News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ok_dad on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @11:42AM (#29474703)
So, what's the best wifi gateway with extra access points for a home that I don't have to screw with and doesn't spy on me or have cloud crap? My ISP sent a Google wifi thing but I'd rather pay a few hundred than use that for 10 bucks a month to rent that thing, and I don't trust Google.

Edit: Thanks for all the answers, from me and anyone else who was looking! I have some good ideas from the below comments and hopefully this thread helps some others as well.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by imiric on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:58PM (#29477432)
I'm currently in the process of moving my home network from Ubiquiti to an open solution with a few Mikrotik RBM11Gs to serve as APs, and will probably also replace my Netgate SG-3100 with pfSense with likely a PC Engines machine. All will probably be running OpenWrt, though if that's too limiting / buggy, I'll just use plain Linux or OpenBSD on them.

The major benefit of this setup is that you don't depend on some manufacturer for updates. Given Ubiquiti's and Netgate's recently hostile actions towards users and open source, this provides a great peace of mind. The other benefit is that you're free to upgrade your hardware as needed, which particularly for WiFi cards is great to have. Right now I'm sticking with WiFi 5 because of the costs, but in the future upgrading to 6E would just be a matter of changing the cards (assuming they're supported by the OS).

Speaking of cards, I went with Compex WLE1216V5-20, which have an Atheros chip and are thus much better supported on Linux than Broadcom, etc.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by donmcronald on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @04:36PM (#29478534)
Have you ever looked at VyOS (https://vyos.io/)? IIRC EdgeOS was a fork of Vyatta and Vyatta became VyOS. Their LTS pricing doesn't work for small businesses, but the rolling release might be an option for home use.

It's sad that everyone only wants to accept huge amounts of cash these days. Take VyOS as an example. The smallest licensing option they have is $6k per year for unlimited installs. That makes it completely unobtainable for a person that I build firewalls for, so we don't even evaluate it.

In terms of percentages, we could probably add about 15% to every firewall sold and that could be passed along to a software vendor. If we had a self serve portal where we could download LTS releases and generate lifetime licenses we'd send them 15% of our firewall (sales) revenue and they'd basically never hear from us.

In real numbers that would be about $1-1.5k a year as long as we could pay per device as we sell/install them. Using pfSense as an example it'd be in the range of $10k since we started using pfSense and, in the last 5 years, I think I've only had 1 issue I couldn't figure out on my own where I had to go ask on their forum.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by broknbottle on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @06:50PM (#29479690)
Take a look at DANOS. It’s the open source version of ATT’s Vyatta.

https://www.danosproject.org/

https://danosproject.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/DAN/pages/819...

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by imiric on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @12:49PM (#29487946)
I haven't, but I remember Vyatta from many years ago, and I'm looking for something less enterprisey. If OpenWrt becomes a problem, I just might fall back to plain Linux or OpenBSD. Though OpenWrt is quite stable and fully featured from what I've read. I really don't need anything special for home use.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ericd on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:21PM (#29477692)
I've been considering replacing my EdgeRouter with a pfsense box (probably the Netgate 6100), have you been dissatisfied with your Netgate?
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by imiric on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:59PM (#29478154)
I also have an EdgeRouter, but will probably replace that last since it works fine and doesn't require any of the Ubiquiti Controller / Cloud shenanigans.

I've had intermittent LAN dropouts on the SG3100 that I couldn't explain from the logs. That in addition to Netgate's hostility towards open source with how they're handling pfSense, and the whole pfSense+ product, just puts a bad taste in my mouth when it comes to supporting the company. For the hardware and software stack they provide, the devices are very overpriced IMO. Same with Ubiquiti, though at least with Ubiquiti you're paying for a set-it-and-forget-it network, as long as you're willing to fully invest in their ecosystem. They're the Apple of network prosumer equipment.

