News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oh, 2022 by j0057 on Sunday January 09, 2022 @04:21PM (#29867441)
> low-lying coastal nations like Bangladesh

And lots of other places. About 1 billion people live along coastlines at 20 meters or less above sea level, and 200 million at 5 meters or less. I live in a wealthy country but well within the 5 meters range and am already having to think about whether it wouldn't be more prudent to sell my house today, now that it's still worth something, and emigrate to somewhere with a more future-proof elevation.

Worst case if Greenland's ice sheet melts, that adds 7 meters to sea level, and Antarctica's another 60 meters. I won't see that in my lifetime but my children might.

Re:Oh, 2022 by lproven on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:39PM (#29878427)
Import fact to remember: it's not about melting.

Ice is less dense than water... but only just. If an ice sheet collapses into the sea, it doesn't need to melt. The ice will displace seawater perfectly effectively just by floating. Most of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet sits on rock that is well under sea level – in places, a kilometre under sea level. It doesn't need to melt: it just needs for the seawater to get underneath it, allowing it to slide off into the sea and break up. Seawater is, obviously, salty and warmer than ice.

The resultant sea-level rise will only take on the order of 12 days to stabilise world wide.

I looked at the figures for this and it was a factor in my decision to sell my house on the outskirts of London and move to Czechia, which is above the level of any possible sea-level rise. Its lowest points are ~120m above mean sea level.

I couldn't afford Austria or Switzerland, and most of the other high-and-dry countries don't have the employment prospects (or beer as good) as the Czech Republic.

Re:Oh, 2022 by walrus01 on Sunday January 09, 2022 @04:24PM (#29867461)
the immediate personal need to not live in a flooded zone is one thing to consider

another thing to think about is the global geopolitical/civil war/economic possible disruptions and consequences of something like potentially half to 3/4 of bangladesh's population becoming international refugees. imagine what happened with syrians around 2012-2015 and people trying to get into europe multiplied by a factor of 50.

and in a theoretical scenario like that happening with bangladesh, simultaneously other groups of aggregate hundreds of millions of low-income coastal residents from around the world also trying to move to safety at the same time.

Re:Oh, 2022 by jaybrendansmith on Sunday January 09, 2022 @07:07PM (#29868895)
Global Warming is absolutely a slow motion comet strike. We don't believe the science, because we don't WANT to believe it. Those of us that DO believe it feel like robots, speaking to the rest of mankind in ones and zeros. And it's still 10-20 years away, we all think. We will just move north (or south). We will just move inland or uphill. We can science our way out of this shit. Not true. None of that is true. When food prices start to skyrocket, and refugees swarm in from lowland countries and every direction including our own country, where will we go? This should absolutely be seen as a slow motion meteor strike, a world-buster event that happens right in front of our eyes before we can truly react. But we must take action. The danger of methane release, particularly methane hydrates, is beyond scary. That, and the raising of sea levels by 2-7 meters, and other unknowns such as the halting of the gulf stream, species die-off, ocean acidification, coral reefs and god knows what else. As a society, we must intelligently react to these dangers as we've done in the past with threats like the ozone layer. We must plan as if a comet was going to hit the planet, starting now.
Re:Oh, 2022 by tick_tock_tick on Sunday January 09, 2022 @08:49PM (#29869609)
> We can science our way out of this shit. Not true.

Why not? We have a lot of promising developments both in cheap energy production and in reducing the cost to vacuumed green house gases out of the atmosphere. I can easily see a world where we change almost nothing about life and still achieve net negative carbon by just ripping it out of the air.

Honestly we even have the technology to do it now just limited will if things ever get real bad that would change very quickly.

Re:Oh, 2022 by mjmahone17 on Sunday January 09, 2022 @11:18PM (#29870569)
> Honestly we even have the technology to do it now just limited will if things ever get real bad that would change very quickly.

COVID tells me that’s highly unlikely. We literally have a movement rejecting known-to-save-lives technology for non-scientific reasons. If things get real bad people will dig deeper to try to protect their own lifestyle right now, even if that means screwing things up 10 years from now.

And enough of those people have enough wealth and power to effectively counter even movements supported by the majority of humanity.

