News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:05PM (#29122737)
The laws of decency, respected by all decent people. Sure, keep a ledger of what I buy from you. But do not tell anyone else anything about me. I respect this principle in non-commercial life, and so do my friends. You are not exempt from the rules governing decency just because you sell things.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by Aerroon on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:20PM (#29122918)
But on the other hand, if you had an interaction with the shopkeeper then wouldn't the same laws of decency prevent you from telling others about that encounter?
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by pessimizer on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:59PM (#29123405)
There are plenty of deals that you make with vendors/merchants that are given in confidence; a merchant may give you 50% off if you promise not to spread it around. Other than those occasions, "shopkeepers" not only want you to spread around that you shopped there, they actually depend on it and will often pay you to do it.

As a customer, I have no interest in you advertising for me, so it's not comparable. Any information that you spread around about me is likely to give other "shopkeepers" greater leverage over me (which is why vendors don't do this in the real world unless they have some sort of financial relationship with each other.)

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:23PM (#29122965)
It depends what I tell. If the shopkeeper tells me that he recommends a particular brand of toe fungus cream because it works for him, I will never reveal his condition to others. But I might mention his hours of operation, or that he runs a good store, because that’s public information.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:31PM (#29123083)
I agree, but it has always been tyrannical to legislate decency. What next, fines for not saying "please" and "thank you"?
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:42PM (#29123217)
There’s s difference between being impolite and being indecent. We have peeping-Tom laws because it's beyond impolite to press your face against someone’s window and peer through the gap in her drapes. Are such laws tyranny? Most think not, because they are there to protect potential victims.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:53PM (#29123336)
If someone can stand on public property and press their face against your window, they should have the perfect right to do so, for as long as they see fit.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:13PM (#29123580)
So you think that the nearly ubiquitous peeping-Tom laws are unjust? You see no purpose to them?
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:14PM (#29124809)
Yes? Draw your curtains before you change? Anything you can see from a public space you have the right to stare at?

Our government shouldn't be in the business of policing modesty or decency. Only administering the basic peace.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:22PM (#29124879)
When I first became aware of these laws I thought as you do. But after a while I came to think the laws are OK, maybe even necessary. You say “draw your curtains”, but in my example the curtains are already drawn. Unless you seal them with duct tape, there are almost always tiny holes or gaps through which someone can see, if they're allowed to do things, like pressing their face against the window, that have no legitimate purpose aside from the intention to invade someone’s privacy. Our laws routinely consider the intention and purpose behind the act.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by kubanczyk on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:05PM (#29123486)
It's not tyrannical in the dictionary sense of the word. You simply don't like it, that's what your arguments boil down to in this subthread so far.