News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:37PM (#29123151)
It’s not tyrannical, unless the very existence of laws is tyranny. Law is the legislation of decency. Any other kind of law we call “unjust”.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:52PM (#29123325)
"decency" is not definable, that's why it's tyrannical to legislate about it. Laws serve to establish a framework merely for peaceful coexistence. To use them to try to make everyone decent is surgery with a sledgehammer.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by munk-a on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:20PM (#29123651)
I'd actually challenge you to find a law in society that doesn't have some origin in vague decency - the legal framework built above decency is something we expect to be rather stable over the long term but, at a really basic level, we have a law to not murder people because we really don't appreciate it when people do it - not because there is some natural law inscribed in our DNA stating that murder must be a crime.

Laws conform with societal ethics and those ethics absolutely change over time and are never uniformly agreed to by all individuals.

Lastly - scale absolutely does matter when it comes to laws we want to enforce. We don't want to enforce a no-gossip law because the invasiveness of enforcement would be unbelievably deep, so decency is there to tell you that while you won't get arrested for doing a thing you should feel guilty about it - most members of society get equipped with this guilt during their upbringing and so criminally malicious gossip is a problem we mostly ignore at a societal level.

Laws are absolutely BS in their inherent nature and a construct of society that could easily shift radically with large political shifts - but that doesn't mean they're invalid.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:30PM (#29124924)
We have laws not to murder people because the state assumes a monopoly on violence. In absence of retributive justice we did and do continue to murder each other in blood feuds that last generations. This is perfectly normal human behavior. The state is there merely to provide a framework in which people who hate each other can be expected to surrender their natural right to use violence.

To me that's where the right of one group (the government) to legitimately use force ends. The sledgehammer that is the legal system should only be used to administrate the peace.

Beyond that, the only concept that can really be impartially measured is liberty. How free are you? In the graph of all possible actions, which are legitimately available to you? Everything else is an attempt to define good or evil, or right and wrong, and is therefore some form of religion. In a world where we are all equal, have no oracle to discern good from evil, and disagree diametrically, the only reasonable thing to do is optimize for liberty, and let everyone figure it out for themselves.

Scale does matter, but not in regards to rights. If you have the right to do a thing, you have the right to do it a million times. If you have the right to write something down, you have the right to keep it in a database. If you can publish your letters, you can do so over HTTP as well. This isn't a new conversation. People have been publishing memoirs of their private correspondence since the printing press. What disturbs me is how we seem to be shifting our consensus that they have the right to do so.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by uncomputation on Saturday November 06, 2021 @12:32AM (#29127549)
> monopoly on violence

So, you’re using Max Weber’s theory of the state in a contradictory way in my reading. Weber’s theory of the state as being the society which derives its authority from a legitimate monopoly on violence was contrasted _against_ the very “natural liberties” that you seem to espouse (e.g. the rights of peeping toms, the rights of private shopkeepers, and the limitation of the government). Either you argue that the legitimacy of the state stems from its legitimate monopoly on violence as a community (thus allowing it to dictate “decency” as you say) or you argue that the legitimacy of the state derives from the citizenry’s own natural rights to self governance and liberty.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:03AM (#29129490)
I'm not strictly arguing for Weber. I'm basically proposing that beyond majority consensus, we have no way of determining that the peeping toms or the discriminatory shopkeepers are in the wrong. In combination with the problems of majority consensus (if a majority agree to murder a minority, is that okay?), the presupposition that we are all equal, and have a right to exist as and where we are, the only reasonable conclusion is to enforce the absolute minimum of law required to maintain the peaceful coexistence that differentiates civilization. This is doubly true in a multicultural society.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by SiempreViernes on Friday November 05, 2021 @06:39PM (#29125485)
> We have laws not to murder people because the state assumes a monopoly on violence.

This theory utterly fails to explain laws against murder from the millennia when there was no such thing as a state that claimed monopoly on violence. In the feudal system there was no such thing as a unified state entity, it was just a bunch of people invested with certain rights organised into nested hierarchy of fealty, no monopolies there, but still they had no problem ruling people guilty of committing murder.

> If you have the right to do a thing, you have the right to do it a million times.

You've never seen those signs that say you get only one free cup of coffee have you?

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @07:09PM (#29125708)
The source of legitimacy of feudal monarchies was divine right. This is not the case today. Our governments derive legitimacy from the consent of, and in defence of the liberty of, the governed. This is why I object to these laws. They only constrain my liberty to interact peacefully with other people, and I certainly don't recall consenting.

> You've never seen those signs that say you get only one free cup of coffee have you?

Indeed I've seen the signs. I would very much object to similar laws.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by SiempreViernes on Saturday November 06, 2021 @04:33AM (#29128421)
You are free to leave if the governed collectively have decided on laws you don't agree with, and they'll probably ask you to if you go on about your demand to be granted veto rights on all legislation.

