If it's portable, your option works well.
For year round off grid use, there's something to be said for sealed lead acid, or flooded lead acid - they don't care about being cycled while cold (capacity is down and the voltage sags a good bit), and as long as they don't get too deeply discharged, they don't freeze.
A single panel, facing south, absolutely vertical, will shed snow and if you have no other loads, is usually enough to offset controller loads and self discharge over time to keep the batteries fully charged (and therefore not freezing) over winter.
There's no way you'll generate enough heat on electricity to keep a battery bank (or cabin) warm in the winter most places. I've got 5kW of panel on my office, and still can't manage that for a small, well insulated shed.
Insulation, too. A lot of sheds and cabins (and single-family homes) could do with more. Saves on cooling bills in the summer, too.
Anyway, in a cold climates like mine an acre would not be enough to keep you warm because trees grow slow when it's winter six months out of twelve. It takes a lot of wood to keep you warm, and one tree gives surprisingly little wood. After a handful of years you'll have clearcut your measly acre and still have another couple of decades to go before it becomes harvestable again. I'd say you want at least 10 acres if you manage it well and the soil and drainage are at least half decent.
They grow faster since they already have a root structure, the size is consistent and the wood is generally straigter (the japanese have a similar technique for extremely straight cedar logs)
Single purpose but not reliably there heat capture methods add cost and maintenance.
It’s often more cost effective to have a general purpose method that while not as efficient in one case is generally more overall (cost) efficient.
Sure, a backup plan is a good idea. But it doesn't have to be very good or very efficient, as it will be rarely used.
There are weeks with zero direct sun, just low cloud cover, scattered snow, and cold cold cold.
I was in Michigan once when Lake Superior froze over, shore to shore.
Unless the place is so well insulated you can keep it warm purely with body heat, you need supplemental heating in climates like this. The sun is not always shining.
Some folks in less severe climates (like New Hampshire) seemed to get by with baking and other managed appliance heat. That does require you spend time doing, and orient your activities around, things to produce heat to stay warm. Some will find that palatable, others won’t.
Posters in Colder climates (like Ontario) noted propane, or thermal mass heaters (such as the rocket heater in the thread).
‘Then the propane could make up the modest difference on long cold cloudy stretches.’
Thanks for linking it!
The amount of heat needing to be generated can then be calculated based on the average temp over a longer period of time, and those batteries I don't imagine have to be "warm" exactly.
Any charging around or below freezing causes pretty quick destruction of the cells as the chemistry switches to a more favorable destructive one way electroplating process instead of the desirable (and reversible) ion exchange process.
A common engineering solution to this has started to be temperature dependent shunts that route charging energy to heating pads around the battery until the battery temp gets above a certain safe point.
It adds complexity, cost, and adds several undesirable failure mode however, and Lithium battery cost is already a major factor in these systems, so if you’re in a situation where you can’t reliably temperature control your batteries (cold climate, non-conditioned battery space), lead acid is still a very viable and often desirable chemistry instead.
Round trip efficiency isn’t great with them, and you have to way over provision to get good cell lifespan, but it works.
Unless you live in the desert, having the batteries too hot isn't as big of an issue as freezing them.
It's good practice to snake a water pipe around every lithium cell anyway in big packs, because otherwise one bad cell can self-heat to the point of catching fire, even while other nearby cells are cold. The flowing water means the bad cell can't get to the point of fire.
New ones do have a significant gain at that temperature. For instance this Samsung Nordic Home: https://www.elkjop.no/product/hjem-og-husholdning/oppvarming...
Solar panels produce the most power on cold winter days. The 'rated power' is for 20 degrees ambient at full (90 degrees, no cloud) incidence at sea level.
What you could say is that solar panels in the winter do not produce the same amount of power in an average day as they do in the summer due to the shorter day and the bigger chance of occlusion as well as the longer path the suns rays have to travel through the atmosphere.
I had 48KWh worth of storage, 2500 W worth of wind and another 5000 W worth of solar. This was in Northern Ontario. Until we added the windmill we fairly regularly needed the generator, after we added the windmill the generator just sat there gathering dust.
This was a major factor in designing the machine the way I did, variable pitch is a lot more work but a machine like that will start up far earlier than a fixed pitch machine. It also had its effect on that stator, which I made with the laminates at a slant over 1/3rd magnet width, which reduced cogging to nearly nothing. This is a huge factor in starting up a direct drive machine.
I’d quite like a battery system, I think I’d DIY (well, design the system but here you need a licensed electrician to wire up the AC/grid connect side) using Victron equipment. I have a 5 kW solar system already with a AC inverter which I can keep, so I would probably use a 5000KVA inverter-charger (Multiplus-II), but then I’d add another 1.5kW or so of solar that is directly DC coupled to the batteries and the DC side of the inverter-charger through a separate DC MPPT tracker.
