News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @08:54AM (#29161723)
It bums me out how the HN crowd lacks any creativity when it comes to anything Crypto. NFTs do solve a problem, and the problem that they solve is that creatives are getting paid for their creative output. Not every NFT is a flex, or used to launder money. Some folks use NFTs as Patreon -> to support artists who's work they admire. "Why not just buy a painting?" Well people who make digital videos and 3d renderings are artists too, aren't they? The promise of NFTs is that they offer a different way for people to interact. Ownership is always based on social constructs, so folks that are involved in this space need to have some consensus of what it means to "own" an NFT on whatever chain. From there these items can be gamified. NFTs run on top of what is essentially programmable money. What if we designate an NFT to an application (a smart contract) that in exchange issues tokens to designate fractional ownership of that NFT? Never in history has anyone been able to buy shares of highly coveted art... maybe now you can? Using smart contracts you can you can also conduct trustless exchanges of digital assets (NFTs). This is huge.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by Traster on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:08AM (#29161892)
I think people on HN react to NFTs perfectly resaonably and I don't think you make a good argument about their value for creatives. As far as I can see NFTs at the moment have done nothing for creatives getting paid. As you point out - we have solved the problem of creatives getting paid for their work, they can sell their work, they can take commissions, or they can use patreon or similar sites. I would bet that at the moment the commission that shopify or patreon are taking are much more creator friendly than paying to mint an NFT. You say that NFTs provide a new way to interact - but what is that interaction? What does an NFT give me that sticking a badge on a shopify store saying "Creative ownership of peice of work X" does not? And I don't see how that problem has anything at all to do with being gamified?

>Never in history has anyone been able to buy shares of highly coveted art... maybe now you can

Well, firstly, let's be clear that it's highly contentious whether you meaningfully own the art if you own an NFT. But let's assume that's a solved problem. YOu can already buy shares of highly coveted art - https://www.masterworks.io . It's exactly the same model as NFTs - some individual buys the actual art, then they offering to sell "shares" of the art. The difference is that Masterworks doesn't carry all the risk of being scammed in the crypto market.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:26AM (#29162137)
For one, NFTs for the most part have a perpetual royalty built in that's paid to the creator.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:38AM (#29162298)
Your base assumption is entirely wrong.

In most cases the creator of the NFT != the creator of the artwork.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by nikk1 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:34AM (#29163891)
>In most cases the creator of the NFT != the creator of the artwork.

You are describing counterfeit art and is easy to identify

That's like pointing out how many fake Gucci bags are out there and dismissing the real Gucci by saying "in most cases the creator of the Gucci bag is not Gucci."

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:00PM (#29165004)
I'm not solely describing "counterfeit" ( again, nft's are not legally protected, so counterfeit is not applicable ).

I'm also talking about hiring a low salary graphic designer to create some simple cartoon avatars and then wash trade it into popularity because of metrics on the platform.

Or just copying of-chain images to create an NFT.

Or copy an NFT and put them on another NFT market.

Or change a pixel and put it on the same NFT bazaar ( by definition of law= code, it is unique by hash)

You can't get a real Gucci bag on NFT. The comparison is false, since i can right-click save a perfect original. There is no copyright on NFT's.

Edit: valid response below and couldn't respond. But it's not correlated to the NFT itself ( not saying you are intuiting that, just mentioning)

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tata71 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:24PM (#29165328)
Not to be pedantic, but, just because you can save and distribute something does not make the legal definition of copyright disappear.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:01PM (#29165024)
Easy to identify? How do you know that the individual behind a digital signature is the individual they claim to be, unless you meet them in person and they give you some fingerprint (which happens 0% of the time)?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by nikk1 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @09:58AM (#29175255)
No need to meet them in person if they have a digital identity.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:43AM (#29162369)
Source?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by wombat-man on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:20AM (#29163723)
there's nothing stopping you from minting an nft for any image afaik.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by weberer on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:30AM (#29163836)
But then nobody would buy that. The value doesn't come from the image, but the combination of the image and the digital signature attached.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:04PM (#29165065)
Then why are NFT owners mad on right clickers?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by ziml77 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:33AM (#29175742)
Are they really? I thought that was just a joke. That's ridiculous if they're serious.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:09PM (#29165120)
Are you sure? I think this is pure speculation on your part.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by weberer on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @08:14AM (#29174272)
Cryptopunk NFTs are selling for millions of dollars. You're free to copy/paste the PNG and see if anyone would even buy that from you for $1.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:21AM (#29175546)
I have just sold the PNG to myself for 100 trillion dollars.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by stiltzkin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:33AM (#29163871)
I can see the legitimate of the image by looking the Ethereum wallet address, even if you have an image of Bored Apes Yacht Club stolen i can see the proof if yours is genuine by looking on the blockchain.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @08:21PM (#29183329)
You have a tool that reverse searches every NFT exchange on the Blockchain for legitimacy? ;)
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by web2sucks on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:39AM (#29162319)
Are you serious? Artists aren’t getting paid? XCOPY a London based artist has made over $10 million on royalties from his NFT artwork. Please supply evidence to back up your bogus statements. NFT provide trust less royalties directly to the creators wallet with no middleman.

Source: https://xcopy.art/ https://superrare.com/artwork-v2/dankrupt-29757

Here’s another artist, Clon, he used to barely sell physical art at festivals, now he’s a multi million dollar art studio, because of NFT royalties. https://twitter.com/cloncast/status/1457425724860633090?s=21

Most people on Hacker news aren’t doing an ounce of research into the potential of NFTs and it’s clearly recognizable when i read all these comments. Reading a few articles by Bloomberg is not sufficient. You will all be left behind.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by Traster on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:07PM (#29165111)
Let me ask you, let's say that I get one of these artists to draw up a contract and sell me one of their peices of art. Do you think it will command the same value, more value or less value than the equivalent NFT associated with it?

