News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:58PM (#29123385)
This is exactly what seems crazy to me. Why does augmenting my capabilities with technology arbitrarily subject me to additional regulation? I should either have a right to do something, or not have that right. That's what "inalienable" means. In this case an inalienable right to free expression.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by foxfluff on Friday November 05, 2021 @04:20PM (#29124311)
> I should either have a right to do something, or not have that right.

Should you have the right to watch which direction I'm going when I pass by at an intersection?

How about at the next intersection?

And the one after that, and the one after that, and the one by my home, and all the ones that I happen to go by when I next leave and go somewhere?

There's no single point at which passive observation turns into stalking but we still have laws against stalking and it's still perfectly ok and legal for you to watch where I'm going. If you understand why it's ok to look around you (and perhaps even take notes or draw what you see, snap a photo) but not OK to do that systematically around someone, you should also understand why we might want to restrict automated unwarranted and consentless data collection, even if taking some notes is OK.

The other thing is scale. Laws against seemingly minor things are enacted when that thing becomes widespread enough to upset many people. You probably don't upset people too much by taking some notes in a shop. If every shop had a fleet of staff dedicated to the same thing, that probably would upset people and lead us to a similar discussion.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by tgsovlerkhgsel on Friday November 05, 2021 @09:09PM (#29126516)
For the same reason why you are allowed to fish with a single fishing rod in some places, but can't just drop a giant net or trawl the whole river: Scale matters, and regulating the tools is often an easier and more effective solution than trying to regulate scale directly.

In particular with data, the processing method makes a qualitative difference, between individual disconnected people each knowing one small snippet of your life, and a megacorp having an overview over whatever you're doing at every moment. By de facto limiting it to "one brain", the panopticon is prevented.

Your rights end where they start impacting other people's rights, and drawing those lines is what we have governments for. Even if you were to use just your memory, if you were tracking what someone is doing in such detail as ad companies do, you'd likely a) not be able to do that to more than a few people b) receive restraining orders for stalking.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:31PM (#29123768)
Augmented capabilities are different capabilities. Your inalienable right to free expression only exists for certain definitions of expression. It does not extend to incitement to crime, revealing classified information, deceptive commercial speech, misleading investors in a public corporation, etc. You have (in my opinion!) an inalienable right to have a pistol, but not to have a hydrogen bomb.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:16PM (#29124829)
How would you derive exactly where the line should be between a pistol and a hydrogen bomb? If you can build one, you should be able to have one no?
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by leephillips on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:54PM (#29125119)
No, you should not. We draw the lines wherever we think we want them. If you think the line is in the wrong place, you bribe a legislator to move it, or vote, or something like that.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by Macha on Friday November 05, 2021 @03:25PM (#29123712)
A recognition that they're not going to be realistically able to stop the small business owner keeping customer preferences in a notebook and the cost/benefit of chasing after them is low should not preclude taking action when it gets scaled up to monitoring way more people in a way more pervasive fashion.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by pjc50 on Friday November 05, 2021 @04:42PM (#29124525)
> Why does augmenting my capabilities with technology arbitrarily subject me to additional regulation?

Augmented capability lets you cause more, newer and larger problems.

We didn't have speed limits on the roads until humans acquired the technological capability to go faster, causing more fatalities.

Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by thegrimmest on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:33PM (#29124949)
We've had laws governing public spaces and common rights of way for millennia. Governing what and to whom people can communicate, and what they are allowed to remember or record, that's the new thing I'm objecting to.
Re:IAB Europe cookie consent pop-ups to be found in breach o... by aembleton on Friday November 05, 2021 @07:33PM (#29125855)
GDPR doesn't care if its in a database or in your notebook, you are still subject to the same laws and as such the data in this case is the property of John. You need his permission to record it.