So the DC coupled solar would be enough to kick-start the system to get the AC side back on after a bit if the grid was out and the batteries were depleted overnight.
You can build a hole that will hold up to this sort of stuff for a while, but that tends to be expensive - underground concrete work is neither cheap nor easy, and given the number of people injured in trench collapses who do it for a living, a serious underground hole isn't a good DIY project either.
That just leaves the maintenance, which also sucks for a hole in the ground. Anything you have to do on the batteries is easier with them on or above the ground, instead of underground in a hole. For lithium, it's fairly low maintenance but you may have to replace some BMS boards every now and then, manually check balance, etc, and for lead it's water every few months, unless you go with sealed, which are "maintenance free," but also "maintenance and status check impossible," so you really just set them and run them to failure - you can't monitor condition like you can with flooded.
It's the sort of solution that, technically, would work - it just ends up being radically more expensive and a hassle than it's remotely worth. Think "Spending $5000 to save $20/yr" sort of thing.
You see the same trend with things like the complex solar trackers that were common in the 80s and early 90s. With the cost of panels, optimizing every bit of power from them was critical, so spending an awful lot of money on support infrastructure to optimize $10/W panel production made quite a bit of practical and financial sense.
Today, with panels at $0.50/W, very few people bother with trackers anymore (for off grid installs). Most things you could improve with a tracker, you can improve with less effort and less money by just hanging more panels. Bonus: With more panels, you get more production on cloudy days when panel orientation doesn't matter (because the sky is more or less evenly lit).
I've got south facing, east facing, and west facing panels on my office, of two different brands, all fed into a single MPPT charge controller input (I do have some blocking diodes to prevent backfeeding a shaded string, though). It's not nearly as "efficient" as some other options, but it's a whole lot cheaper, and gives me more power on the low cloud days that are the rough ones. The rest of the year, I have so much power out there that I'm demand limited, not supply limited (actually, inverter limited - if I added some 48VDC loads, I could use another 5kWh/day easily).
Get a plastic storage box, drill holes for cables and seal them with caulk. Put inside a treated lumber box for extra crushing resistance. Run cables through metal conduits to avoid mice and moles chewing on them.
Rent a backhoe, and you are done in half an afternoon.
All of that said, I dont know that I would actually go that far- you avoid the battery freezing, but then you get to worry about it cooking. For an off-grid cabin that isn't constantly heated in winter, it isn't the worst idea.
No issues so far, two years in. It’s not terribly cool in the hottest days of summer and does require a small heater if I want to keep it above freezing through winter, but in terms of being difficult or expensive to build, not at all.
I know it’s only lighting as a load, but I’ve heard standard LED light bulbs will happily run as low as 36VDC, as they chop the voltage down to that level anyway.
It makes me wonder how many “120VAC” devices with switch mode power supplies could be plugged into 48VDC without any thought at all. And not just electronics like a laptop or non-plasma flatscreen, but everything is moving in this direction:
Like… what’s my Variable Frequency Drive “inverter” refrigerator motor voltage really running at? In theory it should happily run off 120VDC at least. Don’t do that, but somewhere under 110VDC should work fine. And it’s inherently soft start and easier on one’s low voltage wiring than an on/off duty cycle fridge.
Of course I recommend none of this officially.
Active power factor correction circuitry will have a fit, but... eh, whatever. It's DC now, nobody cares!
A 120VRMS AC signal peaks around 170V, and most (not all, but most...) switch mode power supplies are auto ranging, so they'll tolerate from about 100VRMS to about 250VRMS - which is near 400V peak. If you can get 300+VDC into them, they'll be quite happy, but the boost converters to do that are a pain to find, and by the time you build one, you may as well just get a 120VAC inverter and call it good.
The main thing to be concerned about, and the reason to jack the input voltages about as high as you can, is that almost every switch mode power supply has a full bridge rectifier on the input side. From an AC input source, each diode has a 50% duty cycle. Put DC on it, now two diodes are at 100% duty cycle, two are at 0% duty cycle. How much overhead was there in the system? Well... you'll find out! However, a system capable of running and not overloading the diodes at 50% duty cycle at ~100VAC should be totally fine in terms of diode heating at 300VDC - just, perhaps not at 100VDC.
All I could think about was the (potential) improvements on capacitor lifespan since they won’t have to smoothen, but wasn’t sure if their electrolyte could still heat/dry if it was actually the connection to power that makes them hot.
Thinking further, an internal fuse might blow with the (expectedly) larger current draw at 48V.
And yeah on input wiring, you’re pulling more current at 48V.
But as soon as you've got some stuff that requires an inverter, you may as well just light the inverter up for everything. I've got the equipment to do a separate, lithium-backed "DC rail" in my office that would be around 40V, and then buck it down for various devices, run my routers direct on it, and... I've never gotten around to doing it, because until literally everything is on that, I'd still have to run the inverter for things like system sleep (I sleep most of my computers overnight). I'm fiddling watts around and it's just not worth it unless I can actually shut the inverter down entirely. Unfortunately, boosting up to 300VDC isn't cheap or easy.
