News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by deadalus on Friday December 17, 2021 @10:43AM (#29593696)
I will never forget that the Christchurch shooting video was automatically deleted from users' PRIVATE Google Drive and Dropbox - no warnings were given and no explanation was presented.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by snarf21 on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:14PM (#29595095)
I wonder if in the future we'll need a "unique-inize" app that will make trivial changes to pictures and videos that change their hash and their size by a few bytes to defeat this kind of nonsense. Changing even one pixel's hue on one frame by a small amount should make the whole thing encode (depending on codec) to a different size and hash.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by SavantIdiot on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:22PM (#29595207)
There are other kinds of hashes besides cryptographic hashes, which tolerate differences, e.g. you can change things around and still get the same hash. This is what Apple does (or rather did) for their cloud scanner.

Then there are other non-hash methods, similar to how Shazam determines a song in a noisy room. Poles, zeros, FFTs, there are many other strategies that are fault-tolerant.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by snarf21 on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:30PM (#29595329)
Sure but it becomes an arms race. There is also a lot of people that have shown that you can make images of dogs and cats that hash to Apple's hash detector. At some point a white hat is going to start making memes that cause hash collisions. When 300M all violate some hash trigger, it will cause a stir and restart the game.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by kurthr on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:50PM (#29597476)
Sure, but just compress and encrypt. It won't play in place, but otherwise it's nondetectable (other than by out of band timing/metadata or very rough size estimates).
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by bshipp on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:49PM (#29598162)
...which is what floors me when Google made this statement. I thought the whole benefit of their Google drive system was deduplication of common files to minimize storage space costs. If they start tinkering with private files then people have no choice but to encrypt everything.

This will cause their storage requirement to explode. However, if the goal is only to prevent public sharing of content in contravention of the user agreement then I'm surprised it took them this long to implement this.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by 41b696ef1113 on Saturday December 18, 2021 @03:12PM (#29608083)
How many people have the wherewithal to encrypt their content? Even if some have the technical capability, how many are willing to take the reduced quality of life required for what is probably a low probability risk?
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by RachelF on Sunday December 19, 2021 @05:35PM (#29619177)
You can use something like Syncdocs https://syncdocs.com which supports encryption/decryption on the fly to Google Drive
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by jmclnx on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:17PM (#29599055)
Came here to say this. Only an idiot (should say people without knowledge) would upload any personal data to the "Cloud" without encrypting it first. That includes pictures.

As for size, you can always tar/encrypt its dir and include dummy files to modify its size.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by Zamicol on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:44PM (#29595539)
As long as Google is willing to serve binaries, encryption solves this.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by rainbowzootsuit on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:47PM (#29599299)
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by ksec on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:46PM (#29599291)
To battle the Cloud storage paradigm with uniqueness is always going to be a cat and mouse game.

I wish the future is a NAS that is simple, fault tolerant ( Bit-Flip protection, Error Correction, Drive Redundancy ) and extremely affordable. That is something the Apple Time Capsule should have been.

Right now I cant even get a 2x 2.5" 2TB HDD and a NAS enclosure for under $200 RSP. I was hoping Kobol would be it someday. But chip shortage and many other things had them canceled the project.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by beagle3 on Saturday December 18, 2021 @03:47AM (#29602939)
Synology isn’t the cheapest, but they’ve made it “just work”. Every few years - both for home, and for work, I consider getting a “more serious” storage system or building one; and every time I do a serious comparison and end up choosing Synology over building my own FreeNAS/TrueNAS/etc for home, and preferring Synology over NetApp for work.

I do have a couple of NetApps for mission critical stuff; and one of my customers runs an Isilon which I have to support; for almost every workload that can tolerate a few minutes of planned downtime per month, the Synology wins bigly as long as you have knowledgeable IT staff.

And no, you don’t want an Isilon or a NetApp if you don’t have knowledgeable IT staff around - you want a synology (or to get better IT)

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by squarefoot on Saturday December 18, 2021 @03:47AM (#29602938)
> Right now I cant even get a 2x 2.5" 2TB HDD and a NAS enclosure for under $200 RSP

You can get comparatively much more for much less if you look carefully at the used market and spend some time building it for yourself. My 5 bays home NAS cost me just a bit over €130, excluding disks of course: €46 for a SUPERMICRO X7SPA-L mainboard and €88 for a Ultron RPS19-G3380 case, power supply included. All purchased from ebay sellers. I already had the memory modules plus an additional slow SATA controller I use for a non RAID disk, so had to buy only the disks locally. It runs XigmaNAS and has been rock solid with multiple 1 year+ uptimes interrupted only for maintenance or disk upgrades.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by StreamBright on Saturday December 18, 2021 @04:00AM (#29603001)
I think there are pretty good solutions out there with zfs.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by Traubenfuchs on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:27PM (#29597176)
They are way ahead of you, with stuff like neuralhash.

