That was already way too invasive, yes. You could probably get away with it before, because the scale was so small that it wasn't quite as horrible. There is after all a difference between occasionally violating one person's privacy and violating the privacy of thousands of people a minute. Not an actual ethical difference, but there are finite legal resources to go around.
Also, I object to this idea that because the pieces of behavior are acceptable the combined effect is automatically okay. It's perfectly legal to own and use a camera. It's perfectly legal to own an use a telephoto lens. It's even legal to look at your neighbor's house. Nonetheless, taking a camera and pointing it through a telephoto lens at a neighbor's house and recording 24/7 is an excellent way to get arrested.
Laws conform with societal ethics and those ethics absolutely change over time and are never uniformly agreed to by all individuals.
Lastly - scale absolutely does matter when it comes to laws we want to enforce. We don't want to enforce a no-gossip law because the invasiveness of enforcement would be unbelievably deep, so decency is there to tell you that while you won't get arrested for doing a thing you should feel guilty about it - most members of society get equipped with this guilt during their upbringing and so criminally malicious gossip is a problem we mostly ignore at a societal level.
Laws are absolutely BS in their inherent nature and a construct of society that could easily shift radically with large political shifts - but that doesn't mean they're invalid.
To me that's where the right of one group (the government) to legitimately use force ends. The sledgehammer that is the legal system should only be used to administrate the peace.
Beyond that, the only concept that can really be impartially measured is liberty. How free are you? In the graph of all possible actions, which are legitimately available to you? Everything else is an attempt to define good or evil, or right and wrong, and is therefore some form of religion. In a world where we are all equal, have no oracle to discern good from evil, and disagree diametrically, the only reasonable thing to do is optimize for liberty, and let everyone figure it out for themselves.
Scale does matter, but not in regards to rights. If you have the right to do a thing, you have the right to do it a million times. If you have the right to write something down, you have the right to keep it in a database. If you can publish your letters, you can do so over HTTP as well. This isn't a new conversation. People have been publishing memoirs of their private correspondence since the printing press. What disturbs me is how we seem to be shifting our consensus that they have the right to do so.
So, you’re using Max Weber’s theory of the state in a contradictory way in my reading. Weber’s theory of the state as being the society which derives its authority from a legitimate monopoly on violence was contrasted _against_ the very “natural liberties” that you seem to espouse (e.g. the rights of peeping toms, the rights of private shopkeepers, and the limitation of the government). Either you argue that the legitimacy of the state stems from its legitimate monopoly on violence as a community (thus allowing it to dictate “decency” as you say) or you argue that the legitimacy of the state derives from the citizenry’s own natural rights to self governance and liberty.
This theory utterly fails to explain laws against murder from the millennia when there was no such thing as a state that claimed monopoly on violence. In the feudal system there was no such thing as a unified state entity, it was just a bunch of people invested with certain rights organised into nested hierarchy of fealty, no monopolies there, but still they had no problem ruling people guilty of committing murder.
> If you have the right to do a thing, you have the right to do it a million times.
You've never seen those signs that say you get only one free cup of coffee have you?
> You've never seen those signs that say you get only one free cup of coffee have you?
Indeed I've seen the signs. I would very much object to similar laws.
As an aside, I'm slightly curious how you explain the legality of said sign using your absolutist libertarian framework.
The legality of the sign is derived from the fact that it's on private property, from which the owner has a right to expel anyone for any reason. Violating the rules of the sign is simply grounds for expulsion from said property, not criminal consequences. That's the difference between a rule and a law.
Voting is an obvious exception.
You could just as equally declare copyright law or property law to be a religion and insist you don't want to subscribe to it, but society as a whole does, and so if you want to participate you just have to lump it.
One thing you want to keep an eye on that is actually harmful to business (and economic freedom) is if some part of the economy gets caught up in a race-to-the-bottom. This is a situation where everyone's best move is to defect, and then defect again, all the way down until no one is free/making a profit/happy/etc anymore.
