News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by snarf21 on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:14PM (#29595095)
I wonder if in the future we'll need a "unique-inize" app that will make trivial changes to pictures and videos that change their hash and their size by a few bytes to defeat this kind of nonsense. Changing even one pixel's hue on one frame by a small amount should make the whole thing encode (depending on codec) to a different size and hash.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by SavantIdiot on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:22PM (#29595207)
There are other kinds of hashes besides cryptographic hashes, which tolerate differences, e.g. you can change things around and still get the same hash. This is what Apple does (or rather did) for their cloud scanner.

Then there are other non-hash methods, similar to how Shazam determines a song in a noisy room. Poles, zeros, FFTs, there are many other strategies that are fault-tolerant.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by snarf21 on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:30PM (#29595329)
Sure but it becomes an arms race. There is also a lot of people that have shown that you can make images of dogs and cats that hash to Apple's hash detector. At some point a white hat is going to start making memes that cause hash collisions. When 300M all violate some hash trigger, it will cause a stir and restart the game.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by kurthr on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:50PM (#29597476)
Sure, but just compress and encrypt. It won't play in place, but otherwise it's nondetectable (other than by out of band timing/metadata or very rough size estimates).
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by bshipp on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:49PM (#29598162)
...which is what floors me when Google made this statement. I thought the whole benefit of their Google drive system was deduplication of common files to minimize storage space costs. If they start tinkering with private files then people have no choice but to encrypt everything.

This will cause their storage requirement to explode. However, if the goal is only to prevent public sharing of content in contravention of the user agreement then I'm surprised it took them this long to implement this.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by 41b696ef1113 on Saturday December 18, 2021 @03:12PM (#29608083)
How many people have the wherewithal to encrypt their content? Even if some have the technical capability, how many are willing to take the reduced quality of life required for what is probably a low probability risk?
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by RachelF on Sunday December 19, 2021 @05:35PM (#29619177)
You can use something like Syncdocs https://syncdocs.com which supports encryption/decryption on the fly to Google Drive
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by jmclnx on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:17PM (#29599055)
Came here to say this. Only an idiot (should say people without knowledge) would upload any personal data to the "Cloud" without encrypting it first. That includes pictures.

As for size, you can always tar/encrypt its dir and include dummy files to modify its size.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by Zamicol on Friday December 17, 2021 @12:44PM (#29595539)
As long as Google is willing to serve binaries, encryption solves this.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by rainbowzootsuit on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:47PM (#29599299)
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by ksec on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:46PM (#29599291)
To battle the Cloud storage paradigm with uniqueness is always going to be a cat and mouse game.

I wish the future is a NAS that is simple, fault tolerant ( Bit-Flip protection, Error Correction, Drive Redundancy ) and extremely affordable. That is something the Apple Time Capsule should have been.

Right now I cant even get a 2x 2.5" 2TB HDD and a NAS enclosure for under $200 RSP. I was hoping Kobol would be it someday. But chip shortage and many other things had them canceled the project.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by beagle3 on Saturday December 18, 2021 @03:47AM (#29602939)
Synology isn’t the cheapest, but they’ve made it “just work”. Every few years - both for home, and for work, I consider getting a “more serious” storage system or building one; and every time I do a serious comparison and end up choosing Synology over building my own FreeNAS/TrueNAS/etc for home, and preferring Synology over NetApp for work.

I do have a couple of NetApps for mission critical stuff; and one of my customers runs an Isilon which I have to support; for almost every workload that can tolerate a few minutes of planned downtime per month, the Synology wins bigly as long as you have knowledgeable IT staff.

And no, you don’t want an Isilon or a NetApp if you don’t have knowledgeable IT staff around - you want a synology (or to get better IT)

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by squarefoot on Saturday December 18, 2021 @03:47AM (#29602938)
> Right now I cant even get a 2x 2.5" 2TB HDD and a NAS enclosure for under $200 RSP

You can get comparatively much more for much less if you look carefully at the used market and spend some time building it for yourself. My 5 bays home NAS cost me just a bit over €130, excluding disks of course: €46 for a SUPERMICRO X7SPA-L mainboard and €88 for a Ultron RPS19-G3380 case, power supply included. All purchased from ebay sellers. I already had the memory modules plus an additional slow SATA controller I use for a non RAID disk, so had to buy only the disks locally. It runs XigmaNAS and has been rock solid with multiple 1 year+ uptimes interrupted only for maintenance or disk upgrades.

Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by StreamBright on Saturday December 18, 2021 @04:00AM (#29603001)
I think there are pretty good solutions out there with zfs.
Re:Google Drive could soon start locking your files by Traubenfuchs on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:27PM (#29597176)
They are way ahead of you, with stuff like neuralhash.

Does it work? Mostly. Can it be tricked? Yes.