But my main interest in abandoning both is investing in devices that I can upgrade and maintain independently and at my own pace. It will also be cheaper in the long run, though it does require some tinkering to setup.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ericd on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @06:42PM (#29479621)
Got it, thanks very much for the summary! Agreed that the EdgeRouter is fine, but the one I have is a bit anemic (ER Lite), and I've been disappointed with Ubiquiti's push for increased telemetry/phoning home, so I didn't want to buy a more powerful ER to replace it.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by locusm on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @08:45PM (#29480419)
I find Ubiquiti wifi to be excellent and their EdgeRouter line has been reliable too but the routing products are just missing basic stuff.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by tw04 on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @09:24PM (#29480619)
Why not just go to opnsense? That’s what most folks have moved to that have gotten fed up with netgates shenanigans.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by imiric on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @12:53PM (#29488007)
I thought about it, but WiFi cards are generally better supported on Linux, and since I'll be running OpenWrt on the APs, I'd prefer having a unified OS for both APs and the router.

I guess it will depend on how much I like OpenWrt :) I don't have any experience with it.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by tw04 on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @03:09PM (#29489781)
If you do go the OPNSense route, just be aware you need to disable the spectre/meltdown mitigations to get reasonable performance. pfsense has them disabled by default.

In tunables you need:

hw.ibrs_disable="1"

hw.mds_disable="0"

vm.pmap.pti="0"

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by magicalhippo on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:58PM (#29478142)
Unless something radical has changed in the last half year or so, pfSense will be a giant PITA if you have "residential" IPv6. That is, anything but a completely static prefix.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by technofiend on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @08:03PM (#29480208)
I am unhappy with pfsense's inability to push gigabit traffic on my hardware, but IPV6 works fine for me. I'd be curious what isp you have and what your issue is.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by magicalhippo on Thursday December 09, 2021 @07:38AM (#29496679)
My ISP has a dynamic prefix, so it changes "willy-nilly", sometimes per day.

With pfSense, the issue was primarily two-fold. First was the fact that all the firewall rules and such did not support dynamic prefixes. Major PITA right there.

Second was the DNS server, that is, when using pfSense as a DNS server I couldn't figure out how to prevent it from sending the public IPv6 address to clients. Thus when the (public) prefix changed, DNS stopped working on the clients.

Some of this might have improved since I last used it, but I switched to OpenWRT and haven't looked back for a second.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ericd on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @06:44PM (#29479642)
Oh interesting, thanks for the heads up.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by simplyaccont on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @05:55PM (#29479245)
i build in the past a few times APs with compex cards. the problem it's that some of them have extra large form factor and won't fit standard mpcie slots. i had to build an adapter :/ eventually instead of upgrading to new iteration i got a couple of netgear r7800 and flashed them with openwrt. the router is on separate x86 box
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by dprice1 on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:04PM (#29475096)
I used to work on a product for secure small-biz Wifi, and so dogfooded my own product in my house. When that was over and I took that out of my house, I had my eyes on Ubiquiti, and it is an impressive ecosystem. But as others have said, it's out of stock all the time, and Ubiqiti are teasing people right now with their next-gen product which is available but also unobtainable.

Eventually I picked the Asus ZenWifi system, and honestly it works great (I have no affiliation with Asus). There's no cloud account to create when you install it. The app is acceptable. There are various security things you can turn on which seem to require cloud assistance, but the core product seems to work very nicely. Any time you try to turn on something which might cause the system to share extra data, a popup appears to explain that to you.

It's so powerful, Wifi-wise, that I bought three nodes and only deployed two. I use it with Ethernet backhaul but it has a dedicated radio for wireless backhaul. It has ethernet LAN ports on each node, and each node is identical to every other node (i.e. there is no "base" and "satellite"). I went from spotty Wifi throughout my 2,000 sq ft house to very strong Wifi throughout. I wrung my hands for a long time because I gave up VLANs and some other things I wanted, and then said the heck with it.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by formerly_proven on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:07PM (#29475155)
Ubiquiti seems to have turned into a complete shit-show in the last five years.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by donmcronald on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:58PM (#29477442)
Subscriptions are coming I bet. The whole ui.com account thing where they force you to create an account and link new devices like the UDM Pro are the writing on the wall IMO. They back-peddled on adding it to the v2 firmware of Cloud Key's IIRC, but the end game is likely to get everyone paying per device per month.