Re:Oh, 2022 by tick_tock_tick on Monday January 10, 2022 @02:48AM (#29871715)
> COVID tells me that’s highly unlikely. We literally have a movement rejecting known-to-save-lives technology for non-scientific reasons.

COVID is different because you need a massive majority, 80%+, to follow certain guidelines (vaccine, masks, etc). For carbon it just needs to happen, anyone can do it. If the tech gets cheap enough Bill Gates will just setup shop in the desert and start sucking.

Re:Oh, 2022 by ponyfleisch on Monday January 10, 2022 @03:41AM (#29871986)
I think your perception of the ease of/effort required for atmospheric carbon capture is off by a few orders of magnitude.
Re:Oh, 2022 by marcosdumay on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:16PM (#29878026)
I don't get what you want to say.

Decarbonizing is happening, at least to electricity generation and transportation. There is a group insisting on denying this, but it's just your usual form of denialism.

There is reasonable freedom to debate the last 10% of emissions. Those are not being replaced right in front of our eyes. There is also room to claim that decarbonization is not enough. But then you'll have to claim that stopping things as they are is either catastrophic or won't stop the consequences from changing. That's not unthinkable, but not a reasonable default assumption either.

I imagine you are talking about that last one assumption. If so, starting from it is kind of an extreme position. Anyway, it's not clear what kind of cost you are classifying as insurmountable and why governments that are used to spend real amounts of money on all kinds of projects just can't spend on those.

Re:Oh, 2022 by ponyfleisch on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @03:53AM (#29889123)
What I want to say is: atmospheric carbon capture is not the deus ex machina that one might be tempted to believe it is after seeing news of startups like Climeworks doing it.

I responded to a comment implying that if there is a philantropist like Bill Gates camping out in the desert sucking CO2 out of the air, we won’t need a massive collective effort.

Maybe this will be a somewhat effective solution one day for areas where fuel energy density is important (e.g. flight), but that’s about it. Carbon neutrality will still need a distributed effort as point source capture is massively more economical where feasible.

Re:Oh, 2022 by obiefernandez on Monday January 10, 2022 @08:17AM (#29874296)
See "Termination Shock" by Neal Stephenson (his latest novel) for a close variation on this scenario.
Re:Oh, 2022 by MrDresden on Monday January 10, 2022 @03:39AM (#29871981)
>I can easily see a world where we change almost nothing about life and still

This is delusional thinking. There is no future where humanity will be able to continue the way it has and still have a non hostile planet to call home.

The math does not add up for carbon capture tech.

There isn't some scientific silver bullet there that will increase the capture yield.

Building the infrastructure will also emit. Powering the installations will take a lot of energy. There would need to be enormous amounts of these capturing station built around the world for them to make any significant dent in what is already in the atmosphere.

The resources and effort required is so wast, and for so little gain, that we should rather use the alternatives that would give us much more for less.

Subsidize farmers to switch from cattle rearing to forestry for instance. Turn swaths of reclaimed land back to its original wilderness.

Re:Oh, 2022 by walrus01 on Sunday January 09, 2022 @09:17PM (#29869826)
even if we completely stopped emitting carbon immediately (impossible), the damage done might mean that we're still going to see a large percentage of greenland slide into the sea in the next 20-50 years.
Re:Oh, 2022 by quantified on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @02:39AM (#29888689)
Which technology for vacuuming the gases out scale up and require small enough inputs to not contribute to the problem?
Re:Oh, 2022 by andrekandre on Sunday January 09, 2022 @11:35PM (#29870680)

  > Honestly we even have the technology to do it now just limited will if things ever get real bad that would change very quickly.
more important than technology imo is: where are the funds? who is going to pay for all this air filtration?
Re:Oh, 2022 by muzani on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:38AM (#29871042)
Most likely outcome seems like the COVID vaccines. The damage is already severe. And while it can (drastically) reduce damage in the future, it will be there.

Someone had a theory that covid won't be the apocalyptic plague. Instead we'll be hit with another deadlier one that ends up poorly controlled with all the covid fatigue. Something like MERS or Ebola, that the old world managed to control.

I expect this to be the case of climate change. Gov has burned their political capital trying to control covid that there's none left to handle climate change.

Re:Oh, 2022 by wiether on Monday January 10, 2022 @02:38AM (#29871666)
First time I read a comment on the Internet about so well how bad things are, how even worse they are going to be and how nothing is actually done to avoid it. Thank you.