In this case there is a clear race to the bottom situation where everyone ends up having to track everything about everyone, just to keep up with the competition. As this would be pretty much truly be a panopticon-like tyranny by any other name, that's clearly not desirable.
In this case the EU is trying to make legislation that stops the race from going all the way down, by leveling the playing field so that everyone can conveniently say "see, we can't go further because it's actually illegal now".
So the net (long-term) freedom is actually increased by this measure.
If the majority of society was in favour of tracking everything then the opponents of that would have the same options of lobbying to change people's minds. As seen in the difference between end user reactions to GDPR vs ACTA, that seems like it would be much easier.
Would it surprise you that it is in fact Germany that now has very strong privacy protections these days?
In general it seems like you're just asserting that value judgements should be scale free, while ignoring qualitative criticisms.
I myself am a libertarian. A government is merely a large corporation that is impractical to opt out of. Conversely, corporations that are impractical to opt out of constitute de facto government. Data protection laws like the GDPR attempt to constrain the power of corporations so they don't rise to that level, which ultimately constrains the amount of government.
This fully depends on what you include in your definitions.
Imagine this: A company owns a vast area of land. You agree to contract with this company in order to be on their land. This contract includes things like using physical force against you if you violate other terms spelled out in the contract (just as you can contract to have violence done to you at a BDSM club). The contract defines a technical term "right", the definition of which spells out some things you're positively allowed to do, and is somewhat harder to amend but not impossible. The terms allow you to sublease a bit of their land for your exclusive use. Your sole way to terminate this contract is to completely leave the company's land and pay off any balance you owe. Call this company USG and it is indistinguishable from the United States Government.
> Find me one person who doesn't pay taxes and doesn't go to jail
Most people who have under the table income and don't report it. Same as how it's often possible to get around breach of contract when your counterparty doesn't find out. Model vs reality. And note how similar the requirements for keeping your income unreported mirror the requirements for avoiding transitive association with a given corporation.
> I know plenty of people who don't interact with FAANG at all
1. There are likely still surveillance profiles being kept on them. 2. It's hard to believe said people use the web for anything, given the prevalence of Google Tag Manager and CAPTCHAs. 3. More entrenched than FAANG are Equifax and LexisNexis, which are even harder to distance yourself from. I'd say it's easier to renounce your citizenship of most countries than it is to avoid the worst of the surveillance companies.
> Corporations will never rise to the legitimate use of force
You keep using this word legitimate, which entirely depends on perspective. I would say that it is plainly illegitimate to throw someone in a cage for smoking a plant, and so calling government inherently legitimate is a bit dubious.
Corporations, as creatures of law, are an apparatus of government. And they’ve participate in the legitimate use of force from the very dawn of corporations as a thing.
Jus because that's how things are now doesn't mean it has always been that way or always will be.
The earliest Corporations originally did use force and in fact at times maintained armies and /or navies.
...your right to swing your arm leaves off where my right not to have my nose struck begins. -John B. Finch
Why exactly? Which laws would I be violating if I did?
As a customer, I have no interest in you advertising for me, so it's not comparable. Any information that you spread around about me is likely to give other "shopkeepers" greater leverage over me (which is why vendors don't do this in the real world unless they have some sort of financial relationship with each other.)
Our government shouldn't be in the business of policing modesty or decency. Only administering the basic peace.
Before we didn't have these laws because this wasn't a problem in practice - nobody was calling other businesses at scale to tell them who was buying fungus cream. If they were, we would've had a law equivalent to the GDPR to prevent that.
Actually, there was one incident in the US where a politician's video rental history was disclosed against his wishes and as a result a law was drafted to prevent this practice in the future: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Privacy_Protection_Act
I could equally ask "Isn't that information John's, to do with as he pleases?".
Property is a legal fiction, and "intellectual property" doubly so; but it seems perfectly reasonable that society should decide that information about a human person should be controlled by them, rather than by the artificial person of a corporation.
