News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by matsemann on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:04PM (#29122724)
Wow, I think your example is what's mental. In no way what so ever is it ok for someone to share that with someone else.

So I actually like your analogy, it shows how insane the ad businesses and tracking is.

(Except for the part where you say the other business owner does it to give great service. Ads aren't used to help people, no one likes them)

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:06PM (#29124743)
Since always? If someone asks you a question you have a right to answer as you see fit, don't you? Shouldn't you? Even if you've entered into an agreement to keep a secret, it's only a legal contract that you'd be violating (which you have a perfect right to do) not a law.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:14PM (#29124814)
You seem to be using “right” to mean something like the state of affairs where there is no criminal penalty. Am I mistaken? I don’t think most people understand the term in that way. So my answers would be no, you don’t have a right to answer as you see fit; no, you should not; and no, you don’t have a right to violate a contract.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:41PM (#29125020)
Yes, I mean "right" as in action that may be taken with no criminal consequences. What do you mean by the term?

With this definition, you do in fact have a right to breach any contract as there are no criminal penalties for doing so. That's why most contracts specify what happens if they are breached under various conditions. There's a major distinction between civil and criminal law.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:52PM (#29125102)
I mean something that it is wrong for you to do. You indeed do not have the “right” to violate a contract; that’s precisely why doing so exposes you to civil remedies.