The last time they had a pay per device per month service it started at $1/device/month and then they bumped it to $10/device/month. Somehow they thought the one time cost of a device should become an annual cost and that people would adopt it. Obviously that flopped.

Now think of the same scenario, but everyone's gotten complacent and are getting dependent on their devices that are linked back to ui.com. They might not blatantly flip the switch, but now that they have a hook for licensing checks they can start shifting development so new features are licensed for a monthly fee rather than getting them free forever when you buy a device.

IMO as soon as the all-in-one devices that perform management (ex: UDM Pro) while being linked to a ui.com account get enough adoption they'll shift to some kind of feature licensing or simply release new devices / revisions that require "cloud licensing" or something similar.

They're also very flippant when it comes to breaking devices in a way that prevents a connection to the controller. They think SSHing into broken devices to fix them is reasonable and it's not if you have to deal with many sites / devices.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by nullwarp on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:25PM (#29475421)
Yeah easily the most annoying hardware we have to manage to the point where we will no longer use it.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by InTheArena on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:33PM (#29476362)
Its gotten much much better over the last six months or so. The transition to generic linux for their router line was rough, but the worst seems to be over.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by duffyjp on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:30PM (#29476313)
I went from AirPort Extreme -> Google Wifi -> Asus RT-AX86U. They all have their pros and cons but the Asus is immensely more powerful. I love that it can mount a large USB drive as Time Machine, and the wireless is so fast it's actually usable. When there's a 2.5G WAN port you know they mean business.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by dhess on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:24PM (#29475417)
I've heard good things about TP-Link's Omada EAP series. Did you happen to look into that platform?
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by InTheArena on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:38PM (#29476436)
I tried it when Unifi was in bad straits last year. It's a poor copy of the Ubiquti interface. They copied the worst aspects of that UX.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by depingus on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:00PM (#29477459)
One of the nice things about the Omada AP's is that it can run (and be configured) in standalone mode without the need of a controller. I bought one to replace the single Ubiquiti I had and its been solid; better even!
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ksec on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:26PM (#29476253)
>and Ubiqiti are teasing people right now with their next-gen product which is available but also unobtainable.

Any links or reference. Cant find anything with a quick Google Search.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by InTheArena on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:32PM (#29476348)
There is also the classic UDM. Also purchaseable on store.ui.com. For people who want a prosumer alternative to the crappy routers that telcos/cables give, this is a great option. Highly recommend, but it also a gateway drug.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by gorkish on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:41PM (#29476468)
Unfortunately the UDR which replaces the UDM costs a mere $79 and delivers more functionality including Wifi 6. UDM is kind of a poison pill at the moment.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by InTheArena on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:28PM (#29476290)
Unifi Dream Router. You must create a account on store.ui.com, then enable pre-release hardware in the menu options.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ksec on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:42PM (#29476490)
Thx, it is the same UDR with Wifi 6.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ok_dad on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:54PM (#29475855)
This sounds like a good plan for me, thanks for the information, I will put this on my list of things to research more.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by dont__panic on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:18PM (#29476151)
I'm not sure I would call Ubiquiti "impressive" after their recent bout of security breaches: https://krebsonsecurity.com/2021/03/whistleblower-ubiquiti-b...

Not exactly what I want to see in the device that can literally compromise all of my other devices. Am I missing something -- did this turn out to be nothing, or did folks decide that Ubiquiti has bounced back? This seemed really really serious at the time and turned me completely off from ever purchasing one of their products.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by InTheArena on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:31PM (#29476336)
Turns out this story was planted by the perp to tank the stock after Unifi refused to give in to his "anonymous" ransom demand.