If John asks you to make his drink preference available to every competitor of yours, and you for some reason agree to provide that service to him, then of course John can get the benefit of that information sharing, but this should only happen if he specifically opts in to it.
(In reality you wouldn't provide this service helping your competitors, and the information sharing could be managed by another service, which John would probably have to pay for, and service providers would compete based on the security, speed, ease of use, and accuracy of their service).
Someone else can't control what you do or say, but they can establish consequence for what you do or say. Nobody can control whether you assault people or not, but they can certainly put you in jail for it.
> Anything else is awfully invasive don't you think?
I don't think so. Information that you got for the specific purpose of providing a service shouldn't be yours to spread as you see fit. In fact, there have been strict legal procedures in place for a long time for certain professions (e.g. medical sector) to enforce this.
Just like I don't expect my doctor to spread information about my hemmorhoids, I don't expect my bartender to spread information about my drinking habits.
Consumer privacy regulations don't control your brain and mouth, they control the incentives of companies, who are not humans, and do not have mouths or brains. Those companies then control the incentives of their employees who can choose whether or not to work for them.
So I actually like your analogy, it shows how insane the ad businesses and tracking is.
(Except for the part where you say the other business owner does it to give great service. Ads aren't used to help people, no one likes them)
With this definition, you do in fact have a right to breach any contract as there are no criminal penalties for doing so. That's why most contracts specify what happens if they are breached under various conditions. There's a major distinction between civil and criminal law.
To answer your specific scenario, it would be pretty creepy (and possibly illegal) if shopkeepers in different towns were calling each other and discussing my specific purchasing preferences.
That's not how it works in the real world though. Why would a restaurant answer someone random calling them and asking what one of their regulars is typically ordering? I see no possible benefit in answering that question.
This only works in the online advertising world because whenever John enters a shop, restaurant or other establishment his photo is taken and sent to a central authority. That central authority can then sell space in some of those shops to push a product or service to him based on the history of shops he's entered.
You casually say this like it's obviously OK, and like it ever happens in the real world. If I'm doing business with you, and you investigate me to discover other people that I've done similar business with in order to ask them what I like, you're officially a creepy business.
The reason this is a matter of creepiness and not law IRL is because no business with more than a couple of customers could manage to regularly do this. The internet is what provides the dragnets, and the ability to be creepy at scale.
1. When you enter it into a computer, everything changes. The scale with which data can be stored, distributed and aggregated is just staggeringly more huge.
2. People don't like ads, except for a few weirdos. Ads are not a service in the interest of the consumer.
3. Knowing someone personally is fine, but passing on that knowledge without their consent, or at least knowing for certain that it is in their interest, is a no-no.
And that's only the three most egregious things you get wrong.
People who attract new customers with ads must like them. People who were informed of a product that meets their previously-unserved needs must also, right?
3. is just plain old gossip, which is also what I'm describing. It has always been in poor taste, and should never be illegal or regulated at all. Only religions do that.
Edit: grammar
If you keep it in your head, it's not going to be stolen or abused. If you put it in a notebook, the risk increases, but you at least aren't going to be doing this at a large scale, simply due to physical limitations.
Various laws have different thresholds, but usually it's something like a "systematic collection of data" or "automated processing" (I think it's the latter for GDPR), which seems like a reasonable compromise to avoid hampering the low-risk small scale use cases.
Edit, looked it up, this is the definition GDPR uses:
This Regulation applies to the processing of personal data wholly or partly by automated means and to the processing other than by automated means of personal data which form part of a filing system or are intended to form part of a filing system.
So if you keep your database in a notebook, you're probably still fine, because the structure makes it impossible to do nasty things at scale. Once you switch to alphabetically sorted index cards, you've crossed the threshold.
Should you have the right to watch which direction I'm going when I pass by at an intersection?
How about at the next intersection?
And the one after that, and the one after that, and the one by my home, and all the ones that I happen to go by when I next leave and go somewhere?