Does it work? Mostly. Can it be tricked? Yes.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by api on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:50PM (#29596541)
Not on your drives => not your data.

Not encrypted (at rest and in transit) => not private.

There are no exceptions.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by dhimes on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:57PM (#29596674)
Sadly true.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by micromacrofoot on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:00AM (#29593952)
They do the same thing for copyrighted material, they can match a hash and nuke a file off the service at the drop of a hat.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by pedro2 on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:14AM (#29594165)
delete the file? not unshare it and keep it on the personal storage?
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by fknorangesite on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:35AM (#29594503)
fwiw the article says

> These files will be flagged to their owner and restricted automatically, which means they can no longer be shared with other people, and access will be withdrawn from everyone but the owner.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by pedro2 on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:48AM (#29594707)
all articles always say that but non-verifiable comments around the internet say the file is removed from everywhere.

I'm trying to confirm this comment:

> They removed it after they began using GIFCT to ‘prevent terrorists and violent extremists from exploiting digital platforms.’ All hashed versions of that video was removed from user accounts.

> Page 16 : https://www.oecd.org/officialdocuments/publicdisplaydocument...

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by paganel on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:07PM (#29595843)
It would have been interesting if any of those users who got their video file deleted would have been directly attached to the shooter (like an accomplice, let's say), afaik that would have meant that Google Driver and Dropbox had tampered evidence.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by wodenokoto on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:48PM (#29598151)
Google don’t delete. They make unavailable.

If a judge said that owning that video was probable cause or whatever, they could produce every user who used to have that file.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by smueller1234 on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:55AM (#29603816)
Apologies for directly contradicting you, but it's false that Google don't delete. Google do delete in a timely fashion (which is required by law in many places!), it's just that for technical reasons, it becomes unavailable or possibly also crypto erased* first.

On an aside, such a setup is also a layer of defense-in-depth protection against a certain, uncommon class of bugs.

I do work for Google, but don't, in any way, speak for the company. All of the above information can be found on the internet, eg. https://www.quora.com/Does-Google-really-delete-the-account-... about Google accounts themselves.

* https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto-shredding

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by mrweasel on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:35PM (#29595408)
That eliminate both options for journalists and lawyers. There are professions which could have legitimate reasons for having the material and as terrible as it is, is it actually illegal?
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by Meph504 on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:13PM (#29596943)
From the legal standpoint, using those sort of services for storing sensitive case data like that is a bad call. too much media in those situations violate the terms and services of most platforms paid or not, and too many of those platforms have too many liberties with the usage policies on the media.

If you are dealing with case data, you should be have those policies reviewed carefully, and should likely be encrypting before storing anywhere anyway.

I say should because I almost never see case data stored to standard.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by chris1993 on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:04PM (#29597665)
Possession of the Christchurch video is illegal in NZ. Not sure about elsewhere.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by dokem on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:57PM (#29597575)
I was actually trying to watch that video the other day. Google would not find it, Bing listed the actual video as the top result. Never thought I'd start to respect bing over google.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by lern_too_spel on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:38PM (#29598026)
Everything I've seen indicates it was a shared file. I haven't seen any reports that files that are actually private (not shared) get deleted.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by srj on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:51AM (#29594757)
Was it deleted or unshared?
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by paulpauper on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:49PM (#29596531)
as other mentioned, encryption solves this. Or scrambling, compression, etc.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Friday December 17, 2021 @07:42PM (#29600205)
Users? You mean Google's storage space that they allow people to use.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by indigodaddy on Friday December 17, 2021 @07:51PM (#29600274)
Yes users of a service, whether one is paying with one’s personal data, or whether one pays with their personal data AND a yearly fee for a bit more storage, as I do— they are users.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by pedro2 on Friday December 17, 2021 @10:48AM (#29593769)
Whaaat? Link please
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by deadalus on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:05AM (#29594024)
They removed it after they began using GIFCT to ‘prevent terrorists and violent extremists from exploiting digital platforms.’ All hashed versions of that video was removed from user accounts.

Page 16 : https://www.oecd.org/officialdocuments/publicdisplaydocument...

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by yuliyp on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:07PM (#29595851)
I haven't had my coffee yet, but I'm having trouble understanding your claims (about Google Drive deleting TVEC content) and how they relate to the OECD document you linked. That document does not state that Google (except YouTube) is a member of GIFCT. Further, on page 124 (in "Policies") of the document it states that Google Drive will prevent sharing of files it finds violating, or maybe ban an entire account in some situations.

Am I missing something here?