Becuase I take a look at this and it looks to me like all of this commercial activity has basically nothing to do with the art. I would kind of get it if you pointed to me to a guy whose selling peices of art for a few bucks, maybe $50-100 and selling a decent number of them who you know... like the art. But what market is this? These aren't art collectors who are just using the new medium is it. They're not fans of the art. They don't have thousands invested in traditional collections. They're not going to buy the same art, but off-chain. So is this really anything to do with paying artists at all? Who are these people who are suddenly rushing to pay thousands of dollars to artists?

Is this "StarryNight" who paid $2000 for this NFT excited to be supporting xcopy. Or is it the account of the venture capital fund of the same name? That's not exactly the story of giving power to creators that we were being told is it?

I think the problem here on HN is actually the opposite of what you're stating- the second you do do an ounce of research these claims start looking more and more fishy.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by guax on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:06AM (#29163553)
Are people buying art or speculative tokens? This is horse betting with extra steps. Absolutely fantastic for them that they're getting paid for their work, but considering this as sutainable or something that can be achieved by any artist outside of the NFT betting bubble is naive.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by aj3 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:31AM (#29163024)
Your last sentence reads like FOMO. Not sure if it's intended, but it seems that you are making an argument for NFTs as a tool for speculation.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by meheleventyone on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:31AM (#29163025)
How many artists mint an NFT and don't even make back the minting fee because their art doesn't sell?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by motioncuty on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:19AM (#29162835)
For me, as a creative, its the first and easiest way I have ever published my work.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by Daishiman on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:40AM (#29163149)
Then you weren't looking anywhere.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by weberer on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:31AM (#29163847)
Feel free to list some examples.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by Daishiman on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:45PM (#29164793)
DeviantArt and BandCamp aren't good enough? They don't have literally millions of eyeballs?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by dropnerd on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:13PM (#29196246)
how much are artists being paid on deviantart?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:11PM (#29165148)
Can you just publish your work on Instagram or similar site? I don't think publishing has been a problem since a long time. People are publishing their own books.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by weberer on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @08:08AM (#29174226)
>Can you just publish your work on Instagram or similar site

I don't see how you can make money that way.

>People are publishing their own books.

Now this, on the other hand, has a clear solution. You can simply put your epub on Amazon for $10 or so. There's no equivalent that I know of for art. For whatever reason, people are more willing to buy digital text than digital images.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by X6S1x6Okd1st on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:12AM (#29161950)
Just because patron exists doesn't mean alternative revenue streams are useless
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by madeofpalk on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:24AM (#29162113)
Right but where's the "creativity" of the solution that NFTs supposedly bring? Or is it just the same as Patreon (no creativity or uniqueness at all) but just more complex and potential downsides?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by casi18 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:39AM (#29162322)
I mean for one, a patreon staff member who doesnt like you for some reason cant just ban your nft account. That seems like a pretty good starting point.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by madeofpalk on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:46AM (#29162409)
Can't OpenSea just ban people and artwork all the same?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by casi18 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:59AM (#29162573)
you can deploy your own contracts, no-one can stop you.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by madeofpalk on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:15AM (#29162792)
Right in the same way you can just give cash to someone, no one can stop you.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:54AM (#29162513)
It will still be on the chain though.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by X6S1x6Okd1st on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:16PM (#29165223)
resale and the secondary sale cut (that goes to the artist) is fundamentally different than patreon. Not to mention the take rate can be arbitrarily low
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by madeofpalk on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:31PM (#29165441)
Wait but it’s about supporting the original artist, no?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by X6S1x6Okd1st on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:46PM (#29166509)
no not entirely. Even patreon gives benefits in exchange for payment. It's just very different benefits.

are you really engaging in good faith?

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by serverholic on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:28AM (#29162170)
NFTs are selling a much more personal connection with the artist. Buying merchandise or subscribing to patreon is much more impersonal. There is also a sense that you own something. You can show people your NFTs.

Masterworks is centralized. You rely on Masterworks for everything, whereas you can buy NFTs from a number of competing sources.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by danShumway on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:41AM (#29163186)
> NFTs are selling a much more personal connection with the artist. Buying merchandise or subscribing to patreon is much more impersonal.

In what way? A ton of artists I know on Patreon are polling their contributors to get feedback, releasing early content to them, and releasing exclusive behind-the-scenes info or life updates.

What about an NFT provides more personal connection than ongoing support and communication with the artist?

----

And if Patreon isn't enough of a connection to your favorite artists, you can always directly commission them, which will give you a genuinely unique piece of artwork instead of just a serial number, designed in direct cooperation with the artist, that no one else owns, and that is uniquely tied to you in a fundamental way that can't be faked.

What about an NFT provides more personal connection than having direct creative input and a personal hand in the creation of a piece of artwork?

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by Traster on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:46AM (#29163252)
What are you talking about NFTs are more personal? You can literally commission most artists to make you a personal peice. Most Patreons including regular Q&As, opportunities to make suggestions and all sorts of stuff. What exactly is the personal connection that comes from an NFT?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by rory on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:39AM (#29162309)
> Masterworks is centralized. You rely on Masterworks for everything, whereas you can buy NFTs from a number of competing sources.

Just because there are multiple NFT companies doesn't mean they are decentralized. Can I buy an NFT on one platform, then sell it on another?

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:44AM (#29162384)
YES!! NFTs are just a smart contract standard.

Look at OpenSea. It's the google/ebay of NFTs on Ethereum.

They are all interchangeable.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by rory on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:55AM (#29162520)
Good to hear!

