News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by georgeburdell on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:21PM (#29526515)
>Even after becoming the world's largest panel maker, the company continues to lean heavily on government subsidies. In 2019, BOE received $400 million in subsidies from various Chinese local and provincial governments. Per Chinese sources, from 2010 to 2019, they took in over $1.7 billion of subsidies - constituting over 50% of their net profit during this time.

This is why legislation such as the CHIPS Act should not be seen as corporate welfare but rather as leveling the playing field.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by tooltalk on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:21PM (#29526846)
I'm no fan of gov't handouts, but I guess you sometimes need to fight evil with evil. America's semiconductor manufacturing is down to only 13% of global chip production share and declining -- the country's manufacturing industry would get wiped out without the same level of subsidies or protection provided by the Chinese or Taiwanese gov't.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by ren_engineer on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:38PM (#29526921)
>evil

it used to be common sense not to hand over your nation's strategic assets to potential foreign adversaries, common Americans all intuitively knew shipping manufacturing to China was bad. Wall Street greed and bribed politicians allowed this to happen. Evil is selling out your nation for profit

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by addicted on Sunday December 12, 2021 @09:01AM (#29529663)
Common people have benefitted greatly from shipping manufacturing to China.

Americans are richer than ever. The problem in America, however, is that the distribution of that wealth has become completely lopsided so it’s concentrated in a few hands. That’s a domestic policy issue.

Outsourcing manufacturing is different, however, from shopping away strategic assets and not investing in keeping strategic manufacturing capacity alive, which once again is a failure of US domestic policy.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by adreamingsoul on Sunday December 12, 2021 @10:00AM (#29530130)
Any data to back up that claim?
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by bojangleslover on Sunday December 12, 2021 @09:42AM (#29529998)
Wealth inequality isn't necessarily bad

http://www.paulgraham.com/ineq.html

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by patentatt on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:51PM (#29532366)
Please tell me again how a billionaire says wealth inequality is OK. Didn't read the whole piece, but on its face it's farcical to listen to anything someone so wealthy has to say on the subject, even if it's pg.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by bojangleslover on Sunday December 12, 2021 @02:26PM (#29532729)
It means the rich can get richer without the poor getting poorer since they are creating wealth, not taking it in a zero-sum or rent-seeking way. So relative inequality increases but the mean standard of living for everyone including the poor rises.

"Poverty and economic inequality are not identical. When the city is turning off your water because you can't pay the bill, it doesn't make any difference what Larry Page's net worth is compared to yours. He might only be a few times richer than you, and it would still be just as much of a problem that your water was getting turned off."

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by dragonwriter on Sunday December 12, 2021 @02:32PM (#29532785)
> It means the rich can get richer without the poor getting poorer since they are creating wealth, not taking it in a zero-sum or rent-seeking way.

Except outside of the most abject poverty that is fairly rare in the developed world, utility/disutility is more a function of relative economic status than absolute economic status. So, in the only sense that matters, this is at least oversimplified; you have to improve absolute wealth on the lower end considerably just to offset the disutility of increased equality and break even. It is possible to increase inequality and have everyone better off in utilitarian terms, but improvements in the usual economic measures are not sufficient to show that because those are poor proxies for utility.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by niij on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:46PM (#29526946)
There's a stark difference between selling out and refusing to use public funds to subsidize large corporations.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by wsc981 on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:38AM (#29527629)
Import taxes could also protect a countries strategic industries and in that case subsidies might not be needed. I kinda feel using import taxes on foreign goods that are a threat to local industries are a better approach that providing subsidies.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by enaaem on Sunday December 12, 2021 @08:10AM (#29529329)
The foreign company will still have an advantage in other places of the world if your company wants to export to the same locations.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by nine_k on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:39PM (#29527202)
Are you opposed to anti-dumping legislation, too?

Because I see subsidizing exports through the nose as a way of dumping on foreign markets.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by Turing_Machine on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:22AM (#29527362)
Well, it pretty much requires a large corporation to crank out high-quality OLED displays. It's not the kind of thing that can be hand-crafted by a one-person shop on an artisanal basis.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by 1-6 on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:10AM (#29527328)
There’s also a difference subsidizing large companies that relies on being at the top of the supplier chain vs those that exist somewhere near the bottom or the middle.