Not great - but more classic insider attack, then security breach.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by dangoor on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:26PM (#29476254)
As noted in the update to the article, Ubiquiti was a victim of an extortion attempt from an employee. This is a pretty difficult attack to prevent.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by dont__panic on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:40PM (#29476454)
Ah, that's a fair point. I guess at some level a sufficiently privileged employee can manage this in almost any system. But there's also some discussion of backdoors and inadequate access control in Ubiquiti's backend here that could concern privacy-minded folk.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by raesene9 on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:04PM (#29476792)
this is true but if the details in this post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29456593 and others in that thread are to be believed, they have some serious security problems.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ksec on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:25PM (#29476229)
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by cycomanic on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:50PM (#29478044)
I heard good things about PCengines APU products (e.g. see here https://teklager.se/en/products/routers/apu3d4-open-source-r... I'm not affiliated). You essentially run openwrt or pfsense on your own hardware. Alternatively, many people are now putting pfsense/opnsense on their own hardware. In particular thin-clients are very capable and some can be easily be retrofitted with multiple ethernet ports (however, prices have gone up significantly for some of these over the last year). The one thing you need to be careful with is wifi hardware compatibility.

Some instructions here: https://boratory.net/pfsense-firewall-futro-s900/ https://forums.servethehome.com/index.php?resources/introduc...

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ValentineC on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @04:20PM (#29478381)
> The one thing you need to be careful with is wifi hardware compatibility.

I'd suggest using old consumer routers as access points.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by dont__panic on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:48PM (#29475774)
Hot take: All routers completely suck right now, and most of them are built to spy on your network at worst and accidentally expose you to cyberattacks at best.

There are two choices, the way I see it:

1. Invest in a decent router (probably $150-200 at least) and throw openwrt on it. You'll need something with serious CPU beef because openwrt relies more on software than hardware, and most routers use hardware for QoS etc., hence the price tag. You'll also need to actually understand the multitude of settings offered by openwrt if you care at all about security or performance -- this is nontrivial if you aren't already a network engineer.

2. Buy a used Apple Airport router. The last generation support AC wifi, which is... basically as fast as the best things out there right now, barring wifi 6E. On the plus side: this comes with mostly sane defaults and good performance, I easily get 600+ mbps up/down on my gigabit internet. On the downside... I think you can only configure airport routers through macOS (and a mostly-dead iOS app), and they don't let you configure all the settings you might want. A fair tradeoff for good, non-footgun defaults IMO, but YMMV.

There's also the third option of creating some bespoke raspberry pi + wifi hardware solution for yourself, but that's likely to get you punched by your flatmates when it inevitably reboots incorrectly during a power outage or overheats or whatever and suddenly you need to spend 2 hours debugging problems without a working wireless connection and everyone else is pissed they can't use the internet. Unless, of course, you're a brilliant network engineer who would never make a silly mistake or have a bug in their custom router solution.

Which I guess is why most people use Google or Amazon spyware for internet in their homes.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ValentineC on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @04:28PM (#29478448)
> 1. Invest in a decent router (probably $150-200 at least) and throw openwrt on it. You'll need something with serious CPU beef because openwrt relies more on software than hardware, and most routers use hardware for QoS etc., hence the price tag. You'll also need to actually understand the multitude of settings offered by openwrt if you care at all about security or performance -- this is nontrivial if you aren't already a network engineer.

Why not OPNsense on an old x86 box?

> but that's likely to get you punched by your flatmates when it inevitably reboots incorrectly during a power outage or overheats or whatever and suddenly you need to spend 2 hours debugging problems without a working wireless connection and everyone else is pissed they can't use the internet.

I thought for a couple of years that my OPNsense setup would pass the Family Acceptance Factor, but one day (a few months back!) it spontaneously wiped itself of its settings — requiring me to plug in a monitor, reconfigure it to boot, and restore my settings from a backup.

My (very annoyed) family had to ask why we had to jump through hoops, and not use a simple consumer router like everyone else.

I'd imagine that OpenWrt would be the same, or worse.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by sliken on Thursday December 09, 2021 @02:38PM (#29501903)
Old x86 boxes tend to be hot, having moving parts (fans), large, and noisy. Sure some folks have a large house, basement, and don't care. For many a nice new reliable (with warranty) widget that burns little power, is silent, has no moving parts, and is tiny/easily mounted is a pretty big win. The edgerouter is pretty good, I have a 6P, but the ubiquiti trend towards subscriptions, cloud management, etc is pretty worrying.

Given that I'd likely keep my next router for 5+ years, I'm hoping for 2.5gbit (if not 10gbit), 4 ports, IPv6 aware (I get a /60 from my ISP), VLANs (so I can keep the random consumer crap segregated off), etc. I had settled on the hardkernel with 6x2.5 Gbit ports, but it's discontinued.