Digging a little more, it seems like the answer is sometimes yes. In this thread NBA Topshot is excluded: https://old.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/m1mb0s/can_someon...

Is that thread correct? Is the general theme that corporate NFTs don't truly decentralize, but small players and committed crypto people put their NFTs on Ethereum so they can be moved around?

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:03AM (#29162627)
Correct, some "corporate NFTs" are run on their own chains, etc. This is why most of the price action is on Ethereum.

Assuming you are somewhat technical, you can read about the actual smart contract standard, it's called erc721.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by lottin on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:13PM (#29165176)
So they're all centralised on Ethereum, right?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @03:22PM (#29166944)
they are all decentralized on ethereum :)

Though there are some projects that are working on bringing cross-chain portability to NFTs. I don't know how those work though.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by PaulHoule on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:14AM (#29161974)
HN people are a wider community than crypto enthusiasts.

My mother-in-law would be as almost dismissive of NFTs as I am, except she doesn't understand technology so she won't be as articulate about it.

I think some crypto enthusiasts hang out with other crypto enthusiasts way too much and that is how they get HODler ideas and drive the price of things up like

https://www.gutenberg.org/files/24518/24518-h/24518-h.htm

People on HN are mostly normies, except technically articulate. Crypto enthusiasts think we hate crypto, but it's because we're reflective of the wider community which feels like

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ogHtl6UFSSI

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by nrjames on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:41AM (#29162346)
Generative art (Processing, p5.js, etc.) has been a hobby of mine for 15 years or so. During that time, a handful of people were truly able to make a living out of it -- or even get paid for doing it. I ran workshops, taught people to code, helped students learn, etc. and it was all for fun, as a hobby, to get people interested in computer-based art and to learn a bit about programming. (Incidentally, p5.js is excellent for teaching programming to kids b/c of the immediate visual feedback.) Making a living or even getting paid to do this type of work was extremely difficult prior to the emergence of NFTs.

There's now an accessible marketplace for me to sell that work, thanks to NFTs. I do it as a hobby, not relying on the income, through Hic et Nunc, which runs on the Tezos blockchain. I do it for two reasons: it feels really good to sell my work, even if it's just for a few dollars. My entire family, including kids, get really excited when I sell something for just $3 or whatever.

The second reason is that it has vastly accelerated my ability to connect with communities of similar artists. For most of them, this has been a hobby for many years. Through them, I've joined some of the most positive, fun, and creative communities I've ever found on the Internet. Most discussion is not NFT related, but just about techniques, helping each other, fun and friendly weekly coding challenges, etc.

Say what you will about NFTs. I'm not blind to the issues they bring along with them. For a lot of digital artists, however, the accessible marketplaces and creative communities are truly groundbreaking. Honestly, the past 6 months of participating in these communities have been some of the best times of my life, full of new friendships and the occasional small financial reward. I'm very thankful for NFTs providing this because I know that, even if the marketplaces go away, the new creative communities will persist.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by aj3 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:36AM (#29163094)
Nice story, but it's just a coincidence that the platform you found uses NFTs, as far as I can see just as easily it could have been regular centralized platform operating over Stripe or PayPal.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by bsanr on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:43PM (#29164767)
No, that's not correct. deviantArt and similar platforms have been around for years, and none of them have created the kind of income that NFT marketplaces have. Those older platforms were decent as communities, but their marketplaces were designed primarily to generate revenue for the platform itself, not as a free market for the artists providing the content, and it showed.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by iamacyborg on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:34PM (#29164626)
Sedition has been around for yonks
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:19AM (#29162036)
This is a very good point, thank you for making it. I've always approached HN with my own bias, which is an interest in underground technology, hacking, and of course crypto. I never really saw the crowd as mostly normies, but I guess I never paused to reflect that there's a lot of content here I ignore, precisely because it is that.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by madeofpalk on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:25AM (#29162124)
What are "normies"?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by PaulHoule on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:34AM (#29163055)
Tends to be a term that unusual groups (Asperger patients, people who are awkard but don't get diagnosed as anything, incels, etc.) use to refer to normal people that is somewhat pejorative.

My particular use is a bit ambiguous and ironic. I'd see both the crypto enthusiasts and HN users as not normal. In terms of hierarchy however, I'd say HN users are relatively more normal than crypto enthusiasts, but that's half my opinion and half being provocative. (e.g. it will cause some people to make unforced errors.)

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:36AM (#29162263)
Normies is a term that crypto enthusiasts use to refer to folks that don't know much about crypto. I guess it's pejorative, but I use it in jest. Maybe I should stop using it.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by nikk1 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:49AM (#29164051)
The term "normie" predates crypto, though. It goes back to describing anyone who followed the mainstream.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:39AM (#29162321)
Most of these 'normies' probably started earlier in crypto than you.

And got out because it's not interesting anymore.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:53AM (#29162496)
I've been in "crypto" a pretty long time. I agree a lot of it is no longer interesting, namely Bitcoin, but smart contract platforms are fascinating.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:14PM (#29165187)
Well, if you did crypto around the time you joined here = 2019/06.

I can say that this normie predates your crypto experience with 3 years. A lot of people here way earlier.

My currently expired crypto magazine it's most popular article was "how to recover your Bitcoin password" ~ 2017. I've seen/experienced this 'movement' before ;).