There's no single point at which passive observation turns into stalking but we still have laws against stalking and it's still perfectly ok and legal for you to watch where I'm going. If you understand why it's ok to look around you (and perhaps even take notes or draw what you see, snap a photo) but not OK to do that systematically around someone, you should also understand why we might want to restrict automated unwarranted and consentless data collection, even if taking some notes is OK.
The other thing is scale. Laws against seemingly minor things are enacted when that thing becomes widespread enough to upset many people. You probably don't upset people too much by taking some notes in a shop. If every shop had a fleet of staff dedicated to the same thing, that probably would upset people and lead us to a similar discussion.
In particular with data, the processing method makes a qualitative difference, between individual disconnected people each knowing one small snippet of your life, and a megacorp having an overview over whatever you're doing at every moment. By de facto limiting it to "one brain", the panopticon is prevented.
Your rights end where they start impacting other people's rights, and drawing those lines is what we have governments for. Even if you were to use just your memory, if you were tracking what someone is doing in such detail as ad companies do, you'd likely a) not be able to do that to more than a few people b) receive restraining orders for stalking.
Augmented capability lets you cause more, newer and larger problems.
We didn't have speed limits on the roads until humans acquired the technological capability to go faster, causing more fatalities.
That's unacceptable to start with.
>What has changed exactly?
You've automatized something unacceptable ?
>Don't you have a right to record who transacts with you?
Within a certain context, you do. The data that is untrusted to you is done so based on the assumption that you're acting in good faith and won't trade that information without consent.
>Isn't that information yours, to do with as you please?
Absolutely not, at least not in the legal systems we have in Europe.
>Can "John" command us to forget we ever saw him?
Yes, he can ! At least in my opinion and virtually every other European's he does. The right to be forgotten is an active subject of discussion[0]. The stance in the US is that it runs contrary to freedom of expression. The stance in Europe is that personal freedom implies being sovereign over one's own data. In technical areas, the right to be forgotten is interpreted as the right to erasure[1], which happens to be part of the GDPR. I've myself used that right several times. And I end up being very mindful of my usage of data in software I write.
>How is any of this reasonable?
Your ease of business doesn't trump someone's rights over themselves, the data they generate being a extension of it. End of story.
On what grounds exactly? When interacting with people they are able to observe you and record their observations. From where do you derive a "right" to control their behavior in this regard?
How could you classify an observation about yourself made by someone else as "yours"? How would you enforce this "right to be forgotten" when people carry around storage mediums made from meat? Or are you simply suggesting that you should be forced to go through all your letters, diaries, notebooks and ledgers on the whim of someone's demands?
What was once 'I'm particularly fond of a certain shops version of a food item' can then become every shop selling that category of item automatically guiding you to the same type of item. Besides the part where everyone knows your name and a quick dossier like you're a celebrity but without any of the perks, life would be so drab if it was "The usual today John?" at literally every place everywhere always.
You almost certainly had a legitimate interest in remembering your guest’s preferences, but retaining only the necessary amount of personal information is key, and sharing it with other firms is more restricted- an example of where this could be legal is in sharing warning of violent guests.
If you employed an army of people to be able to take photographs and remember or write down what every customer looks like, what time they come in, what they typically wear, how long they spend looking at each product, etc... most people will find that creepy and will take offense at that.
Because that society has decided that it wants no creepy restaurants at all. Same with unclean ones, discriminatory ones, etc.
And yet I see every single supermarket offer their own membership card "to get discounts" and everybody is happy with it. The only purpose of that card is precisely to track your purchases.
It seems to me that some people in society decided that websites aren't allowed to sell ads based on what you view, but all the other tracking in our society is just a-okay. I've not seen a single campaign or push against predatory membership cards or credit card info being sold.
Depends if you're in the EU but I guess you could've lobbied against the GDPR when it was being drafted. You could also lobby against restaurant food safety regulations, or discrimination laws. The reason these laws are there and stick around is because a majority decided that these behaviors were noxious and should be outlawed and the current majority appears to be happy enough with the current situation to not demand laws to be changed.