And if I may add, before COVID I was also concerned about antibiotic resistance, mainly because of how we produce a big part of our food (meat). But after two years of COVID, and given how we dealt with it so far, I think it's an even more worrying threat than I thought. Combined with air, water and soil pollution, there's too many fires to look after.

Re:Oh, 2022 by quantified on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @02:41AM (#29888699)
We still need to worry about antibiotic resistance. Thanks very much for a reminder.
Re:Oh, 2022 by vincentmarle on Monday January 10, 2022 @12:52AM (#29871142)
> As a society, we must intelligently react to these dangers as we've done in the past with threats like the ozone layer. We must plan as if a comet was going to hit the planet, starting now.

Have you seen the movie Don’t Look Up? It’s not gonna happen.

Re:Oh, 2022 by ncmncm on Sunday January 09, 2022 @07:04PM (#29868861)
Not just inundated places.

Much of the tropics will become literally uninhabitable: being outside, in the shade, not moving, you die of heat stroke. Not every day, but in several days of the year, which is entirely enough. Before that, of course, the crops fail.

The effect of massive refugee influx has been seen to drive a rise of fascism in democratic nations.

Re:Oh, 2022 by mooreds on Sunday January 09, 2022 @05:10PM (#29867835)
Yup. It's about to get really really bad for refugees. Here's a PDF report talking about the challenges: https://www.ipcc.ch/apps/njlite/srex/njlite_download.php?id=...
Re:Oh, 2022 by causi on Monday January 10, 2022 @02:54AM (#29871756)
I wonder where the global cultural position will be when the time comes. Will we of the West choose economic ruin and cultural dilution by mass importation of unskilled bodies or choose to watch 150 million people kill each other while starving to death? Right now the stakes are much lower and our nations would still rather watch refugees die.
Re:Oh, 2022 by jacquesm on Sunday January 09, 2022 @08:55PM (#29869651)
The answer is pretty simple, though you may not like it: lots of people will die.
Re:Oh, 2022 by ruined on Monday January 10, 2022 @05:50AM (#29872914)
death is never simple. it turns out to be highly motivating, and motivated people tend to do all kinds of complicated things.
Re:Oh, 2022 by jacquesm on Monday January 10, 2022 @06:59AM (#29873453)
Yes, motivated people will try all kinds of things, but that's not guarantee for success. And usually we're talking about problems at a completely different scale, how we deal with one like this we do not know but if the pandemic is any indication then you have a nice sample of what a response could look like and how effective it will be.

The big mistake is that we try to solve global problems with local control.

Re:Oh, 2022 by erosenbe0 on Monday January 10, 2022 @05:42AM (#29872850)
Plenty of people already currently die from poverty, disease, lack of sanitation, poor nutrition, and conflicts. So maybe the number of these preventable deaths stays about constant as poverty improves but climate worsens?
Re:Oh, 2022 by jacquesm on Monday January 10, 2022 @06:58AM (#29873440)
No. If you start forcibly moving people in those numbers out from some of the real estate that we've invested 100's of years of hard work and income into then that number will not stay about constant. These are the most productive parts of our planet that we're talking about.
Re:Oh, 2022 by erosenbe0 on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:06AM (#29876904)
Agreed. Very scary
Re:Oh, 2022 by walrus01 on Sunday January 09, 2022 @09:52PM (#29870032)
yes, very likely, how many need to die before low lying nation state governments collapse into absolute chaos and civil war remains to be seen.
Re:Oh, 2022 by Psychlist on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:11AM (#29872192)
Imagine if all those desperate engineers in Bangladesh decided that rather than nuclear weapons to match India and Pakistan, they wanted them to build an Orion ship. A really, really big one. Think lofting 100M Bangladeshis into space. And moving to Mars.

That would create a whole different sort of climate change.

Re:Oh, 2022 by inasio on Monday January 10, 2022 @01:51AM (#29871425)
Friend of mine works at IEA, specifically on water projects. Over drinks he told me his biggest worry is the Himalayas basin destabilizing. Water from those glaciers supply something like 2bn+ people.
Re:Oh, 2022 by divbzero on Monday January 10, 2022 @05:54AM (#29872955)
One of the Mission: Imposible films contains a bastardized version of that scenario.
Re:Oh, 2022 by divbzero on Monday January 10, 2022 @06:53AM (#29873389)
> Worst case if Greenland's ice sheet melts, that adds 7 meters to sea level, and Antarctica's another 60 meters. I won't see that in my lifetime but my children might.