Evaluating the tech stack is very important and usually at the very top you find trivial technologies that are not difficult to replicate. This is where you find brand, trademarks, and marketing.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by moralestapia on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:57AM (#29527500)
>usually at the very top you find trivial technologies that are not difficult to replicate

Maybe in other markets, anything related with semiconductors has a HUGE capital barrier to entry. Exhibit A: ASML's EUV machines.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by wincy on Sunday December 12, 2021 @03:49AM (#29528090)
I think the concept GP was using is lowest level of abstraction to highest level. Twitter can be cloned easily. ASML’s EUV machines cannot. I don’t think he meant “high technology”
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by pmontra on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:04AM (#29528645)
By the way, a common pattern of technology trasfer is a company buys a product, reverse engineer it and in a few iterations (which could be many years long) it competes on price or on quality with the original manufacturer.

I understand that an EUV machine is much more complex than a chisel but how difficult (in time) would be to clone one? Did anybody already start doing it?

A scenario is: China invades Taiwan, the chip factories blow up so China doesn't get them, it takes years to build them somewhere else for the rest of the world but China won't have those machines from ASML ever (embargoes.) But can they buy one now and clone it in a reasonable time?

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by tooltalk on Monday December 13, 2021 @02:25AM (#29537529)
My wild speculation: without any outsider's help, 30-40 years, or most likely never.

China has barely 10 years of experience in chip industry and it's not necessarily the most profound one. China's most successful foundry SMIC was made possible by former top TSMC engineers (many with PhD's from top US universities) and it's generally understood that SMIC's most cutting edge 14nm node is really a clone of TSMC N16FFC. Many also suspect 14nm is their limit and can't advanced any further without access to the chip manufacturing supply-chain in the US/Japan/EU, who collectively own 95% of the market. Shanghai Micro Electronic Equipment, SMEE, recently announced that they developed their own 28nm lithography machines, but that's also with help and components from Japan. The 28nm processing is hardly a cutting edge tech and that's not even under US sanction. Even Taiwan/South Korea depend almost entirely on supply-chain from the US/Japan/EU (except wafer).

Now, the key idea here is "outsider's help." It's not impossible if China is allowed to poach engineers from their suppliers/competitors, steal IP, or import highly sensitive, cutting-edge components and materials from the US/JPN/EU. The problem as I see it is, there is obviously no shortage of American multinational companies, such as Apple, Nike, etc,... willing to sell out America's national security or economic interests to make more doh's in China. And Apple isn't just a very profitable US company with the largest market cap in the world, but also it's very well politically connected -- just look at the shenanigan Apple pulled against Qualcomm with their operatives at FTC. The orange man was somewhat of an anomaly and managed to stop this flow, but I'm not so sure about Biden or whoever comes next. The recent revelation, or $270B deal between Tim Apple and Xi, clearly shows what Apple intends to do and where this is going to go if Apple is left unchecked.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by barkingcat on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:25PM (#29527137)
There is also the thing that American corps like to do: sell out and buy out the politicians so they can use public funds to campaign against subsidies, education, and all possible methods to regain the capabilities that they sold out to begin with.

It's like American capitalism wants itself to fail. It's pretty much self sabotage at this point.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by nopenopenopeno on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:48AM (#29527461)
The tendency to destroy itself is both the good and the bad part of capitalism. Karl Marx was pretty sober about this. He always argued capitalism is a necessary stage but externalities would bottom out and the system would inevitably destroy itself.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by rbanffy on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:43AM (#29528810)
The interesting part is that government subsidies like pretty much every responsible government does (China AND the US obviously included) help delay the predicted collapse of capitalism.

What is food stamps for Walmart and Amazon workers if not an unaccounted for government subsidy?

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by nopenopenopeno on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @02:22AM (#29549140)
By that logic, if we truly hated capitalism we could just set off the nukes and never have to worry about stupid capitalism ever again.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by xtian on Sunday December 12, 2021 @07:06AM (#29528916)
In what way has the US refused to use public funds to subsidize large corporations?
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by camillomiller on Sunday December 12, 2021 @04:06AM (#29528145)
LOL but bailing out the financial sector in 2008 without anyone paying for what they did was fine? At least check what’s going on with Evergrande.