> every single supermarket offer their own membership card "to get discounts" and everybody is happy with it
It is opt-in (you can decide to not swipe it when buying the aforementioned fungus cream if you don't want it associated with you), the data collection is relatively common knowledge and is disclosed when you sign up for the card (and if it isn't then that's a breach of the GDPR and should be rectified).
In comparison, online data collection is at best opt-out and at worst mandatory and often invisible (and even if you could see what data is collected from your browser, you have no visibility on what further processing is done on it or to whom it gets transferred or sold).
> but all the other tracking in our society is just a-okay
Source?
> I've not seen a single campaign or push against predatory membership cards
Those are opt-in.
> or credit card info being sold.
Every time the selling of credit card info comes up on HN people speak out against it just like they do against ad tracking, and the only reason nobody else talks about it is because they most likely don't know (would a reasonable person expect their bank to be sharing their purchase info with third-parties?).
Both of these issues are addressed by the GDPR by the way; it covers much more than just ad tracking on the web.
No, quite clearly I've opted-in to the site's content. No body has ever knowingly navigated to a website to enjoy its advertising and tracking. (except for maybe 3-5 individuals)
>You're the one that starts the chain of events in both cases.
This is victim blaming. I started the chain of events leading to the rendering of the website content, not the ads or tracking behavior to which I would otherwise be oblivious. This is akin to saying I asked for a computer virus by purchasing this computer.
What if the data collection was done in such a way that most non-technical people aren't even aware what data is being collected and how it is used? In my hypothetical example about a business employing an army of workers to follow, photograph & take notes about every customer the behavior would at least be visible by the customers (and so they could choose to go elsewhere), which is not the case with modern technology - data is being collected silently in the background.
> why should it be illegal or regulated by the government in any way
There are plenty of other unlawful things you could apply this question to. Society enacts laws to dissuade & punish behaviors that the majority finds reprehensible.
Honestly, more and more I'm starting to think GDPR is just an excuse to fleece "evil foreign tech giants". It's a set of arbitrary rules with vague and selective enforcement that seems not to be completely understood even by the legislators who wrote it, as demonstrated by legislators not knowing the answer to the simple question: Are pop-up consent forms acceptable. It's whatever the bureaucrats don't like that day really.
Guess some US company will have to go to court (and subsidize the European Legal Industry doing so) for the privilege of figuring it out.
It wouldn't be so comical if FAANG wasn't full of European devs who chose to innovate in the Valley, probably to escape this very bureaucracy.
Say we've learned over time that the color purple is really dangerous and needs to be regulated (work with me here for a second) .
Now try explaining "Purple Considered Harmful" to someone who is colorblind. The fact that suddenly grape juice is bad, but orange juice is good... weird. Or the fact that you'd not be allowed to mix tomato ketchup with blueberry jam. And you'd just randomly get fined for trying to sell that "dark green" sweater. Madness!
It would all seem quite arbitrary to the color blind person. Meanwhile someone with color vision would instantly see that all those things are purple, and thus clearly harmful.
The example might seem bit contrived, but something similar might be going on with the European concept of privacy.
People have been hurt due to PII issues in recent history, so one would like to keep control of PII. But try to explain that tingling spidey sense that has kept one's family alive in the last century to someone who has never encountered Nazis or Soviets before, and has instead lived a life of unfettered freedom. That might be rather difficult. Especially if you can't get the base concept across, and need to do it in terms of (very arbitrary seeming) examples.
And Valley is pretty much there because when the long chain of capital-hungry events was building it up, we were still rebuilding from last war while funding preparation for take three thanks to Truman.
Now say John travels to another town, and the proprietor of a similar establishment in that town, wanting to provide John with the best level of service, calls you to ask "Hey, what does John like?", and you tell them.
Now we just supplement your eyes and notepad with technology, and replace phone calls with packet exchanges. What has changed exactly? Don't you have a right to record who transacts with you? Isn't that information yours, to do with as you please? Can "John" command us to forget we ever saw him? Where in this sequence are anyone's rights violated? How is any of this reasonable?