Ps. Ethereum was already popular then because of it's "potential" of programmability.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:00PM (#29165891)
It changes so fast that "when" is largely irrelevant. I started with crypto in 2013, just getting to play with Bitcoin a little bit. Was never a big holder, but waiting for the day it would see bigger adoption. I lost interest in BTC after the block size debate. My first exposure to ETH was shortly after they launched, but it took me a while to really understand how it works. These days I use ETH every single day, mainly via NFTs and side projects. I'm also interested in new and emerging chains with niche use cases, getting in early as a validator as a way of placing bets on potential future success... but I'm in no way a fanatic. I don't think crypto will "replace" fiat. I don't think NFTs will disrupt ownership, and I optimize my gains towards traditional investments. I find crypto fun, and I think it offers interesting ways for folks to interact with each other using programmable money. My gripe I suppose is how easily some folks dismiss it, but to each their own.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:49PM (#29166552)
I think you nailed the bullet with "moved to traditional investments". I don't need to worry about tether anymore and the ROI is good enough.

I'll consider it again after tether drops the crypto market.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by dropnerd on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:17PM (#29196260)
have you been waiting since 2017?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Sunday November 14, 2021 @01:54PM (#29219507)
No, i got out in 2017 when it hit 18 k. And never went back in.

I'm also not following it anymore.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by epinephrinios on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:30PM (#29177428)
Anti-crypto folks around here remind of fast horses running around with a blindfold on. They have the power to run but complete miss the goal.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by abraxaz on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:29AM (#29162174)
> NFTs do solve a problem, and the problem that they solve is that creatives are getting paid for their creative output.

This has been happening for 1000s of years already before NFTs.

> Never in history has anyone been able to buy shares of highly coveted art... maybe now you can?

Yes, they have: https://www.masterworks.io/

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by AlexandrB on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:26AM (#29162130)
Creatives I've listened talk about NFTs have said that NFTs are a terrible deal for them. "Minting" an NFT of their work costs a not-insignificant amount of money and there is no guarantee that anyone will buy the damn thing.

For the Ellens and Kanyes of the world, it's great, because their work is already in-demand and can fetch a huge price on the NFT market. For the 90% of artists in the "long tail" of content production it's probably a net loss over more conventional funding means like Patreon, commissions, and Bandcamp. Even if these collect a higher portion of their income as fees, there's less up-front investment (and hence risk) for the artist.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:28AM (#29162171)
I'm an absolute nobody in the art world. I started minting my art in early 2020. This year i have made about 2.5x my tech salary from NFT sales and royalties. NFTS are an amazing deal for creators.

You are right that there's a barrier to entry as far as minting costs, but it's a small price to pay to find out if you have an audience.

Furthermore, there are now thriving NFT communities on chains like Tezos and Solana, where it costs pennies to mint.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by dorkwood on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @02:48PM (#29166536)
> I'm an absolute nobody in the art world. I started minting my art in early 2020. This year i have made about 2.5x my tech salary from NFT sales and royalties. NFTS are an amazing deal for creators.

I'm not sure what marketplace you're on, but assuming an average tech salary of $100k USD, earning $250k in 12 months would put you well within the top 100 earners on SuperRare. The majority of artists in that tier have over 50,000 followers each, so the fact you're able to compete with them as a 'nobody' means you're a special case.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tata71 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:54AM (#29171539)
Or the asset class is inflated for..some reason.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @08:45AM (#29174541)
It's spread over multiple platforms.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by eropple on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:28AM (#29162960)
Have you computed how much environmental damage you personally have created?

I work to minimize mine, my home's pretty well analyzed to reduce power and consumables usage and I'm in the process of prepping for solar. How are you atoning for your burnings?

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:54AM (#29163376)
I think the environmental impact is overstated. It's often conflated with the environmental impact of Bitcoin. I haven't touched Bitcoin in years. Also POS chains have active NFT ecosystems, like Tezos.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by koonsolo on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:00AM (#29163458)
Solana is proof of stake, not proof of work. So probably pretty minimal.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by exolymph on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @03:39PM (#29167152)
Have you ever flown on an airplane?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by serverholic on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:34AM (#29162241)
This is what I've seen too. For example, I saw an artist on twitter crying because she was able to get out of debt from selling NFTs.

My experience has been largely positive. Artists get better paid. The fans can buy something that gives them a more personal connection with the artist. Everyone else can still view the art for free.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by iamacyborg on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:36PM (#29164647)
What was stopping people from buying your art before?

Are they only buying it now because of FOMO that other people are making money by buying jpg's?

[dead]
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:50AM (#29162458)
Of course I enjoy the money, but if I can benefit form it, then so can others.

I'm also into the tech. I enjoy blockchain development and creating NFTs with unique minting/burning mechanisms.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:08PM (#29165118)
Perhaps it becomes clear when you realize that your NFT trials come from your tech background and surely not from your art background.

Most people don't earn any money on NFT and almost definitely not people without a tech background and a small name reconnaissance.

Eg. Who does your graphic design for the NFT's?

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by casi18 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:57AM (#29162553)
being paid for your work is greed?

because art has no value?

you want artists to suffer, is that it?

I think it is wonderful this person is making money with their art.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:57AM (#29163423)
He's not an artist as he mentioned. He's a tech guy that says artists get paid with NFT's, while he earns money with NFT's.

See the contradiction?

I'm pretty sure his art in a normal situation wouldn't have much value. It would surprise me if anything else has been done than copy/pasting or creating an avatar.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by casi18 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:48AM (#29162431)
Plenty of people in art and music i know who are very happy with nfts. Theres thousands of people on https://beta.catalog.works/ https://foundation.app/ https://zora.co/

We also get royalties on resales which is great, rather than when i sell vinyl and someone buys a few and then re-lists them at a higher price on discogs and i get nothing. not to mention traditional distribution networks would take 50% of sales straight away.

The reason nfts exist in the first place is because so many in the art/music world are annoyed with what we have and are desperate for alternatives, art world has been building on crypto for years -> https://www.daowo.org/#artists-organise-on-the-blockchain

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by serverholic on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:31AM (#29162210)
This is new tech and costs will go down. Layer 2 tech is going to substantially reduce fees and make NFTs more accessible to your average person.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by meheleventyone on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:00AM (#29161794)
> Never in history has anyone been able to buy shares of highly coveted art... maybe now you can?