I've wondered if you could run some of that stuff straight off solar during good sun, but I've never really wanted to subject my computers to that sort of abuse.
That’s where I’m coming from: trying to convince a family member to setup a DC system so the inverter can stay in sleep mode during evening/overnight, because the efficiency is horrendous at small loads. it’s really academic in kWh savings per day, but it saves you the most when sunlight’s the least and reduces battery cycling. But if you’re running an office, the inverter is pretty much running a good load or off, I think.
Most people off grid have plenty of space but care about efficiency in terms of cost.
Maybe even just toss them in an old discarded deep freeze? You could even have one battery in there that is disconnected from the rest of the system so it can be used to jump start the system if it ever gets fully discharged.
Maybe best to have them sit on a thick layer of insulation on the bottom, and a box that can be removed during the summer months so the batteries don't overheat.
Another a bit weird idea would be to somehow put them next to a compost heap, which produces low temperature heat for a long time (years) including during the winter.
I think most people underestimate just how much delta in production there can be on solar. My house array is grid tied, 16kW, a bit weird looking (mostly east-west panels, designed for post net metering). On a really good, cool, clear, windy spring day, I can produce about 105kWh out of the system from sunup to sundown.
On a really bad, low, grey, winter day, that same system produces about 2kWh. It's literally a factor of 50 difference. And we can get several days of that in a row. I have a backup generator that I use for my office on weeks like that (separate, off-grid system).
"Winter, electric heat on solar" is a fairly good filter for those who have read about solar or pondered it, and those who have a few years of it under their belt. The second group are the ones who've tried it, discovered just how horribly it doesn't work, and are trying to convince the first group that, no, really, insert well worn idea here really doesn't fix the problems with it.
I guarantee if it were easy, people would be doing it. That you won't find any serious off grid system doing electric battery heating is because it doesn't work.
But, 2kWh or even less should be plenty to keep a well insulated battery compartment from freezing.
On very cold and clear winter days you are going to get more than that, and on cloudy days it is usually not that cold.
It's old tech, it's boring, but it works fine... flooded lead acid. Don't fully discharge it in the winter, and they won't freeze. They'll cycle just fine in the cold. Well tested, proven, and unless you're full time living and heating an interior space that can be lithium-friendly, they're the right option. Disconnect all the loads and run them on float in the winter with a high, vertical, south facing panel (obviously swap that if you're in the southern hemisphere), and they'll do just fine.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1w8vPBHkMyY5jvkxtK1Qh...
Which is why you want to install disconnects between your battery bank and the electronics. In a worst-case scenario of total discharge you can then bypass the dead batteries, hook the control electronics up to car batteries if necessary (be careful about voltages) and perform some diagnostics or at least read the logs of what went wrong. But the controller+inverter should be running if supplied with voltage from solar/wind/generator regardless of how the batteries are doing.
Most of them don't operate that way. They need the battery bank connected first, and run off the battery bank side, while controlling the panel side.
Some may tolerate that sort of recovery from deep discharge, but it's not a safe bet, and some controllers are pretty clear that if you connect the input side before the batteries, you'll damage the controller.
A dumb PWM controller stands a better chance of doing this, but something like an MPPT controller, unless it's explicitly designed to fail into a PWM configuration at low battery voltage, won't - they need power to drive the buck converter circuitry (the controlling ICs and oscillators and such) in order to get power out of the panels.
What you need is more insulation. I've tested that battery and the internal heaters work great, but you should put it somewhere where the heat that is created stays in the battery.
bad for lithium batteries. even then, it is only bad if you charge or discharge them in freezing temps. lead-acid handle cold just fine.
I used the Solar Controller+Inverter Combos recommended on this site (Growatt) but ultimately switched to ones by Renogy. The Growatt one I purchased has a wifi adapter and app - wifi requirement was a deal breaker when remote. The renogy one has a Bluetooth adapter and app, plus feels better designed (though actually I think the internals are all pretty similar).
There are a couple surprise gotchas I didn’t know:
1) These Controller+Inverter combo units require a battery to turn on. This means: if your battery runs completely out of charge, you have to get electricity from somewhere to charge your battery a bit before the Controller+Inverter will turn on and charge your battery again. I was pretty annoyed at how not “off grid” this felt.
2) Temperatures below freezing are bad for batteries. I purchased a Renogy 48v smart battery with self heating. Unfortunately less sun in winter means less energy, and heat production is energy intensive. I’m not at the cabin 100% of the time so I have to take the battery with me when I leave to avoid spoiling/freezing it. Still not sure how I’ll ultimately get around this.