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by jart on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:30PM (#29597228)
The policy going back to at least 2014 does mention not being allowed to "store" violence and gore. They even say that if it's shocking enough, then no artistic, scientific, educational, or documentary exceptions will allow it to remain on their platforms. I assume that means deletion. It's a different Internet than what many of us grew up with. https://support.google.com/docs/answer/148505
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by abraae on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:18PM (#29595144)
Perhaps I'm sensitive as a NZer, but would you feel the same if the deleted document was a plan for a nuclear weapon etc?

Though while giving a warning is clearly inappropriate, they should certainly have explained what they did.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by ArchOversight on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:25PM (#29595264)
Yes, I would feel the same if the deleted document was a plan for a nuclear weapon.

If it is not shared with anyone, why should a cloud provider get to decide what I can and can't store?

I want to be able to use that storage as an extension of my local hard drives/SSD's with the ease of use of accessing it between different devices. I still consider it my data.

That those bits and bytes happen to represent a document for a nuclear weapon shouldn't matter.

Now if you were to ask if I believe people should store a video of the Christchurch shooter? No, I full-heartedly believe its kind of sick that someone would want to store/archive that, but I don't want a cloud provider making that decision.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by pas on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:59PM (#29595736)
Because it's their ToS, their hard drives, their business. Doing it without at least a day prior notice seems to be a very big no-no, but it obviously did not matter to their bottom line. The general public does not care about these issues enough, because there are other issues in society that seem to be more important for the plurality. (Just to name one crazies shooting people.)
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by thrill on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:33PM (#29595388)
it remains their property on which you store your preciousness
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by ajb on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:21PM (#29596068)
We had that sort of thing in 'real property' too. Today most jurisdictions limit the supervision landlords can decide to implement over tenants (who in fact have a 'property right' in many cases over the property as well as the freeholder, and the right to 'peacefully enjoy' (without intrusion) their home) .

It seems like eventually the law will have to change so that these companies have to start treating users like tenants rather than serfs.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by vorpalhex on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:30PM (#29595336)
The video of the christchurch shooter is a primary source for a historical event, in the same way that combat footage is.

When primary sources are not available to the public then lies have the same footing as truth.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by morpheos137 on Friday December 17, 2021 @07:29PM (#29600093)
Recently I have discovered that google has nuked hundreds of North Korean videos. This upsets me as needless destruction of the historical record. I wonder how people would feel if something like google was around after world war II and censored hundreds of videos of nazi atrocities. It is wrong for a public forum like Youtube or public resource like google drive to restrict content based on subject matter with very few limited exceptions. All political and war footage should be free from restriction.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/09/14...

Stimme Koreas is now gone too.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by vorpalhex on Friday December 17, 2021 @09:11PM (#29600845)
It's never too late to join the digital hoarding initiative.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by morpheos137 on Friday December 17, 2021 @10:48PM (#29601423)
Well it kind of is too late when the historical videos are pulled down and you do not have another source besides Youtube. I am sure that academic and even possibly open source intelligence researchers are similarly frustrated assuming they did not all download the videos many of which had been on the platform for many years.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by willcipriano on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:55PM (#29595679)
Nuclear weapons aren't all that complicated, it's the enrichment that is hard. It's a large scale industrial process that requires a well equiped specialized facility. We can detect these activities from space, that's how big we are talking.

You can get a rough idea of what is needed from Wikipedia. They are simpler machines than a automobile engine, at least in the sense that there are fewer parts involved.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by BTCOG on Friday December 17, 2021 @07:07PM (#29599909)
Yes, and you can legally and readily get all the information for all steps of the manufacture.

As far as encryptions and data go I just echo that "not your drive, not your data" remains true and that encryption is not going to stop a cloud provider from deleting your encrypted content. Feels like I've been saying this for 10 years now (I have) but I truly do not believe cloud use is the future for computing. Drives and mass storage are always getting cheaper.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by dhimes on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:01PM (#29596759)
It's kind of a tough trick to get them to detonate properly.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by willcipriano on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:16PM (#29596993)
A analogy, you can probably find full schematics of a Tesla, or close to it, but that isn't the problem. The car factory is the problem. How do you get one of those? If you have the resources to obtain one, you also have the resources to hire engineers to design a car for you.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by throw10920 on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:56PM (#29596659)
> would you feel the same if the deleted document was a plan for a nuclear weapon

Those two situations aren't even remotely comparable - nuclear weapon plans are straight-up illegal for individuals to own in the US, so by removing one of those, Google would be complying with federal law.

The Christchurch shooting video was not illegal under any law that I'm aware of, so Google was not legally required to delete it, and it was a primary source for a historical event, so Google shouldn't have deleted it, especially not from users' private drives that they weren't sharing (as then you can't even claim that they were spreading extremist material).