Umm, hasn't this been a thing since art has been seen as an investment?

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by phone8675309 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:12AM (#29161955)
What stops me, technologically, from creating an NFT from an image that I didn’t actually create? If it was about creators getting paid then there'd be a better answer than "nothing, caveat emptor".
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by bnralt on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:31AM (#29162201)
Someone mentioned hicetnunc.xyz here, so I went and took a look at their FAQ. I thought this was interesting[1]:

> To make it easier for buyers, please leave a trace to any social profile or website in the description of your artwork, so potential buyers can validate the authenticity. If you can link the NFTs the artist is advertising on the profile with the NFTs on Hicetnunc, you can assume it is legit.

So NFT markets are relying on third party social media sites to prove authenticity. And I suppose artists would rely on the government an actual copywright law if they wanted to enforce anything.

[1] https://github.com/hicetnunc2000/hicetnunc/wiki/General

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by notahacker on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:07AM (#29162686)
Yep. It's either decentralised or a proof of an authentic link to the artist, never both.

The case for NFTs solving artists' problems is it's a way of getting noveaux rich with a particular interest in digital collectibles to spend money on art they wouldn't otherwise give a second glance to. There's real value in matching buyers and sellers. But I guess admitting the value was all in the collectors and not in the supposed transformational properties of the token wouldn't sell tokens as effectively...

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by bsanr on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:52PM (#29164899)
Nothing. This is a canard, though, because the fundamental nature of blockchain technology allows a potential buyer (or anyone, really) to verify the provenance of an NFT. It's then up to the buyer to verify that the NFT originated in a wallet or account associated directly with the artist.

As a buyer, as always, it's your job to verify that you're not buying a counterfeit. As a seller, as always, the value of the NFT you hold is subject to its verifiable provenance.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by kall on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:04AM (#29162652)
Nothing. You are implicitly relying on centralized platforms like twitter for hardest part.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by rip_netrunner on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:28AM (#29162970)
A few NFT marketplaces will verify identity but no where near thoroughly enough. Privacy and KYC are going to be the biggest crypto issue for 2022. More and more projects are looking to incorporate identity oracles like Global ID and are looking to provide no more data than is necessary for KYC inquiries using tech like Zero Knowledge proofs (ZKP).

Panther protocol is the most interesting of these projects I've come across, but every utility driven blockchain is making plans to incorporate identity verification in some way.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by flowless on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:19AM (#29162040)
Nothing. Creators are getting paid because NFTs are associated with their brand, not just magically having a value because you minted one.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by elevader on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:30AM (#29162192)
But creators aren't actually paid anything if the NFT is sold by somebody else, which seems to happen quite a lot (at least according to twitter).
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by flowless on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:37AM (#29162286)
Typically they get paid the initial listing sum of the auction (at least) and what happens on secondary market is not their concern, similar to classic art pieces.

Royalties can be a thing provided NFTs are traded using a smart contract that pays royalties to the creator but it's not that common since artists are compensated well enough by the first approach and don't need to milk secondary market trades.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:38AM (#29162292)
On stolen content no, but if you re-sell the NFT you bought from me, I get a royalty. That's part of the appeal for creators.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:20AM (#29162050)
Correct!
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by jordanpg on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:30AM (#29162186)
I suspect that there is a strong relationship between distaste for anything crypto and lack of any crypto substantial assets.

The problem is that just about everyone here could be a multi-millionaire if they had just taken a few minutes to set up pool mining on their gaming rig back in 2010.

I think there is a tremendous amount of latent bitterness, embarrassment, and frustration about this. I include myself in this group. Folks should pause to reflect on this and determine how much these facts are clouding their opinions.

Crypto is just a new interesting technology. Maybe it will last, maybe not. But the amount of hate and skepticism on this forum is way, way out of proportion to the reality of the thing.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by kall on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:01AM (#29162613)
I think you are right that most people critical of crypto don‘t hold any significant assets. But that seems obvious and means nothing.

If you have a lot of crypto assets, you think it‘s a good thing. If you didn‘t, you would probably divest or would have done long ago. Even if you where ambivalent you may keep it to yourself or erase that doubt, because "you have to believe, wagmi“ seems to be pretty strong in the community (maybe thats too harsh, I‘m not in it).

If you don‘t think they are a good idea, why would you buy into them? Most people in tech aren‘t really strapped for cash and becoming a millionaire with something you think is bad for the world is something many people don‘t want.

But yeah, I also regret selling my 2013 era playing-around assets that would make me a millionaire today. It probably does color my opinion, and if for some reason I had kept them till now, I would have a very positive take, which is also self selecting and means nothing. If I had changed my opinion at any point in those 9 years, I would have sold at the next 10x. I still think that analysis and opinion is colored much stronger for those who hold then for those who don‘t.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by pjc50 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:54AM (#29164134)
If I could take this week's lottery numbers back to 2010 I'd be rich as well.

The thing is, I saw a lot of this stuff happening back in the $400-$500 price range for bitcoin. A colleague ran an arbitrage bot and somehow managed to lose money. The value proposition has always been "you can sell this to others for more" and "you can evade all the existing financial rules", both of which are uncomfortable.

Where has all this crypto money come from?

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tata71 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:58AM (#29171551)
Dark corners at every level.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by bsagdiyev on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:34AM (#29162238)
Or, and hear me out, we’ve all seen our fair share of swindlers and con men in crypto and understand this isn’t much different.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by bsanr on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @01:04PM (#29165062)
Could be both. I think it's both.