How likely is this worst case?

IPCC in 2021 [1] projected a 0.5 m to 2.0 m sea level rise by 2100 (see Figure SPM.8) and NOAA in 2020 [2] suggested a worst case of 2.5 m sea level rise by 2100. It appears that neither are considering the possibility of an entire ice sheet melting?

[1]: https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg1/downloads/report/IPCC_AR6...

[2]: https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/...

Re:Oh, 2022 by beambot on Monday January 10, 2022 @02:57AM (#29871771)
I love the irony in SFBA of major tech companies building their new HQs right on the water's edge. They'll be the first to acknowledge anthropogenic climate change, yet I've never been able to get a satisfactory justification for their realestate decisions.
Re:Oh, 2022 by aldonius on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:29AM (#29872327)
They expect to be able to move (or out of business) by the time that it becomes an issue. If it's just an office building in the downtown, the tech company doesn't own the building anyway, they've just signed a reasonably long lease.
Re:Oh, 2022 by neuronic on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:38AM (#29872401)
That might be because they still believe every single problem on Earth is solvable by technology - their technology in the optimal case.
Re:Oh, 2022 by erosenbe0 on Monday January 10, 2022 @06:17AM (#29873118)
Maybe because Silicon Valley is the ultimate location for maximizing race and class exclusion. It is a de-facto exclusionary zone with minimal accessibility for Black workers and Black families, often by designs, covenants, zoning, and hostility going back 100 years. In order for those entities to opportunity hoard for their own children they need a class exclusive, car-dependent community with low access for 'others.'

Edit: not accusing any particular person, ceo, or entity of malice.

Re:Oh, 2022 by mekkkkkk on Monday January 10, 2022 @08:44AM (#29874635)
How did you manage to get a race angle into this? And which "designs" and "covenants" are you talking about?
Re:Oh, 2022 by erosenbe0 on Monday January 10, 2022 @11:55AM (#29877702)
We are piling on tech companies that purport to care about climate and diversity and other such things while locating their HQ in Silicon Valley, which is obviously not the optimal strategy if those are really priorities. I refer to the [once legal] housing deeds that literally excluded sales to Blacks, developers who did not sell to Blacks as a way of marketing to whites, extreme zoning designed to limit working class residents, allowed discrimination against Blacks at Stanford, overt racism against Blacks by noted founder of Silicon Valley, and so on.
Re:Oh, 2022 by beambot on Monday January 10, 2022 @01:47PM (#29879570)
Race was definitely a bit of a side tangent, but you're absolutely correct. Let me share an interesting anecdote...

I live in a small community on the SFBA peninsula. Our property's original CC&R's (Covenants, Conditions & Restrictions) from 1929 specifically state: "Said property shall not at any time be occupied by any person or persons of the African, Mongolian or other Asiatic race, except as a domestic servant."

A few observations: (1) Obviously, these are no longer legal or enforceable; (2) my wife & daughter both fall into these restricted groups; they laughed when they saw them, but it was a pretty stark reminder of past incidents of discrimination; (3) This community and many others like it command a 30% dollar premium (good schools & city amenities) compared to neighboring communities without those legacy CC&Rs. Crazy how these differences propagate through time.

Bay Area definitely has its share of warts, though it doesn't hold a candle to some of the stuff we witnessed in the rural South.

Re:Oh, 2022 by erosenbe0 on Monday January 10, 2022 @07:19PM (#29885209)
Wow, I really appreciate that anecdote. There are historians of the Bay Area who research those sorts of things.

From what I gather, many do consider that the WWII concentration camps for American citizens of Japanese ancestry was a racial terror on Bay Area residents comparable to what happened in the 20th century South.

Anyway, after covenants ended, for several decades developers and real estate folk found it legally, politically, and financially expedient not to sell to certain minorities. Want that subdivision project to go smoothly and sell quickly? Apparently in many cases it was optimal to subtly or not so subtly advertise exclusionary sales policies.

