they are fixing it). Especially after the snow and ice periods.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by cycomanic on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:15PM (#30128099)
I know, but potholes that damage your suspension? Maybe if you're driving 400 in your bugatti.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by davrosthedalek on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:39AM (#30134402)
Believe me, compared to a typical US street, German streets are perfect. I have seen potholes here a SMART can drive in, and then out....
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by arghwhat on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:08AM (#30126851)
Suspension parts wear out, and something as simple as worn out rubber bushings will fail inspection.

3 years is quite short, but being a "solved problem" does not mean that no service is required. Nothing is permanent.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by vlozko on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:26AM (#30127022)
3 years lifespan for suspension is unacceptably and inexcusably short. No one is asking for parts immune from wear and tear but people should be able to expect at least a status quo.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by epistasis on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:40AM (#30127157)
The one BMW I had was in the shop for a week to fix the rear brake lights, at only 12 or 15 months old.

The idea that luxury brands do not have problems is not something I have ever seen evidenced by owners. Some luxury brands are know for needing continual repairs.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by sudosysgen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:44AM (#30127184)
That's an anecdote you're comparing to a statistic. Of course anything can have manufacturing defects, but a 10% failure rate is not that.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by mrybczyn on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:07AM (#30127393)
Anecdotes of appaling BMW reliability are so prevalent in the online enthusiast car communities, and shade tree mechanic workarounds are so well doumented, that I would question any statistics measuring otherwise. Lies, damned lies, and statistics...
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by epistasis on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:50AM (#30127237)
The opinion of luxury equaling low repair rate is simply not anything I've ever heard before. Are you staying that it is? I added an anecdote with my personal experience, but an anecdote neither proves a point nor refutes it.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by tjansen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:03AM (#30126804)
Certainly true, but when German brands have similar issues, it will never show in the statistics. A 10% fail-rate would bother me if I bought a Tesla, but I know that there were German cars with extreme reliability issues that never showed up in statistics. Like VWs and Audis with early DSG transmissions. Car forums were full with people who experienced it, and I personally know people whose cars had these issues.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by mgraupner on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:00AM (#30127322)
TÜV is not about general car defects or problems like failing transmissions or the infamous camshaft chain failure of VW engines. TÜV is about failures of your car which prevents it from secure operation like failing head lamps, suspession problems and so on.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by tjansen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:40AM (#30127718)
Yes, but ADAC statistics include failures and suffer from the same issues. If a three year old BMW breaks down, most owners will call BMW, not the ADAC. (And some car brands will actually send the ADAC to help you, but they have contracts to make sure it won’t appear in the official ADAC statistics)
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by mgraupner on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:01PM (#30127940)
Yeah, they are very different statistics. TÜV checks if your car is safe to drive on roads, and everybode is obligated to do so every second year (except the first one which is after 3 years). I don't know what ADAC is counting, broken cars on highways probably. :)
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by HarryHirsch on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:16AM (#30126936)
It's the suspension bit that's worrying. When the excessively complex transmission fails you have the vehicle towed to the shop, but the suspension is a safety issue (and you do wonder - if 10 % showed up at the inspection with problems how many owners had their suspension fixed because the car handled funny).
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Sunday January 30, 2022 @02:53AM (#30134964)
Maybe it's because Tesla is heavy.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by mgraupner on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:31AM (#30127642)
As a German I can't attest most of the stuff you wrote.

You go to TÜV directly when you know/think that your car won´t fail the inspection. Otherwise you bring it to the dealership or an independent garage beforehand (in case of the Tesla or if you want so save money). They will fix the stuff for you and then introduce it to inspection. No matter if you drive a BMW, Dacia or Tesla. And TÜV is not cheaper, they want more or less all the same amount of money.

These statistics of TÜV are not about broken cars, it's about road safety. Broken head lamps, failing breaks, rubbers at suspension is brittle, .... These kind of things. And yes, most(not all) German cars won't fail at these things in the first five or so years. And yes, there were cars with bad transmission (DSG), failing engines and so on, but these problems are not counted in the TÜV statistics.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by nautilius on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:09AM (#30126857)
Maybe you missed this part: "Model S placed third-to-last out of all cars, including ICE vehicles, only besting the Dacia Logan and Dacia Duster." I.e., it is not only (seemingly?) worse than expensive cars, but also scores at the bottom of cheap and budget cars. The only cars worse are the cheap Romanian Dacia rebrands of Renault cars.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by namdnay on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:15AM (#30127478)
That's what surprised me the most in this report - Dacias have a great reputation for reliability! They've got the benefit of 10 years' hindsight on the Renault parts bin. I wonder if there aren't other factors at work (e.g. people driving the cheapest possible cars aren't bringing them in for regular dealer maintenance?)
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by benjamir on Saturday January 29, 2022 @03:06PM (#30129863)
There is no benefit using 10 year old Renault parts.