What I don't understand is the vociferousness of the detraction. This community loves Capitalism; crypto is just Capitalism Capitalisming. We've had snake oil salesmen and door-to-door salesmen and contract housing and pyramid schemes and dotcom startups and on and on. People abuse the freedom of the free market; we've always had to cut the "promise" of such markets short with regulation to stop real harm from being done to consumers. That doesn't mean that every possible iteration of such products were useless, or their sale predatory.

Or maybe that's wrong. But that would tend to make most HNers hypocrites, and it's only fair to give everyone the benefit of the doubt.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by rank0 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:04AM (#29163518)
> The problem is that just about everyone here could be a multi-millionaire if they had just taken a few minutes to set up pool mining on their gaming rig back in 2010.

You can say this about anything. Look at the stock market right now relative to 2010. If anyone had known the future, they'd be betting on sports and buying lotto tickets. Way OTM TSLA calls would've made me rich beyond my wildest dreams.

If the only response you have to the detractors is "you're jelly," then you're just falling for your own confirmation bias.

I have been using crypto since 2012.

> But the amount of hate and skepticism on this forum is way, way out of proportion to the reality of the thing.

Crypto has enabled a staggering amount of fraud and criminal activity. Not everything criminal bothers me personally...but financial crimes and exploiting gullible desperate investors really rubs me the wrong way. Oh also, its insanely inefficient to have a global network of redundant computers perform trivial work which could be done by a single web app.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by jordanpg on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:29PM (#29164573)
I disagree that this is exactly the same as the stock market or the lottery. I think the fact that it is a technology that many in the tech sector missed the value of, during a time that they and only they (ie. pre-Coinbase) could have gotten involved, gives it particular sting.

Regardless of criminal activity and fraud, my main point is still that it is a new and interesting technology. No one knows what useful things it will be used for (or not) in 10 and 100 years, just like all new technologies.

Usually people on HN are positive and constructive about new techs. I observe that in the realm of crypto, people are incredibly negative, dwelling on things, like fraud and criminal activity in the present, that don't seem very important to me on a long timeline with unlimited possibilities. I am confident in the market's ability to correct those kinds of things, where there is real value.

My suspicion is those same folks wouldn't hold those opinions if they were super-lucky crypto millionaires. I think the money is causing a general lack of self-reflection in this realm: like I said, bitterness, embarrassment, and frustration. I spot those emotions in myself if I am honest.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @08:47AM (#29174559)
Boiler rooms that sell bogus investment opportunities have been around for decades and extract more money from the gullible than crypto scams ever have.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by rank0 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:37PM (#29181239)
Yeah and that shit is awful too.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by andrewla on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:21AM (#29162061)
> Ownership is always based on social constructs

I mean, no? Ownership is always based on societal constructs; in the useful sense it means that the state is enforcing it. If someone takes it you can use violence or the threat of violence (legitimately, by proxy) to retrieve it. If someone else claims that it is theirs they can attempt to retrieve it through courts (with the the backing of legitimate violence or threat of violence by proxy again). You may exclude people from the use of the thing you own (with violence or threat of violence by proxy, or sometimes, by direct violence for which the state will excuse you).

It devolves always to the state having an effective monopoly on the legitimate use of violence. This is a social construct in a sense, but NFTs are a poor substitute.

Notably, most NFTs can be replicated bit-for-bit, and anyone else can emit a new NFT with the same exact payload, only lacking the traceability, but otherwise indistinguishable from the original. The only way to prevent that would be legal action, in which case you might as well dispense with the notion of the NFT itself.

In fact, a great business if you want to get in on this scam is to just sell counterfeit NFTs; even openly counterfeit! Call yourself "The Copy-Cat" and just resell Copy-Cat original copies of existing high-value NFTs. Even in the real life art world it has transpired that well-done forgeries have acquired a value of their own.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by dandanua on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:41AM (#29162344)
Any sane man understands this, but crypto people are too steeped in lies. They're detached from reality, just like their beloved crypto money.

Even if a perfect decentralized database will be invented, the violence, that enforces the rules under which the real world operates, can't be decentralized.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by andrewla on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:08AM (#29162697)
Oddly enough, I'm a "crypto" person myself -- I've been active in the Bitcoin community since forever, basically. I still think cryptocurrencies are an enormously powerful concept, but we can't blind ourselves to the reality of how money and ownership works in the real world.

I think the real reason my post got downvoted is that someone really wants to do my CopyCat idea and now they're worried that I'll sue them for stealing my idea. Should have made an NFT out of the business proposal.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by casi18 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:53AM (#29162501)
maybe we dont want a society that is based upon threats of violence.

maybe thats the problem.

(3,3)

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by andrewla on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:14AM (#29162769)
There's a strong argument that the nature of "civil society" is how far removed from that threat of violence we live. That is, people obey "the law" because it's the right thing to do and they don't do that.

People don't steal, not because they worry about being arrested or imprisoned, but because stealing isn't right. Policing and Law Enforcement scales sublinearly with population size only if the population is by and large compliant, or rather, that the laws are compatible with the behavior and motivations of the majority of people.

So we keep that foundation far away -- instead of violence, it's the thought of the social opprobrium of the prospect of the threat of violence. But it has to be there, otherwise people who were willing to resort to violence would take everything.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by ncallaway on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:41AM (#29163951)
> maybe we dont want a society that is based upon threats of violence.

I'm not convinced that such a thing is possible.