My Ubiquiti 6xp does a great job, I can keep the config file in git, I can assign a IPv6 /64 per port, run custom firewall rules to redirect all DNS to my DNS server (allowing blocking youtube, web games, etc), etc. I block all remote access to my router and from the consumer crap VLAN with watches, TVs, AV receivers, game consoles, etc.

Here's hoping someone ships similar, have my eye on the Mirotek RB5009UG+S+IN, has 1 10G, 1 2.5G, and a bunch of 1G. I'd need a second vlan capable switch with a 10G uplink for my uses, but it's workable. Hoping for similar with a few more faster ports. Even just 2x10G would make a big difference.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by quesera on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @04:37PM (#29478541)
In my (extensive) experience on several different hardware platforms, OpenWRT is far more stable and featureful than stock firmware.

In the worst case, stock firmware would require a hard reset (power cycle) every few weeks. I've had OpenWRT firmware running without interruption (on UPS) for years at a time.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ok_dad on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:53PM (#29475839)
Thanks for that, it is what I figured. I have a really old, nice, router running one of the WRT-like OSes and I really, really don't want to do that anymore. I have a small family and do not want to mess with this stuff. I might just bite the bullet and hook up a few more of the Google routers. I hate using Google, and don't trust them, but I probably trust them more than most other brands in this space. Also, I can't argue that I don't get good performance from their stuff. The only problem is, if I turn off the cloud features with this thing, I can't even do port forwarding or anything! Who the F puts that behind a cloud? Anyways, thanks for the answer.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by dont__panic on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:16PM (#29476121)
Yeah, I've been frustrated with the router space for a while recently so I figured you might benefit from my research (and likely bias as well). Too bad others in this thread downvoted me without responding, though -- if anybody can recommend a decent answer to this question that I didn't cover or explain why I'm wrong, I'm happy to admit that. I would really like there to be a decent router out there for my use case.

The biggest reason I don't use a Google router or something of that ilk is exactly what you mentioned in this comment: I don't want basic functionality like port forwarding locked behind some cloud account that I might have to pay for monthly eventually (or might get shut down). At least my current hardware will likely work perfectly until the hardware fails.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by cycomanic on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:57PM (#29478127)
I think the reason why you got downvoted is because you made broad sweeping statements without anything to back it up. It also does not reflect my experience, the amount of routers running open source systems that one can buy is much larger than it has ever been (I pointed out some options further up the thread), ASUS uses dd-wrt IIRC and others. Also the openwrt/pfsense/opnsense solutions are not really slower than commercial offerings, many offerings now are capable of running OpenVPN at reasonable speeds, in particular if your CPU has AES-NI support.

The way it was written your statement sounded like a Apple shill really.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by daydream on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @09:49PM (#29480754)
I got an Amplifi Alien recently. They are expensive!!! but it has been rock solid and makes full use of my gigabit uplink. I disabled all the cloud stuff so no issues there. I wanted something fast and reliable that I wouldn’t ever have to mess with, and didn’t mind paying more to get it. Wi-Fi is fast on this thing. First run experience was total crap but once I got past that no issues. I recommend it.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by yardstick on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:54PM (#29476658)
What’s your opinion on Mikrotik devices?
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by dont__panic on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:59PM (#29476720)
I looked into them a while back, and they do generally seem to be capable devices. I think they fall into the too-footgun-y category I mention above, though -- if you don't already know a lot about networks, you can easily leave gaping holes in your network security since there are so many options to screw up. They're a bit on the expensive side, too, and honestly even trying to figure out which router to buy was enough of a nightmare to dissuade me.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by Integer on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:11PM (#29476879)
You could try Turris Omnia, it has beefy hardware and sane defaults. Or some other solutions with OpenWRT pre-installed.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by dont__panic on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:18PM (#29477655)
Thanks for this suggestion, I'll have to keep an eye on this the next time I need a router. Definitely on the pricey side, but given that it's fully open source, that's a con I can live with.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by Peanuts99 on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @06:21PM (#29479447)
Instead of buying out of date kit, just buy a second hand Ruckus AP and call it a day. No telemetry and you can set it up in 10 minutes. They're enterprise grade and will last 10 years or more.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by joshu on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @07:01PM (#29479790)
also about twice as fast ubiquiti in my experience
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by tw04 on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:13PM (#29476909)
Synology has been far and away the best I've deployed for "friends and family". I've not received a single phone call for support and it's the first wifi product I can say that about.