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by pyuser583 on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:22PM (#29597861)
There was a legal case in the US about this … the government accidentally declassified the blueprints for a nuclear bomb.

A magazine tried to publish the blueprints. The government argued all nuke related info is classified regardless of actual legal status.

The federal government dropped the case, fearing they would lose.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by Majestic121 on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:37PM (#29595443)
Why would you delete historical footage ? No one would even think to destroy or censor the footage from Auschwitz
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by pyuser583 on Friday December 17, 2021 @09:17PM (#29600878)
During WWII, Roosevelt and Churchill new about the holocaust and actively censored it from the press.

They didn’t want political pressure to stop it.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by captainoats on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:40PM (#29595475)
Yes, for US citizens the right to information is almost unlimited. Even plans for (nuclear) weapons is protected unless it’s stolen classified material, you intend to develop a nuclear weapon, or you intend to export that information.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by tomjen3 on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:16PM (#29595980)
Having principles mean you support those even for the people you disagree the most with.

In this case, people could have had the video because they agreed with the shooter, to using it to show people how horrible terror really is.

Regardless, I fully support peoples right to have videos of terrible events.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by xtracto on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:40PM (#29596367)
I hear you, even though you are downvoted. Right here in the ~10 comments you have from Americans we can see the "double standards" that people adopt. There was no outrage (actually some "anti-outrage") when Apple, Google and AWS censored Parler, an app that allowed "freedom of expression".

People draw the line when it affects their beliefs, in that case they say it was justified for Google, Apple and AWS to censor an application that potentially can be misused. But they get outraged at the thought of removing a video of a massacre, and also they outrage at the thought of limiting their access to tools that are made for the main sole purpose of killing people.

Go figure!

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by Majestic121 on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:20PM (#29597839)
If you want to compare apples and apples, no American would think to remove videos of 9/11 or the Floyd murder.

But it's not even about Americans, I'm from France and it's the same, no one would think to remove videos about the 11/13 except to keep it off Facebook so that kids would not see it.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by abraae on Saturday December 18, 2021 @04:17AM (#29603086)
I'm as much for my rights to hold whatever digital data as probably most other people on this thread.

But at the same time there are abominations of pure evil that should never exist, not even for "historical interest".

Somewhere in the middle there's a line.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 18, 2021 @12:01AM (#29601814)
Parler is/was a company with millions of dollars and millions of users.

It's entirely reasonable to handle that differently from someone's personal data storage.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by ktkoffroth on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:26PM (#29595275)
Video of a tragedy, while deplorable, is not on the same planet as plans for a nuclear weapon. Are you also of the opinion that thing like live leak should not exist/be accessible?
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by morpheos137 on Friday December 17, 2021 @07:30PM (#29600107)
You do know that liveleak shut down this year, right? We are truly entering an era of restricted speech.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by shmel on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:53PM (#29595647)
It is a very slippery slope. Would you feel the same if it was a genomic sequence of a novel respiratory virus? Would you say it is a plan for a bioweapon and hence must be forbidden?
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by BlueTemplar on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:48PM (#29599305)
Thankfully those are even more "mutually destructive" than nuclear weapons.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by quinnjh on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:12PM (#29598992)
And the slope keeps slipping, what if new virology startups are gatekept by having their research materials flagged as bioweapon precursors?
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by lamontcg on Friday December 17, 2021 @10:57PM (#29601483)
This is probably the worst example to use.

It is like arguing against capital punishment using Ted Bundy's case as example. Generally that works the other way with most people and that's the kind of person they enthusiastically support the state murdering.

Similarly the reaction of most people to Google removing that video is going to be "good" and you're going to have a very uphill battle convincing them otherwise, and you're probably going to lose.

If you talk about university researchers that study pornography and Google nuking their research or their ability to share their research with other institutions, you'd probably make more headway.

It is only on a site like HN where the most upvoted commment is "OMG they deleted practically the worst video imaginable from a mass shooting incident can you believe those fascists?" and everyone votes it up to the top.

The HN echo chamber bubble is real.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by mleonhard on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:42PM (#29601720)
I think the main point of your comment is insightful. The final two sentences are distracting and unnecessary. How about deleting them?
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by lamontcg on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:53PM (#29601775)
No, they're really accurate and to the point, its quite relevant that HN is an echo chamber.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by chii on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:43PM (#29601729)
it's not a bad example at all - the point is that even if the video is vile, it is not and should not be google's mandate to delete private files by applying some extra-judicial moral judgement.

Let the law work - possession of illegal material should be enforced by the police, not by a corporation that the user cannot hold accountable.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by lamontcg on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:54PM (#29601781)
You will not convince anyone to agree with you who does not already agree with those principles already, and you will lose 90% of the rest of the people who find that video horrific and never get past it.