You all have it so ingrained that market forces are the only way things should work that you even end up using absolute categories such as good and evil.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by rbanffy on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:13AM (#29528688)
And that is to say nothing about how much money is funnelled into the defence industry. A lot of the American industrial prowess came precisely from that.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by rektide on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:07AM (#29527320)
Semiconductor making is of such general utility that supporting a robust, accessible, at home supplier market seems incredible incredibly beneficial.

If we're just making handouts to support big companys competing to make their own chips, then yeah, it's boring & "evil". But there's a lot to be gained if America could reopen not just companies but foundries, places that take orders. If a nation can get it's citizens access to domestic chipmaking capabilities at competitive prices, that nation can start spawning all kinds of firms specialized in all manners of chips, can create a massive amount of intellectual & market leadership for itself.

I propose that creating silicon foundries again, as a public good, would be enormously enormously beneficial for the intellectual & economic prosperity of a nation.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by eternauta3k on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:13AM (#29527553)
You're not making any clear arguments why foundries in the US would be better (outside the strategic reasons). Firms can already get chips done overseas.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by rektide on Monday December 13, 2021 @08:31PM (#29547070)
I'd love to hear some university perspectives, on how hard it was for them to get their departments able to make chips. My feeling is that the strategy of availability is the key, vast, & dominating factor in all of this. Getting more and more people being creative about chipmaking, by giving them access to chipmaking, is the thing. That patently seems less and less accessible, less possible. The strategy of making your nation a place of great makers, seems, to me, the only thing worth considering, but your definition/restrictions seem- to me- to oppose thinking of how a nation can improve itself, can beget a good & powerful & creative people.

If the world were well served by chip-making, then I think your disregard would be due. But we seem to be well well well into a period of mass consolidation, of less & less accessibility to chip-making. America & many other places that have been hotbeds of intellectual knowledge & creativity will surely languish & die unless the environment can be improved, unless access to the means of production can be secured & made available to the people, to the students, to the upstarts. Ignore that "stragedy" at your nation's mortal peril, imo.

I think it's a bit telling that the Google/SkyWater collaboration is still on 130nm. It's great that some patron is out there trying to encourage novel chip making, trying to reboot a general knowledge in a dying decaying sector. And there's some reasons why perhaps like 40nm or so might be un-strategic a choice. But generally I think access to even vaguely-quasi-modern chipmaking is falling away, is collapsing. The strategy of keeping this industry accessible is, to me, a defining battle.

(That said, OLED making is not where I think accessible, competitive silicon foundries are needed. But this thread, this story is a telling indicator to me.)

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by Synaesthesia on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:38AM (#29527631)
Protectionism and government intervention like bailing out corporations is typical of governments, and is a reason why the US is successful. Just to give one example, if Reagan hadn't protected the chip industry in the 80's it could have been dominated by Japan.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by jjeaff on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:36AM (#29528783)
My understanding is that the US has the most advanced chip making capabilities in the world and is unmatched by anyone. Intel, AMD, Nvidia, Qualcomm.

Is that not true? Does the US constitute only 13% of world chip making because most chips sold are cheap, low powered chips? And if that is the case, does it really matter that we aren't making the cheap stuff?

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by humanistbot on Sunday December 12, 2021 @10:09AM (#29530190)
Chip design != chip manufacturing. Qualcomm, Broadcomm, Nvidia, and AMD are all so-called "fabless" manufacturers, meaning that they design the chips and then send their designs to fabs like TSMC. Intel is the big exception.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by akmittal on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:48AM (#29528825)
AMD,Nvidia and Qualcomm chips are made in Taiwan/Korea. For future Intel also is moving to TSMC Taiwan.

These chips are not cheap by anyway, US has lost advanced chipmaking ground

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by tooltalk on Sunday December 12, 2021 @09:25AM (#29529849)
If it's any consolation, it's not as bad as Japan. They at one point had all the top players in the business -- now hardly anyone recognizes their name.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by beebeepka on Sunday December 12, 2021 @03:27AM (#29528015)
America's semi industry was spawned and supported with government money since the beginning. China is no different.