Fundamentally, for such a society there has to be some kind of rule that "threats of violence" and "violence itself" are not allowed. How is such a rule enforced? If your society is unwilling to be violent in any way, under any circumstances, but someone else is willing to be violent you're going to have a bad time.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by sandworm101 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:37AM (#29162287)
>> Never in history has anyone been able to buy shares of highly coveted art

What? Anyone can buy a part-share of any work of art. Want to own a 5% share of the Mona Lisa, just ask. If the owner want they can sell you a percentage of that object. Or you can buy a percentage without ownership rights. Or do anything else you want. Property law and the concept of partial ownerships has been around for thousands of years. Most every possible permutation is available should two parties agree.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:55AM (#29163390)
With NFTs you don't have to ask.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by birdyrooster on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:49AM (#29164061)
So if you have an NFT I can buy 5% of it from you without your consent? How does that even work?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:24PM (#29164502)
The owner of the NFT would have to fractionalize it, then anyone can buy fractionalized tokens that are backed by the NFT.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by debaserab2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:13PM (#29170646)
isn't that the asking part?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by sandworm101 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:58AM (#29172204)
Yes.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by egypturnash on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:25AM (#29162919)
Hi. I'm an artist who works exclusively digitally.

Getting paid for my work is a solved problem, I can draw a thing for a client and get money via PayPal or any of the other payment processors competing with it. I have a Patreon campaign to let my fans toss money in my tipjar for me to go draw whatever the heck I want to draw. So do people who make videos and 3d work. I see them doing it all the damn time.

Neither of these methods involve a system where huge numbers of people are converting energy into waste heat as they compete to be the one who gets the token reward for recording a pathetically small number of transactions.

"Proof of ownership"? How about "I have the source file and you don't"? How about "I have an email chain with the artist that goes from asking if they're open for work, through agreeing to a contract, and multiple WIP files, to a final rendering, source file, and settling up of the finances"? Why does converting energy into waste heat in competition to be the one rewarded for recording a tiny number of transactions need to be involved at all?

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by NicoJuicy on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:27AM (#29162146)
I see you're new and probably young. You're mistaking "lack of creativity" for realism.

Right-Click - Save image. Create an NFT, done. Work from an artist digitally is not unique and can be easily copied ( and even become more popular).

Creativity? Dogs, lost cowboy, punks, pigs, hungry aliens are the typical NFT's. That's not art, they mostly sell avatars.

ML models creating art => Not art and again the most technical knowledge person is getting paid.

Wash-trading has become the new normal. The people who pump and dump their own "art" see attraction and as usual, the average people are getting left behind with no piece of the pie. The most popular people ( not even artists) with the biggest following online win.

Nothing is legally backed. NTF's don't have copyright and you don't have a legal standing. BUT... You can cry on Twitter - https://twitter.com/RookieXBT/status/1421548360868286464?ref...

Mostly it's a technical person that steals artwork or just hires a digital designer for a couple of hours and then creates the NFT: https://www.theverge.com/2021/3/20/22334527/nft-scams-artist...

That's realism.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:34AM (#29162239)
I'm neither new nor young - I'm just a guy that gave this thing a chance and really liked the results.

The right click save argument is boring. It's not the image that's the NFT, it's the entry on the blockchain.

I agree about the "typical" NFTs you're talking about, they are referred to as digital collectibles, and yeah they don't do it for me either, but within NFT land there are multiple eco-systems, including those that are centered around what you would traditionally perceive as art.

You are right that nothing is legally backed... but why does it need to be? The blockchain is immutable, so anyone who participates in it has no choice but to honor who the chain designates as an owner.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by detaro on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:59AM (#29162579)
> You are right that nothing is legally backed...

Also not entirely true, at least some of the platforms use licenses for the art that grant the token holders rights.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tedajax on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:21AM (#29162059)
You have to be daft or a scammer to actual believe this.
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by twox2 on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @09:25AM (#29162125)
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by saltminer on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @07:31PM (#29182933)
> NFTs do solve a problem, and the problem that they solve is that creatives are getting paid for their creative output.

It did not. There are already plenty of ways artists can get paid for their work. If you had said "this creates another way for artists to get paid," sure (ignoring all the NFTs that are blatantly stolen), but asserting that this is the only way is false.

> The promise of NFTs is that they offer a different way for people to interact. Ownership is always based on social constructs, so folks that are involved in this space need to have some consensus of what it means to "own" an NFT on whatever chain.

I see "ownership" tossed around so often. But I just pulled up two recently sold listings on OpenSea (one from Bored Apes, the other from Cryptopunks), and unless OpenSea hides information if you're not logged in, there were no rights transferred for the original works themselves - you just own the NFT listing. What's the point of shelling out six figures for mass-generated artwork when you don't even have any IP rights?

Sure, there's the "exclusive community" of Bored Apes (though you can apparently have your NFT stolen but still be in the community, so...not sure how exclusive it really is), but other than that, it just seems like a way to flex on everyone.

I have more legally enforceable rights to a $20 drawing I commissioned (paid for on ko-fi) than many NFTs going for $100k+.

It's either a speculative bubble which will burst eventually, or the community is worth the price (plus the flexing privileges).

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by Dumblydorr on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:35AM (#29163069)
This may be a dumb question, but why should people pay to "own" the art if it can be digitally copied and given to others (can it?)? I understand the artists need money and support, but other than that, why would anyone want to pay a lot to own a file that's accessible for viewing in a free way?
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by koonsolo on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:14AM (#29163666)
bragging rights
Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by danShumway on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @10:00AM (#29162592)
> Some folks use NFTs as Patreon -> to support artists who's work they admire.

No, I don't buy this. Patreon already exists. And when you factor in gas fees, people who use NFTs to support artists are picking one of the least efficient ways to do so. Etherium in its current form is not a scalable model for how to pay for content, the fees make micropayments unnecessarily cumbersome and inefficient.

The fact that none of these people who are using NFTs "to support artists" were interested in supporting digital artists through any of the multitude of existing ways that existed before NFTs leads me to cast serious doubt on their claims that they actually care about the art ecosystem.