They also are introducing full VLAN support in DSM 1.3 which should be out soon if you're a power user. Honestly if they supported PoE for their extenders I probably would have switched out to it. The extenders will mesh wired or wireless which is nice.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by nrclark on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:26PM (#29477066)
Do their products have much in the way of phone-home / cloud access?
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by tw04 on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:38PM (#29477216)
They have a reverse tunnel that you can enable for remote access, but you can disable it.

https://kb.synology.com/en-global/SRM/help/SRM/NetworkCenter...

I personally like that because I can safely remotely access the routers I've deployed for others if I ever have a reason to. They just need to check a box to turn it on or off in the GUI.

They also have an "experience improvement" program that sends home telemetry that can also be disabled. As far as I know there's no "phone home" that you can't turn off if you don't want it.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by aborsy on Saturday December 11, 2021 @05:35AM (#29519935)
QuickConnect makes your NAS wide open to internet. It does so using UPnP or a relay station in a synology data center. Not only Stnology will likely have access to users data at the relay station (see change of certificate!), DSM login page will be open to anyone on internet (you can try random usernames on https://quickconnect.to/ and connect to people’s NASes).

Maybe for routers it’s different, but this service is not secure for NAS.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by bigyellow on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @11:51AM (#29474874)
PC Engines with OpenBSD or Debian Linux. 100% open source hardware, firmware and software, not this closed-source "RouterOS" which is probably bugged.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ahepp on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:30PM (#29477107)
I agree that this is what I would want to use, but doesn't the lack of any kind of specialized switching hardware make it uncompetitive in terms of price/power consumption/speed?

I have on order a mikrotik rb5009UG+S+, which has nine gigabit ethernet ports, one 2.5 gigabit ethernet port, and a 10g sfp+ cage. It has zero fans and benchmarks show it capable of 10 gigabit routing. It costs less than $200.

I love vyos, and I would definitely prefer an open source router. But people I talk to love their mikrotik products. It doesn't seem like the old ones are being abandoned.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by yjftsjthsd-h on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:13PM (#29475236)
Yes, this is easily superior to most options; Debian/OpenBSD/whatever is far more trustworthy than any commercial offering (and many noncommercial options), and hostapd isn't especially hard to set up - a bit of effort up front and then you can just sit on it for years with no more maintenance than installing updates (and even that can be automated with unattended upgrades in Debian). The result is a capable little box that will get security updates indefinitely and which only serves your interests.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by zajio1am on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:46PM (#29475745)
I also use PC Engines Alix with Debian as home router and it is in many ways superior to commercial options, but quality of wifi drivers in Linux is long-term issue.

Also note that in unpatched hostapd channel bonding (40MHz and more channels) does not really work. There is a check whether neighboring channel is crowded (which always is due to overcrowded spectrum) that disables channel bonding. AFAIK Openwrt has patch that allows to override this check, but Debian does not.

As a result, i get consistently higher wifi speeds from commercial wifi APs than from my Alix router.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by dehrmann on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:15PM (#29476109)
I tend to use OpenWRT on Mikrotik devices, but I used a board from PC Engines, and I was was impressed by it. The hardware is very standard, and their support was good. I had a question about the max power the mini PCI port could supply. I got an answer and info on a change I can make that adds a capacitor to help in this scenario.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by _joel on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:50PM (#29476588)
Lovely little systems. Used them to build VPN gateways and for our OOB access at POPs etc.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by djhworld on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:26PM (#29477065)
I've been building a little TP-Link Omada setup for my home. There is a cloud option for the controller software or you can buy the hardware controller (or...run it yourself)

Was going to go all in on Ubiquiti but was put off when reading about the reliability issues, plus was way more expensive.