Capitalism doesn't exist in a vacuum, nor is it magical in the way you imply. You youngsters

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by thevardanian on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:34PM (#29526906)
This is literally not new and has been the case even in the west for centuries. In fact in many ways it contributed to its domination. It's just that the post WW2 era was entirely an anomaly, and one that we got too comfortable with.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by api on Sunday December 12, 2021 @09:59AM (#29530124)
Corporations can't compete with governments, especially large ones with sovereign currencies who can subsidize without bound.

If China is going to do this we either have to do the same or levy corresponding import duties on the product. If we do nothing at all we lose all our industries to China.

Edit: yes the US does this too in other industries like aerospace. That just illustrates the point.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by phkahler on Sunday December 12, 2021 @08:07AM (#29529305)
>> but I guess you sometimes need to fight evil with evil.

Instead of propping up our own companies, a better response might be to ban imports of these government subsidized products. Apple wouldn't be harmed in the slightest, this move is just a cost savings for them.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by freeflight on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:38PM (#29526614)
As if US companies didn't already have those kinds of subsidies [0]. Whole US states will wave away taxes and offer all kinds of perks just to attract the jobs and business of these corporations.

[0] https://subsidytracker.goodjobsfirst.org/parent/intel

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by georgeburdell on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:49PM (#29526674)
According to that website, Intel has received $6B in government subsidies from 1993/2000, variously, to present. Here are Intel's profits for the past 5 full years:

2020: $20.9B [0]

2019: $21B [0]

2018: $21.1B [1]

2017: $9.6B [1]

2016: $10.3B [2]

$6B is a low single digit percentage of their profit going back 28 years. BOE has been subsidized on a whole other level and they're still not consistently profitable.

[0] https://www.intc.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/1439/...

[1] https://www.intc.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/1092/...

[2] https://www.intc.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/1102/...

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by onion2k on Sunday December 12, 2021 @03:06AM (#29527928)
There's a lot of nuance missing from your post. First, $6bn between 1993 and 2000 is worth a bit more in today's money. Second, the $6bn you mention is only what Intel Corp received directly; money to their suppliers, subsidiaries, companies they acquired immediately after the subsidy was granted, etc won't be counted in that total. And lastly, if you counted 2021 in the number you'd have to add tens of billions more due to a huge surge in chip manufacturer subsidies passed by the senate recently.

There's nothing wrong with subsidising Intel. They're competing against countries like South Korea whose government recently announced a package of chip manufacturer subsidies worth $450bn after all. They won't be able to compete if they're aren't given a little help.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by ErikVandeWater on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:48PM (#29526952)
The fact that $6 Billion dollars is a fraction of their profit suggests the United States could just regulate that they and other large US semiconductor firms must produce more chips locally. No need to subsidize.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by colechristensen on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:43PM (#29527219)
Or just put taxes on foreign dumping/oversubsidized products. Development grants are good things but these huge companies don’t need them, have plenty of resources to build capacity and new products. We should be funding new competition and science not playing subsidizing games with our biggest companies.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by tw04 on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:18PM (#29527098)
Remind me how many of the states that are giving tax breaks are majority stakeholders in the companies they're giving tax breaks to. Also, which company can you point to that had 50% of their revenue in subsidies...
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by cma on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:46PM (#29526659)
Why do you think ASML can't sell EUV machines to China? It's because before ASML signed on they were started through a US Govt DoE, US Govt DARPA, and US Megacompany consortium: https://www.photonicsonline.com/doc/asml-joins-euv-llc-team-...

China probably sees things as leveling the playing field too. To find high tech industry that emerges through pure Ayn Rand search through Mogadishu, various favelas, etc., not developed or rapidly developing places.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by rbanffy on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:29AM (#29528757)
The effect of that is that China will eventually acquire their own ASML.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by JumpCrisscross on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:22PM (#29527118)
Agreed. Our society’s seeming cultural inability to mobilise against a proven and motivated ideological adversary may be its death knell. “But meh” might be the answer to how empires dissolve.
[dead]
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by rbanffy on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:24AM (#29528741)
A more interesting idea is what happens if China wins?
[dead]
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by addicted on Sunday December 12, 2021 @09:05AM (#29529688)
And the US has outlasted the USSR and Japan. Both threats disappeared as threats.

And the EU, while extremely successful, does not subsidize their industries (the exception being the airline and airplane manufacturing industries and defense which the US also does).

