A dumber switch would be just fine, but I wanted something with 802.1at POE and good VLAN support because I like to break things up a bit.
OPNsense is darned handy, and I like that it does more than an EdgeRouter would, like terminate a Wireguard VPN. The R610 works wonderfully, and the switch... well... it's a switch. Once configured it's kinda transparent.
Moving houses soon, so I got a second R610 to fill in signal on what I perceive will be dead spots due to plaster+lathe construction, and in testing thus far it all seems to Just Work. And like you appreciate, since it's all modular it's a lot easier to maintain than the UniFi stuff when things go sideways.
Very, very happy with this setup.
Interesting, thanks. Looks similar to one I'm considering to purchase when I'm moving next year. I'd be using OpnSense too.
I think that any slim/passive box will work well. So long as it has enough NICs and they have quality drivers for hardware offload and whatnot it'll work great.
It says it supports a gateway mode, but as a power user I want a bit more control than what I would expect a WAP to offer. I use an EdgeRouter-4 running whatever the latest official release is. Having separate boxes grants me freedom to do things like mess with Wi-Fi settings while my SO watches a show on Apple TV connected via Ethernet. It's the little things.
I often think of a pfSense build, but then I remember how happy I am with the performance and efficiency of a dedicated box.