So you see, there were not as many Black Steve Jobs or Mike Markkula as their could have been -- because certainly as late as 1960, a Black teacher or firefighter or qualified professional would have found it relatively difficult to relocate to Mountain View or San Jose as Steve Jobs' own parents did. And this robbed minorities out of participating in the economic engine.

This was not special to Santa Clara county, as it was common practice all across the nation.

But because SV has such poor commuting conditions for any relatively proportionate critical mass of Black Americans, particularly those who are descendants of slaves, the exclusionary effect is quite extreme and one really can't purport to care about diversity by locating there.

By comparison, an economic engine like Wall Street is a modest subway fare away from literally some of the poorest census tracts in the nation that are located in the Bronx. Which at least in theory allows a poor kid to work up from the mail room, and does not by geography alone minimize opportunities for poor minorities.

Re:Oh, 2022 by kjs3 on Sunday January 09, 2022 @06:49PM (#29868736)
That's the point, isn't it: all those things aren't exactly equal. You likely don't even really have to worry about selling your house now...worst case you loose equity and move someplace else. Personally traumatic & unpleasant, but not exactly the end of the world. Here in the US, I expect people in Miami and Boston and NYC to be partying right up until the point the water laps up against their front door, and then there will be a government program to move you to higher ground.

If you're in Bangladesh, where can you go, other than another country. And people will fight for that. They'll fight wars. With neighbors that have nuclear weapons. That will not end well for any of us.

Re:Oh, 2022 by wombatpm on Sunday January 09, 2022 @09:50PM (#29870020)
So global warming solved by nuclear winter?
Re:Oh, 2022 by fy20 on Monday January 10, 2022 @03:05AM (#29871820)
There's also the option of migration within the country. If we take an elevation map of Bangladesh and compare it to a climate map, there are areas that are higher and still have good climates for crops.

https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Karar-Ahsan/publication...

https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Nicolas-Guilpart-2/publ...

People aren't going to migrate unless there is infrastructure and job opportunities there, so if we want to help these people we should be helping these countries to build new cities that are outside the risk of flood zones. We could even take the opportunity to provide more western standards of living - Dhaka only treats around 1/4 of its waste water - and build more environmentally friendly buildings - Dhaka is within a climate where houses could be heated passively.

Re:Oh, 2022 by ncmncm on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:39AM (#29872412)
People will leave anyplace they cannot live in anymore, no matter what the situation is wherever they are obliged to go.

It is easy to say people can move someplace else in their own country, but other people already live in those places you suggest they move to.

People obliged to move out with just what they can carry are generally not equipped to build new cities. People already in places they hope to move to are generally ill-disposed to building them a place to live for free.

Re:Oh, 2022 by klipt on Sunday January 09, 2022 @11:25PM (#29870612)
Maybe nations like Bangladesh will deploy solar geoengineering to counter final warming:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_geoengineering

It's risky, but if their alternative is millions of deaths, why wouldn't they?

Re:Oh, 2022 by postmeta on Sunday January 09, 2022 @07:43PM (#29869170)
what model predicts 5m rise in 100 years?
Re:Oh, 2022 by samplatt on Sunday January 09, 2022 @10:12PM (#29870160)
It's not (necessarily) about sea-level rise drowning us out.

It's about proximity to the sea-level being an indicator of severe damage done to property and infrastructure done by sea-level-rise and other climate-change factors like increased storm severity and frequency, increased dilapidation speed from salt and extreme temperature changes, etc. Not to mention the increased cost of living due to the above even if damage to life and property is minimal.

Re:Oh, 2022 by bezospen15 on Sunday January 09, 2022 @09:07PM (#29869737)
You have a solid 20 years before it impacts value. We are getting out in 10 years
Re:Oh, 2022 by celeduc on Monday January 10, 2022 @02:22AM (#29871587)
Timing a market that's absolutely sure to collapse is notoriously difficult.
Re:Oh, 2022 by causi on Monday January 10, 2022 @02:50AM (#29871731)
As long as half your buyers are convinced it isn't going to happen, probably not that hard. Real estate in flood and wildfire zones is still valued very highly today.
Re:Oh, 2022 by baq on Monday January 10, 2022 @04:19AM (#29872252)
good news is it'll take a loooong time to heat up that much water.