So whatever lessons China has learnt from the USSR and Japan don’t appear to have a strong track record of success.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by jwmhjwmh on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:09PM (#29527049)
Another win for state economic planning.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by tooltalk on Sunday December 12, 2021 @04:23AM (#29528216)
or more appropriately, it's a win for corporatism led by a multinational company called Apple.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by rbanffy on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:26AM (#29528748)
I’m sorry, but Apple is very much an American company. They only use suppliers in China because capitalism forced them to, otherwise they’d be unable to provide the goods at prices their users would be willing to pay.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by tooltalk on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:33PM (#29534825)
in light of the recent disclosure that Tim Apple committed $270B worth of goodies for China to win some favors from uncle Xi, nobody is buying this rather lame execuse anymore.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by rbanffy on Monday December 13, 2021 @07:13AM (#29538868)
What alternative do they have? To let their competitors beat them? Would the US be better off then?
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by tooltalk on Tuesday December 14, 2021 @03:40PM (#29557303)
Ask Google, Facebook, or better yet Samsung. Apple has no direct competition in the premium phone segment and consequently takes 70% of the entire industry's profit share, despite only 15% in global unit sales.

Not everyone thinks Apple's profit should come before America's national or economic interest.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by eunos on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:23PM (#29526858)
What does it mean by subsidy in this context? Tax breaks?
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by davidjytang on Saturday December 11, 2021 @11:31PM (#29527160)
I worked in another field against Chinese state-owned competitions.

Pretty much for each unit they sell, they not only receive payment from customer, they also receive government payment for the same amount. As a result, they were able to keep the price unreasonably low.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by AYBABTME on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:34AM (#29527402)
How's the CCP financing the subsidies? AFAIK they don't collect taxes on the average citizen/there's rampant tax avoidance.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by est on Sunday December 12, 2021 @08:59AM (#29529645)
> How's the CCP financing the subsidies?

CCP is as a matter of fact the largest VC in China.

Interesting trivia: BOE was considered the most successful example of municipal government VC by Hefei and Chengdu. Hefei bet on both plasma display and LCD, only BOE survived.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by csomar on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:04AM (#29528644)
Their currency doesn't float on the market. Strict capital controls are a hidden tax on exports. Imports are then tariff-ed to balance their sheet. It's an alternative taxation method if you cannot establish a compliant citizenry around your tax system.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by eunos on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:00AM (#29527509)
SOE profits are used as slush fund.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by AYBABTME on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:14AM (#29527558)
What's that?
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by mikehotel on Sunday December 12, 2021 @01:37AM (#29527623)
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by vmception on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:40PM (#29526929)
This is why you finesse as many governments as possible while the people tear themselves up over their government’s budget overruns
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by coolgoose on Sunday December 12, 2021 @08:05AM (#29529290)
I am not against leveling the playing field, but those subsidies are peanuts in the semi-conductor world.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by scoopertrooper on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:40AM (#29527427)
I don't know. If the Chinese government wants to subsidise my OLED screen, I say let them.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by dotancohen on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:48AM (#29527457)
That's extraordinarily short-sighted. When your nation no longer has manufacturing capability and you are beholden to Chinese OLED screens you might think differently. Not only will the price be fit for a monopoly, but also they could freely restrict tech from your other industries, further crippling your nation. Not to mention restricting sales to military and other strategic ventures.

Several decades ago it was food security - the idea that a nation must produce enough of its own food to feed its populace - that was the concern of import policy. Today the field is much, much broader.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_security

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by scoopertrooper on Sunday December 12, 2021 @08:06AM (#29529301)
My nation already has zero OLED screen manufacturing capacity, the world seems to keep spinning.

China will dump out their OLEDs, I’ll get cheaper OLEDs, my nation will make other things and exchange them for OLEDs. China may come to dominate the OLED market, but OLEDs will be displaced by micro-LEDs.

China will never completely control any particular technology simply because, wealthy as they are, they don’t have the resources to afford such a thing. They may be able to buy their way to market dominance, but there will always be alternative sources. Not least, because of the fact they’re not the only country pursuing a strategy of national champions.