As an aside, I'm slightly curious how you explain the legality of said sign using your absolutist libertarian framework.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:06AM (#29129508)
"free to leave" isn't really an excuse for tyranny is it?

The legality of the sign is derived from the fact that it's on private property, from which the owner has a right to expel anyone for any reason. Violating the rules of the sign is simply grounds for expulsion from said property, not criminal consequences. That's the difference between a rule and a law.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by SiempreViernes on Saturday November 06, 2021 @04:37AM (#29128441)
Actually, never mind. I saw your other replies and it's clear you see epicycles as a badge of honour.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by sokoloff on Friday November 05, 2021 @09:09PM (#29126517)
> If you have the right to do a thing, you have the right to do it a million times.

Voting is an obvious exception.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by labster on Friday November 05, 2021 @06:35PM (#29125452)
The state needs not have a monopoly on violence. Dueling was outlawed in France in 1626, and early modern France was certainly a state. The dueling laws only became necessary because our mores on violence changed.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @07:10PM (#29125721)
Early modern France was a monarchy, not a democracy and liberté, égalité, fraternité had yet to be uttered there.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:10PM (#29123554)
Do you have opinions about different laws? That some are arbitrary and unjust, whereas others are good? How do you form these opinions?
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:11PM (#29124791)
By whether these laws enforce negative rights or positive ones. You should have a right to do whatever you want as long as you're not directly interfering with the rights of others to do the same. That's what it means to be free.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:58PM (#29125149)
Is this demarcation a form of religion? Or can you demonstrate its objectivity?
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:21AM (#29129603)
The demarcation represents a minimum set of restrictions on behavior which fundamentally differentiate civilization from its opposite - namely the presupposition of peaceful coexistence. From there, there is no means to derive the degree of compulsion to cooperate, so better not at all.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:54AM (#29129817)
Why is peaceful coexistence the supreme goal? What if my religion, in contrast with yours, holds out another goal as more important than that?
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by Macha on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:56PM (#29123361)
Right, and that's why we have GDPR consent and legitimate interests and all those other terms to come to something that is legally definable.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:59PM (#29123400)
All of those things are basically religious terms to me. Some people subscribe to the religion that they have a "right to be forgotten" or a "right to their data". I don't subscribe to this religion, I want out.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by Macha on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:02PM (#29123446)
You can lobby for the law to be changed. Don't be surprised you can't get a critical mass for "Yes, I'd like businesses to be able to track me".

You could just as equally declare copyright law or property law to be a religion and insist you don't want to subscribe to it, but society as a whole does, and so if you want to participate you just have to lump it.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:06PM (#29123492)
What if the laws were the other way, and business were being mandated to track everything they can about the people they interact with? How would this tyranny be different from the one existing currently? Just because the majority decides something, that doesn't mean it's not tyrannical. People should be free to peacefully interact with each other as they individually see fit. Some people may track, some may choose not to, advertise that fact. Any picking of sides is totally arbitrary and therefore unjust.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by Kim_Bruning on Friday November 05, 2021 @08:19PM (#29126151)
The European union has evolved from the European Economic Union, and they are generally pretty pro-business and pro-freedom.

One thing you want to keep an eye on that is actually harmful to business (and economic freedom) is if some part of the economy gets caught up in a race-to-the-bottom. This is a situation where everyone's best move is to defect, and then defect again, all the way down until no one is free/making a profit/happy/etc anymore.

In this case there is a clear race to the bottom situation where everyone ends up having to track everything about everyone, just to keep up with the competition. As this would be pretty much truly be a panopticon-like tyranny by any other name, that's clearly not desirable.

In this case the EU is trying to make legislation that stops the race from going all the way down, by leveling the playing field so that everyone can conveniently say "see, we can't go further because it's actually illegal now".

So the net (long-term) freedom is actually increased by this measure.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by Macha on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:13PM (#29123577)
Is it not tyrannical to prevent you from selling copies of Lord of the Rings without paying the author by that same logic?

If the majority of society was in favour of tracking everything then the opponents of that would have the same options of lobbying to change people's minds. As seen in the difference between end user reactions to GDPR vs ACTA, that seems like it would be much easier.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:33PM (#29123794)
Yes? Copyright law was widely regarded as tyrannical when first introduced. Anything to which violence is an inappropriate response should not be legislated.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:43PM (#29123909)
Why is violence an inappropriate response to someone threatening your livelihood by violating your copyright?
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:13PM (#29124803)
Because once you've told something to someone it's not yours anymore? Sure you can sign an agreement, but the consequences of violating it are civil, not criminal.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by Kim_Bruning on Friday November 05, 2021 @08:26PM (#29126213)
During WWII in Europe, numerous people in occupied territories learned that it is very important to be able to retain your privacy and ensure people don't learn too much about you. While people of Jewish ancestry are often taken as the canonical example, many other groups of people and individuals learned that "I have nothing to hide" is most definitely never true.

Would it surprise you that it is in fact Germany that now has very strong privacy protections these days?