Pleased with my router + access point + PoE switch + hardware controller :)

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by willis936 on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:01PM (#29475054)
I bought a used Ruckus R610 on ebay for a modest $160 (not including power adapter). I am extremely happy with the hardware performance and the stability and options of the Unleashed firmware.

It says it supports a gateway mode, but as a power user I want a bit more control than what I would expect a WAP to offer. I use an EdgeRouter-4 running whatever the latest official release is. Having separate boxes grants me freedom to do things like mess with Wi-Fi settings while my SO watches a show on Apple TV connected via Ethernet. It's the little things.

I often think of a pfSense build, but then I remember how happy I am with the performance and efficiency of a dedicated box.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by c0nsumer on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:40PM (#29476458)
FWIW, I do OPNsense on a dedicated box (Protectli FW4B) and then an R610 for wireless, with an eBay special EOL'd Brocade switch in the middle.

A dumber switch would be just fine, but I wanted something with 802.1at POE and good VLAN support because I like to break things up a bit.

OPNsense is darned handy, and I like that it does more than an EdgeRouter would, like terminate a Wireguard VPN. The R610 works wonderfully, and the switch... well... it's a switch. Once configured it's kinda transparent.

Moving houses soon, so I got a second R610 to fill in signal on what I perceive will be dead spots due to plaster+lathe construction, and in testing thus far it all seems to Just Work. And like you appreciate, since it's all modular it's a lot easier to maintain than the UniFi stuff when things go sideways.

Very, very happy with this setup.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by squarefoot on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:35PM (#29477867)
> I do OPNsense on a dedicated box (Protectli FW4B)

Interesting, thanks. Looks similar to one I'm considering to purchase when I'm moving next year. I'd be using OpnSense too.

https://www.ipu-system.de/index.html

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by c0nsumer on Sunday December 12, 2021 @02:27PM (#29532733)
Those look nice as well.

I think that any slim/passive box will work well. So long as it has enough NICs and they have quality drivers for hardware offload and whatnot it'll work great.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by wcfields on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:58PM (#29475909)
Before Ubiquiti turned into a garbage fire my go to recommendation for power/performance/budget was used Ruckus APs and pfSense router.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by gonzo on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:43PM (#29475692)
I own Netgate and run R610s at work and at home, if that says anything.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by comeonseriously on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @11:44AM (#29474756)
I use an Edgerouter-x with an eap225 AP located centrally. I have not noticed any spying.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by lephty on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:34PM (#29475567)
+1 for the TP-Link EAP225 and its brethren (they have a cloud management portal, but with just a handful of units they can be managed individually or via self-hosted management server).

I use mine with a Mikrotik RB4011. A very stable and reliable combination.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by djanogo on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @11:51AM (#29474882)
Unify Dream Machine, it's constantly out of stock, you have to keep checking Ubiquiti website to get it. It has cloud access which is used by app to monitor or control it from outside of your house, but you can disable it.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by nullwarp on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:15PM (#29475273)
We use UDM's at work and I really feel like they are half baked products at best. I'm really not a fan and we've stopped using them completely in new installations because of it and have gone back to MikroTik hardware which has never given us issues.

I also just find the UDMs interface an absolute shit show to navigate and find things.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by specto on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:29PM (#29476303)
Agreed... their old edgerouter was much better. Hoping their unifi OS (containerization of their platforms on their hardware) becomes more flexible without the hacks people use now. Until then, I'll keep using my edgerouter...
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by sebazzz on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:23PM (#29475391)
I'm not a fan, but surely the prosumer version has one! Due to system load being above 1 all the time it causes quite some heat, and thus fan noise. Crappy firmware, never fixed.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by bigyellow on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @11:53AM (#29474916)
> It has cloud access which is used by app to monitor or control it from outside of your house, but you can disable it.

Nope, don't trust them to do that after https://community.ui.com/questions/Ubiquiti-ignoring-auto-up...

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by djanogo on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:23PM (#29475397)
Having owned UDM for over a year with auto update off, they never pushed any forced update, I always do it manually every few months. Based on number of updates[1] that they push I can totally give them benefit of doubt that it was a bug.