Food security is also a bit of a joke. Well not a joke, a cudgel used by the farming lobby to shut down reasoned discussions about whether we should reduce some of the largesses currently extended to farmers. Nations don’t need ‘food security’, they need a functioning global supply chain and reasonable leaders that can restrain the dogs of war.

Notions of things like food security only make wars more likely because nations feel like they’d be more likely to win in the event of one occurring. But really, we all know nobody would win in a war where America got to the point where food security was in question.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by est on Sunday December 12, 2021 @09:00AM (#29529655)
> they could freely restrict tech from your other industries, further crippling your nation

So yeah basically what Trump did to China during the trade war.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by azinman2 on Sunday December 12, 2021 @12:45AM (#29527445)
And in doing so, they put everyone else out of business and then own the market.
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by MikusR on Sunday December 12, 2021 @08:11AM (#29529335)
You know what the company that owns this domain does?
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by rbanffy on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:30AM (#29528763)
Isn’t unregulated capitalism prone to natural monopolies?
Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by markdown on Saturday December 11, 2021 @09:38PM (#29526613)
> This is why legislation such as the CHIPS Act should not be seen as corporate welfare but rather as leveling the playing field.

What are your thoughts on affirmative action?

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by olliej on Saturday December 11, 2021 @10:29PM (#29526877)
To equate compensating for centuries of racist, sexist, etc policies that artificially and deliberately suppressed the success of different races, genders, and other groups to corporate subsidies is unequivocally bullshit.

A better comparison if you really insist on comparing treatment of companies to actual people would be to take two identical companies working in the same market. Force one of them to close. After the second has been established for a few hundred years, allow the one you shut down to reopen, but tell them that they can't charge more than 50% of the price of the established firm, and also say that suppliers don't have to provide goods to that firm, and if they do then those suppliers don't have to provide goods at the same level of quality. Those suppliers also charge more, for the lower quality goods. To be safe, you also don't allow the company to build anywhere near existing commercial or industrial zones, so they also have to pay more for shipping and transit, despite being less conveniently placed.

After a while you say "ok, you can sell to everyone and we aren't going to limit what you can charge, etc". Then you turn around and say "see everything is equal now".

Of course by this point entire industries are built around the version of the product sold by the established firm, the established firm has more resources, the subsidiaries of the established firm have more resources, as do their subsidiaries, because all those subsidiaries have been getting the same preferential treatment. Meanwhile the historically penalized firm has been given a bad rap because the quality of a lower quality of goods, because they got worse materials to start with, they couldn't afford the same quality of workers (in fact they were functionally prohibited from employing the best).

Now people say "of course we pay less for goods from that company, they're lower quality".

It may be a true statement, but the reason isn't because the company is fundamentally flawed, just that the established company has had unending advantages, and those advantages continue to apply even after the original penalties were removed.

Of course this is a gross simplification of what actually happened to the victims of the various repressive laws and policies of various countries, because again, companies are not people.

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by ConcernedSA on Sunday December 12, 2021 @06:03AM (#29528642)
The road to hell is paved with good intentions

I am a coloured South African(an ethnic group that was previously disadvantaged due to apartheid era racial policies) we in South Africa have Affirmative action policies called Black Economic Empower(BEE) (Its open to all previously advantaged racial groups ie Black, Coloured, Indian they just call it BEE) that has led to mass corruption and cronyism.

>Start with crony capitalism, which in South Africa goes by the euphemism “black economic empowerment”. The idea behind it seemed laudable enough—to right a historical wrong. Under apartheid, the country produced white titans of industry such as the Oppenheimer family (owners of DeBeers), while making it hard for black South Africans to own businesses. The ANC(Ruling political party) felt it only fair that there should be black billionaires, too. To give them a leg-up it insisted that mining companies should hand at least 26% of their shares to the “historically disadvantaged”. Mining companies (as well as banks and insurers) did so willingly, diluting existing shareholdings when they transferred stakes to the likes of Cyril Ramaphosa, now the president, along with Patrice Motsepe, his brother-in-law, and Bridgette Radebe, his sister-in-law.[1]

I and alot of South Africans could stomach a one-off payment or one-off percentage equity stake in firms(in South Africa the government instituted a policy that South African Corporate firms would sell shares preferential)to disadvantaged groups but after these shares were sold, the government wanted to continuously repeat it.