What sucked 10years ago doesn't become better over time.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by namdnay on Sunday January 30, 2022 @02:41AM (#30134908)
Yes there is, because you already have hindsight on what will break often and what won’t. Dacia have the luxury of being able to take the reliable stuff and drop the unreliable stuff
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by nautilius on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:28AM (#30127608)
Like Teslas? ;-)
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by tjansen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:17AM (#30126940)
If Tesla has no dealerships that offer HU+AU inspections, almost 100% of all Teslas will go to the TÜV without prior inspection by a dealership. But even owners of brand new Dacias will typically let the dealership take care of it.

That's why the numbers are not really comparable.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by croes on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:51AM (#30127250)
You can also bring a Tesla to an inspection before the HU
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by nautilius on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:50AM (#30127844)
Yeah, that's a weird line of argument. Because there is nominally no dealership, it's impossible to have your Tesla taken care of before doing the HU? I guess Teslas are produced - and then just rot away, and there's nothing we can do about it?
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by nautilius on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:38AM (#30127139)
But we're not talking about brand new Dacias, we are talking about all of them.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by stefan_ on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:18AM (#30127509)
That doesn't add up. No one pays for a full inspection and TÜV on top because no one expects a 3 year old car to fail it. It's not just slightly inflated either, 10% is twice of the average and the problems seem concentrated around suspension, a part that isn't expected to fail until much, much later in the car lifecycle - hardly the result of average wear and tear.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by morsch on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:09AM (#30127415)
And Tesla has no dealerships at all, as far as I know.

They seem to have a store and service center in pretty much every major German city, around twenty overall.

https://www.tesla.com/de_de/findus?v=2&bounds=56.42705343328...

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by deng on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:21AM (#30127546)
Oh come on, it is very well known that the Tesla S has ridiculous problems with the headlights (enclosure not water-tight, dimming DRLs, just to mention the most glaring ones). Likewise, the problem with the control arm is nothing new. Unfortunately for Tesla, this is something that the TÜV actually checks for.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by pmorici on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:46AM (#30127200)
Tesla has plenty dealerships they just don’t call them that they are primarily focused on servicing cars with a small sales showroom attached. Everyone orders online though regardless of wether they go see the car in a show room ahead of time.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by NicoJuicy on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:42AM (#30127171)
Du you have any specific data points that everyone uses a dealership for inspection?

I do something similar in Belgium. But most people don't, definitely not for new cars.

And since that is the fundamental thing in your claim, i hope you have more data to be sure than a gut feeling.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by barbazoo on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:56AM (#30127285)
Former German, same here. Personally I've never heard of people bringing their cars to the dealership which then does the TÜV for them.

People do often bring new cars to a dealership for regular inspections, similar to many other countries, where these kinds of problems would be caught. Still, I wouldn't expect these basic problems to show up in a pretty much brand new car but I'm no expert so who knows if that's reasonable.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by keewee7 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:44AM (#30127769)
It's funny that every European Tesla owner I know are happy with their car but American media, twitter, and reddit users are busy telling us we are wrong.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by microtherion on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:27AM (#30127036)
A Renault Zoe costs roughly a third of a Tesla model S new. Which one is supposed to be the "cheap car" again?
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by benjamir on Saturday January 29, 2022 @03:09PM (#30129883)
I'm not a Tesla fanboy, but: have a crash with the Zoe and you will know what cheap crap looks like (0 star NCAP).
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by zelon88 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:55AM (#30127282)
So how do you go about getting a faulty Tesla repaired in Germany? Tesla only allows repairs by authorized technicians.
Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by tommyage on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:36AM (#30127674)
> The 10% is not as bad as it sounds, because the author fails to mention that these statistics are heavily in favour of expensive cars with a good dealership network. And Tesla has no dealerships at all, as far as I know.

Tesla has dealerships, but this is irrelevant. You are referring to garages, which can be included within a dealership. If you bought a car, you can opt into these contracts. Otherwise you can become a customer of any garage. All cars were compared. There are still 10% of teslas, who can not successfuly survive the initial inspection without additional maintenance.