They have dozens of products which they update constantly, picking one bug at one time as malice and blacklisting a company is not correct. If you go that route you won't have any company left to buy from.

[1]https://community.ui.com/releases

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by InTheArena on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:30PM (#29476312)
You don't need it. You can disable the cloud access starting with the latest firmware.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by fifteenforty on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @07:14PM (#29479911)
Have you heard of Fritz!box from AVM? That’s what I have setup for a few friends, with good success. Personally I use a Mikrotik hap ac 3 in my apartment. They have a ‘mesh’ product in the Audience line.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by sam_lowry_ on Wednesday December 08, 2021 @02:08AM (#29482012)
I am happy with hAP ac2 running OpenWRT.

RouterOS is a bit clunky for a Linux user. They kind of mimick Cisco UX, which is a big mess for everyone except professional network engineers.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ksec on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:30PM (#29476319)
It is a real shame Apple stopped their AirPort Express. But if you could still get one 2nd hand it is great.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by InTheArena on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:36PM (#29476413)
I know it's "in" to shit on ubiqitui right now - but the new Ubiquti Dream Router and the older Unifi Dream Machine are the best spiritual successor I have seen to this device. The UDM comes out of the box with the switch and AP, which performas well, while the UDR also has PoE switches and WIFI 6 in case you want to run other APs or security cameras.

And before anyone else jumps in with old information,as of the latest firmware, it does not require cloud access. And the PPoE performance problem has been fixed.

It was a bumpy transition for a bit because they moved off of Vyatta to generic Linux for the routers.

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by darkr on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:03PM (#29476766)
Not sure if it passes the “don’t have to screw with” test (as configuration generally requires a decent level of networking knowledge), but I’m quite happy with Mikrotik Audience access points/routers.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by 60Vhipx7b4JL on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:06PM (#29475129)
how about openwrt/openwisp?
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by icybox on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @02:25PM (#29477052)
I'm running Netgear N600 / WNDR3800 with OpenWRT since day one. So if you (can) plan for OS before buying, you can dodge a bullet when $VENDOR stops giving f*cks. That particular box has been released in 2011! Mikrotik is good enough (tm) probably, but it's licensed/closed-source. bcantrill once mentioned that "Infrastructure software should be open-source" and I'm adhering to this mantra for 10 years now. Dodged many bullets coming my way ... (i.e. if you want to buy something, can you plan for linux/BSD OS when vendor just doesn't care anymore?)

Would like to hear ideas about Apple's airports running custom NetBSD ... are you guys still running those as edge/internet routers with wifi or have you pushed them to the inside of the network and promoted some other box to the firewall role? I'm kinda stuck in the conundrum "it's unix with PF, it can handle itself" and "it's does not get updates anymore".

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by ctoth on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @12:36PM (#29475593)
As far as I understand, no Wi-Fi 6 routers actually run Openwrt. The only way to get somewhat open software on your Wi-fi 6 or newer device is to use Merlin's fork of Asuswrt. Merlin is pretty big on not making large modifications though, so, for instance, it's very difficult to get Docker running on the device because the default Kernel doesn't ship with a lot of necessary modules. There are some nice apps that use the router directly like Diversion but I would really love a little device that managed everything from VLAN tagging to running little docker appliances and also provided a fast modern AP. Imagine an app store where the moderate power user could click and install apps on their router that all lived in little containers.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by JeremyNT on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @03:38PM (#29477906)
> As far as I understand, no Wi-Fi 6 routers actually run Openwrt.

This is no longer the case. Some devices (albeit not too many) now have working 802.11ax [0].

I know most about the Linksys E8450, which does require a newer snapshot of OpenWRT (it's not yet in a stable release).

[0] https://openwrt.org/toh/views/toh_available_16128_ax-wifi

Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by InTheArena on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @01:28PM (#29476278)
If you can get your hands on it - Check out the pre-release Unifi Dream Router. PoE (to drive other AP), Gateway and built in AP all in one.
Re:MikroTik RouterOS v7 stable released by davidandgoliath on Tuesday December 07, 2021 @04:33PM (#29478499)
Ubiquiti amplifi hd. I use the mesh stuff.