So, let's say you actually want to support artists:

----

If you want to buy the digital equivalent of "shares" of an artist's work, use Patreon/Liberapay/etc and join the community of people who are regularly investing into their output. This is the preferable method for many indie artists, because many indie digital artists want predictable income, and Patreon allows you to commit to regular donations instead of one-off payments. Many artists will use Patreon as a way of soliciting early feedback and providing early access to their projects.

If you want to buy specific pieces, donate directly or just buy those pieces on any of the many art-selling sites that exist online (Gumroad, Itch, etc). This is the really straightforward way of saying "this thing that exists is worth money."

If you want to own something more tangible for supporting your artists, look into printing sites and physical products (Etsy, Topatoco, etc). This requires a little bit of setup from the artist, but not any more than NFTs would, and it allows you to somewhat "advertise" your support with physical objects in a more tangible/public way than NFTs would ever allow.

If you want to get something unique and personal out of supporting an artist, commission them. Commissions are often going to be more affordable than buying NFTs, they provide you with an actually unique product instead of just a unique ID number, they allow you to directly interact with the artist you're supporting, and commissions usually come with better IP assignments.

If you want to encourage investment into a piece of artwork, encourage the artist to set up a Kickstarter/IndieGoGo campaign. Kickstarter isn't just usable for funding theoretical products, artists can use Kickstarter to fund predictable work and specific releases. Krita for example used Kickstarter to fund development on specific features, even allowing contributors to "vote" on what features should be prioritized.

If you want status/clout for donating, and you want to be publicly recognized, sponsor artists. Many artists have systems where they'll give you public credit for sponsoring a piece of work. This is also a far better system than NFTs because that clout can't be re-sold or faked, and because the artist directly promotes you to everyone who sees their work; other people don't need to go find your digital wallet and validate it on the blockchain in order to recognize what you've done.

----

So what do NFTs provide that the above solutions don't? A tiny bit of standardization (although it's questionable how standardized they really are), and other than that, pretty much just speculation. NFTs are kind of awful at a lot of this stuff, they're expensive to create and trade, they're complicated to work with, validating copyright/legitimacy is annoying, they're more subject to regulation, they're less private, they can be traded around which devalues the original statement of buying them, a large percentage of them are subject to link rot, the "gamification" of them is laughably bad because gas fees make it impossible to do most interesting mechanics, and even their display/status value is underdeveloped and still in its infancy. But they allow you to gamble that the token you're holding will go up in value and that you can sell it later for a profit.

And that's why people buy them. Not to support artists, all of these people could have been supporting artists ages ago, and they didn't. They buy NTFs because they're a speculative asset. They talk about supporting artists because it makes them feel better and because that conversation feeds into the hype, and that helps their speculative assets grow in value. That's all that's happening here.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by tata71 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:02AM (#29171572)
I didn't read your wall, but, if I bought a $2M Jay Z art, or a deed to a famous house, and wanted to show that off on my Twitter page, web3 tokens allow me to do this — not Patreon.

Might be worth looking into as a Patreon feature — or a competitor.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by danShumway on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @09:08AM (#29174764)
No worries, short version is that in most cases if you're trying to show off to the world that you supported an artist, traditional sponsorship mentions by the artist themself are going to be more public, confer more status, and are going to be seen by more people than a token.

But agreed that having more Patreon integrations (in the same vein as how Discord roles already work) would make that kind of thing even easier.

Re:NFT's aren't the answer to the problems of digital art by 015a on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @11:34AM (#29163887)
Most of the arguments against NFTs ultimately boil down to "centralized systems already do this".

Which to me is very sad and uncreative. The entire point just flew straight over-head at ten thousand miles per hour. Yeah, centralized systems already do this; what is necessary to create a world where they don't? Where people can transfer value without the help of a centralized authority.

Ok so: "How do you verify authenticity". Two responses:

1) What if you don't? What if the NFT itself is the value? We already see this with, for example, the Bored Ape Yacht Club; people can create duplicates, but the originals are cryptographically verified. They created value out of thin air, which is where all value comes from at the end of the day.

2) And in other situations, where the value comes from something real outside the blockchain like the original artist; use centralized systems! It's not all or nothing! Centralized systems are great at verifying providence. Use 'em! "This NFT was the one the artist tweeted about".

Then they follow up with: "Lol I can just copy-paste".

Yeah! Isn't that fantastic? NFTs create value for the people who want that value, by having a concept of "ownership of the original". But nothing is stopping all of us from also enjoying it.

Finally, the end-stage of any debate always arrives at "its destroying the planet".

This is, of course, typed as a comment into a website via a computer burning dirty coal power, through 3,000 miles of underground plastic fiber and fifty network appliances, to a beefy server running in a data center. Afterward, Captain Planet will hop in their gas-burning car to drive to work, drink a grande Starbucks coffee from a disposable cup, flush the toilet ten times throughout the day, pick up the newest iPhone from the Apple Store on the drive home, then watch an hour of Foundation on their 65" TV with 5.1 surround sound.

I'm obviously being a dramatic. More generally and accurately; humanity is destroying the planet. We're really good at it. People act like NFTs are destroying the planet, while every day doing far more to destroy the planet than NFTs ever will. It's a bad argument, especially when NFTs (and ETH in general) present a fantastically optimizable solution to the problem of value ownership; they'll get more efficient over time. Data centers can easily be powered by clean energy.

Here's the axiom I've noticed: the pro-NFT crowd has seen every single argument against them. I don't know if the people who post articles & comments like these think they're being original, like they're the first one to notice that verifiable providence is a difficult problem, but trust me; many people in this community have been thinking about this long before you first heard the word "cryptocurrency". Your inability to exhibit creativity in reasoning about a solution to the problems you present does not mean there is no solution, or that the technology won't continue to flourish.