> When you own something like a BMW, you typically don't drive the car to the inspection yourself. Especially not if it's a leased or company car. Instead, you bring your car to the dealership (or they will pick it up), they inspect the car, fix any issues they encounter and only then bring in an official inspector for the actual inspection. This way, the inspector will hardly find any issues. Also, dealerships typically don't chose TÜV, but one of their competitors that do the inspection at the dealership.

This is valid for any car, regardless of its age or brand, if a garage presents your vehicle for inspection. No need to refer to "german car brands". Also competitors need to respect the same criterias.

> TÜV is where people go who want to save money by skipping the dealership.

The price for the check is fixed. You only fail the check, if there are crucial safety issues or oil leaks. The majority of car owners is thankful for a safety hint from the inspector.

> Most people who do this drive cheaper cars. That's why cheap cars are always having much worse numbers in these statistics.

That is an assumption.

> They are alternative statistics, like ADAC's (Germany's equivalent to AAA), but they all have the same problem. There are no good statistics for German cars. They all favour expensive German brands because those who the statistics will never see a broken car.

This is a biased assumption.

> The dealerships will always take care of that. I'd rather trust US-based Consumer Reports than TÜV or ADAC statistics.

The dealership only takes care of problems iff you either signed an maintenance contract and additional insurance, the issue needs to be solved due to warranty or you accept the charges neccessary to fix the problems.

It simply _is_ the case that tesla has a lower quality then any other europe car brand. Dacia is on the same level as tesla in terms of haptics - but their internas (chassis, engine, bearings..., etc.) are siblings of mature brands.

The TÜV is responsible for checking for safety - Inspectors will get their license permanently revoked if they did not spot an serious issue. I would trust TÜV over any american report.

When an accident happens and a certain money cap is reached, insurances will investigate and escalate to anybody. The TÜV will not prefer any car brand and take these risks.

You do also insult any inspector (DEKRA, GTU or TÜV) by promoting such implications.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by tjansen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @12:24PM (#30128211)
> if a garage presents your vehicle for inspection.

That's the key. Many people don't bring their cars to a garage for inspection. Especially if they don't have annual maintenance intervals which typically end on the same month as the HU intervals.

> The price for the check is fixed. You only fail the check, if there are crucial safety issues or oil leaks

I don't doubt that. The question is whether the dealership will inspect your car before your official inspection or not.

> You do also insult any inspector (DEKRA, GTU or TÜV) by promoting such implications.

??? I am only saying that dealerships are inspecting cars before official inspector sees them, and the rate of pre-inspected cars differs from brand to brand. I don't blame DEKRA, GTU or TÜV for faulty inspections. I blame them for not disclosing the bias in their statistics.

Re:Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspe... by tommyage on Saturday January 29, 2022 @02:14PM (#30129414)
> > if a garage presents your vehicle for inspection.

> That's the key. Many people don't bring their cars to a garage for inspection. Especially if they don't have annual maintenance intervals which typically end on the same month as the HU intervals.

Annual intervals ensure an easy TÜV inspection, but it is differs entirely from the raised point. You can hire a garage to present your car - no need for an annual maintenance contract. No need for intervention by the car manufacture. And you shortend the quotation: Why are you explicitly calling german brands out for: "the average german branded car owner who signed an annual maintenance contract" and why are you omitting my point, that this can be done with any brand and any age of vehicle? I would claim that the luxury brands have _less_ annual maintenance contracts by private households. You need to provide sources for your claims - I just pointed out, that there is no correlation with your claim and it is a biased assumption.

> > The price for the check is fixed. You only fail the check, if there are crucial safety issues or oil leaks

> I don't doubt that. The question is whether the dealership will inspect your car before your official inspection or not.

Any garage can inspect your car - regardless of age. Your opinion is only proven if tesla owners hire less garages then any other brand. And then the age of the car is still neglected.

> > You do also insult any inspector (DEKRA, GTU or TÜV) by promoting such implications.

> ??? I am only saying that dealerships are inspecting cars before official inspector sees them, and the rate of pre-inspected cars differs from brand to brand. I don't blame DEKRA, GTU or TÜV for faulty inspections. I blame them for not disclosing the bias in their statistics.

Inspectors treat any vehicle the same. That means that any garage is able to ensure a successful inspection. There is no dependency on the dealership. Additionally, the owner is responsible for preparing the car.

Since we are referring to fairly new cars: Depending on the kind of purchase the owner _is required_ to present his car at a garage in an interval. Otherwise he will loose his warranty or additional insurances.

And my personal opinion: Anybody who repaired any car on its own will agree: teslas quality is ridicolous cheap.