>If these handouts had been a one-off tax, their harm would by now have been forgotten. But once the new black shareholders had sold their holdings, the government drafted regulations to repeat the process. And so capital investment in mines fell by 45% between 2010 and 2018, with output falling by 10% and employment by 50,000—a tenth of direct employment in the industry in 2010.[1]

When the government gives support not based on merit and competence but gender, race, religion or ethnicity you undermine industrial policy(Instead of support based on a person's potential ability or ability to do things)With affirmative action you end up institutionalising incompetence.

>Black Economic Empowerment, a policy that incentivises firms to give equity to black investors or business to black-owned suppliers, has created a new generation of Randlords with more political acumen than entrepreneurial talent. “Cadre deployment”, whereby ANC party(Ruling political party) members get jobs on the basis of factional fealty rather than merit, has degraded the state. These appointees steer contracts towards chosen “tenderpreneurs”, who in turn donate to the party. By 2007 Kgalema Motlanthe, a party grandee, said: “This rot is across the board...Almost every project is conceived because it offers opportunities for certain people to make money.”[2]

Many South African feel that our counrty has become "a cappuccino society, A vast, huge, black majority at the bottom with a layer of white cream and a few chocolate sprinklings at the top of it" referring to the small black elite who have gained great riches from the post-apartheid years - from a failed attempt to rebalance the wealth among the many.

Yes, I acknowledge the present-day inequities that racist, sexist, etc policies can cause, but if a Government was serious about addressing historical inequalities then you need to invest in education and skills development. Affirmative action never works in the long term, instead of making people competent and self-reliant,it makes them dependent on handouts.

Industrial policy can sometimes work in South Korea, Taiwan, Certain Industries in China, or it can fail spectacularly and end up being a waste of time and resources Malaysia and South Africa(instead of giving equity stakes and handouts you could have used those same resources to invest in everyone, not just a particular race, ethnicity, gender or religion.)

Affirmative action policies can actually be self-defeating and harm the industrial policies you have.

Contrast Taiwan and Malaysia's Industrial Policies and Outcomes

Taiwan's has currently a healthy semiconductor industry with many successful and impressive firms ie TSMC, etc.

And Malaysia with its affirmative action laws favouring certain ethnicities that ultimately undermined their industrial policies. The corruption and shenanigans that result from affirmative action policies happened in South Africa also happened in Malaysia and undermined their long term industrial goals.

Appropriating a quote from Deng Xiaoping "It doesn't matter whether a cat is black or white, as long as it catches mice." This is taken to mean that as long as the economy works, it is a good economy.

Affirmative action is equality of outcome. Do people think they have godly powers that can guarantee certain outcomes or results? There is an inherent risk of failure in all ventures and endeavours.

A correct criticism of capitalism is when it does not provide equal opportunity and so we should always strive to provide equal opportunity, but people confuse that with the equal outcome when, equal outcome can only be enforced through violence because different people, free people make different choices and when they make different choices they have different outcomes if you don't let them suffer the consequences of bad choices or reap the rewards from good choices then you have to use force or violence to get a prefered outcome

If people are really serious about freedom and equality then you should want not just the freedom to succeed, but also the freedom to fail.

[1]https://www.economist.com/leaders/2021/07/24/end-of-the-line...

[2]https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2021/07/24/...

Re:Apple’s Newest OLED Supplier by markdown on Sunday December 12, 2021 @07:02PM (#29535031)
So the affirmative action policies of South Africa failed because they only benefited the then political elite. That doesn't make affirmative action bad.

This is like saying rain is bad because it only fell on one farm out of a hundred.

> if a Government was serious about addressing historical inequalities then you need to invest in education and skills development.

So you agree that affirmative action can work. Your objection is to the way that the political elite pretended to implement affirmative action for the many while really only being interested in enriching themselves.

> Affirmative action is equality of outcome.

Nonsense. It can be whatever you want it to be. If you gave scholarships to impoverished black kids, that isn't a guarantee of a good outcome. Just that those poor black kids have the same opportunity than the rich whites. Now if you said that n% of all board seats of stock exchange listed companies had to be POC, then that would be equality of outcome.

Just because your South African politicians fucked your country over, doesn't make affirmative action bad.